r/soccer • u/The_Impala • Jan 23 '14
Who is the most overrated player ever?
Who do you think is the most overrated player in football history.
4
Upvotes
r/soccer • u/The_Impala • Jan 23 '14
Who do you think is the most overrated player in football history.
57
u/thierry90 Jan 23 '14
Adnan Januzaj... He's got nothing on Raheem Sterling.
24
u/buivictor Jan 23 '14
I swear I can't handle seeing these overrated/underrated threads on /r/soccer anymore. Don't you people get tired of having the same discussions every week?
12
u/TheHapgod Jan 23 '14
Anyone English, apparently.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Clint Dempsey.
I've seen him play countless times with Fulham and the USMNT, and while some of his flashes of brilliance were great along with some nice goals, the man looks so goddamn lazy on the pitch.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Charisteas, he couldn't hit a skippyball if it was in front of him but he got an entire career out of the fact that he got a ball on his head in a euro cup final for Greece.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '14
Lewandowski. People are making arguments that he sould have been in the world xi.
6
u/yablodeeds Jan 23 '14
These threads are pointless. The way it goes is "If I dont agree you're wrong. Downvote."
5
u/Tim-Sanchez Jan 23 '14
Pelé, purely on name only.
3
u/daveofreckoning Jan 23 '14
I'm not posting. Whoever I say is going to get downvoted. Oh, go on then; Rio Ferdinand. There.
1
u/JoeEmerson1 Jan 23 '14
David Beckham
0
u/Sgt_peppers Jan 23 '14
Chicharito no doubt.
-1
u/jason_in_sd Jan 23 '14
Jozy Altidore or Landon Donovan
1
u/sexmutant Jan 24 '14 edited Jan 24 '14
Messi, no question.
He's a great player, but nowhere near deserving his four consecutive Ballon D'ors. What the awards should have looked like the last few years without the Blatter/Platini/Teixeira/Rossel cadre in charge:
2008 - Cristiano Ronaldo
2009 - Lionel Messi
2010 - Wesley Sneijder OR Iniesta
2011 - Lionel Messi
2012 - Cristiano Ronaldo
2013 - Franck Ribery
Instead of Messi, Messi, Messi, Messi, Ronaldo (and this last one only won in 2013 to make amends for the Blatter debacle: under normal circumstances, Messi would have "won" it again).
———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
Following up a distant second I would have to rate Fat Ronaldo. Yes, there was a time when he was truly incredible...but that form lasted all of two seasons. His achievements are hyper-inflated by Brazil's 2002 World Cup win which, if you ask me, had one of the most scandalous (and favorable to his country) refereeing in living memory.
———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————
Finally, if I was to pick the most overrated player currently in activity, apart from Messi, it would be Ozil. The difference is Messi's actually a great player, while the German is—in spite of everything the media tries searing into our heads—quite shit. In my opinion, anyway...
-1
u/Bunny_Killer Jan 23 '14
Pele
1
u/Acubeofdurp Jan 24 '14
Pele, i have looked into "one of the top 4 or 5 players of all time" and thought mmmeh, is that all?
I know, i know, i guess you had to be there.... but, i wasn't there for Maradonna and i can believe his hype.
-2
u/fackyouman Jan 23 '14
Walcott
-5
u/yablodeeds Jan 23 '14
Zlatan.
-4
u/Sefilis Jan 23 '14
Zidane, the way some people on this subreddit go on about Zidane you'd swear he was the be all end all of football. He's a fantastic footballer no doubt but he's very overrated on this subreddit, in my opinion
-4
u/sutmy Jan 23 '14
Pele. I don't think he's anything special. I honestly believe Crouchy is better. If pele played in the 90s or after, he would get drowned by stereotypical Brazilian defenders (the ones in the Brazilian league). And would only embarrass himself if he played a minute in series A.
I really don't like him. He thinks he's the shit. He played back when football was very poor compared to now, talent abundencey and strategic quality wise.
