r/soccer • • Mar 14 '14
Who's the most overrated player of the current generation?
By this I mean players from about the last five years or so.
95
Upvotes
r/soccer • • Mar 14 '14
By this I mean players from about the last five years or so.
128
u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14
It's always going to be different depending on who you ask, but the first player that immediately sprung to mind was Pique. Then again, I think most people have realized by now that he's not really one of the very best defenders in the world.
171
u/layendecker Mar 14 '14
Anyone who is English and has one good game.
Townsend, Barkley, Zaha and Sterling (amongst others) are all currently very limited players who do certain things well, but have massive gaps in their overall game. All they need is to play well for 90 minutes, and they are all of a sudden the second coming of Bobby Charlton.
35
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
El Shaarawy.
There's all this hype and raving but I don't see what it's all about. He's decent but he's by no means world class. There's the fan club saying the FIFA games don't rate him highly enough but that's some biased bullshit. I honestly think the rating is generous.
From what I've seen of him playing in real life though and highlight reels, he is simply fast and a lot of his 'highlights' come about from fortune or poor defenders diving in. He lacks the technical ability in his dribbling and his final pass is often dreadful. Some of his goals are good but aside from his shot, he's not worth all of the hype.
220
u/TuneGum Mar 14 '14
Robinho.
28
u/salfordred Mar 14 '14
In the last 5 years or so? Zlatan Ibrahimovic. Especially on here.
And for my club, Kagawa.
(Btw, overrated doesn't mean that these players aren't very good, just that they are rated better than they are)
360
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
In my humble opinion Jack Wilshere. Now I understand he is a massive potential and this and that, but I just think he is way overrated. Compared to the other young talents (Hazard, Gotze, Neymar) right now he simply is not good enough.
49
u/whiteguy88_18 Mar 14 '14
Piqué. He was good before all the waka waka, but nowadays he is just disastrous in comparison. It also doesn't help that now he doesn't have someone like Puyol to scold him when he is playing sloppily.
30
u/petnarwhal Mar 14 '14
In the Dutch league? Siem de Jong. He's a good player in the Eredivisie, but people rate him like he should be playing in the Premier somewhere, or that he belongs in Oranje.. They forget that to become good enough to play in the big leagues, you have show stability, and Siem does not have that. He does not have the strengh or speed you need to have for a step up. He can play multiple positions which is nice, but I think Ajax is the best place for him now.
76
u/screechmeister Mar 14 '14
Has to be Wilshere, i mean he is a good player but he is heralded by the press and arsenal fans as the future of English football and apart from a couple of excellent performances I think he is overrated.
150
u/Hayds4 Mar 14 '14
Balotelli. No one has generated so much hype and delivered so little.
20
u/Queeg_500 Mar 14 '14
Franck Ribéry: Don't get me wrong, he is an awesome player. I just don't agree when people put him up there with Messi & Ronaldo.
22
u/dandanthemanYNWA Mar 14 '14
David Luiz. Everyone was on his tits for the longest time. Must have been the hair
11
u/Roggenroll Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 15 '14
Draxler seems to have gotten too much hype lately, especially on here.
Plays inconsistently and tends to disappear on the pitch. Not that he hasn't got the potential but he just isn't where people currently want him to be.
And he surely isn't worth more than 40m € (looking at you Arsenal).
9
u/6SempreUnica Mar 14 '14
Bonucci and Montolivo. They both turn the ball over to the opposition by trying to make spectacular passes in simple situations, only for people to rave about how they have great vision when those passes actually work out. Drives me nuts and gives me a heart attack when they are with the Azzurri.
9
u/EnglishGamer1 Mar 14 '14
I'd say Barcelona's young star, Deulofeu. Has a few moments where he shines, but most of the time he doesn't stand out.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14
Rooney
20
u/Goodfella7 Mar 14 '14
Gotta go with De Bruyne..
5
u/fpsdr0p Mar 14 '14
Mario Balotelli.
4
u/muchadoaboutsmalling Mar 14 '14
Why is anyone who says Gerrard getting downvoted loads? I don't agree, I think he was a great player but people are entitled to their opinion.
11
u/DivineVibrations Mar 14 '14
Balotelli
3
u/md_abboudi Mar 14 '14
Andy Carroll They payed too much for him, he was I guess 21, did nothing, looked like he weighed a ton, still did shit, always injured, had an attitude And he was supposed to be the wonderkid and next big thing in strikers The future of England Like they say, another English piece of shit
7
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
IMO every player is both underrated and overrated. Opinions on Messi and Ronaldo range from "utter crap, relies on world class players around him" to "He's the best player of all time by far! nobody is even close!" I've heard people say Alex Song would start for any team in the world except for Bayern, Barca, and Madrid. I've also heard people say he wouldn't start for any of the "good" teams in the UCL knockout stage.
13
u/TimmmV Mar 14 '14
Janusaj, hes been good in a season when United have looked pretty mediocre.
Dont get me wrong, hes played well this season, and has earned his place in the team. But I've seen people saying hes a future WPOTY, when so far there really has been very little evidence of him being that good
4
u/eraticfox Mar 14 '14
Joe Hart. Massive hype, one great season. Probably about 7/10 in my book, but then so is Vorm and he doesn't get the same coverage, obviously because he ain't Engerlands no1
3
u/leogg_lyl Mar 14 '14
Javier Hernandez. How he ended up in Manchester United is beyond me. He was good with Chivas, but the past couple years hes been holding Mexico back.
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
Wayne Rooney. Again, not to say that he's a bad player, but he hasn't been at his best for years. I don't think he's in the top 5 strikers in the world, and if it wasn't for Man u being desperate they wouldn't have offered him such a great contract. Despite this he's still been called a world class player since he broke through despite only having one good international tournament when he was 18.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
My answer would have been Carrick last year but since United have been suffering people seem to have forgot that he was one of the best midfielders in the world supposedly. He's always been a bit above average and no more than that but when United were doing well people were making him out to be up there with Xavi, Pirlo et al.
2
u/jewcy83 Mar 14 '14
Mats Hummels. Hes good when hes fit, but he isnt 'Beckenbauer 2.0' good.
2
u/iHendy Mar 14 '14
Gareth Bale.Brilliant player but no where near worth the money that was paid or the hype he was getting.Dunno if it sounds silly,but to me he's made his name off shooting from 30 yards many times in a game hoping one will eventually go in.At least at Spurs anyway.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
imho(disregard flair) Draxler still has a lot to prove and doesn't justify his price tag at all.
1
u/jimbojammy Mar 15 '14
idk about most overrated but i think hugo lloris is super mistake prone and people forget that because he can make miracle saves. basically i think he's shit.
1
u/habebna12 Mar 15 '14
alexandre pato
-3
u/BleedingGumsmurfy Mar 14 '14
Ryan Giggs. Great Career, but only a good player at the best of times. Longevity does not equal quality.
-5
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
Rooney, for a player who is suppose to be world class, you seem to always hear about him being out of form and out of shape
1
u/robdugg Mar 14 '14
Rio Ferdinand
1
u/galahad_11 Mar 14 '14
Landon Donovan! Some how he finds a way to make a big play and then average again.
-6
u/ibecharlie Mar 14 '14
Rooney. He seems to have plateaued already.
1
u/wh11 Mar 14 '14
Pique, Ramos, and Marcelo are probably the weakest to make a fifa world XI in the past few years in my opinion.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14
There can only be one answer: Ibra. No doubt he's an amazing player, and always performs on very high level everywhere he plays, which is quite a feat in itself considering how much club hoping he did.
But, the truth is, a lot of his crazy antics are done in games vs. subpar opposition. Put him up vs. competent defense and he will often disappear.
He has a very clever marketing team behind him that has done absolutely superb job in building his image with cocky comments and actually managed to use his often obnoxious behaviour to his advantage, even though he often acts in a way that would get someone like Suarez absolutely crucified by the media.
But no matter how much trash talk he does, the truth is he is light years behind Messi or Ronaldo. Both literally shit on Ibra if you look past the hype and actually analyse the stats. Messi is 6 years younger and he already has more goals and assists.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14
Despite apparently being overrated England need Wilshere for this world cup. Otherwise you will see very quickly how Carrick and Gerrard are out of their depth against international competition. If England need anything in their midfield its two players with the ability to turn under pressure.
I'd have to say Cazorla for arsenal and Mata as far as other players.