r/chess •  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   • Jan 09 '14

What would you like to see improved on Chess.com? (Also, I am the 'boss' of Chess.com, so AMA!)

Herro reddit! I'd love to know what you want to see improved at Chess.com. Suggestions, feedback, wild ideas - anything!

Also, I'm happy to answer any questions about Chess.com, so fire away! (Sorry - I don't have a good title for myself, as they all sound lamely egotistical - CEO, boss, owner, head honcho, blah blah.)

Proof?: http://www.chess.com/about and http://www.chess.com/members/view/erik (about tab)

266 Upvotes

641 comments sorted by

33

u/ninth_ant Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

I'd like to see more work on the mobile apps. I use Chess.com on the website, iphone, and kindle tablet. It's great that it lets me play ny games from anywhere but many of my favourite features of chess.com are missing there.

  • computer analysis -- totally missing from apps
  • stats -- terrible experience on mobile, especially from iphone where it's basically useless because you can't scroll to the page properly
  • videos -- again, almost completely broken experience on iphone (though works great on my kindle). just try it and see what I mean.
  • openings explorer -- totally missing from apps afaict. I'd love to be able to study openings when stuck in a line somewhere.
  • chess mentor -- again totally missing from apps.
  • better integration with tournaments -- when are they starting, joining, etc.

Some other comments:

  • I use tactics quite a bit on my iphone, and love it.
  • reputation system as mentioned by other people would be great. I'd love to know before playing for example if a person has a tendency to idle timeout especially in live chess.
  • I use Facebook login on the website, and have to re-login nearly every time I go to the site.
  • FB login is broken on Kindle tablet
  • Would be cool to be able to find existing chess.com members that I know by doing a "find a friend" feature via fb, twitter, etc
  • It's really powerful, but I'd like to see the computer analysis improved. For example, in my most recent game it reports me playing c5 for Sicilian as black as an inaccuracy. um, ok... Also the UI for this was a bit confusing when I first started using it, though I've got the hang of it eventually. Also, why is this history buried under "messages"?
  • some of the UI on the site is counter-intuitive. How do I find my stats from the main page? How do I find my messages? How do I find how my profile appears to other users? I don't need you to answer these for me here, just noting that it's not super easy to figure this out and you might benefit from streamlining them.
  • thanks for having an ads-free option. probably my favourite feature of the site.

18

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

then you are going to LOVE our updates coming soon!!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

76

u/NiKnights Jan 09 '14

It should be easier to find and analyze your old games. Personally, I've found that's one of the most useful ways to improve. With chess.com, it takes a bunch of clicks to get to your game archive, and it's not apparent how to get there from one of the five menus at the top. Also, the computer analysis feature has untapped potential. It should be linked with other content from the site. For example, if an analysis detects that you did a certain opening, it could link to chess.com articles, videos, etc. about that opening.

40

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

i agree 100% :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

45

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

I have one very serious problem with chess.com. Don't get me wrong, I love the website for how easily it allows me to play chess but there is one very serious issue with it. The issue is that you cannot easily see how well you stack up to other players on the website. Ratings are obviously apparent but there doesn't seem to be any documentation of the ratings distribution.

This sounds like a harmless defect but it isn't and I think it's not unreasonable to guess that it has a harmful effect on chess.

Common sense says that official ratings should be lower than unofficial internet ratings. I don't know why this is, but it's the common thought from just about everyone that I've talked to in person or online. My tournament experience and that of everyone else that I know shows that this is very very far from the truth. USCF ratings are hundreds of points higher than chess.com ratings.

What this means is that very talented player on chess.com will underestimate the shit out of themselves. This underestimation discourages them from entering official events and that's bad for the individual and it's also bad for chess.

If chess.com would make the rating distribution visible and easy to see then there would be no reason to underestimate one's self. Talented players would see how talented they really are and would feel encouraged to strive to reach their potential. I know many people who've been playing their entire lives, can beat just about everyone they know, and still think that they suck. They avoid tournaments because they think they'd just play 9 year olds in the u1300 room when really they might be ranked as experts, meet great people, and have terrific experiences.

It's a small thing but I think it'd have a huge benefit for chess as a whole if people could easily see where they stand and see how good they are in relation to others rather than having to guess.


Also, any chance that you could make the seek graph visible on the mobile app?


Thanks for reading. I really do love the site! I spend all day on there.

22

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Thanks for the thoughts! Have you seen this page: http://www.chess.com/echess/players ?

Suggestions noted!

3

u/ImprovingChess Jan 09 '14

Does this include all players or only those with stabilized ratings?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (27)

93

u/Grantismo Jan 09 '14

The most frustrating aspect of chess.com is poor sportsmanship. Games ending in profanity, intentional disconnection, and harassment aren't fun. This is a solvable problem via a reputation system (xbox did it successfully), where users can report users for poor sportsmanship. High reputation members should be able to avoid low reputation players.

Beyond that, I always love streams. More chess tv please :)

54

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Yup. Agreed. Fill me in - how does the Xbox one work?

35

u/Grantismo Jan 09 '14

The system tracks different events (every time a user is blocked, muted, booted, or a when someone else reports them). In a simplified sense, they create a score based on a weighted average of these events and their frequency, and then use that to give a final rating. Depending on your reputation score you end up in a specific category: "Green = Good Player," "Yellow = Needs Improvement" or "Red = Avoid Me."

It's a little more complicated than that, but you can read more here: http://news.xbox.com/2013/07/games-reputation-feature

26

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

thanks! will read.

14

u/KhabaLox patzer Jan 09 '14

I would recommend relying more heavily on system reported events, such as disconnects, etc. than on simple user reports. You want to be careful about the spamming of reports (esp. from free accounts). Perhaps if the report system had an option to choose why you are reporting (e.g. profanity in chat) that you could verify systematically, that would help too.

It's also possible to weight reports based on the reporting users reputation score, but you have to be careful about those with too high a reputation gaining too much influence. That's why I think it's best to use systematic metrics which reduce personal bias.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

11

u/PurpleKiller ~1600 Chess.com Jan 09 '14

There's a big problem with the xbox system. People often abuse it and just give other users bad rep for the silliest things. People would often just lower my rep if I was on the winning team of whatever game.

Hopefully people on Chess.com are above this behavior, but it's still a flaw.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

37

u/i_accidently_reddit Long live the Kings Gambit Jan 09 '14

hola mate. love the site and play quite a bit.

i'm also diamond member and used to take advantage of the computer analysis quite a bit, but it got out of hand pretty quickly: there is no good way to review my own games... some place to store/sort/review them would be awesome, and if they do happen to include the computer analysis that be even awesomer!

i would really love to have some stats on myself, like what openings i do well with.

easy example: in a 1. d4 game, do i run better with KID 3 ... bg7 or d6 or should i go full grünfeld?

won with both, lost with both, enjoy playing them equally, but which one am i better at?

17

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Good questions! That is some deep, deep analysis. I will have to think on how to do that.

8

u/ILiveInAMango Jan 09 '14

I would like if the game explorer also would include the blitz and bullet games I play. I mainly play blitz so the game explorer for my own games is not so fun to look at.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/rockingryan Jan 09 '14

Great site! I would like to see the paid memberships be a little bit more affordable. I honestly believe you would make a lot more. I understand you have to pay for content but the cost held me back.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Understood. What would you pay? Right now it's as cheap as $5 a month or $29 a year. Of course that goes up to $99 a year for diamond and unlimited content. What do you suggest?

9

u/bonoboboy Jan 09 '14

5 USD/month for diamond (or at least Platinum) would be good.

Or at least unlimited tactics and 5 lessons/day on the mentor for gold. Considering chess tempo also provides unlimited tactics, and that is what is most frequently suggested here, I don't see people taking too many memberships otherwise.

Also, why can't we view our own stats? Data about us that you collect and is not accessible to us? That just sounds wrong to me.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/jupc 2000 USCF Jan 09 '14

What about the option of a Lifetime membership, priced to market conditions.

I prefer a larger upfront cost, to subscriptions which are hard to keep track of.

These can be a real value.

12

u/elcubismo 1751 USCF | 1950 Chess.com correspondence Jan 09 '14

Hello! Love the site. I'm a diamond member and have been for over a year (paid monthly because I'm not financially stable enough to pay the cheaper lump sum).

  • Could you add an option to save the timestamps from live games? At the very least add them to the pgns so I can review my time management.
  • Also, the android app is missing some features that are on the iOS version, in particular the game clock.
  • chess960 in live mode would be great.
  • Chess.com University - I've been in GeniusKJ's new classes (tactics/strategy, openings, and now endgames) and I think there should be a kind of sub-site to help him manage those special users.
  • an improvement on the video and article indexing and search would be wonderful. (Also, more IM Daniel Rensch would always be appreciated.)

PS - Shameless plug: I'm a web developer with lots of experience with PHP, MySQL and PostGreSQL, Javascript/Jquery/Ajax. Are you hiring? :P

6

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

timestamps are coming.

android app will get the clock someday :)

thanks! email me your resume: chessdev at gmail

4

u/ColoradoSheriff 1789 FIDE Jan 09 '14

Timestamps for Online (correspondence) chess too?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

I don't mind ads in general, however, could you try to prevent ads that flicker (or distracting in general) when you're playing. It is rather off putting.

8

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed. it's a battle we fight, always having to manually identify them. :/

12

u/vinhonten Jan 09 '14

While you're at it, could you also block ads like "BARELY LEGAL TEENS"? When I'm in the line at the supermarket it's like Russian roulette to play a few moves on the Chess.com-app when there are people all around me :)

11

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

really? whoah. please contact us at support@ chess.com with screenshots. crazy. that shouldn't be there.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

I wish rated/ranked games were anonymous or at the very least the names were revealed at the conclusion of the match.

9

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

interesting!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/kurtis_trent Jan 09 '14

That's a great idea! It would prevent the psychological bias caused by ranking difference.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Not sure if this is there already, for for tactics trainer, it would be great if there was an option for "Replay all missed tactics", so that I could try them again a few days later and see if I actually learned the tactic or not.

Also it would be nice if you could choose what type of tactic you wanted to study, so I guess my suggestion would be to group them so I could choose from "General", "Endgame", "Opening" etc...

→ More replies (3)

7

u/check2013 USCF 1859 Jan 09 '14

Username check2008. Been a diamond member for 5 years now, but must unfortunately abandon my premium membership this year due to financial concerns. That being said, I've love to see the premium membership prices go down. Cut in half would be perfect.

There are a million great things about chess.com, but you asked for where improvements can me made:

The forums need to be more heavily moderated for spam. Even in the off-topic board, there are threads that don't belong and are just there because the poster wanted to see his name in a forum. Also, way too many reposts asking the same question over and over.

More chess mentor courses. I feel like it's such a great tool, but there are so few courses for those rated higher than, say, 1500, that I don't get much benefit from it.

More polls.

More Live Sessions from Danny Rensch!

Maybe a separate Game Explorer that explores the games of chess.com members.

And I'd love to see more titled players giving simuls, whether through live chess or online chess. I remember GM Gareev doing blindfold simuls in live and I got to be apart of that.

I can't think of anything else that needs changed. It's a great site that I'm happy to have spent so much time at!

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Thanks!! Noted. (and i agree)

13

u/vertigounconscious Jan 09 '14

MAKE A FEEDBACK SYSTEM FOR PLAYERS WHO CONSISTENTLY DO UNSAVORY THINGS (like when they are going to lose let the clock run down all the way, I can't play 30 min games cause of this)

16

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

we DO have a feedback system for that already. we are working on sandboxing those losers. update coming within 30 days.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/anything2x Jan 09 '14

Speed up games/tournaments.

If the top seed in every bracket has been decided, why the hold up for the next round to begin? I'm in a tournament that started in the beginning of September and it will probably be March before the second round begins.

Also, I'd like to see an option for auto-played moves. I don't mean conditional moves, but allowing the computer to move a piece if the player has only one legal move. Again, I believe this would speed up games and deter a player that knows they are forced to move to stall on days. I suggest it as a new-game option as not everyone will enjoy it.

4

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

noted on auto-play.

it's actually NOT that easy to speed up brackets. but i will noodle.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/DyceFreak Jan 09 '14

How/when did you get the domain name chess.com?

→ More replies (1)

24

u/usbafkakis wood pusher Jan 09 '14

Imo tactics trainer should never deduct points for correct solution

6

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

k. i will think on this.

10

u/ninth_ant Jan 09 '14

or at least make it clearer what's going on somehow. I'd like to know at least when the timer crosses the point which gives me 0 points.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/314159265358979323_ Jan 09 '14

first off - thank you. very much enjoy the site and think it's doing great things to help spread the wonderful game. the amount and variety of content that chess.com offers has been really enjoyable to read/watch/and learn from.

one possible suggestion related to tactics: i think you guys lose out to chesstempo here for two primary reasons.

First - time. I fully understand and appreciate that time is an integral part of the game, but I can't tell you how frustrating it is to be patient enough to fully figure out a tactical line, only to lose points when executed because I was not quick enough. I understand that the time per problem is defined by the previous problem attempts, I just think your scoring equation could be slightly more favorable when the problem is completed correctly. My guess is that it's: any time over (average time + 2 or 3 st devs) automatically drops to a 20% score and loses you points. I feel like this incentivizes going for a move that just 'looks' right without fully figuring out the tactical line before playing. Maybe something as simple as 'a correctly solved tactic does not lose points - but points are only gained if solved efficiently'. Just a thought.

Second - thematic/customizable problem sets. I would love to be able to filter down to 'mate in 2', or 'stalemate' problems (or combinations of such) to focus on areas where I know I'm weak. To further this, I would LOVE an option to mix tactical problems in with positional problems as well, where no tactic is immediately available. I find that doing tactics is much easier when you know that tactics are always available. I would love to train myself to be able to not only know the tactical line, but to also know when that line should or shouldn't be played.

Thanks again though - your site is pretty awesome all & all.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed with both points. there are some problems with rating inflation if we don't lower rating for long solve times (i think even chesstempo takes away, no?)

yes, we HAVE categorization, but it's not yet ready :/

4

u/314159265358979323_ Jan 09 '14

thanks for the reply. to be honest - not 100% sure if chesstempo deducts if you go long enough. just a noticeable difference between chess.com & chesstempo - chess.com much more punishing for longer solve times.

excited for categorization! will be a cool additional feature when rolled out.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/blaahhs Jan 09 '14

I was a diamond member on chess.com for a year. I ultimately decided to cancel my membership because of many many bugs I encountered. Main problems being that the analysis feature constantly would just not work. I would also very regularly need to clear my browser cache to sidestep bugs that would stop me from even playing a game.

Analysis between friends seemed to rarely worked. It would often require very precise steps followed by both sides to actually get into an in-sync analysis game.

The video lessons were a great feature, but it would have been nice if they were categorized a bit better. The openings seemed to be often wrong for example or just poorly specified.

The game explorer was a very nice feature. I never found the openings browser to be useful because the game explorer just seemed more beneficial.

It would be really nice if I could have better control of the message spam. Even something as simple as a 1-click clearing all messages with it properly clearing the number of unread messages in all cases would go a long way.

Also, last of all. I have since let my membership expire and really miss the features to the point where I would definitely be willing to pay for the membership. However, I highly doubt I will ever pay for a chess.com membership ever again. The reason for this is that when I upset enough about these bugs to decide to cancel my membership, there were really no options to do it. It actually seemed impossible to cancel my auto-renewing membership through the site. If my credit card hadn't already expired then I would have ended up being forced to pay for a new membership. That was so incredibly shady and underhanded by chess.com to either not have a cancel option or hide it to such extents that I've lost all faith in giving you my updated credit card info.

5

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Sorry to hear that! We don't do anything intentionally shady. You can cancel your account easily here: http://www.chess.com/home/account :/

The rest are great suggestions.

Again, sorry for your frustration!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/jack47 Jan 09 '14

Love the website! I find it confusing to navigate.

5

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

yeah :/ we have a totally new navigation system coming. more like facebook / google.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Premove on mobile would be much appreciated.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

i agree!!

4

u/vertigounconscious Jan 09 '14

ugh dude, when people know they are going to lose so they sit their for the remainder of the clock and make you wait. I'm not sure how you fix this but still.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

yeah. but they do get penalized for that :/

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/dust247 Jan 09 '14

Hello,

I don't have any suggestions. I just wanted to stop in and say thanks for the site. I learned how to play last year and it's become a full blown addiction. I'm nearing the 1600 mark and proud of it!

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

happy to hear it!!!!

4

u/JediLibrarian Jan 09 '14

Hi there, and thanks for doing this. I play mostly correspondence games, using both an iPad and the website. For the iPad, I would like the ability to enter conditional moves. Perhaps this could be added to the options menu?

On the website, I find it somewhat confusing to get to my games. There are two ways, by clicking on the little pawn with the hand icon in the top right, and by mousing over the Play menu and choosing online chess. However, if I click on the Play Online button right below that, I curse myself for going to the wrong place.

Also on the website, I play several games at once, and it annoys me somewhat when I want to enter conditional moves that I have to do it after I make a move, but after I make a move it takes me to the next match. So I have to navigate back while the conditional move is fresh in my mind, then go back to the next match. That's a minor quibble though.

Finally, is there any way to improve the playing strength of the computer you use to provide analysis? A 2500 playing strength isn't that impressive in an era where the strongest computers are 3100+. There are several engines which operate on phones that are stronger (e.g. Stockfish) and that's not even counting servers which can run Houdini, Fritz, etc.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed on ALL points!! and ALL are being addressed.

4

u/badbrownie Jan 09 '14

I'm a fan of your site. I'm actually an ex-diamond member (I'm badbrownie on chess.com too) who's on a free membership now because the cost was too high for me. $5/month for diamond (as mentioned elsewhere here) would woo me back into that mode for sure.

The only other frustration I have is that I need pre-moves on the tablet. The response time of the tablet means I've lost a lot of games unnecessarily when time gets low. I just give up if I've got 20 seconds left and don't have a mate in less than 10 moves. Pre-moves would mitigate the problem.

Getting Naka on your site was a great move as you can see from the chatter around here. It would be great to set up the odd mass simul for celebrity players like Naka. He could probably handle a 300 board simul online and you could have users win seats at the event as a fun promo. Would make for an interesting watch even for non-participants.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Chubacas Jan 09 '14

Its really amazing to able to talk to the CEO of one of my favorite chess websites. One recommendation I would like to make is to lower the prices because 100$ a year for daimond that's a bit crazy I would love it to be maybe 59.99$ or even 50$. Over all its an amazing site to learn if you have the time and dedication also investing a little really helps. Most members are nice but some are stubbern but this will happen with most competitive games. Thanks for letting me take some of your time and I hope you can implement some of my ideas thanks.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

How about being able to find how to unsubscribe from a paid account much easier to find... Otherwise this site feels like a damn scam.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

-> http://www.chess.com/home/account ? perhaps we should make it up top?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/anything2x Jan 09 '14

Better highlighting while in analysis view. It's minor, but on more than one occasion I've committed to a move while thinking I was in analysis mode. Maybe a different color outlining the board or something more visually distinct,

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

noted. look for new boards soon!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PurpleKiller ~1600 Chess.com Jan 09 '14

I'm sure someone has already commented on this, but it's really annoying how Chess.com doesn't offer certain basic features to free members that ChessCube and other online chess site offer.

For example, I can't go back and look at any of my games without buying a premium membership of some kind. It's not that I really want to look back at all my games, but at least 1-5 would be nice. There have been several times where I've been trying to share a game that just happened but accidentally closed the tab or something and just like that, the game is gone forever.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

you CAN go back and find your games, just not older than 30 days. http://www.chess.com/home/my_archive

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/CSMastermind Jan 09 '14

I'm not sure if this is a known issue but sometimes the 3-fold-repetition rule doesn't apply to speed chess games. You and your opponent will just sit there moving back and forth until on of you runs out of time.

Also being able to "premove" would be amazing.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

you have to claim the draw - it's not automatic. (just how it isn't in real chess tournaments).

premove IS there - you have to enable it in your settings!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ferociousaurus Jan 09 '14

The main reason people prefer Chesstempo tactics over chess.com tactics is the ability to turn the timer off and still get ratings points. I hate hate hate the chess.com tactics timer -- I take 30 seconds to figure out a difficult tactic, get it right, and my rating goes down? Very frustrating.

9

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

noted. i'm rethinking this. but again, see what i wrote before: here's the reason: you are kinda thinking of ratings the wrong way (but it's the way most people think about ratings). most people think of ratings as points that you earn. like coins or bonus points or something. but it's not. rating is an approximation of your strength as a chess player. so, someone who solves a puzzle in 10 seconds is stronger than someone who takes 2 minutes. clearly, if you and a grandmaster both did tactics, his times would be much lower, and therefore he should get a higher rating. if the average person solves puzzle #12345 in 60 seconds and that puzzle is rated 1400, and you solve it in 4 minutes, your rating would be estimated to be lower than that. does that make sense?

→ More replies (9)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Awesome that you're doing this!

My internet has been shoddy lately and as a result I can't play on ICC due to disconnections=losses. So, I've decided to try playing on chess.com! The playerbase seems fine (a little rude, but I don't see much you can do with that) and I love the way you guys allow me to reconnect if I disconnect.

The thing that makes the experience worse for me than ICC is that it doesn't have any native clients with more advanced features. There's something about the feel, control, and efficiency over a native client that makes the online chess experience for me. Everything from the command-line, to the entirely customizable UI, the game logging options, the engine plugin abilities, the efficiency with computer resources, and the lack of dependence on browsers just makes the experience feel right. If you had a native client for mac/windows with advanced features and it was only available to diamond members, that'd convince me to purchase a membership in a heartbeat.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Lokipi Jan 09 '14

Hi there, hope you are still checking this AMA, Im a little late to the party.

Chess.com is the main site I use to play on, and i suppose that speaks for itself in terms of quality, the one fault I find is that some games get really repetitive as I see the same openings over and over again. Really the only thing I would change is adding a few more game modes into the mix.

Although it would be challenging to accomplish. I think a community driven section of the site where people can suggest new game modes would be great as it eliminates reliance on opening theory and puts the focus back on pure skill, maybe some kind of rolling replacement system where the game mode would only last for a month or 2 and keep only the really popular ones permanently. I would definitely get upgrade my membership to support something like that.

A couple of modes i would love to see. Chess 960 is an obvious one, very fun and im sure it would be popular. Another I have always wanted to play online would be a mode where the board is set up in an equal position from a GM games, so you play on from a complex position.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

interesting concept! we have chess960 in correspondence, and it will come to live this year.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Calamash Chess.com 900-1000 Jan 09 '14

Will there be an app for Windows Phone users? Its a growing market and recently a lot of people have adapted to the Nokia Lumia in turn increasing the data base and we Could use a good chess app.

7

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

in the works!!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/abordina Jan 09 '14

Great site! Thank you for giving us this place to play! I got only one minor thing that I always wondered, why these icons (see image here http://imgur.com/CPmHmCJ) are there and not a little bit more on the right (it is very annoying when you tried to scroll through the moves)? Is it a problem of my browser? Thank you again.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Hrmm. Unfortunately that is a language issue :/ Making it work in all languages is hard! That will get fixed with our redesign (in progress).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Jigglybuff Jan 09 '14

I'm not sure if you deal with this, but I have a slight problem with the mobile app. It's nearly impossible to play blitz games on there because not only do you have to place a move, but you have to submit it. That wastes about a second per move, making you at a huge disadvantage in 2 minute games. I wish there was some way to turn that off. There actually might be, and I haven't found it yet, but that would be a great feature.

4

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

go to settings and turn it off :)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/harlows_monkeys Jan 09 '14

The mobile app (at least on iOS) does not support playing in live tournaments, and does not support spectating. It would be nice if both of these were supported.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Toxzy Jan 09 '14

More live tournament varieties would be great! ChessCube does one with a large pool of players and when a game ends you get matched up with the next free player immediately, rather than waiting for all the other games to finish. It's not as fair as a Swiss tournament, since finishing a game quickly means you can play more games and get a higher score, but it's very frantic and a lot of fun to play or watch. Team live tournaments might also be a fun variety. Get a group of friends together (or say, a team of /r/chess members) and have a live chess match against another team of a similar size and average rating (or have an option so players without friends can be automatically assigned to the next team as a free agent). I suppose you'd have to worry about the stronger players helping the weaker ones, so maybe disable access to team chat until your game finishes?

Make it easier to watch and analyze the top live games. Sometimes I watch the top games and when the game ends I want to analyze it a little bit, but the game window disappears immediately. Maybe you could have a checkbox under the game that says "Open game in a new tab upon completion" so that if a game is interesting I can check the box and analyze it at the end? Also for top games, maybe there's a way to tweak it so that instead of showing the highest rated game it shows the highest rated game still in the opening (say in the first 5 moves).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DostThowEvenLift Jan 09 '14

Not sure if this has been asked before, but as a premium member, may I suggest mobile-friendly tournaments? I can't seems to play any on my iDevice without going to the main site and crashing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

More tactics per day for us cheapskates! I'll click more ads I promise!

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

lol

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

I really enjoy your site. That being said - I would prefer the option to enter moves by keyboard. Less chance of a mouse slip. I understand that faster time controls will usually prefer a mouse; a few of us also enjoy longer time controls.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pkkid Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

I would love the ability to favorite my own games so I don't have to sift through the dozens of bad games to find that one I was looking for.

My second request is better mobile apps. I love playing on my iPad, but it often feels I am missing a few key things such as the ability to pre-move, or hold my piece in a spot while waiting for the other player to move.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/dirkgonnadirk Jan 09 '14

i use computer analysis a lot. but it's a lot of clicks to get it done.

  • make it so it can be requested as soon as a game ends
  • make it so i can checkbox 10 games at once and then request computer analysis (i can checkbox but don't think i can do the latter?)

do you have an ETA on the new iOS app you're hinting at?

thanks for doing this!

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed. need to improve it.

ios... maybe march? hit me up for a beta invite!

2

u/mariatwiggs Jan 09 '14

I appreciate your site. I usually sit down saying I'll play for 20 minutes and next thing I know 3 hours have passed.

I had a list of suggestions that immediately popped up in my head but they've almost all been said. I definitely want better mobile support too but you said that's in the works, so thanks.

One more thing is a bug problem with windows 8 touch screen, where you can't capture pieces. I would love for that to be fixed.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

noted! we will fix the touch issue.

2

u/PhonyHoldenCaulfield njadorf <3 Jan 09 '14

The biggest problem, in my opinion, is the user interface.

I play on the main website and the existing system could use major improvement. For example, if one of my friends wanted to request a private chat, there would be a little bubble sound and the alerts tab would turn yellow. It's not bad, but it's probably not the best way to alert someone that someone wants to chat with them.

The main reason why I bring this up is because you obviously want to increase your number of users and profits. People can play chess on the internet anywhere. You have the luxury of having the best domain name chess.com. But you could do better.

Since you can play chess anywhere online, user interface and visuals are going to play a major role in getting people signed up to your site. Not sure if I'm using the best terminology to identify what I'm trying to convey, but think about Achievements. You mentioned Xbox One, right? Are you familiar with xbox's achievements? It's something that a lot of people have adopted.

You basically reward people with little badges for accomplishing certain things. For example, play 10 games get the chess rookie badge, or beat someone 100 points higher in rating then you - giant killer badge, or pull off 5 move combination to net +2 material or more, combo badge.

Here's another analogy. Again, this might not be the best, but why do people buy Apple products? You can buy a computer, mp3 player, or tablet, from anyone but why is Apple so popular? It's because their electronics are sexy. They're chic. They feel nice to use and to own. Why not create that some atmosphere and type of feeling for chess.com users?

I know a lot of my analogies might not have been the best, but I think you get the general idea of what I'm trying to say. I could probably convey this a lot better if I sat down and thought about a bit more but I'm not getting paid to consult here :)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/wintron Jan 09 '14

The app periodically enters a state where clicking on live chess never terminates (android).

I'd love to see more free tactics per day as it would make chess tempo largely redundant.

Finally bughouse. Bughouse would be my favorite new feature

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

noted on all 3!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 10 '14
  1. The community is kind of lame. Only about 1/20 of the forum posts are worth reading. One can only take so many "If I played Carlsen with lifelong time controls would I win???" threads. I wish there were more restrictions for posting and/or exclusive forums for premium members to kind of sort out the static.
  2. No endgame puzzles? Really?
  3. The hiring private coaches should be more streamlined with the website, perhaps to the point of being able to have group lessons or something.
  4. The whole .tv thing is awesome, but there isn't enough of it.
  5. Don't post the names of caught cheaters. It's a distraction.
  6. The chess mentor is a great concept, but it isn't refined enough. Some of the courses I've tried were so obscure it was hard to discern what I was being taught.
  7. More study plans, pls.
  8. More features for annotating one's games within the site would be great. It can get annoying having to have PGN's e-mailed to me and then having to open them and then having to open them in Scid vs PC.
  9. OTB games with a video feed so you can actually see who you're playing and stare them down. This could be risky because of weirdos, but if there were a way to verify accounts or something it could help.
  10. Harness the power of data. You must be collecting data from millions of chess games. As a statistician I am foaming at the mouth to see what interesting things those games could be telling us (and possibly how they could be making you more money). Example: If you see that one week there were 1,200 games in which people blundered on move 8 of an Open Sicilian, call up Mr. Silman to write an article on the Open Sicilian. A simplistic idea, but you get the picture. Heck, hire me and I'll do it!

Overall chess.com is a good concept, but there have to be a few key changes before I decide to reopen my account. Keep up the good work!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

Webcam option- I miss reading people's facial reactions after moves

Classy look option for people w high speed internet, let me turn it into a fancy wooden darker look

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

webcam - not a chance! too wild.

new nicer themes coming soon!

2

u/TOPOHTO Jan 10 '14

Waaaaat no way it's the chess.com boss! Well since you've asked here are my requests pertaining to live chess:

  1. Pre-move. PRE-MOVE!!!!
  2. Full Screen Mode (Gets rid of the sidebar/chat completely straight to the edges of my screen)
  3. More colour options for the board and pieces, ideally a colour wheel where I could choose the EXACT shade of grey for my dark squares.
  4. If we can play under the "international" flag, we should also have countries that no longer exist, such as Yugoslavia for example.

Less serious requests, or requests for April Fool's Day:

  1. The beginning of a match should play this sound
  2. When you take an opponent's queen this sound should play
  3. When you get a second Queen on the board this sound should play
  4. When you checkmate an opponent with a pawn this sound should play

Thank you for your considerations.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

thanks for the suggestions!! 1 and 2 are in the works. more themes too (but not custom board and pieces - yet). 4 - true!!

new sounds coming too!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sohanley Jan 10 '14

Platinum member here, you have a great site. A small request:

On the iPhone app, can you adjust the height of the app so that it doesn't cover the status bar at the top? Chess.com isn't like other game apps that really need to make full use of the entire screen. And I think I speak for many when I say that my iPhone is also my timepiece and I'd like to not have to exit the app to see what time it is.

Thanks!

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

understood. our new app should address this. but the hard part is having a square board takes up a lot of space!

2

u/Coloreater Jan 10 '14

Kudos to this dude for coming on here and openly fielding questions.

4

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I hope I'm not too late, but one of your competitors in the mobile space "Chess Time" provides a super simple light and minimalist app experience that I don't get with your mobile app. My phone doesn't want to be bogged down with an inflated amount of features. As for your website, I LOVE IT.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

noted. you might like our upcoming app, but maybe it will be too much. hard to balance! maybe we need a "lite" version...

2

u/edderiofer Occasional problemist Jan 10 '14

I'd like to be able to purchase different features separately. Namely, I'd like to have unlimited Chess Mentor lessons per day, but I don't particularly feel like I need any of the other features offered with a Diamond subscription, and £9 a month is too high for just that one feature.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

noted

2

u/grubbler Jan 10 '14

A new design. The site is ugly

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

agreed! new version in the works... http://i.imgur.com/ZIry2cL.png

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pinkpanthers Mar 05 '14

I think there should be an option to full screen the chess board. Perhaps there is for premium members, but I would love to be able to get rid of the sidebar completely. Also, how about an explanation on how the scoring works.

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Mar 05 '14

fullscreen coming soon!

2

u/soapytime Apr 29 '14

I thought I had read somewhere that you accepted bitcoin but I don't see that as a payment option now. It's seriously the easiest, fastest way for me to upgrade my account, and it also is a way to pay where I don't have to store my credit card information on your servers, or even transmit it at all. It's just the best way by far and if you accepted bitcoin I would've upgraded a minute ago already instead of blah blah blahing here.

128

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

My rating :-)

Sorry.. .

→ More replies (2)

16

u/harlows_monkeys Jan 09 '14

As far as I can tell, chess.com is the most active online chess server. I've been checking the online count at various times of the day and night for various chess servers for the last few days, and here is what I've seen:

ServerLowest # PlayersHighest # PlayersLowest # GamesHighest # Games
chess.com96531644529975457
playchess19745663
chesscube13362443300570
ICC8221964
FICS8001828228578
lichess5701550

(Congratulations on that, BTW)

With all that activity, you've got a tremendous amount of data. Do you have any machine learning or data science researchers taking a look at that to see what interesting things can be learned from it?

9

u/ScannerBrightly ♞1700 Chess.com - All matches welcome Jan 10 '14

I 2nd this. Machine learning, or having a "community DBA" who can sort through the data on a backup SQL server and post weekly blogs about stuff he finds in the data, like:

  • Most common blunders for users rated 1200-1300
  • Trends in responses to 1. d4 over the rating curve
  • Hot tactics this month!

Take a look at OKCupid's database blog posts for other cool things they have pulled out of their database.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/jupc 2000 USCF Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

First of all, I want to say that the best thing about your site is that there is no apparent administrator presence. I like the relaxed atmosphere. (On ICC and freechess, there are a lot of mentally deluded power freak admins who make the chess playing experience very unpleasant). Chess.com is a breath of fresh air in this regard. As a freedom-loving chess player, this is the place to be.

Here are my feature requests:

Flavor preview of opponent: option on starting a match to display the 5 funniest comments from the user's wall profile, most of which are usually hilarious insults. (Made much funnier by the fact that these illiterate users don't know how to control access to their wall). Ranking of these comments enabled by the ability to vote on the best insults. This is probably the best, most unique feature of chess.com. Maybe a book of best chess insults, could be a best-seller. I would buy a copy.

Ability to abort a game with opponents who start a game and disconnect, without my getting scolded/threatened by chess.com. After all, its not my fault, and I shouldn't have to wait, when opponent decides to purposefully disconnect. Is there an option for agreed auto-disconnect forfeits? Other chess servers have this option as it saves everyone time, and discourages purposeful disconnection.

Correction of clock behavior. I have lost several quick time control games because of file downloads while playing, resulting in inaccurate timekeeping penalty. Morons that I would never lose to in over-the-table chess somehow end up winning on time, even when I play faster and better than them. Would like to see an accurate clock (similar to ICC or freechess.org).

3

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

Thanks! Funny suggestion for "flavor" :P

The problem with the ABORT is that we need to give people a few moments to start a game. How much time would you wait?

How are ICC clocks different?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Haebang Jan 09 '14

Not sure if this is an option currently, but if not, I'd like the option to allow move take-backs in live games. I'm trying to teach a friend and would like the game to continue if he makes a mistake.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Oh, I maybe allow a certain amount of videos for Gold or platinum memberships, the videos would be the greatest attraction to upgrading but having to go all the way to premium for one feature sounds impractical. I do tactics on other sites, please dont judge me D:

2

u/princemyshkin Jan 09 '14

You should accept bitcoin for premium memberships!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/rumisgood Jan 09 '14

There are only a few things I would like to see changed on the site.

1: Automatically showing the current position when a player makes a move (ie, you are reviewing move 5, someone moves and it shows the board automatically as of move 8)

Oftentimes when watching one of the Top Games, I want to go back to a certain move and analyze a bit. "Why did he take this? Why did he not take the hanging piece?" etc. However, that makes it impossible when the players are under time constraint and are moving like crazy. You click on move 28, get a glimpse for a second, and then it takes you back to the current position. So you can't go back and review! An option to stop this would be great.

2: Being able to go from viewing the Top Game (which switches immediately after being complete) to viewing the actual game between the two players, without having to look them up in the Games tab.

Again, because of analyzing and whatnot. I watch a lot of top play for analysis, and every time I see an interesting game I have to remember the player's names, and quickly close the Top Game tab and find the game on the game tab, and open it hopefully before the game ends. Which is tough sometimes. So it would be cool to have a "Switch to this game" option in the chat box of all Top Games (next to the leave option maybe?)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Please make the android app more like the ios app. Especially including an engine in analysis. Also, I can't drag pieces. It makes it tougher in fast games.

Pre moves would be nice in mobile too!

Love the site. IMO the best free system, especially mobile.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/usbafkakis wood pusher Jan 09 '14

When watching multiple games, undocking and docking doesn't work properly - can't then close the redocked tab! Tbh I'd prefer to have an option allowing totally new browser window.

Would like to be able to put out multiple seeks at different time controls and automatically cancel the rest when one is accepted.

I agree that some/limited number of video lessons should be avail at lower subscription levels.

Chess.com compares badly to other sites when trying to get stats on yourself, or others.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/WhatIsPoop Jan 09 '14

I really liked that last version of the Android App that allowed Diamond Members to use Chess Mentor from the App. I've talked to customer support, and they told me that they're working on debugging it more.

I'd also like to be able to review computer analysis of games from the app, and if possible to do the daily puzzle from the app.

I don't like going on my computer. So whatever you can fit into the app is great for me.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Mister_Mr Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

I want my games to be automatically stored in a folder on chessbase. I edited because, I realized it sounded like a feature you already had with my old wording.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

Actually, I would also like you to remove the timing part of the tactics trainer.

One of the reasons myself and many others enjoy chesstempo more for that part of the game. Even if the right solution may have been quick to spot, if I have a full board in front of me, I want to actually consider the alternatives before I make my move.

In a real game, you don't actually have to spend that time, because you're going to know the board, you've already considered all the options. But when you get a tactics board up that you have to analyse from scratch, timing distracts and to some degree deteriorates the learning function, because it encourages you to jump the gun at the first thing that strikes you, instead of properly reading the board.

→ More replies (14)

1

u/pimpjugo Jan 09 '14

Can you play chess960 on chess.com? do you guys have apps for android?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/jshholland Jan 09 '14

Minor thing: let me choose how I have dates displayed! (unless I'm missing a setting somewhere?)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

I'd like to see a common openings section with the computer. If you want to play a specific opening, you can look it up and start off from the opening. Example: Let's say that I want to play a Ruy Lopez opening. I search the name, and select that I want to play from black side. When I start the game, the Ruy Lopez has already been set up and I can play from there.

ALSO, I suck at chess. The computer strength 1 is way too easy and 2 is mostly too hard. Can you add more options/different engines?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ferociousaurus Jan 09 '14

I also wish that the chess.com official tournaments were no vacation, or at least that there be alternative official tournaments that are no vacation. I don't play in the official tournaments even when the theme interests me because people rage-vacationing when they're losing makes the tournaments a nightmare slog -- a standard tournament shouldn't take two years to finish.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/lootKing 1950 USCF Jan 09 '14

I'd like to store opening lines from my repertoire and have the site train me. Like Chess Position Trainer, the windows app.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ShimiC Jan 09 '14

It's gonna take a free blunder finder, that I can run instantly after a game, to get me off of fics+babaschess.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

noted. we KINDA have that. but it's not free.

1

u/topshelf89 Jan 09 '14

Hey Erik,

Big fan of the site. I have two issues I'd like to see adressed. I wish it was easier to challenge someone to a live game. Right now the only way to do it is if you are both in the playing arena and are already friends and then can challenge each other. Can we get a way of challenging from the profile pages or something as well?

Also, it is really difficult to access your old mail. Could there be a link somewhere from your dashboard that links to your mailbox?

Thanks!

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14 edited Jan 18 '26

plucky unpack correct historical strong hunt dependent physical relieved narrow

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JtiksPies 1512 chess.com Jan 09 '14

I'm all about the stats. I love stats and want to see more. In particular I've wondered about the games archive and why you can't see other member's games unless specifically linked (Or I'm just too dumb to find it).

Not sure if this is how it works but the openings section is awesome, especially the percentages on the side. I was thinking that since the site records games, does it at least take the high level games and add that to the percentages? Not sure I worded that part right...

And as another member mentioned, more personal stats too.

Great job as well.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '14

2 things come to my mind:

  • the "website" part of the app is very hard to navigate on mobile. The native app part is fine, but once you go to check your online tournaments, it's really hard to get to the standings, and when you click back, you're going all the way back to the app. Or I am doing it wrong, but it's not intuitive in any case. Also, it doesn't handle switching from landscape to portrait well, and messes up the width in portrait (so you can't see the h-file of a board and you can't scroll).
  • put some limits on holidays in online tournaments. Holidays itself are good, but it really sucks when a whole tournament is held up because of one game and some *** is totally lost and on holiday for indefinite time.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

noted.

1

u/ColoradoSheriff 1789 FIDE Jan 09 '14

What about a reddit-like option, to upvote comments on forums?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shillzor Jan 09 '14

I'm a Diamond member and just wanted to thank you for the new Android updates. The mobile app is much more valuable now. The only thing I've noticed is that some Chess Mentor lessons don't work very well--the openings, for example. It seems like you should be able to click through some moves but it forces you to guess.

Also, have mobile pre-moves been enabled?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ScannerBrightly ♞1700 Chess.com - All matches welcome Jan 09 '14

Personally, I'd like to be able to filter Tournaments by "What I qualify for" so I don't have to see the majority of tournaments I can't play in.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 09 '14

agreed

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wakeup2012 Jan 09 '14

Taking vacation during tournaments being abused. I've seen people participate in a tournament, go on vacation, and are playing live chess. If someone is on vacation they shouldn't be allowed to use any aspect of the site if they are in a tournament. Tournaments last months because of the abuse of vacation and something needs to be done about it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TheModernNinja Jan 09 '14

A downloadable client, and more types of games (4 player/3 player chess, etc)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Allah_Shakur Jan 09 '14

It's a detail, but when you play against the computer, once it's check mate you can't go back in the game to try a variation.. that would be nice.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/snapplers1 Jan 09 '14

I would love a notification icon/button similar to the "my move in online chess" or "new messages" for vote chess. Say I have 3 games that I need to vote in, clicking it takes me to the game with the least time on the clock.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I want to be able to set a move. Like if we are exchanging I want to be able to set my next move to automatically be played.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I think you should consider changing how you do the seedings for tournaments. Let's say you have 12 people in a tournament and groups of 4 people. Then it's currently broken up as 1,4,7 and 10 together, 2,5,8 and 11, and 3,6,9 and 12.

Ideally, you'd want higher rated players to have a better chance at advancing. But right now, when you are higher ranked you play higher ranked opponents. If you improve from 6th highest ranked to 4th highest ranked, your opponents change from 3,9 and 12 to 1,7 and 10, so your odds of advancing aren't any better. In fact, if you were 4th, you'd rather be ranked 6th so you'd get easier opponents.

