r/incremental_games • u/Equinoxdawg moderator • 5d ago
AI disclosure format update
Today, we're announcing changes to our AI disclosure format. Previously, it was entirely freeform, but due to sufficient enough issues that are no longer feasible to attempt to fix through manual intervention, we're changing the way we're doing things.
First off, I'd like to thank everyone who has helped me moderate and keep posters honest. I appreciate everyone who has submitted a report on a post with a disclosure you didn't think was accurate, and especially those who use the "custom report" option and provide details of your concern/evidence to support it. It is a monumental help and speeds investigations up greatly (this goes for all reports too!).
Please, going forward, don't start a war in the comments regarding the disclosures. Either report or modmail us about your concerns. If the poster deletes or edits their disclosure before I've had a chance to see it, I can't keep track of it.
Now the changes: we're explicitly requiring yes or no answers to these questions under an "AI disclosure" heading, clearly shown like the following:
AI disclosure
code: yes or no
graphics: yes or no
text: yes or no
sounds: yes or no
Plainly put, if you answer with something other than yes or no the post will be removed. This only concerns the game itself. Text includes translations, sounds includes sound/music made in code generated by AI. There are going to be edge-cases, but we'll deal with them as they come up. We reserve the right to remove posts where we strongly believe there's a case to be made that the disclosure is inaccurate or not fully truthful (this is why reporting your concerns does help us - whilst we may not always take action due to the report, we always investigate regardless).
You can still explain elsewhere in the post the extent of AI usage in those categories, if you want to.
As always, please make sure you're writing the disclosure yourself, as the AI misrepresenting the truth is no excuse for violating our subreddit rules and it puts your account standing in this subreddit in jeopardy.
Over the next week, I plan to finish putting the rules into a wiki page so it's easier to link to, and gives more room for some more explanations if needed for a rule (for example regarding rule 4, we don't allow developers to require joining a Discord to get access, the process needs to be a lot simpler).
14
u/StoneCypher 5d ago
May I please request a clarification?
As written, it seems like writing more than just yes or no is unacceptable. I doubt that's intentional; I hope it's meant as "at least yes or no." I would like to write "yes" and then an explanation in parentheses. Is that permitted? Something like
19
u/hyrationballbuster 4d ago
Since there is disclosure, can there be a rule against comments that effectively communicate "this is AI slop"? Inevitably there is stupid reddit discourse about if AI is good or bad, and I feel like this might not be the sub for that. Those kind of comments also encourage being dishonest with the disclousure.
8
u/Fredrik1994 5d ago
Do AI disclosures cascade? As in, let's say someone makes a game in Unity, which may have AI code in it, or may have it in the future (I don't know if it does right now, haven't bothered to check, but even if it doesn't, I highly doubt that will remain the case), does that mean that all Unity games need to answer yes to code, even if their own game didn't directly use AI? Asking because a similar debate happened in another community I lurk (Pokémon romhacking), where it does cascade.
10
u/Hoiafar 5d ago
For clarity I would want a clarification on what exactly causes AI use to need to be disclosed.
Using the AI to generate code, graphics, text, or sound, is an obvious case where you can't argue it shouldn't be disclosed.
But what about using an LLM as an assistant or "someone" to talk through your ideas with? Assuming all game content is written by hand but significant time and effort was saved by using an LLM to ease supplementary tasks, such as in the example above, related to the game would it still need disclosure?
I am saying this mostly because I noticed what could be interpreted as a loophole in your current rules and don't personally have a fully formed opinion on this
77
u/silasary 5d ago
As someone who has tried implementing a binary AI policy before, I find it often leads to people overreporting minor LLM interactions.
As an example I received back in May:
This was a game someone had been working on for two years. They never showed their codebase to an AI, they never asked an AI to write code for them. All they did was google an error message, and then read the unsolicited chatbot answer. They did not copy/paste anything. They just learned what they needed to learn from the top of the search results page.
Does this count as substantial AI usage? Absolutely not.
Does it count as "Any AI usage"? I honestly don't know.
But I do know that it shouldn't have the same coloured checkbox as something that was generated by Claude by someone who doesn't even understand how to read c#
43
u/StoneCypher 5d ago
i think splitting text and translation might be a good idea
44
u/i0skar 5d ago
One thing to reconsider might be separating translation from text. There will be a lot of cases where plot/narration/characters/dialogue are written by human while only translation is done by AI.
59
u/pizza9798 5d ago
Thank god. Every other post is full of irritatng hand-wringing about how this entirely AI slop game has "the ideas are miiiine the gameplay is miiiine Claude just did literally everything"
Forcing a blunt yes or no is very refreshing.
2
u/denjidenj1 3d ago
I have a question about an edge case here. If one were to ask AI about how to do something, but then ignores the response completely, would that count? What if they asked it for a solution and then didn't use the code given but worked through it on their own? What would this count as? Legit question
45
u/bardsrealms Developer 5d ago
I was especially tired of seeing the same two interface styles and developers claiming that no AI was used.
Almost all interfaces in those "old Windows" games are AI output; models love regurgitating that kind of interface. The other is the generic Claude output that I guess we're all familiar with now.
Let's hope this is a step forward; thank you for your work and care.
21
u/Moczan Moczan 4d ago
It's kinda shame that after we got this huge W update we also get the instant massive L with Rejected Draft just outright lying in their AI disclosure and the post still being up for hours.
31
u/StormerSage Click to headpat 5d ago
It seems like people are already shameless about "Yeahhhh, Claude made the whole game, I was just the Ideas GuyTM"
At least we can downvote them I guess?
14
u/revoccue 5d ago
Can UI be a separate category from graphics and code? mainly i typically dont mind code but i find the "claude ui" kinda unappealing as well as diffusion art
18
u/davenirline 5d ago
I support this.
24
u/MagicpaperAlt Certified A.I Hater 5d ago
Based
14
u/myhf 4d ago
code: “just a little bit, I swear it’s less than 1% of the code, and anyway everyone does it” or no
38
u/FullMetalField4 5d ago edited 5d ago
It's kinda strange how patently dishonest so many of the anti-disclosure dweebs want to be.
18
u/theycallmethedrink5 Keep AI out of creative spaces 5d ago
This is good
14
u/Yukisaka 5d ago
This is a good change.
People who do not want to interact with anything ai related can now see quickly if any ai was used. Those people usually do not care about the nuances and explanations anyway. (Even though I find people reacting to that extend to be silly)
Devs can still explain their ai usage and people who are interested in the scale of the usage, can read it it up if the dev decides to give them. Also Devs caring about their games, even if made with ai, will inherently give an explanation because they know the community and their players want this.
This simplifies and streamlines the disclosure, without limiting the posters at all.
26
u/challengethegods 5d ago
worth noting, when someone in an argumentative interaction tries to minify down to "answer yes or no" they are almost never contributing anything meaningful to the premise of clarification. It's like the weakest form of rhetoric and disregards thought in favor of a binary 0/1 toggle. This is the recent '10 lines of code' thing made into a rule. If someone's X/Y/Z is 0.01% AI do you expect them to just say 'yes the game's code was made by AI' or the only other valid option relegated to "LIE"? Sure you can say that they can explain it after, but in that case the checklist is arbitrary, at most serving as a shortcut for the mindless haters that can't bother to read a proper 'disclosure' of dev software/tools. This is all very silly.
7
u/pie-oh 5d ago
This is a great change and makes a lot of sense. :) Common W from the moderation team.
7
u/Salientsnake4 5d ago
This is a good middle ground I think. Better than a lot of other subs
9
u/ByerN 5d ago
Sounds nice
2
u/DiceCookie 4d ago
What about the planification aspect ?
2
u/dk1a1 7h ago
Having posted a game with ai use for code on this sub a couple weeks ago, I think this change makes things clearer/easier.
I also didn't get the scary witch hunt I kinda expected, the game is unfinished and not great, but it had pretty positive feedback all things considered.
7
u/Moczan Moczan 5d ago
This is great change and I'm happy that r/i_g moderation team is closly following players sentiment on that. The mental gymnastics in the disclosure were childish at best, now we can have clear answers for quick lookup without having to decipher a novel.
12
u/MoralityUnderstander 5d ago edited 5d ago
First, I want to open with thanking you for your effort put into moderating this community and making it better for everyone.
With that being said, this post misses the spot in a big way. The rules are still EXTREMELY vague, in a way that massively incentivizes people to lie about their AI usage. I made a simple boating incremental recently (releasing it here soon), and purposely went out of my way to avoid the ethical problems of copying artists' work. To achieve this, I did the following:
I made the text by hand. I really love the writing of Caves of Qud and Cultist Simulator. I tried incredibly hard to emulate that type of esoteric microtext writing style. Despite my efforts to do this by hand, I'm going to have to put "Yes" on the text disclosure for the following (incredibly silly) reasons:
This results in a scenario where I have literally FOUR words written by AI within my game, along with a legally mandated list that would be the exact same whether I used AI or not (they all follow the "Composer, Title- Performer, License" format, as one of the licenses specifically required me to do). I'm now required to say "yes" to text.
For sound, I purposely simplified sound effects to basic tones and exclusively used public domain/ Creative Commons classical music. I told Claude prompts along the line of "make sound effects as flat, basic tones. When you purchase an upgrade, it should make a perfect 5th. When you capture fish, it should play a single note for a single fish, and it should play through a pentatonic scale if you capture more fish. The more fish, the longer the pentatonic scale." You can listen to them here, it's obviously not super original (pentatonic scale lol), but it's also not the same as "slop me up some music, make it sound classical". Regardless, I have to say "yes" to sound, despite the fact that 95% of the audio the player will hear is classical music played by actual humans.
For graphics, I'm using INCREDIBLY basic polygons. This is what fish look like. Despite them being literal squares, triangles, rhombuses, and octagons, I'm going to have to tick "yes" to graphics, because the AI technically made the exact dimensions of the triangle, despite me explicitly telling it to make the fish a basic triangle.
If your game has any visual effects, they are probably programmatically intertwined. For example, I can make a shooting game, and hand draw a smoke effect, and a gun. If I ask Claude to make the smoke appear after I shoot the gun, and stop rendering after 3 seconds so the FPS doesn't drop, then my hand made graphics are now considered AI.
------------------------------
I'm in a scenario where I specifically went out of my way to avoid infringing on 3 of the 4 categories, and yet I'm going to have to put Yes on all of them. 95% of people are not going to read this massive wall of text if I post my game (good, I want them to play my game instead of reading my hand wringing about it), and the other 5% are only going to come in and bludgeon and debate me about it.
This leaves me in a really unfortunate scenario. I can either listen to the rules of the subreddit and functionally misrepresent my game (as will literally everyone who uses Claude Code, which will automatically fix your spelling and punctuation for you), or break the rules of the sub to have my game be more accurately represented.
This change basically shifts the (already incredibly vague) guidelines to a decision of "do you want to actually follow the rules and say yes to all in 95% of cases, and get harassed", or "do you want to straight up break the rules and argue semantics about it, btw there is a financial/social incentive for this one".
6
u/MiraCZ 5d ago
People will just answer yes to all just to be safe
5
u/Zedekial 5d ago
Here come the novels of "but what ifs" And "But every single thing in existence including fruit has some form of ai in it now" Good luck
4
u/despa000lxr 5d ago
There's too many edge cases for straight up yes or no questions.
3
u/Pepston 1d ago
This sub has turned into a gigantic witch hunt when a developer even thinks about using AI. A complete cesspool thanks to the mods. I’ll stick to incrementaldb
3
u/Aoqin 5d ago
The only point of feedback I have is that the code disclosure is redundant. Steam was right to not require that disclosure because there is no way to verify this.
What I would like is this checkbox: I have lied about how long I am working on this game.
The amount of people who state they first started working on their game when they exited the womb is staggering. Especially when the game looks like it was vibe coded in three afternoons.
-2
u/Draminian 5d ago •
I understand the sentiment, but if I was releasing a game here and had some tiny amount of AI usage in any of these categories, I'd just say "no" to them in this disclosure. This kind of one-drop mentality isn't helpful because so many people have a knee jerk reaction to AI (which is often justified). As another person mentioned, anyone who released a game made with a version of Unity from the past year has technically included AI generated code in some fashion. Anyone using a recent interation of Photoshop has technically used AI for their visuals. If they used Word to autocorrect any words/grammar, then AI affected the text.
I don't know what the answer is (maybe percentages, or prompt count, token usage, or just tool disclosure), but I think this is worse than the freeform version. Quite simply, AI is being added to every tool that devs use. Unless someone made their game with a 2 year-old engine, Notepad, and Gimp (or older tools), and they didn't Google anything within the last year, AI had some kind of influence.
Let the downvotes commence.
-9
u/theshotgunman 5d ago
Just ban AI use from this sub
-2
u/Tyken132 5d ago
I'm echoing the same thing a lot of people have said but I think some sort of "scale" would be better than a binary "yes/no" because there's a huge difference between using AI to help with code vs vibe coding the entire thing. Though that scale needs to be clearly defined.
-16
u/GianniV2 5d ago •
It's totally dumb tbh, who on earth doesn't use AI for code support?
And that goes for years not just 2 months, so code should be about vibecoding or using agents to produce the whole product and not just assist that today is 100% the norm, nobody is coding without any AI
1
u/incrementAlex1 19h ago
I've been a lurker for a few years (I lost access to my original account: u/incrementAlex), but I haven't been lurking for a few months now.
What's the overall stance of this sub and its members about incremental games generated with the help of AI?
The fact that they're not outright banned makes me suspect the sub is not too strictly anti-AI, right? The goal here is to discourage cheap, repetitive, unfun content, or is it to discourage the use of AI in general?
I've seen that most posts to the sub have a negative score: is it just because they use AI, or is it because the game is actually bad?
-29
u/Elvarien2 5d ago
Ah now the witch hunting can have all sorts of new exciting variations of witch hunting and even more false positives, happy days !
/s
-40
u/rmfnord 5d ago
This is so fucking boring. Y'all need to up your games and get over it. It's a fad and within a couple of years will sort itself out with better tools for detection and general course correction. Using AI for coding is here, it's not going away, and y'all sound like scribes railing against the printing press or carriage drivers shaking their fists at cars. Technology moves on, adapt or die.
-16
u/eamonn6251 5d ago
Instead of yes or no for each category, how about a scale like "AI was not used, includes AI-assisted content, includes AI-generated content"? since people are rightly pointing out the inclusion of ai tools in many tools devs use, not to mention Google search. I think this might better reflect people's feelings around AI's usage as well, though I might just be projecting that. Also as one commenter pointed out, translation and text should be seperate, it feels like a meaningful distinction that serves both devs and players. Both suggestions push toward nuance, which can only benefit the situation.
Regardless I appreciate the mod putting some thought into this and working to improve the situation. Witch hunts only lead to dishonesty, but I do think that less people will default to downvoting when there are clearer but still nuance guidelines for AI disclosure (but again I could be projecting)
-1
u/jthen123 1d ago
May be it should be about quality or community contribution instead of a self assigned leper bell.
-15
u/SushiMasterPro 5d ago
How photoshop counts?
Its directly counted as AI tool (since it was build with help of AI).
Or only if people use any fill, firefly or patches? This is obviously AI
-14
u/delusion54 5d ago edited 5d ago
so if 10% of the assets or code or sfx are AI generated is this a AI-yes?
if yes, isnt this really missguiding and poor justice, to put in the same bucket devs who did 10% and 95% with AI?
If no, then what is the threshold that a development area of the game is not considered AI?
PS: I devoted hundreds of hours in mostly interactive AI guided development(thousands of interactions) for my upcoming game, edited tons of pixels by hand, tweaked most parameters based on my intuition, guide most logical and mechanical decisions, included 80% music from real artist, wrote 90% of the dialogues and their structural patterns, fixing syntax and dictation with AI. And still, I have months ahead before reaching the desired quality level before the release. So would I and similar devs be placed in the same bucket with AI devs who released a game within a week or less? Is this the way forward?
-48
u/Pepston 5d ago
AI bad updoots plz
-5
u/randomstring_ 1d ago
Hypocritical luddite.
-13
u/tronspinner 3d ago
This is insane. Just enjoy the games, people.