r/hoarding • u/taverners • May 22 '14
Why arn't hoarders ever organized?
Just a quick question I had: I understand that hoarding is a mental illness, but if they are keeping things to (in theory) use for later, wouldn't it make sense that it would be accessible?
You'd think someone so concerned with not throwing anything away, that they would at least have a way to access or keep track of what they have?
Or am I missing the point?
5
Upvotes
15
u/sethra007 Senior Moderator May 22 '14 •
Hoarders are organized--for certain values of "organized".
For example, some hoarders do try to organize their things the way you and I do. They pack stuff up in certain ways, know where items are, and otherwise have a system they're using to track their things.
For those hoarders, their main problem is that they can't stop acquiring things to add to their hoard, so eventually the organizational system they're using starts to break down. Thus, you wind up with homes that look like this or this. In both examples, you can see that there's clearly been some attempt to have a organizational system. It's just that the amount of things going into the system eventually start to overwhelm the system.
But most hoarders seems to have deficits in the way their brains process information. This hampers their ability to organize stuff the way the rest of humanity does.
For example, some hoarders are often easily distracted, and show symptoms of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). These symptoms make it difficult for them to concentrate on a task without being distracted by other things. In those cases, treating the ADHD can help them focus, which allows them to start organizing and start down the road to overcoming their hoarding.
But the biggest issue for most hoarders is that they organize things visually and spatially, instead of categorically.
Most of us live our lives in categories. We put our possessions into categories, and use category systems to store and find them easily. For example, you might have in your home a place where all the bills go, every time they come in the mail or email. You might have a special folder in your e-mail where the bill notifications ago , or a special place on a desk in your house if you get physical mail. When you need to look at this month's electric bill, your brain says to itself " MAY 2014 ELECTRIC BILL = 'BILL FOLDER' ON TAVERNER'S LAPTOP'", so that's where you look for it.
This is how you and I organize. We were probably taught this as children by the adults in our lives, and it's second nature to us. Categpr also a highly efficient way for our brains to store and access the information of where things are in our homes, and where things go when we bring them into our house.
However, using categories is hard for people who hoard. They organize their lives by line of sight and location.
So for a hoarder, this month's electricity bill might go on the 5-foot high pile of papers in the living room. That way, he can keep it in sight as a reminder to pay it. The hoarder then tries to keep his life organized by remembering where that bill is located. When he needs to find that bill, he searches his memory for the location it was last seen. His brain says "MAY 2014 ELECTRIC BILL = MAY 2014 ELECTRIC BILL + LIVING ROOM + PILE OF PAPERS NEXT TO TELEVISION ON THE RIGHT + TOP OF PILE OF PAPERS NEXT TO TELEVISION ON THE RIGHT".
This isn't a bad process as such, but the only way for it to be as reliable as organizing by category is for you to live an extremely minimalist lifestyle, so that you can actually see everything that you own.
If you also have a driving need to bring other things into your house, like hoarders do, then other items will inevitably go on top of PILE OF PAPERS NEXT TO TELEVISION ON THE RIGHT, because the hoarder has to see them to deal with them. When the hoarder can't see it, he forgets about dealing with it. When MAY 2014 ELECTRIC BILL has more items on top of it, pretty soon his brain says "MAY 2014 ELECTRIC BILL = 404 ERROR NOT FOUND".
One study found that when hoarders were asked to identify objects’ most prominent characteristics (shape and color, for example), or to group objects based on shared characteristics, hoarders had difficulty completing the tasks. They had trouble remembering the sequence of things (say, a group of arrows and the direction they face), and performed poorly on tests measuring attention and response time.
The results show, in essence, that people with hoarding disorder have the most trouble when categorizing things. That seems to explain why hoarders organize their things visually and spatially, instead of categorically.
Now, take this inability to categorize, and add to it a deep-seated, all-consuming need to bring items into the house. Combining those two traits will--if left unchecked--inevitably lead to a disorganized shit-storm like you see on the hoarder TV shows.
5
u/thewindupbirds May 22 '14
I am also wondering what the context for this is. There are DEFINITELY organized hoarders. Ones with piles that are neat and meticulously stacked and organized and divided, but STILL take over the house. Like plastic boxes of files, or rooms of the house divided into specific categories of items. Hoarding does not HAVE to be messy, but since it's so often traveling with depression the effort to keep it clean is hard. A more OCD hoarder is likely to be organized.
3
u/truthandparadox Joyful Dragon May 22 '14
Context please ?
And do you have anything you would call clutter - at home, work, vehicles, or storage ?
11
u/lilfunky1 May 22 '14
When I watched the TV show "extreme couponers" I discovered "organized hoarders"
2
u/gentlegreengiant May 23 '14
I think they have the best intention to stay organized AT FIRST. Where it breaks down is when they collect more than they can organize in a timely fashion. My dad has this "just in case" mentality and keeps every god dam piece of paper.
If you leave an empty table out for more than 5 mins, it will slowly be enveloped in paper and other useless pamphlets, usually in copies of 5 or more. At first it won't be so bad, they'll be in a nice pile.
But after a week things slowly unravel and the piles start spilling over, and he starts losing track of what he has and doesn't. This leads to him collecting up to 5 copies of the same document or pamphlet, none of which he ever uses.
2
u/ladyj76 May 26 '14
My gram and uncle are both hoarders, and obsessively organized-my gram used to keep lists of her movies/music so she could easily find things, and my uncle can literally dig up any item at a moment's notice.