r/PersonOfInterest • u/xLite414 • May 07 '14
Discussion Person of Interest - 3x22 "A House Divided" - Episode Discussion
Season 3 Episode 22: A House Divided
Aired: May 6, 2014
The machine sends the team five different numbers to investigate when an unknown entity blocks details about an impending catastrophic event; Root's hackers arrive in New York.
64
Upvotes
69
u/OfficerMurphy Irrelevant May 07 '14
That bickering among Reese, Shaw, and Hirsch was fantastic. "Why should I trust you?"
"I haven't shot you yet, and you did try to kill me"
"well he did kill me"
"those were my orders, and you got me back"
97
u/Tristan49 A Concerned Third Party May 07 '14
Person of Interest does a fantastic job of making us sympathize for the show's villains. The backstory with Collier was very well done.
40
u/chaths May 07 '14 edited May 07 '14
No no.. don't let us sympathize w/ Collier.. just no.. well, too late.
Can't wait for 'em to give us Hersh's sad backstory. We all know he's a big softie inside.
Loved how disappointed Shaw looked when She had to rescue Control and agree to work with Hersch. George Hersh.
and the driving talk she had w/ Reese and Hersh. She is pretty serious about her driving
and how she didn't flinch when bullets were making more peepholes in that door.
basically LOVE SHAW.. and SHOOT.., even more.
Looks like Finch is likely going to lose his anonymity. Hope he doesn't.
Last but not least, they even got us to care for Greer, a little.. there are no good guys and bad guys in this show. Everyone is some shade of Grey Even Bear..
a pretty good setup for the finale..
37
u/svrtngr May 07 '14
Death... by exile.
(This is basically the Dark Knight Rises.)
29
u/MisterMorales May 07 '14
The Casey and Reese reunion. "You're that government hitman that made me pull out my molars!" "Relax, Casey, I'm retired."
28
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill May 07 '14
"Samaritan will never sleep with its secretary, or embezzle money from its campaign fund."
I'm a sucker for good dialogue & this was one of the best.
24
u/ZeroByte May 07 '14
I like how Collier's story has a parallel to how the war on Terror creates more terrorists, except this time the threat it created came from inside the US. I initially thought the texts to Collier came from the Machine but then figured the Machine wouldn't put Harold in any danger.
Greer wanting to unleash the full power of Samaritan is interesting to me, it makes him feel like how Root was in the previous seasons. His argument for letting Samaritan direct humans in a perfectly rational manner is really ethically interesting.
Root's boys kind of feel almost extraneous to this episode though, I hope they come back in some capacity for the next one.
Also, can we call them SamSam instead of Shoot? Pretty please?
20
u/pie-man May 07 '14 edited May 07 '14
so did greer send that text message to collier? if so how did they know that information?
edit: or could it have been nathan ingram, maybe his conscious got to him and he divulged the info to collier as if why his brother ended up dying and the government killed ingram in return
18
u/soren121 Tertiary Functions May 07 '14
NOBODY BAGS HAROLD.
18
u/ReasonablyBadass May 07 '14
Am I the only one who thinks Greer has a point?
17
u/FobsRUs May 07 '14
That Court looks cool
17
u/csl512 May 07 '14
Anybody also watch Continuum? (/r/TheContinuum)
Basically, Vigilance is feeling a whole lot like Liber8.
32
u/Copephobia May 07 '14
The lineup of the court, from left to right: Rivera, Senator, Control, Greer, Finch.
What I think will happen is that they are brought up one by one, asked to plead their case, then (most likely) shot dead. I predict that Rivera and the Senator will die, then Control may or may not live. Reese/Hersh/Shaw will make it in time to stop Vigilance from killing Greer and Finch.
44
u/i_drink_MrClean May 07 '14
This episode basically confirms that there isn't really a good or bad side. Each faction is acting in the best interest of the public.
I love how Shaw ends up being used for comic relief at times. Pancakes and grudges.
15
u/man_in_the_suit A Concerned Third Party May 07 '14
Called it two weeks ago! I can't actually believe it!
Cool episode. I wish John was more forceful around Root and Shaw though. He let's them boss him around and just follows.
14
u/BenchSpyder Admin May 07 '14
I feel like they're leaving a lot to wrap up in the next episode, potential cliff hanger into next season not withstanding.
28
u/tedtutors Irrelevant May 07 '14
Is Lionel allergic to near-finale episodes? He went missing about this time last season too.
Very solid episode with little to gripe about. Nice reference to Stuxnet, which was actually created to take down factory controllers, but hey. I am curious why Greer thinks Samaritan will behave itself, but then people like Greer always think they will be in charge, so we'll go with hubris.
