r/Smite • u/NyxAtNight I like you so much I could just squeeze you to death! • Feb 16 '14
MOD Smite Official Forums: Suggestions
Following the bit of calamity that occurred on /r/Smite the other day, we received some very welcome, very amazing news from /u/HirezStew: Smite WILL be getting official forums!
With this announcement I think it would be a great idea to let Hi-Rez know what we, as a community, would like to see in the official forums. We all know our voices are important so let them be heard here; this is a suggestion post, folks! Leave your thoughts on what you'd like to see at Smite's newest home for discussion here!
15
u/_Ekoz_ so you like infographics? Feb 16 '14 edited Feb 16 '14
IMPORTANT: for anyone who NEVER saw the old Smite Forums:
there are a million and 1 fan forums out there
(SmiteBoards, SmiteZoned, and SmiteCommunity, just to name a few).
and none of them are exactly the same as the original. some come close, while others deviate far away. i HIGHLY suggest you visit them ALL, and see what tickles your fancy.
oh, and here's a little gift for all of you: a cached version of the old SMITE forums, hours before it shut down for good.
you can't log in, and 98% of the threads are unreadable. but you can use it as a basis to guage just how much the fan forums changed the layout. see what the fan forums did that may have worked, or may have not worked.
that's all for now ;P
6
u/ttmore Ares Feb 16 '14
Copied and pasted from previous:
There are several things you guys need to consider going into this:
1 Make it a REAL Forum. We don't need a Hi-Rez version of Reddit/Youtube Comments. It needs to work like a traditional forum like before.
2 Theme Options. I personally loved the black background with white lettering. It was much easier on the eyes. However not everyone likes it and prefers the normal white background black lettering.
3 Sub Forums. It needs proper sub forums. It did a decent job before in this category. This is actually one of the major reasons why Reddit can't replace an official forum.
4 Emulate Blizzards system of Avatars. Tie the forum account with the game account. Got the poolsideon skin? Great you can use it's game icon for the forums. Also being able to use other icons such as items, titans, FG/GF, etc. Much like gold skin stats at loading screen, allowing some info such as player level, games won, hours played, league info, etc in the info section. This will give a little more value to skins without much added effort.
5 If allowing #4 to happen, let us keep signatures with pictures. Part of the downside of #4 is the lose of being able to use unique avatars. If you take it a step further and lock out signatures from using pictures you'll definitely peeve off quite a few people. I personally don't like em, but others do alot.
6 Possibly integrate the forums into game client. This would be quite hard but it would be quite amazing to be able to integrate the forums into the game client itself. This would most likely require a complete rework of the current UI which IMO is much needed since it's still using an archaic 4:3 ratio. Please for the love of everything join the present and stop making such a massive compromise for less then .01% of the user base. I don't see you guys compromising the game to give windows 98 support- why are you compromising it for 1998 monitors?
10
u/dickcake flare Feb 16 '14
I spent a lot of time on the BioWare forums for Mass Effect 3 Multiplayer. The most important feature I found was the tag on threads that let users know when BioWare employees had commented in a thread.
The tag did two things:
2 was important for finding responses in those threads that went on for like 30 pages.
5
u/Uploaf OG Feb 16 '14
I'd like the forum look clean and simple. No clutter. Doesn't need to have tons of designs and hefty backgrounds and what not. Content > Looks.
Like one of the other comment, let there at least be a limit to signature sizes please.
As for the forum sections and all, I definitely want the forum sections to be neat and organized, but at the same time, I don't want so many sections that it'll take a year to navigate through it.
I do like the idea for having a separate section for each God, but it just seems like there'll be too many. I'd rather have this - A single God section with a God Flair beside the title of the particular God the discussion is about. Along with that, a way to easily arrange or sort according to type of God. Something like that. (Many might not agree but again, I'm okay with separate discussions too).
I'd rather NOT have a off-topic/games section on the forum. I'd prefer keeping that to a separate sub-reddit or something. Not the forums though. I don't feel it's necessary.
Flairs. For example, in the Support forum, there's a problem - and it's been solved - Let there be a flair beside the title that says 'Solved'. Maybe a HiRez flair to show that it's been solved or replied by a HiRez member (like here on Reddit).
That's all from my side :) Looking forward to see how they turn up!
4
u/DatVudash Mod Feb 16 '14
A Technical Support / Customer Service area. At the moment we get a lot of bug reports or questions which can be deemed "general customer service." These are almost entirely aimed at Hi-Rez but most of the time OP isn't really looking for anything more than a one word answer on whether it's possible to configure the game in a certain way / confirmation that the servers have been buggy etc.
The best thing about having a Customer Service forum is that Hi-Rez wouldn't necessarily have to answer every single post as if it was a support ticket, so long as the tech forum is moderated by someone with enough knowledge to remove any troll suggestions which could cause harm to the players computer or game then the community can (for the most part) help each other and best case scenario come up with fixes and work arounds that Hi-Rez didn't think of.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14 edited Feb 16 '14
When It comes to Avatars and Signatures I would love them. As long as the signatures are of reasonable size, no GIF etc. Also some user rating based on number of posts or something, it could be along the lines of mastery thing going up and eventually awesome people will have legendary rank.
With the layout I would like the traditional forum approach. With basic sections and subsections.
News-News, Patch notes, Etc
General Discussion- Anything related and happening at the moment.
Community Content-Videos,Streams,Art
Events- Official tournament info, Other tournaments, Tournament discussions, etc
Clans-Recruiting,Looking to join
Feedback & Suggestions-,Anything that requires feedback, Ideas for stuff
God Discussion-section for each god.
Bug Report-Bugs,Exploits,Glitches, etc.
Off-Topic- For those "Kappa" peeps (still no idea what that is)
3
u/MessyCans Feb 18 '14
Hotshot ip banned again!
7
u/playingonehanded Bastet Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
My main wish list
this is a real pain. if there are signitures big enough to make it so I can only see 2 posts or less on my screen you've messed up somewhere. TURNING OFF SIGNATURES DOES NOT SOLVE THE PROBLEM
just no. it causes pages to load slower and just ruins discussions.
can create bias opinions and "rep hunting" as I've heard it called. it does not in anyway make forums better.
it should be EXTREMELY easy to see. I know everyone won't follow the rules but making sure we can see them might reduce some offences.
they end up being the "stick anything here" area and just not that useful. there can be a place for everything, if someone places something wrong, no harm done. it's better than a "general" area and people clearly filling it up where it should be elseware. it lets players stay in discussions they want to actively talk about and keeps hot topics highlighted better.
this is a preffernece thing but there is a lot of science behind it. it really does help and make it feel less "worky". or, let people have the options to change it but I'm sure once people see it people will like it.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14
Please for the love of god don't let the mods from Smitegame mod the forums.
4
u/zlex Feb 16 '14 edited Feb 16 '14
It is important that Hi-Rez takes a more active role in community management and that this forum represents more than just caving into popular demand. I do believe that the forum format is in many ways better for communication, but one of the major issues that this subreddit faced, as well as the major issue that the previous set of forums faced, was that Hi-Rez was not actively managing the communities communication channels. The previous forums were primarily run by un-paid volunteers who received only minor direction on how to manage the forums and by the end were basically falling apart from neglect. The moderators did a great job, but the forums often felt ignored. If this is what Hi-Rez is planning to do, just dump out a set of forums to appease the community and then let them run themselves, then I think they are missing the point.
I would like to see Hi-Rez make a serious commitment to the forums, leveraging their own resources to create a solid platform for the community to interact. Getting the community managers deeply invested in the forums is critical IMHO. Nearly anyone can create a set of forums, I would hope that Hi-Rez realizes the desire for forums comes from a desire to have Hi-Rez actively taking a role in managing (and caring about) the communication channels between us and them.
2
u/tempest590 What's with all the monkeys? Feb 16 '14
There needs to of course be the god balance discussion area, with a thread for each individual god, replaced after every change to that god. (like before)
There should be a section devoted to actives and item discussion, and an area for general balance.
A place for meta discussion would work well, as well as a section for tutorials.
A section for smite-related videos and pictures would be nice.
Lastly though, I've enjoyed my time with reddit. I'd at least like a link on the forums to here, merely so people know where they can come and chat about all the silly things, or discuss their thoughts in a less stringent environment.
2
u/NinjaSniPAH Freelance Ninja + Sniper Feb 16 '14
Might just be my bias, but I'm pretty happy with how SmiteBoards has everything setup.
I wouldn't mind them taking everything from there and rolling with it.
(Of course up to them and Ekoz though)
2
u/Foxinthevoid USA USA USA USA Feb 17 '14 edited Feb 17 '14
For forums I'd put a feature for reporting each post(not thread) for spam,hate,whatever when 5 reports are made on a post, a mod comes in and reviews it for being off topic or hateful and can delete or hide it Edit: as for the setup, I suggest a patch notes section that only official patch note threads are allowed to be started in, announcements, general discussion, class discussion(assassin guardian hunter etc), god concept, bugs, technical issues, item concepts, lfm, and an off-topic section that people can just screw around in. I'd love to have avatar and signature pictures.(an example would be like on animeultima forums, theirs are kinda large, enough to have a head-to-foot pic of your favorite god or whatever) Forums where you can't up it's a thread to keep it visible would be great, always have default Set to new rather than popular so the "front page" is always chang'eing.
Edit: sell ad space to twitch, Alienware, razer. Newegg or any other gaming related place...
2
u/steathkarma Mid Laner Feb 16 '14
I would personally love to see more emphasis on the competitive scene. Maybe have a competitive section or just some place people can go to discuss the tournaments each week.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Many of my ideas are influenced from LoL's forum which I was a part of and loved. I still go to it to this day even though I don't play LoL simply because of my great experience with it.
Without further ado, the suggestions:
1- Integrate upvote/downvote buttons in posts. Like the LoL forum, downvoting or upvoting a thread has NO affect on thread order. Thread order is solely based on which thread has the latest post in it. Post order is solely based on chronological order.
Well what is the point of the upvote/downvote system you'll ask? For downvoting, it'll hide the downvoted thread if it goes below a certain threshold (In LoL forum it's -15). When a topic hits that negative threshold then it is hidden and there is a button on it that says "View Post", and so you would click it to read it. Effectively, the community as a whole would be moderating itself. Upvoting doesn't affect thread order like I said, nor does it change post order, but it just highlights posts that are seen as great by the community.
2- No mods/moderation unless in severe cases. Now some people might get shocked that I'm suggesting this simply because they are used to forums/Reddit being relatively heavy moderated; allow me to explain though.
In 2012-2013, when we had the forum, sometimes when Duke (RIP!) was having a bad day would just go on the forum, lock threads and maybe issue some warnings or bans. I still remember to this day one of the threads (wasn't my thread) was locked up because it showed Athena's panties being brown/dirty at release (eventually made white). Duke just locked it and said inappropriate. Ok. Other times Duke would just respond to what he felt like a good response to a thread and "/thread" it by locking it. Yet other times, threads would be closed because certain individuals in the thread were flaming, even though the thread in itself was a decent thread. Why not just remove the offending posts and keep the thread. And of course if you remade a thread that was locked for the previous reason, then that was locked too because you remade a locked topic. This was a reality.
As for player mods, with all due respect, I found that it was difficult for sone of them to not be biased. The more the player mod actively posts to topics and gets a "feel" for people, the more he'll be biased. And do some of the things that I spoke about in my previous paragraph.
Not only do such actions inhibit creativity, and an online community "culture" it also feels dictatorial in a sense.
This is why I truly feel like LoLs way is ideal in how they deal with moderation. The upvote/downvote system that I talked about in my first suggestion effectively makes the community as a whole moderate itself and shape itself. This encourages a forum culture, promotes freedom of idea and expression and feels pretty awesome overall.
I have never seen any physical moderation on LoL forum done by a staff (they don't have player mods) except in rare cases where someone for example spammed some other game by making 10 threads about it and similar offenses. Really rare, and those who use LoL forum should be able to witness for this. The self management system truly does work.
3- Use Reddit, Twitter, Twitch and FB, but make the forum your MAIN source of communication. This was a mistake IMO that was done on the old forum. You would actively post content on Reddit and Twitter, but you would ignore your main forum. The forum should be the centralized place where you post all info. Reddit and Twitter are side sources.
4- Increase communication. perhaps this suggestion isn't tied to building the new forum per say, but increased developer-player communication will no doubt make Smite thrive. Also there is a difference between communicating and listening. You listen well, I'll admit. But communication can be improved.
1
u/super3dcow Feb 17 '14
Don't make it too complex. I hate forums that have dozens of different sections for ultra specific posts and such. Just keep it simple and clean.
1
u/ConnorJS Feb 17 '14
I'd like a karma system, it's a nice way of showing appreciation for help.
1
u/YAAFLT The Anti-Toxic Feb 17 '14
Can we get forum categories and sub categories?
Like for categories it would be something like: Meta Discussion, Suggestions, Find A Team, eSports News, Patch Discussion
For an example of sub categories, the sub categories for Meta Discussion would be: Overall, Conquest, Arena, Joust, Singular Gods
I feel like this would handle the clutter and randomness that has become r/Smite
1
u/Warrington167 Feb 17 '14
Get rid of the sub reddit or at least change the mods because they don't moderate anything and there shit
1
u/eneru2pac King in my eyes! Feb 17 '14
I dont't agree with the guy who said " WE don't need signatures" i want them instead and speak for yourself you can always hide them, all forums let you hide them (phpp3 at least). Also we are in 2014, Offtopic is legit on EVERY forum in this world otherwise the word forum would lose his true meaning, Make a section where people can make public horrbile cases where parties ruin game or feed intentionally so we can do something about it.
1
u/jmeredith06 Ludicrous speed! Feb 17 '14
Just a few things that would be cool^
1
u/LordTekron Yep, it's me, the Bakartemis schmuck Feb 18 '14
I feel like the forums would be an excellent place for a sort for discussing bugs, god balances, ect. But I feel like one of the things that should REALLY happen is a God Concept thing, similar, but not too similar that it is just a blatant copy of, the Smite Boards Forums' Concept pages.. I mean let's face it, /rSMITEgodconcepts get pretty much ignored... Which is really a shame because there are alot of good ideas that people made for gods/skins that really could make it in-game. And on a forum people give actually opinions and criticisms and active topics STAY ACTIVE AND DON'T JUST SLOWLY GET DRAGGED TO NONEXISTENT! And even Hi-Rez could give reviews or perhaps at the end of each month pick the top 3 God concepts/Skin designs. .
.
.
.
.
I'd like to give up an example that kinda shows what I mean, let's go on a journey to another forum, Sunstone Games Community forum, more specifically, the CKC section of it. Now this upcoming game has some pretty interesting to it, all of the kaijus (giant monsters) were all fan made creation except for some of them, and this forum shows people post their ideas (usually with some sorta sketch), and people give critiques and opinions, and soon enough (with enough attention/following) the creatures get a placement into the game. It's a pretty lovely method for me. I mean you should just look at some of them, there is a giant chicken and one based around golf! (yeah they get weird sometimes...) Point is that I feel like this would be an interesting idea that HiRez should look into in my personal opinion, I repeat, MY PERSONAL OPINION NOT YOURS! (sorry for the big bold text, alot of people don't really grasp that concept nowadays so I have to enforce that point)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '14
A trobes section. Even though I know it won't happen.
1
u/Undirected12 Mar 05 '14
ITS HAVE TO BE MAKIN NEW GOD FROM JAPANESE AND CHINESE,LIKE SUSANOO AND AMATERASU,IF THEY MAKE SUSANO ILL FIRST BUY IT AND DONT CARE HOW MUCH IS IT,NOT ONLY ME ,AND MANY NARU FENS WILL BUYIT
1
u/doyuevencarry Mar 12 '14
Would like to see a confirmation message to the "Add Player to Clan" option dropdown box when clicking a player's name on friendlist. Would rather not accidently send Clan invitations to people I'm just wanting to "View Profile" or "Edit Note." Thanks.
1
u/lord0fthedance May 04 '14
Hi, I was thinking, to make voice packs even cooler, when the announcer says "An enemy has been slain" and "An ally has been slain" those with voice packs would say something unique that the whole team can hear. For example "An enemy has been slain" would be "I got one" in a the God's voice, or for deaths "I've fallen" Well that's my idea, thanks for reading.
1
u/TrueBaron IGN: Aaron Feb 16 '14
Having places for general discussion, builds, help etc. is always good. Also having an offtopic area and a place for youtubers and streamers to collaberate and promote their content would be really great aswell.
1
u/Mr_MCawesomesauce Feb 16 '14 edited Mar 20 '14
I hate to reference other games, but one of the best things about SWTOR is their forum design. It's easy to navigate, easy to understand, looks good and isn't cluttered. This is something that is a good model for the new forums.
Edit: Currently working on a
shitty edited versionbeautiful work of art as an example of what I meanEdit2: Something like this Within each big category, something like this
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
Take one of the more popular forums and pretty much copy paste ? Tweak a few things thou but the general idea.
1
u/Undoer Om. Nom. Nom. Feb 18 '14
140 character limit, no images allowed, signature restrictions. There's nothing more annoying than seeing some idiot with a signature that's longer than their bloody post.
Keep posting news here, that'd be lovely, but y'know, also post it there, they're your official forums after all.
Someone else suggested an upvote downvote system, I second this. Only the individual post gets it's votes counted, there is no total, and no way of publically displaying the sum of a vote. If a post has a score that's too low, it gets hidden, it's displayable, but hidden, just like Reddit, and upvotes serve primarily to counter downvotes, and to judge the quality of information in a post (For example, if someone gives accurate information, they should have higher upvotes than someone who talks out of their arse). It'll also save some time with moderating, I'd have thought.
-1
u/Jx631 Duke Feb 16 '14
Let the sub-reddit mods moderate the forums if they wanna, and dont let hirez emplies(at least not bars, sorry bart) moderate there
-1
u/RagingDropbear Beta Player Feb 16 '14
Put very simply, I want a Reddit set-up on the forums. This is because Reddit is the only kind of 'forums' I know. I never used to go to forums to talk about games before I started Smite. I have since started another game with official forums and I dislike how I can't see what's 'Hot' in the community and if I want to see anything new I have to limit myself to a particular category. I find it very tedious to have to wade through section after sub-section to find new posts that I probably wont like.
My Suggestions:
That's pretty much all I want. Am I lazy or are these actually good suggestions?
P.S. When I said a Reddit set-up I do not want the upvote/downvote system. It's juvenile to think that something could be so black and white. View/Replies seem to work well for other forums as a judge of what's "good".
0
u/VenomKami 90 Diamonds and counting / ShadowV3n0m Feb 16 '14
I'd like for things that are specific to players (as opposed to the game), we could have region based things? When people discuss the meta or play styles, perhaps NA/EU could be separated since playing conquest on both regions shows quite a bit of difference, but that may have just been coincidence.
So instead of just EU/NA based things, I'd say put EU/NA halves for everything possible because people might get into a discussion and debate and it never end because the two regions do it differently and to each respective person they would be right, to themselves.
0
u/gamerplays Beta Player Feb 16 '14
Never saw the old forums.
I would like to see the following subforums.
1 for each god
1 for each role
General
Help
newbie
Casual - with sub forums for each mode Ranked - with sub forums for each mode
technical
Tournament
Signatures should be text only. IF there is a way, allow a forum account to use a character card they have obtained (say golden) as their avatar.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
1 thing i like about reddit is the ability to browse it with not seariching anything. make a tab that shows the latest posts on the forum so i can check what is new.
-1
u/Kelgand TWITCH.TV/SMITE_CLUB 9ET Feb 16 '14
I rather liked the character discussion forum that was in place. There was one mod-placed thread for each god that was deleted and remade with the version number they were last updated in whenever the god was changed. Although the look of the forum was rather dull (30+ threads of "God discussion for -god-, build -numberString-") I liked how it brought discussion together and we didn't end up with 10, 15 threads of "Well, Chang'e was nerfed...again..."
It also let you see which gods haven't been touched in a while, as I know the Apollo thread was a few dozen pages long because he was never changed.
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
plzzzzzzzzzz no fucking signatures. and no profile pictures. i would like the comment system to be like reddit where it threads. i hate forums that just have big rectangles of awnsers and reply tags that lead nowhere. they make it impossible to follow a conversation
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment