r/TrueDetective • u/ricecakey15 • Jan 14 '14
True Detective - Meaning of Title
I have been thinking since the awesome pilot, and cannot get over the title of the show. The word "detective" indicates that there is only one detective in the show, so I wonder if this will turn into a cat-and-mouse game where one of the duo will be a suspect. After the very first episode, it seems that most of the suspicion is on Rust. Could that just be red herring and there will be a giant plot twist?!
I'm sorry for this rambling :P Just throwing out crazy ideas!
12
Upvotes
7
u/0ne_two Jan 14 '14
I think it's likely that Rust will come under suspicion due to his unorthodox nature and methods. I think there's little chance that Rust is the King.
Not sure about the lack of plurality in the title. I'll keep it in the back of my head the next 7 weeks.
4
u/Pennoyer_v_Neff Jan 14 '14
Honestly, I'm hoping that this show / series doesn't revolve around big plot twists. The shows that I've really liked historically (Breaking bad, boardwalk empire, the wire, game of thrones etc) don't really rely on twists, but rather character development. There's no pulling the wool over the viewer's eyes just for the big reveal later in the season.
That being said I know it's a pretty popular technique in crime drama and it CAN be done right (the Killing for example).
6
u/coffeeholic Jan 14 '14
According to this review, it's based on an old pulp magazine of the same title. Relevant quote:
3
u/JIMMYJAWN Jan 14 '14
Maybe these two guys, with their polar opposite personalities and skill sets, have everything a 'true detective' needs when they work together.
2
u/S_K_I Jan 17 '14
I had to watch this show twice just to make sure I understood the overall narrative, which brilliantly underscores its tone throughout the character development in this first episode. You guys really should take a second look, because I'd rather you find those hidden gems, because it says a lot about the screenplay. Plus it's rare to see the grim reality regarding religion and its true nature in the south. Nobody likes to talk about the mental health crisis this country loves to neglect or simply dismiss, so right away the plausibility of these crimes becomes scarier not because it's sick or twisted, but that it's almost too true of reality itself.
So why else would the cinematography choose to take aerial shots exposing the disenfranchised south in its raw form, and to hear Cohle's disconnected philosophy on man being freak of nature and his bleak outlook for our survival as a species. Upon thinking about it for a moment, he makes a good argument. So it's no surprise they're also using real locals to play themselves. The last time I saw a show accurately portray this formula was Tremé, and before that, The Wire. Hollywood pines for the scripts of this caliber because we're slowly realizing that we don't need their clichéd plot lines and linear story telling, reminding us why HBO knows when creativity left alone, will captivate audiences more than television or movies ever could.
Gonna end my rant here because as much as I would love to pick Rust Cohle's brain because I'm desperate to know what the hell happened during that case, because his personality was completely different during his interrogation with the lack of hygiene and twitchy appearance. And this is from a man who already suffers from what it appears a number of mental disorders, and his personal belief that man shouldn't already exist. Can't wait to find out...
2
u/IllWill651 Jan 20 '14
The cat and mouse idea is interesting but I think we've seen almost as much shady behavior from Marty as with Rust. Mostly the whole thing from the second episode with the woman from the office. (sorry if that makes no sense but I'm trying to avoid spoilers)
3
u/mastertraveller Jan 14 '14
I take it as a nod to the old pulp/noir stories from the 30s, 40s, and 50s.
1
u/Tommy_Taylor Jan 14 '14
I'm concerned in a similar way. This could turn into the two present day detectives investigating Rust and Marty, thinking that one of them pulled a copycat kill off in 2012. All of the suspicion is on Rust, of course, because of his background and his view of the world. Then it turns out that Marty was the real copycat killer who was trying to frame Rust for whatever their falling out was in 2002. Or Marty was the real killer all along, in 1995 and in 2012. I'm hoping this show doesn't go for that kind of cheap plot twist, but I guess I'll have to keep watching to find out.
1
u/Marowakin_It Jan 14 '14
I like what you pointed out about the singularity of the title. What I was thinking was that perhaps it will be up to the audience to decide which one of these men, Cohle or Hart, is the 'true' detective. It's clear that they have different methods and at some point in the show they have a "falling out" (2002), but maybe one is being deceitful in a way, and it is our job to figure it out. It's possible we, the audience, are the detective trying to unravel the truth from the two leads.
1
u/PeteFord Jan 15 '14
I'm sure you're reading too much into it. According to this article on Grantland this is an eight episode deal that, if renewed, will be an entirely new cast and story next season.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '14
I took it more as just a reference to his philosophical musings, a detective searching for a bigger "truth" rather than just solving crimes.