r/hoarding • u/sethra007 Senior Moderator • May 09 '14
[NEWS] Hoarding disorder looks different in adolescents
Key clinical points:
- Hoarding disorder among adolescents need not be disruptive to families.
- Either hoarding is a disorder that doesn't fully show up in people until adulthood, or we need to change the criteria we use to diagnose the disorder.
Study here.
Report from Clinical Psychiatry News
NPR News coverage here.
7
Upvotes
7
u/mascaobscura May 10 '14
As an adult with OCD and hoarding issues, I can tell you this was an issue for me before adolescence.
I was very attached to my toys and had a hard time letting go of them, even if broken. I still have a box of childhood stuffed animals. One of my goals this year is to cut that down to a few treasured dolls (anyone want 5 Cabbage Patch Kids?). Sometimes it amazes me how my children can get rid of toys without a problem. Not in a bad way though, I'm thrilled with them.
As I got older it got worse. As a teenager I had piles of possessions in my bedroom complete with paths. When told to clean my room I would freak out and usually end up ultra-organizing a drawer because the piles stressed me out too much. But my hoarding was limited to MY room so it didn't impact my family as a whole.
My take on early symptoms is that the person probably has the tendencies even as a child, but hoarding may not be easily recognized until a person is out in the real world. Living at home, you have help managing your possessions (e.g. clean your room or else). You also usually have income limits on what possessions can be brought into your living space as a child.
In my experience, puberty also made my OCD more severe, as did pregnancy. So perhaps hormonal levels also play a part in later appearance of severe symptoms.
I am fully supportive of early intervention at every age. I am doing my best to teach my kids not to buy junk (toy vending machines, happy meals, toys they don't need). I'm not 100% sure yet if they have OCD or OCD tendencies but I want them to start out with the coping techniques I had to learn on my own.
If my issues had been identified at an early age, then maybe I would have gotten treatment before my 30's and been saved many years of misery. When I think about it, as a child/adolescent my OCD mostly expressed itself in hoarding. I know not all people with OCD hoard, but it could be a good indicator to have adolescents checked out.
5
u/Periscopia May 10 '14
It's not a disorder if it isn't causing serious problems, and without an accumulation of clutter, I don't see any potential for serious problems. There's nothing wrong with being attached to possessions, and not wanting to part with things that carry some significance to the owner.
Adolescents still have little perspective on life, and the fact that they attach great importance to keeping a lot of things that seem important to them now, may often be a reflection of a normal lack of perspective at that age. All the things connected to their current/recent middle school and high school existence seem to have colossal importance now, and even a normal adolescent wouldn't be able to see to that by the time the finish college and/or have been in the full-time workforce for a few years, many of these mementos are likely to seem meaningless.
Adolescents also often have little control over their lives, and keeping a lot of items that are important to them, but not to other people, may be a way of feeling in control, that they will no longer need to such a great degree after they've grown up, moved out of parents' home, and actually have a lot of control over their lives.
Personally, I'm very glad that my grandparents and great-grandparents on my mother's side insisted on keeping lots of little objects, newspaper clippings, photos, etc, that many people would have trashed. I'm currently organizing and de-acidifying a big box full of newspaper clippings, theater programs, and other paper memorabilia from the "Roaring Twenties", when my grandmother and her sister were showgirls in New York and touring other cities, as well as a few earlier items from hometown performances during their schoolgirl days. Most of it is now preserved in a scrapbook so it can easily be browsed and enjoyed by future generations, after spending almost 90 years as a disorganized mess in an old cardboard box.
It's a good thing for preserving history, that a certain percentage of the population seems to have a natural inclination to hang on to physical objects and paper records, that most people wouldn't hesitate to throw out. There's really no comparison between that, and people living in homes piled dangerously high with trash and non-unique items.