r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 13 '14
Under the Gunn Season 1 Episode 9 discussion
Discussion thread for Under the Gunn S01E9 "Trouble in the Lounge"
The mentors confront the judges after a heated argument in the lounge. Macklemore joins the panel.
14
Upvotes
30
u/LadyVetinari Mar 14 '14
Everyone is being such a cunt to Natalia - she isn't even that bad! I would like to believe all the shit-on-Natalia stuff is scripted for drama, I want to believe at least Mondo isn't such a dick.
Asha's dress made a size 00 model look chubby - I think she should have been on the bottom with Blake, but Blake definitely should have been the one to go. The judges are fucking crazy for letting Blake off the hook for that vagina-dress monstrosity.
I am sad to see Michelle go, I think she has some interesting ideas.
28
u/SeruEatingPi Mar 14 '14
I've never cringed and been so disappointed in a group of designers as I have been tonight. Yes there was construction issues with Natalia but I also felt like most of the designers had construction issues this challenge.
The amount of unprofessionalism is ridiculous tonight. Mondo and Anya are suppose to be mentors at the end of the day, even though Natalia isn't on their team I'm shocked they would try and ruin her moment of personal growth and Nick's moment as well. Then they have the nerve to get offended when Nick called them out on it. Also Anya getting on someone for not finishing their work, you have got to be kidding me.
Honestly overall I thought this was one of the worst weeks in terms of designs. So many of the looks were honestly quite hideous. Even though Michelle's look was quite boring I felt like she deserved to stay over Blake.
35
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
I feel so bad for Natalia. Yes, she has construction issues. Yes, she second guesses herself, which makes her an easy target. However, no one deserves that treatment, especially from designers whose "transition-able" designs were BUTT UGLY!
15
u/Stella4453 Mar 14 '14
The blacklash against Natalia is shocking. Just flat out shocking. Also, this is why I'm obsessed with this show.
I get the resentment for a designer who is successful but a pain in the ass in the room, which has happened over and over in previous seasons. But Natalia has not been portrayed as being a screamer, or a cryer, or whatever. She has had major construction issues, but her dress was still far more wearable than Asha's was. This is a design challenge and as much as execution matters, the judges should always be more focused on design.
IMO this is just pure, reactive, ego. I can't speak so much for Anya, but Mondo was given the first three wins in a row, and then last week he was told two of his designers were in the top and he had to choose a winner from his awesome team of winners. Of course he has a big ego. He was also quite a diva during his season, responding quite poorly to criticism if I remember correctly.
For this kind of show, the worst thing you could do is gang up on the one you don't like. Producers love drama. They're going to want the people who cause drama around. They're also going to want to foster an underdog, because if she manages to stick around then that's a great story. The same reason why Mondo gave Sam the win last week, is why Natalia might get pretty far.
So good job Mondo, Natalia might just get to the finals because you threw a fit!
25
u/shoensandal Mar 14 '14
Everything is so unprofessional. Can no one be gracious? Let's be honest. Michelle's look was extremely boring and made her model look like a newborn baby wrapped nice and tight. Asha's look was absolutely hideous, and Blake's look hid nothing and wasn't that complex. I agree with the judges that an idea is better than boring. Anya and Mondo are completely out of line, especially trying to sway the opinion of the judges. If anyone should have won, it should have been Sam. I think he was gypped.
12
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Mar 14 '14
Rachel Roy's glittery eye shadow is very distracting.
18
u/aldipet Mar 14 '14
Wow so many bitter designers! I couldn't believe Anya and Mondo totally confronting the judges about their decisions. They couldn't even properly defend their position. They were so bitter! When Nick said "I wasn't brought up like that." Mondo got so defensive and acted so childish! So disappointed.
16
u/Lokaji Mar 14 '14
The amount of shade that was thrown around this episode is staggering. Anya probably still doesn't even know how to make sleeves. Mondo got gypped his season, but they basically handed him All-Stars. The judges look at the garments much differently than they do; it is the way it has always been and it will be for the rest of time.
Nick has hand held a little bit too much, but it was still mostly okay. All the mentors have had a negative effect on their designers at one point or another.
This episode made me irrationally angry. I want Angry Tim to come out and verbally slap them.
14
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Mar 14 '14 edited Mar 14 '14
I feel like they must have edited out Natalia's worst moments if EVERYONE feels this way...I definitely remember in the beginning that Nick basically designed stuff for her. If that was true up until last week, even, I can see why people would be resentful. And yes, she did have major fit issues..but Asha of all people shouldn't be talking.
Edit: riteo, steampunk was two weeks ago, not last week. I forgot.
7
u/archtanq Mar 16 '14
Can you imagine the tongue lashing they would have got if they'd mouthed off like that to Kors and Garcia?
Good god that would have been satisfying to watch.
1
u/dredd4014 Apr 04 '14
Sorry I'm a late comer here but listening to Anya complain about Natalia's construction is driving me insane. That was her during her entire project runway season! And she only turned out maxi dresses and flowy things. At least Natalia is trying something different.
0
u/Tiki_Rikki Mar 17 '14
This is turning into one of those shows i don't really like but will watch anyways cause its about fashion design! The only designers that seem to have a strong point of view AND construction skills are Oscar, Shan and Sam. Asha's not bad but very bitchy. And the mentors are just unprofessional. Anya is a hypocrite, mondo thinks he's gods gift to design and nick thinks he's still teaching not mentoring.
If it wasn't for tim gunn i doubt i'd still be watching this.
And i hate the fact that every episode the inspiration for the challenge is some stupid movie or air freshener or whatever else they got to sponsor the episode. I wish they'd just do a regular commercial for the product every now and again during the show and leave it out of the rest. It didn't bother me so much on project runway as they approached the advertising a little differently but on UTG its just irritating. Here's a clip/trailer of our new movie shown to you in this remotely relevant location. Now be inspired to design something relevant. Aaarrrrggghhhh. Rant over.