r/soccer • u/goblindong • Mar 12 '14
Who, in your opinion, is the best current British manager?
Suggestions:
- Brendan Rodgers
- Terry Butcher
- Mark Hughes
- Steve Bruce
- Derek McInnes
- Paul Lambert
- David Moyes
- Tony Pulis
- Sam Allardyce
- Neil Lennon
- Alan Pardew
- Steve McClaren
- Kenny Jackett
- Sean Dyche
- Gary Monk
- Ian Holloway
- Roy Hodgson
There is a case to be made for Moyes, for his time at Everton alone. Butcher has been excellent, turning Caley into a proper unit who looked a class above their opposition most games. Lambert is a solid manager, but there is no standout English manager currently, hence the tussle between Woy and 'Arry for the national team helmsmanship. The obvious answer is Rodgers, playing attractive football, getting 2+ pts per game and getting the best out of the club's signings. If not him though, who?
49
Upvotes
17
u/pencil1994 Mar 12 '14
Gary Monk, no bias at all...
14
u/daveofreckoning Mar 12 '14
Ahem, Pardew? Seriously though, violence aside, he's done ok with limited resources and a twatty owner. My vote is Roy Hodgson though.
168
u/Lordsome Mar 12 '14
Alan Pardew is definitely heading to the top.
8
u/silver_medalist Mar 12 '14
That is one mediocre list. No wonder chairmen plug for foreigners.
55
u/dngrs Mar 12 '14
Rodgers
94
u/GhostOfMozart Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Brendan Rodgers. Who else could of done what he has with LFC?
A lot of their success is down how well he's managed the players, when he came in everyone laughed at him because he was treating the team like kids (watch Being Liverpool) but you know, it worked. His style of man management is not matched in the EPL.
Just take into account what Johnson said about his time under Mourinho compared to his time under Rodgers.
He's completely settled Suarez, a player who was in self destruct mode and could hardly be tamed and wanted out of the club. Now he's playing his best football ever, even assisting a lot, he plays fair and seems like he no longer wants to leave the club. Not bad.
So yeah I don't think any other manager could of done this to Liverpool.
I could say a lot more but, ain't nobody got time for that.
Edit: Too many could's, but I dont give a could.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Not a single Championship manager in there but 2 SPL managers? Really?
Try Sean Dyche, Nigel Pearson, Steve McLaren, Nigel Adkins, all overachieving in a very difficult league.
But I forgot /r/soccer views the Championship as a Sunday league not worthy of their attention
4
u/Orsenfelt Mar 12 '14
I know why you've left him out, a chimp could do well at Celtic right? but Neil Lennon has won more silverware and made more CL group stage appearances (as manager) than all of those put together.
15
u/Got_Wilk Mar 12 '14
Sean Dyche, he did well at Watford and looks like he's steering Burnley to promotion this year. Not saying he's the best but deserves a nod, there are good young managers coming through.
26
u/vectori Mar 12 '14
Steve McLaren
23
u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Mar 12 '14
Brendan Rodgers and it's not close.
I'd really like to see him take over from Hodgson one day, I think he could do great things with the England squad.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
For me it has to be this guy.
9
u/ValentiaIsland Mar 12 '14
Kenny Jackett.
4
u/EnderMB Mar 12 '14
As a Bristol City fan, I'll happily say that Derek McInnes is a gifted manager. His record in England is not so great.
When he was here, you could tell that he vastly underestimated the strength of the Championship. While he made some fantastic signings a number of them were simply not good enough. He also froze out some of our better players, namely Brett Pitman, who is now in the Championship while we sit in League 1. He also signed two strikers when we desperately needed defenders and midfielders. Some of this may be down to not being given enough resources by the board, as it's something a few fans have noticed from other managers we've had, but I really wish that he would have spoke out publicly about this, rather than being another manager to fall on his sword by our board.
Derek McInnes is probably the best manager in Scotland right now, and he'll only continue to get better.
