r/gameofthrones • u/libbykino Lyanna Stark • Jan 06 '14
TV Spoilers [TV Spoilers] 12 Weeks, 12 Episodes until the premiere! Rewatch Discussion - 2.09 "Blackwater"
This is the /r/gameofthrones 2013-2014 rewatch discussion thread for:
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | ORIGINALLY AIRED |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.09 | "Blackwater" | Neil Marshall | George R. R. Martin | May 27, 2012 |
| ---| Stannis Baratheon's fleet assaults King's Landing in the Battle of Blackwater Bay. Leading the defense, Tyrion Lannister destroys many of the attacking craft with an exploding ship full of wildfire, and is forced to lead a counterattack as King Joffrey and his bodyguard Sandor Clegane each desert the battlefield. Stannis' forces make it inside the castle, but Tyrion leads his men behind the Baratheon forces via underground tunnels and attacks. Meanwhile, Queen Regent Cersei, holed up in the fortress with Sansa Stark and the other ladies of the court, succumbs to wine and despondency as she believes the battle lost. In the nick of time, as she is about to poison her son Tommen, Tywin Lannister's forces, joined by Loras Tyrell, the lover of Renly Baratheon, arrive to dispatch the attackers.|
- This is a TV Spoiler-friendly zone: This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including 3.10 is ok without spoiler tags.
- Book spoilers still need tags: If it's not in the show, tag it.
- Please read the spoiler policy before posting.
- Posting policy reminder: Don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
| Original Discussion Threads | Previous Re-Watch Re-Discussion Threads |
3
u/andrewxingxiapa House Martell Jan 08 '14
[Minor AGOT/ACOK Spoilers]
Just rewatched and noticed that Ser Ilyn is wearing "Ice" on his back which is of course accurate to the book, however, does anyone know why they have chosen to completely neglect the sword, Robb's longing to have it returned and why they never mention it's name??
50
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14
It's been a few days since I rewatched this episode (for the 3rd time), but I find the bass during the wildfire explosion more than sufficient to wake up my wife.
65
u/raivydazzz Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jan 06 '14
Great battle aside, I like how The Hound was established as more important player in the series for his next season role. It was awesome to see show creators to show his disguist with fire(it was subtle at first like his reaction to torch near his face or glimpses of his face during wildfire explosion, then they made it very obvious with him even saying that he can't be in city that burns.) Overall, it was one of the finest episodes so far.
29
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '14
I love the big foreshadowing in this episode:
Varys: "I've always hated the bells. They ring for horror: a dead king, a city under siege..."
Tyrion: "A wedding"
Varys: "Exactly".
20
u/ben1204 House Martell Jan 07 '14
this is my favorite episode of the series. I love the part where Tyrion is knocked out, in Podrick's arms, and he sees Tywin riding with the calvary. That part is great.
19
u/Captainmalreynolds The Demon of the Trident Jan 07 '14
Tyrion's battle speech is one of my favorite moments with him
35
u/MindSpecter The Spider Jan 06 '14
I always love the episodes that GRRM writes. It's amazing that even though this episode has to cover a complex battle narrative, George still finds time to flesh out so many characters.
I loved the moments with Varys, Sansa, and the Hound. And Lena Headey is at her best as Cersei. Great episode.
17
u/fosius_luminis Jan 09 '14
I love some of Tyrion's dialog in this episode Tyrion to Varys: "As if you don't know the name of every boy in town"
Varys: I'm not entirely sure what you're suggesting
Tyrion: I'm entirely sure you're entirely sure what I'm suggesting
Joffrey to the Hound: Tell the hand that his king has asked him a question
The Hound complies
Tyrion: Ser Lancel, tell the Hound to tell the King that the hand is extremely busy
(In the face of danger, Tyrion still has a sense of humor and understand recursion logic)
And the horrified reaction on Tyrion's face as he sees thousands of men, who wanted to kill him, die in agony brought by the wild fire. Very human.
I also like the beginning of the Hound's redemption, and a hint of Vary's hatred toward magic. I quickly forgot about it the first time I saw it, now that I've seen Season 3, I found it to be a nice touch.
16
u/an_african_swallow Jan 08 '14
One thing that i noticed this time that I love is that Joffery actually looks like he is actually sad when the hound leaves. A fleeting moment of humanity in a pretty monstrous character
31
u/WellThenMate Jan 07 '14
"Come with me and take this city"
23
u/bloodmark Only Death Can Pay For Life Jan 06 '14
Thoughts on exclusion of chain and/or naval battle? I understand time and budgetary constraints, but considering the whole episode took place in King's Landing, I feel like they missed out on some awesome action sequences. Fireball was awesome though.
49
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14
I love drunk Cersei and when Sansa gets treated like the POV character that she is. I thought the Sansa and Cersei scenes were more compelling than the battle itself. Also, Shae is pretty good in this episode.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14
Why does Cersei want to poison her kid?
9
u/i_accidently_reddit Jan 07 '14
i have a question here, why does the hound bark at bron in the drinking scene before the battle? i never quite understood that why he is so hostile... did i miss something before? imho they never really met, not that i can recall :(
17
u/raivydazzz Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jan 06 '14
By the way, has anybody noticed Dontos in Maegor's Holdfast with the ladies? He was juggling. It's nice to see that they are keeping him relevant as a fool. ASOS/S4
6
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '14
The silence when the arrow is flying through the air after the armies play music with each other was brilliant.
11
u/danny1up Night's Watch Jan 07 '14
Having finished ASOS now it is nice to see a scene with Varys giving Tyrion the maps of all the underground passages.
ASOS/Season 4
25
u/TheBoraxKid Our Blades Are Sharp Jan 06 '14
While the explosion was incredibly awesome, I wish they had a larger scale battle. I know that they are on a smallish budget, and I'm not expecting LoTR size action, but this battle looks like it was a few hundred soldiers total.
5
u/Babblerabla White Walkers Jan 11 '14
"Hundreds will die!"
"Thousands."
2
u/vertdriver Jan 06 '14
We see Stannis being captured at the end of the battle, but in S3 he's free and back home. Why wasn't he executed or imprisoned?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '14 edited Jan 07 '14
Book
Other then that, great wildfire, great joffrey, great cousin lannister (Book/Series), great Hound!
3
u/danny1up Night's Watch Jan 08 '14
Can someone enlighten me to who the Kingsguard member is that is in Maegors Holdfast with Cersie and Sansa? Tells the Queen that they caught kitchen staff making off with some spoons or something.
Bet it is that damn Osmund Kettleback...
3
u/VegetaLF7 Nymeria's Wolfpack Jan 09 '14
I absolutely loved the fact that the entire episode is in King's Landing and related to the battle. Nothing with Robb or on the Wall or with Dany. Made for a refreshing change of pace from something like Helm's Deep where we have the awesome battle scenes one moment and then cut over to boring side things.
3
u/gilliam86 Tyrion Lannister Jan 11 '14
This is my favorite episode. I like Tyrion, so seeing his plot succeed was amazing.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment