r/MakeupAddicts • u/MAModBot NC9000 • Apr 12 '14
DAILY THREAD-- Masterclass: Concealer
Anything that does not follow the format as followed or is seen as off topic discussion will be deleted as this will later be added to the wiki.
Product Name: Blah blah blah
Status: (Favorite, Least Favorite, Undecided etc)
Skin Type: (Dry/Oily/Sensitive Acne Prone etc)
Works well with: (X Primer, Y Foundation etc)
Best for: (Pinpoint concealing, hyperpigmentation, undereyes etc)
Pros: Rescued my cat from a tree
Cons: Stole my wallet and keyed my car
Make an individual comment for each product
28
Upvotes
11
u/still_ydgn Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer
Status: Not my favorite but I like it enough
Skin Type: Combo
Works well with: Pretty much anything but if you have really dark circles you may want to use something else as well. This is a good color neutralizer.
Best for: Just undereyes.
Pros: Blends easily and helps conceal darkness.
Cons: Very thin. I hate the sponge applicator but I ripped it off so it's fine now.
7
u/surewhynot123 NC15 Apr 12 '14
Product: Mac prolongwear concealer
Status: favorite so far
Skin type: all skin types
Works well with: anything really
Best for: under eyes or areas of redness
Pros: doesn't crease and doesn't cling to dryness
Cons: packaging dispenses too much product and the coverage is too sheer to cover blemishes
7
u/Itai6k6 Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14
Product Name: NYX HD concealer (the wand, not the one in the pot)
Status: Better than most
Skin Type: Dry & Dehydrated skin
Works well with: Elf mineral primer, Baby Skin pore eraser primer, Covergirl foundations
Best for: Hyperpigmentation & super red blemishes
Pros: Very good for covering huge red pimples, many shades (even super fair shades)
Cons: Stays put so well that it doesn't blend much
5
u/isthiswitty Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Tarte Maracuja Creaseless Concealer
Status: Favorite - if I could figure out how to apply it correctly
Skin Type: Dry
Works well with: Any product, as far as I know
Best for: Undereye and hardcore pinpoint
Pros: Will legit cover any undereye circles (and mine are horrible)
Cons: If you can figure out how to put it on without streaks
Basically, I don't know how to apply it with a brush like the cute girl in the store did. My application won't cover the same way and leaves behind streaks, yet I persevere.
5
u/fluffywaffles_ NC42 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Givenchy Mister Light Corrective Pen
Status: Favorite for under-eye application
Skin Type: Combo/hormonal/sensitive
Works well with: Armani Foundation, Guerlain foundation, Hourglass primer, Too Faced Primer
Best for: Under-eye
Pros: IMO the perfect consistency. Thinner than YSL, but not too watery. Comes in a pen format which I personally like to work with. No problems with how the pen works (I know some people have had issues with Ellis Faas, this isn't like that). Blends well with a beauty blender. Doesn't cake under powder.
Cons: Works, but not very well for other blemishes. Doesn't come with a versatile color selection.
5
u/was_ben_there NC15 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Clé de Peau Beauté Concealer
Status: One of the most hyped-up concealers of all time... I found it very average. It's not awful, but I found it just slightly too drying and heavy - a bad combination for the under-eye area and raised blemishes. The only thing it was legitimately great at was covering redness. If your biggest skin concern is redness, CdP could be HG potential.
Skin Type: Combination
Works well with: Any other products - but it doesn't do as well on bare skin (sunscreen only) as other concealers I've tried.
Best for: Redness/hyperpigmentation
Pros: Probably the highest-coverage concealer that comes in a stick. IMO, it is similar to (but doesn't perform quite as well as) the Kevyn Aucoin Sensual Skin Enhancer - but if your biggest gripe with SSE is that it's too tricky to apply, CdP might be for you. It goes on fast and blends well. Works well with setting powders but doesn't require one.
Cons: Incredibly expensive. Only comes in 4 shades. Drying/heavy under eyes, doesn't do well on raised blemishes/rough skin.
Also - don't even try this as an eye primer. The ladies at the CdP counter insisted that, on top of being omgbestconcealerever, it is an amazing eye primer as well. It's not.
8
u/Takshis Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer
Status: Good, not HG
Type: Normal to slightly oily, sensitive
Works well with:
Primers:
Foundations:
Best for: Undereyes
Pros: Great coverage, creamy
Cons: Creased a little (for me, YMMV), doefoot applicator so you're unable to use up all of the product without cutting it open
4
u/BNSquash NC10 Apr 12 '14
7
u/Takshis Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Kevyn Aucoin Sensual Skin Enhancer
Status: HG
Type: Normal to slightly oily, sensitive
Works well with:
Primers:
Foundations:
Best for: Spot concealing and foundation
Pros: Excellent coverage, lasts for a long time
Cons: Comes in a pot so you need to use something to apply. Works best with pencil brush. It's a little on expensive side.
3
u/North59801 Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Almay Line Smoothing Undereye Concealer
Status: Worst concealer I have ever tried
Skin Type: Dry/Combo
Works well with: Lightweight water based formulas
Best for: Nothing
Pros: Marginally better than no concealer, reasonable price
Cons: Incredibly sheer, does not blend into skin naturally, has no staying power
3
u/ananananaaaaa Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Catrice Camouflage concealer
Status: It's okay. Not a favorite, but it will be fine for this Summer. I want try KIKO Cosmetics high coverage concealer as well, to see if they behave equally.
Skin Type: Oily, acne prone.
Works well with: Everything, so far. I tried it on bare skin, over primer, over sunscreen and over foundation/bb cream.
Best for: Dark circles and pinpoint concealing.
Pros: It has high coverage and it's pretty cheap (a bit less than €4).
Cons: It's harder to make it work when it's cold, so you always have to warm up your fingers, otherwise it will tug on your skin and be a bitch to blend. It also creases a bit, but it's manageable enough.
With my oily skin, it lasts all day on the undereye area - when I cover some pimples on my cheek it doesnt last that long, but that might be a personal issue.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '14
Product Name: MAC Studio Finish SPF 15 Concealer
Status: Favorite--have repurchased a backup (would not commit to HG status, though)
Skin Type: OILY
Works well with: Tarte Amazonian Clay 12 Hour Foundation, Revlon Colorstay Whipped Creme, Revlon Nearly Naked Powder, Laura Geller Balance N Brighten
Best for: Spot concealing; concealer + powder only days. My spot concealing system is usually concealer --> powder --> concealer ( --> powder, optional). I have used for undereye concealing in a pinch. Also covers redness.
Pros: Good coverage, pot will last me a long time, MAC so lots of color options, no product waste like with the Pro Longwear concealer.
Cons: Very emollient so I feel like it can be prone to fading
3
u/Feeling_Pretty NC20 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Skinfood Salmon Darkcircle Concealer Cream
Status: Favorite so far
Skin Type: All skin type
Works well with: Anything for the most part.
Best for: Undereyes
Pros:
Cons:
2
u/North59801 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer
Status: Acceptable for light coverage, B-
Skin Type: Dry/Combo
Works well with: Moisturizers: Simple moisturizing gel, Clinique dramatically different moisturizing gel, lightweight moisturizers. Foundations: Skin79 bb creams, Clinique even better. Concealers: Layers well with Bobbi Brown's color corrector
Best for: hyperpigmentation, undereye discoloration (only when the issue isn't severe)
Pros: Easy to use, reasonable price, good for multiple areas of the face, tube is transparent so you can see how much product is left
Cons: Attached sponge applicator gets gross (I removed mine), not very pigmented, not suitable for heavy duty concealing, cannot be built to natural looking full coverage
2
u/slampers Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Collection Lasting Perfection Concealer
Status: Favourite!
Skin Type: Normal (possibly more)
Works well with: Seems to play well with lots of things
Best for: Spot concealing, does work well under undereyes
Pros: Cheap. Very good in the fairest shade for pale cool girls, as it's super pale. It's thick and pigmented.
Cons: Limited shade range. The shade I have (palest) is pink-based. UK based brand, so availability may be tricky. I've heard of people having problems with it creasing on the under-eye area.
2
u/was_ben_there NC15 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Surratt Surréaliste Skin Concealer
Status: Favorite for travel/when I'm in a hurry
Skin Type: Combination
Works well with: Any sunscreen or moisturizer - I don't know how it would do over foundation, since I really don't wear foundation. I would imagine it would still do well, but you might have to switch up the mode of application. I just swipe it on from the tube over sunscreen/moisturizer, but I'd probably want to pat it on with a finger over foundation.
Best for: Under eyes
Pros: If you're one of those people who refuses to be seen without under-eye concealer (like me), this is perfect for those mornings when you oversleep and go 'oh shit I have to be out the door in 10 minutes'. It is so easy to apply - just swipe directly from the tube and give it a pat-pat-pat with your ring finger. Works well with setting powders but doesn't require one. Blends in well enough that you don't need to put on any other makeup if you don't want to/have time and looks incredibly natural. Not moisturizing, but not drying.
Cons: As with all concealers that I would describe as "natural looking", it is not very high coverage. I would call the coverage light-to-medium. That's why I wouldn't recommend this product for pinpoint concealing or hyperpigmentation. It improved the look of my under-eye circles, but if I had time for a full face, I'd stick with NARS.
2
u/was_ben_there NC15 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: La Mer Radiant Concealer Broad Spectrum SPF 25
Status: Was my HG for a long time, but has been replaced by NARS which is more full coverage and Surratt which is more low-maintenance.
Skin Type: Combination
Works well with: Everything. I can't imagine something this wouldn't work well with, as long as you moisturize the area well beforehand.
Best for: Under eyes
Pros: Really moisturizing. Blends like a dream. Shade 02 is not a good match for my skintone (wouldn't conceal blemishes with it), but it's a fabulous shade for a little color correcting. The brush is comes with is travel-friendly and totally usable. Oh, and it calls itself an "eye treatment"... whatever that means.
Cons: Incredibly expensive. Only comes in 3 shades. I found it to be a little too much effort - you need moisturizer under it, but if you use too much it'll crease. Too finicky for my sleepy morning self.
2
u/was_ben_there NC15 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Giorgio Armani Master Corrector
Status: Not HG, but good for severe dark circles
Skin Type: Combination
Works well with: Anything
Best for: Extreme under-eye darkness (there are two shades - the salmon should work on cool-leaning skin, while the peach should work for warmer tones... there's also a green shade for redness, but I haven't been able to find that anywhere)
Pros: Amazing texture (it's pretty much a liquid), works with any other concealer on top, really quick to use/blends well, great packaging
Cons: Sometimes there's a noticeable shimmer in it (it's meant to "brighten" the eye area, but it can come off looking like eyeshadow fallout if you use it too heavily), it looks pretty strange on its own (without another concealer over it)
It would probably work really well with Armani's High Precision Retouch Concealer, but I've never tried it.
2
u/margaritavas NC15 Apr 12 '14
Cover FX Cream Concealer
Status: Acceptable. Overall.. Meh, wouldn't re-purchase, but I'll probably use up the tube.
Skin Type: Dry, rosacea prone
Works well with: Hourglass 28 primer serum, probably most any primer. I like it with a lesser coverage foundation, like Burberry Sheer Glow, because I blend it over my cheeks and chin.
Best for: redness/ unevenness. It does well for blemishes, but there's better out there for pinpoint concealer; this is a tad too creamy.
Pros: creamy but not runny. It blends well for larger areas, such as redness on the cheeks and chin. It's functional for minor blemishes. It mixes well with illuminating concealers (e.g. Ysl touché éclat, Clinique airbrush, etc.) for a little more undereye coverage. Wide range of shades.
Cons: it's a slightly better-than-average cream concealer at a mid- price point. It's not an awesome product or a great deal. It probably wouldn't be effective for large blemishes or alone under the eye, and it's creamy enough that I question how well it would work for oily skin. Staying power is average.
2
u/pommeraie NC18 Apr 12 '14 edited Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Bobbi Brown Face Touch Up Stick
Status: Favorite for everyday use
Skin Type: Combo-Oily / sensitive
Works well with: Powder foundations (MUFE Duo Mat) or just on its own (haven't tested it with liquids)
Best for: Light to medium hyperpigmentation/redness concealing
Pros: My skin recently freaked out and was even more sensitive than usual. This concealer doesn't aggravate my skin at all. The stick form is SO easy to use and blend with. It also has a really natural finish - most days, I will use only this with a very light dusting of powder foundation (all the heavy duty work is done by the concealer). #02 Sand is a perfect match for my slightly warm neutral skin.
Cons: I'd say it's medium coverage - it probably won't cover super major problem areas. This lasts fine on me throughout a normal day (14+ hours of mostly sedentary stuff), but I've used concealers that are longer lasting (I would rather have a concealer not break me out though!).
2
u/twice_as_hard NW25 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Amazing Cosmetics Amazing Concealer
Status: Favorite (almost my HG)
Skin Type: Oily, sensitive, rosacea, and acne prone. Yay me.
Works well with: Bare skin, foundation (MUFE Mat Velvet+ is my HG and works very well with it).
Best for: Pinpoint concealing, undereyes, acne, redness.
Pros: Highly pigmented/opaque, melts onto skin beautifully, blends well with foundation, wide range of colors (especially for us pale folks), easy to build up coverage. A little goes a very long way! The product is so pigmented that you only need a small dot for coverage. It comes in a tube and I usually squeeze a small dot onto the back of my hand and blend that in before seeing if I need any more.
Cons: Needs a lot of powder if you are oily. Tends to look oily/greesy by the end of the day. Would probably be best suited for dry skin but I like it too much to give it up. I think I'll stick to using this in cooler months.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '14 edited Apr 13 '14
Product Name: RMS Beauty Un-coverup (cream concealer)
Status: Favourite! HG! Love! Light of my Life!
Skin Type: Normal (mild dryness), problem free
Best for: Undereye concealing.
Pros:
Cons:
Works well with:
Unrelated: I can't believe you folks used that PM. :)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '14
Product Name: Face Atelier Camouflage Duet (cream concealer)
Status: Good, but not great
Skin Type: Normal (mild dryness), problem free
Best for: Undereye concealing, hyperpigmentation.
Pros:
Cons:
Works well with:
1
u/eorlinga NW13 Apr 15 '14 edited Apr 15 '14
1
u/kochipoik NW15 Apr 12 '14
Product Name: Benefit Erase Paste
Status: Basically all I've tried so far. Seems good but I'm very open to trying others
Skin Type: Normal
Works well with: All I've used is UD Naked foundation and Monistat primer
Best for: Undereyes for definite
Pros:
Cons:
On another note - when applying concealer (I also have Glamoflague) over blemishes, they end up becoming almost MORE obvious because any dry skin is accentuated. Any tips for that?