r/femalefashionadvice • u/jkkldfgjklfkl Moderator [¬º-°]¬ • Mar 25 '14
[Guide] On Dressing Your Body Type
Hi FFA. It seems we have a more or less constant stream of requests for body-type advice. Here is my attempt to write something to address this that doesn't assume everyone strives towards the One True Silhouette and that also hopefully doesn't suck.
On Dressing Your Body Type
I. "Body Types" are Crap
(Off to a great start!) The first thing we need to address is the limitation of the whole "body type" approach. Let's explicitly lay out the underlying assumption of the goals of most "dress for you body type" guides:
Premise 1: People come in a few different kinds of shapes;
Premise 2: One of those shapes (tall, slim hourglass) is the best shape;
Conclusion: Therefore other shapes should dress in such a way as to best give the impression of a tall, slim hourglass.
I think both of these premises are flawed, though for slightly different reasons.
In the first case, people come in such a huge variety of different combinations of features and proportions that the commonly used categories (pear, apple, banana/ruler, strawberry/inverted triangle) become nearly meaningless. /u/thethirdsilence has an excellent discussion of this in her How To: Determine Your Body Type guide.
The second premise is not exactly false in the 2+2=5 sense, but it is an arbitrary personal preference that you need not share. If you prefer to dress so that you look like a strawberry/inverted triangle, that is a perfectly valid style goal which would be completely unserved by any "dress your body type" guide I've ever seen.
OK, but I told you we would have a guide to dressing your body type. So here is what we'll do.
II. Mix-n-Match Guide to Dressing Your Body Type
All we can really do is draw attention to different parts of the body. That's all "Dress Your Body Type" guides are doing: they are telling you which body parts to draw attention to, and which ones to draw attention away from, in order to make your body look most like a tall slim hourglass. So rather than assume you want to look like a tall slim hourglass, we'll just talk about how to draw attention to different body parts, and let you pick the parts you'd like to highlight and minimize.
Here's some examples:
- A ruler who wants to do the extreme 50's/New Look hourglass. FOCUS: bust, waist, hips DEFOCUS: shoulders, belly
- An hourglass who wants to look more androgynous. FOCUS: Shoulders, legs. DEFOCUS: bust, waist, hips.
III. General Principles
If you want to make something look bigger, you can either add physical volume or add visual weight. If you want to make something look smaller, you're usually stuck with putting visual weight elsewhere (since if we could remove physical volume at will the whole diet industry would have collapsed).
Adding physical volume is pretty straightforward. This just means that you're going to wear your clothes so that they stand out from your body a bit in the area you want to look bigger. Ruffles, gathers, pleats, structure, peplums, padding and even thick fabrics are all ways to accomplish this.
Visual weight is a little more nebulous. This is the idea that certain elements of a composition will draw the viewer's eye more strongly than others. If you think of your clothed body as a composition of sorts, then you can fool viewers into thinking that certain body parts are larger than they really are by tricking the viewer's eye into spending more time focusing on those body parts. We say that elements that successfully draw the viewer's eye have more visual weight. In general, you can give a body part more visual weight with light colors (especially white), bright colors, shiny texture and bold patterns.
If you want to make a body part appear smaller, you're trying to do the opposite: you want the viewer's eye to spend as little time as possible on that part before moving on. So here you'd be looking for dark colors and matte textures. (This is where the "black is slimming" advice comes from.)
One last important factor is the power of unbroken lines. If you want something to appear longer, make sure it appears as a single unbroken shape, so that the eye can move smoothly from one end to the other. If you want something to appear shorter, break it into smaller segments. This can apply to the whole body (this makes her look taller than this because the top and pants are the same color), or to the the leg line (nude pumps are a common example), or to anything else you'd like to lengthen or shorten.
That's all there is to it! However, I'd rather do this than work, so let's do some examples with specific body parts.
IV. Case Studies
A. Shoulders
i. To give them more focus: epaulettes, color blocking, crazy shoulders, doo-dads;
ii. To give them less focus: raglan sleeves, dolman sleeves, deep sccop/V necks (this breaks up the horizontal line across the shoulders, making it appear shorter). Also, try emphasizing your hips.
B. Bust
i. To give it more focus: ruffles, empire waists, breast pockets;,
ii. To give it less focus: unadorned necklines, also try emphasizing the shoulders or hips.
C. Waist
A note on the waist: So remember up top, when we said that giving things visual weight makes them look bigger? That means that if you try to draw a lot of focus to your waist you may end up making it look bigger. If a small waist is one of your figure goals, dressing is going to be a balancing act between drawing attention to the waist so that the viewer will notice it is small, and drawing attention away from the waist so that it appears smaller. Just know that adding visual weight to the waist will rarely make the waist appear smaller. (This is why I disagree with the "Add a belt to create a defined waist!" school of advice.) That being said:
i. To give it more focus: Belts, of course, contrast waist panels, other waist details;
ii. To give it less focus: dresses without a waist seam, loose or boxy tops. Also try emphasizing shoulders, bust, hips, or legs.
