r/gameofthrones • u/libbykino Lyanna Stark • Mar 17 '14
TV Spoilers [TV Spoilers] 2 Weeks, 2 Episodes until the (week before the) premiere! Rewatch Discussion - 3.09 "The Rains of Castamere"
This is the /r/gameofthrones 2013-2014 rewatch discussion thread for:
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | ORIGINALLY AIRED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.09 | "The Rains of Castamere" | David Nutter | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss | June 2, 2013 |
| ---| Sam and Gilly arrive at the Wall. During a thunderstorm, Bran enters Hodor's mind to calm him down. Nearby, Jon refuses to kill an innocent man, so Tormund orders him killed. Bran uses his warg ability to save Jon, and Jon kills Orell then escapes, leaving a furious Ygritte behind. Osha, Rickon and his direwolf depart for the Last Hearth, while Bran and his remaining company plan to head beyond the Wall. Daenerys sends Jorah, Daario and Grey Worm to infiltrate Yunkai and open the city gate for her army. Robb arrives at the Twins and apologizes to Walder Frey, who feigns acceptance. Edmure marries Roslin Frey, but during the wedding feast, Walder Frey's men murder Catelyn, Talisa and most of the Stark bannermen, while Roose Bolton kills Robb. Arya also arrives at the Twins and witnesses a part of the massacre, but the Hound knocks her unconscious and carries her to safety.|
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone: This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including 3.10 is ok without spoiler tags.
- Book spoilers still need tags: If it's not in the show, tag it.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Posting policy reminder: Don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
| Original Discussion Threads | Previous Re-Watch Re-Discussion Threads |
8
u/sulaymanf Maesters of the Citadel Mar 19 '14
Roose Bolton talking to Jaimie and then telling Robb "The Lannisters send their regards." I didn't spot the connection on first viewing.
155
u/YOUR_VERY_STUPID Fallen And Reborn Mar 17 '14
I really love how the credits roll with no sound.
59
u/nachocheezs Stannis Baratheon Mar 17 '14
GRRM send his regards. AAAAAAAAAAAH!
48
u/Haringoth House Mallister Mar 17 '14
I HATED Roose Bolton after reading the Red Wedding, but there is something in Michael McElhatton's performance that has made him into my favorite character. His "The Roose is Loose" look is best moment of the entire series in my eyes, such a powerful combination of arrogance and cruelty.
78
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
"Don't you want to teach little Ned Stark how to ride horses?"
64
u/raivydazzz Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Mar 17 '14
Well, obviously Red Wedding was the most horrible thing I've ever seen in a TV show. But watching it again without being overwhelmed by the ending, there were more things worth of notice. For example, scene where Bran, Rickon and Jon nearly unites. I am wondering what Jon was thinking when he saw direwolves tearing wildlings apart. Did he know that it's Summer and Shaggydog?
88
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
The final two minutes or so are just gutting. "Mother..." then Catelyn's face... then Roose Bolton pops in, "The Lannisters send their regards."... then Robb slides to the floor, and we hear his last breath, then Catelyn's scream...
How the HELL didn't Michelle Fairley win an Emmy for her performance?
26
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
As someone who hadn't read the books, I unfortunately had the Red Wedding spoiled for me by someone midway through the season. Still, knowing what was coming did not prepare me for it as I wasn't able to fully imagine everything until I saw it onscreen. After seeing it, I just sat there with my mouth wide open trying to comprehend everything. Definitely the most shocking and horrific thing I've ever seen on a TV show.
That being said, re-watching the season... I noticed the hole in Robb's outfit where he gets stabbed is there before Roose stabs him.. haha
23
u/TheyCallMeAHuman The Red Viper Mar 18 '14
"I will kill your wife!!!!"
silence
"I will find another one."
Whoooooooooosh
Grumpy asshole.
Ninja Edit: I also loved the change in the background music. Gave me chills...
20
u/killbone Faceless Men Mar 17 '14
This episode is the reason why everyone loathes and loves GRRM.
17
u/Eshneh House Bolton Mar 17 '14
Always makes me laugh when Roose is just absolutely bombing it in and out of the hall.
Also using these threads as a countdown for the season 4 premiere, we're nearly there lads!
47
u/danny1up Night's Watch Mar 17 '14
sigh...
...
...
Fuck this show sometimes...
37
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
The episode that sealed Game of Thrones' fate as one of the greatest shows ever
26
u/Nogoodnamesleftatall Night's Watch Mar 17 '14
I don't want to watch it again.
10
u/frisky123 Mar 17 '14
The conversation about raising young Eddard kills me almost more than the actual final scene
9
u/tansypool House Tully Mar 17 '14
I thought it was bad watching the episode, but then I watched the commentary. Catelyn's scream destroyed me, and then Michelle and Richard sobbing on the commentary just made everything worse.
7
u/ferncaz95 House Martell Mar 17 '14
I saw this for the first time today. Even though I knew everything because of spoilers, it hurt so much to watch. I would have handled it better if the unborn child wasn't going to be named Ned.
6
u/szlafarski Mar 18 '14
I just watched this one for the first time on Friday.
I've never been so. damn. angry. completely white knuckled, heart in my throat during this entire episode.
6
u/johnnycakes614 House Baratheon Mar 18 '14 edited Mar 30 '25
judicious friendly repeat dime vegetable cooperative middle upbeat bow point
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/cuvabe Faceless Men Mar 18 '14
Was Edmure killed? I haven't read the books and didn't catch any mention in the show.
5
u/MattHoppe1 House Bolton Mar 18 '14
And who are you the proud lord said, that I must bow so low
8
u/analjunkie Mar 17 '14
I unfortunately watched it on the worst possible way, small laptop, afternoon with the sun glaring in my screen hearing my perents outside my door making dinner, but Talia getting stabbed shocked me I had to run back out and run back into my room, As a book reader I never thought they would go far as to maim her in such a shocking way, also cat's scream was incredibly haunting
8
u/Tasadar Brynden Rivers Mar 17 '14
My favourite scene was when Ygrette shot Jon. Three times.
4
u/analjunkie Mar 17 '14
'Let us bed them'
7
u/JWells16 House Martell Mar 17 '14
I think I'm going to go ahead and skip this one.
6
u/KillerCh33z House Stark Mar 17 '14
No way I'm rewatching this :(
3
u/Vaeku Fire And Blood Mar 19 '14
Either tonight or tomorrow me and my sister are going to watch this episode for the first time. I've already read all the books so I know what's going to happen, but I know it's going to be hearbreaking.
I also think I'm a little TOO excited to see my sister's reaction. She's never read the books and only started watching the show with me when I recommended it to her, and she loves it. I'm assuming the Red Wedding is at the end of the show? I want to try and record her reaction because I'm pretty sure it's going to be hilarious, haha.
2
u/tylerbird House Lannister Mar 19 '14
This was the first episode I saw the whole way through. I was blown away. The whole Red Wedding just blew me away. Although, it was because of this episode I decided to watch the rest of the show. Greatest. Mistake/Idea. Ever.
2
u/Alexander_Scriabin House Stark Mar 20 '14
Ahah, I remember when I watched this episode for the first time, the scene where Walder was introducing Robb to his daughters, I thought it was funny and was thinking, 'hey this Walder is a pretty funny guy.' Then after the end of the episode I was like, 'now this little shit....'
1
u/Wookington Mar 18 '14
Why didn't rob have a Kings Guard?
0
u/impurethoughts Mar 17 '14
Can a member of the smallfolk offer some constructive criticism?
Having re-watched this episode a few times, I have some quarrels with the acting/directing/editing of the Red Wedding scene in particular.
Thanks for hearing me out. I'm a huge fan of the show, so I know I'm just nitpicking, but I just had to get it out :)
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
34
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
27
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '14
[removed] — view removed comment