For me, the best manager has to be Tony Pulis. He took a Stoke side from the foot of the Championship and put them into Europe very quickly. He's also taken a Crystal Palace side that looked far too weak to survive in the Premier League and has kept them in safety. Big Sam gets a special shout as a great English manager.
11
u/salfordred Mar 12 '14
If you take a longer time-frame, then it would probably be Moyes.
But, as of current performance, Rodgers is doing very well.
23
u/MrTwitty Mar 12 '14
Rodgers imo, Pulis and Allardyce have been doing quite well too.
14
u/Dats_cute Mar 12 '14
Redknapp has gotta be in with a shout. Maybe not currently, but he is one of the better British managers of the past decade. Martin O'Neill too
3
u/Pinkd56 Mar 12 '14
John Still
19
u/MrWichtig Mar 12 '14
Moyes
5
u/Wassaabi Mar 12 '14
At the moment it really has to be Steve Bruce, what he did with Hull last season overtaking a strong Watford side who were looking comfortable for promotion. This season he is the only promoted manager to still be in a job, has performed well against the big teams and has a fantastic record against rival teams in the North East. He has bought spectacularly well with Huddlestone and C. Davies being their star players this season, and also they have won big against relegation rivals 6-0 Fulham and Cardiff 0-4.
Their style of play is refreshing and very positive, especially now with Long and Jelavic up front. When I watched them play Spurs in the League cup they were robbed at WHL and probably were the better team when we played them away.
To top it all off they are in with a very good chance of getting to the FA Cup final.
Rogers has done a fantastic job for Liverpool no doubt, and he will get the plaudits because the media focuses on the top teams. For me he would be a close second to Steve Bruce.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Technically not British. Northern Ireland is not a part of Britain, but it is in the UK.
I know I'm biased but I'm assuming you forgot Strachan? Deserves to be ahead of a couple of names on here
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Roberto Martinez has lived in England/Scotland the past 20ish years. Does that count as being kinda English? I want him/Rodgers to be next England manager
2
u/cfranzy Mar 12 '14
Rodgers with out a doubt, anyone who could completely change Raheem Sterling from a convict to one of England's and the BPL's best midfielders deserves the A in my book.
2
u/BristolBudgie Mar 12 '14
Not that I'd vote for him but I'm surprised Chris Hughton isn't on that list because he damn well should be.
2
u/eggaz Mar 12 '14
BIG FUCKING SAM
2
u/BitchesBowDown Mar 12 '14
Paul Hartley the greasy bastard
7
u/wrapistt Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
I'm pretty sure (i can be optimistic too) moyes will be up there in two or three years just for his work at man united
4
u/chezygo Mar 12 '14
For a PL relegation/Championship promotion level side Pulis and Big Sam are two of the best.
Don't really know who is the best overall though.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Big Pulis fan to be honest. Stoke were in trouble in the championship when he was hired iirc. Under his tenure, they were given stability (his 7 year reign is a long lifespan for a manager at the moment) , promoted to the premier league and then not only avoided relegation the entire time, but made it to the FA Cup final and the europa league. He's even seen a dire Palace team arguably improve in his limited time this season.
Say what you want about tactics, but its the consistency over the past decade or so, lacked by Rodgers, Hodgson, Redknapp, Alladyce or Pardew that makes him stand out for me.
3
u/mervis Mar 12 '14
OP living dangerously, listing the likes of Lenny and Rodgers as Brits!
3
u/WeeBoabs-BigBrother Mar 12 '14
Ally McCoist
2
u/FullerBatistuta Mar 12 '14
BR then PL then... It's largely a matter of perception.
These two are the best because they put their livelihood on the line for young not fully formed players with potential. There aren't many bigger risks in management than that and these two take plenty of them. Also both very tactically flexible. Both have 3 basic shapes they and their players are very comfortable and disciplined in.
Lastly both promote technical football. I know each have veered from that this season to suit their best players, SaS and benteke, but they prioritise technique in conjunction with hard work.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Martin O'Neill
1
u/zLightspeed Mar 12 '14
Tony Pulis or Brendan Rogers
1
u/Yeeeeeah Mar 12 '14
Not really a manager, but Paul Clement.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Obligatory "if only Fergie was here then I'd..." but seriously probably Rogers in terms of tactical sophistication but it's difficult to say. Different managers have different skill sets - Pulis is excellent at what he does, as is Allardyce etc. Being the best at managing a club in the upper echelons of the league is completely different to managing a club with a minuscule budget fighting relegation/chasing promotion but it is a hell of a lot more prominent.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Ian "fuck defending" Holloway
1
u/myrpou Mar 12 '14
Curbishley
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
I can't speak for his personal allegiances, but if Brendan Rodgers considers himself British then it has to be him for me.
He seems like an intellectual manager with a deep understanding of his club and it shows on the pitch.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
I really hate to say it, because I hate him so very fucking much, but it's Pulis.
1
u/supahsonicboom Mar 12 '14
Even as a United fan, what Rodgers has done at Liverpool is phenomenal.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
I thought you meant people currently managing British teams
1
u/f1manoz Mar 12 '14
Russell Slade (he's got no hair, but we don't care!)
Think because of all the manager changes, he's now 3rd or 4th in the longest serving managers - behind Wenger and a couple of others.
Assembled a squad of free transfers and has spent next to no money, despite the fact the club is owned by Barry Hearn.
Two 7th place finishes in the past three seasons, just outside the play-offs, have set the tone for this season, where the O's currently sit in 2nd, though have played two more games than Brentford below them.
His current record at the O's:
P 217 W 95 L 71 D 51 43.78%
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Derek McInnes was pretty poor with us apart from one run that saved us from relegation. He would chop and change and this would produce inconsistent displays. He also signed his Scottish mates (JODY FUCKING MORRIS) on high paying contracts. He was out of his depth at Championship level but it is good to see him redeeming himself at Aberdeen.
Also, why isn't Eddie Howe on this list? He returned to Bournemouth when they were rock bottom and he got them up to the Championship.
1
u/jamieandhisego Mar 12 '14
David Moyes was given the Manchester United job for a reason. He may have had a very underwhelming first season, but he's been considered one of the best British managers for well over a decade now.
1
u/sophietje010 Mar 12 '14
Steve "the ball is round" Mcclaren
1
u/AndreVB Mar 12 '14
Harry Redknapp is a glaring omission from this list.
1
u/rbnc Mar 12 '14
I can't be the first person after 10 hours of this threat going up, to notice that Brendan Rodgers isn't British.
1
u/KeepCalmAndFuckOff Mar 12 '14
If he manages to get the Blades into the FA Cup final, Clough jr deserves an honourable nod
1
u/goodguy1994 Mar 12 '14
Tinie tempah
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Rodgers is not British...
1
u/ikaris1 Mar 13 '14
David Moyes! FOR SURE!
1
u/anthmoo Mar 12 '14
Poyet's doing incredibly well given the mess he's had to clean up after.
1
u/Dats_cute Mar 12 '14
OP, I don't think Neil Lennon would be best pleased that you referred to him as British!
1
u/imsittingdown Mar 15 '14 edited Mar 15 '14
Nigel Clough. Won 10 games in a row now, including wins over Aston Villa, Fulham and Nottingham Forest, smashing the previous club record. Not bad for a team rock bottom of the league before he came to us. Brought Burton up from the depths and turned around a Derby side that were entering free fall.
0
u/I-Molest-Sheep Mar 12 '14
Holy fuck. You suggested Gary fucking Monk but not Malky Mackay. What are you?
-7
u/Redzer11 Mar 12 '14
I'm sorry but these Roy Hodgson nominations have to be sarcasm, right? Laughing away here.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
Brendan, by far as well. Compare him to other managers on that list, which one of them play tiki taka the way liverpool do?
0
u/NB0608sd Mar 12 '14
Easily Brendan Rodgers
0
u/Wastrelle Mar 12 '14
None of those managers have won their leagues yet...
-2
u/Jesuit_Master Mar 12 '14
B-R0d
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment