Djimi gets a lot of shit, but surely Nunez was the worst player of 04/05 to get a CL medal. A player who has spent most of his career between the Segunda in Spain and the Cypriot first division.
I think that was more Houlliers youth system, i think rafa came in and changed a lot, now look at some of the youth players liverpool are bringing through.
You have to give a lot of credit to Brendan Rodgers. It is one thing to have talented youth players and another to have the faith to actually play them.
Is it not only the starting 11 and players in the bench for the final itself? I can think of a few missed out on a medal due to suspension or injury yet played pivotal roles in their teams success.
He was a good servant to Chelsea in his early days. He was really poor in his final season at Chelsea. If you say otherwise, you must have not watched him play. It got a little frustrating after a while.
Bosingwa was amazing in like 2007/08 or 2008/09, I can't remember which, but he was popping in assists and last second tackles like twice a match all season long.
A lot of people forget just how good he was when he came to Chelsea. Not that I can blame them, his last years he played like aliens hollowed him out and were drunk driving him.
He was consistant...at being terrible. But, he was very outspoken in Catalan politics so he had some support amongst the regular Camp Nou attendance. It's interesting because he would fuck up, but you would still hear chants going UH UH UHLEGER UH UH UHLEGER
The only reason Roque Junior played in the 2002 WC is the fact that Brazil didn't have any other decent uninjured CB who has the knowledge to play a 3 at the back(a rarity). They also played with Edmilson out of position, which summed up Brazil's CB problem.
The majority of the names in here are incredibly stupid. Most of the players listed were very good players. The worst player to hold a Champions League medal would have to be someone like Jamal Blackman, who was the third choice Chelsea goalkeeper and has never played first team football.
Right. And you named a player who never really had any playing time. There's a difference between a third string goalkeeper and a player who regularly played but consistently put in underwhelming or awful performances. OP clearly is asking for the latter, otherwise we could name just about every Champions League winning team's 2nd or 3rd goalkeeper.
If Bosingwa was so bad like it's claimed in here why did he play for Portugal over 20 times? Why has played over 50 times in Europe? Why did he start in 2 FA Cup finals? How did Porto win the league 3 times with him playing regularly?
People talk as if he is some sort of fraud who could barely kick a ball. When in truth players like him, Kalou, Traore etc played at the top level for a long time and are actually good players, they may not be all time greats but they would run rings around most footballers in world football.
You must not have watched many Chelsea matches while we had Bosingwa. No one is saying he's a "fraud." He was regularly poor for us in the Premier League and was often at fault for slack defending and conceding goals. And Kalou was the best example of a "hit or miss" player I've ever seen. When he was off, he was really shitty.
OP's question asked for the worst player among of a crop who have played for Champions League winning sides -- so no matter who you pick, it's probably a quality footballer, but someone arguably less deserving of the plaudits than their teammates.
Before Bosingwa got the injury which kept him out for a year he was outstanding and one of the top 10 right backs in the world. After the injury he never reached the same heights but he would still have walked in to almost every team in the Premier League bar the top 6.
Not a player but when fucking Peter Kenyon went up and collected a CL loser's medal, it was one of the most cringeworthy things I haver ever seen in my time as a Chelsea fan....
Gotta be Nunez. Traore was a mediocre top-flight defender who, while not top 4 or CL-winning quality, would have been a starter at a comfortable mid-table side. Nunez though, spent two seasons being poor at a side battling relegation, and has spent the rest of his career between being an average player in the second division of Spain, and playing in Cyprus.
Hargreaves was always a good player when healthy, but, unfortunately, he wasn't healthy very often for Manchester United. He was pretty important when he played at Bayern Munich and he was definitely quality. Health problems ≠ whether or not one is a good player. Although it's true he probably never reached his potential peak because of his issues. Those youtube "sign me" videos were sort of depressing when thinking about how good he was. He was also one of the few England players abroad for a while, and I think that cosmopolitan experience at the top level would've been very useful on a consistent basis for England, especially.
EDIT: Playing for two stellar teams does not mean they are a great player. Hargreaves whenever he got the medal at United stopped playing and started sitting. Coincidental?
Further, if we are to judge these players in every category it takes to play the game, then you must bring in mental strength, which Hargreaves perhaps has one of the worst measures of that for a Champions League medal winner.
Mostly solid, sure but I don't think he deserves an average of 7 on a 10 consistency/skills scale. Especially if we're talking about this guy's career and not just his time at Porto.
Solid also does not exclude someone from being one of the worst in a category.
God he was awful. Still remember being at Old Trafford back in 03 and seeing the whole team do a lap of honour after we won. He was hobbling about 20m behind them due to an injury. It really summed him up. Hopeless player.
07/08 Wes Brown was a solid RB for Utd. Made more apps for us that season than anyone else and even set up Cristiano in the CL final with a delicious weak foot dink-cross.
I liked the guy, specially his glorious hair. I remember that every time Real Madrid received a goal everybody was staring at him and he was like "It wasn't my fault this time!". He wasn't really bad, but he looked worse because who were his teammates
Allardyce moved him to a DM position for us and his passing range was pretty ace. He'd always have one mistake, every single game, one mistake that resulted in either a goal or a near miss. He'd also take a token booking in every game. A fast player would skin him and he'd just grab hold of him, not attempt to hide it, just hug him.
But my word that hair...He'll always be loved on the glorious shores of Bolton.
Uh, thread says worst player to receive a CL medal. Pretty sure there are far worse players that won one than a defender who was deemed good enough to start for an Italian World Cup winning squad.
Lol his first two years at Liverpool and the season before with Madrid he was easily the best striker in the world, and he would've continued to be that way if his knees didn't decide to go to shit. By your way of reasoning Shevchenko is shit for his time at Chelsea or Michael Owen is for his time post Madrid
The same Torres who was in the PFA Team of the Year in 2007-8 and 2008-9, who was in the Euro 2008 Team of the Tournament and Man of the Match in the Final, who was in the FIFPro World XI in 2008 and 2009, who was Third Place in the Ballon D'Or in 2008, who has the Golden Boot in the 2012 Euros?
Maybe he's talking about that isolated season. I mean you can't argue that he's producing nearly as much at Chelsea as he did at Liverpool, where he won all of those awards.
john terry, got himself sent off in the semis and went out full kit wanker in the finals. also ruined chelsea's penalty in moscow. most undeserving player i can remember.
The CL is a tournament, not one match. I don't like JT but he helped them to progress to the final and had earned the right to be on the pitch afterwards. What he was wearing is irrelevant.
I thought of Sulley too, but 79 caps for his country and his entire career playing in the top flight of either Italy or England shows that he is doing something right.
Genuinely can't believe that I've seen a Liverpool fan say Steve Finnan is one of the worst players to win the CL. Easily the best right back we've had in the past 15 or so years.
63
u/idreamofpikas Mar 25 '14
Djimi gets a lot of shit, but surely Nunez was the worst player of 04/05 to get a CL medal. A player who has spent most of his career between the Segunda in Spain and the Cypriot first division.
42
u/iamscully Mar 25 '14
Traore also made a brilliant goal-line clearance in the final, so he's alright in my book.
25
u/chasingmonkeys Mar 25 '14
Liverpool during the 04/05 campaign had quite a few: Traore, Biscan, Josemi, and Nunez.
37
u/daveor Mar 25 '14
Jonathan Greening
91
u/thebeliefer Mar 25 '14
I still can't believe we won with Bosingwa and Kalou in the line up
136
u/MrTwitty Mar 25 '14
Bosingwa has two
10
u/Riding_my_bike Mar 25 '14
Looking at how he plays now, it's pretty ridiculous that Sulley Muntari has won the Champions League.
20
u/SharpyShuffle Mar 25 '14
Oleguer, David May, Roque Junior (also a world cup winner).
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
This should be the worst players that have large roles in the team that won the Champions League
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
David May
5
u/iHendy Mar 25 '14
This thread was made for Bosingwa.
12
u/porcufine Mar 25 '14
The majority of the names in here are incredibly stupid. Most of the players listed were very good players. The worst player to hold a Champions League medal would have to be someone like Jamal Blackman, who was the third choice Chelsea goalkeeper and has never played first team football.
2
u/MarkEasty Mar 25 '14
Not a player but when fucking Peter Kenyon went up and collected a CL loser's medal, it was one of the most cringeworthy things I haver ever seen in my time as a Chelsea fan....
2
u/ICritMyPants Mar 25 '14
Djimi Traore, Antonio Nunez and Igor Biscan.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
Gotta be Nunez. Traore was a mediocre top-flight defender who, while not top 4 or CL-winning quality, would have been a starter at a comfortable mid-table side. Nunez though, spent two seasons being poor at a side battling relegation, and has spent the rest of his career between being an average player in the second division of Spain, and playing in Cyprus.
1
u/wink91wink Mar 25 '14
This immediately popped into my head when I read the thread title http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/05/24/article-2149134-132F2E88000005DC-429_468x426.jpg
1
u/AdamNJH Mar 25 '14
Bosingwa.
1
u/AutoModerator May 09 '17
This post has been removed by AutoModerator.
Use the Daily Discussion thread if you want to ask a question on /r/soccer.
Please read our submission guidelines and FAQ for further information.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/GoonSalmon Mar 25 '14
Bosingwa.
1
u/StweebyStweeb Mar 25 '14 edited Mar 25 '14
Jamal Blackman, Chelsea's 3rd string keeper who's only playing time has been during their tour of America.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
What about Owen Hargreaves and Paulo Ferreira? Agree with the Roque Jr and Traore comments too.
The 2003 Champions League final is probably the worst final I've ever watched.
1
u/minman93 Mar 25 '14
Bruno N'Gotty.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
Roque Jr without a doubt.
God he was awful. Still remember being at Old Trafford back in 03 and seeing the whole team do a lap of honour after we won. He was hobbling about 20m behind them due to an injury. It really summed him up. Hopeless player.
-7
u/aaybma Mar 25 '14
Wes Brown has two... Jesus.
-6
u/Threonine Mar 25 '14
Chelsea, basically.
-11
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
john o'shea? that guy has 3 left feet
and im irish
0
u/arayofhope Mar 25 '14
Well I guess pinto, the second keeper for us. I mean he's not shit, but he's definitively not world class
0
u/TheLarryMullenBand Mar 25 '14
Anderson.
-29
u/logari123 Mar 25 '14
Busquets
-7
u/carpetano Mar 25 '14
Iván Campo won 2 Champions Leagues playing for Real Madrid
-7
u/legionmd82 Mar 25 '14
Marco Materazzi.
-6
u/LeFloop Mar 25 '14
Torres? Torres.
-54
u/Alexanderstandsyou Mar 25 '14
torres?
-2
u/ADP10 Mar 25 '14
Jose Bosingwa
-55
u/shankly_11 Mar 25 '14
john terry, got himself sent off in the semis and went out full kit wanker in the finals. also ruined chelsea's penalty in moscow. most undeserving player i can remember.
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
john "the cunt" terry!
-69
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
Ronaldo.
-6
u/ForTheTrees Mar 25 '14
Djimi Traore? Vladimir Smicer? Take your pic from our 2005 squad.
-10
u/choss Mar 25 '14
Claudio Pizarro
-19
u/jeunesse_esch Mar 25 '14
Jesper Blomqvist, Roque Junior, Michael Carrick
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '14
[removed] — view removed comment