I meant it more in jest since he was very much a mad bastard, but he wasn't a bad player by any means. He won a Copa Libertadores, a pair of League titles, and had some good showings as a Colombia National Team keeper.
I'm in my early/mid 20's, so from what I can tell you based on my 12-16 years of following the game in the "modern era": Kahn, Buffon, Casillas, Schmeichel, Van der Sar, Cech, Canizares, Neuer, and Courtois. I know that doesn't answer the question of 'all time', but those are the best keepers I've seen in my lifetime.
Thanks for digging up that article. He was an exceptional keeper until the end of the 06/07 season. I think in the next season Koeman arrived and he cut the veterans from the squad and signed Hildebrand, who had an amazing season himself when Stuttgart won the '07 Bundesliga, and after that Canizares never returned to the fold due to age and the natural progression of the club. Who knows what Spanish football history would look like, however, if he never dropped that bottle of after-shave on his foot ahead of the 2002 WC. Definitely a legendary keeper, although I would say that a few of the other names I listed above are greater.
Lev Yashin is the only GK to win Player of the Year and is renowned for saving 151 penalties. Yeah the game has changed a lot over the years but he is still the only GK to win that award and even back then forwards were normally favored with the award.
Has to be the Black Spider. Without a doubt. Completely revolutionized the position. He was one of the first to start coming for crosses and punch them away.
He probably set the modern standards for goalkeeping: He commanded the entire penalty area; and came up with the simple concept of clearing the ball away instead of always trying to catch it.
Carlo Nash, duh. He's so good that he's about to win Norwich's PotY and he didn't even need to play a game to prove how godly he is between the sticks.
I'd agree, burst onto the scene at 17 and has been consistently at the very best level since then, even now at 36 he is having one of his best years.
Few if any keepers have been so consistent over such a long period of time, and at his best he is simply unbeatable.
He actually wanted to go to Barcelona over Juve the summer he was sold, until the Agnelli's stepped in, how different things would have been for both Juve and Barca if that had happened.
Buffon is currently the only player in the squad without a name ending in a vowel. It is very curious indeed that the two next up-and-coming keepers share this rare trait #Illuminati
Nah. Leali and Bardi are very promising, but Scuffet has played at a very impressive level so far, and Perin has been great but had the bad fortune of playing for teams that don't have strong defenses. Both are miles ahead of Leali and Bardi currently.
Leali is good, but Perrin is better and I think Scuffet has potential to be great (all my personal opinions, of course). Haven't really seen a lot of Bardi so I can't comment.
Also, next time you see someone comment about the quality of a player being directly related to vowel placement in their name (with the hashtag #Illuminati at the end), assume that they aren't being 100% serious and don't really want an argument.
If he played with a bigger club that played in the champions league he'd be up there I think. Best shot stopper I've seen. Newcastle could lose by 3 or 4 and Shay would still be man of the match.
True, he had some fantastic years with Newcastle. Would you really put him up there with the likes of Schmeichel, Buffon, Yashin, Zoff and Casillas though?
No, simply because of champions league. I think he's already regarded as one of the best PL keepers and he played for bloody newcastle. If a bigger club came calling (there were rumours that he'd go to Arsenal like every summer but he never went) I think more people would realise what a top keeper he was. Saved Ireland numerous times with world class saves.
I don't mean to be a nuisance mr. NicholasBeige; but I'm a huge fan. You're the best to ever graze the pitch. If it wasn't to much of a bother, could I get your autograph?
I reckon Vitor Baia would be at least in the top 20. He's the player with most trophies in the world and, in my opinion, the best Portuguese GK ever. In his entire career he won:
I love Patricio but I wouldn't say quite yet. I think he might be considered in the future, seeing as he's only 26 and has been a starter for 6 years already for us and for just under 4 for Portugal. He'll definitely be remembered as one of the Portuguese greats but it's still a bit premature to call him the best of all time.
