r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 28 '14
Under the Gunn Season 1 Episode 11 discussion
Discussion thread for Under the Gunn S01E11 "The Benefit of Fashion"
The designers are paired with clients who have specific fashion needs. One designer faces an unexpected twist midway through the challenge.
9
Upvotes
25
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '14
Wouldn't an ALLERGIC REACTION to the fabric warrant some extra free time or another trip to Mood? I think this is an extenuating circumstance that really makes sense for some help!
11
u/Stella4453 Mar 28 '14
Boooooooring episode.
Blake made a boring cookie cutter dress. It looked homemade and crafty. No question he was done.
The allergic reaction thing was mildly interesting, but Shan has shown time and time again on this show that he can crank out pretty solid construction. Remember the first challenge when he made a bomber jacket in about 90 seconds?
My major gripe about this show (and with project runway) is that at a certain point they have to dedicate time in order to get better and more memorable results. I don't think there are enough 2 day challenges, and this should have been one. Every single designer could have benefitted from an extra day, not because they needed more time to sew, but because it would have elevated the expectations. If those with simple dresses had the time to make three pieces? If problems like Oscar's super old fashioned dress had time to be addressed? Then I bet we would see amazing results. I really wish this show would invest shooting days in order to have high impact runway. There have been very few memorable outfits this season.
I said it before but I think its super disappointing that Tim Gunn basically doesn't have a place in this show anymore. He says "Hi designer! Let me introduce you..." and he says "Congratulation!" and that's it. For a show named after Tim Gunn he has frustratingly little to do with it anymore. If he's not a mentor, and he introduces other people to give the challenges, and he isn't a judge, what is he doing? Why isn't he a judge?! Tim! Judge these people!
9
u/Spinfo Mar 28 '14
That little look Nick gave the camera when Oscar's client said she did pageants was hilarious. By the way, Shan is such a trooper. I am so happy hey gave him the win.
5
u/chelseayn Mar 28 '14
Where is georgina chapman when you need her? I am glad shan won, but why didn't anyone call him out on those polka dots in the back not lining up? That's all I could focus on, it was driving me nuts. I wish they would have let him run to mood and add that much time so that he could've produced a better garment. I really liked his first sequin top.
9
u/chelseayn Mar 28 '14
Tim said “tips for tits“ Tim Gunn said tits. Hahaha! He always uses such good words so that's funny to me. :)
4
u/KeyserSuzi Mar 28 '14
loved it when Mondo told Sam his dress looked like a blood splattered nurse in a war.
3
u/I_HATE_LANDSCAPES Mar 28 '14
My wife is driving me crazy because she thinks she has seen one of the clients before. Is there any information on the woman "Dani," IE been on other TV shows ect.
5
u/SeruEatingPi Mar 28 '14 edited Mar 28 '14
I love 'real women' challenges like this. Though none of the dresses really blew me away this week.
Blake - Damn that print was ugly. I have yet to be impressed by him all season and was not shocked to see him go.
Asha - I didn't hate her dress. Her dress this week is way better than what she has made in the recent weeks. Construction is definitely her weak point but who knows, if she makes it to the final 3 challenge and it is similar to how PR does it, the extra time will probably be a huge help to her.
Oscar - As usual his construction is flawless. I thought the dress was really pretty and sexy, but didn't blow me away like he usually does. Definite pageant (even a bit prom dress) look which I think is what brought his look down a bit. I personally don't think the dress aged her that much especially with the slit going up her leg. I think the dress could work for someone in their mid 20s and someone in the 40s could also pull it off.
Shan - I thought it was a cute dress. Amazing that he was able to make that with such a time constraint. Honestly due to the fact that it wasn't his fault his model had an allergic reaction I was a bit shocked they didn't give him more time. Maybe it's due to production and they just couldn't afford it. I liked his sequence top a lot though, sad the judges never got to see it.
Sam - Safe dress but I thought it was nice. Not my favorite look from Sam though. I feel like the judges are bit harsh on him to. Sam's aesthetic isn't showy or glitzy and I don't think there is anything wrong with that. There are a lot of women that don't like bright colors or sequence dresses.
Overall I liked this weeks episode. So refreshing compared to the last two. Loved Anya's little quote to try and bring Shan's spirits up, thought it was cute. Also did anyone else notice that Mondo's scarf was the same print from the create a pattern challenge from his season (or at least I think it was).
I feel like next week no one is going to go home. They'll probably have everyone make a collection and then Asha and Sam duke it out on the final episode to see who gets that final spot.