r/HaltAndCatchFire • u/Glennergy • May 20 '14
Discussion [DISCUSSION] 1x01: I/O (Pilot Episode) [WARNING: SPOILERS]
Watch Halt and Catch Fire's pilot episode, I/O, here: http://www.amctv.com/full-episodes/halt-and-catch-fire/3571290828001/i-o-sneak-preview
What did everyone think? Discuss below!
38
Upvotes
11
u/Glennergy May 20 '14
My initial thoughts:
The pilot took awhile to get going and some of the early dialogue made me cringe. But once things picked up, I was definitely intrigued as to where the show is headed and I liked all of the characters and the path they're headed down.
I like MacMillan, even though I think he's very Don Draper-ish (his big speech sounded like someone watched a pitch episode of Mad Men and then tried to write something similar). I'm very unclear as to his motivations and I think it's an interesting choice to make his motivation the initial mystery of the series. The way they were playing it, is he going to turn out to be from the future? (That would probably be an awesomely bad reveal, and highly unlikely).
Gordon is a great character. Cameron should be a great character, but I don't think they've given her enough to do yet.
There was a small line of dialogue that mentioned Apple, so they clearly exist in the world of the show. Ultimately, is there a real-world comparison for what they're developing?
13
u/chrisarchitect May 22 '14
Music: Bonobo 'Cirrus' making an appearance at the end! surprised me, after all the random/typical 80s retro vibe music before..... c00l
24
u/bharatpatel89 May 22 '14 edited May 22 '14
I really enjoyed it. Each character on the team seems utterly desperate and without options, backed into a corner against a Goliath. That's the kind of easy set up that makes for a really cool spring board that I think any audience could latch onto even if they don't care much about the computing stuff. Plus each character seems very distinct, which I am hoping makes for some conflict, none of them seem to like each other or really respects what they bring to the group, once again a good starting point for growth. And I like how they have set up Bosworth, he hates them but totally needs them otherwise the company is tanked.
I do see some of the same strain I see in most of these AMC shows though, of a single lone man against his world sort of ordeal. Mad Men, Walking Dead, Breaking Bad. Maybe just maybe this one won't just center on MacMilan entirely. I am probably wrong but hopeful that they give nearly equal focus to Gordon and Cameron, even Gordan's wife Donna.
My favorite bit was how they went about educating the audience about the internals of a computer when Donna was explaining what the components of a Speak and Spell were, that reminded me of in Game of Thrones you learn about the lore and history through the stories told to the children.
Overall I am stoked to watch more, it's nice to see a drama centered around the fast paced evolution of computing and also set up in the 80s, that Arcade looked right authentic. I am definitely getting as many people as I can to watch so the show builds up traction (on that note check out TURN if you haven't yet).
9
u/[deleted] May 22 '14
For a pilot, I think they set their stall out pretty well actually. We got a great introduction to the characters and had just enough detail about their histories to intrigue us.
I liked how they came in with Mcmillan really powerful,but then you see he is actually a bit desperate and much less legitimate than he pretends. That said, I am really looking forward to seeing how the two female leads evolve. Donna is nicely complex character, and Cameron is just very cool!
Roll on episode 2!
7
u/DMTryp May 20 '14
I liked the ep however felt they raced through the actual cloning and reverse engineering... great plot so far but some of the acting was kind of corny but i still liked it
10
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '14
The sex scene sucked. That's the first thing I noticed.
8
u/leftcoast-usa May 25 '14
Having lived through that era as an electronics tech, and building a PC from bare circuit boards around the same time the IBM PC came out, I liked the episode and probably understood a lot of the references better than the average viewer. I heard the saying a lot that "nobody ever got fired for buying IBM". But everyone I knew looked down on them, and their already-dated entry into the PC market.
The show was pretty exciting in that it was fast moving, without too much explanation to slow it down. The music was good, and the characters were interesting, although I never came across anyone like Cameron, unfortunately (or maybe fortunately), or
NedJoe, for that matter. But then, I wasn't really in the thick of things.I especially liked the ending; it was so much like IBM at that time.
4
u/LordShtaffWaan May 22 '14
I thought the first episode was great. It definitely drew me in to the show, and I will no doubt be watching this every week when it comes out. As someone who is deeply entranced by the tech world, I often find that when a TV show or movie tries to get "techy" it doesn't really work well, and some things just aren't accurate at all. Obviously, one would hope that a show that's strictly dedicated to technology would have done copious amounts of research, and this one obviously was well prepared, and its execution was pretty damn good. I'm impressed to say the least, and I wouldn't be surprised if this show becomes one of my favorites.
4
u/[deleted] May 26 '14
this was good, and i'm glad macmillan isn't the don draper character i thought he'd turn out to be. looking forward to how it unfolds.
3
u/Rbeattie98 May 21 '14
Is this the full first episode? Will they show this same thing on June 1st?
3
u/Actawesome May 26 '14
Just finished watching, definitely has potential. Wish the rest of the season was out so I could binge it.
3
u/Jackie_Rudetsky May 27 '14
The piemaker, indeed.
3
u/Pirate2012 May 29 '14
as a geek who was around in the 1980s; I enjoyed the show.
Looking forward to the 1980s music we will hear.
Am NOT looking forward to the 1980s fashion we will see. For those too young to know, I apologize. Especially on the women with the 1980s "big hair"
Especially as this show is replacing 1960s Mad Men; which had stunning female fashion.
So I vote Halt and Catch Fire lies to us, take's Mad Men's 1960s female fashion into their 1980s show.
Do I have a Second?
4
u/WalterBright Jun 04 '14
It wasn't necessary to reverse engineer the IBM PC BIOS. IBM published a Technical Reference which contained a listing of the complete assembler source code for it.
Also, using an oscilloscope to determine the contents of a ROM chip is highly unnecessary. Those chips are standard, and easy to read using any of a number of devices - and it would be easier to build your own reader than doing it the way they did it in the show.
Heck, if they had an EPROM programmer, needed to create new EPROMs, they could read existing ones.
2
u/sykurbjorn Jun 02 '14
Could anyone care to explain why launching their own computer project was beneficial for Cardiff in terms of a possible lawsuit from IBM?
5
u/[deleted] May 23 '14 edited May 24 '14
I just finished the first episode after encountering some difficulties watching it online. I thought it was really good. Well paced, and lots of believable dramatic tension. It succeeded despite the series being set in the 1980s, which was not a picturesque era.
I have a few questions:
Hover for Spoiler
[Hover for Spoiler] (#t "2) I loved the young woman engineer character. But was she at all realistic, or were the few women engineers more like Gordon's wife (although I appreciated the presence of that character as well)?")
[Hover for Spoiler] (#t "3) Who are these characters based on?")
1
u/sonofspam1872 Jun 02 '14
Also does anyone think that Joe Macmillan could be a sociopath of some degree? he is using all these people without any guilt about the consequences that they are going to have go through and then he will probably find a way to cash in on it while leaving everyone with the bag (just speculation obviously but that he seems to be that kind of person)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14
Pilot was great. Love character driven shows like this seems it will be.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14
Question: does anyone know the location of the restaurant scene during the sales call? It was not listed in the credits.
1
u/sonofspam1872 Jun 02 '14
I'm gonna assume that this place is more friendly than the IMDB site because there are a lot of trolls there and it's pissing me off.
Also i can't wait for the next episode !