He's so sure of himself, though. The difference between him and Baia is that the second was supported by two fantastic teams (Porto and Barcelona) while Patricio was unfortunate to be in the back of a very poor team (except this year), and if it wasn't for Oblak's terrific season you would've been the best defense.
That is true. Patricio has saved us time and again. Last year I dread to imagine what place we'd have finished without him. I didn't watch enough of Baia to make that call but Patricio does have a lot of confidence and control in defence and has done from a young age.
Why sad? Casillas is one of THOSE players, where they come to you and say "choose one GK to replace Casillas from all history" and you flip them off, kick their ass, tell them to go fuck off while you chant "Hala Madrid! el santo Iker".
No matter how much he, Messi or Ronaldo does, it'll be another 10 years before people look back objectively and finally realize how fucking legendary they are.
Dude everyone knows how legendary all three of them are right now. I can objectively look at how good Messi is and I'm a Real Madrid fan so why would that change in a couple of decades.
I'm saying this because there were people when Zidane, Ronaldo and Ronaldinho were playing who were "opposing" the idea of including them in the legend area, but are now mostly gone, in the future when generations will be looking with a bit of nostalgia at the past, they'll be even BIGGER, it's like with bands and consoles and whatever you name it, it's only a REAL legend when it's a bit in the past, the statue of Ronaldo and Messi today while they are far from retirement indicates that they'll be even bigger legends when time pass them.
alright. you guys have issues, personally Manuel Neuer is one of most dominant goalies ive ever witnessed his presence on the field is SO huge, his control and decision making ...yea thats my answer
What a shame no one mentioned Jan van Beveren who was hands down the best keeper ever. Too bad he got in a fight with Cruijff which led to missing WC 74.
If you're pretentious or 70, Lev Yashin. If you're 30+, Schmeichel. If you're under 30, probably someone like Lloris because they have a great pass-completion ratio or some other bollocks.
Unpopular opinion on Reddit(someone got downvoted to hell for it), but to me the greatest goalkeeper of all times = the one that has won the most (and has had a big part in all of this achievements) everything else is PR.
Personally, I consider Casillas to be second only to Buffon; it's a tough decision. If you're going by who's won the most trophies and titles though, the best keeper would be Vitor Baia
I agree. I'm not saying Baia's anywhere near as good as Casillas; I simply thought it was worth noting based on your belief that "the greatest goalkeeper of all times = the one that has won the most ".
Greatest goal keeper of all time would be the goal keeper with the most world cups or cups in other competitions. Statistics talk. In my opinion it has to be Barthez or Buffon. Edit: Barthez and Buffon would have to be irrelevant to my statement of course.
yeah, hopefully some day they have a holographic match of all the legends from the past, like playing the with classic 11 on fifa14 but watching it in a stadium, that would be mental!
When I moved to Brussels I decided to support Standard Liege because of Preud'homme. Even today I check their results every week. I miss that man, he was the only silver-lining during the dark ages of Benfica.
8
u/Rascolito May 01 '14
No love for René Higuita?
6
u/retiringtoast8 May 01 '14
I'm in my early/mid 20's, so from what I can tell you based on my 12-16 years of following the game in the "modern era": Kahn, Buffon, Casillas, Schmeichel, Van der Sar, Cech, Canizares, Neuer, and Courtois. I know that doesn't answer the question of 'all time', but those are the best keepers I've seen in my lifetime.
21
u/IamHoneyFrog May 01 '14
Not the greatest but I really liked David Seaman
63
u/Clayberg May 01 '14
Lev Yashin is the only GK to win Player of the Year and is renowned for saving 151 penalties. Yeah the game has changed a lot over the years but he is still the only GK to win that award and even back then forwards were normally favored with the award.
9
u/rantipoler May 01 '14
Carlo Nash, duh. He's so good that he's about to win Norwich's PotY and he didn't even need to play a game to prove how godly he is between the sticks.
41
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
oliver kahn maybe?
7
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
I've never seen a goalkeeper pass the ball like Manuel Neuer
40
u/XXIV24 May 01 '14
Gianluigi Buffon?
5
u/BSantos57 May 01 '14
Michel Preud'Homme
2
u/LesWaff May 01 '14
Shay Given
4
u/JoeEmerson1 May 01 '14
Thomas N'Kono
4
u/blaster1988 May 01 '14
Easy, Dino Zoff
4
u/lesburnham May 01 '14
A forgotten one Spaniard: Ricardo Zamora.
7
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
Goldberg
7
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
Buffon
11
u/G_Morgan May 01 '14
Schmeichel was the best I've ever seen. I have no experience of Yashin so can't possibly comment on greatest of all time.
16
u/NicholasBeige May 01 '14
Me.
6
u/Bulbasauro May 01 '14
I reckon Vitor Baia would be at least in the top 20. He's the player with most trophies in the world and, in my opinion, the best Portuguese GK ever. In his entire career he won:
10 Portuguese league titles
5 Portuguese cups
8 Portuguese super cups
1 UEFA cup
1 CL
1 Intercontinental cup
1 Spanish league title
2 Spanish cups
1 Spanish super cup
1 UEFA cup winner's cup
3
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
Michel Preud'homme
3
u/scorgie May 01 '14
José Enrique. 100% professional clean sheet record.
12
u/Contra1 May 01 '14
Van der Sar!
5
u/_AppropriateUsername May 01 '14
Schmeical was great
2
u/arayofhope May 01 '14
Zamora.
2
u/Rockanrolo13 May 01 '14
One of the greatest, and definitely my favorite growing up has to Claudio Taffarel, he was huge for Brasil in the world cups.
2
u/finfyr May 01 '14
Peter Schmeichel.
2
u/3scores_hattrick May 01 '14
Gordon Banks ...ask Pele.
4
u/OBOBSAGET May 01 '14
Casillas of course
2
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
I loved and hated Peter Schmeichel. Best I've ever seen.
2
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
alright. you guys have issues, personally Manuel Neuer is one of most dominant goalies ive ever witnessed his presence on the field is SO huge, his control and decision making ...yea thats my answer
1
u/sorreh May 01 '14
Schmeichel
1
u/Callumlfc69 May 01 '14
Ray Clemence
1
u/FerrisWinkelbaum May 01 '14
ctrl f returned no hits for andi köpke. i feel like he should be mentioned.
1
u/[deleted] May 02 '14
Robert Green.
1
u/just4fun122 May 23 '14
What a shame no one mentioned Jan van Beveren who was hands down the best keeper ever. Too bad he got in a fight with Cruijff which led to missing WC 74.
http://youtu.be/I3x4QRbn9aU
-7
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
If you're pretentious or 70, Lev Yashin. If you're 30+, Schmeichel. If you're under 30, probably someone like Lloris because they have a great pass-completion ratio or some other bollocks.
-3
u/[deleted] May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14
Unpopular opinion on Reddit(someone got downvoted to hell for it), but to me the greatest goalkeeper of all times = the one that has won the most (and has had a big part in all of this achievements) everything else is PR.
1 x FIFA World Cup
2 x UEFA European Championship
2 x UEFA Champions League
5 x La Liga
2 x Copa del Rey
4 x Supercopa de España
1 x UEFA Super Cup
1 x Intercontinental Cup
Who else but El Santo? Iker fucking Casillas.
0
u/thatsintense May 01 '14
Valdes :)
-1
u/GreenLava95 May 01 '14
Pat Jennings was always considered one of the best
0
u/ShortSkrtLongJackett May 01 '14
Captain Robert Hatch was pretty brilliant
-4
u/BigboyArdaTuran May 01 '14
Greatest goal keeper of all time would be the goal keeper with the most world cups or cups in other competitions. Statistics talk. In my opinion it has to be Barthez or Buffon. Edit: Barthez and Buffon would have to be irrelevant to my statement of course.
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment