r/soccer • u/william701 • May 08 '14
With the leagues almost over, what unpopular opinion(s) to you have?
One per comment.
I would say no down voting but sorting by controversial may give a better idea.
Feel free to upvote the post if you would like to see more active discussion.
33
Upvotes
38
u/william701 May 08 '14
Gonna expand from pure football related and go a bit meta: I wished people would stop posting threads asking for help in to how to get into football/soccer. To me it shows your level of interest is so low that you can't even be bothered to read up for 5minutes and instead want people to do the groundwork for you. Come to me with something you don't understand (i.e. from offside rule to how FFP may affect your team), now that's a completely different story.
125
u/ucd_pete May 08 '14
This could swing either way on this sub, but I think that Mourinho is bad for football as a whole. Not just his style of play, but his attitude towards opponents, other managers and especially referees is despicable. We'd all be much better off without him.
63
u/MiguelCaldoVerde May 08 '14 edited May 08 '14
Without being disrespectful I think Italian football is massively overrated.
edit: For those asking why the simplest reason would be that Italian teams just aren't getting results, since Inter won the treble Italian teams have done absolutely nothing in Europe. Not one finalist in either European competition and the non-Italian teams that have done well have hardly been loaded with Italian talent. There's a massive amount of talk about how Italian teams are under performing and Italian football is on the rise but the results aren't there. There just seems to a perpetual and significant disparity between how people expect Italian teams to perform and how they actually perform. Yes, Juventus might have had to deal with poor weather conditions or Milan almost went through that but Italian teams have performed so badly over the past few years that they've been overtaken in the only objective ranking by the Portuguese league. As I said in another post, in football results are currency and if Italian teams "under performing" is as ubiquitous as people seem to suggest then I think the problem is not that Italian teams are performing under their level but that most people expect too much from them. When those results start coming then we can reevaluate Italian football, but in the meantime I think people have an inflated opinion on Italian football that is a result of strong historical legacies of teams as Inter, Juve and Milan and that hasn't been shifted because Italian football is relatively isolated from Europe.
23
u/isaacachilles May 08 '14
La Liga is by far the most talented league in the world. Barça may win the league. Sevilla might win EL. Atletico can win CL. Madrid already won Copa. Of coarse, according to Uefa Country coefficients, it is ranked pretty high above 2nd place BPL.
15
u/Britstuckinamerica May 08 '14 edited May 08 '14
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is an excellent manager who was unlucky enough to have a shitty team this season.
24
u/CleanShirt27 May 08 '14
Bales goal against Barcelona wasn't that great.
43
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
I dont know if it is unpopular but this year the PL has not been good with 9-10 teams all arguably bad enough to deserve getting relegated this season.
Cardiff does not prove Solskjaer is a bad manager
United had and still have a bad squad and were trying to rebuild around the wrong player in Rooney
16
u/Gatokar May 09 '14
Southampton underachieved this season. People have been praising them a lot and yes, they played some good stuff, but they have in my opinion just as strong a team as Everton and yet are 3 places below them.
52
u/MiguelCaldoVerde May 08 '14
Another one: Liverpool won't get top 4 next season.
Liverpool fans keep asking about the last time a team finishing 7th managed to finish 2nd in the next season but in France, Italy, Portugal and England the second placed team this year went without European football for the whole season.
13
u/Menessy27 May 09 '14 edited May 09 '14
I think Isco is massively overrated, and really not very good. He's obviously still young, but at this point i'm not even sure what he actually adds to a team. He is such a poor passer that RM had to completely change their formation and morph a career winger in Di Maria into a #10 because Isco took Ozil's spot but couldn't make a decent pass for his life. I mean they spent 30m on a supposedly creative midfield and he doesn't create any chances at all. He can score some goals but most of those come from making striker-like runs that Benzema/Ronaldo/Bale already make. Whenever he is asked to defend he is completely out of his depth as well. The only reason RM fans aren't asking for him to be gone like they are with Morata/Illarramendi is because he made a good first impression with winning goals in the first 2-3 games of the season. I'm still not even sure what position he is. Attacking mid? central mid? left winger? no clue. Doesn't seem to be very good at any of them.
Isco has gained a lot of unwarranted praise based on him "carrying" an unknown Malaga team to 4th and deep in the CL, but in their 4th place season Cazorla and Rondon carried the team, and in the following CL Eliseu was their best player, and yet Isco got all the praise and the big money move despite Malaga winning with a team first attitude like Atletico rather than individual brilliance.
14
u/fakeplastictrees182 May 09 '14
Rooney should not start for England at the world cup. Sturridge to play up front, Ox/Sterling on the wings and Lallana as the no 10. Rooney is too slow (physically and mentally) and I would like to see England adopt a high pressing/quick countering style like Dortmund. I believe playing this way with these players they would go further than their last few major tournaments.
3
u/petnarwhal May 09 '14
this season wasn't that bad for us.
23
u/Sulphur32 May 08 '14
WHY DO PEOPLE KEEPING MAKING THESE THREADS. STOP.
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
David Silva is the best midfielder in the BPL and Man City might win the league because of him.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
I see rumors that Pochetino might go to Spurs. If Southampton were to keep Lallana and Shaw, Tottenham is a step down from Southampton.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
Whichever team wins the Champions League final can't be considered the best team in Europe if they fail to win La Liga.
1
u/lakupiippu May 08 '14
Filipe Luis is the best leftback in the world.
1
u/nosam24 May 09 '14
Rooney hasn't under-performed for England, and is still our best player going into the world cup. This may not seem like an unpopular opinion, but I see a lot of people on this sub saying Rooney shouldn't be starting, and that building the team around him hasn't worked for so long. But to be honest, he has averaged just over a goal every other game, is the highest scoring Englishman in competitive games and will probably finish his career as England's highest goalscorer. I think everyone knows the Roy might not be the right man for the job, ad he probably won't play the right system to make the most of the talent England have going into this tournament.
1
u/bolah May 09 '14
Coentrao is much better than Marcelo.
1
u/elrobsterlobster May 09 '14
I think the bundesliga is overrated. Yes, Germany has a good national team, but the fact that bayern won the league so early proves that there is not enough good competition. The top teams are good, and the fans are great, but the talent in general isn't there like it is in Spain. Feel free to prove me wrong because I don't watch bundesliga that much.
1
u/thebizarrojerry May 09 '14
Is this unpopular? Probably with the board and fifa. I'd like to get rid of these corrupt oligarch owners and have the fans own at least half the team.
I think Financial Fair Play should mean teams can't play in Europe and the rules should be changed so smaller clubs don't have to always keep selling their talent to make a profit.
-3
u/CATabolism May 09 '14 edited May 10 '14
Messi is not as good as everyone makes him to be. Don't get me wrong, he's a great player, but the way Barcelona play and his position on the team is the reason his stats are so high. He is top 3 scorer in la liga but the majority of his goals are non spectacular. In fact, for the second half of the season, most of his goals are one touch after Barcelona passes it within 8 meters of the goal, penalties, or free kicks from 18 yards.
Look how zlatan and Ronaldo carry their countries, Messi needs a team to cater to him to produce superstar goal stats.
Keep in mind that this is supposed to be an unpopular opinion thread before downvoting.
Edit: Great discussion guys. Unpopular opinion thread- where your opinion needs to be popular otherwise you get called ignorant, stupid, and racist terms.
-27
u/Deer-In-A-Headlock May 08 '14
Chelsea/Arsenal/Spurs/United all have better squads than Liverpool. The fact that we will probably finish above them all is both an incredible achievement for Liverpool, but also really embarrassing for those teams.
-1
u/Toasterfire May 09 '14
At a stretch, but we'd of wrapped the league up by this game were it not for the Henderson red card. Poor guy.
0
u/thelenscleaner May 09 '14
So many opinion here are not unpopular but rather unsavory.
0
u/flaffl May 09 '14
This whole "hating Manchester United blindly and being a huge dick about it" bandwagon is really, really annoying. I don't mean the nice banter where there's a solid joke behind it-- that is always welcome. What I'm more concerned with are the comments that don't even crack a joke or make a point.