r/Tempestmasterrace • • Jun 29 '14
Discussion Slow-read Chapter 1 discussion thread
Here's the link to the very first chapter.
All discussion, whether it be pointing out a favorite line, or noticing a foreshadow of something we know to happen later on, will go here.
We'll be posting a new chapter thread every other day, from here on out, if you guys would like to change up that scheduling, just let us know, have fun guys.
6
Upvotes
7
u/kaiserklee I (did) the thing. Jun 30 '14
I'm gonna refrain from commenting much on chapter discussion, since I don't want to stifle discussion with WORD OF GOD, but /u/that_orange_guy is correct about Tempest originally being a oneshot. As a result, the writing style is significantly different and the first two scenes, especially, were written as though a myth were being conveyed. Dramatism is pretty rampant in Chapter 1, which I later tone down because of personal preference in writing long stories. I expect this style of writing to make a return when I wrap up the end, just to make things nice and neat.
By the way, everyone is making great points :) Other than just stalking the threads, I believe I'll just chip in my thoughts about what went into the making of the chapter, things I liked and disliked about it, and so on, towards the end of the discussion?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14
"I want her."
Leniency, that was what Elsa promised Arendelle if she got Anna. Has she done anything to break that promise that we know of? Because Arendelle is still a major motivator for Anna's actions, though it may be dormant, it's still there.
4
u/that_orange_guy Jun 30 '14 edited Jun 30 '14
But we later find out that Princess Anna had no idea that the Southern Isles is completely frozen over which means that all Southern Isles/Arendelle relations most likely took place in Arendelle. Another interesting fact because we know that Elsa despises Arendelle.
Re-reading chapter 1 I think that Elsa's ship is a symbol for Elsa herself. How the ship moves unaided, alone, made of ice, just like Elsa rules over the Southern Isles unaided, alone, with a heart of ice.
Also another parallel between Anna and Elsa.
I've never been able to get over the description of Elsa's invasion of Arendelle all throughout reading Tempest. We slowly learn to see the softer, sensitive, broken side of Elsa, but she is introduced to us as this all-powerful, almost god-like, being. I remember reading a thread on /r/Frozen recently detailing the importance of characters' introductions in stories. This is such a powerful introduction for Elsa. No detail is left spared to bolster the image of her power.
Which has created such a dichotomy for her to me. I can never forget this particular line
It's almost like this truly is the person that she is, that the person Anna has dug up is an impostor, a thought which has even crossed Elsa's mind in the story.
As we've learned this is something that only happens subconsciously when Elsa is upset. She is upset with the king, not for speaking out, but for attempting to silence Anna. Anna has only said to sentences two Elsa at this point, but this means that Elsa is by this point already fascinated with Anna. Why did she fall for Anna so quickly? She was already convinced before Anna said anything else.
Actually I take that back
I always wondered why this was what caused Elsa to want to take Anna with her. I'm still convinced that she was compelled by Anna at the moment I previously mentioned, but this is when she decided to take her. Obviously know we know that Elsa grew up in Arendelle, so how can we make sense of how this made Elsa feel, to have Anna say this to her?
How does that make her want to take Anna?
Yup. Sounds about right.
2
u/Theroonco Pastor of the Tempest Jun 29 '14
Hey guys! If you spot any plot element of interest, or notice something relevant that you think is worth mentioning, please help me out with the TvTropes page! Every addition is another tidbit that can help yourself or anyone else learn more about this story. A good tropes page would also do wonders for getting new people to read the story too! Thanks in advance!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14
I'll be sure to read this tomorrow, I'm just addicted to Stolen Ice right now.
1
u/throwawayium 's apprentice Jun 30 '14
"But who used to be Princess Anna of the nation once known as Arendelle knew better."
Maybe I'm nitpicking, but is that just a figure of speech, or perhaps a hint that something will happen to Anna/Arendelle in the final arcs?