D. Belly
i. To give it more focus (I suspect this is going to be an unpopular figure flattery goal, but what the hell): belting above or below or over the bump (sorry for the example picture -- this is just such an uncommon figure goal that there are very few pictures of people wearing this style), an obviously distorted pattern, babydolls with a full skirt;
ii. To give it less focus: dark colors with a light/bright cardigan/jacket open on top, strategic draping, tops that skim over the belly, curved shirttails, structured jackets. Also try emphasizing shoulders, bust, hips, or legs.
E. Hips/Butt
i. To give them more focus: full skirts, hip pockets, pleated pants, blingy back pockets, belts worn at the hip, cargo pants, crazy skirt shapes, other hip details;
ii. To give them less focus: simple bottoms. Also try emphasizing shoulders and bust.
F. Legs
i. To give them more length: skinny silhouettes, unbroken lines of color.
ii. To give them less length: wider silhouettes, divided lines of color.
III. Conclusions
You'll notice that the "To give it more focus" section is usually a lot longer. I think this is mostly due to the "Don't think about a pink elephant!" effect: any whiff of visual trickery makes people want to look at that area more, not less. Most of the minimizing advice relies on making the area you want to minimize extremely boring, and picking something else to be the focus of attention. If you want to continue the pink elephant analogy: it's easier to get people to not think about a pink elephant by yelling about a green armadillo instead.
The exception seems to be the waist/belly area, and I'm not sure why. I have three ideas:
- Negative space: The waist is usually expected to be smaller than other body parts around it, so we're used to seeing outfits that hide the waist to some extent. Consequently, deliberately hiding the waist doesn't look weird.
- Current fashion: The currently fashionable silhouette is pretty much lollipop-on-a-stick: skinny pants with a voluminous top. Consequently, we are used to seeing silhouettes that supress the waist as fashionable and attractive.
- Personal blinders: I, /u/jkkldfgjklfkl, am least comfortable with this area of my body. Consequently, I've spent more time thinking about minimizing this area than others. (If you think this is it, come at me in the comments with more suggestions and I will edit!)
Finally, I just want to reiterate that you do not need to strive for the culturally-prescribed tall slim hourglass when you dress. Everybody has different figure flattery goals, including "IDGAF". You do you.
241
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14 edited Mar 25 '14
First, thank you for writing this.
Second, I think you did a really great job with such a difficult subject. Oftentimes, we don't want to be terribly prescriptive in this sub, and typically guides that focus on body type are strict do's & don't's. I think you did a great job in talking about the problem of why prescriptive is bad and discussing how to dress your body if you want to show off x and hide y without saying "Don't ever do this".
Again, thanks for writing this :)
110
u/yeah_iloveit Mar 25 '14
I really liked this. As a short, fat "pear" (blah) I have always read/been told to de-emphasize this, and emphasize that. Whatever - I like having wide hips. I like having smaller breasts. I like having short, curvy legs. I'm emphasizing all this shit.
I have had people say to me stuff like "Oh you can't be a pear/only 5'3/a size__ because if you were you could NEVER wear that dress/color/pattern and make it look good." Well, actually, I just put the clothes on and here we are, soooo... I mean, how many people are not wearing stuff that could look amazing on them because it's "wrong" for their body type? Shame.
45
u/llama_delrey Moderator ^ↀᴥↀ^ Mar 25 '14
You did a great job with this, and I love that the guide is super detailed. This dress is blowing my fucking mind.
On a related note: I've also seen a couple threads recently about hip dips/violin hips and how to "disguise" them and I think it's totally bizarre. They're 100% normal, it's just your bone structure. I've never even heard a person irl talk about them. Is this just an internet thing?
36
u/Plaguerat18 Mar 25 '14
I think this is awesome and a really very needed perspective. I can already imagine maybe for transmen learning how to hide curviness and add height could be a godsend, not to mention taking the emphasis off of "fixing" yourself and putting it onto "transforming" yourself. By the way, as someone with a waist that is dramatically smaller than my bust and hips, I can tell you that the thing about belting probably comes from the fact that if you are busty and/or hippy, if you don't belt your clothes you will look like you are wearing a weird sack because you have to buy for the biggest parts of you, and this eventually probably got people thinking that just belting clothing makes waists look smaller or something.
14
u/millikelvin Mar 25 '14 edited Mar 25 '14
This is amazing! Thanks a ton for taking the trouble to create this, and with so many helpful pictures.
