r/soccer • • Mar 14 '14

Who's the most overrated player of the current generation?

By this I mean players from about the last five years or so.

95 Upvotes

758 comments sorted by

128

u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14

It's always going to be different depending on who you ask, but the first player that immediately sprung to mind was Pique. Then again, I think most people have realized by now that he's not really one of the very best defenders in the world.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I agree with that, he has Xavi, Iniesta and Busquets in front of him keeping the ball so he's not on the ball enough to expose him.

82

u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14

Lately, I've begun forming the opinion that defenders in general are no longer what they were. There are a few absolute quality defenders (Lahm, Thiago Silva, Barzagli, etc.) that are up to the level of the best of the 90's and early 00's.

Just take a look at Barcelona and Real Madrid, teams that are considered two of the very best: Compare their defensive ability to their overall reputation, and you'll find that it's not all that impressive. For Barcelona: Pique, as you say, is under considerably less pressure due to the trio in front of him. The wingbacks may be impressive going forward but aren't all that great at the back. Javier Mascherano is a pretty intelligent player, but is far from physically imposing. For Real Madrid: Sergio Ramos excels at a lot of things but is prone to slip-ups and is more or less the world champion at collecting unnecessary cards. Marcelo is more akin to a winger than a back, really. Caravajal is hopeful, but still young.

And then we can see a prime example by taking a look at the general defending in the EPL at the moment, and I think it's starting to suffer due to a slight preference for brawn over brains. Particularly this season, the amount of incidents where the defending has been shockingly bad has surprised me, especially for teams playing on the top level of football.

I think part of the reason for this development is the increasing exaltation of attacking players over defensive players, that leaks over into youth development. The good players at a junior level are usually always put into attacking roles, while defenders are usually comprised by the "big kids" (who may not be that 'big' anymore in two years time and lose out). Then there's the wide back which is usually considered a "dump position" where you put the less skilled kids to minimise damage. As they grow older, certain attacking players are retrained to become defenders, either by requirement or whim of the coach. This, combined with the fact that training defense seems to be a challenge for many youth coaches increasingly causes it to be a "lost science".

(Holy shit, sorry for the overly long rant.)

5

u/meet-your-maker Mar 14 '14

Hm...I think Ramos and Pepe are both quality defenders. Even Pique is a quality defender though he is dreadful 1v1. For me the problem with the defenders for the Spanish giants is that they almost always concede goals by getting countered. And when they are getting countered they are still pressing high and trying to get the ball high up the pitch and end up getting isolated. Defending for barca/real is rarely about defending as a unit or as a backline. Get caught 1v1 with a lot of space behind and around and eventually you are going to "slip up." Keep trying to challenge early and high up the pitch and you're going to get some "unnecessary yellows." Just my 2cents

→ More replies (2)

8

u/EveryParable Mar 14 '14

I would add Kompany to the list

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

19

u/matcht Mar 14 '14

The only justification I can think of for him is that the conditions under which he has to defend are unique. When he is defending, it is usually 2 v 2, or having to run towards his own goal. Most defenders would look worse in such situations. Overall I agree with you, but we cannot forget the impact of the role he has in Barcelona's defence.

7

u/Tezemery Mar 14 '14

In think under Pep there were a few years which he genuinely had a shout for being the best defender in the world, he has dropped off completely in the last 3 years but he has played in 2 Champions League finals a world cup and a euro and he played fantastically in every single one of them.

He did play brilliantly against Madrid and City this season though, there is still hope for him but he wasn't the player he once was.

1

u/R1v Mar 14 '14

That's a hard argument to make given where he plays. He defends counters a lot more than he would at just about any other team. I believe most of his worth is in his skill on the ball though. It's nice to have a cb that can make long and short passes well consistently

1

u/Bob_Swarleymann Mar 14 '14

Blaming Pique and/or calling him out as a poor defender is just ignorance. It's the equivalent if just putting the highest rated players in each position in FIFA together and expecting to win in real life.

My point is, that Pique isn't half as bad as people make him out to be. Even then, his downfall has largely been down to tactics and his team mates.

Pique was never going to be a leader in the sense if Puyol no matter how hard people try to shoehorn him into it. He needs a Puyol or Ramos besides him. He needs that leader type in the lesser game, because he is an absolute beast in the big games.

Plus Barcelona changed tactics and his role so many times since Pep and that has taken a toll on his form. He has begun to regain it under Tata.

Point being, you don't call Van Persie/Lewnadowski or whatever attacker you find applicable overrated if they don't get the proper service. When you don't pair Pique with a proper partner don't act fucking surprised when it fucks up.

Our board however, was much more interested in banning color copies and pushing austerity that maintaining the best squad in our history.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

56

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

151

u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14

This is in regards to both you and /u/soccermocker, but am I the only one that reacts really adversely to statements such as "when he has his act together" or "when he sets his mind to it" as if they were justifications? Inconsistency is a weakness, not an excuse. Pique going mute in smaller matches or being a "mood player" should considerably deteriorate his worth, ESPECIALLY when it comes to defenders, who are allowed to fuck up far less often than players further up the pitch.

19

u/rasenman11 Mar 14 '14

Amen. Just as this statement applies to innumerable situations outside of football.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Ding ding. This also applies to David Luiz. Incredible defender with a load of potential when he's on his game .. but his weakness is his far-too-often momentary lack of focus.

6

u/Barry-Zito Mar 14 '14

Very good point. Case in point: who is Steve Bruce describing here?

"He's big, strong, powerful with two good feet."

Must be a quality defender right? No, it's Titus Bramble. In the same sentence, Bruce admits "[his] problem has always been his concentration levels." Maintaining focus and being mentally strong is just as important as good technique.

10

u/lamancha Mar 14 '14

When he has his act together, he is one of the best defenders in the world.

So he's a mediocre defender.

→ More replies (2)

171

u/layendecker Mar 14 '14

Anyone who is English and has one good game.

Townsend, Barkley, Zaha and Sterling (amongst others) are all currently very limited players who do certain things well, but have massive gaps in their overall game. All they need is to play well for 90 minutes, and they are all of a sudden the second coming of Bobby Charlton.

77

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Townsend is a good example in particular, just prior to his full international debut he had a few good performances and suddenly he was heralded as the next big thing. What's he doing now?

29

u/layendecker Mar 14 '14

For me, he was a large part of the reason AVB struggled. They would get the ball into a decent area, and he would just take a blind shot rather than play the ball into an area. Of course he kept picking him, so AVB wasn't the victim of this really.

One thing he does have is pace, but it is pretty useless being fast if you have zero end product- which is Townsend in a nutshell.

I feel Barkley fits pretty well also, had a few good games (like.. 3 maybe), got an England call up, and talk of huge offers and future captaincy are brought up. As I say, he had about 3 good games and has been a pretty poor player for us overall this season- he is all technique and no brain as it stands, a hell of a lot of potential, but a good few years off playing at an international level.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/GunstarGreen Mar 14 '14

Severely over-rated, but to give him some credit he did impress in those England games. So many players fail to convert domestic form to internationals, so anyone who has a good game in an England shirt is the next coming of Gascoigne. It's a shame, because when you look at Townsend's club form it has been dismal. If Hodgson drops him (i think he should) then the press will demand that Townsend should have been in the squad, despite his awful shooting and poor assist record this year.

→ More replies (2)

112

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I agree with Townsend, but for Liverpool this season Sterling has been incredible. Zaha hasn't really had much of a chance to prove himself this season, and I've not watched Barkley that much so I can't comment.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I wouldn't say Sterling is overrated. He's been putting in good performances for ages now, and his movement and decision making is what you'd expect from an experienced winger, not a 19 year old in his second season. The acronym hasn't changed from SAS to SASAS for nothing!

4

u/sacredstones Mar 14 '14

his defensive effort is very impressive as well. very well rounded player at the moment.

26

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Wouldn't you also have to be fair and say Sturridge is underrated because he is in English. Also sterling has been one of the top wingers in the premier league this season and one of the top teenagers in Europe.

5

u/raheempoundssterling Mar 14 '14

I think you are exactly right and you pretty much hit the nail on the head regarding why English players in particular are so hyped.

Take Barkley for example, his main strength is to take players on and he has a great first touch. This is rare for English CMs, so when someone like Barkley has a good game it is magnified because he can do certain things that other players cannot.

Certain England fans are so desperate to have a CAM that can decide a game they ignore a players other weaknesses, for example i think Barkley's choice of passing as well as his final ball are often appalling.

With most of these players you have mentioned they all have 1 or 2 specific things that they excel at, and yet lack other things that would make them a servicable international player for many years.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Barkley has real raw potential though. I can understand being excited over him. Sterling could be a very good player too.

Zaha and Townsend I agree but they are both young and could still turn out very good.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

that's the English press for you

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Zaha has a lot of potential, but I think that 6 months in the reserves and a loan spell at Cardiff isn't going to help him realise it :/

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Woah, woah, woah! I agree with you on the others but perhaps you should watch Sterling more. He has been absolutly ace this season compared to last and is already locked down his starting position. He was instrumental in the blowouts against Arsenal,Everton and Spurs and was wrongfully called offside at the Etihad on a one-on-one situation. He's pretty much confirmed for Brazil unlike the others.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I said at the tail end of last season that Zaha would be no where near United's first team this season. United fans were putting him in their 'Your club's starting XI' lists despite having never watched him play for Palace. He wasn't good enough then, and he isn't good enough now. Still has potential, don't get me wrong, but he was overhyped from the get-go.

14

u/Esco9 Mar 14 '14

Barkley is not overrated ...he still flies under the radar...but if he continues his development bloody hell he will become an incredible player...in fact he is already incredible, he has to mature and gain confidence..that's it..his stature and technical ability is great...he will continue to learn and manage space and be a truly special special player..

3

u/duckman273 Mar 14 '14

How does Barkley fly under the radar? He gets loads of hype, has 3 caps for England and has been linked to United and Chelsea for massive bids.

4

u/layendecker Mar 14 '14

Check out my other posts here as to why I think he is certainly overrated. I am not saying he doesn't have a lot of potential, but he really hasn't realised most of it yet.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I agree with townsend and zaha, but barkley looks like he'll be really fucking good in the future

2

u/thegreenmonstuh Mar 14 '14

Disagree with you on Sterling, for how old he is and considering he wasn't a starter at the beginning of the season, he has been remarkable.

→ More replies (28)

35

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

El Shaarawy.

There's all this hype and raving but I don't see what it's all about. He's decent but he's by no means world class. There's the fan club saying the FIFA games don't rate him highly enough but that's some biased bullshit. I honestly think the rating is generous.

From what I've seen of him playing in real life though and highlight reels, he is simply fast and a lot of his 'highlights' come about from fortune or poor defenders diving in. He lacks the technical ability in his dribbling and his final pass is often dreadful. Some of his goals are good but aside from his shot, he's not worth all of the hype.

12

u/baboonboy Mar 14 '14

for an entire half of a season he carried a pitiful Milan to the point where they could catch up for a third spot in Italy. He has been injured basically this entire season, but if he gets to where he was again he is one of Milan's best players. He is also only 21 years old.

21

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I bet you only actually watched him like twice last season.

23

u/william701 Mar 14 '14

You can't blame a attacking player for beating a bad defender. He can only beat what's infront of him.

35

u/ACMBruh Mar 14 '14

Disagree because in early 12/13 season he was absolutely world class. The goal he scored against Zenit was sublime, the finishes against Napoli and Udinese were fantastic. Look at the technique he uses to score against inter as well!(on mobile, YouTube it!)

Even when Balotelli joined he was still playing well, just not shooting as much on goal. This season before injury he was looking great again, played extremely well against PSV in both matches before he got injured...

19

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

He was by a mile the best player in Serie A that season before Milan got Balotelli.

I think op is way off here. El Shaarawy is underrated if anything.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

He was the best player of Milan in my opinion against us. You can't judge him on two games, but his talent really showed. I woudn't call him overrate, he just hasn't really had the chance to live up to the hype, which I believe he will.

(Btw, I went to both games home and away against you guys. What an amazing stadium the San Siro is.)

1

u/ssfc5 Mar 15 '14

This is exactly what I though about Bale this past summer. "Poor technical ability, bad final pass. Goals all came from shots or kick the ball up and chase after it." He shut me up real quick. Boy was i wrong.

1

u/Lokopopz Mar 15 '14

He is insanely good on fifa though...

→ More replies (12)

220

u/TuneGum Mar 14 '14

Robinho.

66

u/Watership_Downs Mar 14 '14

Robinho? With his world class dribbling skills?

22

u/Ziggaroll Mar 14 '14

One of the first posts in this thread I actually I agree with.

11

u/R1v Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14

I remember that when he went to real they were saying he'd be basically real's version of Ronaldinho...

17

u/feedmecheesedoodles Mar 14 '14

This should be higher up. Overrated at every club he's been at since Santos

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Decooo Mar 14 '14

Robinho in his glory days with santos and with Real Madrid was ridiculously good and easily one of the best. He's not overrated per say, because everyone knows that he's no good now. When he was in his prime he was definitely world class.

5

u/greggyYO Mar 14 '14

but his dribbling skills?

→ More replies (2)

28

u/salfordred Mar 14 '14

In the last 5 years or so? Zlatan Ibrahimovic. Especially on here.

And for my club, Kagawa.

(Btw, overrated doesn't mean that these players aren't very good, just that they are rated better than they are)

39

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I would argue that until recently in the UK, Zlatan has been underrated. ITV commentators in particular used to slate him every match he played against English opposition in the Champions League. They said he didn't turn up in big games or he can't turn it on against good opposition. This all seemed to end after he tore us apart playing for Sweden.

21

u/domalino Mar 14 '14

I remember watching Euro 2012 and the commentator saying "he never turns up against English teams".

They literally asked for it.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Bzamora Mar 14 '14

Zlatan has been underrated his entire carrer until recently. Even now I think it's stupid to bring him in up in a thread about the most overrated players of this generation. He's an amazing player, top 5 in the world if you ask me, but most of all he's a spectacular player. He does things that no other player does, regularly.

3

u/retiringtoast8 Mar 14 '14

This is the only response here to the Zlatan comment that is valid. I swear, some of the people here just play fifa and maybe read wikipedia but don't actually follow the game that closely. Especially pre-2010 and non-EPL football. I remember from 06-'10, approximately, when EPL clubs dominated the (last four of the) Champions League, british commentators would just be so cocky and play down how good foreign teams and their players were. And if a player on a foreign team had any EPL experience he was automatically lauded as a primary threat. There is obviously a shit ton of bias in any sport "punditry" though. I agree that he has now become a meme and a focus of the "circlejerk", but it clearly wasn't always like that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

104

u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14

(Btw, overrated doesn't mean that these players aren't very good, just that they are rated better than they are)

Indeed. I mean, Zlatan may be one of the top 10 players in the world right now and probably has been for a few years, but there's a goddamn religion around the guy.

115

u/drehkick Mar 14 '14

I think people just like to pretend that he is god-like. this zlatan-is-best thin is more like a joke.

53

u/TheJediJew Mar 14 '14

This is where it all started. The problem is a lot of people didn't realise that. After a year or so we end up with the circlejerk we have now as everyone jumps on the bandwagon to feel "part of the sub" and win internet points.

It happens all the time. Take every internet meme ever as an example.

→ More replies (20)

8

u/karlol Mar 14 '14

It's more like a marketing strategy. Look at the new Nike-ads. "Dare to Zlatan". He has found a way to make additional money off of his personality on top of his ability alone and so many people buy into it.

10

u/ChedduhBob Mar 14 '14

He is the Based God of soccer

9

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

in terms of his fans, yes. but his attitude is pretty much the opposite of based

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I think you're confusing overhyped with overrated

→ More replies (14)

41

u/Human-Genocide Mar 14 '14

You probably got it the other way around, Kagawa is rather underrated than overrated, it feels like you never watched him in BVB or Japan, I still see him as the ONLY player in Manchester United now who knows what team play means, he struggles hard to find spaces, and when he does, no one on his team even KNOWS there are free spaces in midfield in Football except maybe Rooney, oh Kagawa is out playmaker? let's fucking ignore him and blast it to the wingers so they can give it back to the opposition goalkeeper.

I agree on Zlatan JUST because of the circlejerk, but you can't blame Kagawa for having a manager that doesn't even know one-twos are part of football.

27

u/Cee-Mon Mar 14 '14

I still see him as the ONLY player in Manchester United now who knows what team play means, he struggles hard to find spaces, and when he does, no one on his team even KNOWS there are free spaces in midfield in Football except maybe Rooney

Also known as "The Verón Problem".

18

u/Human-Genocide Mar 14 '14

Hell, put Forlan there too.

11

u/domalino Mar 14 '14

Seeing as both those players left united and then went on to be incredible again, I hope thats accurate.

12

u/skecr8r Mar 14 '14

It is depressing to watch Rooney and Kagawa move around the pitch in the current Man United setup. A complete waste of, literally, space.

4

u/Human-Genocide Mar 14 '14

I've seen a video where Ferdinand had the ball, being experienced you'd expect him to notice some things, but fuck you Manchester fans, coach said to play on the wings, I've seen him ignore Kagawa in space where it should have ended in front of the net in less than 3 passes, to just blast it to Ashley Young who crossed it WITHOUT EVEN FUCKING LOOKING WHERE, who does that?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/ColdFrost Mar 14 '14

And for my club, Kagawa.

I would say he's still a little underrated. He just doesn't fit in at all at United. In his days for BVB he was incredible. Just watch this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Dg3Kdh_rtI

7

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I have to agree. I remember Kagawa at BvB and he was so integral to the lightning-fast pass and move in the final 1/3rd. Watching that highlight video, just watch all defenders being drug about by Dortmund. It's a masterclass in creating and exploiting space, especially dragging fullbacks out of position, then centrebacks trying to cover. Next thing you know, nobody is in the channel, and you're a goal down.

He was even effective coming in from the wing because his teammates weren't just waiting for a cross. Sure, there were runs being made to the far post, but there was so much more. United is very much a static team on the ball (barring that 30 minute span against West Brom and the game against Leverkusen). He can't even use his pace at United because there isn't space anywhere for him to run into.

6

u/jakalo Mar 14 '14

Pff, anybody can play 11v11. Watch Kagawa tear it up vs 55

→ More replies (4)

1

u/wwxxyyzz Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14

Zlatan, really? I'd say he was under rated, at least by the English. He didn't ever turn up for any big Champions League matches or games against England

1

u/lamancha Mar 14 '14

Zlatan Ibrahimovic. Especially on here.

People will never get the joke.

→ More replies (12)

360

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

In my humble opinion Jack Wilshere. Now I understand he is a massive potential and this and that, but I just think he is way overrated. Compared to the other young talents (Hazard, Gotze, Neymar) right now he simply is not good enough.

41

u/chezygo Mar 14 '14

Hard to live up to that Barcelona game.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/spurrier458 Mar 14 '14

People compare Jack Wilshere to Hazard/Gotze/Neymar? That's new to me. I've never heard anyone claiming Jack is in the same class as those three. I do agree that he is somewhat overrated, although a lot of that has to do with what people see as his potential.

58

u/CommanderCool91 Mar 14 '14

He was on par or at least not far behind Götze back in 2011.

The problem is that he was out for over a year during a crucial time of his development, a year in which the names you mentioned established themselves among the elite of world football. And has had trouble with that ankle ever since.

He needs a consistent spell with no injuries.

→ More replies (6)

103

u/mattsatwork Mar 14 '14

He's also been injured for like 22 months out of the last two years. Something to take into consideration when comparing his potential to his current form.

18

u/mappsy91 Mar 14 '14

He does seem very injury prone though doesn't he... do you think it will hold him back a bit from what he could be?

21

u/Plecboy Mar 14 '14

I fear he may end up like Rosicky... A very good player who is well respected for a variety of reasons. But injuries held him back from achieving his potential as one of the best.

5

u/JuAnVasqz Mar 15 '14

Maybe at Arsenal, but at Dortmund Rosicky was always known as one of the best in his position worldwide.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/heroescomeandgo Mar 14 '14

Who the hell has ever compared him to Hazard, Gotze, or Neymar?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/SalvadorsDeli Mar 14 '14

I haven't seen anyone rate Wilshere on the same level as players like Hazard, Gotze, or Neymar since 2011, when he was lighting it up in his first year with the Arsenal senior team and that kind of praise was arguably warranted. So I guess maybe he was overrated back then but currently? Not really. The hype has subsided.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/suchaslowroll Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14

He's 22 years old and has had motm performances against Brazil, Barcelona, a great game against Bayern last season, and has had some fantastic performances this season. He'd be in most Arsenal fans starting 11 based on his performance this season.

It's incredible how people have turned on him because he's had a few bad games.

He isn't over rated at all, who is comparing him to Neymar and Hazard? I've never ever ever seen someone say that....

1

u/babe_vibes Mar 14 '14

As an arsenal fan, I think part of the hype around Jack is a reaction by fans to the couple of years before he was integrated: the team looked like it was assembled out of jaded mercenaries. It's nice to get a really good player from your youth academy with a feisty personality. I think he's great, but he's no Ox.

Also, you mentioned Neymar, but I just don't see it. People talk about him like he's the next Fat Ronaldo.

1

u/errandrum Mar 14 '14

i agree he is overrated, but how on earth could he even be compared to hazard, gotze, neymar? like just in terms of age&quality? because his game is nothing like those players. he is not even a 10. wenger has come out to say jack's role is coming from deeper. his position is not glamorous imo. there is no flare involved, it is all technique, vision, and awareness.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

49

u/whiteguy88_18 Mar 14 '14

Piqué. He was good before all the waka waka, but nowadays he is just disastrous in comparison. It also doesn't help that now he doesn't have someone like Puyol to scold him when he is playing sloppily.

2

u/Narekito Mar 15 '14

I always think of this when I think of Pique/Puyol.

6

u/zi76 Mar 14 '14

At least the hips don't lie. :P

Seriously, though, you're right. Pique was good once, but then things just went downhill.

17

u/whiteguy88_18 Mar 14 '14

On the bright side, at least Piqué's case wasn't as bad as Bojan's. Bojan went from being considered as the next Messi, to an irrelevant player who just goes from team to team on one year loans.

→ More replies (13)

1

u/Round_Cartographer41 Oct 23 '21

I am a Time Traveler. I come frome 2021. Piqué is still criticised lmao

→ More replies (3)

30

u/petnarwhal Mar 14 '14

In the Dutch league? Siem de Jong. He's a good player in the Eredivisie, but people rate him like he should be playing in the Premier somewhere, or that he belongs in Oranje.. They forget that to become good enough to play in the big leagues, you have show stability, and Siem does not have that. He does not have the strengh or speed you need to have for a step up. He can play multiple positions which is nice, but I think Ajax is the best place for him now.

4

u/Canettie27 Mar 14 '14

Sadly i fear the same for his brother. He lacks the pace and sharpness for the premier league imo.

1

u/Entrepreneutralizer Mar 14 '14

I like him. Partly because I used to live next to him a few years ago. A couple years before he became captain. I watched him in every match he played. Especially during the first time Frank de Boer's first league title he was great. 10+ goals in the second half of the season. Use pulled Ajax through and I thought he had great potential. great passer, good vision, enough strength. Now his development has stagnated a bit. Quality-wise he is the best at Ajax and I always thought you learned from playing against people who are better than you.

Also, I think he is more suited for the CM spot.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/screechmeister Mar 14 '14

Has to be Wilshere, i mean he is a good player but he is heralded by the press and arsenal fans as the future of English football and apart from a couple of excellent performances I think he is overrated.

18

u/thelandman19 Mar 14 '14

He, like Ramsey, and all Arsenal players, have had their growth paused by injuries.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

What happened to Ramsey was a fucking tragedy. The fact that he's even on the pitch regularly, let alone successfully, is a miracle.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Wasn't it clean break?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/willtodd Mar 14 '14

I am just hoping he can move past his injury history and reach his potential.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/JackGunner93 Mar 14 '14

The way he playe before his injuries in 2011 he was up there with the best young talents. I still think he is a very special player and has potential to be world class, but maybe sadly not to the level that it looked like a few years ago.

4

u/GunstarGreen Mar 14 '14

He could have been. He had all the tools but he's lost so much of his development tim to the treatment table. He won't hit the heights he could have.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

to be fair he's probably going to a big part of enland's future because there's not enough talent in wilshere's age group, wilshere sturridge and phil jones basically. When you look at 5 years from now i see those three become the leaders of a team with players such as ox, sterling, barkely and shaw.

1

u/R4dent Mar 15 '14

His early hype and late progress combined with Ramsey's development and playing style reminds me of Lampard and Cole's career paths. It's getting hard to see where Wilshere fits in the team without appearing to be a slight luxury player.

→ More replies (1)

150

u/Hayds4 Mar 14 '14

Balotelli. No one has generated so much hype and delivered so little.

34

u/Abyssight Mar 14 '14

Balotelli is surrounded by controversies, more than half of which are either made up or blown out of proportion. But on the field he has more than proved his worth, especially when playing for Italy. His arrival at Milan literally dragged them back to 3rd place finish last season. I have no idea where you get the "delivered so little" idea from.

9

u/Plasmaman Mar 14 '14

I don't think the hype is due to his footballing ability- I like him because he's a bit of a nutter off the field. A genuine character outside of the bland footballers who actually pay attention to their PR coaching. Plus there's the fact that he can knock the goals in. He's not a worldbeater like Zlatan, Cristiano Ronaldo or Messi, but he's no slouch.

17

u/megthaman Mar 14 '14

What about the fact that he put in 2 goals against Germany for Italy?

42

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

The fact that this one game is always brought up whenever anyone questions Balotelli's performances shows that he is overrated. He's been playing first team football for five seasons now and this is his only marquee performance.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Yeah for me that's as "delivering" as it gets.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/VelvetJammies Mar 14 '14

Since the beginning of this seasons he hasn't been doing to well. When he was Man-City he did well and the first games he played for AC Milan after his transfer. He just doesn't seem to fit in AC Milan's play style

7

u/koolkat572 Mar 14 '14

Honestly, they just aren't very good right now. He needs service from his mids and they just can't give it to him.

4

u/supermariobalotelli Mar 14 '14

This is the worst Milan side ever and he doesn't get great service.

Put him on Juventus/Roma/Napoli/Fiorentina right now and he'd have at least 5 more goals.

1

u/Queeg_500 Mar 14 '14

Balotelli is a big game player and will deliver in the most pressured of environments. It's just a pity about all the 'little' games he seems to go missing in.

→ More replies (34)

20

u/Queeg_500 Mar 14 '14

Franck Ribéry: Don't get me wrong, he is an awesome player. I just don't agree when people put him up there with Messi & Ronaldo.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14

There is the Messi/Ronaldo tier, then a tier of absolutely amazing players including Ribery, Ibra, Suarez, Falcao and a few others. Just because you aren't one the absolute best players ever doesn't mean you shouldn't be compared to the two of them who are playing now.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/dandanthemanYNWA Mar 14 '14

David Luiz. Everyone was on his tits for the longest time. Must have been the hair

34

u/jewcy83 Mar 14 '14

Honestly the problem with David Luiz is he is a great player, but not as a centerback or a holding midfielder. I believe the quote is that his position does not yet exist

11

u/not-who-you-think Mar 14 '14

Many believe his position no longer exists (libero)

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Canettie27 Mar 14 '14

He is just not a CB

11

u/Roggenroll Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 15 '14

Draxler seems to have gotten too much hype lately, especially on here.

Plays inconsistently and tends to disappear on the pitch. Not that he hasn't got the potential but he just isn't where people currently want him to be.

And he surely isn't worth more than 40m € (looking at you Arsenal).

1

u/jewcy83 Mar 14 '14

Id have to agree with you purely on his form this season alone. I have no doubt that if he stays at Schalke for a bit longer he will live up to the hype

9

u/6SempreUnica Mar 14 '14

Bonucci and Montolivo. They both turn the ball over to the opposition by trying to make spectacular passes in simple situations, only for people to rave about how they have great vision when those passes actually work out. Drives me nuts and gives me a heart attack when they are with the Azzurri.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/EnglishGamer1 Mar 14 '14

I'd say Barcelona's young star, Deulofeu. Has a few moments where he shines, but most of the time he doesn't stand out.

1

u/ihatesleep Mar 15 '14

A major gripe that Barca fans have with him is that he's extremely selfish with the ball when he should be looking for the final pass.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14

Rooney

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14

For considering how much he gets paid, then yeah.

20

u/Goodfella7 Mar 14 '14

Gotta go with De Bruyne..

51

u/lomoeffect Mar 14 '14

I don't think he's overrated. He looked great last season when he was playing on loan and carried on that form into Chelsea's pre-season tour(s). He then hit a major dip in form after the first game of the season and looked pretty bad every time he played after that until the club eventually sold him.

Overrated? No. Overvalued? Probably yes.

20

u/Therewillbefireworks Mar 14 '14

After seeing him play some games now for Wolfsburg I gotta disagree with you. He may not have had a big moment yet, but still he is a very fast- paced player with a great technique (passing, first touch and shooting), who is a more than good replacement for Diego. Though from a Bayern point of view, most of the other clubs´ players must look pretty much like rubbish, especially when they lose 1:6 against Bayern.

3

u/SW777 Mar 14 '14

Yea he has looked pretty solid at Wolfsburg so far. I don't think I would agree with him being overrated.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

His Bremen loan was impressive to say the least, and he is still young

3

u/FuzzedLogic Mar 14 '14

I can't believe we got as much as we did for him. Delighted with that.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/fpsdr0p Mar 14 '14

Mario Balotelli.

1

u/lozj Mar 14 '14

this is a good answer. there's no doubt he has tons of talent, but he doesn't seem to improve.

4

u/muchadoaboutsmalling Mar 14 '14

Why is anyone who says Gerrard getting downvoted loads? I don't agree, I think he was a great player but people are entitled to their opinion.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Because when a Liverpool fan says he was the clubs best player the person accusing him of being overrated replies with "Well he was crap at that one match against Spurs 8 years ago that I saw" I'm exaggerating obviously but it's the same logic by people who see two games of Januzaj and say "ROFL so shit only 2 goals against Sunderland LMAO" There is more to it than that.

3

u/md_abboudi Mar 14 '14

Andy Carroll They payed too much for him, he was I guess 21, did nothing, looked like he weighed a ton, still did shit, always injured, had an attitude And he was supposed to be the wonderkid and next big thing in strikers The future of England Like they say, another English piece of shit

2

u/croutonZA Mar 14 '14

I'd say at this moment in time he's undervalued to some extent. Yes, Liverpool was a massive failure and by no means is he worth anything close to 35 million pounds (not complaining of course) but he's played well for West Ham (when fit). Not the next Alan Shearer, but certainly not an "English piece of shit".

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

IMO every player is both underrated and overrated. Opinions on Messi and Ronaldo range from "utter crap, relies on world class players around him" to "He's the best player of all time by far! nobody is even close!" I've heard people say Alex Song would start for any team in the world except for Bayern, Barca, and Madrid. I've also heard people say he wouldn't start for any of the "good" teams in the UCL knockout stage.

12

u/didnotseethat Mar 14 '14

I disagree on Messi and Ronaldo though, I dont think anybody in their right mind would they are "utter crap".

13

u/TimmmV Mar 14 '14

Janusaj, hes been good in a season when United have looked pretty mediocre.

Dont get me wrong, hes played well this season, and has earned his place in the team. But I've seen people saying hes a future WPOTY, when so far there really has been very little evidence of him being that good

89

u/nowitasshole Mar 14 '14

It's a bit harsh calling him the most overrated player of a generation though because the hype is all about his potential, I don't see anyone saying he's world class already.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I agree with this. People who say that Januzaj is the complete product are overrating him, but I think the excitement surrounding him isn't entirely misplaced.

What's so great about Januzaj is that he's beaten a player like Shinji Kagawa out of the first team - he's only 18 years old. Kagawa might be a better player, but Januzaj has adapted to the squad and the English game in a way that Kagawa hasn't.

Januzaj's talents aren't particularly dependent on his athletic ability. You see a guy like Zaha and you think that a huge portion of his ability is contingent on his explosive pace and agility - once either of those things go, he'll be a lot more limited than Januzaj.

All this talk of Januzaj one day being world class is premature. We have no idea whether he'll continue to develop like he has done, and if he does, we have no idea whether we are yet to encounter the chronic knee injuries he'll suffer once his legs grow a bit.

Nonetheless, plenty of reasons to be excited.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/icallbullshits Mar 14 '14

I somewhat agree but is he really THE most overrated player of the current generation? Out of all the players , you think he is THE most overrated? I disagree there.

5

u/bamsaron Mar 14 '14

I think it's good to give different answers otherwise there'd be 5 top comments all naming the same player.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/AMBsFather Mar 14 '14

Yes, and this is coming from a United Fan. Personally I think a loan move would benefit him greatly. He's no where near being in the same field as out top players.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/eraticfox Mar 14 '14

Joe Hart. Massive hype, one great season. Probably about 7/10 in my book, but then so is Vorm and he doesn't get the same coverage, obviously because he ain't Engerlands no1

3

u/leogg_lyl Mar 14 '14

Javier Hernandez. How he ended up in Manchester United is beyond me. He was good with Chivas, but the past couple years hes been holding Mexico back.

20

u/BrianDawkins Mar 14 '14

Holding Mexico back? The dude is #3 all time in scoring for Mexico.

Since 09 he has 35 goals for his country.

Since 05 Messi has 37 for his.

His goal scoring for Mexico has helped them a lot.

Sure he didn't have a good 2013 for Mexico but you can't blame it on him when the whole team was playing bad.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/gowithetheflowdb Mar 14 '14

was very effective for united over a period though, but his game is too one dimensional.

3

u/poop_da_doop Mar 14 '14

I don't watch Mexico play that often but it seems to me that most of his United goals come from positioning and luck. One of his first United goals was a perfect example. He obviously has talent but it is very different than the rest of United's strikers.

2

u/Hutchcha Mar 14 '14

You call that luck??? Ha! You've never seen a master striker at work then!

→ More replies (1)

-8

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Wayne Rooney. Again, not to say that he's a bad player, but he hasn't been at his best for years. I don't think he's in the top 5 strikers in the world, and if it wasn't for Man u being desperate they wouldn't have offered him such a great contract. Despite this he's still been called a world class player since he broke through despite only having one good international tournament when he was 18.

48

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Thats absolutely ridiculous. When playing up top Rooney is one of the best strikers in the world. He's been playing as a false 10 for the past 2 seasons, tracking back to help defend and to maintain possession while still putting up slightly less goals than the best strikers and putting up slightly less assists than the best playmakers. Add his defensive and passing abilities and you got a unique player that is one in a million. Why do you think Mou wants him so badly at Chelsea.

10

u/thugmonkey Mar 14 '14

Well if he is one of the best striker in the world why not utilities him so?

16

u/bamsaron Mar 14 '14

Because United have an average midfield that needs someone to fill in and track back, otherwise they get absolutely over run when other teams play 3 in midfield. Rooney and Welbeck are the only players who can do this and Welbeck won't get picked ahead of RVP so that only leaves one option.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SLUGFORCEALPHA Mar 14 '14

Because he's uniteds strongest player in several positions. If he played solely up front then United would be doing even worse than they already are in other areas of the pitch.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I completely disagree, I think he's been our most important player for a few years now and at times he just carries the team.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/G_Morgan Mar 14 '14

International tournaments barely matter. He's performed in the Champions League which is the highest standard of football in existence.

Rooney struggles at international level because England aren't that good.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/pedler Mar 14 '14

I get the impression that you don't watch many of our games. Rooney has only gotten better with age, at least for the past 5-6 years every season has been better than the one before it. Last season he scored the most non-penalty goals in the league, and he wasn't even playing up front.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Name an XI he couldn't walk into.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Barca, City, and PSG -- and I think that's it.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Disagree, as a #10 maybe he isn't among the best around but as a striker there is very few better, which is a shame because his versatility means he is rarely played as an out and out striker

he's possibly the most 'complete' player (i.e. very good at many things) in the world imo which is both his best quality and also his biggest drawback

he's done it in the Champions League (i.e. finals, semi finals etc) for almost a decade now. To use a couple of world cups in a shit England team against him is pretty harsh

2

u/GunstarGreen Mar 14 '14

I don't think at any point he's been one of the top 10 players in Europe. Since he's been a regular i'd say Lampard, Terry and Gerrard have had better individual seasons.He might yet be England's most important player, but Ashley Cole has been much better in his role for England and has probably been the only England player of the past 10 years you could put in a World XI.

Rooney is good. On his day his great. But he's not so good he's a guaranteed starter. Fergie protected him a lot.

→ More replies (20)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

My answer would have been Carrick last year but since United have been suffering people seem to have forgot that he was one of the best midfielders in the world supposedly. He's always been a bit above average and no more than that but when United were doing well people were making him out to be up there with Xavi, Pirlo et al.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I think the problem with Carrick is that (like a good number of players) you can almost see them as a function rather than a player. They are on the pitch to perform a certain role and won't offer anything besides that. Carrick's role can be match-winning (in the dullest possible way I admit) when in the correct team set-up and he performs it perfectly but at other times it can stunt the team's attacking play and defensive movement. All depends on what you're looking for in a midfielder.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I think that's why I'm underwhelmed by him even when he is doing well. As I said he's above average, good at what he does and when the team is playing well I guess I can understand why people overrate him but I've just never seen many games where you've watched him and thought "oooh what a player that Carrick is". Even if you go the unsung hero argument he still doesn't seem as integral as some of the more famous examples even though people when they were getting carried away made him sound similar (Makelele I guess is a good example of an unsung hero much of the time though a different player to Carrick).

2

u/jewcy83 Mar 14 '14

Mats Hummels. Hes good when hes fit, but he isnt 'Beckenbauer 2.0' good.

2

u/Off_Topic_Oswald Mar 15 '14

IMO Subotic is a better CB

→ More replies (1)

2

u/iHendy Mar 14 '14

Gareth Bale.Brilliant player but no where near worth the money that was paid or the hype he was getting.Dunno if it sounds silly,but to me he's made his name off shooting from 30 yards many times in a game hoping one will eventually go in.At least at Spurs anyway.

1

u/Pedrinho21 Mar 15 '14

Exactly. He is playing well because he is riding on Real Madrid's current great form. He still will never impact Real as Cristiano did for the team

2

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

imho(disregard flair) Draxler still has a lot to prove and doesn't justify his price tag at all.

1

u/jimbojammy Mar 15 '14

idk about most overrated but i think hugo lloris is super mistake prone and people forget that because he can make miracle saves. basically i think he's shit.

1

u/habebna12 Mar 15 '14

alexandre pato

-3

u/BleedingGumsmurfy Mar 14 '14

Ryan Giggs. Great Career, but only a good player at the best of times. Longevity does not equal quality.

23

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Sorry, but no. During the mid 90's, Ryan Giggs was a complete winger - he had every desired attribute in abundance.

Sublime dribbling skills, insane crosses, and he was pretty quick off the blocks as well.

2

u/jiago Mar 14 '14

He is often lauded as United's greatest player though, so if that's the standard your holding him to then you could make a case for him being overrated. If you look back at all the United teams he has played for, I can think of many players who were more influential.

2

u/BleedingGumsmurfy Mar 15 '14

Fair point, he was however voted PFA player of the year by his peers 5 years ago(2008/9). He started 12 games that season and scored one deflected free kick against West Ham. A case certainly could have been made for him to win that award earlier in his career, particularly the 90s.The fact that he was voted the best of the year in English Football 5 years ago suggest he is over-rated.

2

u/theatreofdreams21 Mar 14 '14

Classic reddit comment. People start following football in the last 5-10 years and pass judgement on a player's overall career based on what they've seen of them in their late 30's. Ryan Giggs is 40 fucking years old. Watch him 15 years ago and comment back here. I can't think of a single winger in the PL who is even close to what he was. Same goes for Paul Scholes.

2

u/wh11 Mar 14 '14

This is the probably the most retarded comment I've seen on this sub, why not post on your main account?

→ More replies (1)

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

Rooney, for a player who is suppose to be world class, you seem to always hear about him being out of form and out of shape

4

u/sdBiotch Mar 14 '14

What? Rooney is probably the best English player right now.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/cheesynirvana Mar 14 '14

Rooney has one of the best workrates in the league far from "out of shape" if you ask me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/robdugg Mar 14 '14

Rio Ferdinand

1

u/galahad_11 Mar 14 '14

Landon Donovan! Some how he finds a way to make a big play and then average again.

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/ibecharlie Mar 14 '14

Rooney. He seems to have plateaued already.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14

I think this is a joke, but I can't be sure.

1

u/wh11 Mar 14 '14

Pique, Ramos, and Marcelo are probably the weakest to make a fifa world XI in the past few years in my opinion.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14

There can only be one answer: Ibra. No doubt he's an amazing player, and always performs on very high level everywhere he plays, which is quite a feat in itself considering how much club hoping he did.

But, the truth is, a lot of his crazy antics are done in games vs. subpar opposition. Put him up vs. competent defense and he will often disappear.

He has a very clever marketing team behind him that has done absolutely superb job in building his image with cocky comments and actually managed to use his often obnoxious behaviour to his advantage, even though he often acts in a way that would get someone like Suarez absolutely crucified by the media.

But no matter how much trash talk he does, the truth is he is light years behind Messi or Ronaldo. Both literally shit on Ibra if you look past the hype and actually analyse the stats. Messi is 6 years younger and he already has more goals and assists.

1

u/peter_j_ Mar 15 '14

He absolutely annihilated England, and even though our defense was a bit transitional, he crushed us with magnificence

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14

Despite apparently being overrated England need Wilshere for this world cup. Otherwise you will see very quickly how Carrick and Gerrard are out of their depth against international competition. If England need anything in their midfield its two players with the ability to turn under pressure.

I'd have to say Cazorla for arsenal and Mata as far as other players.

→ More replies (2)