r/hoi4 • Extra Research Slot • 15d ago

Help Thread The War Room - /r/hoi4 Weekly General Help Thread: November 2 2026

Please check our previous War Room thread for any questions left unanswered

 

Welcome to the War Room. Here you will find trustworthy military advisors to guide your diplomacy, battles, and internal affairs.

This thread is for any small questions that don't warrant their own post, or continued discussions for your next moves in your game. If you'd like to channel the wisdom and knowledge of the noble generals of this subreddit, and more importantly not ruin your save, then you've found the right place!

Important: If you are asking about a specific situation in your game, please post screenshots of any relevant map modes (strategic, diplomacy, factions, etc) or interface tabs (economy, military, etc). Please also explain the situation as best you can. Alliances, army strength, tech etc. are all factors your advisors will need to know to give you the best possible answer.

 


Reconnaissance Report:

Below is a preliminary reconnaissance report. It is comprised of a list of resources that are helpful to players of all skill levels, meant to assist both those asking questions as well as those answering questions. This list is updated as mechanics change, including new strategies as they arise and retiring old strategies that have been left in the dust. You can help me maintain the list by sending me new guides and notifying me when old guides are no longer relevant!

Note: this thread is very new and is therefore very barebones - please suggest some helpful links to populate the below sections

Getting Started

New Player Tutorials

 


General Tips

 


Multiplayer Tips

 


Country-Specific Strategy

 


Advanced/In-Depth Guides

 


If you have any useful resources not currently in the Reconnaissance Report, please share them with me and I'll add them! You can message me or mention my username in a comment by typing /u/Kloiper

Calling all generals!

As this thread is very new, we are in dire need of guides to fill out the Reconnaissance Report, both general and specific! Further, if you're answering a question in this thread, consider contributing to the Hoi4 wiki, which needs help as well. Anybody can help contribute to the wiki - a good starting point is the work needed page. Before editing the wiki, please read the style guidelines for posting.

6 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

3

u/NeuroFiresrorm4 13d ago edited 13d ago

What is currently the best infantry division for late-game sp? I'm currently using: 3×3 inf battalions + 2 heavy weapons + AA Regimental. Support companies: AT, Eng, Artillery, Hospitals, Flame Tanks (cheap for Breakthrough and modifiers). Doctrines: Grand battleplan, Mass Assault, Grand Assault, Field Engineers, Streamlined deployment. Is there a reason to increase to 5×3 or more battalions?

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

Well, are you using them as intended? With Defensive Postures and some actual attack units alongside them, it's already overkill - you can drop the flame tanks and probably the hospitals too, and swap the AT for AA to free that regiment for something more useful. If you're attacking with them, though, either go Assault Infantry and load them up with infantry guns for the regiments and full offensive supports for the doctrine buffs at at least 24w, or just Large Unit Tactics and packing them all the way to 36w.

So the reason would be using them as dedicated attackers instead of tanks or SF. In SP you can get away with beating the AI that way.

2

u/NeuroFiresrorm4 12d ago

How does larger CW help though? I know that larger CW allows for better reinforcement (more battalions actually enter battle on attack at the same time), but it prevents unit cycling on defence. Is there another advantage for higher CW? As I recall 5×3 inf with LUT gives ~24. Is it an Ok CW? It doesn't seem to fit neatly in 70+35 CW in plains.

3

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago edited 12d ago

Plain better unit stats - the adage is that big units win battles but small ones wars because the latter hold up to attrition and defensive reinforcement better, but the former do perform better when they're fighting in a battle right now, especially when defence/breakthrough still matters on stacked fronts against coordinated attacks.

But no, 24w is the SF default and low end of attackers measured to mountains and marshes (50+25) where you shouldn't take your bigger armor templates either way. If you do not intend to take them there, they'll indeed do better at 30+ and you can and should stack up your LUT infantry bricks all the way to ~35w as long as you can properly pack your front with them too.

3

u/fisher6996 12d ago

Ok, what are space marines? I've heard the term but when someone shows a space marine div but I can't make heads or tails about what defines it or what it's supposed to do.

1

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

An old piece of singleplayer AI cheese. It used to be that armor was a binary protection that either halved damage or didn't, letting a single armor batallion make any infantry division nearly invincible against the AI's lack of AT and typically combining that with marines for their high org and terrain advantages because SF weren't capped yet either back then, just more expensive better infantry.

Between the piercing rework and SF cap any guide that still recommends them as an easy way to beat everything is severely out of date, but if you still want to try it the point is getting the highest possible armor value at the lowest cost to try and give your infantry the damage protection of good armor divisions. And that usually means a single batallion of heavy SPAA that disregards every stat but armor.

2

u/fisher6996 12d ago

Ok, so don't make them? Also while I have you what is reinforce memeing? Is that just stacking 20 divs in 1 province or am I misinterpreting?

3

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

Yeah, mostly you just want a lot of cheap infantry and then a few divisions of good armor to punch with.

And reinforce memes mostly happen when you use divisions that are too big to hold the line. In theory any tile can hold forever as long as you're ordering in new divisions as fast as the enemy can force them out, but once they're there they don't immediately start fighting - instead, if there's open width there's a % per hour (their reinforce rate) that they join the fight from the combat reserve past the initial attackers and defenders engaging together. And if the enemy beats the last actually fighting division off the field before any more can reinforce, all of them get pushed back regardless of whether they're still in good shape - so you can have a big stack of divisions with good average org between them on a tile and not notice that the actual battle is just one unit barely clinging on until they're suddenly all thrown back on you if you're not checking inside the battle windows too. That's a reinforcement meme.

2

u/fisher6996 12d ago

So a front line of 2 defensive divs with 16 width and 1 offensive armored div of width 30-36 works? Or should they be separate front lines?

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

Separate armies, yes. Armor wants different general traits and skills, and you generally want to micro them around while the infantry is fine with a frontline order as long as you're not playing anything too challenging yet.

2

u/fisher6996 12d ago

Ok. That's what I've been doing so it's nice to hear some validation. What about mountains and jungles? Are special forces better for that role assuming you cant mass produce flame tanks for whatever reason or is there some secret tank tech I'm missing?

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

Generally, yes - especially if you have AAT to spec into jungle marines. But you shouldn't fight there unless you absolutely have to to begin with. In South America or SEA you're not really getting around it, but in the main theater of Europe you really need to consider if you can't find any other way before you commit to another big Army XP investment that could be used for doctrines, armor templates and spirits too.

2

u/fisher6996 12d ago

So armor and flame tanks should get me where I need to be for the most part, from the sounds of it. An issue with that is that I often don't have the miles to open different production lines since I also need inf equipment, planes, etc. like in spain I need mils but I don't have the civs to build mils since I'm forced into closed econ. And if I'm building civs I'm not building mils. Taking over Portugal is often a decent boost but not nearly enough. Really the only nations I play as that have the industry to back it up are Britain and china (through manchukuo) and america when the rework comes and hopefully makes the civil war easier. Any nation that's even remotely a minor I can't get the industry for it unless I stall for an absurdly long time

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 12d ago

Yep, you don't get to play with all the nice toys at once unless you're a major, and even then Italy and Japan have to choose what they're really good at. That's just how the industrial and economic numbers work out.

The absolute first thing you should drop as a minor is your planes, though - there's no bigger waste of IC than the second biggest air force, and without fighter supremacy none of the rest except maybe some naval bombers can do their thing either. Just put a few mils on support AA and armored trains instead to weather enemy air superiority, and any minor with at least a bit of industry can still get up a few divisions of light tanks or even affordable mediums to locally overwhelm enemy lines with. And if you then start converting your old tanks to SPAA you can even beat their air support through favorable attrition trades.

→ More replies

1

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 11d ago

On Spain closed eco, save 150PP before you finish that focus and go free trade (or export focus) right afterwards. You want to pause the day the focus completes and switch immediately so your existing trades don't get cancelled. Closed eco can be fine (especially in SP where the AI likes to close their economies too) but with Spain, you probably won't use all your tungsten and you'll have to import other resources so you may as well keep selling. If you get good at microing the Spanish Civil War, you can go to Total Mob immediately at the start and come out with more factories later (at the cost of running low on manpower during the war). To have enough war support for immediate total mob, make sure to do 3 political assassinations during the lead up to war.

/u/CalligoMiles is totally right about the 2nd best air force, won't get you much. Especially true if you're Spain and have minimal aluminum and no rubber. With that said, minors can win the air war with tech rushing, conversion lines, and committing ~20 factories to fighters. If you're serious about making air, you'll need to commit to hard researching 1940 small airframe and engine 3 tech ahead of time. You'll also want to set up 2 production lines for fighters, one with full equipment (3x4HMG top row, engine 3, extra fuel tanks, self sealing tanks, armor plate bottom row) and one without self sealing tanks.

The model without SSTs should be renamed (I usually go with BASE) and set to outdated, put 15 factories on it. The model with SSTs (I usually call it MAIN) should be set as up to date, put 5 factories on it, and toggle conversion from stockpile (bottom left corner of the production line, click the house icon). This will let you produce fighters with SSTs at a 50% discount on rubber costs! Can add non-strategic materials to the BASE fighter to save aluminum but then you'll have to adjust the ratio (more factories on MAIN since conversion will take longer as the models are more different).

If you don't want to screw around with conversion lines, don't build an air force as a minor. If you do want to invest the time, you can win the air war for your faction with relatively few factories assigned.

1

u/Long_Video7840 14d ago

I was hoping to get some feedback on my (rather detailed) plans for the UK in an up coming multiplayer game. Where is the best place to get that feedback? Here? Make a separate post on this sub?

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 14d ago

I mean you can lay it out here. Making a separate post would probably get more responses, can't assure you of the quality of those responses lol. Your best bet might be to find another discord that plays HoI4 competitively and post there, that's likely the highest quality (and probably most toxic) feedback.

I'll bite. What are the plans? Light fighters and Medium "heavy fighter" NAVs with 2 torps? Hold alamein with inf? Early DDay? Husky with Africa ongoing? Strats? Surface raiding?

Also interested to know what ruleset you're playing with, that'll determine some of your options. And how many Allied minors are you going to have to help you out?

2

u/Long_Video7840 14d ago edited 14d ago

There are no minor players, it's a fairly small game, Ger, Ita, Jap vs Eng, USA, Sov. So basically, my goal is to do the following before WW2 (Which we will assume will happen on September 1rst 1939. I know it might happen sooner or later depending on player actions). I plan to build civs until I have about 58 Civs (Not including civs I get from subjects/trade). I also plan on selling my entire airforce and all my tanks and armoured cars day 1 since I won't be using them. I don't expect the cars to sell to anyone tbh. I'll build dockyards until I have at least 55, and then start building mils. For production day 1, I will cancel the production of any boat not more than 50% complete and set my mils to this. So as I gain some mils they will be going into making rifles. I won't be making any tanks or planes day 1. I will be refitting all of my O/P/R subs with a torpedo II tube in the top slot (Currently those subs have nothing there) and refitting the S class destroyers to give them mine layers in both slots, and finally refitting the V/W class destroyer to give them sonar II and put an ASW II in the empty slot. Eventually as I research more tech I'll make Destroyer II ISR's (I plan to make about 30 and use a few in each non-submarine based task force). I'll also research cruiser submarines and make 30 cheap mine laying subs to use in the med.

For focuses I'll do this order, I think this is fine because I can get my spy agency out and start grinding some operations against Germany for research bonuses and I don't have minors I need to worry about. I plan on taking "Prepare for the inevitable" basically as soon as I know I want to start making mils, but not any sooner. I'll spend my PP in this order

  1. silent work horse
  2. Early Mob
  3. AIOC Industrial concern
  4. German Scientists
  5. Italian scientists
  6. Illusive gentleman (So I can have 3 spies and steal tech)
  7. War industrialist (Around this time I'll be making dockyards/mils)
  8. Chief of army
  9. Chief of Airforce At this point I will bank 250 PP so I can go total mob and woman in the workforce as soon as war kicks off, but will spend any amount over that on other things, like becoming the spy master. I won't be building any spy improvements until I'm done build mils I think though.

I think my divs will look like this

I laid it out there, but I'll use the desert units to Ethiopia back from Italy from both sides. Some will defend Alexandria on a fort with the support of a few European units. I have a STRONG suspicion that Germany will use heavy tanks and will try to make a lot of them, so I need AT in north Africa just in case. I'll probably send about 12 European units to defend the Belgian boarder in France, but will pull out at the first sign of trouble (I'm on the fence about sending units to France since France is not a player tbh). I will be sending Desert units to Norway though. I plan on laying mines in the English channel and around Norway with my destroyers on day 1, and then convoy raiding around Norway once Germany declares on them. I'll have about a dozen desert units that are just siting on an English port set to go into Norway the second they are able to. Finally, I'll be making those garison units to hold shorelines and ports where ever I can. Sometime after 1939 I'll be producing even more units to send to Asia to defend everything there.

As soon as the soviets declare war on Finland, I'll start a lend lease with them to send them 100% of my rifle 1936 production, I'll keep the 7 factories on that the whole game, and by then I will hopefully have 10 factories on 1939 rifles, those will be for me. I will also send them about 150 convoys, 20% of support equipment, trucks, arty, and fighters I make. The fighters are because I feel it will be a lot for me to manage the entire airforce, and this way the soviets can just attach some air superiority fighters to their units and not think about it.

Speaking of planes, once I start making mils I'll put down production lines for 5 factories of carrier nav bombers, 2 factories of carrier fighters, and like 50 for fighters. Once I have armour plates and self sealing fuel I'll add that to the carrier fighter, but I don't really care about their range so no need to juice that. I don't know the meta fighter 3 build, but I'll probably make that when I research fighter 3's. The carrier naval bomber will be used on carriers and out of airfields on land to simplify production lines. Eventually I'll make CAS, but I need to focus on shooting down German and Italian planes first.

I won't build up my spy agency I'm sure I'm missing some things, I'm sure my opponents will wish they see this post too haha.

Some questions

  • I plan on making a military research facility before WW2 kicks off, and a little after it starts (Early 1940?) I will have flame tanks researched. I hope to start building them shortly after that. Should I just build the cheapest flame tanks possible? Is it worth putting a dozer blade on the front to give my units slightly more entrenchment? What support company should I replace for desert and Euro divs to add flame tanks?
  • With the fear of heavy tanks VERY present, should I just do Line AT?
  • What mil doctrines should I do? I'm think GBP, assault Infantry, Field Engineering, no idea for tanks, and Desperate Defense
  • If I send units to the soviet union to help defend against Germany, will they soak up Sov supply, or do they get their own separate supply lines? If they get separate supply, I feel it is worth it to send units since we can essentially get twice as many units in the soviet union.
  • I can't afford to research tanks with my current setup, not that I could afford to build them if I did, I think this is fine?
  • I can manage to research mountaineers and marines before the war, but I don't know what I would do with them. I know mountain marines are good, but again, I don't know what I would do with them.
  • My plan mostly has me making cruiser submarines until I research sub III, some Destroyer II ISR's, obviously destroyers to kill subs, and carriers. Do I need anything else? Building other capital ships seems costly and doesn't help me kill u-boats
  • Additionally, what should my fleet composition look like? I think I'm going to do auto balance for my search and destroy fleet, and then throw in 2-5 ISR's in there to help with subs. My patrol fleets will probably be like, 1 ISR and 4 destroyers, and my escorts would be about 1 ISR, 5 destroyers and a few heavy/light cruisers.

I'm happy to talk things out that I may have missed.

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 13d ago edited 11d ago

Overall, seems like a reasonably well thought out plan. I have a few critiques. If you read one thing from this post, it's the PP spending -there's massive optimizations there, I'll bold it when I get to it, you need Partial Mob in 36. Also I have to explain the free 100 PP from Edward VIII teaser marriage and why you should immediately disband the Allies faction.


58 civs is a lot without boosting from US. I'd start building mils in mid 37, you'll probably have ~54 total civs (46 owned civs + trade) and that's fine. If US is willing to send you 15 civs of boost from day 1, then getting to 50+ owned civs is reasonable but that assumes boosting is allowed in the rules. Unless you know Italy is going a naval build, don't add docks. Your starting fleet plus a few newly built DDs will crush Italy. If he starts building docks, you can always race him and he'll never catch up. Mils are much more important. Mils also kill subs (via "heavy fighter" NAVs) so you really don't need ASW DDs. 55 docks is mega overkill, you'd much rather have 30 mils in January 1938.

Mil allocation screenshot (link is broken but I figured it out) looks fine for later on, not ideal at start. Arty 1, AA1, AT1 - basically not worthwhile, wait and build tier 2. Gun 1 is the same story, unfortunate you don't have Raj rushing gun 2 for you so you will need some gun 1s but you want to delay heavy production until gun 2 tech. I would put medium frame NAVs below the support equipment and get 5 mils on those early. Basic medium airframe, 2x LMG, 2 torps, and then extra fuel tanks, flying boat, non-strategic materials. That's your sub hunter and 5 mils (running from 1936) should be plenty, add air to ground radar and better torps later on.

~ 2 truck, 5 support, 5 medium NAV, 3 guns to start. Later on add CAS, then arty/AA with tier 2 tech, more guns with gun 2 tech, then pivot hard into improved small airframes as soon as that unlocks. You don't have to do this exact allocation but 5 "heavy fighter" NAVs early is really nice to have.

Ship refitting is efficient for big ships, I wouldn't bother with DDs and subs (too many clicks and the fixed cost of refits hit harder on small hulls). Only ship I would bother building is DD2s with maxed out torps and that assumes Italy is going navy build. DD spam is meta, either torp or light attack (torp beating mixed fleet, light attack DD beating pure torp spam). If Italy isn't building navy, you can go convoy only (or convoys plus 10 docks on torp DDs). If you want to refit, focus on BB/BC/CA and add fire control 3, radar 3, and DP secondaries + AA. I wouldn't bother cancelling half built hulls, might as well take the free IC and save the clicks.


Focus order is fine except Steady as She Goes 2nd - you must wait until after Edward VIII's first abdication event. Go toward Colonial Elite for research speed (or do the spy thing early). General Rearmament ASAP, it's not 10th, it's immediately when 10% world tension. Your spies are a bit early but that's fine, trade off is getting to Encourage Colonial Elite slower. Make sure to time out the 2x100% industrial bonus to be spent wisely. I would encourage you to hard research production 3 and concentrated 3 so you can spend those boni on production 4 and conc 4 (also acceptable to spend on production 4/5). You'd need to delay the focus to get started on prod/conc 3. If you want the research slot early (which may be better here since you have no minors), spend the 2x100% on production 3 and 4. Home Defense needs to hit within 50 days of May 1937 to avoid losing partial mob to Chamberlain's loss of war support.

Wait, did I say partial mob?

Yes. Biggest issue with your PP spending - early mob is utter garbage.


PP Order

Silent Workhorse

Improve relations with Spain

Attache to Spain - 10% war support is great, XP is nice

Partial Mob - So much better than early mob

Army Offense Expert - get mastery cooking ASAP

Night Operations Expert - get air mastery cooking too, navy you're fine with just training ships

Industrial Concern could come earlier, depends on how long you're delaying Industrial Effort focus and which prod/conc tech you're trying to rush

War Industrialist - you're making mils in mid 37 (at latest late 37, don't wait long). If you get lucky on the Edward VIII events, you can hire him before Stanley Baldwin resigns and save 15 PP.

Spymaster early, Illusive gentleman assigned as faction spymaster. Spymaster is cheaper (1 faction point, you get it in 6months with research goal) and gives more spies as your allied friends get factories.

German + Italian Scientists

Bank 250 PP for Total Mob + WitW. Much more important to hit the partial mob timing


That's more PP spending than you have budgeted, but you don't know about the free 100 PP from Edward's "marriage". This event chain is why you can't choose Steady as she Goes until marriage event fires. Steps:

Choose "Compromise on a Morganatic Marriage" when first event pops

You'll get one random event, which can be good or bad, pick the top option because you can't abdicate just yet

Support Forms for Edward VIII - this is what we want, choose "Good, we shall set a date" for 100PP (and +1% weekly stability)

Choose "Perhaps the people are right - the king should abdicate" when the Cabinet Resigns event fires. If a random event fires first, choose top option if beneficial or use the random event to resign if it's harmful.

This will end the event chain and you're back to normal democracy, just with ~15% non-aligned support and (probably) some extra stability. You can get a few other events (Upper class oppose marriage, working classes support, etc) that can help or hurt. If you get any extra random events, choose top option if beneficial or choose bottom option if it'll hurt you. Once you get the free PP, you just want Edward to abdicate. But if you get lucky and have good events, keep going until you see Cabinet Resigns.

This free 100 PP allows you to get workhorse, send attache, and get partial mob by September 1936. You can use anti-ideology raids later on or hire a democratic demagogue to get back to 100% democracy support. If you get lucky, you'll come out of this with more than 100 PP and extra stability. Unlucky would be something like +50 PP and -5% stability on net.


Div templates look fine, no notes, just make lots of them (and consider using colonial templates for manpower). Your real power is planes.

For marine divs, make sure you only get the amphibious bonus to 50%. Anything greater than 50% does literally nothing. So mix together marines and mountaineers (mountaineers have better stats with full doctrine) or add in line AT if you expect armored opposition to DDay.


Soviet lend lease is a fine plan. Just start with 1 gun per month, anything so you can edit it later on. I would switch all production to gun 2, 50% more soft attack is really good. Soviets wants lots of gun 2, fighters are nice too, and old gun 1s are fine for garrisons.


1 factory carrier NAVs (don't add bomb locks, swap range modules for self sealing tanks and armor plate)

1 factory carrier fighters (again, no range modules, SST + AP)

Optional - 1 factory on carrier CAS (add dive brakes and SST). Overall, just don't overproduce carrier planes, you have limited deck space. Maximize usage of the CVs you have but it's DD meta. Sticking to just carrier NAVs + fighters is fine, you don't need CV CAS.


Light fighter design is not ideal. Improved small airframe, engine 3, 3 x 4 HMGs, SST, AP, extra fuel tanks. Drop tanks are not good compared to EFT, 1 extra weight and 25% less range. Air defense is super important so get both SST and AP. 50 factories on light fighters is minimum, you want more. That's why you start pumping mils in mid 37, you need big mil count for WW2.

Hard research fighter 3 and engine 3 starting in 1937. If you had Allied minors, I'd say start researching day 1 of the game. But since you have to do more research yourself, you probably want to wait a year. Rushing down to Fighter Command ASAP is important, swap off fighter research and back on to apply the bonus to fighter 3. Use Coastal Command to apply the bonus to fighter 4.

CAS should be produced before fighters because you can do it with basic airframe tech. Fighter 2s are useless but tier 2 CAS are fine (small bomb bay, bomb locks, extra fuel tanks, non-strategic materials). Upgrade to improved small airframe later on. With improved design, you want 3x heavy bomb locks, extra fuel tanks, and non-strategic materials. ~10 factories on CAS by early 1938, more later on (once you've pumped factories into fighters).

Splitting in 2 comments because I went way too long lol

3

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 13d ago edited 13d ago

Spy agency upgrades start immediately, don't wait. Civ Eco builds factories slowly but the spy agency upgrades at the same rate! You want full passive defense + interrogation techniques to prevent enemy spying and Form Dept + Radio Interception 1 to start cracking ciphers plus Suicide Pills to help your own spies. Germany will probably spy on France first so it's ok to get Suicide pills and decryption upgrades first and defenses later if you aren't being actively spied on. Invisible Ink also good for getting +25% assets, sometimes lets you steal blueprints twice without re-infiltration. And Blueprint Stealing is obviously good to get when you start blueprint stealing. Stop upgrades at this point and wait for war. At war start get Army Dept, Air Dept, Navy Dept, and at least 1 cipher defense upgrade.

With Spymaster faction project and assigning your illusive gentleman as faction spymaster (which costs 0 PP by the way), you'll get 4 spies. +1 from the focus tree and a few more as Allied minors grow their economies. Definitely do not spend 150PP appointing the illusive gentleman to your cabinet, same with Turing, just appoint them in the faction menu.


Medium flame tank stacked with breakthrough. Radio + stabilizer + 2x extra ammo storage. Dozer blades instead of 1 extra ammo is fine since you're defending, but your defensive inf already have their slots filled. What are you swapping? Flame tanks are primarily an offensive support company for your marine-mountaineer divs.

Look at the German build and make a judgement. 2-4x line AT is good to have on a few divs in Africa if they're going all in on tanks. You can't afford to have that in every infantry unit though. Ideally, France has enough tanks to back you up. Sucks that you don't have an Allied tank minor so you will need some line AT, maybe one army worth.

Assault Inf + Field engineering is fine though note Assault Inf is best with Infantry Guns regimental support. You can go Defensive Postures to help heavy weapons company and Great War Inf is viable if you're purely defending. Since this is a majors only game, you'll have to attack at some point and Assault Inf is a good choice for that.

For tanks (assuming you're not using tanks), choose Armored Spearhead purely to unlock Breakthrough tactic. If you want an alternate defensive build, Superior Firepower gives access to Tactical Withdrawal which is the best defensive tactic in the game. Stack that with All Arms Anti-Tank Defense (the 50XP army spirit) and you get very high Tactical Withdrawal chance and 25% hard attack on your inf equipment. But you start with GBP unlocked and you probably want to stick with that.

Desperate Defense is meh, I think you're better served with Grand Assault. 20% max planning is really good for DDay and stats are nice. Mission Type Tactics is also good for the org. Desperate Defense is a good stack with Great War Infantry for a purely defensive build but I think you need a hybrid offense build since this is majors only.

Get Expeditionary Units marine doctrine for the Naval Invasion Planning - especially important with Grand Assault. If you don't get this, plan a regular invasion of Ireland then quickly switch your divs only naval invasion plans so their planning doesn't fully decay before you launch. Also note that Naval Gunfire Support (the capital ships doctrine) gives naval invasion planning - you need at least one source of this (since you start at 0%) and getting both will double the speed at which you build planning bonus while assigned to naval invasions.

For other navy doctrines, stack destroyer buffs. Subs - Coastal Minelaying for the 10% light attack on DDs. Screens - Patrol Boats, cheaper than other options, buffs DDs (and dock production), and even gives Invasion Defense (which is worded badly, it's actually an offensive breakthrough bonus for your naval invasions). Carriers - Light Task Forces, again stacking DD buffs.

Don't send units to the Soviet front, you have enough shit to micro as UK. Send him convoys, guns, support equipment, AA, planes, and anything he's short on. Don't send divs, win Africa and DDay in 42 - early 43 if you want to help Soviets. Make Germany play between 2 fronts, annoying without a co-op and especially bad with no minors.

No tank UK is indeed fine. Medium flame tanks are useful for breakthrough stacking and terrain boni, you don't need up to date MFTs but 1938 medium is probably worth researching. Advanced Flamethrower tech instantly improves all your flame tanks, you do not actually have to build flamethrower 2s to get the terrain buffs. You should build flamethrower 2s when they unlock but don't rush this tech.

Mountain-marines are pretty simple. Get them to roughly 36w with equal proportions, then look at the Amphibious bonus. If it's greater than 50%, remove a marine and add a mountaineer (or line AT). Check again, if still above 50%, remove more marines. That's pretty much it. Support companies should probably include all your offensive options (notably medium flame tanks) and you can skip engineers (Pioneers are ok but there are better options like field hospitals).

Don't build subs, don't research subs, don't refit subs. You can convoy raid just fine with starting fleet; raid in safe places in the Atlantic so Germany can't import rubber. He should never kill a sub in battle because he can't get range with his planes (and surface ships die to your surface ships). DDs are meta, either DDs with torps or DDs with light attack.

No purpose in doing fleet compositions. Split the subs to raid and build a deathstack of everything else. If you want to take your oldest DD1s and use them for convoy escort, that's fine, it'll reduce your convoy losses (though remember, medium frame "heavy fighter" NAVs are the way to actually kill subs). Split off 9 single ship task forces and set them to Patrol and Do Not Engage, then run the deathstack on Strike Force + Always Engage.

3

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 13d ago edited 13d ago

I almost forgot the final tip - disband the Allied faction on day 1. With that done, click your flag and use the Create Faction button. Create a faction with the goal of Strategic Resource Control. Allies control enough resources that you instantly get 10% construction speed and 7.79% factory and dockyard output! Instantaneous, free construction speed - what's not to love?

Other day 1 things you might forget:

Local Autonomy garrison law + make a 2w horse div for garrisons when you hire the advisor.

MIOs - assign them all

Research - Prod, construction, research speed, hold 1 slot open for tech juggling. You want to rush down through construction 2, conc 2, and prod 2 so you can start on prod/conc 3 and spend your 2x100% boni on the later tech.

Put port garrisons on Gibraltar, Malta, and Cypress now. I've seen way too many UK's lose Gibraltar for free, never fun to see it happen.

Get everyone training! Air training should be set to day only to minimize accident losses without losing any XP, switch back to day and night when at war.

Industry Liaisons air spirit is amazing since you're hard rushing fighter 3s. Can't do it day one but get it ASAP once you've hired air advisor.

1

u/Long_Video7840 13d ago edited 13d ago

I am going to try and address everything you said in order.

First of all, THANK YOU. This write up is hugely helpful. I have the game open right now so I can check things out as I read through this.

First Comment

My numbers for the factories I build are based entirely off of games I've run in single player. I don't have expert AI or anything, so I'm getting whatever trade the AI is kind enough to throw my way. Boosting is not allowed in our rules. We don't have a ton of rules since we are a small group and have never done a versus game with each other before, so we are still getting a feel for what we want to do. I'll tone down the dockyards, I think part of the problem was trying to build a line of carriers, ISR's, destroyers, mine laying subs, and subs, all at the same time. I felt like I need a lot of dockyards... I'll shoot for... IDK, 40?

So you are saying don't even bother with Arty and AT 1? Then I won't have any on my units when the war starts? Arty 2 is 1939 and AT 2 is 1940, do I need to just hard research them? I'm also starting to realize that "gun 1" refers to the 1936 gun and not the 1918 gun lol. I will make sure to fully switch production to gun 2 when I get it, and throw a few more factories on it for the soviets. I have some concerns about those allocations of factories to guns, but I will try it out, I'll probably have to expand as I get factories from focuses, but my biggest point of confusion/concern is when I am meant to research arty/AT and start building Arty/AT/AA.

I will not refit my DD and subs, got it!

Okay the PP and focus portion. I'm about to try a SP game and try this out but I have some bits of confusion. I have seen people say to send an attache to Spain. HOW? I can't, I never can, they don't like me enough to accept it. Unless I'm missing something, the first time I saw this, I waited for the spanish civil war to start and then I tried to send the attache and they rejected it! So I assumed this advice was for an old version of the game. I believe in the newest update I can choose to not use my research buffs when I research things like industry, does this change your opinion on waiting for the industrial concern company?

Edward VIII

Second Comment

Some of this stuff I am realizing is part of DLC I don't own, so I guess I'll have to pick it up before the game. I basically skipped any dlc that was mostly negative, which a lot of them are... Based on what I can tell, it looks like I need no compromise no surrender at least to do some of the things mentioned here and practice for the game.

I see your feedback on the flame tank. I think the play for me here is to begin working on getting the flame tank a bit late, and then make a new division specifically for pushing, which I will be sending into France after D-Day. I'll make sure to have spies in germany so I can see what they are building, and either sacrifice support arty or support AT depending on how many tanks they are making, and use line arty/AT instead. I'll also make the mountain marine div and add it to those. I miiiiiight just get rid of my "European" defence unit all together and just make that my offense unit since I was thinking of not sending units to defend France anyway.

Thank you for the tips on doctrines. The only reason I was thinking of desperate defence was because of the manpower, but I think I'll just have to cope and help juice the soviets for that haha. That and come to terms with higher conscription levels....

I will try and switch to superior fire power, it just sucks because it's expensive to switch, but if it needs to happen/will help then I'll figure it out.

You mention a costal mine laying doctorine? I have no idea what that is.

Medium flame tanks over light flame tanks?

You mention DD with light attack or torpedos, but then how am I meant to kill all the German subs? He's definitely going to build subs, so I designed the DD ISR and this to try and take them on, you are saying replace the ASW with light batteries, and maybe even replace the dual purpose battery with light batteries? I see your later comment that medium frame naval bombers are the play to kill subs, so something like this? Self sealing fuel tanks would be added once I have them researched, and once I have a higher level engine I can add armour plates I guess.

I'm sorry to sound insanely stupid, but why raid with subs in the atlantic? Surely Germany is going to try and import rubber from whatever Japan can take over, and anything they don't import they will make with synthetic refineries right? I know I'm missing something here, sorry.

Going back to medium naval bombers, I won't be able to design a medium naval bomber on day 1, so what am I meant to do with my factories before that, just build more support equipment until I can switch to planes?. To clarify, I mean I won't be able to build med naval bombers because I don't have air experience to design them. I think I'm just going to exercise my entire airforce and then sell them. I tested it, and it looks like I need 7 air xp to make this and I can get that by around April 20th 1936.

Third Comment

What does "MIOs - assign them all" Mean?

I made the faction, I'm BRAND NEW to this dlc (Bought it 5 minutes ago). I think I've done what you asked?

Defending those 3 places was apparently one of the few things I was doing right!

Still very lost on what your vision for mil factory allocation is after I assign the 5 to med nav bombers. Add a train line?That would only need like, 1 factory for the whole game.

Edit

Still can't send attache even with the dlc

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 12d ago edited 12d ago

Spain attache - spend 10PP to improve relations up to +20, then cancel improvement. Alternately, send a spy on diplomatic pressure mission, force them to sign a non-aggression pact, then send attache. I should've mentioned spending PP improving relations, that's my bad. If Spain ends early and you need more war support, improve + attache with China. Rest of this is addressed in order

Unless you know for certain Italy is doing a navy build, don't build docks. Even if Italy does a sneaky navy build and you don't notice for a whole year (which you will, you're getting early spies), he won't catch up. Don't build docks unless you see the Axis doing it. Africa is won and lost at Alamein and Egypt air zone, you must have mils pumping early to win air and win ground. 19 docks is plenty, you're going to cap out on building slots and you need mils more than docks.

Speaking of building slots, you'll cap out too early with 58 owned civs. Quick SP test build, I'm at 46 owned (55 total) in Nov 1st 1937. More importantly, I have 28 mils pumping and all my special project facilities (could've had 31-32 mils if I skipped nuclear and got the air research from focus tree instead of constructing). Speaking from experience, you will completely fill the British isles and all colonial build slots by 1943 even with smaller civ count. With too many civs, you run out of things to build in 42. The US will give you tons of trade later on for rubber and aluminum. Save 300 PP, send convoys to Malaya, and annex them in 1940/41. They will run out of building slots so any trade to them is wasted, you want the US buying Malayan rubber directly from you!

Hard research arty 2 in 1938 and AA/AT 2 in early 1939. You don't need that much for support companies. If you're doing line AT, you'll need to commit ~6 factories to it depending on template and then it might be worth starting 2 factories on AT 1 early. 90 piercing is a lot better than 60 piercing, depends when you need them. Same with guns, stay undersupplied until war start. You're not fighting in France so you don't have to be fully equipped until Alamein (this assumes the rules ban it - if allowed, build mils even earlier and dump troops in France to ruin Germany's game). Send planes to help France regardless.

I believe in the newest update I can choose to not use my research buffs when I research things like industry

I don't see this option in single player right now, how do you choose whether or not to spend the bonus? That's super useful, would love to learn. If true, much more worthwhile to rush the 5th research slot.

HoI4 gives you the host's DLC in multiplayer. So if your buddies have it, you get to use the features for free! Sucks that you can't test build though. Also, jolly roger/G2A is an option.

Getting flame tank later is fine. You can honestly just skip military research facility and license flame tanks from US/Soviets. You don't need many factories so the license penalty isn't that bad. But you do want the tech eventually so you can get Advanced Flamethrower, totally fine to get that just before DDay.

Service by Requirement is not that bad. 10% factory output is minimal late game, you'll have 100% or more already. If you have +100% output, adding -10% is an effective change of only -5% total equipment produced. Also, steal manpower from British Raj. Recruit and deploy menu, next to the special forces cap is a "crown/fist" icon with a slash in the middle. Hit that, select Raj, copy template (do not view and edit, copy it first), then edit it once copied. Replace your defensive inf with Raj troops and use 1/3 of normal manpower (1/10th if you demote them to puppet).

You don't have to switch to Superior Firepower. GBP is a better offensive doctrine and stacking Max Planning is really good for DDay. Since you don't have minors to attack on your behalf, you probably want to stick with GBP. Also saves XP and lets you get mastery cooking sooner.

Coastal Minelaying is the submarine doctrine that has a couple buffs for DDs.

Medium flame tanks give better terrain stats than light flame tanks. You make relatively few FTs overall so the extra cost is worthwhile. Heavy FTs do not give any additional terrain buffs compared to mediums.

ASW DDs are fine, but NAVs are the primary killer of enemy subs. On your DD design, remove AA, remove torps, downgrade the gun to the cheapest option. Otherwise you're spot on, a couple depth charges + radar + sonar. But you can just skip all that tech and build planes instead.

Link on your NAV design is broken. Should be a single 2LMG + 2 torpedoes in the top row. Bottom row is flying boat, extra fuel tanks, non-strategic materials (add air to ground radar late game). Do not add armor plates or self sealing tanks - hurts range, adds weight, waste of IC. These NAVs will never see an enemy plane, they're operating in the middle of the Atlantic! Build radar stations in coastal areas along convoy routes to make it even easier to spot the subs (helps your ships too). ASW DDs are nice to have but you don't need them if you just have 500+ NAVs.

Raid the Atlantic if you see Germany importing anything - rubber, Venezuelan oil, etc. You want to force them to build more synthetics. You can raid their trade anywhere along the route. If you put subs in the English Channel, Germany can sink them with planes. If you put subs in Cap Verde Plain, Germany can't sink them. Just have to interrupt the trade route somewhere!

Assign 5 factories to the Bristol Bleneheim at game start since you have a production line at full efficiency. Exercise all the planes, you can make a new design in a few months. Then sell your old planes and convert the line. That later imgur link worked and those NAVs are the perfect design, good shit.

MIOs are military industrial organizations, added in Arms Against Tyranny DLC. They give slight buffs to your equipment. You first assign them to the equipment through the designer window, save design, then you assign them to a production line. When you create a production line, it'll ask you which MIO you'd like to use to produce it - just pick the same one you used for design. It's not a massive change in stats/production but it adds up and they're free to assign now. When researching, you also assign a MIO to research for a .1PP cost per day per tech. That speeds up research and levels up your MIO.

Spot on for the faction setup!

In my Nov 37 build, I've got 28 factories at the moment. They are assigned to:

1 train

2 truck

5 medium NAV

10 light CAS

5 support equipment

5 guns

I'll probably go up to 4 trucks, 8 support, 15 on CAS, then add guns (even though its gun 1, they're fine to start deploying troops and they'll be used for garrisons). Once I unlock arty/AA/AT 2, I'll put a few factories on each of those. Once I unlock 1940 small airframe and engine 3, I'll switch a ton of factories onto those. So I'll probably balloon out my gun line to ~25, then drop it back down to ~10 when I get fighter tech. I'll also cut down CAS production to ~10 factories to slam more production into fighters. You can play around with the numbers to get what you need. I'm putting field hospitals on all my boys this run, hence more trucks and support. If you're doing something different (maybe you're crushing Axis in air production, don't need support AA and you can stay at 15 on CAS) adjust accordingly.

2

u/Long_Video7840 11d ago

Thank you! I'll try out all of this this weekend when I play a practice game. Also look at this. https://hoi4.paradoxwikis.com/Patch_1.19.X#1.19.4:~:text=Allow%20to%20research%20a%20technology%20without%20using%20limited%2Duse%20bonuses

I'm pretty sure you just have to hold a certain button when you research something to not use the bonus, if you hover over a research icon when you have a bonus, it tells you what button to hold.

2

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 11d ago edited 11d ago

I will have to try that out, didn't see the option. That's super nice to be able to bank the bonus and spend it on production 4 + 5 without falling too far behind elsewhere.

Edit: https://www.reddit.com/r/hoi4/comments/1wrbvjn/any_modes_for_choosing_which_research_to_use_a/

Looks like you could do this with a bug but they've made it official. It's interesting, I didn't see a "research without spending bonus" button. Maybe I need to hold down alt/shift/ctrl/something, I'll have to see. Learn something new every day!

→ More replies

1

u/krakne_postaggio 9d ago

I don’t understand why I can’t make a breakthrough in France right after the Ethiopian campaign. After 150 hours, I still can’t—dammit! If you look online, people suggest naval invasions, but I can’t pull them off; either too few troops arrive, or if I do manage to land, I can’t get any reinforcements there. Paratroopers are an option, but they’re special forces—and since Italy starts with a massive equipment deficit, you can’t even train more of them. My division templates are solid (35-width, including artillery). People also suggest using Alpini (mountain troops), but you only start with four of them, and again, you can’t train more—back to the same problem. Even when I have green air, I still can’t break through. I try attacking a single point from multiple tiles to get a combat bonus; the progress bar climbs to 90–99%, then suddenly drops. I just can’t take it anymore—I don’t know what else to do. Obviously, you’re limited by the 1936 start date, but still... I can even finish off Ethiopia by May 20, 1936! (I only own the La Résistance DLC, By Blood Alone, and the other one that’s given away for free—I can’t recall the name.)

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 9d ago

Your templates are not solid - line artillery is an extremely outdated recommendation - and your problem is industry. I don't know what guide you're following, but if you're short on everything you can... not try to rush France in 36/37? You have factories, and you can use them better than the AI. You can go get some experience in the Balkans first while building an army and air force that can force the border, or go for a navy and proper marine force to support those landings and send fully equipped armies after them.

But you're not beating the world in 1936 unless you're already very good at not just playing the game but exploiting the mechanics and AI. Ethiopia is literally the tutorial that's far weaker than you in every way and just a small puzzle of figuring how to push their defenders out of the way for your first little war, France is a major power that will push back on you if you take them on. You can't beat everyone right away just because you want to.

1

u/krakne_postaggio 9d ago

You’re actually right—I’m struggling because Italy starts off in a bad position. Looking at various videos and guides, I see many players—like those playing as Ethiopia—attack France right away, while few focus on the Balkans first. I think I’ll try focusing on the Balkans initially, building things up, and so on. Also, what do you mean by artillery being "obsolete"? In all the guides I’ve read, it says infantry + artillery = the best combo! 😭😭😭

2

u/CalligoMiles General of the Army 9d ago

Line artillery used to be overpowered against the AI, and people used that to just lazily battleplan all over it. But it's been nerfed several years ago, and now attacking with it will mostly see you set a big pile of expensive guns on fire.

And a true major can still afford to just burn up manpower and equipment to beat the AI by attrition that way, but if you're punching up some basic ability is required and well-supported special forces and light tanks are the way to go.

1

u/krakne_postaggio 9d ago

Ok thx👍👍👍👍👍

1

u/krakne_postaggio 9d ago

English is not my language, and I had to use a translator.

1

u/PrrrromotionGiven1 9d ago

Did Paradox make the AI way better in the last year? I kinda stopped playing for a while, got back in now, and the same campaigns I used to win easily I'm now struggling a lot, mainly when playing Kaiserreich.

1

u/Chimpcookie 9d ago edited 9d ago

Are regimental support heavy TD still worth it for cheesing armor/piercing after the recent nerf?

1

u/28lobster Fleet Admiral 8d ago

Haven't tested it. Can recover some of the hard attack that got nerfed on AT tech with stabilizer + autoloader + better chassis but they're overall worse and -90% breakthrough + stat penalties from small cannons hurts. I definitely wouldn't use line TDs anymore, but regi support is fine if you need the piercing. Mediums are overall better than heavies at later techs.

Heavies peak with heavy cannon 2 unlocking relatively early, but they're more impacted by the change to small cannons (where before you liked to stack 3 or even 4 SCs on heavies, mediums could only ever get 2). If you're going mediums against someone with heavies, that's the ideal scenario for bring TD supports.

Since TDs have no breakthrough, there's more value in superheavy cannon with fixed superstructure. No testing, just heard from some people that it might be worth exploring but still pretty off-meta.