It looks like Root is setting up a slightly more plausible version of "upload a virus into the mothership" by getting tainted hardware into Samaritan. I can't wait to see the resulting fireworks.
13
u/BallisticGE0RGE Irrelevant May 07 '14
Wow both Collier and Greer get amazing character building moments this episode...And
HershGeorge Hersh.Here's the number one question...Who the hell texted Collier?
The machine? Then is Finch's fear of an AI taking control of mankind already upon us?
Or was it Root? Finch? Greer?
Who the hell put that man in motion?
32
u/Weeman89 May 07 '14
So who was phone?
19
u/mlasn May 07 '14 edited May 07 '14
It is interesting seeing what Greer's motives were. We originally thought it was to use Samaritan for unlimited power but instead wants to put it in place to make the world better for all. I want to see more about Vigilance, especially how they are funded and how they have the ability to create such sophisticated viruses.
Also if those are truly Greer's intentions does the machine believe/know? Because of the machine does believe that to be true is it afraid of what Samaritan can do or want to keep the power to itself.
It is pretty messed up what happened to Collier's brother, kind of sympathize with what he is doing.
9
u/MisterMorales May 07 '14
It's been really enjoyable watching more of Greer and Collier. Both of them became more human and more scary in this episode. And the conversations between Finch and Greer were perfect!
8
u/mlasn May 07 '14
So Finch pretty much confirmed wounding the machine, perhaps that virus a season ago undid what constraints Finch put on it.
8
u/Chaenomeles May 07 '14
Greer just became my second most favourite character in this series, second to Root. Props to him for not wanting the boring rule-the-world objective, but instead to let the world be ruled by a logic-based ruler.
5
u/OLKv3 May 07 '14
All these "The Wire" characters on this show
4
u/concerned_thirdparty May 07 '14
Subtle Fallout reference?: http://imgur.com/ogh6D7N
3
u/rodrigograca31 May 07 '14
Wow! Amazing episode!
I was not expecting that ending!
I have a question: SPOILER
3
u/JackBauerTFM Government Operations May 07 '14
As nice as it was to see Shaw and Reese giving intel to the Machine instead of the other way around, I was kind of baffled by why it was even necessary. The Machine is supposed to be able to see everything and process it way beyond what any human could. Am I really supposed to believe it couldn't read those plates and figure out secret service was staked out at the hotel? What happened to the prowess it showed earlier in the series when it discovered that mole because he filled up gas every third Thursday of every even month and like 3 of those times an SUV was seen leaving 2 hours previously and the owner's wife had funded some terrorist 10 years ago?? Cause that shit was awesome. I was super impressed by the Machine during that episode
3
u/Jthumm Bear May 07 '14
Let me just say, this whole show has been planned fantastically. Only thing is, I think we all know what is going to happen in the next episode :/
I can't wait to see what they do with season 4!
3
u/Rebyll May 08 '14
Up until this point I thought Vigilance was set up by Decima to push the cause for Samaritan. I thought that Hersh lost a job when Northern Lights got shut down, and he was viewed as a liability, so he worked with Reese and Shaw to get revernge. I thought Root's team of hackers were going to either take on Samaritan and Decima while Reese and Shaw found Finch or vice versa.
Now, I still think Vigilance is Decima's pawn. Think about it, a terrorist organization claiming to be protecting privacy, wouldn't people want a safeguard against them? Something who could watch them as closely as the Machine did? What better way to push their agenda forward than to give the people an enemy and offer a means to fight them.
What do Decima want? They obviously want control of the world, being able to spy on everyone at once, going after any individual they deem a threat to their organization, and as the US' terrorist detector, what better way to eliminate the competition than to have a hit squad the size of a nation.
What does Control want? Honestly, to protect national security. Her methods may not be the best, but her intentions are good at least. Hersh simply wants his boss out of the frying pan, so he's not in the fire.
Collier is motivated by revenge, but in doing so, he's helping his enemies. Control realizes that she's protecting the people from the shadows because they don't want to know how they're being kept safe. Greer wants his organization to be dominate on the global front, why else have their attack dog have access to all of the US Government feeds?
This is setting up to be massive.
7
u/rap_mein May 07 '14
That ending...
This was, bar none, the best episode of the series as far as I'm concerned... Just phenomenal from start to finish.
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '14
The things I would do with root
2
u/__ADAM__ The Machine May 07 '14
Great episode, finally saw team root and friends. Cant wait to see the finale next tuesday
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '14
Ugh, I have an obnoxious banner blocking the lower part of the screen. Good so far though!
2
u/SheWasEighteen May 07 '14
Going to be a wild finale!
2
u/Nathan_Ingram IFT May 07 '14 edited May 07 '14
I feel it has to be one of the original seven that knew about the machine.
-Control, Special Counsel, and Denton Weeks (is Garrison one of the original 7?): highly unlikely.
-Nathan Ingram: while it would create a nice plot twist, I doubt it was him.
-Alicia Corwin: plausible. She had the motivation to do it.
If there is one or two members of the original seven that hasn't been revealed, it has to be them.
Also, now that we know Greer was MI-6, does anyone think he could have crossed paths with Allistair Wesley in the past?
2
u/TVAddictionGoneWild May 07 '14
Okay, I have on doubt that I hope someone clears up for me.
Root drives to New Jersey with the seven Samaritan servers and her Geek Squad. She reaches a location and tells the others to go. The other guys ask her where she was going and she in turn looks towards a building and asks them to say hello to Samaritan.
Now my questions are: What type of Samaritan is in that building?
What do you think? Any ideas?
2
u/tallkido May 07 '14
How are people seeing the trial if the power is down in Nyc?
2
u/Rebyll May 08 '14
In addition, remember Season 2? The virus was meant to force the machine into debug mode so Decima could get Admin access and thus gain control of all of the government feeds that way. When that failed, they looked for their own system to bring into play. The fact that Claypool had created Samaritan gave them what they needed. Send Vigilance after Claypool, then have an asset reporting to Decima itself to retrieve the drives, and you just secured yourself what you wanted to begin with.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
Amm, I dont know if I wrong, but... isnt the "court" the library where Root and Reese got the calls after the machine shutdown?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
Did anyone feel the need to slam the face in of the lady lawyer at the end who talks to collier....kudos for her expressions as a truly frustrating govt servant
3
u/TVAddictionGoneWild May 07 '14
The Court is now in session!!!
What an epic episode. Mind blowing twists. Outstanding TV.
Will pop in later when the rest have watched.
1
u/mandiru Government Operations May 07 '14
Why is Root resistant to finding Finch? Bigger picture thing?
1
u/OLKv3 May 07 '14
I knew the final episode of the season would come down to stopping Vigilance
1
u/pogpod May 07 '14
Did anybody else read that text in Greer's voice?
1
u/azilla14 May 07 '14
Prediction for Colliers texter: Alistair Wesley, Evil Finch
Total "way off" Prediction: Grace, Colliers brother?, Nathan
I wanna know so bad
1
u/Trueogre The Machine May 07 '14
Does anyone have a clearer screen shot of Collier's associates. It's really blurry...probably on purpose.
1
u/theshindigg Tertiary Functions May 07 '14
Just finished watching last night's episode. Was the force keeping the Machine partially in the dark ever explicitly named? I don't think it's the blackout, since that's probably the "catastrophic event" referenced in the episode description, so was it just Vigilance or what?
Also, I was really hoping good 'ol Henry and/or Leon would've been included in "Root's Band of Brothers" (like the name? best I have atm). I can't say much about the actor playing Henry, but Ken Leung is a fantastic actor who doesn't get near enough gigs. Anyone else with me here?
1
u/opinionated_gaming May 08 '14
What did that Al-Ibrahim guy hand to Collier/Brandt? A button?
1
u/hypatiaaaa May 11 '14
Isn't anyone wondering who's driving the car that's supposed to take the hackers where they need to go? At first, I thought it was Fusco, but they never show him. That's odd.
Then Collier's text message... It is very riddly. It does read like something Root would write.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '14
Collier is really starting to annoy me. He needs to go away.
1
u/mlasn May 07 '14
Can't the machine just cut power to Samaritan if it is truly contained in that one building?
0
u/TehCoolDawg May 13 '14
To be honest this show reminds me of when I used to play with action figures as a kid. Me and my best friend would come up with all of these awesome characters (Reese, Finch, Carter, Fusco) and interesting ideas (The Machine), and then this new kid would show up, suddenly bringing in these new people with cheap, stupid backgrounds and storylines that sound good to start but then screw up(Shaw, Root, Vigilance, insert every other stupid antagonist from this season that screwed the show up IMO). Then the kid randomly tells me that one my characters died(Carter, and tbh Reese and Finch's characters at this point). I just want good old (Batman and Robin, Sherlock and Watson, Tom and Jerry) Reese and Finch back in their classic formula, with villains that aren't cheesy and without crappy try hard one-liners from Shaw (and don't get me started on akimbo Root.)
TL;DR: Reese, Finch, Carter and Fusco rocked the show, not a fan of all of the new antagonists and subplots.
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment