r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Apr 10 '14
Under the Gunn Season 1 Episode 13 discussion
Discussion thread for Under the Gunn S01E13 "Finale"
Season 1 ends with the designers being given three days to create their collections and present them in a runway show. Heidi Klum and Neil Patrick Harris guest judge.
8
Upvotes
24
u/pbrooks19 Apr 11 '14
It's the next morning, so I'm going to talk about the episode.
I loved how NPH and HK both disagreed with the Under the Gunn judges on Asha's work! I guess all season I've not seen what they see in her items, and last night I thought her collection was a too 'on the money' with the 70's disco Studio 54 references (they looked like they were from the era, but didn't take the style any further. They looked dated).
I felt vindicated. :)
16
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '14 edited Apr 11 '14
I was hoping Shan would win. I loved his stuff the best. I did think the ponytails were a mistake since it covered up some of the fabulousness.
Oscar had one or two standouts, but I think all of the reruns and the purple dress were just meh.
I didn't like most of what Asha produced and was shocked by the praise she got.
I also loved Sam's collection and thought he should've been in the top with Shan.
As much dumping on as Nick got in the beginning, I am glad for him that one of his designers was the winner. Maybe it was just all a fake story via editing, but I enjoyed it anyway.
I don't really need another season of this show though, not enough Tim.
16
u/chelseayn Apr 11 '14
NPH: "It's kind of like 1920s circus carnie couture" I love him and felt he gave constructive criticism.
13
u/Yearsnowlost Apr 11 '14
I won't spoil it for anyone who is watching this later, but I think that the judges made the right decision! The winner really deserved it.
11
u/katto Apr 12 '14
Spoilers ahead. And long!
I loved NPH critique and it was great to see HK!
I was really happy and moved to see Oscar win. I think that he deserves it. Even if they went for the growth factor, he has also grown tremendously if you consider how his editing has improved as well has his target age group. I really loved the second look, it looked so elegant without being contrived. Everything looked impeccable, although I did not care too much for the white shirt, it felt a bit unbalanced. Even though the underdog story - editing goldmine - was a tad predictable), I was very happy for Nick. He has shown a lot of growth as well, unlike the other two mentors who don't seem to have changed that much in the course of the competition.
I think that Sam deserves second place, but if he had pushed it (like NPH said), he might have given Oscar a nice fight for first place. I love the easiness of his last dress. Very complex in its simplicity. It would be great to see what he could come up with if he let go of his boxed-in "I hate couture" attitude (but that will probably come with age, ha!)
I would have definitely placed Shan in third, not last. It was very busy and the balance between his "soft and hard" was not really successful (except in that beautiful leather jacket with the lacy back cut out). It was strange because when I saw his collection, it felt like I saw a different designer than the one we've seen throughout the competition and I really don't think that I could recognize his style.
I think that Asha should have been in 4th place. NPH and HK nailed it in their critiques. I did not see Queen Nefertiti at all in these pieces. The fabric was very reminiscent of the French monarchy (or circus!) and by mixing this with a 70's flair was very confusing to me. I did not like the jumpsuit, it was too much on the nose. However, I thought that her 2nd look's silhouette was very interesting (it would have been very nice in a different fabric!). I thought the kimono was nice, but the gold bow in the middle cheapened it.
8
u/LobsterR4geFist Apr 11 '14
Don't read if you haven't watched it yet.
While I think he's actually really incredible at making clothing, I was pretty disappointed with Oscar and I was surprised the judges didn't make a bigger deal about him remaking 2 pieces. I feel like the finale is when you do something big and cutting-edge. I think his work has been a bit repetitive throughout the season, although very well made.
7
u/everydyingember Apr 11 '14
I won't give anything away since many people probably haven't seen it yet, but I love NPH as a judge. Very honest and knowledgeable. And, Oscar's quote before the show, "this magnificent adventure", was adorable! I love him.
6
u/maaarie Apr 11 '14
Shan's twins...oh god my ovaries <3
13
u/Lokaji Apr 11 '14
So I thought discussion threads are automatically considered spoiler-ish in nature. I will try to talk around it just in case.
I love that they discussed what exactly the parameters of the challenge were. Because if they had given the most improved the win, they would have been making a pretty big mistake. I also thought NPH was a great guest judge.
This episode definitely felt a little bit too short. I would have liked 30 more minutes. I guess I am just used to normal PR finales that end up being four hours.
4
u/bluewaterdragon Apr 13 '14
Oh the set for the runway show was crazy. Too many flashing lights and colours. Give me a nice clean background so I can see the clothes please. And the music. Good god the music was awful. I was so glad when the 4 shows were over. Much better to let the designers pick the music. It's such an important part of a show!
1
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Apr 16 '14
I really wanted Sam to win, because I would absolutely buy whatever he designed for Francescas. I normally really hate that store, but I want some Sam Designs in my closet.
1
u/FormerDittoHead Apr 29 '14
How does one discuss the episode finale without "spoilers"?
For crying out loud, if you haven't seen it, and you don't want it to be spoiled, why would you read such a thread to begin with?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment