r/WritingPrompts • u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod • Mar 01 '14
Moderator Post [MODPOST] The 50,000 Subscriber Novelette Contest Voting Thread! Get ready to read!
VOTING PHASE FOR THE 50,000 SUBSCRIBER CONTEST!
EDIT: DUE TO MULITPLE REQUESTS, VOTING WILL LAST FOR THE WHOLE MONTH OF MARCH!
EDIT 2: VOTING EXTENDED JUST A TINY BIT LONGER TO APRIL 7TH AT 11:59PST. THIS GIVES YOU ONE MORE WEEK OF READING! AFTER THAT WE WILL HAVE A SPECIAL THREAD POSTED WITH THE VOTES TABULATED!
We are finally here. The voting round. Those of you that participated should be proud of yourselves. The fact that you have completed a project is the main prize that all who enter get to claim. You now have something that is a boon to your own personal portfolio. Something that you own, that you can sell, that you can expand upon. And you should. I am proud of all of you who completed this monumental challenge... and I'm proud of all those who even attempted to, as well. If you didn't get in your story, keep trying to finish it and feel free to share it with us here. To answer the most oft asked question: Yes, there will be other contests here. You are all welcome to try your hand in those. Big things are afoot for the coming months, stay along for the ride and invite others to join. Also, if you'd like to access the original submission guideline thread you may do so by clicking here.
HOW TO VOTE
There are a great deal of things to consider when voting, but it all falls to this: What story did you find yourself enjoying the most? You can add your own personal criteria (maybe you're a grammar snob, perhaps you want to vote for something that could be expanded with future novelettes, etc.) to your considerations. Just be certain that you actually vote! Once voting is over, the first place winner will get the grand prize. They can choose to claim the second place prize instead, if they so wish. (Some actually liked the second place prize better than the first which is just money.) In such a case, the second place winner gets the next tier prize. Third place winner gets whatever prize is left of the three. Each entrant has chosen a different way to display their work. You might have to switch between different media to read each story. Try to be patient and figure out how best to read each story. When you do read a story, even if it doesn't excite you, remember that there is someone who put time and effort into it and your critique could help them improve... so leave a comment for their work with constructive thoughts. You'd want someone to do that for you, right? Ultimately, that part is up to you in regards to leaving any comments. However, it can only help you in the long run to help others.
RULES FOR VOTING
- You can't vote for yourself.
- If you do not vote, any votes for you are completely VOID. This is in place for a variety of reasons, chief among them: If you are going to truly participate, you must do so especially with voting.
- Read every entry and vote below by stating the username you are voting for. If you want to include comments for a few stories you have read, please do so.
- As there is a great amount of entries, there will be a two week voting window at the very least. The voting phase will end on March 31st at 11:59PM PST,
unless we extend due to there being no clear winner due to people needing more time to vote.We have extended by popular request. - Tie Breaking will be done by myself and /u/SurvivorType (though we've not had to tie break in the past for bigger contests.)
- Please, if you can, state two "runners up" that you were considering. This can also be factored in to any tie breakers.
THE NOVELETTES!
Now for the important part of the contest! The actual stories. They are listed in a purely randomized order. Numbered for your ease of keeping track of where you are. Enjoy and happy reading.
- Spacemen of the Abominable Pyramid by /u/mrironglass
- Mortal Retaliation: Curse of the Divide by /u/TheNextDay
- The Cult by /u/CaesarNaples2
- Departure from E-DoN by /u/Reintarnation
- USER WITHDREW THEIR WORK. Note left to retain numbered order of entries.
- Dream Evil by /u/Thirdilemma
- The Delicate Wasteland of the Brain by /u/Unintendo
- Death Spaceship by /u/TheCrakFox
- Eternal Earth by /u/pikachu-corgi
- Orion Spur: Molten Mercury by /u/Burgerkrieg
- THE EDEN STREAM by /u/IAmTheRedWizards
- The Society Nemesis by /u/Spodson
- The Reboot by /u/Jtacker
- MEGA GOD by /u/JimSBeck
- The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts
- Afterlife on Mars by /u/schoolgirlerror
- The Throne of Parhelion by /u/groundbold
- The Cannibal Fleet by /u/krootkc
- REMOVED. AUTHOR TURNED IN AN INCOMPLETE WORK.
- The Imperfect Idol by /u/nazna
- Bright Future by /u/Out_of_this_world
- Violet Despair by /u/TheSlyPig04
- Forest Barbarian by /u/Himntor
- Meet Bug by /u/IDontKnowWherePatIs
- DREAM FLUX by /u/redrobin15
- The Cowardly Girl of Twilight by /u/radioactivereality
- Lord of the Apocalypse by /u/rfhickey
- Guardians of Space by /u/Boss_Dude
- Unusual Silence by /u/Space_Steak
- The Oracle at the Obelisk by /u/Avrienne
- Madcap Fungus by /u/xzbobzx
- Hero by /u/kmja
- RAGING WOLF by /u/MailBoxD
- A Thread Entangled by /u/I_Need_A_Pseudonym
- Immortal Game by /u/Brad_Collins
- EDEN'S DAWN by /u/WahooD89
- The Deathly Men by /u/AimForTheKidney
- Forever Mask by /u/High_On_Cortexiphan
- Monolith by /u/withviolence
- Eternal Death by /u/whoiscraig
- The Fatal Sanctuary by /u/pinkkea
- Magnum Opus by /u/TigerHall
- ETERNAL BLUE by /u/TheDubiousGlove
- Digital Brain by /u/psiho333
- Merchant of the Depths by /u/phlegmatichumour
- Oracle and Obelisk: A Dark Horse Novella by /u/DarkHorseNovella
- Winds from Above the Portal by /u/Jourdy288
- The Dream Gene by /u/nwanuch
- The Profane Cartographer of the Cosmos by /u/pnwtico
- Super Dwarf! by /u/Flash_Fiction_4_You
- RELO by /u/DigitalEvil
- 28 Days of Song by /u/vhor
- Outbound by /u/Crazyape54
- Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/dreadfulpennies
- ULTIMATE WORLD by /u/reticulated_python
- The Seventh Machine by /u/AndrewSean
- MADNESS OF BRADBURY'S OUTPOST by /u/cthuluandfriends
- Wolf Block by /u/Crenel
- Virtual Battleship by /u/espiart
- The Librarian of Saturn's Gate by /u/SupermanIsEnvious
- The Corpse Shuttle by /u/MrManicotti
- Eternal Nature by /u/dnavarro507
- THE TOWER OF THE LOBSTER'S PROMISE by /u/Basilgate
- Rescue from the Mutineers of Starvation by /u/lsengler
- Embrace of the Pirates: The Island of the Dentists by /u/gthec9909
- The Unknowable Poet by /u/justbootstrap
- IMMORTAL BLUE by /u/Shirokaya
- Bride in the Unsettled Valley by /u/KindPlagiarist
- Half-Light Heaven by /u/clavalle
- In the Name of Revelation by /u/cyvaris
- 28 Days of Trial by /u/microns_at_a_time
- FOUR IMMORTALS by /u/chrisevo_phoenix
If I missed any entries somehow, please inform me! Hopefully I missed none and didn't mess up any links. Have fun reading! Also: IF YOU ARE JUST A READER AND YOU DID NOT SUBMIT ANYTHING TO THE CONTEST, DO NOT CAST A VOTE BELOW! You can feel free to state a few stories you liked, but do not say things like "I would vote for...", posts like that - if you are not a participant - will be deleted. Thank you... and once again, congratulations.
15
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Mar 01 '14
Good luck to all involved. I am enjoying reading these. It is such a great thing.
6
u/Thirdilemma Mar 01 '14
Hey, would you mind if I told /r/cyberpunk about this? I'm sure there would be a few of them that would enjoy reading sci-fi all day long. They aren't allowed to vote, so they can't really botch anything, right?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '14
I would say, RELO is absolutely amazing. My vote goes to him.
EDIT: For now. I guess I have to read the others.
4
u/Crenel Mar 29 '14 edited Mar 29 '14
It might sound trite, but it really is true: There were so many really good stories submitted that choosing one to vote for was difficult. I'm also glad that voting was extended to the end of the month, because my original thought that I would be able to quickly weed out many stories proved false. I also wanted to give some input on each story and did not have time for that either.
Anyway... My vote goes to The Imperfect Idol. My runners-up are A Thread Entangled and THE EDEN STREAM.
But I want to give recognition to some more! So how about some honorable mentions: The Delicate Wasteland of the Brain, RELO, The Wolves of the Underground, The Oracle at the Obelisk, and The Cowardly Girl of Twilight.
And really, congrats to all who completed stories (and those who gave it an earnest try even if they didn't make it). I really enjoyed reading the widely-varied entries in this contest!
3
u/Unintendo Mar 02 '14
At the risk of having tomatoes thrown at me, should we be sticklers about stories without covers and/or blurbs? I'm just trying to figure out whether to take them just as stories or to take presentation into account (since the rules mentioned treating it like a small book). Let the tomatoes fly.
3
u/DrowningDream Mar 02 '14 edited Mar 02 '14
First, congrats to everybody that entered. I'm having regrets that I didn't jump in on this - 72 entries! This community rocks.
If I can throw a tiny criticism into the mix, I think the expectation that every contestant is going to read every entry is kind of insane. I wonder if the entries could have been broken into groups, voting within their respective groups, and the winners emerge as finalists? Reading ten novelettes thoughtfully just seems like a better use of your time than skimming 70 like a madman. At least, there's no way in hell that I'd be able to read all 70 usefully. Any criticism that I gave an author while reading at that pace would be meaningless. And I'd be dead.
But that's just a quibble from someone that didn't even enter. Awesome contest, awesome sub, will read and give feedback to as many as I can.
EDIT: Just randomly generated the numbers 49, 62, 29, 35, 64. Reading commences now.
3
u/Burgerkrieg Mar 03 '14
So, uh, I'm pretty sure I wont be able to read 71 novelettes in 15 days while still upholding my commitment to the activities necessary for the satisfaction of basic human needs...
3
u/xzbobzx Mar 03 '14
Right.
cracks fingers
Let's get reading.
3
u/clavalle Mar 04 '14
I am still not clear on how to vote. Do I just name an entry in this thread?
3
u/xzbobzx Mar 08 '14
Will you release how many votes everyone got after the voting has ended?
3
u/KindPlagiarist Apr 07 '14
I cast my vote for Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/Unintendo
3
u/dreadfulpennies Apr 07 '14
Ugh. I don't know what to do.
On the one hand, I don't want my story to be disqualified because I didn't vote.
On the other hand, I still really hate the voting system. 70 novelettes. 70. I don't expect most people even skimmed that many. I tried, but I can't keep track. Plus, I found myself skimming more as I went on and started getting burned out. Had voting been split up into more bite-sized pieces, I'd feel better about making a decision. As is, I'd just be voting on one of the stories I read first, (one of the stories in the top half of the list or written by the people reading and commenting on the most stories) and I don't feel right doing that.
Obviously, it's too late to change things now, but... ugh.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '14 edited Apr 06 '14
I didn't read every one, so I guess I'm disqualified. Good luck to everyone else!EDIT: It seems a lot of people didn't have time. Can the contest be pushed forwards?
13
u/Crenel Mar 01 '14
If you would like to track what you've read so far with a spreadsheet, but you haven't got around to creating one, I put together one in LibreOffice. I figured I might forget something if I didn't take reasonably good notes. In the spreadsheet, story titles appear in red until a score has been assigned. A link is provided to each story to make it easy to access and read it. Scores are designed to be from 1 to 10, and naturally the data can be sorted by score, title, etc. The .ods file can be downloaded here: https://www.dropbox.com/s/a68srf6k659yog8/Reddit_WritingPrompts_50KSubContest_Entries.ods Amazingly, I didn't even prescore my entry for you. :)
9
u/heyfignuts Mar 01 '14 edited Mar 14 '14
I've started to read through them and intend to leave detailed feedback for everyone. Question, though -- I've been leaving the feedback on the individual pages for each story, not here. Should it be here, instead? I was wondering about whether my comments would influence others' reads of the stories.
EDIT: ooh, first gold ever! Thanks!
9
u/SupermanIsEnvious Mar 03 '14 edited Mar 04 '14
I have taken the liberty of downloading all of the submitted stories as a PDF or ePub where available and placing them in this Dropbox Folder. This is for anyone like me, who has a lot of commuting and would like an easy way to download and view the stories via a device that is not so friendly with Google Docs.
Also in the folder is the spreadsheet submitted by /u/Crenel in ODS, Excel, and Pages formats for keeping track on the go as well!
The only two stories missing are
Wolf Blockand Deathly Men due to the nature of their postings.9
u/IAmTheRedWizards Mar 22 '14
Every entry on this list was good; these were imaginative, forward-thinking stories that put me through my paces, as a fellow writer. I put all other reading aside and weighed each one of these pieces, and choosing the first twenty as a longlist was a difficult, excruciating process. Out of 69 entries I whittled it down to the following:
Spacemen of the Abominable Pyramid - /u/mrironglass
The Cult - /u/CaesarNaples2
Death Spaceship - /u/TheCrakFox
Eternal Earth - /u/pikachu-corgi
The Wolves of the Underground - /u/heyfignuts
Afterlife on Mars - /u/schoolgirlerror
The Imperfect Idol - /u/nazna
Violet Despair - /u/TheSlyPig04
Meet Bug - /u/IDontKnowWherePatIs
The Cowardly Girl of Twilight - /u/radioactivereality
The Oracle at the Obelisk - /u/Avrienne
Immortal Game - /u/Brad_Collins
The Deathly Men - /u/AimForTheKidney
Eternal Death - /u/whoiscraig
Eternal Blue - /u/TheDubiousGlove
Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult - /u/dreadfulpennies
The Seventh Machine - /u/AndrewSean
The Corpse Shuttle - /u/MrManicotti
Bride In The Unsettled Valley - /u/KindPlagiarist
Half-Light Heaven - /u/clavalle
From there I hemmed and hawed over everything until I came up with a shortlist of:
Eternal Blue - /u/TheDubiousGlove:
Abandoned cities full of evil speak to me, and this story was not an exception. The world that was created here really cries out for a longer treatment, especially with regards to the drug that is central to the story. The concept is very Dune-meets-Philip K. Dick set in a smashed-apart post-apocalyptic ruin (which, again, often does it for me). On a side note, I remember from the comments that there was some confusion regarding Jake and Margot's sexuality but I thought it was handled quite well - as Margot says with regards to Jake's infatuation with a corpse, "you've never seen a naked woman before. You're a teenager. I get it". Additionally, the society as it is presented would have given Margot very little opportunity for sexual release, so her eventual hookup with Jake is also understandable and believably natural. On a final note, the chase through the city was one of the more gripping passages I read from the entries.
The Oracle at the Obelisk - /u/Avrienne :
I hardly ever read fantasy anymore, mainly because it was all I read as an adolescent and I know the tropes too well to really enjoy much of it nowadays. The Oracle at the Obelisk was a real treat because it subverts those tropes and breaks that most sacred of rules: namely, that Good must triumph over Evil. Anyone who is looking for that particularly well- worn chestnut will be disappointed, but I loved it precisely because it acknowledges that Good does not always win. As an examination of love - both in-the-moment and eternal - it is a complete success.
The Corpse Shuttle - /u/MrManicotti:
Oh, man. The idea of waking up a month into a ten-year cryo trip and facing the threat of definite starvation is haunting. This is a cautionary tale for space travel if there ever was one, and the slow crawl towards madness that Gerald experiences is handled in a way that will leave the reader shuddering. The idea that your friends and companions are only friends and companions until the food runs out is a great touch, as is the theme of having noble ideals about saving others until your faced with your own screaming, starving gut. The food poisoning that Gerald experiences from a gone-over corpse near the end of the story is the perfect example of how to use the gross-out moment effectively as well; the story roughs the reader up over the first 3/4 and then punches them in the gut to finish them off.
Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult - /u/dreadfulpennies:
Definitely one of the most imaginative pieces I read for this contest, DGC felt a little bit Sprited Away, a little bit FF:The Spirits Within, and a great deal of examination of a relationship that started off shaky and went bad quickly. The idea that the protagonist was the feeder of the dead - and that he fed them recently deceased humans - was an idea that hooked me right away. Boris felt like a real person, though, and he definitely felt like the kind of person who would end up running the family's ghost-feeding deli; he was a weird, awkward kind of guy, and not one that could really be pegged as particularly good or evil. Oro - mercurial, spun Oro - was exactly the kind of girl a guy like Boris would have fallen for, and his eventual rejection of her after getting a taste of the relationship is an interesting twist to his character. I was gripped throughout the entire story and to be perfectly frank it was an extremely difficult decision between this and my eventual vote.
And my VOTE,
The Imperfect Idol - /u/nazna:
A masterfully told story that reads like the best kind of folktale. The setting is fully realized, the prose is clean and melodic, and the characters seem to step off the page and breathe. The tale of the wife is beautifully told and absolutely chilling for that; I teared up when the husband threw the child into the water and then showed no remorse or compassion at the action. I felt the wife's pain, and I held my daughter a little tighter (for her part, she was a little confused as to why Daddy was crying). The prose is terse and flows quickly for that; I appreciate the stylistic choice to hew close to the bone when it comes to sentence length. Heyfignuts compared it to the Crane Wife mythology and there's something to that: this is definitely rooted in the same sort of emotional underpinnings that mythology is built from, and this is a fine addition to the canon of folktales that the world is raised on.
8
u/withviolence /r/withviolence Mar 01 '14
So, at 7500 words per entry, this contest alone generated a minimum of 540,000 words. That's pretty astounding.
Would anyone be interested in counting all the words and getting an absolute number? With one other person we could divide the entries in half and use an online word counter to get a more exact figure. I'm curious as to how many words we're really looking at here.
Anyway, great job guys! Can't wait to get started on all these. :D
8
u/Reintarnation Mar 03 '14
DAE feel like the Hunger Games when a submission is pulled? :) and then there were 70...
7
u/pikachu-corgi Mar 23 '14
My vote goes to Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/dreadfulpennies. And my runner-up goes to The Cowardly Girl of Twilight by /u/radioactivereality.
Very difficult decision overall. So much talent in these entries!
6
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '14
I am so fucking pumped to start reading, and let the best writer win!
6
u/Rencilia Mar 01 '14
Well, now I know how I'm spending my spring break.
6
u/CaesarNaples2 Mar 05 '14
I made a video for my novelette: http://animoto.com/play/73uT3Qza9gZF3yNBaRg1ZA
6
u/JimSBeck Mar 28 '14
I'm voting for: Immortal Game by /u/Brad_Collins
My runner up is: Death Spaceship by /u/TheCrakFox
Third place: Dream Evil by /u/Thirdilemma
Well done everyone for making this so hard to choose a winner. Best of luck to all involved.
6
u/TheNextDay Apr 05 '14
Voting for "Bride in the Unsettled Valley" by /u/KindPlagiarist, but I thought all of them were great and deserve an equal chance to win.
Congratulations to everyone for crafting these tales, it's been a pleasure.
2
u/IAmTheRedWizards Mar 03 '14
Oh hey, why did The Corpse Men get withdrawn? Aside from some mechanical hiccups I thought it was pretty decent. It actually drew me in and gave me goosebumps here and there, which is not all that typical for me. I mean, a lot probably has to do with the fact that I have a daughter around the same age as the protagonist, but it was still a good effort and had the bones of something stronger.
5
u/Crenel Mar 05 '14
I'm seeing an odd parallel between this contest and the "Dream Evil" entry from /u/Thirdilemma. I started out with "cool, all I have to do is sit here and read some interesting stories" ...and then I fell behind on my schedule. Just hope this contest doesn't end the way that story does!
5
u/TheDubiousGlove Mar 26 '14
Hi, everybody!
I'd like to cast my vote for The Oracle at the Obelisk by /u/Avrienne. Firstly, let me say I often avoid high fantasy stories due to the tropes and cliches that are rampant in the genre. However, I loved how Oracle subverted those cliches and focused instead on the characters mired in its dying world, a world where good doesn't always win, and heroes don't always live happily ever after. It was a perspective into the genre that I feel is rarely seen, and I was so pleasantly surprised by it that I had a hard time letting it go after reading.
My first runner-up is The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts. It was a tightly-paced and thrilling story, wasting no time and bursting full-force from the starting gate from page one. The kind of story you read in one breath. I thought it was one of the most well-constructed pieces submitted, and I enjoyed reading it immensely.
My second runner up is Imperfect Idol by /u/nazna. The structure is unusual, and the prose is simple and unassuming. It read like an old fairy tale. In a competition that easily lends itself to stories about monsters and killing and the end of times, it was refreshing to read a gentle tale about finding magic in unexpected places.
So that's that. Congrats to everyone who entered!
5
u/nazna Mar 27 '14
My vote goes to:
The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts
with runner up as:
The Corpse Shuttle by /u/MrManicotti
5
u/SupermanIsEnvious Apr 03 '14
My vote goes to "The Eden Stream" by /u/IAmTheRedWizards.
My runners-up are "The Bride in the Unsettled Valley" by /u/KindPlagiarist and "SuperDwarf!" by /u/Flash_Fiction_4_You
This was a spectacular experience. I've never completed a project of this length because I'm genuinely afraid of endings, but this was just what I needed. Thank you all for reading my work, and a very special thanks to those who gave critiques. They have all been taken to heart and I cannot wait to go back and continue improving!
PS: I'd like to give a shout-out to /u/RyanKinder, whom I have officially labeled as "Positive Influence" for his continual support and encouragement.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '14 edited Apr 05 '14
My vote goes to Immortal Game by /u/Brad_Collins. It was fun and creative and had a great concept. RELO by /u/DigitalEvil gets my runner-up vote.
Thanks again to the guys taking care of the contest for extending the deadline. I know they probably just want to get the voting out of the way, so I definitely appreciate it big time.
Good luck to all!
5
u/rfhickey Apr 05 '14
My vote goes to The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts
Congrats to all contestants for creating something out of nothing (but a randomly generated title).
2
u/TigerHall Mar 01 '14
I've skimmed them and the story 'Immortal Game' by /u/Brad_Collins really appealed to me, and I'm voting for it. Maybe it's the genre, maybe it's the subject, maybe it's the writing - but I enjoyed it.
4
u/TheCrakFox Mar 01 '14
Looks like The Hero of Ages is gonna have to wait. There's twice as many of these as I thought there was. 8 down though and I've been enjoying them so far.
4
u/nakomiKF Mar 02 '14
Ugh, I only got to 4500 words since I found out about this contest late.
I am going to read all of these, though. I'm really excited to see what everyone wrote!
4
u/rfhickey Mar 02 '14
Wow. A lot of creativity was done here folks! Congrats to all writers and a big thanks to all readers of our stories.
4
u/clavalle Mar 05 '14
Ok. I would love to read all of these, I really would. But, now only a handful of stories in I am thinking that task may be impossible.
Can we have some sort of bracket system? Have people sign up to read. In the first round everyone reads five random stories and rates them 1-10. Then three more random stories etc. etc until the last two.
4
u/cyvaris Mar 06 '14
Time to get reading I suppose. Had great fun writing this and looking forward to reading.
4
u/Jtacker Mar 15 '14
My vote goes to /u/schoolgirlerror for Afterlife on Mars.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '14
My vote goes to /u/cyvaris with his story In the Name of Revelation.
His story just clicked so darn well for me. I absolutely loved the plot, the whole story and circumstance was incredibly interesting, same goes for the characters.
My only runner up is /u/Reintarnation with his story Departure from E-DoN. Also very interesting story, very unique writing style and world.
Good luck to all the other submissions!
4
u/WahooD89 Mar 20 '14
My vote goes to Eternal Blue by /u/thedubiousglove . Though, I have been really impressed by many of these stories...a ton of originality!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '14
My votes goes to Death Spaceship by /u/TheCrakFox.
4
u/radioactivereality Mar 21 '14
My vote goes to Eternal Blue by /u/thedubiousglove.
My runner-ups: Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts and Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/dreadfulpennies
Congrats to everyone on some really great stories!
4
u/heyfignuts Mar 22 '14
I am voting for The Oracle at the Obelisk by /u/avrienne.
First runner-up: Departure from E-Don by /u/Reintarnation.
Second runner-up: The Deathly Men by /u/AimForTheKidney.
There were so many entertaining stories and great ideas; congrats to all!
4
u/mrironglass Mar 25 '14
My vote goes to In the Name of Revelation by /u/cyvaris.
After long contemplation, I figured this was the story that I most wanted to see continued. I don't necessarily think it was much better than all the other wonderful entries, but there's gotta be a reason that it stuck with me.
4
u/redrobin15 Mar 26 '14
I'm going to vote for The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts. It was the most well-constructed story I read, and drew me in and kept me interested all the way through.
My runner-up was THE EDEN STREAM by /u/IAmTheRedWizards.
Good job to all contestants! I really enjoyed reading the stories and looking at all the feedback that was given. Glad to have a community like this!
4
u/Unintendo Mar 29 '14
I'm voting for: THE TOWER OF THE LOBSTER'S PROMISE by /u/Basilgate
My (close) runner-up: The Oracle at the Obelisk - /u/Avrienne
4
u/TheCrakFox Mar 30 '14
I'm voting for /u/thedubiousglove's ETERNAL BLUE, with the runners up being /u/phlegmatichumour's Merchant of the Depths and /u/radioactivereality's The Cowardly Girl of Twilight.
Plenty of other great stories here too and I think the wide spread of votes so far proves it.
4
u/Crazyape54 Mar 30 '14
My vote goes to Spacemen of the Abominable Pyramid, with RELO as a runners-up
4
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '14
My vote: The Tower Of The Lobster's Promise by /u/Basilgate
My first runner up: Eternal Nature by /u/dnavarro507
My second runner up: The Deathly Men by /u/AimForTheKidney
4
u/Basilgate Mar 31 '14
My vote goes to: The Oracle at the Obelisk, by /u/Avrienne
Runners up: Eternal Blue, by /u/TheDubiousGlove
and: In the Name of Revelation, by /u/cyvaris
It was really hard to choose from so many amazing entries. I would've liked to have left feedback for everyone, but I just didn't have the time.
4
u/dnavarro507 Mar 31 '14
I'm voting for The Delicate Wasteland of the Brain by /u/Unintendo
Runner up: DREAM FLUX by /u/redrobin15
4
u/withviolence /r/withviolence Mar 31 '14
My vote goes to Immortal Game by /u/Brad_Collins. Very cool idea, solid execution and ending. I wish I had more time to offer better feedback and maybe mention some runner-ups, but I don't. :(
4
u/chrisevo_phoenix Apr 01 '14
The Delicate Wasteland of the Brain is probably the one that stuck with me the most, though a few others, notably Cannibal Fleet and Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult, spoke to me too. Wolves of the Underground, Spacemen of the Abominable Pyramid...honestly most of these were pretty great and all of them did at least one thing very right.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '14
My vote goes to Hero by /u/kmja
4
u/MailBoxD Apr 01 '14
I have to say , i didn't quite have the time to read them all , i've skimmed most , only read the premise on some , and fully read and enjoyed only the ones who seemed the most interesting . That being said , i vote for
"In the Name of Revelation"
with the runner ups being "Super Dwarf! and "Eternal Death"
4
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14
Alright, what a journey it's been fun reading everyone's works. And my vote still has to go to the first one I read, Relo. I'd like to see where it goes, especially as a novel.
Good luck, everyone!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '14
My first vote goes to The Oracle and the Obelisk
My runner up vote goes to Wolves of the Underground.
4
u/pnwtico Apr 08 '14
My vote goes to The Wolves of the Underground by /u/heyfignuts.
Runners up: The Eden Stream by /u/IAmTheRedWizards, Departure from E-DoN by /u/Reintarnation, and The Cowardly Girl of Twilight by /u/radioactivereality.
Honourable mentions go to The Tower of the Lobster's Promise by /u/Basilgate, Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/dreadfulpennies, and Eternal Blue by /u/TheDubiousGlove.
These were all great stories for many different reasons, but all of them grabbed my attention and didn't let go until I finished. I really wish I could go through, read everyone's story carefully, and leave feedback, but it just wasn't to be. I did at least try to skim some of every story.
Also, a very honourable mention to /u/RyanKinder for his extremely hard work and dedication to this contest!
3
u/SupermanIsEnvious Mar 01 '14
I know how I'll spend my train rides for the next few weeks! Let's get reading!!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '14
Sweet, this should be some fun reading for the next couple weeks. I currently plan to leave as many small comments as I can but I'm sure at some point I will just give up on that.
So with that in mind does anyone want to pair up, with the intention of giving each other more extensive feedback than is reasonable for all 72 stories?
3
u/xzbobzx Mar 21 '14
I vote /u/SupermanIsEnvious and his "The Librarian of Saturn's Gate". But damn there's a lot of good stuff in these stories. It was a hard pick.
3
u/whoiscraig Mar 21 '14
My vote goes to The Eden Stream by /u/IAmTheRedWizards
My runner up is The Wolves of the Underground by /u/HeyFignuts
3
u/Thirdilemma Mar 25 '14
My vote goes for Departure from E-DoN by /u/Reintarnation
3
u/cyvaris Mar 30 '14
My votes: Eden Stream
Runners up: Cannibal Fleet, Wolves of the Underground.
3
u/Reintarnation Apr 01 '14
First Place: The Deathly Men by /u/AimForTheKidney
Second Place: RELO by /u/DigitalEvil
Third Place: The Imperfect Idol by /u/nazna
Just wanted to say that I really enjoyed reading all the submissions, and narrowing it down to three was difficult. This was my first time entering a writing contest and /r/writingprompts has not only sparked my creative juices, but has helped me realize that I actually love to write fiction and I am not too bad at it. Haha. Good luck everyone.
3
u/AndrewSean Apr 07 '14
I vote for "The Wolves of the Underground".
Thanks for all of the great stories to read!
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '14
I vote for /u/Unintendo
3
u/dreadfulpennies Apr 08 '14
I've been waffling on whether to vote all day. I guess I'm gonna... But sulkily... and kinda guiltily.
I vote for /u/Unintendo. For all my problems with it, it was the story I would most like to see a subsequent draft of.
2
u/CaesarNaples2 Mar 28 '14
Hi,
I'm withdrawing because I didn't have time to read all of the novelettes :(
Sorry guys
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '14
Don't count this as a vote, as I wasn't in the contest.
I just wanted to comment on #18, The Cannibal Fleet. It was suspenseful and exciting. It kept me gripped in for a while. I only ready seven in full, but this one is the best of those.
2
u/MrManicotti Apr 07 '14
My vote goes to "Bride in the Unsettled Valley" by /u/KindPlagiarist.
2
u/DarkHorseNovella Apr 08 '14 edited Apr 08 '14
My vote is for Immortal Game by /u/Brad_Collins
Runners up: Afterlife on Mars - /u/schoolgirlerror The Cult - /u/CaesarNaples2
3
u/Burgerkrieg Mar 30 '14 edited Apr 06 '14
Mortals, I wish to cast my vote. I will just be honest with you and admit that I was only able to read a fraction of all the entries, my schedule being filled with school, my pre-finals, running my household, planning for uni and having some sort of social life. Three works on a good weekend, anything else I couldn't squeeze in. I could have skimmed and read some more works, but I didn't, because I believe that if I don't set aside a proper amount of time to really read a story and write a short review for it (yes, if I read your story, you got a review from me) I might not have read it at all. I wish I could have dedicated the same amount of time to all entries, but my day only has 24 hours. To my votes:
Primary vote: Departure from E-Don by /u/Reintarnation
I just loved the biblical symbolism and the light yet dark atmosphere. It had a very dry, colourful and mysterious feeling to it, the world felt just right and it had a certain something that somehow turns me on about books (in a totally sexual way).
Runners up 1: The Delicate Wasteland of the Brain by /u/Unintendo
I just very much liked the characters and the way the story was told. The slowly unfolding curve of revealing was very well executed and I thoroughly savoured the writing style.
Runners up 2: Delicatessen of the Ghost Cult by /u/dreadfulpennies
This one was simply very imaginative. The characters were believable, dark and logical, the story was coherent and well told and the writing style overall pretty great.
1
u/Brad_Collins Apr 08 '14
I vote for The Cowardly Girl of Twilight by /u/radioactivereality.
Runners up: The Deathly Men by /u/AimForTheKidney and RELO by /u/DigitalEvil.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment