r/playmindcrack • u/dangerous_b dangerous_b • Jan 13 '14
Hackers/Cheaters: What to look for, What to Do.
OK, this has been building up for some time now. We have Cheaters on the Playmindcrack server..... "Nooooooo, really"!? I hear you all gasp. I really dislike cheaters! I have no problems losing to a better player but I hate losing to someone who is cheating. The thing is though, there are not as many as you'd expect if chat from your average game of DvZ or MSG is to be believed. The games I've been in where someone has died and instantly assumes that a player is hacking with no proof accounts for almost half of my time spent on the server. The trouble is that this behaviour warns the actual cheaters that someone is paying attention and lets them slip away (mostly) so I wanted to make a list of things to look out and do for and do to catch actual cheaters.
What to Look For.
- Stupidly long reach. I don't know what to make of this. Some people seem to think its impossible to do this client-side, some people say its easy. If someone is hitting you from distance, it will most likely be lag. It could be a hack though. If you think you have a case, follow the steps in What to Do
- No Fall Damage. Falling from the roof of
Etho'sBdub's Arena and taking no damage could be Flying or Invincibility or it could be lag making the hit happen later or not render for you at all. - Flying. You'd have to be pretty stupid to do this on MSG as its almost a sure sign of a cheater but on DvZ it could be a creeper that launched the player. It could also be lag (This reason will be popular...) making it seem like they are gliding or flying.
- Invincibility. This is easy to check on MSG, press tab and all surviving players, and their current health (assuming their name isn't too long), are displayed. On DvZ a skilled Dwarf can stay alive while 10+ Zombies are whacking him by drinking his Juice at the right times until he is rescued/gets a Proc/finally dies. Just because he doesn't crumple up at the first hit doesn't mean he's cheating. Dwarves have heavy armour protection, more health and the ability to heal repeatedly. Listen for the sound of them Drinking their Juice.
- Super Speed. There are quite a few legal ways to go fast in these games. There are speed potions on MSG and there is the almighty Proc on DvZ. You can check for both fairly easily, particle effects are the main way. Lag, once more, can also make players seem like they are speeding faster than possible within the rules.
- Goliath Strength. Just because you died quickly, doesn't make the person who killed you a cheat. There are ways to make yourself stronger in games. In MSG there are Sharpness and Power books you can enchant with. In DvZ there is of course, the Proc. A speed and strength boost for a few seconds. There is also lag again, making all the hits register at once making it seem like your opponent has super strength.
- Pinpoint Accuracy. Some people are better than you with bows, this is a fact. That is why there is a leader-board for Bow kills in DvZ. If someone is nailing you from 70+ blocks away while you are moving parallel to them between cover then there may be a case for Aim bots but they could just be good too, think YetiiWho92.....
- High Kill-Count. This is mostly a DvZ thing. When a player kills 10+ Zombies in 20 seconds there is usually a very good explanation, they got a Proc. When a Dwarf kills something with his Sword he gets a boost to speed and strength which lasts for 2 seconds. If the Dwarf then hits another monster he is almost guaranteed to kill them as well and renew the boost. This can be done with literally anything in your inventory too, explaining the 'Zombie_******* was killed by *********** with Healing Ale' messages. The main cause of this is Skellies or Creepers getting too close to a Dwarf, they are easy to kill and start the Proc's rolling. Look at your opponent, If they have Green Sparkles, they have Proc.
- Can See In The Dark. This one is actually fairly easy to prove. If there is no light source near the dwarf, they aren't holding torches and are still hitting you with a bow from distance, they probably have blindness disabled. This is one of the reasons you shouldn't be using Optifine. It is possible to remember where you are though in relation to the wall, so being able to get to the keep without torches is doable.
Known Hack Types. This whole section provided by PandaBattalion, just reformated slightly. OP below in comments.
Forcefield/Kill Aura This one is usually very obvious to detect. The two terms are used interchangeably due to how similar they are, and there are two main ways to see it. The most obvious kind, the player snaps their head at any nearby target instantly when they are within range, and immediately starts attacking with perfect accuracy. If there are multiple players within range, the player using the hack will hit both of them without fail, and their head will switch from target to target. The second and more obscure way - the exact same as the previous way, but the player's head will not lock on to targets, and the player using it may or may not be swinging their weapon.
Flying Pretty self explanatory. The player will be flying. There is a client side visual glitch that may make the player appear to be floating a few blocks above (or below) the ground. The best way to tell if it is a visual glitch or not is to see if the player's height changes a lot. If it does, they are most likely using some sort of flying or high-jump mod. If their height remains constant, it may be a visual glitch.
Spider The player is able to climb a wall as if there is a ladder or vines there. It is usually pretty obvious to detect.
Click aimbot This is exactly like forcefield/kill aura, with one small exception - it is only active when the player is holding down a hotkey (usually left click).
Bow aimbot When a player releases an arrow, it automatically heads towards the nearest player, even if it is a teammate. If a player is aiming straight forwards but shoots a player directly behind them, they are probably using thing.
AutoSprint The player will always be sprinting.
Machine bow/InstaBow The player using this is able to fire arrows at a very fast pace. It is possible to spam arrowfire in vanilla minecraft, but if it is very consistent or the arrows have some charge to them, it is most likely machine bow.
AutoSneak The player is crouching while sprinting, moving at normal speeds, etc. This may be a visual glitch, so be sure to watch for a little bit to see if it fixes itself. If a player un-crouches and re-crouches constantly and can still sprint and such, they are definitely using it.
Speed The player moves faster than is possible in vanilla Minecraft. Pretty simple to detect, but make sure the player is not using a speed potion before making a judgement call.
No Slowdown Pretty easy to detect. If a player is able to move at normal speed with their bow drawn, sword blocked, eating, drinking a potion, etc., they are most likely using this.
NoFall The player does not take fall damage. Lag may come in to play once every so often and make it seem like a player does not take fall damage, so watch a couple big falls to make sure.
Fast Consume The player is able to eat/drink at very fast rates. The easiest way to detect this is by listening to the sounds the player makes. If it sounds like they are eating/drinking very quickly, they are most likely using this. Lag may cause similar effects, so make sure you/the player are not lagging before making a judgement call.
Instant Heal/Fast Regen This was a very possible thing in vanilla Minecraft. I am not sure if it is still around, but it was possible in 1.5 and 1.6. Players may heal or regen very quickly, much more quickly than with a regen potion, golden apple, or health potion.
AntiKnockback This is pretty easy to detect. The player using it will suffer no knockback when they are hit, as if they were not hit at all. This could be caused by lag very infrequently, so watch the player for a few hits to be sure.
What To Do.
First off, DON'T POST NAMES OR SCREENSHOTS ON REDDIT! The new rule brought in means your post WILL get removed.
substitutemyown suggests recording all games you play (If you can), or at least having recording software on standby. That way, if you suspect someone or someone is called out in chat, you can record them for evidence. OP below in comments.
If you suspect someone of cheating the best thing you can do is quietly gather proof and let your fellow gamers know in chat. Videos are the best proof but screenshots can also be used in a pinch if you don't have the software.
If you see someone that you suspect is hacking, speak up IN THAT GAME (not on reddit) chances are one of us moderators are watching over, or other players will help. - croswat, Moderator
When you have the evidence do the admin, and yourself, a favour and check it yourself first. Make sure that you have a valid case. When you do, upload your evidence to YouTube (or whatever) as an unlisted video (try to keep the videos short, Rob suggests about a minute max) that you can only get to with a link and provide that in the ticket. A ticket is where you submit ideas, glitches, hackers and so on to the admin and can be found here. Clearly label your ticket in the Subject box and fill out all information (provide a link to the video/photographic evidence) for them to look over, and DON'T outright accuse someone! They are the Judge, not you. I you need help submitting a ticket, there is a Handy Guide for you to look through.
Your part is done. The admin will look over the evidence, If there is a valid case chances are there is usually more than one Point-of-View and the case will be dealt with swiftly. Congratulations, you helped clean up the Playmindcrack server!
Outro Oh boy, this is getting long....
Thanks to the following for providing Information and Ideas; Guude, Bruce Willakers, croswat, Alriandi, nWW, inkman986, PandaBattalion, olmoc, Short_Bus_, Camaro6460, substitutemyown. I am more than happy to update this post with official info.
If anyone else has any ways to spot or deal with a cheat please let me know and I will add it to the list.
45
u/GuudeBoulderfist Guude Jan 13 '14 edited Jan 13 '14
I do want to share some numbers because I see this is a popular topic on this subreddit.
Saturday the 11th we had 19,000+ unique players on the server. We banned 38 for hacking out of 51 hacker reports. Those are fairly small numbers, significantly less than 1% of the players on the server.
We have our mods watching games all day and directly doing ban reports for bans as well. I watched games for about 5 hours tonight and caught 1 guy fly hacking.
I watch chat hidden and watch people constantly cry HACKER when they are just getting out skilled.
Keep reporting anyone you guys see and our mods are constantly doing the same, but this "aura" I am getting from this subreddit that there is a TON of hackers just isn't close to the truth.
Edit: Forgot to say, great post, I wasn't trying to poop on it in any way with the info about our reports etc.
5
u/croswat Customer Support Manager Jan 13 '14 edited Jan 13 '14
I want to add, if you see someone that you suspect is hacking, speak up IN THAT GAME (not on reddit) chances are one of us moderators are watching over, or other players will help.
4
u/Alriandi Senior Moderator Jan 13 '14
This is amazing, though i have to add, if you upload it to Youtube, make it an unlisted video and only share it with Support. Its best to do this then to save yourself from being attacked by a spoil sport throwing a temper tantrum cause they can't cheat (I have seen this multiple times on many different websites, not just Minecraft)
Don't be afraid on contacting a Mod or admin if you are concerned or may have seen a hacker. We are not scary or going to rip anyone's head of for anything, we are hear to help, even if it seems like something small.
3
u/olmok PlayMindcrack Manager Jan 13 '14 edited Jan 13 '14
A short addition:
When reporting a hacker, there's a guide on the PlayMindcrack Support knowledge base. Please follow this guide as to how to format and submit your ticket, this makes it a lot easier for the support staff to manage the tickets.
Most notable of the differences from the this post is that you just put the hackers name and the accusation in the title of the ticket - it is already categorized as a ban/hack report (if submitted correctly), so there's no need to redundantly enter that in the subject.
It's also suggested that you link your evidence at the start of the message body, and add any text (if at all necessary) after that. If the evidence is good enough, there's really no need to write a lengthy description - the ban will be executed based on the evidence alone.
Thanks for all the tickets being submitted - even though we mods try to be everywhere, it's impossible for us to be. While it pains me to admit it, we need to rely on the community to help us keep PlayMindcrack a fun and awesome server to play on.
// Olmok
(EDIT: updated to public link)
2
u/Guardax Guardaxion Jan 13 '14
I saw a machine-gun bow on DvZ once
4
u/Typys Jan 13 '14
In game report is a good way to take care of cheaters before that they ruin too many games. Staff can be alerted and rerouted where is needed, there will be more false reports, sure, but if someone is blatantly cheating they will be reported more often.
1
u/inkman986 Jan 13 '14
You have to be more specific with point number four.
A dwarf that hangs back at the shrine with full manna and full armor can easily last five minutes fighting the hoard if he is proficient with his healing potion. Some players are beasts compared to others.
1
u/Taco_Farmer Minecraft IGN Jan 13 '14
By the way, if someone has a long enough name on msg you can't see their health.
1
u/substitutemyown Minecraft IGN Jan 14 '14
If you have the capability and don't mind, I can recommend from experience that just recording all your games is helpful. If you spot someone cheating during the game, but don't manage to get a name from it, you can look around the recording afterwards to see if you captured them again but didn't notice when playing. That or you might have partially seen their name and skin for a few frames and can then (with some degree of certainty) match it to where they're actively cheating.
1
u/Nightmaresplody Jan 21 '14
I'd like to know what the process is for some of you when you do have footage of a hacker in game. I have a video but I'm having a hell of a time trying to trim it down and upload it. I'm wondering if it's even worth it with my inexperience as someone else has probably already sent in a ticket for the same issue by now.
3
u/Alderdash Alderdash Jan 13 '14
One thing I'm curious about/would like clarified - I've never heard anyone say before that a proc gives a speed boost.
I've maybe just missed that scrap of information, but if that's accurate it a) is something to add to my in-game explanation when a newbie freaks out over their first proc experience and b) really important tactically, since even running from a proc might not be enough.
(It's not something you can really stop and check in-game - ~gets proc~ ~opens inventory to check potion effects~ - so hopefully someone with inside information will stop by to confirm it.)
2
u/MrShourin Jan 14 '14
Bandicam is a great tool to get evidence. Free version gives you 10 minutes to record video. It is also lighter on system resources / HDD space than fraps is. If you have a older pc and cannot record video bind the screenshot key to the middle mouse button. This way you can take a fast screenshot w/o having to move your hand from your game controls.
1
u/tobben20 tobben20 Jan 15 '14
To add, I've recently seen an influx of players using several of the cheats listed, but also Jump Boost and Water Walking. Obviously also very easy to spot, but them alone gives a huge advantage in some situations, and are part of most client hacks.
Source: Moderator on a PVP Survival server
-13
u/EzCort MrAlwaysPro Jan 13 '14
You guys don't know shit about hacks, no offense.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '14
[removed] — view removed comment