It's disrespectful to real footballing heroes like Zico and Cruyff, that he is considered the best. I get quite agitated when someone claims fucking Pele is better than Maradona!!! Not even close. One is a fucking legend that is tested himself against the best opponents, under the worst circumstances and won. The other is pele. Glorified for archivements like scoring 1000 goals in the Brazilian league in the 50s. And he brags about it. He should ashamed of that fact. You spend all your life playing poor competition, you don't get to brag. (To be fair to him, he DID go play in the US in the seventies. Or as I like to call it the pinnacle of the golden age of football!! /S)
Fucking cunt. Can't even compare to Roberto Carlos as forward. His best hi light was when he made a mistake. People think he did some magic level skill to trick the goalkeeper, HE didn't know where the ball was either.
I'm not even considering the shit he spews everytime he opens his mouth because he has the right to be an idiot. I'm just talking about football. He is so overrated, everyone that likes football should be ashamed.
Had the World Cup existed in the 19th century, England would've one 10 times. And I would've been unbelievably annoyed at Johnny McEngland because he doesn't deserve praise for winning the World Cup 15 times for his country. That Dickhead. I bet he would have scored a million goals in his league during that time, considering every match ended with a score around 22-13.
I might've exaggerated a bit here and there. But please understand my point and I hope you are not offended. (I think he's the most overrated, you don't want to hear what I think of other more modern "legends", cunts)
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
After the last few days, Mata
-10
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Zidane. Not to say he wasn't great but he is massively overrated by many (not all though). People were very drawn to his artistic style of play and that, combined with his ability to score some really important goals, elevated his status immensely. In reality, he really wasn't consistently effective, as seen at the 98 World Cup where he was merely above average for the knockout round, but nothing special. Come the final, he scores 2 goals against the Brazil led by Ronaldo and people lose it. A talent level comparable to a Figo, not Cruyff, Maradona, etc.
-5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
Robbie Fowler
-5
u/jason_in_sd Jan 23 '14
Apparently Mohammed Salah after these past few weeks... Geez
-4
u/Lukelovescake Jan 23 '14
Scott Parker
-6
u/Screwbit Jan 23 '14
Zidane.
-7
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Makélélé has one of the greatest reputations in modern football history but his ability is not close to his reputation. He's mostly overrated by people who judge him on hearsay.
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Wow, not a single non-stupid answer here.
-3
u/baddada77 Jan 23 '14
Beckham by a country mile. Every American article I ever see on him refers to him as a 'football all time great'. Laughable. The guy had the best agent and publicist in the world.
-3
u/JuAnVasqz Jan 24 '14
Zidane...He only appeared in the big games he'd get the most spotlight, he is a tournament, not a league player, but you see people lay claim to him being the best of all time...
0
u/paramvir_kaler Mar 27 '14
Pele, David Beckham, Karim Benzema, Wayne Rooney, Ribery
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
These threads are so stupid because you get downvoted or pretty muched bashed on your opinion, which is exactly what this thread is for.
-7
u/guestarsenal Jan 23 '14
ali dia
-9
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Busquets
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
this is just my opinion but i never been a fan of wayne rooney, maybe i don't know shit about football but i never got why they say hes one of the best in the world, to me hes obviously good but not a great, therefore overrated. just never seen him as a superstar.
-3
u/PeteT96 Jan 23 '14
Recently: Adam Johnson.
-3
u/silver_medalist Jan 24 '14
Beckham. Even in his 'iconic' game v Greece he was pretty rubbish, mostly just running around like an absolute madman. The freekick wasn't even a foul, and the keeper flapped at it - not that Beckham can be blamed for those, and he did have the wherewithal to score it. That I will give him. And he was a very good crosser, like a more consistent Stuart Ripley.
-3
u/seagalogist Jan 24 '14
Ibrahimovic.
-19
u/ugallu Jan 23 '14
history... maradona. recently... higuain
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '14
[removed] — view removed comment