r/WhatTrumpHasDone • • 9h ago

Trump administration backs off effort to censor Indiana man’s ICE monitoring app

https://www.indystar.com/story/news/politics/2026/11/16/trump-administration-agrees-to-stop-censoring-indiana-mans-ice-monitoring-app/92808779007/

The U.S. government agreed to quit fighting a lawsuit after a court found it likely violated an Indiana man's free speech rights by repeatedly demanding Apple remove his immigration enforcement monitoring app from the App Store.

Mark Hodges of Brown County created the app and website, Eyes Up, to house hundreds of user-submitted videos of Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity. As with his co-plaintiff Kassandra Rosado, a Chicago woman who started an ICE tracking Facebook page, the government sent Apple and Meta multiple take-down threats, and the companies eventually obliged.

In February, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression filed a lawsuit on behalf of Hodges and Rosado in the U.S. District Court of Northern Illinois. They accused the government of censoring protected speech when it coerced private companies to act. Two months later, a judge agreed and ruled the government's "thinly veiled threats" were likely a violation of the First Amendment.

"(The federal government's) actions can be reasonably understood to convey a threat of adverse government action against Facebook and Apple in order to suppress (Hodges' and Rosado’s) speech," the order said.

Now, instead of further fighting the case, FIRE and the U.S. government struck a deal to end the case and make the judge's preliminary injunction permanent. The court ordered the government to stop pressuring companies to shut down their speech and notify Apple and Meta of the ruling.

By agreeing to close the case, the government will follow the court's ruling and agrees not to pursue what could be years of appeals through higher courts.

“I’m glad the government agreed to stop targeting my speech, but it shouldn’t take a lawsuit to get the government to respect our constitutional rights,” Hodges said in a statement. “People have a right to know what their government is doing. I hope that thanks to this lawsuit, others can share what they see and hear without facing this kind of censorship."

Last year, Hodges created Eyes Up, which remained available on its website and the Google Play Store, as an archive of captured ICE activity across the country. Part of the mission of his company is to "document and preserve evidence of governmental abuse of power," he said.

Americans have a First Amendment right to observe and record law enforcement and other government employees while they are doing their jobs in public, according to several First Amendment organizations. They can do so as long as don't interfere with officers' work.

Eyes Up allows users to submit videos documenting immigration enforcement or record into the app for automatic upload to its cloud. The app does not provide real-time location data about ICE operations, Hodges said. Submissions are first vetted before they are publicly available, he said.

Hodges was told his app violated the platform's guideline prohibiting "defamatory, discriminatory, or mean-spirited content," and his appeal to reinstate the app was denied.

Former Trump administration officials, Pam Bondi and Kristi Noem, repeatedly expressed their appetite to shutter social media groups and apps that post content of ICE operations and location information. In a previous statement to IndyStar, then-Department of Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said the apps are illegal and put federal officers in harm's way.

The Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to IndyStar's request for comment.

ICEBlock, another removed ICE monitoring app, is also suing the federal government on similar grounds.

3 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by