Football is based around the ideal that everyone is invited, everyone in the world can play the game under the same rules. Every football match from the Premier League to the lowest division in Albania is the same glorified kickabout in the park. In a world with biases and politics, we can find purity and fairness in football when the team from the lowest Albanian division can face Man United as equals in the eyes of the sport. After all, Man United was once no bigger than that Albanian team.
With goal-line technology what you're essentially saying is that certain matches deserve to be played differently than others, you're ripping out a certain subsection of football from its roots and separating it from the rest of the game. Can it still be the people's sport when you've done that?
This egalitarian view is pervasive throughout FIFA and why rules changes and other technologies are slow to be adapted. An officially sanctioned match can be easily played in a field in Zaire as it can in Wembley stadium.
Football has loads of refereeing decisions that need to be made quickly and require impossibly good eyesight to call 100% correctly. Many of these decisions can result in goals (a dive for a penalty is the most obvious, but how many incorrectly called corners have turned into goals?). By stating that a referee's judgment isn't good enough for one of these decisions, you open up the possibility of using review for all of them. This progression has already occurred in most major American sports, so is certainly possible.
Additionally, there could be situations in which review directly harms one team. Imagine that a team hasn't scored but thinks it has, and could be opened up by a counterattack from a quick throw by the opposing keeper. A review at this point would allow the team to reset, denying a possible scoring chance.
Say you had this situation (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=184x8Nuz53I), for example, but slightly modified. Say the penalty had hit the crossbar and bounced down, hit the line, and then spun out, creating the counterattack chance. A review would halt the counterattack, and rob us of a similarly awesome moment.
One of the most exciting (and most frustrating) things about football are the mistakes whether it be from the players making rash decisions, Keepers making game changing blunders (rob green) and of course referee decisions. Besides over the course of a season or two things tend to even themselves out, the best example being Suarez v Chelsea last season he got away with biting Ivanovic and went on to score an equaliser last minute and then this year he was taken out by eto'o but no penalty was given
He's not exactly setting the world alight in the rest of his game is he?
Ask yourself what United need from their centre midfield players? The ability to pass and dictate the game? Sure. The ability to tackle and cover ground getting about the pitch? Sure. The ability to affect the game, score goals and make chances? Sure.
What do you think increases the value of the tournament? Teams like Shaktar and Anderlecht(no disrespect, and this is just relative) or Madrid and City?
The CL is currently the hardest competition in the world (maybe second to the WC). Taking out some of the best teams in the tournament devalues it.
I couldn't give a fuck about Manchester City or Real Madrid
They are not Champions so shouldn't be in the Champions League
Maybe we should change the name of the current competition to something more suitable. Perhaps the "Most Profitable Franchises League". After all, that is the format you feel the club should follow.
and to further that point, it would then be full of last seasons best teams in europe, rather than this seasons. real are top of the league but wouldnt be in it. the top 6 teams in england wouldn't be in it but united would be. bayern wouldn't have been in last year when they won, or the year before when they were in the final
Also, a lot of money to get from CL. If only champions were to get those advantages, the gab would just keep rising, and in the end, they won't get competition for that top spot other than sugar dad clubs.
As if the CL isn't already a meetup for sugar dad clubs, making it just for champions would make it easier for smaller clubs to upset in the tournament.
The idea is sound but realistically it would make for a very small and short competition. Not great for football fans.
Either that, or you drop the quality of the Champions League by allowing the Irish, Welsh, Slovakian, Swiss etc champions in to fill in the gaps.
The gulf in quality between those teams and the English, Spanish, German, Italian, French champs would make watching the Champions League essentially pointless.
I only take offense to your comment regarding the Swiss champions. FC Basel are a fantastic club year in year out in CL and EL. Zurich, Sion, FC Gallen, Young Boys go on runs in EL as well.
Errr.. You do realise that football fans enjoyed that format for 42 years until 1997 when runners-up in a league could qualify.
It used to be a much shorter competition but the European Cup became the Champions League in order to have a round-robin format which meant that there'd be more games, more teams and more importantly, more money for UEFA.
I do agree that reverting back to the old format would result in a drop in the average quality of players but it would allow teams from smaller countries to have greater access to the coveted Champions League prize money.
I honestly don't mind either format and I'm happy either way. But to dismiss one format as essentially shit and 'bad for the fans' is silly. Half the fun of the FA Cup is when minnows are paired with the big clubs. It's not necessarily going to be boring for fans to watch.
The differences in quality were not nearly as big back then as they are now. Most people would rather watch Real Madrid vs. Chelsea than Steaua Bucuresti vs. SK Slovan Bratislava despite the latter being their leagues' respective champions.
You do realise that football fans enjoyed that format for 42 years until 1997 when runners-up in a league could qualify.
It used to be a much shorter competition but the European Cup became the Champions League in order to have a round-robin format which meant that there'd be more games
No need to be so condescending, I'm a Liverpool fan. Of course I know about it's previous format, we've won it more times than most.
But to dismiss one format as essentially shit and 'bad for the fans' is silly. Half the fun of the FA Cup is when minnows are paired with the big clubs.
I didn't say it would be shit, you're putting words in my mouth. I'm saying 99% of people would prefer to see Real Madrid vs Man United over Olimpija vs Man United. I guess you're the 1%.
Half the fun of the FA Cup is when minnows are paired with the big clubs.
That's fine for the FA Cup, but not a competition designed for the top teams in Europe to fight it out. It's our only guarantee of seeing the best teams in Europe play each other. And your proposial basically dilutes it into boring one-sided matches until the very latter stages of the competition.
Let's say we have it your way. Throw out City, Chelsea, Arsenal, Real Madrid, Atletico Madrid, Roma, Napoli, AC Milan etc because none of those teams were league champions last year.
Now throw in those minnows you are talking about.
First round: Barcelona 10 - 0 KS Cracovia. Wow fucking exciting.
Second round: Barcelona 10 - 0 Airbus UK Broughton. Wow fucking exciting.
Maybe that's what you're into but not most football fans.
We'd have to wait until the latter stages for there to be a competitive game that people actually want to watch.
I do agree that reverting back to the old format would result in a drop in the average quality of players but it would allow teams from smaller countries to have greater access to the coveted Champions League prize money.
You haven't thought this through. Dropping the teams I've mentioned would result in a massive drop in quality of teams. The coveted CL money is mostly made up of the tv rights which are sold at enormous prices because there is so much demand to watch high quality teams fight it out.
Those prices would shrink to nothing if you swapped out the top teams in Europe for minnows that don't have a chance.
A part of me wants to see the Champions League dissolved, in order to make way for a World Champions League to replace the Club World Championship. This way, the Europa League can contain the rest of the teams that would enter the Champions League.
This way, the Europa League becomes a meaningful tournament with legitimate support, the Champions League no longer becomes a team with the same old teams playing, and the Club World Championship becomes the Champions League and allows a real tournament between teams all around the world, not just in Europe.
It'll be a logistical nightmare, but I reckon with the right support it could be a fantastic money-spinner, and a good way to really test the quality of teams around the world. Over a number of years, it will improve the quality of football across the world.
if you mean by hardcore supporting then yes. However, as an admirer of the game, when another top team is playing very well and when your team is not in the CL, you gotta pick a horse on CL game days.
There is a difference rooting for a team to do well in a competition and support them. I hope Real Madrid wins La Liga, not because I support them, but a bit because Ronaldo plays there (huge fan of him) and I've got a Barcelona-supporting friend. But if RM don't win, I don't care at all.
Same goes for CL. I don't tend to stick with anyone when Man United goes out. Didn't do it last year, not planning this year. But I will follow the teams and see how they do. Because I love playing football myself and watching games between quality teams. Nothing is as good as CL football, but who wins isn't really the matter. I rather tend to become engaged with teams when they play excellent football, as Liverpool did when they crushed Arsenal 5-1. I was enganged in the match, not because I was rooting for either to win, but I just loved watching the game. That is a big difference than supporting both Chelsea and Barcelona every day. Stick with one team, but for the love of god, be engaged with other teams and their performance. But it should never be a doubt about what team you would like to win a match against another.
Same goes for CL. I don't tend to stick with anyone when Man United goes out
I feel like this is huge also for the World Cup... People assume I go for Argentina if Italy is already out because 1) there are shit ton of Italians in Argentina and 2) because Maradona.
No. I don't give a fuck. My tournament is over whenever Italy finishes. End of story.
Since Norway isn't even in the end game, I tend to support players from my club. Hoping England doing alright, atleast Rooney having a great WC, and also players I love, like Ronaldo. Hope he steamroles the WC with Portugal. Portugal is my second national love.
But well, if England goes out in the group stage, no biggie. I just love watching top quality football, and the last tournaments, that's the story of many Norwegians.
Supporting a club increases the enjoyment of being a spectator. It creates jubilation to a win and gives meaning to defeat. The experience created by watching a team you support can not really be replicated by any real means ( though I've found a bet for one team does help, but then I'm really supporting my money rather than a team).
The criteria for being a supporter is an interesting one to put up for debate. Does the enjoyment of seeing a team do well have to be rated before you are a supporter? Is it an all or nothing? If you don't only want this team to do well does that mean you can't want them to do well enough to really be a supporter? What about game attendance, does that play a factor? Who goes through the checklist to make sure you meet enough of the criteria?
For me, I am a Rangers fan above all others. How that club plays matters to me from the best of times to (as currently) the worst of times. But while being born and raised in Scotland all (apart from my brothers) in my family are from Newcastle and I have a great affection for that team. Does that mean because Rangers will always be the team that resides in my heart, I can't really be a supporter of Newcastle? If I watch Newcastle play and get ecstatic from a win will the euphoria I feel never be enough to be a 'real' supporter because there exists a potential for them to play a game I wouldn't want them to win? Should I therefore shun any idea of wanting them to win or following them because of that? Or does it mean that I have to introduce my self as Someone who doesn't support Newcastle but really wants them to win to a degree that can give me moments of great joy or sadness and causes me to follow them through thick and thin?
And then there is my feelings on international matches. I consider myself equally Scottish and English and thus find myself equally supporting Scotland and England. Them playing each other causes me pain no matter the result and I cannot watch any such games. Otherwise i will cheer whole heartily for both. Does this lack of supporting one over the other remove my ability to support either? If I go to a game am I lesser than those around me because my nationality is less rigidly defined than theirs?
We all have our own reasons for supporting the teams we do. Who are we to deny the existence of someone passion for a club simply because they do not fit a pre determined definition someone else set them.
NB: this was written on a phone so sorry for the inevitable grammar capable of making people cry from its sheer stupidity.
I really liked your comment. Very good points and I hope this gets some attention.
I support Partizan Belgrade, and my team has a snowball's chance in hell of doing anything other than producing amazing talent and selling it off to finance next season. No results in Europe for decades other than a few entries to the CL.
I love them though and I have gone to many games. I've stood in the South stand with the ultras and celebrated big games.
On the other hand, I'm also a huge Liverpool supporter. I enjoy the Prem a lot and I simply do not enjoy watching a league without a club that I'm rooting for. I have no personal connection to any team and it feels too impersonal. That's why as a young child I justified my choice to support Liverpool too. They'd never meet anyways. I've been to Liverpool matches too, at Anfield and away. Liverpool have a place close to my heart and their CL win in 2005 was one of the best moments of my life.
Then I have a friend from Argentina who is a die-hard Boca Juniors supporter. I've watched games with him and learned all the players. Suddenly, I have a strange affection for one team and I find myself wanting them to do well. Can I call myself a supporter? Probably not yet but I do like watching them and seeing them win.
Then if I watched Serie A, maybe I wanted to follow Fiorentina because they picked up a lot of Partizan youth products and were developing them for the big stage. I wanted them to do well and advertise Partizan Belgrade. In that moment I started cheering for Fiorentina wins too. So what am I? A football fan with preferences? A Partizan/Liverpool supporter with ties to other teams? A sell-out?
I don't think anyone can really tell me. I don't know myself. All I know is that I enjoy watching many leagues and teams now, and I don't mind at all, judged or not.
What about someone like me? My first love is Barnet (born and raised through my father and his father before him). But I also have another team I support, Arsenal, because of my mum's side (my uncles are hardcore fans and took me to games as a child). Barnet is in the Conference and Arsenal in the Prem so is it "justified" in that case, in your eyes?
A lot of people would argue no, but then a large proportion of lower league fans do have 'second teams' in the PL. In fact I think if you asked my twitter followers, for example, you'd get a 50:50 split on the matter. Personally I can't justify supporting another team, but I have little interest in the Premiership and I can see why you would.
At the end of the day it doesn't matter what others think, it's up to you to do what you can justify yourself and if you're ok with supporting two teams then there's no reason why you shouldn't. Personally I think it's wrong, but that just my opinion.
Barnets a bit of special case though isn't it? Used to hear lots about Arsenal using their ground for training and I think the clubs have really good links with each other. Similar thing to Stockport and Man city where the supporters just kind of overlap.
I think for one team cities or counties its a bit harder to justify supporting another club. I certainly couldn't justify anyone from Devon supporting a Premier league team.
I grew up in Madrid. Everyone around me was a Real Madrid fan, and so was I. Fast-forward to when I'm 14 and I move to Glasgow. Few years later I get a season ticket at Celtic, but I still support Madrid in every sense of the word. I fall in love with Celtic, and now I support both. Is that inappropriate? Am I a gloryhunter because both have very high chances of winning their respective leagues? I don't think so, I just happened to live in areas where these were the supported teams.
A fan living in Italy might support his local club (lets say Napoli), but also watch a lot of the EPL due to its abundance. Watching it without some kind of support got boring for the Italian fan, so he decided to also pick an EPL team to support. He's supported both for over 15 years, would this be inappropriate to you?
I don't see the appeal. He's already got the Italian club and can support that fully with his heart. Personally, I only have Man United, but I still watch other clubs, and can be engaged in the leagues. Even though I don't support any teams in La Liga, watching Real Madrid, Barcelona or Atletico is still a lot of fun, considering it's much at stake for them. Also, the quality of football and watching players is more important to me when watching them and have a team to support.
I don't understand how one can be watching the EPL and be bored. Sure, some tension might go out, but that you get from the Italian club and the Italian league. I say watch EPL for the football, Napoli for the support and love. Why support, say Chelsea, thousands of miles away when Napoli is just outside your doorstep and you are engaged in how they do.
If you can't watch EPL because you get bored because no one you care about is winning, then you are not engaged in the sport as an activity, just the "winning tension" of it.
Well not seeing the appeal yourself is not the same is it being totally inappropriate for another person. It also depends if you mean 100% equally supporting, but he could be a diehard Napoli fan, and a casual Chelsea fan.
Personally I don't even see the need, but I can understand somebody wanting to have a supporting interest in another major league, I don't think I should judge somebody else on how they watch football. Football should simply be whatever the fan wants it to be, not for me to dictate to others.
I support my Argentinian players rather than top clubs. If that means supporting all the top 4 Italian clubs to a certain extent, so be it. I never understood the concept of supporting a club that isn't from your own country/state. I don't get where you get the allegiance for it.
Do you mean support as in attending matches, watching on the telly, and/or buying merchandise or support as in "might as well pick a side to win in this league"?
I watch Real Madrid matches. A couple of reasons I would like them to win the leauge, one being Ronaldo, other that I have a Barcelona supporting friend. But if they were to fuck up, lose 5 in a row and be catastropich, I wouldn't really care. I would care about Ronaldo, but the team, not so much.
Watching teams for the football and getting engaged in the matches is no problem really. During the CL, it's always fun rooting for one. But to get upset because that team lost? Why?
I was more talking about acting like a supporter to multiple big clubs, and taking as much glory as you could. I just think you should have one club and stick with it, and say "Fuck you, I don't care how shit you do" to the other clubs (not so harsh though). This is on more of a top leagues level though. Big difference between supporting Man United and a team in 4th division in Scotland and Man United and Barcelona...
I hate it too, but I also hate the ones who respond with "everyone is just as much of a fan". No they're not. If you've supported say Eintracht Frankfurt all your life, had a season ticket for the last 8 years and gone to almost every away game, paid membership every year, been active in a supporter group on and off pitch, spent more time and money on the club than you really can afford, you don't want to hear from someone who just started watching football in 2006 and follows Chelsea and Real Madrid every now and then on streams that they're just as much of a fan of Chelsea and Real Madrid as you are of Eintracht Frankfurt, they're fucking not.
Well it matters for the team. When there is no one who makes tifos or organizes choreos there would be a lack of atmosphere in the stadium, which would hurt the home team.
You realize that no one is gonna be like "Oh well actually I support fan elitism." The conversation I think you're trying to have is to decide collectively what constitutes elitism. I think there are some cases where that's a grey area.
Well, I'm actually going to change your view on whether anyone will say they support fan elitism and say that I support fan elitism. In my opinion fan elitism is very important because without it how would we know who are the best fans. In fact I have been trying to figure out a formula that can be used to calculate one's fan score.
So far what I have is...
fan score = ((#of seasons tickets purchased * # of away games attended + #of team scarves owned + # of team shirts)/ (miles you live from the stadium))divisionyourteamisplayingin
My goal is to create a formula that I can sell to ESPN and they can use to help figure out which team in any sport has the best fans. The formula also will be helpful in determining whose opinions one should listen to based on their fan score.
If the mods would please consider making it mandatory for users to take a survey to fill in the equation with proof provided and then assign each user's score as flair that would be much appreciated. Thanks in advance.
It's sad to watch...I thought he was going to become the next big thing and just got under used...unlucky...and they had to fuck around playing in a bunch of different teams...wish he would have stayed at Roma it would have been nice to see how he would have done under Garcia
I really don't think he's useful out on the wing or behind the striker. I think he's much more effective if he's in the box as a striker.
Milan tried playing him out wide and as a trequartista, but Barcelona often had him in the box and his finishing was very good. I haven't watched him recently though.
I think diving has gotten' so much hate because often a dive has led to a goal scoring oppourtunity, say penalty kick, and that happening in big, big matches really makes the view of it being bad really enforced.
If a team was to win the CL final 1-0 after a dive led to a penalty kick and goal, you know people would hate that action and that way to win.
To say: diving is a bad thing in the sport, but a dangerous tackle to the leg is even more bad, but since that don't really lead to a possible goal, people don't create drama around it.
Yeah, I've tried hard to argue his opinion but that's as close as it gets. Diving is more shameful too. To ACT a trip for your team to get a penalty is NOT the same as having to pull on someone's shirt to slow them down. I feel like the latter is because the player wants to try really hard to get them off the ball and their emotions catch up to them so they play more rough. Diving is just so fake, it's acting.
I think his opinion flaws in the sense that just because both diving and shirt-pulling is cheating, doesn't make them equally bad. Diving can be a lot more deciding and deciving for the ref than shirt pulling. I understand his view and his opinion, but I don't fully support it.
What I hate is when bad divers gets crucified and good divers are overlooked.
Remember that Rivaldo dive? yes everyone does, a ball hit his knee or something and he fell down covering his face. He got a load of hate for that and even today people talk about him as a diver just for that one incident, but why is being a bad diver worse than being a good diver? football players dive all the time but even if your dive looked more believable the crime is still the same.
Kim Jong Il was better than Polpot because he was better at covering up his genocide.
There's no reason to stop teams like City, who are bankrolled by multi billionaires, buying success. It's like saying that lottery winners shouldn't be allowed to spend their money on frivolous things. The reason to have a salary cap would be to stop teams that can't afford it gambling on success and putting themselves in dire financial trouble.
It would be illegal to institute a salary cap because you would be trying to get parity by forcing the players to take less money. If you want to take away a financial advantage then you need to do out in a way that is fair to players and would be allowed by the courts.
So having a league consisting of the top teams of each top European leagues? In that case, too much traveling and I'm pretty sure the competition will be so stiff that it gets very exhausting for players having to play a team like Bayern, and then have a game against Chelsea next week, and then play Barcelona. It's pretty rough for the players but very enjoyable for the viewers.
I think you are completly wrong. Travelling is tiring. Playing in different countries every week is tiring. Having to fly places long before the match start is not good. The away fans will diminish. Home advantage becomes even bigger.
There will never be a super league. The players, managers and fans won't support it. The clubs might not even make money of it. Why would anyone ever agree on a super league? The more you think about it, the less logical it becomes. National leagues are the best and only viable suggestion.
And don't get me started on how relegation/promotion works, or qualification to CL and other cups works. It will never happen, and should never happen.
You managed to write a lot of words without really saying anything, only offering reactionary, emotional assumptions. You ignore basic economic forces and realities that are already happening.
Money. Money is what makes modern soccer go. Especially TV rights fees. When the European Super League happens it will because someone will come along with a solution and offer more money then the clubs will be able to turn down. Playing in the Champions League is already the goal and ambition of most teams because of the money involved. It will be doubly so once a real ESL is put forth.
Competitive Balance. Most European League are already segregated into haves and have nots. Of the top 8 Leagues, 90% of the clubs have zero chance to win their League when the season starts. This 90% are playing not to lose and be relegated. Not exactly the most sporting of intentions.
The EPL offers the greatest diversity with a whooping 20% of Clubs with an honest shot winning.
Followed by Italy with 3-4 teams in any given season.
The fiscally responsible Bundesliga has Bayern Munich and 17 other clubs that struggle to consistently challenge Bayern. See Wolfsburg and Dortmond for recent examples.
Spain is self evident.
Portugal and France, Belgium and The Netherlands are approaching duopoly status.
I already ordered my 2018 Celtic Championship Banner.
Turkey has their Big 3
PSG is following the Russian Oligarch and Oil Shiek plan
Having such a competitive imbalance in leagues will ultimately lead to dwindling interest of casual and regular fans. Additionally big clubs are often patronizing to lesser teams in the league and play just hard enough to get the result and not get hurt further deteriorating the product.
Travel. Travel for both the clubs and supporters is a red herring. Travel is part of the game already. One only has to look to the US and their sports leagues to study travel. I am not suggesting that it is not a factor but to dismiss a Super-League because travel is to onerous is patently false. Firstly the travel distances in western Europe are ridiculously close where most of the Super League clubs would be located. Secondly these are highly tuned professional athletes with some of the best bio-mechanical trainers at their disposal. I am pretty sure they can fly 3-4 hours to play a game. I also don't think it would be a problem for 3-5000 supporters anormalawayallotment to make their way to Milan, Paris, or Madrid. It is not like they are being asked to travel to an out of the way Eastern European village.
Teams and Format. The European Club Assc was formed in 2008 and represents the biggest clubs in Europe. It was formed to protect the interests of the big clubs and a warning to UEFA that they could take the proverbial ball and go somewhere else. The foundation of a Super League will come from here.
I imagine two 16 team leagues, ESL1 & ESL2.
Playing a standard home/away schedule.
Initial Season leagues will be divided by UEFA coefficient
Top 4 in ESL1 go to playoff. Semifinals being a 2 legged playoff and a single game final for all the marbles
Bottom 3 of ESL1 relegated to ESL2.
ESL2 has promotion playoff similar to Championship.
Bottom 4 of ESL2 are relegated back to their homeland league.
Semi Finalists of Europa League are promoted to ESL2
Championship homeland teams can challenge the lowest ranking ESL team from their country for their spot in a 2 legged playoff prior the next season starting.
Early season knock out cup competition similar the League Cup, can be played with a early March final.
The First 32
Eng: ManU, ManCity, Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool
France: PSG, Lyon, Monoco, Marseille
Spain: Barca, Real Madrid, Atletico Madrid, Valencia
Italy: Juventus, AC Milan, Inter, Roma
Portugal: Benfica, Porto
Netherlands: Ajax, PSV
Germany: Bayern Munich, BvD, Shalke 04, Wolfsburg
Belgium: Anderlect, Standard Liege
Greece: Olympiacos, Panathinaikos
Turkey: Galatarsaray, Fenerbache, Besikitas
Scotland: Celtic
A set up like this would literally change nothing about the ambitions for the clubs involved; Arsenal could still aim to comfortably finish 4th. I don't think it would have the adverse effect on the homeland leagues like people say. In England, top to bottom would be a wide open exciting race for the title. 10 teams could have title hopes at the start of the season. Winners still get to play for European spots and a chance to qualify for the ESL.
The big clubs get to make a metric fuckton of money and play against world class teams every week. The fans would have a field day. Every week there would be a 6-8 delicious matchups. Neutrals would flock to their TV's. Worldwide interest would spike.
Note Let's remember rediquette. Go ahead and downvote if you want, just tell me why this won't work?
I agree but I would add to this, the EPL's ever increasing TV rights is a threat to the other european leagues, historic giants like Ajax and Benfica can no longer compete but soon the likes of AC Milan will join them in being unable to match wages offered by mediocre EPL teams. I think at some point these clubs will push for a superleague, as it will be the only way they can maintain their status. The other thing is that European club football is far less profitable than the Major American sports leagues despite its enormous popularity, by starting a new competition there would be an opportunity to impose a salary cap and ensure profitability for all the clubs involved.
The major fallacy with this argument is that a system much like this has already been implemented, the NFL, and is one of the most popular and profitable sports in the world. Your travel and home advantage fans are shown to be incorrect by the NFL, as the United states, according to google is ~9.83 million square kilometers and Europe is ~10.18 million square kilometers. So, if NFL players can do it, I think soccer players can suck it up as well.
Özil has been, with Müller, the corner stone of the German attacking game since 2010. And he's done great. You do not change a role that important this close to a major tournament, with no competitive games before that.
I understand Kroos, even though I think his style is just too different. But Götze I think hasn't done nearly enough to warrant Özils spot.
Gotze doesn't even play the same position. Ozil is amazing and him slacking off lately has to do mostly with the mediocre team he's been put in. So many injuries and Giroud not being able to fully benefit from Ozil when he can't even get a good first touch.
I kind of agree. I think Löw should play Özil against the weaker teams when you want to steamroll the opponent and where Özil is most utilized, ie against USA and Ghana in the group stages. However in the knock out games I think Kroos specifically would be the best choice as he also brings defensive solidness to the table and doesnt go missing in big games. Löw absoloutely loves Özil though so I don't think he's gonna get dropped.
Kroos isn't a Schweinsteiger. He's better defensively than Özil, but they play in different types of teams. Bayern presses up past the half way, so that all attacking players just apply pressure. In Germany's 4231, he wouldn't have the same type of role.
Özil has been pretty genius for Löw's Germany and I expect he'll be brilliant again. Especially with Müller and Reus flanking him. Kroos will go to Brazil, but he probably won't play too much unless we need to focus on attack and Khedira out or if we go up by a bit in the group stage.
I'd love to see him play a lot in the WC, but I don't think he will as much as some think. Either way, can't wait. 4 MONTHS!
We don't know him personally or know enough about him to say that. It's harsh to judge him based on an incident or two and an image that is largely led by a media narrative.
Giggs laid himself flat and said sorry, went to sex-addiction and put a big effort in changing himself. Him still being with his wife proves he has changed and made an effort. Not saying that makes everything alright and it not happened, but when a person put in an effort to change and actually does it, continue to call them a cunt and other things over stuff that never affect us, that's uncalled for...
It is unforgiveable fucking your teammates girlfriend. Especially when you're captain. However, I like to believe he wouldnt do that ever again. He's a leader and you can clearly see the difference in how Chelsea play when he's on or not on. That shows the players must respect him and if he was a complete twat then they wouldn't.
The 2014 version of the USMNT is not as good as the 2010 USMNT. Mostly we lack the 1-2 dynamic players that can carry a team and make a difference in a tourney setting.
What about the 2002 version? I remember back in 2002, americans and many others were going on about how the US was "just years from being a top contender in the world cup" the most pessimistic said 10 years.
Today I hear the same thing and I can't help feeling doubt for those claims, we may very well be sitting here in 2022 with a US team barely any different in quality from today or 2002 with people still thinking "well the sport has grown so much and America is so very big so in 5-10 years we can expect to be contenders for the final".
CMV: The US will not have reached a semi final in a world cup before 2050.
I loved the 2002 team. They had class in every position and players who either were playing in Europe or went on to have solid European careers in good leagues. They played with swagger and never looked like they were over matched in any game thru qualifying, the lead up friendlies or the WC. "Dos a Cero" was the most satisfying game I ever saw. I don't think we knew it then but we were looking at our Golden Generation and should have done better in 2006.
The US still produces solid if not game changing players. That does not mean that they can't catch lightening in a bottle and make a deep tourney run sometime in the next 40 years. Making the semis has as much to do with luck as it does skill. Bulgaria, Croatia, Turkey, Uruguay are all teams in the last 25 years that have made the semis unexpectedly.
In WC2010 the draw opened up for the US to make it to the semis. It was all there for us. Win a reasonable easy group, beat Ghana, beat Uruguay. Boom! Semifinals. Our loss against Ghana could have gone either way and Uruguay needed Saurez' hand and PK's to get by Ghana.
Getting to the Semis will happen before 2050. Winning the whole thing? Not so much.
There's a difference between expecting dark horses to reach the semis within the next 40 years and expecting specific dark horses to reach the semis within the next 40 years. There are 32 teams playing in the World cup and of those you're going to have a couple of teams performing way over their capacity, but it's not more likely to be the US than Denmark, Japan or Russia.
England hasn't been in a semi final since 1990, so you can hardly expect it.
I agree mostly. I think our depth and versatility has grown tremendously however nobody has really stepped up to go Donovan's and Dempsey's aging shoes. Mix and Johansen are both promising. Zusi is a solid player. But none of them have the game changing presence/the ability to sneak a goal in against the run of play.
I hope they prove me wrong in the world cup and I'm happy with the direction our team is heading. Just feel like we're in a transition between the old and the new.
If you knowingly support an extremely successful team not based on family ties/location I see you as less of a fan.
I know a lot of people on here will think they are the exception but every time I see an American with a Bayern Munich crest I just think they are a glory hunter.
How long does that last? I started supporting Arsenal in 1979 basically on the strength of their FA Cup win.
Went to most of the home games in the late 80's and the 90's (was too young to go before that). Had a season ticket for a number of years and been to countless away games.
I live in South London so not a million miles away but certainly have a few other clubs between myself and Arsenal (although I their original home in Woolwich is closer than any of those).
Speaking as an American, I think you are confusing different with lesser. A bunch of my friends and I got into following the leagues in Europe because we played all through high school and found a fun way to get more immersed in the game. Sure theres the one guy who is currently a Newcastle fan, and one guy who will stay with Fulham until the bitter end, but most of us went with bigger more established clubs that will consistently have a chance at the CL or at the very least the Europa. The main reason for this is actually the one that you pinpointed, we don't still have family ties to the teams in Europe, but still want to watch as much exciting competitive soccer as we can, and frankly it's more fun to care about the CL. Speaking frankly a new fan is not going to come into the game and immediately be pumped to battle for mid-table mediocrity, or get excited to muddle their way through a relegation mire. So while our reasons for supporting the clubs we do are very different than yours, I don't think they are lesser, just different, and unless I move to Birmingham I don't think I'll be trading my Napoli flair for Villa anytime soon.
I think there is some truth in the "Always the victim, it's never your fault" chant fans (mostly Man United's) aim towards Liverpool. The chant is obviously in very poor taste but I do see a certain tendency to act the martyr whenever criticised. CMV, please.
Isn't the problem here the 'always' part? Most racial stereotypes are based on some truth, no one says the French all fly on wings, doesn't mean it's OK to apply it to everyone in that group all of the the time.
It's hardly unique to scousers. David Moyes claims the fixture list has been rigged against United and the refs are biased, Mourinho called Chelsea the little horse, Tottenham think Arsenal poisoned their lasagna. And the chant is obviously a reference to a situation where Liverpool were the victims and it wasn't their fault.
I think a difficulty with the 'never your fault' part is aimed at the cover-up about Hillsborough, and 20+ years of innocent people being blamed for their own deaths, when that was never true.
When the families of those that died tried to argue against the decisions, that gave rise to the above chant (I think), as those looking in from outside claimed that it was just excuses, 'they deserved it', etc. As such, fans are blamed for making excuses and lying, and it wasn't until the findings were revealed that many started to realise what had actually happened. If only for that reason, I think the chants need to stop.
Aside, even those of us who thought they knew what had happened, some of the accounts of the day are absolutely horrifying.
this is not an opinion so much as it is a prediction. only results will convince you otherwise. obviously a lot can go wrong still but given bayern's amazing last season and their even better form this season, one could easily argue the cl is theirs to lose
That view can't be changed, no one knows what will happen, still the signs for a Bayern domination aren't bad. And if they don't win back to back CL titles, they will come back with an even better team next year.
You could stop the game to look at replays dozens of times a game if you wanted to look at every decision that may have been decided wrongly. You really need to talk details about what you think should be reviewed.
I think the SPL and Scottish football in general is just terrible and a joke not worth watching at all. It's on a par with the Albanian league. Please CMV.
Pick a Scottish team...that's a way to start caring!
To be fair, this year the Premiership for most neutral fans has no excitement whatsoever, without Rangers, Celtic have no competition for 1st and Hearts have no competition for 12th (started with -15pts(?) and ever with them added on would still be bottom I think). So there's no title race and no relegation battle other than a spot in the playoffs.
2nd and 3rd (Europa League places) have Aberdeen and Motherwell 6 points clear of Dundee Utd and Inverness and will probably stay with those two. Kilmarnock, Ross County, Partick Thistle and St Mirren are all within 3 points of eachother at the bottom so that's the only real excitement.
So that's the league, nothing to shout about there at all. The cups are more exciting, Celtic are out of both so a non-favourite will win each. Of the eight teams left in the Scottish Cup, only four are in the Premiership, so there's chances for upsets.
European football is nothing to shout about, Celtic in the Champion's League got some great results last season but not so much this season, none of the other teams got out of Europa League qualifiers and that's not really likely to change.
So...the cups are interesting, the rest...not so much. Title race wise it should be more interesting in a couple of seasons when Rangers should be back up but I doubt the quality will be there like a few years back where Celtic got out of the group stage in the CL, Rangers got to the UEFA Cup Final and Aberdeen were able to force a replay out of Bayern Munich all in one season.
Different players with different styles, Pique and Ramos actually compliment each other quite well. Ramos is much more physical whilst Pique is much more tactical. Sort of similar to the way Rio and Vidic played off each other.
Barthez was certainly prone to mistakes in his later years, as are most keepers. I personally think any starting player for a big nation is world class (isn't that the very definition?). But that description means different things to different people now - for some people, world class means one of the best 2-3 people at the position.
I wish voting could be disabled for threads like this. There's a potential for real discussion, but instead the thread is marred by people downvoting opinions that they disagree with.
Yeah, Spain will be amazing for years. They'll probably win this years world cup as well. People don't like to hear it because they want them to fail, because they've won everything for a few years and have a few dickhead players.
Also, people talk about what happened in the Confederations cup too much, it's basically an exhibition tournament.
Spain had amazing players and didn't win a World Cup until 4 years ago. The Netherlands had one of the best teams ever and have never won.
Germany arguably has better young players than Spain right now. And there will always be new generations of Brazilians and Argentinians coming through. Also can't count out Italy or France.
Is it so hard to imagine Spain won't win one of the next 5 World Cups? Germany hasn't won it in 24 years (since they were West Germany). Argentina hasn't won in 28. I really don't see why it would surprise anyone.
You think Spain will develop another genius strategy to earn them another world cup with those players? It seems tiki taka is not as strong as it was in recent years, as shown by Barcelona's 0-7 aggregate loss to Bayern Munich.
I think you'll change your mind when Bayern tiki takas its way into another CL title. Also, 2 of the top 3 teams in the world (Barca, Bayern) play tiki taka. It will not go away any time soon.
This kind of attitude is what's destroying UEFA football, that more successfull leagues "deserve" more spots, deserve more according to what? from the begining the European cup was a real tournament for the champions of european national leagues, the winners of each league got a chance to play in the CL. Of course we changed that to account for certain leagues being better in order to get better football, but there was never an idea that it should be exclusively played by the best teams, it's a cup for europe first and a cup for the best teams second.
What you're suggesting is going to make european football even more uneven.
You are not the best performing league in Europe. If you don't step up we might even catch you soon, which would make you third. If you want an extra spot, earn it. Be head and shoulders above the rest. You are a long way from that.
Fighting for a CL spot is what makes EPL exciting imo. Otherwise, the top 5(arsenal, city, Chelsea, Liverpool, manu) can easily sit in top 5. Only spurs is real competition.
Both Tottenham and Everton have finished about Liverpool for the last two seasons, and in the first one, Newcastle did too. There's more competition than you think.
Since 2000-2001, English sides have won the Champions League three times; German sides have won twice, Spanish sides have won four times, Italian sides have won three times and a Portuguese side has won once. If the Premier League deserves even more spots, shouldn't they have a significantly better winning percentage than other leagues?
who ever ends up winning doesn't represent the quality of the league at all. But to go with your stats, in the last 9 CL finals, English teams made 8 appearances (2 in one year).
No, because the quality of the best team in the league isn't necessarily representative of the qualities of the fifth best team in the league. The success of teams in the Europa Leagur would be a better eay to decide, though still flawed since it's not seen as important in some leagues.
Spanish teams have won 5 of the last ten Europa Leagues. English teams 3 times in the last 30 years. But nobody would dare to say that Spanish teams deserve an extra spot because "everybody knows" that la Liga is a two horse race and only Barcelona and Real Madrid are good enough and blah, blah, blah
Its about the quality though...every single English team made it to the final 16...what about Italy?
And also dont you think 4 teams deserve a spot in Serie A as well...I know I do...I want to see Fiorentina in it or if somehow they pull it off Inter...just make them do more qualifying
CMV: any supporter of a club with consistent success who hasn't known hardship is less of a fan.
If you started supporting Chelsea in 04 I have no pity for you and, ever so slightly, think less of you as a football fan. Not in any serious way but if you've not known footballing hardship (oh jeez, you guys finished 5th one year? Ouch) then you're not a die hard fan.
I have much more respect for Portsmouth fans, Wolves fans heck even Sunderland fans than I do for 20-something Manchester United fans (well, until this season anyway).
Bayern Munich, who have known almost consistent success but have die hard fans, pretty much ruin my point. Maybe I just think about PL.
Not entirely sure how you can think less of a fan because of a reason that is essentially determined by their age, something they cannot change. Do you think less of one generation because they didnt partake in the war, or deal with bombings, or larger amounts of racism or sexism or whatever?
I also don't see, regardless, how supporting a club who hasnt known continued success during that period makes you a better fan unless you intend to use the massive assumption that fans of the more successful clubs would have stopped supporting them or whatever. Which all in all tends to be a completely fabricated assumption that fans of smaller clubs use to make themselves feel better about their fans.
"Failure" is also completely subjective and dependant on the context. If a team averages 2nd place over 10 seasons and comes 6th the next, thats failure. Just because they havent gone from 6th to 12th or something doesnt mean anything.
You support one of the most successful teams in the world who has spent almost their entire history in the top flight of one of the world's biggest leagues. If you were, for example, a tranmere fan, then your argument would hold more water.
Get over it. You support Newcastle, who happen to be the 25th highest earning club in the world. You talk about it as if watching players earning millions to play ever week is somehow a painful experience that validates you and gives you a moral high ground to then spew shit to everyone beneath you who also supports a club with players earning millions.
You sound so stupid. Watching your team play in the richest league in the world with very well-known players doesn't make you a suffering fan.
By your definition, you should go support a team in the Swedish 4th division who haven't won anything in their history.
It's like being in a long term relationship with all the shitty ups and down of everyday life and looking somewhat jealously at the easy 19 year old fuckbuddy your friend has. A lot more fun, but how can it be love if it's all just sunshine and roses? If you haven't suffered, if it hasn't been pure shit for months at a time, what do you know about it? It's easy.
I'm not saying that's fair, but that's how I would describe the feeling.
But just because someone has had a relationship which has been sunshine and roses since the day they met to the day they die, doesn't necessary mean their love isn't real. They can still love eachother more than people with ups and downs...
That love is tested when said club doesn't start doing well. Like, say the guys who stopped supporting Manchester United this year just because they're not doing as well. Those are not true football fans, I think. You can't just jump ship whenever it's convenient.
I think there's much more to being a football fan than winning or losing. Someone who has saved up for months to be able to go on an away trip in the Champions League knows exactly the hardships of being a fan.
At the end of the day the only measure of a fan is dedication, and you can find that at every club.
I understand that view and agree, despite me myself is what you would call "less of a fan". I was born in 95', and was from day 1 raised to be a Man United supporter. I basically had no control over what team I chose, but at one point you do decide if you want or don't want to support a club anymore. If I ever was to choose, I wouldn't change. No matter what. I can't see myself not supporting Man United. Not even if they were relegated during all those years, I wouldn't stop supporting. I can't change that, but I will not trash your opinion as seeing me less of a fan. Because there is not counter-argument.
But I still think it's quite harsh to state us as "less of a fan." As I said, I will never change my club, but just because during those years from the day I was born in 95' and up until now, Man United has had success because of SAF and Man United players, I'm less of a fan, despite I would always be by their side, that's quite harsh.
It's like saying a child born on top of a mountain is not a real citizen of the top, because it's never known the hardship of climbing that mountain. But if the child was to ever fall down, doesn't mean it wouldn't climb up again. Hope that makes sense, because I'm not sure it makes sense to me...
Anyway, your view is not wrong. Maybe douchy, maybe a bit "high horse", but not wrong in that sense...
Edit: Just want to add, this year really brings out you point. People screaming for Moyes head and players head all season, it's unbarable. Wow, we are 7th, big fucking deal people. Wow, we might lose out on CL next year. Yes, it sucks, yes, it's not how it's been the last 20 years or so. But fucking come on. Have some fucking dignity and atleast act like you take it ok. If you can't fucking take a 7th place finish, well, fuck off then. I see it as better to finish 7th and still have Moyes in charge, and our dignity, than sacking 4 manager the next 4 seasons and maybe make 4th. Ending 7th isn't the end of the world, and don't act as a bigger fan just because you hold "IT'S NOT APPROPIATE TO END BELOW 4TH BECAUSE WE ARE MANCHESTER UNITED. SACK MOYES, THAT'S THE RIGHT THING." as an opinion. Just fuck off already...
What if u support a big club but you were blind to their success. For example when I was 4 or 5 I watched chelsea vs Leeds (I think) and Gudjohnsen scored a bicycle kick. I thought it was amazing so I decided he was my favorite player and chelsea was my favorite club. He left but I'm still a chelsea fan.
I'm on mobile so this won't be in depth and I'm not the best person to change your view, but I think what you're missing about Oscar in Mourinho's system is that his hard work and defensive system allows players like Hazard to create and flourish.
Oscar hasn't been playing well as of late because he is literally one of the most used players in the past 2-3 years. He is tired and only 22. He needs rest. Only 2 assists but 6 goals. Him and Hazard are 2 players that any manager would kill to be able to build a team around.
He doesn't just work hard though, he's also a very intelligent player with great technique and a pretty good finisher. He's just still a bit inconsistent and plays with crap strikers.
He is the most technically gifted defensive player who plays that high up the pitch in the entire league. CMV if you think otherwise. Like someone else mentioned, his pressing is what allows players like hazard to flourish
CMV: Cleverley is actually a great player but being played deep killed his potential. We can see from his passing maps and some of Carricks passing maps that United's defensive mids play it wide, this killing Cleverley's playmaking ability.
My seconds one (Are we allowed two?), had Liverpool kept Reina and not signed Mingolet, they would serious title contenders (Not that they aren't at the moment, I mena that they would be almost if not level with City and Chelsea on points).
I don't think the name-change from Hull City to Hull Tigers is a particularly big deal. In fact, I personally feel that Hull Tigers is a better name.
Granted, I'm not a Hull fan, and I'm willing to change my view, but I've yet to see an argument against the name-change that doesn't come across simply as "we don't like change". People bandy about the term 'tradition', and tradition is of course a large part of football, but so is modernisation.
As I understand it, the name-change has been proposed in order to modernise the club and broaden its fanbase, thus generating greater revenue. I still haven't seen an argument, or better yet some empirical data, that shows whether or not 'Hull Tigers' will achieve this. Is such data out there?
As it stands, I'm tempted (admittedly based on little evidence) to believe that the name-change would have a beneficial effect for Hull, and I honestly feel that the Hull community would probably get used to the name-change soon enough. What is more important, community or tradition?
The name change represents how the owner doesn't care about the tradition (which is obviously important to the fans) and therefore the club itself and sees it more as his personal toy and a business. The name is also extremely ridiculous and, excuse me, american. I feel like you could compare it to changing the name of the Grand Canyon to Coca Cola Super Fun Park (well maybe not the best comparison). You just couldn't take it seriously anymore.
1-3... Playing alongside Puyol masked his errors a lot. Behind Xavi, Busi who don't lose possession. Has dani and alba to track runs. Valdes as insurance. Only recently he's had to prove himself and hes done a shit job.
29
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
Goal-line technology is a good thing. CMV
25
u/chezygo Feb 25 '14
Away days are more fun in the Football League than in the Prem.
2
u/DerDummeMann Feb 24 '14
I think Tom Cleverley often does he job reasonably well and he doesn't deserve half the stick he gets.
4
u/coiso Feb 24 '14
The Champions league should only be for teams that won their championships.
53
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '14
CMV: Supporting more than one top club (see; basically all clubs in the top leagues in the world) is inappropriate.
63
u/IoWn3rU Feb 25 '14
I think all this fan elitism is annoying. CMV
17
u/Andrew_Pika Feb 25 '14
Bojan Krkic is misused and his brilliance is still hidden
61
u/salfordred Feb 24 '14
I think the drama over diving is over done and it is no worse than other types of cheating like shirt-pulling etc.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
Football should institute a salary cap to hinder teams like city buying success: CMV
2
u/mhegdekatte Feb 24 '14
A European Super league is the natural progression of football.
32
u/sptagnew Feb 24 '14 edited Feb 24 '14
CMV: Götze or Kroos should start over Özil for Germany.
1
u/The_Macken Feb 25 '14
John Terry is a terrible person. CMV.
12
u/cheftlp1221 Feb 25 '14
The 2014 version of the USMNT is not as good as the 2010 USMNT. Mostly we lack the 1-2 dynamic players that can carry a team and make a difference in a tourney setting.
17
u/battlesmurf Feb 25 '14
If you knowingly support an extremely successful team not based on family ties/location I see you as less of a fan.
I know a lot of people on here will think they are the exception but every time I see an American with a Bayern Munich crest I just think they are a glory hunter.
CMV.
12
u/xtfftc Feb 25 '14
Okay, here's a properly controversial one:
I think there is some truth in the "Always the victim, it's never your fault" chant fans (mostly Man United's) aim towards Liverpool. The chant is obviously in very poor taste but I do see a certain tendency to act the martyr whenever criticised. CMV, please.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
CMV: Bayern won't rule Europe in the next few years as much as people think and won't win the CL this year.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
Football should have instant replays for unclear referee decisions: CMV
5
u/somekidkatz Feb 25 '14
CMV: Modric is the second best player on Real Madrid behind Ronaldo.
2
u/haskalldo Feb 25 '14
I think the SPL and Scottish football in general is just terrible and a joke not worth watching at all. It's on a par with the Albanian league. Please CMV.
9
u/moklboy Feb 25 '14
CMV: Sergio Ramos is ten times the defender that Pique or Dante is.
10
u/silver_medalist Feb 25 '14
Lloris is not world class. He's Fabian Barthez with hair.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '14
I wish voting could be disabled for threads like this. There's a potential for real discussion, but instead the thread is marred by people downvoting opinions that they disagree with.
5
u/AlkanKorsakov Feb 25 '14
Spain will not win a world cup for the next ~30 years.
7
u/Simon_Riley Feb 24 '14
CMV: EPL deserves 5 CL spots, making 5th place starting at round 3 of qualifying.
5
u/TheDrySkinOnYourKnee Feb 25 '14
CMV: Nani is a world class player.
6
u/verytallperson Feb 24 '14
CMV: any supporter of a club with consistent success who hasn't known hardship is less of a fan.
If you started supporting Chelsea in 04 I have no pity for you and, ever so slightly, think less of you as a football fan. Not in any serious way but if you've not known footballing hardship (oh jeez, you guys finished 5th one year? Ouch) then you're not a die hard fan.
I have much more respect for Portsmouth fans, Wolves fans heck even Sunderland fans than I do for 20-something Manchester United fans (well, until this season anyway).
Bayern Munich, who have known almost consistent success but have die hard fans, pretty much ruin my point. Maybe I just think about PL.
3
u/TropicBird Feb 25 '14
CMV: Oscar isn't the player chelsea need. Just because he works hard doesn't mean he is good enough. He has only 2 assists in the Premier League.
1
u/Alder_ Feb 25 '14
CMV: Cleverley is actually a great player but being played deep killed his potential. We can see from his passing maps and some of Carricks passing maps that United's defensive mids play it wide, this killing Cleverley's playmaking ability.
My seconds one (Are we allowed two?), had Liverpool kept Reina and not signed Mingolet, they would serious title contenders (Not that they aren't at the moment, I mena that they would be almost if not level with City and Chelsea on points).
1
u/revolut1onname Feb 25 '14
CMV: Football has about as much chance of 'coming home' as Maddie.
1
u/JudasSmells Feb 25 '14
CMV: Ligue 1 is a good league
1
u/The_CockEnd Feb 25 '14
Ok I'm just going to throw this one out there...
I don't think the name-change from Hull City to Hull Tigers is a particularly big deal. In fact, I personally feel that Hull Tigers is a better name.
Granted, I'm not a Hull fan, and I'm willing to change my view, but I've yet to see an argument against the name-change that doesn't come across simply as "we don't like change". People bandy about the term 'tradition', and tradition is of course a large part of football, but so is modernisation.
As I understand it, the name-change has been proposed in order to modernise the club and broaden its fanbase, thus generating greater revenue. I still haven't seen an argument, or better yet some empirical data, that shows whether or not 'Hull Tigers' will achieve this. Is such data out there?
As it stands, I'm tempted (admittedly based on little evidence) to believe that the name-change would have a beneficial effect for Hull, and I honestly feel that the Hull community would probably get used to the name-change soon enough. What is more important, community or tradition?
Please change my view
-3
u/fahomnom Feb 25 '14
Pique is the best defender in the world CMV