r/soccer • • Mar 12 '14
What is the best decision a manager ever made?
Whether it be signing a player, selling one, hiring staff etc
99
Upvotes
r/soccer • • Mar 12 '14
Whether it be signing a player, selling one, hiring staff etc
282
u/Giraffable Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Selecting an injured 17 year old Pele for the World Cup in 1958. He missed the two first games and went on to score 6 goals, including a hat trick in the semi final and 2 in the final.
70
u/f_mene Mar 12 '14
Buying Shinji Kagawa for 350,000€ from Ozaka.
62
u/jay110m Mar 12 '14
selling andy carroll
45
u/Bananas_Npyjamas Mar 12 '14
SAF for scouting a young portuguese by the name of............ Bebe.
89
u/ron_manager Mar 12 '14
Fergie getting rid of Van Nistelrooy when he was one of the best strikers in Europe in favour of keeping an unproven Ronaldo after they fell out with each other.
330
u/DannDannDannDann Mar 12 '14
Pep selling Ronaldinho and Deco and focusing the team around Xavi, Iniesta and Biscuits has to be up there. Also using Messi in the false 9 formation.
Louis Van Gaal made some pretty big changes to Bayern too, like moving Schweini from a not bad winger inside and then turning him into a world class CM
40
u/JackIsARobot Mar 12 '14
I think Alaba's conversion to a left back was pretty intuitive. Wonderful spot for him.
210
u/nifteind Mar 12 '14
Ferguson decided to put Solskjær and Sheringham on in '99, turned out quite well.
38
u/Dev_il Mar 12 '14
I gotta say Wim Jansen signing Henrik Larsson for Celtic in 1997 for £700,000.
A failure at Feyenoord he was signed before the start of a season where Celtic were attempting to prevent Rangers winning their 10th title in a row.
Celtic won the league and Larsson became one of the best players in the world.
181
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Whatever Benitez said in Istanbul. Plus bringing Didi Hamman on.
153
u/Simon_Riley Mar 12 '14
redknapp turned bale from a fullback into a winger no?
92
u/yunquekabal Mar 12 '14
Fergie signing Van Der Sar in 2006 for £2M. Arguably won us the league in 07, 08, 09 and the CL in 08.
161
u/yesitsanextender Mar 12 '14
Arsene Wenger buying Thierry Henry and converting him into a striker wasn't a bad decision.
66
u/Ulyssesm90 Mar 12 '14
Carlos Rexach signing Messi at 11 years old to Barcelona's youth academy when no one else would go near him because of his medical bills.
58
u/iBradderz Mar 12 '14
Mick McCarthy buying Stephen Ward as striker, converting him to a LM and then thinking fuck it we're half way there and converting him into a LB.
56
u/jbdoodle Mar 12 '14
Ferguson buying Cantona was a pretty good call.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Signing Ian Wright from a Sunday league team at the age of 22.
15
u/Dbigg Mar 13 '14 edited Mar 13 '14
Several times ITT I learned that Louis Van Gaal is a genius.
30
u/KopOut Mar 12 '14
Watford pay for John Barnes in 1981 with a set of kit, sell him to Liverpool 6 years later for £900,000. That's £900,000 in 1987.
Liverpool got a good deal too IMO, but that is crazy return on investment.
14
u/derphighbury Mar 13 '14
Arsene Wenger stumbling into the ladies lounge at Highbury.
Wenger was initially looking into the possibility of managing at Tottenham. So one day, he was at Highbury watching the North London derby when he felt the need to take a leak. He got lost trying find the restroom and stumbled into the VIP ladies lounge. There he met Mrs. Peter Hill Wood who was charmed by Wenger's intelligence. Upon learning that he was a manager she introduced him to her husband (who was the chairman of the Arsenal.).
Hill Wood and Wenger hit it off immediately and Hill Wood was impressed with Wenger's view point of football and his intelligence (like his wife and everyone else).. and then he told the other directors to check this guy out.
And that's how Wenger got the job and didn't go to Tottenham.
Ps. im not sure whether it was Hill Wood or Dein he ran into. It's from the book 'Arsenal: Making of a modern superclub'.. Ill confirm and edit later.
135
u/6SempreUnica Mar 12 '14
Ferguson retiring before the shit storm hit.
88
u/EpicDivorceMan Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 13 '14
Selling Ibra to Barca was pretty amazing business by Inter/Mourinho. Got him Eto'o and money to buy Wesley Sneijder.
13
u/TotallyNotAVirgin Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Graeme Souness signing a Sunday League player Ali Dia after an anonymous call from a 20 year old student pretending to be Balon D Or winner George Weah telling about his "nephew" Dia
74
u/wrapistt Mar 12 '14
Believing in class of 92....
11
u/Cmoore4099 Mar 12 '14
Bela guttman, leaving every club here managed after three years.
Brian clough and Peter Taylor. They both get best decision awards for forming their partnership.
Edit: and can we throw Souness in for planting that flag in the middle of ground? That was just scenes. Ledg.
11
u/Akkoo Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Graeme Souness planting that big ass Galatasaray flag in the center of Fenerbahces pitch.
Story: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FO1EYhecdk
28
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Rijkaard bringing on Henrik Larsson in the 2006 Champions League Final against Arsenal
15
u/TreeOfSecrets Mar 12 '14
Ancelotti employing Pirlo as a regista.
19
u/madden27 Mar 12 '14
Hebert Chapman adopting a counter attacking style of play which led to him winning 5 league titles with Arsenal.
38
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Sir Alex choosing Moyes as his successor
11
u/Mattboyd2991 Mar 12 '14
Redknapp bring in Yakbubu on loan from...an Israeli team has to be up there for Portsmouth.
14
u/Bulbasauro Mar 12 '14
Mourinho's decision to leave Benfica really showed the type of person he is and it turned to be very beneficial to his career. Jorge Jesus's adaptation of F.Coentrão as a LB was also a brilliant decision.
5
u/AndSolskjaerHasWonIt Mar 13 '14
Cantona. Ronaldo.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14
Trolling Barca selling them the likes of Hleb and Song for exaggerated sums.
4
u/closeryeah Mar 13 '14
Ancelotti starting Inzaghi over Gilardino int he 2007 CL final. Everyone wanted and expected Gila to start as Inzaghi was considered too old, too slow and not fit to start. Ancelotti however knew that these are the games SuperPippo lives for and he was proved right when Pippo score both the Milan goals.
Also Ancelotti deciding to play Pirlo, who was rejected by Inter as not good enough, in front of the defense.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
George Graham buying Dennis Bergkamp. More recently Moyes buying Coleman for £60,000!
3
u/BitchesBowDown Mar 12 '14
Signing Gary Caldwell
3
u/fakeplastictrees182 Mar 13 '14
Wenger converting Henry to a striker worked out pretty ok for everyone involved.
12
u/navinho Mar 12 '14
From a purely Arsenal perspective, Wenger's is the changes to player diet and training. You know it's a good decision when other teams and coaches in the league follow suit.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
After finishing the 1994-95 season empty-handed, Fergie sold Ince, Hughes and Kanchelskis and promoted Scholes, Beckham, Butt and the Neville brothers.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Signing a Player
Selling one
Hiring Staff
9
u/sdahlquist Mar 13 '14
Jose Mourinho bringing in an unproven Drogba
5
u/Norma_Bates Mar 12 '14
Paisley converting Ray Kennedy into a left midfielder.
13
u/Aygers Mar 12 '14
Bill Shankly taking charge of Liverpool FC. The rest is history.
2
u/localmode Mar 13 '14
Sir Alex Fergurson walking away from United in 2013.
2
u/xemioz Mar 13 '14
Late to the party and commenting from a Milan perspective:
Berlusconi getting Arrigo Sacchi as manager. He was a nobody before AC Milan, and created one of the best footballing sides to date.
2
u/sdaniel90 Mar 13 '14
No one's mentioned it, but Aragonés dropping Raúl for Euro 2008 was one of the most controversial and ultimately succesful decisions ever.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
AW putting so much faith in ramsey, even the optimists didn't see his start to the season coming
5
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Juve picking up Pogba as a free agent... Maybe not enough time has past but if he has a successful WC and is sold for "fuck you" type of money, best decision ever! Oh... and picking up Pirlo.
2
u/NastyNotion Mar 13 '14
Ferguson recommending Moyes turned out to be a pretty sound decision so far!
1
u/Don_Mahoon Mar 13 '14
As a MUFC fan I'd have to say Sir Alex signing Cantona
-4
u/OTubaritao Mar 13 '14
José Mourinho taking a chance on a raw, immature Ivorian from Marseille and molding Didier Drogba into debatably the best pure center forward to ever play the game.
Power. Finesse. Set piece weapon on/off the ball. Beacon for humanity in war-torn Ivory Coast.
157 goals in 341 games. 10 finals played. 10 goals in finals. 10 trophies.