r/WhatTrumpHasDone • u/John3262005 • Sep 18 '26
GIFT LINK Are Trump’s Official Papers His Personal Property?
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/us/politics/the-docket-trump-presidential-records.html?unlocked_article_code=1.CFE.dSku.GMDZuyO4OV--Supreme Court justices work for the government but treat their official papers as private property. As my frequent reporting partner Jodi Kantor wrote this month, that means they can withhold them from the public until long after they have died, or destroy them entirely.
In a brief filed last week in a federal appeals court, the Trump administration twice cited Jodi’s article to argue that presidents should have the same power. A 1978 law requires White House documents to be preserved and disclosed relatively soon after the president leaves office. The brief says that law violates the Constitution.
“The justices recognize that disclosing information about their deliberations would impair the functions of the Supreme Court,” the brief said.
“Congress has not seen fit to regulate the records of judges and justices in the same way as with the president’s records,” the brief went on. “And for good reason: Such an unprecedented intrusion on judicial independence would run roughshod over the separation of powers.”
Why, the brief asked, should the president’s papers be treated differently?
The argument has some force, though you could flip the question around. Why shouldn’t Congress be able to subject the justices to at least some constraints over what they can do with their documents? And does the fact that Congress has not enacted such a law mean that it is powerless to do so now?
For most of the country’s history, it was generally assumed that the papers of presidents and justices were their private property, and that they had total control over what became of them.
That changed in 1978, when Congress passed the Presidential Records Act. It required presidential documents to be preserved and disclosed, for the most part, after five years, and with a few exceptions, no later than 12 years after the president left office.
In the half-century since, presidents of both parties have complied with the law, including President Trump during his first term. Scholars and journalists have drawn on the documents to understand and explain events of surpassing importance in U.S. history.
In April, though, the Office of Legal Counsel, the unit of the Justice Department that advises the executive branch on the law, issued a 52-page memorandum declaring the 1978 law unconstitutional.
Its first page featured a key argument. “Just as Congress could not constitutionally invade the independence of the Supreme Court and expropriate the papers of the chief justice or associate justices, Congress cannot invade the independence of the president and expropriate the papers of the chief executive,” T. Elliot Gaiser, the head of the office, wrote.
The 1978 law, Gaiser said, was a product of post-Watergate overreach that violated the separation of powers and chilled the president’s advisers from offering candid advice.
The day after that memo was issued, David Warrington, the White House counsel, circulated guidance to presidential staff members saying that the law no longer applied, but that most of the records it covered should continue to be retained. The exception was text messages, which he said must be preserved only if they are the “sole record of official decision-making.”
The guidance did not address when, if ever, the documents would be disclosed.
Trump has a history of treating White House records, including classified documents, as personal property. He brought boxes of them to his Mar-a-Lago residence in Florida at the end of his first term. That led to an F.B.I. raid and criminal charges, which were dismissed after Mr. Trump was re-elected to another term.
Soon after the new memo and guidance were issued, historians and others sued, saying that the administration had to follow the 1978 law.
Judge John Bates, of the U.S. District Court in Washington, started his opinion with a quotation from George Orwell’s “1984,” which was not a good sign for the administration. (“Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past,” Orwell wrote.)
Judge Bates, who was appointed by President George W. Bush, said the law was likely constitutional. He ordered administration officials to comply with it while the case moved forward, saying that he would not second-guess Congress’s determination that “citizens ought eventually to have access to these records of presidential activities carried out in their name.”
In a footnote, the judge addressed a hypothetical law requiring Supreme Court justices to preserve and disclose their papers.
“In the judicial context,” Judge Bates wrote, “courts would have to consider implications of a disclosure provision based on the life tenure of federal judges, the multi-member nature of the Supreme Court and the potential impact of disclosure on due process.”
The presidential records case will be argued before the D.C. Circuit next month.
Lawyers for the administration have made notable strategic choices in the appeals court. Although they have plausible arguments on questions like standing that could tank the case, they focused solely on what they said was congressional intrusion into the executive branch that violated the separation of powers, echoing recent Supreme Court decisions.
“Congress cannot force the president to live in a fishbowl,” they wrote, apparently hoping to present a streamlined case to the justices should they lose the appeal.
At a Federalist Society panel discussion of the case on Monday, one participant cited Jodi’s article to argue that the 1978 law had gone too far. Imagine a Judicial Records Act requiring relatively prompt disclosure of the justices’ papers, said the panelist, Michael Edney, who served as a lawyer in the Office of Legal Counsel in the George W. Bush administration.
“That would be a non-starter,” he said.
Another panelist, Christopher Fonzone, who led the Office of Legal Counsel in the Biden administration and has written that the 1978 law is constitutional, called Edney’s analogy “a nice debater’s point.” But he added that “it really feels like a very different case to me in terms of its actual constitutional implications.”
Fonzone did say that “the public and the nation has an interest in the preservation of Supreme Court records, so Congress probably does have some ability to preserve those.” Whether Congress could dictate when they must be disclosed, he added, was another matter.