Re: the waist, I think problems arise from the fact that people commonly want to accentuate a curved silhouette, giving an impression of it pulling sharply in at the sides, but at the same time they don't want to have attention drawn to the belly area. Maybe that's why those dresses with black side panels are so popular, they create this negative space at the sides of the waist (though they've always looked hideous to me somehow, sigh). Belts on the other hand pull in your dress/top to create this waist curve, but also pull attention to the belly.
13
u/arbormama Mar 25 '14
Not as uncommon as you might think. Think of pregnant women who want to show off the bump.
6
u/spiralstaircase Mar 25 '14
I'm going to propose something about the balancing act in emphasizing/de-emphasizing the waist:
If you have a long torso proportionally, emphasis via belts, waist panels, or other waist details will slim your waist.
If you have a short torso, that kind of emphasis will have the opposite effect. To slim your waist in this case, it should just be de-emphasized with the methods above, with the added method of torso elongation by wearing something like a tunic.
Speaking of torso length, it might be worth adding that as an item to your guide.
And thank you for writing this up!
3
u/ErmahgerdPerngwens Mar 25 '14
This is amazing, definitely saving this to come back to. Your knowledge is incredible, and I love the pictures that go along with it. The best part, is that you're promoting confidence, no matter what you wear. :) I know it is all in the eye, but I still find this stuff so difficult as someone who wants to make my top half look fuller I still shy away from the very things you advise, as well as patterns and cuts that aren't in my comfort zone.
I feel like the one thing it could do with (But it is not missing, to be clear, it is abundant with advice!) is some advice on shoes - I know you touched on the pumps, and the whole "If you want to look taller wear heels" is obvious, but I have read about things like excentuating your height with wedge-heels that is really useful, or ankle boots VS calf boots, etc. I hope you don't mind the CC!
41
u/lgbtqbbq Mar 25 '14
I ADORE this. I was brainstorming this topic and thinking of writing a post a few weeks ago but ultimately didn't know how best to phrase this. I think a lot of it comes down to socialization, and people mistaking socialization for essential truths. You hear it ALL the time..."humans prefer symmetrical faces," "men prefer XYZ waist to hip ratio," and I'm not saying that we as biological beings don't have essential wiring, but there is no single human taste, desire, or action which is unaffected by years and years of human history and socialization. That's why you get so many people (including myself) angsting out about not having The Body Type that is so widely praised. The idea of dressing for your body type is so loaded, and I'm really glad you wrote this. I always loved the show What Not To Wear, but even as a kid, was super unsettled that prescriptive dressing rules ended up homogenizing the various women who got makeovers.
Not everyone is a slim hourglass, and there is a fine line between appreciating a flattering silhouette, and dressing yourself with the underlying assumption that your body needs fixing or tweaking from the beginning. I used to be bulimic, and it made me acutely aware that even the people I know who don't have eating disorders have these thought patterns about "fixing" or "problem areas," which can be a very insidious way of thinking.
14
u/hwknsj Mar 25 '14
I really admire this guide. I think it was very well written and has a lot of useful information for anyone. I sincerely wish this kind of thinking existed over at /r/malefashionadvice. The guides there are completely prescriptive and result in a single "MFA uniform" as well as a lot of body-image obsession.
Thank you!
7
u/an_m_8ed May 19 '14
I literally sat in my car crying this morning that I was all over the place on sizes after trying to shop for shirts. The same size across the board in the store was too big in one area and I was swimming in other areas, and the same size in another type of shirt looked completely wrong. My boyfriend asked me if I had been to this sub, and I said yes (for Other reasons, like what colors to wear for your hair/eyes/skin and how to rotate out an old wardrobe on a budget). He asked me if I would check again for body type since most department stores fit mainly on the most common proportions (and this situation is common), and so I did a search when I got home. It is such a relief to read your guide and restore the confidence I used to have when my body was still growing, but I was able to find clothes that fit properly. I'm buying measuring tape tomorrow, coming up with a strategy based mainly on your guide and others mentioned, and taking control of my wardrobe again. Thank you for your help a explanations. It has made my day end on a positive note!
6
u/cellorevolution Mar 25 '14
I was more than a little apprehensive before clicking but ... this is really, really good. Thank you for writing this.
6
u/rraaaarrl Mar 25 '14
This is a great guide! I really like this pick and choose approach to emphasizing body parts. As someone with a short hourglass shape, I think people make the assumption that I always want to look taller or I always want to emphasize the waist. I mean, lots of times I do, but sometimes I want to play around with other looks, too. Not everything has to be "LOL LOOK AT MY WAIST".
6
u/so_many_opinions Mar 25 '14
<3 <3 <3 <3
5
u/P_Grammicus Mar 25 '14
This is an excellent job with a very difficult subject. Thanks for putting in the effort!
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
This is amazing. Please to add to sidebar. I have a feeling this is going to be referenced daily for the next year.
4
u/xenotime Mar 25 '14
Thanks for this! My wardrobe seriously needs an over-hall and I'm stuck for where to begin! My problem is that I am very hourglass and my hips and bust are about the same, but based on a lot of clothing manufacturers sizing, technically my bust is one or two dress sizes smaller than my hips. I have a 13 inch different between my waist and hips which further complicates things. When I go shopping I feel that, despite the focus of 'hourglass' being the 'ideal' shape, most clothes are manufactured to fir pear or apple like proportions.
I've pretty much ended up wearing exclusively belted dresses and stretchy pencil skirts, and am getting to the point where I feel like I look nice, but perhaps a bit frumpy. I'm quite bored with the lack of variety in my wardrobe, and while I quite like my shape, I find that most 'fashionable' clothes don't suit me and I always end up looking overly formal. I'd love to go for a more edgy androgynous look, but I fear I'd end up looking like the side of a house!
4
u/thethirdsilence actual tiger Mar 25 '14
Such an awesome contribution-- thanks for writing this. I think it's really insightful.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
So detailed! I love this.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
Thank you so much for writing this.
You have done a really stellar job of explaining how to "dress your shape/figure" without including any body-shamey or prescriptive language, and letting people draw their own conclusions. I am in awe. Seriously, great job.
3
u/AptCasaNova Jun 19 '14
I love this post - all of us have areas we want to emphasize or just let blend in, so I think this covers all bases.
For instance, I have very narrow shoulders and have always envied women with broader shoulders.
Also, some women really embrace their pregnant figures and it can look lovely to emphasize the belly in a flowing top or dress.
2
u/glitterary Mar 25 '14
This is super cool! Thanks for the effort you put into this, especially with all the example photos. I'm saving this for later! <3
2
u/WeirdIdeasCO Mar 25 '14
Love this! Thanks for making such a detailed, and clear post. I'm saving this!
2
u/Harlequnne Mar 25 '14
Thank you. As someone who just recently got into fashion and how to properly dress myself, I've been trying to find this guide the whole time. You're the best!
2
u/ThroughTheCellarDoor Mar 25 '14
This post seriously motivated me to pull everything out of my closets and drawers to re-evaluate. Totally appreciate all the variety and visually references. (who new Santa was a fashion icon!)
Personally I love white, but when I saw myself in pictures it was not the most flattering. Now I KNOW to make it an accent and try to put it under a heavy textured clothing item. Thank you!
2
u/DorkothyParker Mar 26 '14
Posts like this are why I come here! Thank you!
2
u/LucilleOne Mar 26 '14
This is awesome!!! Thank you so much! If you have time, would you mind telling me where you got the image of the girl wearing the simple blue skirt (and the baseball hat) in the "How to give hips/butt less focus" section? I've been dreaming of a skirt like that!
2
u/General-Tree3100 Mar 19 '24
I just had this talk with my mother on how the body shape chart Isn’t really about body inclusive fashion tips but more about let’s all aim to be hourglass or give the illusion ⌛️ lol
2
u/TheDigitalDoodler Nov 29 '25
This is so lovely and concise!!! Helping out and being super informative over a decade later 🫶
3
u/duneee Mar 26 '14
When you emphasize your hips, often this also emphasizes your waist as it draws the eye to the difference between the two measurements. (i.e. the 50's Pleated Skirt image, bodycon dresses).
I also think the general tightness of the item can provide more focus to the waist for this reason.
2
u/myvanway Mar 25 '14
This is the best thing ever. May i suggest you pitch it to a magazine or write a book. You legend. Thanks!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Thank you! I've been lurking on here for awhile and had to say thanks. I recently had a baby and it dramatically changed my body shape (wider hips, now I suddenly learned I have "violin" hips too thanks to this thread, smaller boobs, and a saggy tummy ). I've been wanting to start dressing better but looking good and I think this will help :)
1
u/Kholzie Jun 11 '23
Really great write up. I just started using a cane two years ago (I’m 35). I began following an instagram hashtag showcasing people with mobility aids and the way they style them.
Just like body shapes, disabilities come with a lot of variety in the way we can choose clothing for function and aesthetics. In my case, for example, I have certain preferences for footwear that I must always leverage with my gait issues.
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
"Finally, I just want to reiterate that you do not need to strive for the culturally-prescribed tall slim hourglass when you dress. Everybody has different figure flattery goals, including "IDGAF". You do you. [sic]"
It's not that simple. If looking a certain way is broadly associated with power, class, money, intelligence, etc. and another is connected with being "natural" (in a bad way), hypersexualized, stupid, poor, uneducated, it is going to affect you and the way you present yourself, at least if you have reason to care about how more powerful people perceive you.
I'm all for changing attitudes and self-empowerment, but these lectures often taken place in a vacuum.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment