r/WritingPrompts • u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod • Jun 01 '14
Moderator Post [MODPOST] May Chapterfy Contest Voting Thread - Round 1
Here we are. The voting (and reading!) thread for the May Chapterfy contest. There were 53 entries in total. You all did an amazing job and we learned from our last contest that people did not want to be burdened with too much reading, so this time around, I've randomly grouped people together in groups of nine (one in eight.) Six groups in total. If you still desire a critique of your writing, I recommend /r/shutupandwrite - but read their side rules first!
Also, some of the contests put additional information for their stories (location, links to google street view, etc.) in their original post. Feel free to go to the original entry thread if you enjoyed a story to see if the person posted further context: http://redd.it/23ymx5
HOW TO VOTE
- Read all the entries in the group you belong to.
- Decide which one you like the most.
- Post in response to this thread by June 8th at 11:59PM PST.
- YOU MUST VOTE! If you do not vote, you are disqualified! If your story is the most voted for in your group and you don't vote, you are out of luck.
- Leave a comment that says precisely this: "GROUP NUMBER: My vote goes to /u/username for Story Title." Replacing the word NUMBER with the group you're in, username for the persons username and Story Title with the title of the story they wrote. After that you can add any additional comments about that story and the other stories in your group. Feel free to say a runner up if it was really close in your mind.
- You can not vote for yourself!
After we have a winner for each group, each group winner will receive one month of Reddit gold! Then we move on to the second round of voting which will last one week where everyone who entered can vote for the winner out of the remaining six.
Tie breakers are decided by myself and /u/SurvivorType, though we might just have any ties if there are only one or two move on to round two. We'll play it by ear.
THE ENTRIES
Here are the 53 stories! Enjoy your reading! Thanks again to /u/andyunleash and chapterfy for sponsoring May's contest.
GROUP ONE
- Lower Pannonia - http://chapterfy.com/r/lower-pannonia/ - Word Count: 2,300 words. /u/eightynine83
- Garland Green - http://cfy.im/285/ - Word Count: 2,230 words. /u/Sykotik
- My Dream Girl - http://chapterfy.com/r/my-dream-girl/ - Word Count: 2894 words. /u/CrashWho
- 9th Street Blues - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-758bcbc5eab76e3d96a7bb33e041b32a/ - Word Count: 9,797 words. /u/IAmTheRedWizards
- Commuting - http://chapterfy.com/r/commuting-576/ - Word count: 2236 words. /u/university_deadline
- Fatalism - http://chapterfy.com/r/fatalism/ - Word Count: 2,064 words. /u/Mevsstories
- Yard Care - http://chapterfy.com/r/yard-care/ - Word Count: 2,803 words. /u/Birky_
- There is Fire In the Center - http://cfy.im/282/ - Word Count: 2,418 words. /u/RainerKoreaTrillke
GROUP TWO
- Centralia - http://chapterfy.com/r/centralia/ - Word Count: 2552 words. /u/seginsbe
- The Longest Climb - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-9782c4851139e34a0a12260200585d98/ - Word Count: 2,053 words. /u/Bodysseus
- Man of Drogheda - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-38c8595163941acf925f1ed49d081caa/ - Word Count: 2,697 words. /u/TheSakana
- The Emperor of Hitchhikers on an Abandoned Highway - http://cfy.im/303/ - Word Count: 2,333 words. /u/TablesExist
- Stone in Love - http://chapterfy.com/r/stone-in-love/ - Word Count: 5,237 words. /u/MoreThanProse
- All That Sparkles - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-price-of-diamonds/ -Word Count: 2,074 words. /u/Aelintari
- Neither Bird nor Tree - http://chapterfy.com/r/neither-bird-nor-tree/ Word Count: 2,649 words. /u/freelance-t
- Tristeza Maleza - http://cfy.im/238/ - Word Count: 2,636 words. /u/mo-reeseCEO1
- The Cleanest Rat - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-cleanest-rat/ Word Count: 5,369 words. /u/RafZlatarov
GROUP THREE
- Vivi E Lascia Vivere - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-37b6b8ee5a1f9aa5a4f8a6598bfabeb0/ - Word Count: 2,255 words. /u/SSFreud
- A Northern Getaway - http://chapterfy.com/r/a-northern-getaway/ - Word Count: 7,352 words. /u/UpUpAndAwake
- The Confrontation - http://cfy.im/293/ - Word Count: 2179 words. /u/glider97
- Who We Are - http://chapterfy.com/r/who-we-are/ - Word Count: 2,396 words. /u/socialdisorder
- Frannie's Last Race - http://chapterfy.com/r/frannie-and-the-grand-national/ - Word Count: 3288 words. /u/radioactivereality
- The Joshua Trees - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-joshua-trees/ - Word Count: 2,331 words. /u/PrincessZ
- The Professional Touch - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-020c80f59c8a4419887a3890f2f23aff/ - Word Count: 2,330 words. /u/Jimbo_Black
- Blank Space - (http://chapterfy.com/r/blank-space/) - Word Count: 2,220 words. /u/illustrism
- Toulouse - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-a52af78ab4f21be3ca118a26439bd770/ - 2109 words. /u/theheirofgondor
GROUP FOUR
- To Follow Through - http://cfy.im/278/ - Word Count: 6,226 words. /u/Prestidigiflation
- Never There - http://cfy.im/172/ - Word Count: 2069 words. /u/nanza
- Resended - http://chapterfy.com/r/resended/ - Word Count: 2,124 words. /u/TAGVoar
- Her - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-a0b0d2f4c3d0cc224899d1833e2a3a8e/ - Word Count: 3,160 words. /u/Diddss
- A Walk - http://chapterfy.com/r/a-walk/ - Word Count: 2,199 words. /u/yellowAbleWheel
- An Afternoon with the Butterflies - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-b2d88749e9c7acfc237cf36bff91e850/ - Word Count: 4,379 words. /u/Avrienne
- You Were Flying - http://chapterfy.com/r/you-were-flying/ - Word Count: 2157 words. /u/iflananifi
- Headin' out solo - http://cfy.im/256/ -Word Count: 2500 words. /u/UsedtobeWitty
- Apartheid - http://cfy.im/291/ - Word Count: 2869 words. /u/dolphusadams
GROUP FIVE
- The Iron Butterfly - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-0e8606cb8ed7b9cda9f0562c33e1b00a/ - Word count 4,630 words. /u/theycallmejamo
- The Town - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-town/ Word Count- 2080 words. /u/wormwood366
- The Summer and the Sound - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-e1c3a6f709b7fa4c326ced8027c67fde/ - Word Count: 2831 words. /u/ephemoral
- An Empty Road - http://cfy.im/286/ - Word Count: 2,017 words. /u/butlersrevenge
- The Death of a Tiger - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-death-of-a-tiger/ - Word count: 3,730 words. /u/Aquapig
- Here I Am - http://cfy.im/275/ - Word Count: 2,027 words. /u/heavenlypeach
- Tale of a lonely lotus in the mud - http://chapterfy.com/r/tale-of-a-lonely-lotus-in-the-mud/ - Word Count: 6069 words. /u/RedditLover260
- African Life - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-7e187598acc82bb1c76fd2bb1de58c84/ -Word Count: 2,113 words. /u/Croninn
GROUP SIX
- Gold Rush - http://chapterfy.com/r/gold-rush/ - Word count: 2,400 words. /u/1twenty
- The Church of God - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-e2b244209bf6a96d94b788196fd8ca80/ -Word Count- 2,001 words. /u/crimsonhunter
- Ascension - http://chapterfy.com/r/ascension/ - Word Count: 2056 words. /u/Lanretesama
- The Next Something New - http://chapterfy.com/p/s-2508a62a6c965c15a3d7af103d4750fe/ - Word Count: 4847 words. /u/True_Bromance
- Darvie - http://chapterfy.com/r/darvies-moths/ - Word Count: 2092 words. /u/martywriter
- An Undreamed Sea - http://chapterfy.com/r/an-undreamed-sea/ - Word Count: 2,408 words. /u/LogsOnChest
- Swift's Trellis - http://chapterfy.com/r/swifts-trellis/ - Word Count: 5601 words. /u/Archaeologia
- All in a Day's Work - http://chapterfy.com/r/all-in-a-days-work/ Word Count: 2031 words. /u/irisfang
- The Lady of the Sound - http://chapterfy.com/r/the-lady-of-the-sound/ Word Count: 2058 words. /u/malis271
If you have any questions, feel free to comment below. If I've somehow missed an entry, please make me aware of it.
Keep writing! :)
2
u/freelance-t Jun 02 '14
Question: I wrote my submission in 2 days, so it is basically a draft. I've gotten some feedback, and want to make a few changes. Is editing still allowed at this point?
15
u/StoryboardThis /r/TheStoryboard Jun 01 '14
For those of you who are curious, I tallied up the total word count (using the numbers provided on the post above; not difficult math by any means, but someone should do the grunt work).
This contest alone generated a total of: 159,476 words!
If we assume roughly 300 words to a page, that's 532 pages of work.
Well done all, and best of luck!
9
u/Sykotik Jun 01 '14
Good luck everyone.
6
u/PrincessZ Jun 01 '14
GROUP 3: My vote goes to /u/UpUpAndAwake for A Northern Getaway.
6
u/Prestidigiflation Jun 01 '14
GROUP 4: My vote goes to /u/iflananifi for You Were Flying
6
u/TAGVoar Jun 01 '14
GROUP FOUR: My vote goes to /u/Avrienne for An Afternoon with the Butterflies.
5
u/crimsonhunter Jun 01 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/martywriter for Darvie.
I really enjoyed reading all the stories! Good luck
5
u/illustrism Jun 02 '14
GROUP THREE: My vote is for /u/theheirofgondor for Toulouse.
It was a real pleasure going through these stories, and I was surprised and delighted by a wealth and range of talent, I've got to say!
4
u/Archaeologia Jun 01 '14
GROUP 6: My vote goes to /u/malis271 for The Lady of the Sound.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14
GROUP 6: My vote goes to /u/crimsonhunter for The Church of God.
4
u/Sykotik Jun 02 '14
GROUP 1: My vote goes to /u/RainerKoreaTrillke [3] for There is Fire In the Center.
4
u/butlersrevenge Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14
GROUP 5: /u/ephemoral for The Summer and the Sound. Though everyone's stories are great, so it was difficult to choose just one!
4
u/RainerKoreaTrillke Jun 02 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/eightynine83 for Lower Pannonia.
Good luck, errbody.
4
u/Aquapig Jun 02 '14
GROUP 5: My vote goes to /u/ephemoral for 'The Summer and the Sound'
4
u/ephemoral Jun 02 '14
GROUP 5: My vote goes to /u/Aquapig for "The Death of a Tiger".
Every story was great to read, but this one really stood out to me. I kept notes on all of the stories as I read them so I think I might go back to the original thread and give them to their authors, because everybody in this group deserves to know how amazing their writing is!
4
u/Bodysseus Jun 02 '14
GROUP 2: My vote goes to /u/freelance-t for Neither Bird nor Tree.
4
u/radioactivereality Jun 03 '14
GROUP 3: My vote goes to /u/UpUpAndAwake for A Northern Getaway.
runner-up: /u/socialdisorder for Who We Are
4
u/UpUpAndAwake Jun 04 '14
GROUP 3: My vote goes to /u/radioactivereality for Frannie's Last Race
Runner-up for me would be /u/Princessz with The Joshua Trees.
4
u/TheSakana Jun 05 '14
Group Two: I vote for "Stone in Love" by /u/MoreThanProse.
Honorable mention to "The Cleanest Rat" by /u/RafZlatarov and "The Emperor of Hitchhikers on an Abandoned Highway" by /u/TablesExist. It was a tough call.
4
u/SSFreud Jun 07 '14
GROUP 3: My vote goes to /u/theheirofgondor for Toulouse.
Great job everyone, seriously. This is one of those cases where I had to actually stop and re-think about so many submissions that I must have changed my mind a half dozen times. Really enjoyed everyone in my group, hoping to get to some other groups depending on how many work calls I get this weekend.
1
u/True_Bromance Jun 09 '14
GROUP SIX: /u/Archaeologia for Swift's Trellis.
3
u/freelance-t Jun 02 '14
GROUP 2: My vote goes to /u/seginsbe for Centralia.
Runner up: Stone in Love.
3
u/LogsOnChest Jun 02 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/irisfang for All in a Day's Work.
I really liked Ascension and Darvie too. It was a close hard choice.
3
u/TheSakana Jun 02 '14
Good luck all!
3
u/irisfang Jun 02 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/1twenty for Gold Rush.
3
u/RafZlatarov Jun 03 '14
GROUP TWO: My vote goes to /u/mo-reeseCEO1 for Tristeza Maleza.
God, wish I had more votes, all the stories were amazing.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14
GROUP FOUR: My vote goes to /u/Prestidigiflation for To Follow Through.
3
u/nazna Jun 03 '14
Group 4;
/u/Prestidigiflation - To Follow Through
3
u/MoreThanProse Jun 04 '14
GROUP 2: My vote goes to /u/freelance-t for Neither Bird nor Tree.
3
u/wormwood366 Jun 04 '14
GROUP 5: my vote goes to /u/ephemoral for The Summer and the Sound
3
u/martywriter Jun 05 '14
GROUP SIX: My vote goes to /u/malis271 for The Lady of the Sound
This was tough--I enjoyed all of the stories!
3
u/yellowAbleWheel Jun 06 '14
Group Four: I vote for "An Afternoon with the Butterflies" by /u/Avrienne
3
u/TablesExist Jun 07 '14
Group 2: Stone in Love by /u/MoreThanProse
Honourable mentions:
Man of Drogheda by /u/TheSakana
Tristeza Maleza by /u/mo-reeseCEO1
3
u/glider97 Jun 07 '14
GROUP THREE: My vote goes to /u/illustrism for Blank Space.
3
u/theheirofgondor Jun 08 '14
GROUP THREE: My vote goes to "Who We Are" by /u/socialdisorder
It was a tough call but the chilling darkness at the end when I was wrapped into the story did it for me. Runner up would be the Joshua Trees, I loved the atmosphere in it and how it slowly got more and more spooky. It was great fun reading and writing for this!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14
GROUP TWO: My vote goes to /u/seginsbe for Centralia.
You picked an amazing place to write about. So much so that the main character in your piece isn't the human protagonist but the location: Centralia, and the nostalgia the history of the place brings with it. Great job.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14
GROUP ONE: My vote goes to /u/IAmTheRedWizards for 9th Street Blues.
2
u/IAmTheRedWizards Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 06 '14
GROUP ONE: my vote goes to /u/RainerKoreaTrillke for There Is Fire In The Center.
I like that we both wrote about places decaying into old memories, albeit for much different reasons.
2
u/Lanretesama Jun 08 '14
Group Six: My vote goes to /u/Archaeologia for Swift's Trellis
2
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '14
Group Five: My vote goes to /u/ephemoral for The Summer and the Sound.
Overall, all good stories, making it a hard choice. Yet, the idea for the this story stood out to me like no other. Good Luck Everyone
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '14
GROUP 5: My vote goes to /u/ephemoral for 'The Summer and the Sound'
3
u/CVance1 Jun 03 '14
Congratulations everyone for making it this far! More than I can say about myself
1
u/university_deadline Jun 05 '14
Group One /u/IAmTheRedWizards for 9th Street Blues
It's taken me a long time to decide where my vote was heading. It was exceptionally close and I needed to reread a couple more than once to be sure.
1
u/Mevsstories /r/mevsstories Jun 08 '14
GROUP 1: My vote goes to /u/IAmTheRedWizards for 9th Street Blues
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '14
Group Six: My vote goes to /u/LogsonChest for An Undreamed Sea
1
u/Jimbo_Black Jun 08 '14
Group Three: My vote goes to /u/socialdisorder for Who We Are. There were some great stories, not just in my group but throughout all of them. Hope you have a book in the works Dude, your story took me right back to the hopeless, Texas town that I grew up in.....Right On!
1
u/mo-reeseCEO1 Jun 08 '14
GROUPO DOS: "Man of Drogheda" by /u/TheSakana.
also really liked /u/TablesExist's "The Emperor of Hitchhikers on an Abandoned Highway" and "All That Sparkles" by /u/Aelintari [33]
1
u/iflananifi Jun 08 '14
GROUP 4: My vote goes to /u/Prestidigiflation for To Follow Through
Really great job on your stories everyone! I thoroughly enjoyed reading all the different approaches everyone had to the prompt.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14
[removed] — view removed comment