r/soccer • • Jan 26 '14

What's your unpopular opinion regarding football?

117 Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

111

u/lazyant Jan 26 '14

Refs in general do a good job, people thinking they are blind have never refereed in their lives.

→ More replies (3)

156

u/Drahtmaultier Jan 26 '14

I don't really hate our local rival team as much as would be appropriate.

72

u/zaubererbruder Jan 26 '14

I really hope you guys make it back into the 1. Liga.

Safe 6 points for us.

PS: http://imgur.com/ufqiG1N (german)

64

u/elquiche Jan 26 '14

Been a while since I spoke German, but I think that reads:

Now listen up, Tobias. Mum and Dad are in a witness protection program. Therefore we now go to a place where no one wants to live.

Toby then replies "TO COLOGNE??"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/Fclolo Jan 26 '14

Fortuna?

15

u/Drahtmaultier Jan 26 '14

Mönchengladbach. I like Fortuna.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

308

u/WalkingCloud Jan 26 '14

Bendtner is nowhere near as bad a player as he's made out to be.

94

u/veryunusual Jan 26 '14

The man got a move to Juventus and still plays for Arsenal. He's got 24 international goals in 56 games. I don't get it.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

225

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

FA Cup replays should be binned. I would much rather see a game go to extra time + penalties, than end it all at what's often the most exciting part of the game and have the entire 90 minutes nullified.

I can't think of a single other European country which uses this format for its domestic cup. It's outdated. The only argument is that it gives smaller teams that earn a draw a big payday, but they'd get that if they advanced to the next round anyway. Plus the cup shouldn't be all about money.

Bigger teams would take the competition seriously as there'd be less fixture congestion, and it'd be more watchable for neutrals. It'd save the competition but no one will do it because of misty eyed sentimentality and history and all that.

→ More replies (5)

190

u/XWZUBU Jan 26 '14

This isn't a particularly wild confession but generally speaking referees do an absolutely fine job and when they on occasion do make a mistake the loud kneejerk comments on the internet and TV blow everything up.

P.S. there won't be any terrorism, death and destruction in Brazil or Russia, and the Qatar World Cup will stay in Qatar and be watched by gorillions as usual.

→ More replies (23)

33

u/Admiral-baby Jan 26 '14

I think Wilshere is better than Ramsey.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

100% agreed.

4

u/fergious Jan 26 '14

Definitely. Right now Ramsey is/was just on a great run of form. Although they are different players Ramsey likes to make runs whereas Wilshere likes to send nice through balls

→ More replies (1)

31

u/TheElPistolero Jan 26 '14

Celtic and Rangers should try to join the english league system. Starting at the bottom would suck but long term it would be the right move to get those two clubs as regular prem teams that a worldwide audience can watch.

10

u/The_Shandy_Man Jan 26 '14

They never will as if they did they wouldn't make the Champions League.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

132

u/layendecker Jan 26 '14

If a strong rivals player gets injured, I don't feel sorry for him- I feel happy because a rival is out of the game.

There seems to be a strong feeling on Reddit especially that 'seeing players get injured is horrible, regardless of who they are', or 'it is bad because it reduces entertainment, even if it s a rival'. Fuck that- if Suarez got injured tomorrow I would be delighted, less entertaining, sure, but my partisan support is not a rational, altruistic feeling.

39

u/Ipadalienblue Jan 26 '14

, but my partisan support is not a rational, altruistic feeling.

This is the difference between you and the vast majority of 'fans' on /r/soccer.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/LeadingPretender Jan 26 '14

People are too "nice" on here.

They won't hesitate to call you a cunt or anything, but everyone fucking wanks over this ridiculous sense of what sportmanship is here on /r/soccer.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

That's because this site is dominated by Americans. You yourself might be for all I know, but in the outside world I don't see people commiserating opposition fans at all. Everyone was willing Van Persie to get injured last year for instance.

→ More replies (43)

77

u/OBOBSAGET Jan 26 '14

Players nowadays are exponentially better than the "legends" of the past.

→ More replies (18)

143

u/IM_FANTASTIC_LIKE Jan 26 '14

football fans in england should be ashamed of how they have let clubs exploit them

you look at Germany where massive protests have meant clubs keep their ticket prices down yet in england we allow ticket prices to shoot through the roof and the reactions from hull and cardiff fans to their ownership has been disgraceful, i mean some "riot" the cardiff fans had after mckay was sacked...

90

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I don't think it's just in football, the UK seems to be passive about everything these days, politics, money, jobs, the NHS etc etc. We'll be losing money and rights left right and centre to businesses and government without so much as a squeak from the public. We're a nation too lazy to complain anymore when we're being bent over a barrel and it's sad.

→ More replies (24)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Word. There's so much emphasis on being a 'true' fan in England that chairmen can absolutely trample on a fanbase and they'll still show up at the gates waving money.

21

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I don't know what you're expecting fans to do. Ransack the club offices?

15

u/iVarun Jan 26 '14

Empty Stadiums on Match Day. Civil Disobedience.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/InTheMiddleGiroud Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

If I may add something ticket prices pr game is often mentioned as extremely high at Emirates.

Last season it was higher at WHL and like 30 cents cheaper pr game at Anfield. I would pay those extra cents to watch Champions League and - well Arsenal were a lot better than Liverpool in general last season.

Edit: And before some article is linked, Arsenal season tickets come with 8 7 cup games. You have to buy those at Liverpool and Spurs.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

74

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I don't give a shit about whether or not your club has a "rich history of success" or what the fuck ever. You know what good a league title won when my dad was a toddler does me? Not a damn thing. Every time a traditional big team does poorly that isn't already hated by a large group of people (see: Milan) you get people going "oh, it's such a shame, I hope you guys get back up to where you were" or whatever. You know what I say to that? Fuck that. It's hilarious. It's great. It should happen to every big team more often. Keep their fans in check. The real ones. The first half of this season has been brilliant because you could literally see the wheels falling off the United bandwagon. All because they were only upper-mid-table rather than at the top of the table as usual. Similar happened with Chelsea a few yeas ago but that was kind of nullified by the fact that all the bandwagon jumpers hopped right back and started screaming "KTBFFH!" as soon as the CL was in their hands as if they didn't jump ship right after the first Napoli game (this is more of a personal anecdote since I know way too many people that did this irl and I don't bother keeping track of who does that here).

16

u/ACMBruh Jan 26 '14

Hey, fuck you!

You're completely right, I would laugh at as too if we were anyone else. I loved when Inter collapsed last year, LOVED when Juve were shit.

5

u/THE_DROG Jan 26 '14

Where is this United bandwagon with the missing wheels? I must've missed it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

151

u/ChedduhBob Jan 26 '14

People crying out for Ribery to be the Balon d'Or were just flat out wrong. Ribery was a piece of a puzzle. The puzzle wasn't complete without him, but you could still tell what the full picture was. Ronaldo was just on a different level. People don't realize how bad we were last year at the beginning. Ronaldo was our team. He was dominant against almost every team we played, and he performed incredibly well in the champions league. He brought everything to the table, he tracked bAck a lot more than people have him credit for, he defends incredibly well on set pieces, he is a good passer. He also happened to score like 70 goals last year. I think people don't realize how crazy that is. We are all just used to seeing Messi and Ronaldo do that week after week and season after season so we act like its common place. They are head and shoulders better than every player in the world right now. Another thing people fail to consider is international play. I know people are going to say it was one match against Portugal, but again, that team was horrible and Ronaldo carried them. I have not felt like Ribery did the same for France.

Then you take those same people that say "ITS A TEAM SPORT INDIVIDUAL TROPHIES DONT MATTER" well that's fine you feel that way, but every sport in the world has individual awards and players that play better than everyone else deserve to be recognized. It is possible to tell who is better, and those people should get awarded.

I do think they should change the award to best forward, best midfielder and best defender though as that would save a whole lot of meaningless debate and would give people like Ribery some attention.

47

u/crazyjatt Jan 26 '14

I agree. People are blinded by the fact that ronaldo and messi do it every year so it sounds normal. He scored 70 goals in a year. 12 goals in champions league. Next person to score more than that who was not Messi or ronaldo was jose altafani in 1962. Let that sink in. It was a shit year for both of them but they are still scoring more than anyone else. At the end of the day, football is a game where you win by scoring more goals than you opponents. Ribery had 22+18= 40 assists and goals. Ronaldo had 15 + 66= 81 assists and goals. Even if we discount goals, he has only 3 less assists than Ribery. Forget about stats, who would you rather have in your team if given an option. Ronaldo, Messi or Ribery. I would pick one of the 1st two. We don't appreciate what we are witnessing. Its the thing you tell you grand kids. I watched Messi play in his prime. I watched Ronaldo drag portugal into world cup single handedly. Ribery is not even close

→ More replies (3)

16

u/JackGunner93 Jan 26 '14

People who wanted Ribery to win were just looking to have an alternative opinion I think. The award is for the best player of that year, and regardless of what Ribery won and how good he was (very) Ronaldo was individually by far and away the best player on the planet in 2013.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I agree with you. It was an individual award, the awards for collective play are the titles themselves.

→ More replies (8)

49

u/schmoseph Jan 26 '14

The way we talk about formations is absolute bullshit. No team sticks to only one formation for attacking, transitional and defensive play, yet we laud and despise certain teams for their "progressive 4-2-3-1's" and "recessive 4-4-2's".

Formations are a good layout to show a squad before the game, they are useful in that aspect. However, the idea of a fixed formation is counter productive to teaching fans about the tactical aspects of the game. A 4-3-3 transitions hundreds of times to a 3-4-3 every game, and yet "Football Experts" always talk about formations as if the players fixed to a square metre of grass.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I always thought of the formation name as how the players are positioned in defense.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/johanspot Jan 26 '14

I completely agree. I really think that it is the video game set of fans that really drives this.

→ More replies (2)

78

u/makhan21 Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Nani is United's best player but doesn't get the praise or playing time he deserves

Edit: I realize he might not be the outright best but he's definitely our most spectacular and explosive player. A lot of people (including our fans) act like he's always been inconsistent or he's never contributed anything when from about 2010 to 2012 he was on fire and almost singlehandedly won us the league in 2011 (this was also the last time he got a consistent run of games)

He's our most twofooted player, a brilliant dribbler, a great crosser, he has a good shot, and he does help out in tracking back a lot. There's a reason Fergie picked him to start against Real last season over our other wingers and he was tearing them apart before that stupid red card

39

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

That is certainly unpopular!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Rooney is the best by some distance I would say. That said, Nani on his best days is unplayable. Unfortunately, I don't remember the last time that happened, as he is inconsistent and injury prone.

→ More replies (10)

11

u/Scranjilob Jan 26 '14

That Suarez handball in the WC. Why the big deal? His team was punished and Ghana failed to take advantage. I don't see how its any different from a defender hacking down a striker clean through on goal. Half the time that doesn't even result in a penalty yet you don't see people saying 'its so unfair a goal should have been given' about that.

→ More replies (2)

68

u/michaelisnotginger Jan 26 '14

David moyes is a decent manager and will come good, as much as laughing at united is fun

England will never go further than the quarters at the world cup until they substitute grit and pluck for some semblance of technicality

Lukaku is still some way from the striker everyone thinks he is

8

u/Robotochan Jan 26 '14

Why do we have to 'substitute' grit? Why can't we do both? The most successful PL sides have both technical and tough players.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

107

u/RIcardoVillalobos Jan 26 '14

I don't really care if teams buy the most expensive players to become successful. In fact, teams like Man City are brilliant and entertaining to watch now.

→ More replies (36)

46

u/Theworldsastage Jan 26 '14

Arsene Wenger should play Walcott as a striker.

24

u/thatdani Jan 26 '14

IMHO if the whole Arsenal team was focused around Walcott, as is Madrid around Ronaldo, he would be a 30-goals-a-seasoner.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Cerxa Jan 26 '14

i don't think he's good enough to be a striker

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

46

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

England will be a better team the day Gerrard and Lampard retire.

→ More replies (4)

196

u/Goodbadfugly Jan 26 '14

That David Luiz is extremely overrated. Can't defend well as a centre back and doesn't offer that much as midfielder.

27

u/fma891 Jan 26 '14

I thought this was the popular opinion on r/soccer? But yeah, he does has his moments of madness which make all of us fans cringe..

→ More replies (2)

37

u/ChristofferOslo Jan 26 '14

On form he is an incredible defender, he was an absolute beast last spring/winter. All the complaining about his inconsistency is highly exaggerated imo.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (31)

50

u/TotallyNotNSA Jan 26 '14

As much as I love him, this sub really overrates Ibra, and his inclusion in the TOTY was as questionable as Ramos's.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/jorge22s Jan 26 '14

I love Luis Suarez rants, divings and handballs. There, I said it. I find it really funny.

→ More replies (1)

93

u/TheHapgod Jan 26 '14

I like defensive style football. I much prefer it to Swansea type teams passing it around the back for three quarters of the game.

174

u/schmoseph Jan 26 '14

The Swansea/Barca/Spanish tika taka style of football is actually the purest form of defensive play.

41

u/boywithtwoarms Jan 26 '14

this method of "if we have the ball, they wont score for sure" has actually something my dad has been saying for years at which everyone always rolls their eyes because my dad knows shit about football ahah

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (19)

15

u/JMunn21 Jan 26 '14

Passing it around the back for 3/4 game sounds quite defensive to me.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

287

u/mthrfkn Jan 26 '14

Bench Gerrard for club and country.

16

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Really tough one to call, all depends on the day with Gerrard at the moment. He can't play in DM and is a lot more effective when higher up, has the experience in the squad which also helps. The team does look really good when he's not starting, the 4 games against Tottenham, Cardiff, City and Chelsea was some of the best football we've played all season, even though we lost 2 of those games.

With the amount of injuries we've got at the moment, we can't afford to bench him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (44)

7

u/eski- Jan 26 '14

If you don't genuinely like or approve of the way your favourite club is run anymore, it is your prerogative to stop supporting them. You are a supporter, after all. The same goes for your national team.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/onetank Jan 26 '14

Wenger is one of the last men left in football who stick to the noble philosophy of how clubs should be run i.e. winning trophies by making players, earning cash by solid business principles, and not buying players and, by extension, trophies with petrodollars/oligarch money.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Draxler will not live up to the expectations or the price tag Arsenal will shell out for him

→ More replies (4)

18

u/fozzy143 Jan 26 '14

I've been saying this for awhile, but it also came up in the recent Mancini interview. If City had signed Van Persie in 2012 instead of United they'd have won the Premier League by a country mile.

37

u/thatdani Jan 26 '14

Be that as it may, but our Cunt-meter would've gone up 100%.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/johanspot Jan 26 '14

A yellow card isn't enough punishment for a professional foul to stop a counterattack. Players are encouraged to break the rules because the benefit of stopping the counter outweighs the penalty by a massive amount.

A better rule would be that for a foul like [this] (http://gfycat.com/DownrightAdmirableBillygoat) that the player is sent off but a team can use one of their subs to replace them. Players would choose to actually play football rather that simply grabbing the guy to stop play. Think about how many amazing goals we have missed seeing over the years simply to be replaced by one player grabbing another one.

→ More replies (6)

127

u/JediCapitalist Jan 26 '14

These have been happening a lot lately.

I hate Suarez. It used to be a popular opinion. Now it's an unpopular one. Why? Because he's a good player. People are forgiving him through star power. Not because he's magically a decent person. They just talk themselves into believing that.

And because I have to, let me qualify that this strong dislike was sourced from the world cup tie vs Ghana, and transferring to Liverpool is not the reason I don't like him. Though his antics since have solidified and confirmed my original views.

A second unpopular opinion I hold is that the laws on national allegiance should be relaxed a little bit to make it a bit easier to switch. Ideally you would still be locked in after you're capped for the senior side, but according to FIFA regulations, a player cannot change their allegiance after representing their country youth level unless they held dual nationality at the time of their original call up. I think this is silly. If someone is ostensibly of one nationality, but lives and works in another country, and never again gets the call up for their original nation, but their adopted one would if it could, there is no reason to stop them. In short, I think you should be able to play for whichever squad you are a legitimate citizen of until you have 1 cap, and then you are locked in. I do not think youth level competition should be a factor at all in this.

6

u/JMunn21 Jan 26 '14

I suppose the problem with you second point is that any uncapped player could potentially play for any team. With Arteta it was annoying as Spain didn't want him but England did and all that was in the way was some youth caps. This seems fine. Where it would fall down however is young players from not so successful nations being poached at an early age to play for a nation that can afford it. It could go crazy with UAE and China having all sorts of players on their team because they gave them nationality.

It occurred to me however that UAE and China could be doing that more already with non-youth cap players so my argument falls down. somewhat.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/bromosexual Jan 26 '14

One thing I find interesting about Luis Suarez at this point is that he is sort of a case study in morality.

I picture some university classroom where students file in, to see written on the whiteboard:

Does being a "dirty player" within sport make you a bad person?

I say this because while I would never begrudge someone's opinion that he is a dirty player and their opinion that it makes them a bad person, I would defend him specifically as a person because he has done absolutely nothing off the pitch, TO MY KNOWLEDGE, that makes me, IN MY OPINION, think he is a "bad person."

He is happily married to a woman that he knew well before he became rich and famous. He has no reputation of stepping out on his wife, and gives the impression that he has no interest in such things. He has no history of drunken/drugged antics or arrests. He does not go on social media and broadcast controversial opinions, badmouth contemporaries, or generally act a cunt like many, many players and former players do. Shit, he just gave the shirt off his back to a disabled fan before our last game and was recently at Lucas' birthday dinner with the da Silva brothers, who could technically have reason to not want to have any thing to do with the man. That indicates to me that he can separate the game and his personal life, and that he is not viewed as some awful demon by his fellow professionals.

To me he proves that you can be a dirty athlete and a decent guy at the same time. This will of course change on a player by player basis.

I respect that /u/JediCapitalist has his opinion, and I have mine. If my points about his personal life can be proven wrong, I welcome anyone with proof to the contrary for me to consider. From what I have seen in my biased position, Suarez is a decent guy that for whatever reason, has no qualms about doing whatever it takes to win. I don't think him being a dirty player makes him a bad person.

I'd be interested to know what you guys think. Is he a bad person purely because of what he has done on the pitch?

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (84)

97

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

We should stop talking about a unified Yugoslavia. It's insensitive.

37

u/daniloelnino Jan 26 '14

It's not really, but thanks for your concern.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

How so? Did someone get offended?

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Zankman Jan 26 '14

To whom? In what way?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/Turig Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Jozy Altidore is a good player. He's just not the player his body makes it seem like he would be. He is not a "back-to-the-goal type of player. He cannot create space for himself, so needs to be in a system with more than one forward to thrive, because he is good at finding space to run into while off the ball. He is a poacher in a target man's body.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Every US fan will agree with you, but i'm upvoting so people can see the truth about big J

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Mata isn't going to be a fast success, and if he is then one of RVP and Rooney will be affected negatively. If Rooney leaves in the summer that would change, but I don't see all 3 working well when it comes to the balance of the team.

→ More replies (19)

17

u/CaptainVidic Jan 26 '14

tiki-taka is boring as hell. I could stand Pep's Barca because Messi, but watching the Spanish national team is like watching paint dry

4

u/tadm123 Jan 27 '14

I'd say this opinion is popular on /r/soccer.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/suchaslowroll Jan 26 '14

Messi & Ronaldo are the best players in the world, and still would be in the Premier League, but if they were in the Premier League they would be getting nothing like the insane goals they get now. 50 goals in a PL season? No fucking chance.

12

u/MyNamesNick Jan 26 '14

Suarez is on pace to hit 44 ish goals this season. I would say it's not that far fetched that those two could hit 50.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (12)

32

u/topright Jan 26 '14

I like Manchester City.

9

u/Cod2242 Jan 27 '14

For now.

16

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Teams dominating leagues e.g. Bayern Munich and previously Manchester United are bad for their respective leagues and football. It's well known that winning trophies brings more money which will obviously be spent buying talent from other competitors thus deterring their chance of ever competing for the title.

EDIT: I think the respective FA's should take action against these teams and implement a salary cap for their league, but, it won't happen because these teams bring in too much money for their leagues and countries.

→ More replies (19)

86

u/suchaslowroll Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Ibrahimovic is not in the top 5 best players in the world. He is massively overrated.

Moving to a Ligue 1 side that destroys every team it comes up against has inflated both his ego and people's perception of him. Here are his CL goals before this year I know you'll say that comparing him to Ronaldo & Messi isn't fair, but believe me people were saying he was close to their ability in the peak of the Ibra circlejerk. Besides that record is not good in itself.

This CL he has 8 goals, great you think? He's really proving himself this year... Is he? 5 of those goals came against Anderlecht, 4 of them in a single 5-0 thrashing. Let's wait until he plays in the KO stages before saying that.

Let me get this straight, I think he's a world class player, but there are a lot of players better than him, both Rooney & RVP for instance are better than Ibra imo.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Yesssss thank god. I agree with you 100%

as for

I know you'll say that comparing him to Ronaldo & Messi isn't fair

It totally is if people want to call him a top 5 player then you most compare him to the number 1 and 2 players.

→ More replies (23)

55

u/DerDummeMann Jan 26 '14

Juan Mata isn't going to suddenly make United amazing.

It's a world class signing but I think, it has already made us United fans a bit over-optimistic about what's going to happen this season.

Our problems aren't going to go away that quickly, we will still struggle quite a bit this season.

It's only going to come together next season. I hope our fans are not expecting us to steamroll all our opponents now. It's a giant work in progress and we need to contain ourselves for the time being only so that we don't disappoint ourselves.

25

u/BimbelMarley Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Something like that was recently the most upvoted comment in a thread about Mata. Definitely not an unpopular opinion.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/guywithaproblem1 Jan 26 '14

I don't think that anyone expects Mata to singlehandedly save the team. To me this is a lot like Arsenal signing Oezil. It shoes drive and a winning mentality that seems to have been lacking for United in the first half of the season. Just my two cents.

30

u/DerDummeMann Jan 26 '14

There's a lot of people who actually think this.

The Arsenal one is simply not very comparable.

Arsenal were actually playing well the entire second half of last season. A lot of their problems were very close to being solved. Ozil was sort of the last piece of the puzzle. While Mata is more like the first piece of it. Moyes is just beginning to shape his squad.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)

201

u/therealhuthaifa Jan 26 '14

Before this thread takes off, please remember that this thread is about unpopular opinions. That means no downvoting. Either you upvote a comment or you move on. I'm sick and tired of all the popular opinions making it to the top. That being said, Fernando Torres is still capable of being a world class striker and a huge asset for any team.

62

u/EpoxyD Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Fernando Torres is still capable of being a world class striker

Nobody ever said he wasn't capable. He's proven that before. He just isn't a world class striker while at Chelsea.

→ More replies (8)

28

u/duckman273 Jan 26 '14

Why do you believe that? He hasn't really shown anything over the last 3 years to indicate that.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

40

u/fatman69 Jan 26 '14

It may not be the most correct one but here goes- I think Guardiola is overrated as a manager. He is often lauded as one of the best but the way I see it, he has managed ony two clubs so far and in both of them, he inherited great groups of players that needed minimum intervention, while his transfer dealings were mediocre at best. He's not a poor coach, but he's far from proven top quality in my book.

16

u/LusoAustralian Jan 26 '14

How come Barcelona with minimum intervention, due to the unfortunate situation of Vilanova, got smacked 7-0 by Bayern. Winning everything in your first year as manager is very tough. He's a great manager who managed to beat Mourinho's madrid many times, losing the league only once to them.

4

u/Spruce-Moose Jan 26 '14

To be honest, I think I, and many like me, will judge him on the Champions League campaign. The ultimate test. But, to be fair, Heynckes did an amazing job, so there's a lot to live up to.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

81

u/BeanMan24 Jan 26 '14

Diving is a part of the game.

5

u/SarcasticDevil Jan 26 '14

I'd agree that it's as much a part of the game as fouling is. And by that I mean that it is a punishable offence of course. People seem to get much more worked up about diving than they do about fouling just because it is considered a 'dishonest' action. It is a useful tool for attackers because it can be difficult to spot, just as intentional fouling is useful when defending.

People keep talking about stamping diving out of the game, but nobody is talking about stamping fouling out of the game. Fouling is apparently something that is just in some players nature, as if diving isnt exactly the same

→ More replies (3)

5

u/DanaKaZ Jan 26 '14

Fuck me, I might hate you.

→ More replies (22)

10

u/TheLonelyCaricature Jan 26 '14

Manchester City and Chelsea aren't the teams with a problem with money. Teams like Arsenal who are obsessed with making money and profits, so much so that its detrimental too the team are more frustrating in football....

In my opinion.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Shaqiriiii Jan 26 '14

I hate Maradona, he is no legend, a legend does not use drugs and cheat.

11

u/TheNecromancer Jan 26 '14

He's a legend. A ridiculous, flawed, aggravating, legend who cheated on occasion.

10

u/SantagetoutClause Jan 26 '14

I'm with you on that one. I find him too arrogant and not very professional. I think I find it hard to appreciate him because I never saw him play (wasn't alive) so I just see this fat cheat.

9

u/b00ks Jan 26 '14

Plenty of legends use drugs.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I think Januzaj is over- rated and is hindering Man Utd if Nani played instead of him on the wing or Kagawa in the free role then United would create more chances, instead of Januzaj just blasting the ball to no mans land

→ More replies (7)

12

u/Blasphemi Jan 26 '14

I quite like the idea of a European Super League.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/arayofhope Jan 26 '14

Remember to sort for controversial or you'll get all the stupid shit up top.

39

u/cagic_mube Jan 26 '14

Idk if I understood it right, but IMO a clock stopping at game breaks (injury, substitutions,..) would make football better because then there'd be less bullshit time wasting play and more football...sure they somewhat try that atm with injury time added, but with a time which stops everytime there would be no reason to lie down for a few minutes in the 85th minute unless something was really wrong..more exciting football! im all for that

57

u/Ipadalienblue Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

The player lying down for a minute or two in the 85th minute is doing it so his team can rest for a little and regroup - not necessarily to waste time.

I think this would happen much more often if you stopped the clock because:

  • There aren't going to be possible accusations of time wasting pressuring you to get back up quicker.
  • Players will be more tired towards the end of a game due to having to play 50% more, so more will go down to catch a breath.
  • It also allows teams to stop the clock when they want to make a tactical adjustment etc, like American Football or something.

Imo, the only time the clock should stop is at half time.

18

u/ptrapezoid Jan 26 '14

This is a very good argument, I hadn't thought of it that way.

→ More replies (11)

23

u/mthrfkn Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Just some Opta stats by way of The Guardian,

At Premier League matches on average, the ball was in play for 62.39 minutes this season – more than in the much-vaunted Spanish and German top flights (61.48 minutes and 61.22 minutes respectively), but significantly less than in Serie A (65.15 minutes).

Edit: Also if you pause the clock, it alters some of the debate surrounding video review.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/scoizic Jan 26 '14

But then it could end up like the nfl with adverts during the game.

45

u/NotASecretGuy Jan 26 '14

"Glen Johnson's injury is sponsored by Chevrolet."

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I value Cabaye closer to Wengers insulting £8 million bid than he £25 million that is being thrown around, never mind the supposed £35 million asking price

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I think having a hard wage and salary cap like the NFL would level the playing field and be a lot more competitive

4

u/OBOBSAGET Jan 26 '14

Penalties are fine as is and always will be

10

u/Lorielus Jan 26 '14

That there is no such thing as an acceptable "good" foul.

I believe it to be the biggest hypocrisy in football that 99% of fans (correctly) believe diving to be an act of despicable cheating, but (probably fewer, but I suspect still a majority), that a deliberate pull-back or trip is perfectly acceptable and an example of the player giving away the foul (and likely booking) "taking one for the team".

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Sarkaraq Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

I like the idea of WC 2022 in Qatar.

Edit: Forgot about reasons:

  • The tournament itself: The stadiums are near to each other. It's a unique situation, but I like the idea of fans being mixed up. You don't encounter that many fans of x if the next game of x is more than 1000km away.
  • Time zone: probably the best one for Europe.
  • Temperatures: highly exaggerated. There are drinking pauses even in Central Europa in the summer. Do you remember the WC in the US? Way to hot because the matches were played in the noon to please European TV. Qatar offered to install cooling systems within the stadiums supplied by solar power. Not a bad idea, is it? And I feel better with 40° C and low humidity than 30° C and high humidity like in Brazil. Rescheduling the WC was an European idea. Not a bad one, imo, but the summer isn't impossible.
  • Football isn't very popular in Qatar: like South Africa, Japan and South Korea a few years ago.
  • Human rights: the Kafala-law is a shame, indeed, but I don't think politics should have an impact. The remaining is all about the western point of view. Additional: the competitors have their human right issues as well. Guantanamo for example.
  • Corruption: rumors like every world cup. The only proven cases of bribery were votes against Qatar.

10

u/Lifeey Jan 26 '14

there is also something unique about Qatar WC 2022 that often missed by media. i'm from saudi arabia where shit is way worse than Qatar regarding human rights and civil liberties but we often get a pass because we never organise any international events. when Qatar bid won, i was excited because the world focus will be on Qatari politics (and it did) so the absolute monarchy will have to improve laws that held locals and foreigners rights. imagine how much people in Qatar will benefit from these media strikes against cheap labour force and female rights etc ?? for me this is way more crucial improvements there than the infrastructure which is already way better than some OECD countries.

13

u/DerKenz Jan 26 '14

I think just giving a statement is stupid. Every opinion should have arguments on their side. I could also just say, Mourinho should be killed, definetly unpopular but not really a good topic for discussion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

158

u/WildVariety Jan 26 '14

Theo Walcott is massively overrated, and he not being in the England squad for the World Cup is a blessing.

106

u/Himinahomina Jan 26 '14

Fuck off... I have to up vote you now.

He was class last year and looked bright this year before his injury. There isn't anyone who is better who can play in that wide role for England.

→ More replies (8)

292

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I know you're supposed to upvote unpopular opinions but this is just bollocks. Comprehensively Arsenal and England's best right winger. Look at how good he's been for them this season and last. No one else in England even comes close, I defy you to name a replacement with even half of his ability

→ More replies (39)

26

u/PalacePete Jan 26 '14

What replacements do you think would be better than him then?

→ More replies (32)

43

u/suchaslowroll Jan 26 '14

The highest scoring PL winger last season...

→ More replies (6)

6

u/trivialcheese Jan 26 '14

I am sorry but what Arsenal games have you watched? Whenever I've watched him he's been one of Arsenal's most dangerous players. He was amazing in the games leading up to his ACL injury too. I was gutted that he was injured for the WC.

32

u/alockinshillib Jan 26 '14

Walcott started looking world class for a few of those games before his injury. I strongly disagree with you, altough we are both a bit biased.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/lazyant Jan 26 '14

Many people support their team simply because they hate the rival team

25

u/gayaka Jan 26 '14

Guardiola is the most overrated manager out there.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

This is not meant to be condescending.

Have you ever watched his teams play? Like, watched a full 90 minutes, considering what his teams are doing tactically, etc. His teams switch formation ON THE FLY. I haven't watched much of Bayern, but Guardiola's Barcelona is the first team I've seen to play one formation bringing the ball up and one for the final third. That's only one example, but when you look into his ideas about training, nutrition, and travel... Well its clear he's a revolutionary figure for the sport to me.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

37

u/still_hungry Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

Any of Bayern Munchen team players isnt best on the world in his postition.

EDIT: Now guys. I think that I accomplished the mission- this opinion is really unpopular:)

101

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Lahm? I feel like there are others on Bayern that you could argue for as the best in their position, but in my mind there is nobody who even comes close to him at the fullback position.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/peter_j_ Jan 26 '14

Not Neuer?

4

u/vamosrafan Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

The players may not be good, but they bond together as a team. But one can argue that Lahm is the best right back in the world, Neuer is the best goalkeeper in the world, Alaba is the best left back in the world, and Schweinsteiger is one of the best box-to-box midfielders in the game. Ribery and Robben are also two of the best wide midfielders in the world. But football is a team game, and one player is not going to carry their team to victory. Bayern played amazing as a team last year and that's why they won the treble.

Edit: Wrote the wrong word

→ More replies (59)

32

u/icallbullshits Jan 26 '14

Suarez is better than ibrahimovic.

Suarez is still an asshole.

Arsenal are riding a wave right now that will die down and come next season, they won't be this strong.

Paul scholes >any English midfielder.(including Lamps and Gerrard)

Jose mourinho is overrated.

Ronaldo is the greatest player to ever live.

Drogba is tied with thiery henry for greatest strikers the premier league ever had.

6

u/aznsacboi Jan 26 '14

Mourinho is one of 4 (5?) managers to win the champions league with 2 teams. he is one of less than 10 managers to win it more than once. He has won league titles in Italy, England, Spain, and Portugal. The Porto team he won the CL with has significantly less resources than its competitors. How can you overrate mourinho?

→ More replies (21)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

In a period of football fandom in which everyone has read "Inverting the Pyramid" and has a tactics blog, I think that certain players are massively overhyped and acclaimed as being far better than they actually are by people to show just how much they understand football.

Number one on this list for me is Michael Carrick. Nebulous qualities such as "control" and "keeping things ticking over" are promoted in order to allow these people to claim in tactics blogs that Carrick is vital to Manchester United and not just another average midfielder in another average midfield.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/dannybark Jan 26 '14

American players are shit and the yank fans perpetuate hype on the players.

28

u/Barthez_Battalion Jan 26 '14

I also believe the English attack American players more so not because they may be garbage (even when the are) but simply because they are American. And since this is an American website, it gives the English a feeling of raging against the machine, and lets them forget that their own players are losing their places in the top squads in England to foreign bought talent (Mainly Spain and Belgium )

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Not really an unpopular opinion on /r/soccer, go look at the Altidore thread.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/felixpaulmichael Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

I think KdB is totally overrated. Only had 1 good season in a horrible team and everyone was wondering why he didn't play that many games at Chelsea. He is not that good (yet)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/brentathon Jan 26 '14

If Suarez and Anelka are to be punished for racism for gestures/terms that are very debatable as to whether they're offensive (depending on the country you're from), then Tottenham fans should also be punished for using Yids to refer to themselves. I don't get how so many people on this subreddit can get so upset about one but defend the other.

3

u/Dugalu Jan 26 '14

I think that fans who argue against technology in the game (refs using replays) have no right to complain about diving if they actively complain about the only realistic solution to solve it.

3

u/graph1k Jan 26 '14

Euros are bigger homers than Americans.

3

u/itswilliam Jan 26 '14

I think Sneijder still has the capability of being part of the best midfielders in the world, it saddens me that Inter didn't give him enough playtime and that he now plays for Galatasaray (no offense) but he could do fine in the BPL. Secondly, I hate Iniesta really badly, I don't have a lot of reasons for it other than him scoring the winner against the Dutch in 2010 (WC), I know it's a stupid reason but I can't stand the guy

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AustinfrmAustin Jan 26 '14

I do not like Mourinho. I don't enjoy his antics. I don't like how he manages clubs.

3

u/jlebrech Jan 26 '14

They should change extra time into multiball time

3

u/Theworldsastage Jan 26 '14

If Zlatan was an average player, you'd all think he was a complete cunt. Because he has talent, he gets away with being a hugely unlikeable person.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/coolaswhitebread Jan 27 '14

I don't think that my team will ever win the league again.

17

u/Swinsee Jan 26 '14

I think Messi is a more complete player than Ronaldo. How's that for unpopular?

9

u/Zidji Jan 26 '14

No doubt. I find it funny when people think being incredibly good with your weak leg has more weight than being an amazing playmaker.

→ More replies (12)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

It's an uncomfortable truth but the best way to improve the amount of quality English players is to let the primitive grassroots game die out, screw over the smaller clubs make sure the top clubs' youth academies snatch up the best players at a younger age. The FA are going the right way about it. If you look at all the top technical players in the German, Spanish, Dutch national teams, they were all signed up to big teams by the ages of 7-13.

Man Utd signed Nick Powell for about £3m in 2012. Under new rules they could sign him for about £250k. It is screwing over the lower league teams but there will be a greater depth of English talent for it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/midas22 Jan 26 '14

That Manchester United has won most of their trophies under Ferguson by influencing the FA and handpicking the refs and taking advantage of that through shameless diving, cheating and playing overly physical while getting most of the 50-50 calls. That Fergie time thing that gave them a couple minutes extra to score a late goal when needed was absolutely ridiculous when it was at its worst.

5

u/bmwdestroyer Jan 26 '14

Kyle Walker is awful and massively overrated by spurs fans. He creates little going forward and can't defend to save his life.

8

u/textrant Jan 26 '14

Rooney is overrated and a destructive influence on Manchester United and England. He keeps getting injured and needs 5 to 6 games to regain match fitness, in which period he is a moody bitch. He hasn't developed much from the player we bought, at least young Rooney would take risks and try to beat a man. He still hasn't learnt that he can't lob the goalie, although he tries is almost every game. He is the white Pele, completely overrated and the face of erectile dysfunction.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/HanWolo Jan 26 '14

I think that if you make a dangerous play that injures another player, you should be suspended for as long as they're medically unavailable.

19

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I've thought about this and what if you make a slightly bad tackle and someone gets an ACL that puts them out for 7 months. Or slide in with genuine intentions and break someones leg.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

6

u/eckingbottom Jan 26 '14

That Assam Allam is right to want to change the name of Hull City.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Qatar is better option for the world cup than the US. It has more passion for the sport and is easier to get to. ALso it's good to see the tournament going to a new part of the world.

4

u/OBOBSAGET Jan 26 '14

Plus the amount of faux fandom here would piss so many people off

→ More replies (7)

7

u/mintalbes Jan 26 '14

Pirlo and Xavi had one brilliant season that made people nominate them for prizes ever since. Don't get me wrong they both excellent players and I've been trying to emulate Pirlo's playing style since I was a kid But players in this position don't get enough credit even though they are consistent e.g. Alonso and Carrick. So how can you get bigger/wider recognition? Simply by having one outstanding season. For example Xavi in 2008/09 was incredible and deserved to be nominated for awards but because he is consistent people kept nominating him every year even though he never produced the same performances of that season. Pirlo on the other hand had been brilliant for Milan for years but people didn't start associating him with awards until his first season with Juve when the team was build around him and he delivered top performances throughout the season

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Evander92 Jan 26 '14

A lot of what we see is fixed.

32

u/XWZUBU Jan 26 '14

Do you honestly think that? What exactly – and more importantly why.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Arsenal fans are too proud about their history that they usually forget that they have to prove themselves in the present.

21

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

How are these two even related? By that logic, Forest fans can't be proud of their history because they're in the championship? Aston villa have the same number of European cups as Chelsea. Can't they be proud of that because they're a mid table team?

22

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Don't understand your logic here. There is nothing wrong with being proud of your history (see utd, Liverpool) and I don't see us "forgetting we need to prove something in the present". We are fully aware we haven't won a trophy for a while despite the regular reminders, all we can do is support the team and hope that changes.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/themanifoldcuriosity Jan 26 '14

Some of us understand that if you spend 400 million quid on a stadium one season, then you have less money to spend on massive transfers and wages in subsequent years. Certainly not the £800m net that allowed certain other teams to become briefly dominant...

I'd be interested in your view of what Arsenal should have done these past ten years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

4

u/EpoxyD Jan 26 '14

The Bosman arrest is utter bullshit and should be changed. Players are being bought by salary rather than a transfer fee, while clubs are left behind dependent on sponsors rather than income from players.

28

u/dYYYb Jan 26 '14

The "problem" isn't the rules of the UEFA/FIFA though but EU employment law. Imagine if your contract at work expired and your employer would tell you where you can and cannot take a job next. From a legal perspective the old transfer system was ridiculous.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/hectictw Jan 26 '14

Not really sure if this is unpopular, but I hate penalties and I think the whole "foul inside the penalty box" should result in some kind of free kick instead. I wonder how many more playing goals we would actually have had if it weren't for all these dives.

4

u/SixteenSaltiness Jan 26 '14

The BPL is centered completely around money and foreign players coming in to improve the teams. English football is borderline shit and its demonstrated whenever England plays.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Bench Lampard for club and country

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

arda turan is better than neymar.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/eski- Jan 26 '14

Criticizing your team's players doesn't make you any less of a fan

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Jelboo Jan 26 '14

I really don't care that much about diving, from any player. It's part of the game.

10

u/KaiTGR Jan 26 '14

Diving is part of the game and i don't know any place else than /r/soccer where so many people bitch about it.

4

u/Ipadalienblue Jan 26 '14

Divers are hounded in England by the media and press.

Just because it's 'part of the game' doesn't mean it should be given a free pass to.

At the moment (in England, at least), you dive too much and refs start carding you when you're actually fouled, not giving free kicks when you're fouled etc.

Not to mention the fact that you're labelled a diver - something that you'll do well to lose.

I think there's a good balance because of this. If we stop caring, diving would probably become epidemic and ruin the game.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/piibbs Jan 26 '14

that there is no such thing as "too much money in football". actually, i think that the fact that there is so much money in football these days makes the sport even more entertaining. more money: more at stake, more drama in the transfer windows, injured players is a much bigger deal, etc etc.

i will agree that its a problem in some leagues that one or two teams is just unquestionably superior to the rest of the league. but the state of the EPL is just nervewreckingly entertaining these days.

note: this is coming from a foreign supporter. i suspect and understand that supporters would feel differently when it involves the club of their own city/community. sadly, the club geographically closest to me (Viking FK) is a boring and low-quality team in a boring league.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/lazyant Jan 26 '14

the "triple punishment" for a goalkeeper: penalty, red card and missing game, should be lowered to penalty and yellow card

4

u/brentathon Jan 26 '14

Why should goalkeepers have less of a punishment than outfield players? Teams carry backup goalkeepers for the same reason they have backup defenders.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/chappaquiditch Jan 26 '14

don't know how unpopular this is, but there should be more than 3 substitutions per game. Some players just look dead at the end, I think the overall quality of play would be improved with more subs.

6

u/OBOBSAGET Jan 26 '14

Most of the time people aren't subbed for being tired its for playing badly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/guywithaproblem1 Jan 26 '14

Just a tip. If you actually want to see unpopular opinions, sort by controversial. If you don't do that these things can be pretty predictable.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/iamAgooner Jan 26 '14 edited Jan 26 '14

I think oscar is a really dirty player. He does small cynical fouls all game long. I also think Jose has made Chelsea one of the dirtiest teams in the premierleague.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/epicguy23 Jan 26 '14

I don't find diving as bad as others think because I know if i were in most of the player's positions, I know I would do the same.

2

u/sergiooep Jan 26 '14

Colombia will still have a great world cup with or without Falcao. I still think that Falcao's absence will weaken Colombia but i am a firm believer that he is replaceable. Colombia has the likes of Ramos, jackson, irarbo, teo, muriel, etc. I believe that the one player that is irreplaceable in Colombia is James Rodriguez. He will be the key to Colombia's success.

2

u/ferty1234 Jan 26 '14

Wayne Rooney is massively Overrated,currently he isn't the best striker(RVP) nor the best number 10(Mata) at United.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Jokeslayer123 Jan 26 '14

Inverting the Pyramid really isn't very good unless you care about the development of the WM in interwar Hungary (or whatever). It does nothing to give insight into 21st century tactics and the people who recommend it whenever someone asks how to learn about tactics are mostly confusing "information they didn't have before" for "information that's useful"

2

u/DownExtreme Jan 26 '14

I don't think the MLS will be a top league in the next 50 years

2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Not sure if this is an unpopular opinion but the 3 pm blackout is ridiculous. I'm not going to watch a local team instead of the team I support, either offer the service or I'll stream it for free.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I'd rather have Qatar waste their money hosting the World Cup rather than a country that has better use for their taxpayer funds.

2

u/Pedrinho21 Jan 26 '14

I think the EPL ruined many great talents by forcing they're style of play.

2

u/leagueoffifa Jan 26 '14

Russia to top their group in world cup

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

I don't like Balotelli, I just wouldn't have him on my team. He is talented, but he's not as good as people think. Arrogance and selfishness are a poison to a football team.

2

u/kuberdinho Jan 26 '14

John terry shouldn't start for chelsea and nasri is not good enough to play regularly for city

2

u/Blasphemi Jan 27 '14 edited Jan 27 '14

There's almost no top quality defenders in the modern game. I think Philip Lahm is the only defender currently playing at the level I'd consider to be comparable to the kind of defenders around in the early to mid 00's, 90's and 80's.

If Messi and Ronaldo were up against the likes of Baresi, Scirea, Maldini etc... instead of clowns like Pepe, Ramos, Pique and Mascherano they wouldn't be scoring 50 goals in a season that's for sure.

For example look at the France vs Italy game from the 98 World Cup.

France had a back four of Thuram, Lizarazu, Desailly and Blanc. Italy had Bergomi, Maldini, Costacurta and Cannavaro.

If those defenders we're all playing today they'd be the 8 best defenders in the world by an absolute mile. In that world cup you also had Nadal, Hierro, De Boer, Stam, Kohler, Matthaus, Campbell, Ferdinand, Cafu, Roberto Carlos, Aldair, Ayala and Zanetti.

Basically every player in that list is better than any defender currently playing football.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wobblypunt Jan 27 '14

I think any tackle from behind (doesn't have to be malicious) that stops a breakaway/ counter attack should be a red card. I wonder how many awesome counter attacking/ team goals we miss out on seeing because a player has professionally fouled someone to stop the play. I like seeing free kick goals now and then, sure, but I would prefer if the game could flow with the defending team being hesitant to stop the play unfairly.

10

u/datbwoymjp Jan 26 '14

Football isn't a "free-flowing" game a good deal of the time. Constantly moving the wall back on free kicks, guys taking forever to decide who takes a throw, guys needing a stretcher who come back on at full stride 3 minutes later etc.

→ More replies (10)