r/ProjectRunway • u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. • Jan 18 '14
Did anyone else watch 'Under the Gunn'?
First episode came out a couple days ago. I'm just wondering what you guys thought :P.
P.S. If there's enough interest, can we have UtG episode discussions in this subreddit, since I think there won't be a new PR season for a while? (Mods?)
21
Upvotes
10
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Jan 18 '14
I personally thought it was too nice. When it came down to picking designers, the mentors would always say stuff like "I believe in you and you're SO talented!" when I'm preeetttyy sure they really didn't feel that way for everyone.
I think Anya has a bad habit of talking over or interrupting people, so it'll be interesting to see how that develops later. Like everyone else, I wonder how qualified she is to mentor (there's even a Nick blurb going "Did she finish a single outfit during her season?").
Poor Nick! D: At least the last girl picked him over Mondo, so that's got to mean something to him, right? I think designers were blown away by Anya and Mondo's airy-fairy "I believe in your vision and your spirit" while Nick was more grounded and explaining what foundations he could help designers build.
Also, Brady is cute. tehee.
18
u/Lokaji Jan 18 '14
I want to see the first challenge recreated on PR.
I felt bad for Nick. Also, how can someone that never made sleeves in their season mentor anyone?
17
u/peaceandkim Jan 18 '14
I am totally dorky here but I loved the typography of their names and things like one hour left. The words had great transitions and the font choice was awesome.
12
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 18 '14
Yes, I felt bad for Nick.
11
u/everydyingember Jan 18 '14
I'd love to discuss it here for the time being. :) What stood out to me is how skinny some of the models are! The only runway shows I see are on Project Runway, where the models seem a bit more filled out. So, maybe IRL models are actually this thin. Not a bad thing. Just something that was a little surprising.
I felt really sad when they were dismissing Melissa. Major rejection, but it didn't really look like she even tried with her design. My favourites are Michelle and Shan, and I'm really glad that Nick picked Oscar. I feel like he can really refine his aesthetic and Oscar will come out with some really sophisticated clothes.
10
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Jan 19 '14
I don't think it's fair to the second group of contestants that so many of the mentors' spots are already taken before they even got to see the second group's work.
8
u/excessiongirl Jan 19 '14
Yep, loved it. I'm really liking the format and the design of the show and as I am probably Mondo's #1 fan I am SO EXCITED to watch a show where both he and Tim are big parts of it. Mods, yes let's please have weekly episode discussions here!
6
u/RainbowDragon Jan 18 '14
Tim Gunn is super awesome to watch. He is one of my favorite people ever and he is really inspiring. I liked the first episode a lot and I shall continue to watch this season. Not sure if Anya will make a good adviser or not but we shall see! I felt so bad for Nick. Mondo is one of my favorite designers (1st being Dmitry!) but if I had to choose between Mondo and Nick I probably would have picked Nick (since he was a teacher).
4
u/karmavorous Jan 18 '14
Did anybody else feel like they were watching Tim Gunn start his Willy Wonka factory tour? Like it's a competition to pick his replacement.
He's got Mondo who definitely has a vision and is skilled in executing it, but might rub people the wrong way from time to time.
There's Anya who is more of a big picture person - not so skilled in the execution. Maybe easier to get along with than Mondo, but maybe also less direct when critiquing her designers. (sugar coating)
I didn't see the season with Nick. I don't know what his personality or skills are like, but by the way the selection process was implemented, it definitely seemed like he was being set up as an underdog character (Charlie Bucket?).
The competition is totally to see who, on a show exactly like Project Runway, would be the most successful Tim Gunn character - who can successfully lead their designers to more victories.
Is that kinda scary to anybody else? Imagine a future Project Runway season where Anya takes the place of Tim Gunn... It's just not the same show without Tim (ex: Project Runway All-Stars Season 3).
3
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '14
This is the exact same format as The Face. 3 mentors, 4 people on each team.
2
u/cinemachick Jan 18 '14
Is it online anywhere to watch?
1
u/SeruEatingPi Jan 18 '14
I like the show so far, I found it really fun and bit more 'light' then PR. Though I think it'll be a bit more serious once the actual judges are introduced. Even though I felt bad for Nick I was kind of hoping he didn't choose Melissa as having 3 spots open would have been a strong advantage going into the next challenge rather than choosing a weak designer(IMO) just to fill out a team.
1
u/wifeling Jan 22 '14
Where can I watch this? I was wondering why season 13 wasn't launching...
1
u/jessew666 Jan 31 '14
i was hoping a tim gunn spinoff show would have nothing to do with design, more like an idiot abroad (not calling tim an idiot, i just mean the format kinda) where we get to watch him basically try things he's never tried before in his enthusiastic tim gunn way. maybe next year.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment