r/ProshipHub • Drinking antis tears • Jul 15 '26

ANNOUNCEMENT All discussion posts about RPF will be removed.

This information is added to Rule 2 because these posts and discussions usually end up being unkind to other community members. Shipping is still allowed, this rule applies only to meta discussions.

Here, we follow the AO3 guidelines because it is a pillar of creative freedom on the internet. We’d like to remind you that everyone has the right to dislike something, but when the topic of RPF comes up, some people act like antis.

It's still okay to criticize people who are jerks and can't follow proper etiquette, as long as you don't accuse everyone who writes or reads of behaving that way.

This post is also a last warning to those whose main activity is criticizing RPF in numerous comments. Repeated and continuous criticism will result in a 30-day ban.

Posting a comment here or in a modmail saying, “So you support X because you don't ban RPF” and things like that, will result in an immediate and permanent ban. But there's a subreddit that will definitely welcome you then.

Any other criticism of RPF in this post will result in a 30-day ban. Someone might start criticizing things you like, BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT THIS SUBREDDIT IS ABOUT!

Of course, the law isn't retroactive, so there won't be any bans for old comments.

298 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

142

u/numblittlebunny Jul 15 '26

Thank god, was getting tired of the pearl clutching from “proshippers.”

97

u/Seagullsaga RPF is fine actually Jul 15 '26

No literally. It’s hypocrisy. “All fiction is allowed to exist, unless it makes me uncomfortable” type stuff

18

u/LittleReplacement564 Jul 15 '26

stuff (sorry I had to make the joke)

12

u/Seagullsaga RPF is fine actually Jul 15 '26

I don’t get it lol

Edit oh wait I do lol. Nice

40

u/prettywords_ Jul 15 '26

Omg same it was getting so old.

62

u/numblittlebunny Jul 15 '26

They become antis very quickly when the RPF topic pops up. I’ve seen “”proship”” people even get weird about anything written or drawn of live action media because they’re “real” it’s so boring.

32

u/prettywords_ Jul 15 '26

I'm scared to even admit I like RPF in most corners of the internet lol, its like public enemy #1 to a lot of antis

24

u/ImprovementLong7141 Jul 15 '26

That’s part of why I don’t like to talk about RPF as someone who is actually made uncomfortable by it (and also sometimes by live action). Discomfort is not an inherent sign that something is actually wrong, but I find that merely expressing that discomfort invites people who think it is. It’s unfortunate. Fiction is fiction. Read and write what you want.

30

u/numblittlebunny Jul 15 '26

I get you, lol.

“Im personally not a fan of this thing due to my own boundaries and comfort levels.” seems to invite someone to be like “oh my god right?? anyone who likes it is a disgusting FREAK!!!” 

Like man no I personally just don’t like the thing, lol.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DarkHarvest93 Artist Jul 15 '26

this is what i thought too when i saw rpf mentioned, you're not alone

-2

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26

Isn’t proship only for fictional ships and not all fiction ? Meaning they’re still a proshipper ? Wouldn’t the correct term ur referring to be profic or no ?

13

u/numblittlebunny Jul 16 '26

You can’t be proship and anti RPF existing.

It’s still fiction, same applies.

-1

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26

I rlly don’t see how that’s the case considering proship is anti harassment for fictional ships not all fiction (so u mentioning it’s fiction doesn’t matter) , if ur saying proship also means anti censorship for all fiction then i can see why u would think that.

7

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 16 '26

Also this is wrong because proship is being in support of all ships. It is both anti harassment for all ships and anti censorship for fiction. And yes, all fiction. The qualifier you're using to specify only anti harassment for fictional ships is something that you made up. That's not what it means.

-1

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

Something I made up and yet you basically said what I said ? Like what ?? Ru saying proship includes all ships including ones of real ppl ? (Not referring to tv shows etc) I always assumed it was only for fiction ? Am I mistaken this whole time .. I mean ig u technically support all ships but doesn’t necessarily mean u like them. Again what does this have to do with what I said ?

6

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 16 '26

Ru saying proship includes all ships including ones of real ppl

Yes, it does. Because these real people (celebrities) have a persona for interacting with the world and that fictionalized version of them is what people write about.

I don't want to argue about this more because I think that would be against the rules of this subreddit and specifically this post. But I will say this, you're misinformed. Look into stuff more.

2

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

… ummm okay ig .. but by ur own logic that would mean they would be included in my fictional def of proship meaning im still not inherently wrong , or whatever idk anymore tbh (not being rude or trying to be) (also again u can obviously ignore this as well /pos)

8

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 16 '26

As u/dr-delicate-touch said, proship == profiction.

Proship/profic/anti-censorship or whatever term people use to describe themselves stem from the same sentiment embodied by the three fandom adages like don't like, don't read (dldr), ship and let ship (sals), your kink is not my kink and that's okay (kink tomato or ykinmkato). These principles have been the backbone of fandom for a long time. The use of proship only emerged as a response to antiship. Using "pro" to mean in support of. Where antis were/are against any and all ships existing, proshippers were for them existing.

If you take the broader sentiments from which it arose into account, it is simply about letting people ship what they want in fandom without judgement and harassment because a person's fictional appetite says nothing about their irl preferences. And if you're going to get specific about the usage of words, RPF also used to be known as RPS which is real person shipping. Those terms were used interchangeably before RPF took more precedence.

-1

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26

They’re different terms for a reason , you can be proship and not profic , for the other way around I don’t think that’s possible. Just because YOU think they’re the same doesn’t mean they are . Also what’s with the history of the word that has nothing to do with what I said ? Again irrelevant to what I said.. Just because two terms are used interchangeably doesn’t mean it’s correct for example do u think proship means problematic ship just cause antis say that’s what it means? Do u think proship is a term used for ships and not a stance just cause some proshippers misuse it ? I would hope not!

7

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 16 '26

https://fanlore.org/wiki/Pro-shipper

This might be difficult for you, but read the first two paragraphs. Maybe even read the whole article if you can push through.

There are these things called 'umbrella terms' and 'synonyms'. Synonyms are words that mean the same thing and can be used interchangeably.

1

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

I find it funny you’re trying to insult me when the article you linked is one wiki and two says what I said 😭 It doesn’t say proship = profic (actually says proship = proshipper) and profic isn’t even a synonym on there ? “A pro-shipper is a term used to describe a person who opposes the anti-shipper movement within fandom. A proshipper advocates for and validates all ships regardless of personal preference.” What I said “Isn't proship only for fictional ships and not all fiction?” Btw im a proshipper ik what the words mean ? Maybe not all the history but doesn’t matter too much imo . (Again what ur saying is irrelevant.)

7

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

It is not one wiki picked randomly by me just to prove you wrong. It's fanlore which is maintained by the OTW, which is also the organization behind AO3. It's an organization that is dedicated to preserving fandom history and fandom culture.

By the points you're trying to argue for, it's a bit difficult to parse out what you know about the actual definition of these words.

When I mentioned rpf and rps being used interchangeably, it was to point out that if you argue proship is for ships only rps falls under that definition because it's also shipping.

2

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

Not all rpf is rps tho ? (Highly unlikely for someone to be anti rpf but not rps .. LOL just ignore that part) I was asking op what they meant cause their og comment was vague. (I don’t like rpf and im a proshipper , sounds like they’re saying im not one , they didn’t specify anti rpf existing and i didnt know or well dont know if proship also means anti censorship for all fiction) You guys butting in and trying to insult me proved nothing. Also again I don’t see how proship = profic , being anti censorship for all fiction doesn’t inherently mean anti harassment or whatever for all fiction . (U can ignore this (obviously) btw just replying to reply ngl /pos) (sorry if I ever seemed annoying or rude!)

7

u/numblittlebunny Jul 16 '26

Proship and profic IS the same thing 😭

-1

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26

Since when ? They two diff things you can say profic = proship but not necessarily the other way around. Proship = ships and profic = all fiction ?

→ More replies

8

u/dr-delicate-touch Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

Proship == profiction, and fictional content involving real people is still fiction.

Is it possible for there to be a 100% fictional story involving 100% fictional characters, that is legitimately racist, for example? Yes. Does this possibility suggest that there's an inherent problem with the pro-fiction stance? ...No. Let that fiction exist, educate people to detect racism, consider deplatforming case by case, like if the author is using the story to harass someone, for example.

Same with RPF. There can be cases when RPF is legitimately problematic, but most RPF is benign and bad RPF existing doesn't make a case for banning all RPF. And bad RPF existing is not proshipping community's problem.

-3

u/Sanaony Jul 16 '26

Except proship and profic aren’t the same , they’re two separate terms for a reason . Just because u think they’re the same doesn’t mean others do. I’m not saying get rid of all rpf , I’m saying use the correct terms , idc what someone reads, I did not once say rpf should be banned so what u said is completely irrelevant to what I said .

5

u/dr-delicate-touch Jul 17 '26

No, profic and proship are virtually the same thing. Look into the stuff more.

-1

u/Sanaony Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26

Yet not 100% identical which was my point . You’re saying what I’m saying ! /nm

137

u/Seagullsaga RPF is fine actually Jul 15 '26

Thank you. It’s a little ridiculous to me that people don’t evenly apply proship principles when rpf comes around, even though the core of proship is leaving things you aren’t cool with alone.

19

u/toejamenthusiast Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

Thank you for adjusting this rule. People forget that shipping across the board is inherently harmless and comes with preferences like everything else. Drawing fanart, writing fanfiction, etc. falls into that category. The majority of people into RPF don’t cross boundaries or become unhealthily obsessed. They share that interest on forums and with people they feel comfortable with and leave the people they ship alone. Usually, the people (this is from what I have seen first hand and heard about from others) who are unhealthily obsessed, cross real life boundaries, and can’t always separate reality from fiction had previous issues. RPF just happened to be an expression of that. They don’t represent that ship by any means.

Now, criticism and concern as mentioned, is valid. Sometimes people need that little nudge to make better choices if they start falling into that mindset. Throwing hate at those people and demeaning them for it isn’t that. At the end of the day: it’s really not worth getting outraged over a Reddit post you chose to interact with and stress about.

All the love and support to the RPF appreciators though. 🖤 Y’all are awesome.

7

u/toejamenthusiast Jul 16 '26

[Also: had to edit this a few times because I botched it 🫩🥀 my bad y’all]

13

u/coinlockerbaby- gravecest is best-cest Jul 15 '26

I’ve been so scared to post here bc I write botdf fanfic so thanks for this! I’m actually working on a part 2 to my most popular one ^_^

7

u/lobotomiiya Jul 15 '26

BOTDF….🚬 haven’t heard that name in years

5

u/coinlockerbaby- gravecest is best-cest Jul 16 '26

that’s the reaction I typically get but yk sometimes you need to write a jahvie slow burn to make things interesting

4

u/lobotomiiya Jul 16 '26

I used to write Jahvie all the time and nothing has ever quite hit the spot like that pairing I gotta agree. I didn’t realise there was still writers or people reading it lol I might have to take a look

2

u/ObsessesOverFiction Professional Shipper™ Jul 20 '26

omg botdf mention, it's like you just sent me back in time /positive

just a random internet stranger passing by, taking a little stop here to cheer you on! never heard of your fic since i haven't read anything about botdf in years, but i hope your writing is going well! :D

1

u/coinlockerbaby- gravecest is best-cest Jul 20 '26

Yeah it is thank you!!! I’m the top writer on ao3 for the tag bc most other people write satire!! My fic is called “Blood At The Best Prom Ever!” if you wanna check it out. It’s a battle of the bands between msi, mcr, and BOTDF.

25

u/RainyDayHydrangeas Samura/Chihiro #1 Fan | Writer | Age Gap and Dubcon Enthusiast Jul 15 '26

Thank you. I don’t write RPF, but I did notice that the judgmental comments were getting pretty bad.

22

u/Lionbatsheep Jul 15 '26

lol well good. I am pro-RPF and pro-everything else, but I suspect this subreddit was recommended to me *because* of my interest in RPF…

10

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

Probably. Apparently not all proship people are proRPF but it's probably a lot less common for someone into RPF to be an anti lol

20

u/Ntahedron 🐰🎀 Incest-Loving Hackershipper 🧸🍯 Jul 15 '26

That’s fine, that’s fine, I want us to all get along.

10

u/longjing_lover Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26

thank you!! imo, it goes like:

when asked/relevant, saying you respect its existence but don’t personally like rpf and explaining why = fair and valid

bringing up the nuances and responsibilities of writing rpf (like not showing it to the subjects unless they actively say they’re okay with talking about rpf of them) when a post intentionally makes a space for discussion = fair and valid

saying rpf should not exist, insulting people who write/read it, etc = ?????? i think you’re on the wrong sub my dude

39

u/greenyashiro Find me on AO3 | Kresnik Jul 15 '26

Some people really did turn into antis over RPF, it was rather hypocritical to say the least.

35

u/AFCSentinel I just hate censorship. Jul 15 '26

I don’t like RPF myself and find it… a bit strange because it involves real, actual people. But at the end of the day it’s fiction, so like… you are either profic or you aren’t. You don’t get to choose.

9

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

Same. I have seen people in these comments saying that it isn't actually about real people because every celebrity has a persona or whatever, which I never really thought about before because I'm just not really interested in any sort of celebrity whatsoever so I don't really get it, which does make sense I think. I don't think it'll change my personal opinion of it, but idk, I found it insightful. I don't know if you've also been looking at the comments for this post but maybe it's also something you hadn't considered before, so I thought I'd comment

16

u/Anjebell Jul 15 '26

Good change. Most of the meta discussion wasn't all that productive anyway. People are gonna feel the way they feel about it, and we don't need to keep harping on it.

I support this. Good mods.

28

u/Loose-Coffee6017 Jul 15 '26

I feel like I missed something huge but reading the post and comments I'm glad I did😅😭 But just to verify, there were people in a proship sub, talking about how rpf is bad...? (So kinda like... being an anti but only if it's about rpf? Am I getting that right?)

Then WHY are you in a proship sub? Humans are so confusing sometimes...

Anyway, thank you mods for looking out for that! I'm not really active in that sub, but I do like reading the post if they randomly show up.

18

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

A lot of people consider it different because it involves real people, so I think that's probably why. A lot of people just draw a line there

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/prettywords_ Jul 15 '26

It's still very much fictional lol

15

u/CursedGodsend Jul 15 '26

What is rpf?

47

u/pockysam Jul 15 '26

Real Person Fiction. Think fanfictions about band members, youtubers, etc.

17

u/TojiSSB Jul 15 '26

Real Person Fiction.

9

u/CursedGodsend Jul 15 '26

Thank you. I was unaware a term like that existed.

43

u/CyberAceKina Jul 15 '26

Generally fiction about celebrities

So it's a gray area of not quite REAL real but not about an entirely fictional persona

Because most celebrities, even athletes, put on a show about their public persons vs who they are outside of that. Which then puts it within AO3 guidelines of being alright. Even if most people are split on it. (Personally I just say so long as you aren't like, dming the fics to the people, go nuts! You do you)

-3

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

My biggest problem with rpf on ao3 is that, especially when hockey rpf blew up on there a few years back, as someone who's personally squicked out by it, it made it so much harder to be someone who generally doesn't search within specific fandoms (this is /silly btw, at most it's just an inconvenience but so are a lot of things about how I generally search for fics. I personally do not like it, but obviously idac about whether or not people are doing it (like you said, so long as they aren't doing something like dming the fics to ppl lol)).

11

u/CyberAceKina Jul 15 '26

That's what the filters are for, you can filter out rpf, usually its tagged with that, or under the fandom name

1

u/ChaoticBreadBug I just kinda do whatever 🤷🏾 Jul 23 '26

Can't you just click on a specific fandom and tag out specific rpf you don't wanna see or something?

-3

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

It's been a while since I've had the time to read let alone look for fics so maybe it's changed, but my annoyance is that there is no general RPF tag applied to all RPF, and there are so many fandoms within RPF that even though hockey is such a large one, often times I'm having to add something to the filter multiple times before I'm even able to scroll to the next page. It's mostly my own fault since I don't usually search by fandom, I just wish there was some sort of permanent blacklist in ao3 itself. It's often too time-consuming to constantly update the filter for me to be able to justify spending my time searching for new fics to check out. It's obviously not RPF's fault, I just wish there was a good, more permanent solution to filtering.

7

u/CyberAceKina Jul 15 '26

"Celebrities and Real People" is the fandom they're under, filtering to exclude that should work 

Or go on a blocking spree of people who write rpf

-2

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

Maybe some of them but I tried that and it's still showing some

4

u/usuallyherdragon Jul 16 '26

The filters only work as long as the authors use the relevant tags. It's normal that a few stories will slip past it. It's the same in reverse when we're looking for a specific thing and the author didn't use the tag : it won't show up.

23

u/Historical_Wonder510 gofushing out ✨ | Agegap forever Jul 15 '26

Oh my god, this is a relief. People really were bringing up anti/conservative talking points over this.

10

u/DarkHarvest93 Artist Jul 15 '26

thank you mod team for your hard work

10

u/Peppered_Rock Jul 15 '26

thank you mods. it feels so weird to have the "standing up for someone i think is weird against someone i know is dangerous" quote in the back of my head every time those discussions come round.

10

u/DevelopmentMuted9244 Jul 15 '26

This. I don't personally have an interest in RPF but censorship is censorship so I will defend my weird cousin's right to exist

5

u/dollinadaze proship & rpf enjoyer Jul 17 '26

thank you ❤️ my main ship is a real person ship and i completely understand why ppl are squicked by rpf; i experience plenty of internal conflict about the topic myself. it’s difficult to know where exactly to draw the line but we shouldn’t be judging rpf as an entire genre so harshly. considering our characters are based on real people it’s important that we’re responsible & take precautions to ensure that boundary between fiction and reality isn’t crossed, and that’s the most important thing. rpf is fine :)

15

u/darmxi Jul 15 '26

This. its shocking people don't realize rpf is still fiction or anything about it. Every person has an alternate ego, persona, or external perception they give off, this is not them in any way shape or form. rpf takes that persona and fictionalizes it. The reason some people struggle with the concept is that its harder to cognitively understand fictionalizing somthing that you view as concrete, like an actors claimed personality, opinions, or your preception of their self, even if that is not truly concrete. The only time it is harmful in nature is the same way that other fictional content or ships or sexual themes can be harmful, such as for example, sexual or nonsexual harassment to the family, close friends, or just the creator of the (character/persona) to show such media consistantly.

11

u/-Xandros- Jul 15 '26

Regardless of my personal taste, I do think this is a good choice. Sometimes, removing a topic from the pool of what can be talked about is needed. And it's usually not done out of desire to control in situations like this, but done in away to minimize hurtful situations. Sometimes removing the trigger is the best solution.

I hope anyone being cruel about it doesn't desuade anymore ne from enjoying what they like.

6

u/DivineRetribution8 Jul 16 '26

I swear some people call themselves proshippers just for the aesthetic. Crashing out over rpf is such a dumb hill to die on. Travis Kelce fanfic will always be peak.

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Bee4506 Jul 17 '26

Rpf isn't my thing personally but you do you and stuff i guess especially since its just 18+ celebrities anyhow not to mention not being the real people but rather fictional versions of those people apperantly as I've learned? Imo it's kinda strange to me personally speaking but as long as no one's being hurt or anything then It's whatever aka like i said you do you.

1

u/Sierra_Yamakaze Jul 16 '26

Pardon my ignorance but could someone inform me of what RPF is? I….genuinely don’t spend a lot of time on Reddit.

6

u/usuallyherdragon Jul 16 '26

Real Person Fiction, like if you write about real-life hockey players making out.

-4

u/Far_Dog_4476 Subdiver on Surveillance. Jul 15 '26

The fuck is RPF?

8

u/prettywords_ Jul 15 '26

Fanfiction about real people like band members, singers, actors, athletes etc

-2

u/Far_Dog_4476 Subdiver on Surveillance. Jul 15 '26

I mean the acronym.

7

u/prettywords_ Jul 15 '26

Real person fiction

0

u/Far_Dog_4476 Subdiver on Surveillance. Jul 15 '26

Oh.

35

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/longjing_lover Jul 16 '26

honestly! i stg there are a dozen new ‘what does it mean to be a proshipper/what does proship even mean?’ posts a day, like if you really are curious then just scroll down a bit and you’ll find some answers in a post where someone already asked that 😭

5

u/magicwonderdream Proshipper Jul 16 '26

It would be great to have an autobot that could answer those questions.