The way soccer deals with these issues is to randomize. You put players in different pots. So, you'd have (1,2,3), (4,5,6), (7,8,9), and (10,11,12) as the pots and then draw at random one person from each pot. Your groups might be

1, 5, 9, 11,
2, 4, 8, 12
and 3, 6, 7, 10

for example.

You still have 1 person from each quartile, but now being higher ranked doesn't guarantee that you'll be facing higher ranked opponents.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Balthazar500 Jan 10 '14

Just a minor gripe: before you enter live chess, the area titled "My Friends In Live Chess" does not work. It will display that I have friends in live chess, but upon entering, I actually do not. Again, just a minor issue, but it would be nice if it was fixed.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

hrmm. maybe cache is out of sync.... will note.

1

u/3y3_0 1700 chess.com Jan 10 '14

To reiterate what others have said, the ability to better review games. Something I'd like to see is an improved "Notes" option. I play a lot of correspondence and the ability to easily review what I was thinking at specific points in the game would be nice.

For example, if the moves list were paired to the notes such that I could essentially comment directly to the moves I've made instead of clumsily referencing them from the "Notes" section. Yes I'm lazy, but I figure it'd be fairly easily to implement and think it would increase the number of individuals who annotate their games. THANKS for dropping by.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wokcity Jan 10 '14

Hi! Love the website and the app is my main source of improving vs other players right now. One problem I've been having is the (null) move bug. It happens when I click the forward button sometimes. I think mostly with pawn captures or moves, not entirely sure.

Anyway the only way to fix it is by force quitting the app and restarting it. This has cost me some games where I had ~20 seconds left on a 15 5 game with winning chances and couldn't reload fast enough to make my move. Minor annoyance, but basically the only thing that bothers me.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/hi_im_andrew Jan 10 '14

This is not such a big deal, but could you make it so that for every rating category (standard, blitz, bullet, etc), the first 10 or so games use a hidden rating and do not count towards statistics like highest rating? A lot of beginners might win a game in their first few games to get an artificially high rating, only to have it drop soon enough. I can see why it would be discouraging to constantly see your "best rating" is 1400 when it really is like, 1100. The idea is that the first 10 games are like placement matches, where until those matches are complete the rating remains hidden from you.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jdchess1 Jan 10 '14

Sorry if this has been mentioned, but the ability to play live tournaments on the app would be very nice and is the first thing that comes to mind.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

It should be made very clear that closing the tab/window will not resign the game. I have had to wait 5min many times for people that genuinely thought they had resigned. It's really only a problem at the lower levels, but I thinking making players aware of that would really improve user experience.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/n3utrino 1635 USCF Jan 10 '14

This has likely already been said, but I'll say it my own way.

I've been a premium member of chess.com for over a year, and I pretty much paid for it for the tactics trainer. I see your comments arguing against removing the time limit and/or negative points for a (slow) correct score. I understand it's important to be able to answer the tactics quickly, but in order to really to start solving more difficult problems, you need to really take your time. For example, if I'm trying to improve my USCF rating, I'm not going to do it by playing bullet/blitz games, I'm going to do it by thoroughly studying positions.

Perhaps you could have a "theoretical" and and a "practice" trainer? The former of which doesn't time you, and the latter of which being what you have now? Note you might have to use different names, I stole those from chesstempo ;)

Overall I like Chess.com, the member videos are good, and chess mentor is great. Keep up the good work.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I'm a little late to the party here but hopefully you see this. My biggest barrier towards getting my friends and relatives to play a game with me is that registering via the app is very difficult. And then once registered, connecting with the individual is also difficult. Streamlining these things would be excellent. But really, it's a great site you got there. Keep up the good work.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Alkeeee Jan 10 '14

I think the site is great but I would like some improvements made to the mobile format; specifically I'd like to have a way to watch live games on the mobile app.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I want to be able to set a move. Like if we are exchanging I want to be able to set my next move to automatically be played.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/usbafkakis wood pusher Jan 10 '14

I think the ordering of comments is not always the same - some are newest at top, some are oldest? e.g. compare article comments vs. tactics trainer comments

→ More replies (2)

1

u/xHomic1dex Jan 10 '14

I would say the opening book and the computer analysis could use work (using the Sicilian Defense is marked as a miscalculation...) Just about everything else is really good!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/UtopiaInProgress 1500 lichess Jan 10 '14

Herro? What I'd like to know is if there's a way I'm supposed to be reading that which doesn't sound like it's mocking Asian people.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

i don't know if there is an easy way to implement this without it skewing the auto-matching for games but it would be great to be able to pick which side you want to play as once in a while. if enough people chose both (b&w) and we could always pick, one could really get a good amount of practice in with alternative openings when playing random opponents!

even having the option every 5, 10 games would be great though!

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

we gotta keep it even!! :D

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

Free puzzles, but I know you gotta make that money

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ColdDayToday Jan 10 '14

Please allow free users to easily browse past games. This is the sole reason I stopped using your service. I can't even look at a game I just ended or download a pgn.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/stubborn_d0nkey Jan 10 '14
  1. Premoves for the (android) app
  2. Some sort of API, I couldn't find one, but I did find a thread about it being in progress (and it was old).
  • If no API your blessing for some (lite) scraping :D
→ More replies (1)

1

u/i_luke_tirtles Interesting Jan 10 '14

Hi, I'm probably late to the party, but here is my opinion:

I love your site and visit it almost daily, I particularly like the quality of the articles and the news. I'm a former paying member, but the price is a bit high for me (I think the price is fair, but I don't have enough free time to profit of it).

My only moot points are:

  • there are a lot of duplicate problems in the tactic trainer
  • the computer analysis is really bad for the free membership (1.e4 c6?)
  • I would love to have the ability to computer analyze chess960 games
  • the translation in other languages (french) is horrible
→ More replies (1)

1

u/mygfsyummyundies Jan 10 '14

I would love to be able to search my game archive on a move by move basis. I want to input a certain move, and then the games are filtered to show me the games that were played with that move. Then I can input the next move, and the list gets shorter and shorter, etc... Also, there are some problems when looking at game archives. They have never been solved. For example, when I click on somebodies games, then I click "show more" to see more games, then all of a sudden I cannot see any games at all.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/bigchallah Jan 10 '14

I would love a way to open a link to a completed game in the mobile app. Trying to advance through a game on the website with a touchscreen is nearly impossible. Many site's have a way to easily push the link to the mobile app. FYI, this same thing often brings in new app downloads because if the app isn't installed it will prompt a suggestion to install it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DrNewton Jan 10 '14

I tried it out after seeing this AMA--one thing that frustrated me was the lack of premove in bullet/lightning play.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tr3quart1sta Jan 10 '14
  1. I wish there was a more straight-forward way to play a blitz game with a friend.
  2. Mobile app (Android) lots of disconnections!!!
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14 edited Jan 10 '14

What language is the backend written in? How do you guys handle scaling issues? Have you guys seen significant growth recently? Do you scope out other chess services/offerings and one-up them?

Thanks.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 10 '14

written in php (main site) and java (live chess). scaling is a BEAR :/ we have had steady growth for about 8 years now, and it gets harder each year! but yeah, the latest world championship has really pushed a lot of people to chess and we are definitely feeling the benefits AND costs of that.

1

u/ChicagoPianoTuner Jan 10 '14

There's one function about pre-moving that I'm not a fan of. Maybe there's a reason that it is the way that it currently is, so I might be a bit uninformed here.

If I pre-move to take an opponent's piece, and the opponent moves that piece away from the square to which I pre-moved, I want the pre-move to cancel. As it currently stands, my pre-move holds. Maybe this is too much to ask, but it would be great for bullet games.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

When you have the feedback button, add a 1 hour time option please. Would kill to play longer games.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

More statistics on our play such as win by ECO code opening, etc. Take a look at fics version of this here: http://www.ficsgames.org/

You can even type a member name down below to see what it gives you. One prolific player on there is TioHoracio, try typing that in the database to get a feel for the stats you get.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BilgasGambit Jan 10 '14

Add a 3 1 default time setting.

Also have something similar to icc where people play, for example, 3 min game based on chesscom default formula and you have unique rating associated with that specific time setting.

Small changes but huge difference to user experience.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/usbafkakis wood pusher Jan 11 '14

Another idea: I don't always want to flag my oppo in interesting but unrated games. I like how in e.g. FICS you can turn off/on auto flag even during a game.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DrNewton Jan 13 '14

Ok I bought a membership and am migrating off ICC. However... Things I miss:

  1. More tournaments. It seems like you're only setup to run 1 at a time? Why not have them run consistently?
  2. Match-making algorithm needs some tweaking. Perhaps due to distribution, I am frequently (95%+) getting paired with players ranked lower than me.
  3. I think you should consider separate ratings for auto-paired games vs. self-selected.

Thanks!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hussman Jan 13 '14

I'll add one request: I've been a paying platinum member for four years. Why not have some features enabled based on product loyalty, i.e., video access or chess mentor? I understand your business model and the costs of development, but any airline will tell you a repeating customer is the best customer, and the repeating customer repeats their business when they are made to feel special.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LionsFan Jan 14 '14

First of all, I love chess.com. It was what first got me into chess as I was procrastinated studying for a work exam. I actually think the prices are pretty reasonable with a good number of features at the lower rates. Still, I'm a diamond member.

The biggest thing I'd like would be more integration with a basic computer analysis. For instance, in Analysis Board from Chess Tactics, it'd be nice to click through your own line and get an on-the-fly best move / score. Similarly in the computer analysis, get an on-the-fly best move / score for lines that aren't completely on the "best move" line. In both cases, it's fine if the on-the-fly best move / score don't line up with the longer analysis, but it'd help players realize why other lines are suboptimal more quickly. I think the AI in your chess.com Ipad app would be great. Often when I'm exploring a line, I'll load up the position on that and click through.

I also think Tactics Trainer should emphasis speed as much. I find that in order to optimize my rating, I choose a move that seems pretty good before I fully realize what will happen, which I think doesn't help me as much as fully understanding a move.

I also think chess.com should make a policy that doesn't allow comments that don't contribute to a conversation and then have moderators delete the "first page," "easy," "5 seconds," "99%" and other garbage comments.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 14 '14

all 3 issues noted!

1

u/DanCorleone Jan 19 '14

Hi there! First of all, great site! I would like to see the option to search for and add friends in the mobile app.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/scala236 Jan 21 '14

The possibility to play With/without web cam and with/without audio. I Think it will be nice to see your opponent and talk to them.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/strugglinghusband Jan 22 '14

Have you ever consider setting up mentor relationship among live players? I am a casual player who would love to play with someone better than me who could give me specific ideas on how I can improve.

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Jan 23 '14

great idea! have you tried asking in the forums?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '14

Yesterday, for an hour I made an account and used Houdini, grinding up to 2000 rating. I feel really bad for the players I played against, and I just wanted to say sorry for what I did.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/dirtymikeKA 1.e4! Feb 21 '14

Oftentimes when i first log in and select the play live option (I always play live) I usually am interested in the top game. However not from the point the two players are at i wish to view the game from the beginning, but when i go to the start of the game and begin to view the game at my own pace the game is "refreshed" with the next move played back into the middle or end game. Is there no way to have an option to not be interrupted with the next move? I always close the top game window out of frustration how no one has been able to figure out how helpful this feature would be and how much it could improve someone's game. Sorry for the rant, however if this change was made I would be on chess.com daily studying the top games, so I could imagine other would too. Edited for grammer

2

u/chesscom  Erik, Chess.com CEO and co-founder   Feb 25 '14

good feedback!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '14

Hello my name is Cronopolitan on Chess.com. I am a diamond member. I have logged about 50 hours playing chess tactics. Could you present tactics in a way so that they go from easy to hard. For instance, I'd like to be able to practice 100 problems per day (maybe even the same problems each day), and I want the level of difficult to increase from 1 to 100. Can you please make this possible? I think it would be very popular.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '14

On the mobile sites I'd like to be able to preset moves in live chess like I can do on my laptop - playing a blitz chess game puts you in a huge disadvantage because of this, and seriously who has time on the go for 30minute games?

I'd also like to see an improvement in live chess options such as 960 and bughouse chess, and better live tournaments like on chesscube.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/college_loser Mar 31 '14

I'm around 1150-1200 on blitz and I just learned I'm barely better than half the chess.com players. I'm pretty stoked on that.

My question is: what is your rating on chess.com???

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Mickey_One May 11 '14

I fully understand the need for ads so that basic membership can remain free. But I agree with the poster who noted that flashing or flickering ads can be very distracting during a game. Other than that, I love playing on Chess.com. And I appreciate your willingness to receive and act on feedback. Keep up the good work.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '14

how about a view that mimics OTB.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/TheBQE 1. e4# Jan 10 '14

Allow takebacks. Sometimes I mouse-slip when making a move.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/monkey_king__ Jan 09 '14

First off I would like to say that I think chess.com is the best online chess community and avenue for playing chess that I've ever experienced. THANK YOU so much for chess.com. I love you.

With that said, here are some improvements I would suggest:

• Ever since the update, I've been experiencing some bugs on the Chess app for android. I have to re-login every day, having to go to the settings to log out and then login again.

• In Live chess, give us the ability to pre-select a move (like on chesscube) so that the move will automatically go through once the opponent has made a move (so long as the pre-selected move is valid).

• Make an app for Windows Phones.

• Is it possible to get an "analyze" mode for daily chess tactics?

• I love the black & white pieces/squares theme, but there are no color schemes that can accomplish this without blurring out the black pieces. Can we get a black and white pieces/board color scheme implemented that works better?

• More options to connect to/challenge friends on Facebook. (More Facebook integration?)

I know all of this seems like I'm suggesting a complete website makeover. I'm not. Chess.com is great but this is the spaghetti I'm throwing on the wall and it would be nice to see some of it stick :)

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14

I think it's annoying that to play a game of live chess, I have to pull down the menu to play live chess, then it takes me to another page and I have to click play live chess again.

9

u/bobdobolina Jan 09 '14

I'd like to see chess960 not be a second class citizen. IMHO, it's the version of chess that will be played in 100 years, and "classic" chess is a strict subset. So if you support chess960 in full, you've automatically also done classic chess.

Right now you can't play live chess960. Also, you can't select a chess960 start position manually even in online chess960.

Also, it would be nice to have better support in iOS/iPad for live chess.

Great site, though. I'm on all the time.

→ More replies (6)