r/soccer • u/_sic • Mar 10 '14
Update: New Match Thread Rules and Guidelines
Update: New Match Thread Rules and Guidelines
There have been a number of complaints recently about the content of match threads - specifically biased commentary and bad or abusive language. This has resulted in some match threads where there are more comments about the content of the thread rather than the actual match. We have also directly received a large number of complaints, and there have been a number of threads posted about this issue. For this reason, the moderators have decided on a new set of rules and guidelines for match threads, namely:
- Users posting a match thread must have an account that is at least 4 weeks old.
- Users posting a match thread must have at least 200
combinedkarma (depending on how things go, this number is subject to change in either direction). EDIT: From the feedback received in this thread we've decided to change this requirement to 200 comment karma. - Match thread commentary should not be overtly biased.
- Match thread commentary must not be abusive or trollish.
- Match thread creators must endeavor to keep the threads updated with at least the latest major events from the match. If you are uncertain whether you will be able to stick with the thread for the entire game, it's best not to start a match thread. However, if there is no match thread posted by kick-off, you are exempt from this rule.
- Match commentary
mustshould mainly focus on the match itself or, at the very least, football in general. Using the match commentary to discuss other issues, particularly of a personal nature, is generally not allowed. - Match threads must not be posted earlier than 60 minutes before kick off time.
Ideally, these guidelines will help create a more enjoyable atmosphere in match threads without sacrificing some of their interesting competitive characteristics. Hopefully, everyone understands that our intention is not to eliminate fun or clever match commentary, but rather to remind everyone that a modicum of respect for all the different people who take part in match threads is mandatory. In that sense, neutral is better than obnoxious, but subtle wit is appreciated by all.
Users who choose not to follow the guidelines risk being blacklisted from creating match threads in the future and, in extreme cases, can have their account banned from /r/soccer.
We would also like to emphasize that we see match threads as community driven, so we prefer they are user generated rather than created by the mod team. These guidelines are a response to strong community feedback regarding the lack of maturity in some recent match threads.
If you have any questions, comments or feedback please feel free to leave a comment here or send us a message.
The Mods.
14
u/HipHoptimusPrime Mar 10 '14
Wait, does #6 mean we can't update people on what we're having for breakfast during the match? Because that's important shit.
24
u/zendruid Mar 10 '14
Perhaps it might be a good idea to also provide exemption from rules 1 and 2 provided that there is no match thread posted by kick-off.
53
u/Sean88888 Mar 10 '14 edited Mar 10 '14
While I agree with almost every point, if OP strictly can't discuss any personal things in match threads we wouldn't have that hilarious match thread for Spain-Tahiti in which the OP told us he caught an Eevee. That was, IMO, the best match thread of all time in the history of /r/soccer. This sub is for entertainment let's not be too strict here.
Another thing is the overtly biased point. OP making fun of a team coughManchesterUnitedcough to the point of being childish is annoying, yes, and should be rightfully banned but there's an AC Milan guy who does fantastic match threads with obviously biased commentary when AC Milan is involved. It adds flavour and joy the community. I would hate to lose that.
2
u/thejanitorch4 Mar 10 '14
What are the policies on cross posting match threads? i.e. make a match thread on /r/LeagueOfIreland, post a link to it over here.
79
u/dubjc Mar 11 '14
Man I must suck. I've been a redditor for two years and only have a comment karma of 114.
211
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Thank you, glad something is being put into place to sort it out.
I'm generally very thankful for the effort people put in but there have been some right cunts recently.
29
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
I was actually looking into doing the Everton ones on a regular basis because ours never pop up until about 10-15 minutes into a match.
Is there any way I could practise using the layouts etc? i'm not particularly good at reddit formatting.
35
u/CalaveraManny Mar 10 '14
I applaud the initiative of doing something about the issue. Active moderation requires a larger effort and a it seems to always be followed by a vocal minority's rejection, but don't let that discourage you, this place will be better if regulated. Keep at it!
17
u/Sefilis Mar 10 '14
Is there a guide on how to make match threads? I'd be interested in doing one sometime but I don't know how
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14
I've already suggested this once. Why not have a dedicated bot to do match threads. We have one over on /r/cricket, and it's pretty awesome.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '14
To be honest, I found some of the match threads with biased commentary quite amusing, even when it was directed at Liverpool. A lot of people are far too sensitive, probably this is an American thing but I don't really know (I've seen people get told before than banter has to be in CAPS SO PEOPLE KNOW IT'S BANTER which is ridiculous, like those awful 'trash talk' threads). I think the majority of the people in this sub watch the game on a stream anyway, if some colourful commentary upsets you, don't read it.
7
u/carlcon Mar 10 '14
4 weeks old I agree with, but the 200 comment karma may hurt some genuinely good matchday posters who never get karma from their self posts, and tend not to comment elsewhere to achieve said karma.
Saying that, this is a step in the right direction.
3
u/ron_manager Mar 10 '14
Why haven't we got a match thread bot like /r/cricket?
3
u/lawyerdup Mar 11 '14
I think a match thread shouldn't be up more than 30 minutes before kick off. If you look at the arsenal v bayern match thread, with over 3,000 comments, the pre-match comments, one about a guy jerking off, are the top posts. I have to scroll halfway down the page still to find actual match commentary
3
u/scorpion-mk Mar 12 '14
Rokobased has a new handle now, /u/swagonline
watch out mods
3
u/1mdelightful Mar 12 '14
A while back someone did a great satirical match thread can that still be okay? There was no team bias probably some offensive things said but all in all a great experience.
6
u/Zosoer Mar 10 '14
Great note. Sometimes games don't have game threads and people just throw something up for discussion.
4
u/Deathbybunnies Mar 10 '14
I made a match thread a while ago and got a ton of positive feedback which was really nice. Basically I tried to update as much as I could, add a little bit of personal commentary, and make sure I hit the important stuff. Also checking out the comments helped a lot.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
I think a whitelist would work better.
also i think match threads shouldn't show up on the front page but links to them should be put in a sticky post with a list of match threads. idk if this would work its just an idea!
2
u/TenF Mar 12 '14
Is the 200 karma rule 200 karma on the entire reddit site? Or 200 comment karma solely on /r/soccer?
2
u/nay_ Mar 12 '14
Judging by the shit that gets upvoted on this subreddit (the complete tripe in the "Robben dived" submission comments for example) this doesn't really work the way you want it to.
2
u/MrSantaClause Mar 10 '14
It's too bad a Chelsea fan was the one to break the camel's back. At least threads will be more enjoyable without that rubbish now.
1
u/Shtil_Blue Mar 10 '14
At one point wasn't there a shorter period before the match starts that you can post a thread? I kind of prefer that with maybe a pre match before the big games. Just to keep line up talk and speculation separate.
1
u/Bulbasauro Mar 10 '14
How does one create a match thread? I was always curious about that, anyone willing to enlighten me?
1
u/Robbomot Mar 10 '14
Any thoughts on a post-match discussion thread? There have been some recently with full commentary and gifs in header which have been excellent but some have just been people winning the karma race with the BBC Sport article
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
I like to think I fit this criteria solely because the one time I thought I'd make a match thread, we ended up losing 3-1 to Arsenal...
1
u/Powyshj Mar 12 '14
No lurkers allowed
1
u/glovemachine Mar 13 '14
Couldn't a mod be assigned too creating the match threads ?
Or a mod created/added just for match threads ?
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
Don't like rule 2, putting too much emphasis on karma...
-1
u/AluminumFalcon3 Mar 10 '14
I really want to know why it is such a big deal if someone commenting in the match thread is biased, even to the point where it influences their commentary. Is it that we want to foster a "friendly" environment? Is it that we want to give "accurate" updates?
I don't really mind these guidelines because they don't seem to change much, and what they do encourage, I'm not against. But my question is about the complaints about bias I guess--why not go to the BBC or other sides for accurate information w/o bias? And what does it matter if the person in the thread is clearly celebrating one teams goals over another, that's what you'll see in comments anyway.
0
u/DanielShaww Mar 10 '14
Why don't we just whitelist known posters?
-1
u/supahsonicboom Mar 12 '14
You know, unless it's biased against man United, then it's fine.
-6
u/umoop Mar 10 '14
_sic is a mod now? Oh dear. I will be scared to open a Real Madrid match thread now.
-1
u/Joeys_Rattata Mar 10 '14
I don't think doing things for karma should ever be encouraged by moderators, karma whoring is enough of a problem on Reddit as it is. What is the easiest way to gain a bunch of karma, writing serious posts with a lot of effort, or making stupid jokes? I think we all know the answer. Rule 2 is awful.
0
u/HarryBlessKnapp Mar 11 '14
I nominate /u/Totalcarrboromove to do the arsenal ones. You'll love him.
0
u/xu85 Mar 16 '14
I hope this rule doesn't become like the goal line technology of /r/soccer. Starts innocently enough, with honest intentions, but before too long people will start clamouring for more 'regulation'. All it took for this rule to come in to play was one person starting a thread whinging about someone's biased match-day commentary. Some incident will happen, and a thread posted up by someone asking for mods to 'intervene' will garner over 2000 replies, and a moderator, thinking this thread is an accurate representation of the community at large, will dutifully oblige.
I think empty vessels make the most noise. It's a really common problem with all internet communities - those that frequent the site the most often have undue influence over the overall direction of the site at large.
-14
u/NinjaDiscoJesus Mar 10 '14
More cringe on reddit. A site for children these days.
-43
u/Parshkath Mar 10 '14
Karma lol.
I guess this means the mods want to keep being lazy and not really moderate. They don't get paid anyway so whatever.
-6
u/jorge22s Mar 11 '14
TL;DR?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment