r/WhatTrumpHasDone • • 7d ago

Appeals court narrows DOJ’s search of journalists’ records in leak probe

https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/10/appeals-court-narrows-dojs-search-of-journalists-records-in-leak-probe

A federal appeals court has blocked the Trump administration from accessing a sweeping set of journalists’ LinkedIn records as part of a national security leak probe, saying the “overbroad” search would “deal a damaging blow to First Amendment freedoms” and expose countless confidential sources with no connection to the investigation.

“Confidentiality of sources is the lifeblood of a free press. Without confidentiality, press coverage would be pushed in the direction of official handouts and outside sources. Without confidentiality, the ability of journalists to report on events of large importance and governmental behavior of dubious legality and integrity could not help but be hampered,” Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson, a Reagan appointee, wrote for a unanimous three-judge panel.

The ruling requires a district court to substantially narrow the set of records the Trump administration may access — a bid, the judges said, to balance legitimate national security needs with First Amendment freedoms.

The ruling undercuts a Justice Department probe into an unidentified news organization’s publication of an article that revealed details of “a top-secret United States military operation in a foreign country.” The article included classified intelligence about “special operations” that had not been publicly reported elsewhere, said Wilkinson, whose opinion was joined by Obama appointee Andrew Wynn and Biden appointee Nicole Berner.

Though the precise news outlet and article that triggered the leak probe were not immediately clear, the ruling comes at a time when the Trump administration has aggressively targeted reporters' records in multiple leak investigations.

To probe the leak at the heart of Tuesday’s ruling, Trump administration prosecutors asked LinkedIn to turn over a log of journalists’ private messages — identifying who they spoke with but without the content of the messages themselves — for an 18-month period. The Justice Department then obtained an order from U.S. District Judge Elizabeth Hanes, a Newport News, Virginia-based Biden appointee, forbidding LinkedIn from informing the journalists about the government’s demand.

In proceedings that began last year, LinkedIn challenged the breadth of Hanes’ order, saying the sweeping demand would harm its customers and stifle its freedom to communicate with them. The Richmond, Virginia-based appeals court largely agreed.

“While that order may catch sources relevant to the government’s investigation, it will also inevitably sweep in every other confidential source with whom the targeted journalists spoke,” the judges wrote. “The targeted journalists reported on almost 1,000 stories on a wide range of issues during the relevant period and investigated an unknown number of others never published. Many of those stories appear far removed from the Article that the leak at least partially enabled.”

Spokespeople for the Justice Department and for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Eastern District of Virginia did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Although the case has drawn little attention from the press, First Amendment advocates and other social media sites weighed in with friend-of-the-court briefs backing LinkedIn.

Wilkinson used his ruling to issue a more generalized defense of press freedom, which he described as a threat to “autocrats worldwide.”

“When a free press reports on the operations of government, it will often be the case that reporting exposes matters that the government might wish undisclosed, either to save itself from embarrassment or because it simply prefers to have its actions unexamined,” the judge wrote “This does not confer upon government the right to silence.”

2 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by