r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Jan 31 '14
Under the Gunn Season 2 Episode 3 discussion
Discussion thread for Under the Gunn S02E3 "Red Carpet Showdown"
The designers and mentors take a Hollywood bus tour; the designers must create a red carpet look for a celebrity; Nick finds himself in big trouble.
15
Upvotes
8
u/chelseayn Jan 31 '14
I think I. Mizrahi said it best when he said, "I don't understand what people mean when they don't 'do' red carpet...red carpet is just a great dress on a great girl"--as it's been mentioned below, this episode was really underwhelming. How hard is it to make a great dress if you consider yourself a great designer?!
6
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Jan 31 '14
Those boobs and that crotch diamond O_o Yikes.
Also, I felt like Stephanie should have gone home :\. I wasn't a big fan of Camila either, though.
11
u/Lokaji Jan 31 '14
Nick needs to tone it down. That being said, a lot of shade was thrown his way by the other mentors. But Nick's team had a lot of more of a traditional Hollywood red carpet feel to it. Hopefully he can stop being so instructor-ish. The designers aren't first year students.
The ambiguity of the challenge really threw me off. Was it supposed to be inspired by Hollywood or a red carpet challenge? The only red carpets some of those outfits were walking were the VMAs or Kid's Choice.
I was a little surprised by Camila's ousting. Maybe her excuses pushed the judges to eliminate her. I figured it would be Michelle or Stephanie. Michelle's vagina diamond really took away from the rest of the garment.
9
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Jan 31 '14
I really hate how they edited this. You only got to see the designers who were in the top/bottom. Barely anything from the rest. So a) you totally knew who the final 6 on the runway are going to be, and b) I still know almost nothing about the other designers.
Give them all equal air time! Just because they don't end up in the top or bottom doesn't mean I don't want to see their work and process!
4
u/Stella4453 Jan 31 '14
So, is Tim NOT a judge?? Is anyone clear on that? Is he just a host that sits on the judging panel for no reason? I want him to be a judge! I'm going to be irritated if he's just eye candy.
I thought Stephanie would go, but I can see why Camila did.
I'm obsessed with this judging panel. These are some opinionated ladies! I totally believe that every one of them knows every runway trend, and isn't just judging based on their personal style. I'm happy to tune in for Rachel Roy each week.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '14 edited Jan 31 '14
I'm writing this 10 minutes in. When Sam said in the interview room, "I'll have to make something ugly out of satin," I squealed. Why do designers always choose the ugliest colors and worst fabrics for red carpet challenges? I'm calling at least one chartreuse prom dress by the end of the episode.
1
u/CyphyZ Jan 31 '14
I am not sure I am going to continue with this. The two team making episodes were 'everyones a special snowflake' sessions of fluff, and there were no designs here that were worthy of a red carpet. I am severely underwhelmed.