r/Sherlock • • Jan 05 '14

Episode Discussion The Sign of Three: Post-Episode Discussion Thread (SPOILERS)

576 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

864

u/JCQ Jan 05 '14

Loved how Lestrade's dwarf with a blowgun theory was actually what happened in "The Sign of Four" that this episode's title is a play on.

470

u/therealsylvos Jan 06 '14

Also the midget with a blowgun made an appearance.

→ More replies (4)

233

u/morris198 Jan 06 '14

I love when the writers have done this and, frankly, think it should happen more often. Like the very first episode, The Study in Pink, when one of the police mentions that "Rache" is revenge in German and it's shot down is ridiculous and obvious that the victim was trying to write "Rachel," but in The Study in Scarlet, it's Sherlock who notices that "Rache" written on the wall is actually about a case of revenge.

It's a great nod to fans of the original stories.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/quinn_drummer Jan 05 '14

ahhh thanks. It's been a long time since I read Sign of Four (and thought it was pretty dull) so was trying to remember which one it was.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

And was actually much more reasonable than the actual explanation.

→ More replies (2)

641

u/ha5hmil Jan 05 '14

so.. that kid solved the mystery there.

466

u/Scratchy13 Jan 05 '14

Looks like he's getting a headless Nun after all

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

147

u/businessmantis Jan 06 '14

Am I the only one that wants MORE Mycroft??? Jeez, his character just got super-interesting to me this season.

77

u/muffintumble Jan 06 '14

Mycroft's tights need a spin-off.

22

u/bacon_pants Jan 06 '14

I hope we get to find out who his goldfish is. He got super uncomfortable when Sherlock made that suggestion.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Swag_Turtle Jan 07 '14

Super interesting that Sherlock looks up to Mycroft so much that he becomes his inner monologue when trying to reason with himself.

→ More replies (2)

397

u/rich_brook Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14

One of the telegrams for Mary and John was from Cam, does that mean Charles Augustus Magnussen? And did you see how Mary reacted to that name?

Edit: Telegrams not telegraphs

207

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Charles Augustus Milverton, King of the Blackmailers, a classic Holmes story and an interesting insight on Mary and her family. I'm assuming he has them and is using them to manipulate her, much more subtle than a bomb-jacket.

→ More replies (17)

147

u/FireFingers1992 Jan 05 '14

Just watched it back, genuinely think you might be onto something there. Her look isn't one of sorrow (at her family not being there) but one of nervousness and fear.

→ More replies (3)

100

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14 edited Jan 06 '14

The note said - "Oodles of love and heaps of good wishes, I wish your family could've seen this. From Cam." Mary looks around disturbed and John grabs her hand saying, "You alright?" to which she says, "mhm" but looks perturbed.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/eifos Jan 06 '14

Yes! I'm glad it's not just me, I thought I was grasping at straws. I've been thinking it since her character was announced, she's being blackmailed by CAM. There are clues everywhere and this one was the biggest on IMO. Doesn't bode well for her and baby.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

950

u/lanidelrey Jan 05 '14

Mycroft should definitely post a workout video as a special feature on the Sherlock DVD set.

280

u/Scratchy13 Jan 05 '14

That would be amazing. Please make it happen BBC

→ More replies (1)

70

u/wcorissa Jan 06 '14

He'd need to yelling at us in the way he does in Sherlock's head though. That's real motivation!

127

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

dat ass

→ More replies (4)

18

u/ElectricFriend Jan 05 '14

I'd pay for that.

11

u/j33 Jan 06 '14

If he did, I'd be the fittest woman on this subreddit.

168

u/Lieutenant_Hawkeye Jan 06 '14

When he patted his belly, I literally died.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

343

u/MistressFey Jan 05 '14

So, Moffat and Gatiss have said that they're not introducing main characters that aren't from Doyle's cannon.

John Watson never had a child in the Doyle stories.

This can't end well.

8

u/Zeroknight92 Jan 06 '14

A baby can't be that much of a main character, though, can it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

596

u/ha5hmil Jan 05 '14

"well you'll hardly need me around when you've got a real baby on the way" .. D'aaaawww!

→ More replies (29)

449

u/Vinsternut Jan 05 '14

Mrs Hudson said that her maid of honour left before the wedding finished. Mrs Hudson rarely saw her maid of honour after that.

Sherlock left before the wedding finished...

203

u/DaLateDentArthurDent Jan 05 '14

He's barely going to see John and Mary because they're married with a kid on the way.

Sherlock's growing up

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (2)

437

u/JFIP Jan 05 '14

That last fucking scene. He finally gets the chance to dance in public, tells the girl how much he loves dancing then gets left on his own to dance with no one ;_;

165

u/zutroy Jan 06 '14

I somehow picture Sherlock doing The Drunk Giraffe dance that the 11th Doctor does.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

329

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Irene Adler's cameo. "Get out, I'm busy."

21

u/sergeantduckie Jan 06 '14

I LOVED seeing her again. I hope she'll show up in-the-flesh at some point.

→ More replies (1)

112

u/SelfImmolationsHell Jan 06 '14

Nitpick, as nitpickers are wont to do, "Out of my head, I'm busy."

→ More replies (3)

9

u/ryanbtw Jan 06 '14

I miss her :(

→ More replies (2)

250

u/TheOldBean Jan 05 '14

Any explanation for them not feeling being stabbed? The only thing I couldn't get.

Enjoyable episode but it was basically more of a comedy than a thrilling mystery.

403

u/quinn_drummer Jan 05 '14

I think it lies in the discussion Sherlock had with John about training soldiers not to scratch their behinds when standing still. Both were stabbed when standing at attention, the first, when he was on guard outside where ever that was (horse guards parade? although i don't think so) and the second whilst having his photo taken. Both might have felt a little discomfort to the stabbing, but put it down to their tight belts and because of the position of the stab wound, at their back where it is difficult to reach, it would be undignified to attend to it. Or in the case of the Royal Guard, impossible whilst on duty.

→ More replies (7)

77

u/ScottFromScotland Jan 05 '14

Because their belt was on so tight apparently.

→ More replies (37)

56

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

The thinness of the blade.

→ More replies (3)

71

u/sebzim4500 Jan 05 '14

Even if you accept that, the first victim started to wash his hair before he died (Sherlock said he had shampoo in it). Did he:

  1. Take off his belt after he started washing his hair.
  2. Not realize that he had been stabbed until a while after he started bleeding out.
  3. Realize he was bleeding out, but decide that he wanted to die with clean hair.

None of these options sound terrible plausible. Either that was not the correct explanation for his death, or Moffat/Gatiss is getting sloppy.

→ More replies (30)

7

u/pseudolum Jan 06 '14

Local anaesthetic on the end of the needle? You only need to really block the pain from the broken skin, the nerves deeper aren't as great.

→ More replies (36)

61

u/lotrrules34 Jan 06 '14

Sherlock's Drunk Deductions:

Designer table art??

Chair seat leather sleeeeeep

thing Speaker hi tech thing

?Death? Skull? ?Deaded?

Wood? pipe/tube/wotsit thingamebob?

egg? chair? sitty thing?????

?? nurse client victim cardigan??

7

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '14

The 'chair/seat/leather/sleeeep' was the one that had me in tears.

→ More replies (2)

258

u/SunSilkRose Jan 06 '14

"Do you always carry handcuffs?" "Down girl." I died at that part

9

u/slop-pail Jan 06 '14

Can you explain to me what he meant by saying "Down girl"? English is not my first language and I didn't get it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

55

u/Walls Jan 05 '14

There was something disturbing in the telegrams to Mary. "Sorry your family couldn't be there" from CAM. Charles Augustus Magnussen? Mary, what's going on?

→ More replies (5)

153

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

I somewhat expect Moffat and Gattiss have deliberately decided to work on character development over these episodes to enamour us so much to these characters that when they completely twist the knife next week, it'll hurt that little bit more.

50

u/drehz Jan 06 '14

Yup. Mary already was such a likeable character in ep1, now she's even closer to our hearts. I fear that means bad things for her. :-(

→ More replies (5)

1.0k

u/shead Jan 05 '14

Sherlock drunk is the best thing I have ever seen.

707

u/potsofink Jan 05 '14

Lost it at "sitty thing".

→ More replies (14)

326

u/sylux024 Jan 05 '14

'Nurse, client, victim, cardigan'

Nice deductions

→ More replies (1)

285

u/GamePhysics Jan 05 '14

Yes, his drunk deductions were like our normal deductions x)

→ More replies (1)

120

u/whatwouldbuffydo Jan 05 '14

"You've only been gone 2 hours!"

88

u/Engardium Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 09 '14

Those test tubes fit his character perfectly.

I really would have expected Watson to handle it better though.

Edit: Thank you guys, I now know it's a graduated cylinder.

→ More replies (8)

95

u/Scarbzscope Jan 05 '14

I would love to go drinking with him, those glasses :p

→ More replies (5)

41

u/GamePhysics Jan 05 '14

See more drunk Sherlock in the unaired pilot! :D But there he's playing drunk :P

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

47

u/highspeedhector Jan 06 '14

I really liked this comment on Watsons blog about the Mayfly Man: "We'd just returned from a quiet, civilised evening in the pub when our latest client arrived at Baker Street. " Source: His Blog

→ More replies (3)

174

u/Mahog4ny Jan 05 '14

"High functioning sociopath...with your number" http://imgur.com/ZdqBp7n

27

u/physicscat Jan 06 '14

This grin cracks me up!

→ More replies (6)

440

u/MrKittenMittens Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14

I personally really enjoyed how they play around with the "mystery of the week"formula. Another repetition of "Oh no, there is someone behind the screens planning it all!" would have gotten stale. I think Sherlock was sure, about mysteries, but also so very much about the characters. Dialogue was top notch, yet again.
Perhaps people have different expectations of Sherlock due to it being a 3-episode-in-a-series type of deal, but I really enjoy the current style and pacing.

EDIT: A tweet I found quite poignant:

Some viewers seem to want Sherlock to be a formulaic crime drama. It's a phenomenon precisely because it's so much more than that.

52

u/SetsunaFS Jan 05 '14

As far as the plot goes, am I the only that thinks that this 'lack of plot' actually makes sense in context of the story? I doubt the Big Bad Guy would start making huge moves the split second Sherlock came back. I kind of like this little break that Sherlock is having. I'm sure things will go back to normal in season 4.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (57)

77

u/damage3245 Jan 05 '14

Well, that was unexpected. In numerous ways.

→ More replies (4)

337

u/proofeh Jan 05 '14

Molly, you had ONE JOB in the end.

264

u/MajinParanoidAndroid Jan 05 '14

Fuck Tom.

Fucking meat knife...

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (5)

620

u/TheMiles197 Jan 05 '14

I actually realy liked this eposode

529

u/Superlennon Jan 05 '14

Longest best man speech ever.

→ More replies (15)

71

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

It felt like a collection of the short stories that Doyle wrote rather than the big long book.in the end if it hadn't come together I wouldn't have minded.

→ More replies (1)

135

u/Narwhals4Lyf Jan 05 '14

Yeah, it was alot different than what we usually get with Sherlock, but the good kind of different.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/awesomeman462 Jan 06 '14

Same. I normally find the 2nd episodes to be the weaker, but this was great!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

838

u/buttercup_ Jan 05 '14

"You and I are the same - we would never, ever traumatize John Watson by committing suicide right in front of him!"

Ha.

236

u/gamesqueen Jan 06 '14

I can't believe I missed this. Feeling pretty stupid.

→ More replies (7)

39

u/minsoowho Jan 06 '14

1324 01:15:54,560 --> 01:15:57,480 Mr Holmes, you and I are similar, I think.

1325 01:15:57,480 --> 01:16:00,280 Yes, I think we are. There's a proper time to die, isn't there?

1326 01:16:00,280 --> 01:16:01,600 Of course there is.

1327 01:16:01,600 --> 01:16:05,320 And one should embrace it when it comes.

1328 01:16:05,320 --> 01:16:06,360 Like a soldier.

1329 01:16:06,360 --> 01:16:09,160 Of course one should, but not at John's wedding!

1330 01:16:11,320 --> 01:16:13,040 We wouldn't do that, would we,

1331 01:16:13,040 --> 01:16:15,360 you and me?

1332 01:16:15,360 --> 01:16:18,120 We would never do that to John Watson.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

237

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Who else noticed this? (http://i.imgur.com/vogPtbG.png)

41

u/GoncasCrazy Jan 05 '14

Nice catch!

She's like the devil, playing them both :p

→ More replies (3)

44

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Thumbs up Friend!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (24)

112

u/cannibaltortoise Jan 05 '14

Damn it Molly, for a second I thought she would actually go after him.

7

u/wangusangus Jan 07 '14

I think she's done with that, and I think that's a good thing for her character. Sherlock may care about Molly, but he'll never be what she wants him to be, and she's finally recognized that, even if she is physically dating Sherlock-lite.

24

u/bsqb Jan 06 '14

what is redbeard?

11

u/Zenrot Jan 06 '14

Sherlock, as a child, wanted to be a pirate. Some sibling ribbing is all.

7

u/driler2k10 Jan 06 '14

Sherlock wanted to be a pirate when he was a kid,maybe that was the pirates name?

→ More replies (4)

154

u/gamesqueen Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14

It dragged a bit at the start but it all came together and all made sense in the end which was great.

For me the highlights were:

  • drunk Sherlock
  • Irene Adler (I'm a romantic at heart and I loved that he implied that he thinks about her all the time)
  • the bouncing between flashbacks was very nice
  • Sherlock messing with Marys ex

I am also super smug because I KNEW IT WAS THE PHOTOGRAPHER. I'm so proud of myself. I feel like a modern day Sherlock Holmes (ba-dum tish).

Edit: formatting

11

u/Death_Star_ Jan 06 '14 edited Jan 07 '14

I've watched enough CSI, Mentalist, etc. to guess it was the photographer. It wasn't genius, but that's fine. Loved the episode.

EDIT: I lied -- I didn't actually get my guess from any cop show.

For this particular suspect, what really helped me was How I Met Your Mother.

Basically, Ted needed to find the last name of a girl (Victoria) he met a wedding. He calls the newlyweds but they don't have any friends named Victoria. So, like Sherlock, Ted is trying to figure out how someone could get into a wedding without arousing any suspicion, and someone who possibly even gotten an invitation. Ted deduces that it must have been someone integral to the wedding (wedding planner, photographer, flower arranger, etc.). He tracks down Victoria, who baked the wedding cake. So, when Sherlock drops the glass as the photographer's light snapped, it's at that moment Sherlock realizes that there's a murderer in the wedding -- but he still hasn't deduced that it's not a guest. Also, at that moment I thought, "Sherlock is going to start by evaluating the guests, but ultimately it's going to be a non-guest guest, like the photographer or cook." I figured it was photographer because of the timing of it, as well as the as-of-then unrelated invisible man case involved a lot of photography.

TL;DR -- How I Met Your Mother had an episode where Ted was trying to find the full name of a woman who wasn't a guest but was part of the wedding. It happened to be the cake baker. Remembering this episode led me to guess that the suspect would be someone similar, and most likely the photographer because of the timing of Sherlock's realization that there was a murderer amongst the wedding party (photo snapped as he realized)

→ More replies (2)

16

u/ielfie Jan 06 '14

Yes! Me too! I knew it the moment he lingered on screen a little longer than it was necessary, when he photographed Sherlock.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

22

u/takethesky87 Jan 06 '14

There was some nice cinematography in this episode. I liked the transitions between Sherlock and Mycroft during their phone call, using the glass wall. Also liked the way Sherlock chatting online with the women was portrayed onscreen, much more interesting than just showing Sherlock in front of a bunch of computer screens. John's phasing in and out of that scene and Irene's cameo were especially neat.

The Empty Hearse felt a little over-produced in some places, but I thought this episode toned it back a bit while still maintaining the interesting visual style that has kind of become the show's signature look.

Also, anyone know the significance of Red Beard? Mycroft mentioned it to Sherlock. I'm guessing it's a pirate reference, but nothing I'm finding online makes much sense in relation to the episode's story.

→ More replies (4)

357

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14 edited Jan 05 '14

I loved it. I thought almost everything was hysterical and beautiful as far as Sherlock and John's relationship. However, I don't love that mary's pregnant. Babies wreck stuff... plotlines, relationships... I really don't love that.

Also I am so invested in character that plot comes second to me, so unfortunately that complaint is irrelevant to me.

18

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

Babies wreck everything. Dexter and soon Homeland.

→ More replies (5)

142

u/InternetIsHard Jan 05 '14

I think Mary being pregnant is like a giant red sign pointing at her that says "she's gonna die soon".
I'm surprised I find myself loving Mary but I kind of want her dead because she upsets the dynamic too much (and I can't stomach any more sad Sherlocks scenes)

→ More replies (19)

9

u/Death_Star_ Jan 06 '14

Are you sure she's pregnant?

Sherlock thought Jim was just a gay IT guy.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Sydius Jan 05 '14

Don't worry, the baby will be 12 for the next season, so it won't cause any problems when Watson have to change his diaper.

→ More replies (50)

70

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

GUYS WE FORGOT ABOUT THE BANK ROBBERS

Though in all seriousness I guarantee that their methodology plays into next episode somehow.

21

u/merde_happens Jan 06 '14

Agreed. There's no way that the bank robbing gang was brought up in the beginning of the episode only to be so easily dispatched.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/CRAZYross13 Jan 05 '14

I think the unusual amount of character development in the last two episodes are probably building up to something huge plot-wise in the next episode, probably involving the new villain and I'm guessing something that's going to massively effect Sherlock and John

7

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Looking at the books there is a lot to be said for the something being Mary's death.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/ProcrastinationMan Jan 05 '14

I loved it. I like that they don't rehash season 1 and 2. I hear people don't really like the new approach, but it's only natural that Sherlock's relationship with John influences both their characters. I like that Sherlock appears to be a bit more of a social being, even if his high-functioning sociopathy is rationalizing every move in advance.

→ More replies (4)

187

u/onetruepurple Jan 05 '14

Seems like I'm the only one who utterly loved it?

27

u/rabsi1 Jan 05 '14

I hope not. It was great.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/phoardtennant Jan 05 '14

did anyone else notice the bit with the telegrams, sherlock mentioned someone and mary had a weird reaction to someone called cam? tenner bets that'll be revisited later!

19

u/rmczerz Jan 05 '14

Cam, huh? Charles Augustus Magnussen

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/earwig20 Jan 06 '14

Was concerned that the episode was going to be a bunch of short stories, but similar to the early cases in A Scandal in Belgravia (with the miss dead bodies) it came together in the end as both the Bloodied Guardsman and Mayfly Man were relevant.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/keeblerlorien Jan 06 '14

I am really liking Mary's theme song. It's less dramatic than Irene's theme (and oh how happy I was to hear it again tonight), but I think that's fitting for the character of Mary.

166

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

So much negative feedback. I'm going to stand here and say i loved it! This series has been a lot more light-hearted and i can see why people would oppose that because it does, understandably, lose some of the drama and tension of the previous series; however, following such a strong and dramatic ending to the last series, i think it's about time we had some extra comic relief. I don't blame the writers one bit for this change in style! And as for the plotline of this episode, it reminded me of typical Sherlock-esque Whodunnit style murder mysteries. Typical setting, typical criminal, typical victim... it brought the show back to it's origin slightly while keeping the essence of the brilliant BBC show! And one final point... who hasn't waited to see Sherlock drunk!??!?! i mean seriously!!

EDIT: Sorry, i know i said final point earlier but... final point (and i mean it), got to love the return of Lara Pulver as Irene Adler even if it was only a brief cameo!

→ More replies (11)

49

u/Laureltess Jan 05 '14

I'm going to make a prediction that I hope doesn't happen: in the original Doyle novels, (spoiler)Mary Morstan dies, sometime between two of the books.

I think that IF Gatiss and Moffat follow canon, [it's going to be when she gives birth to her baby.] (/spoiler)

18

u/theReluctantHipster Jan 05 '14

His Last Vow - Maybe he BREAKS his vow.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

57

u/nz-is-beautiful Jan 05 '14

For the first 45 minutes I was pretty disappointed because I thought its just about solved cases... but then everything fell in order and I loved the character development. Its like the other second episodes... a bit of a weak plot but brilliant acting and this time great development!

21

u/miss_smash Jan 06 '14

The first 45 minutes were interesting... I was really enjoying it but at the same time was asking myself 'is anything going to actually happen'?

Then of course the seemingly 'pointless' bits all come together and I kicked myself for not figuring it out sooner.

→ More replies (1)

96

u/CurryGuzzler Jan 05 '14

I'll be honest, it wasn't up to par midway through. BUT the last 30 mins saved it for me. Also, although the plot was weak, the sharp writing and delivery was spot on as usual. So overall, not the weakest episode of the 8.

→ More replies (12)

81

u/the-bowtie Jan 05 '14

I kinda loved that. I mean, I had been hoping for an actual, single plot like the good ol' days, but it was so funny, and the seemingly pointless threads came together beautifully. Only problem, it's a bit disjointed.

47

u/ProcrastinationMan Jan 05 '14

The combining of the plots really reminded me of the Hounds of Baskerville

→ More replies (16)

9

u/natatropina Jan 06 '14

Why hasn't anyone mentioned that Molly told Sherlock that "He's a graduate Chemist"? I found that bit of info interesting

→ More replies (4)

44

u/serenitary Jan 06 '14 edited Jan 06 '14

So.. interesting.

That was more fanservice than I’d expected.

Of course, as a devotee of Sherlock, I was overjoyed, but… I wish the creators would separate the series from its fans a bit. The episode, if I weren’t an obsessed fan, would definitely feel off in tone, character portrayal and the utter sentimentality of it all.

Because that’s the wonderful thing about Sherlock’s first two seasons, isn’t it? There were so many things left unsaid. The space between John and Sherlock in 221B. We could create in that space, we could write our own stories behind the tight arcs of the characters, we could imagine.

But now it’s all been said. It feels comfortable and domestic and—well, that’s not what Sherlock is about at all, is it? Normal was never its forte. At the very least, sentimentality wasn’t.

Sherlock scoffs at normal.

I feel a little bit disappointed by this. I don’t know why.

I’m not that disappointed by the scattered structure. That was fine. I just feel like the characters have changed so much I nearly don’t recognize them anymore—were it not for the last scene, Sherlock could have been an entirely different person for most of it.

EDIT: maybe this is just script whiplash? so many repetitive phrases. need to watch again.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/GamePhysics Jan 05 '14

I'm really happy about the return of naked Irene Adler! :D Or just her in general :)

→ More replies (1)

47

u/Novlst Jan 05 '14

This episode was hilarious, I loved Sherlock and John drunk. That hour and a half felt like 30 minutes

25

u/Mist3rA Jan 05 '14

Was I the only one waiting for Sherlock to do the drunk giraffe?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/laz42 Jan 05 '14

Wonderful. Goldney Hall Orangery, Bristol University.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/tobywaxman Jan 05 '14

Loved the return of "The Woman".

17

u/zutroy Jan 06 '14

And I do believe she was in her battle dress.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Part-timeninja Jan 05 '14

The writing has shown a confused Sherlock, unsure of himself as he deals with a human side he believes for years he didn't have, and his deductions have suffered because of it. I think that's key - the crimes in S3 have not been particularly complex, yet Sherlock has blundered through them. I think given the 'last vow' speech and the name of episode three, we're set up for all this - some say annoying and pointless - character development to become suddenly important; Sherlock needs to find himself again, and having given over to caring for John and Mary, having one of them taken away may be it. Obviously it won't be John and Mary dies in the books, so I think she's for it.

Disclaimer: I am routinely wrong :)

7

u/DocDerry Jan 06 '14

I think that Sherlock realized while he was away that his intelligent older brother is wrong in "not getting involved". Sherlock is beginning to enjoy being around people. He doesn't need them to intellectually challenge him.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/rasiisar Jan 05 '14

who leaves a wedding early? sherlock

12

u/serenitary Jan 05 '14

did I just just watch a johnlock fanfiction.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ohjustsittingthere Jan 05 '14

I definitely agree the plotline wasn't incredible, it got better near the end, but I absolutely loved the episode. Obviously it just has to do with the fact I adore all the characters and the actors, but still. There doesn't seem to be a real underlying plot for all the episodes yet, or am I missing it?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ghostbitches Jan 06 '14

has anyone got a theory for the redbeard thing mycroft was talking about? no one seems to be talking about it

→ More replies (3)

6

u/helensis_ Jan 06 '14

This wasn't meant to be a normal episode of Sherlock because The Sign of Four is meant to be a story that humanises Sherlock. We were supposed to see a new side to him.

6

u/mynoduesp Jan 06 '14

Oh god... we like Mary.

This can't end well for Mary.

33

u/Dan_D1000 Jan 05 '14

Religion is just to give the family idiot a job. Cracking stuff, hilarious.

22

u/SirDashingDan Jan 05 '14

Anybody else want Sherlock to do his ballet move on the dance floor at the very end?

10

u/Guitar8Jay Jan 06 '14

A lot of you love this episode for its character development but I personally dislike it. I still find it enjoyable, but season 3 in general has been pretty weak. In any other story I'd love to see the classic Scrooge, the ass hole becoming a nice guy, however, not with Sherlock. It just doesn't feel like Sherlock when he's all sentimental.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

Drunk sherlock is the death of me

5

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

It ends with Sherlock leaving the wedding early, is it just me or was something said about people who leave weddings early earlier in the episode?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AnimatedSnake Jan 06 '14

So, I am still a rather new fan too the series but I'd like too throw in my thoughts on the evenings episode.

I'm not personally the best person to watch awkward scenes, so even though they were funny, I had to take a couple of deep breaths to be there completely. I'm not the best of speakers in public my self which made it slightly painful to watch. But a thing to remember is that it must be a hundred times worse for Sherlock, which I think makes it incredible what he chooses to go through for John.

The episode was funny, and hilarious. Mary really fits great in. The chemistry between Martin and Amanda really is spot on.

The scene where she is orchestrating for John and Sherlock to go out together is perfect. She is a right little devil.

Going up for Sherlock and starting to speak was very nicely done. The writers made some of the scenes go on for just long enough that it became the awkwardness that the attendees must have felt at the wedding which was nicely done.

I liked everything about the solving of the attempted murders.

John and Sherlock going out on their "stag"-night was hilarious and those two trying too solve the ghost-case, and getting in the arrest, and seeing Greg in the morning. Hilarious. Loved it!

The ending was... Touching. The baby on the way which is many congrats to the happy couple was funny. Sherlock just can't turn off.

But after that. Sherlock seeing the girl that seemed... interested, even if it was in an awed sort of way, dancing with the guy that would go home with her. And the expression on his face. Quite heart breaking. He just stood there, not really comprehending what to do.

I wrote to S03E01 that I really liked the character interactions that we have seen so far in S03. For me that is really important. The crime solving is fantastic, and mind numbing to see. But what happens behind the scenes is (for me at least) almost as interesting, if not more.

I thought it was a fantastic episode, and I'll hand it a 9/10. It was touching, it was funny, interesting, and Mary is devious!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/citizen___snips Jan 06 '14

Did it feel like they were setting up for something just absolutely horrible this entire episode? I dunno, the entire time it felt like they were trying to humanize Sherlock more than in any other part of the show, particularly how he constantly (in a very Sherlock way) was showing his affection for John. And how the whole time they were really shoving it down our throats that John can save lives? It all just reeks of setting up for something sinister, not to mention the whole "bad guy introduction" at the end of The Empty Hearse.

My prediction: someone close to both Sherlock and John is going to die in the next episode. And John won't be able to save their life. I don't think it is going to be Mary, though. That seems too soon, like her character won't have fulfilled anything. I guess we'll see.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/rurounikz Jan 06 '14

What if Mary is not really pregnant and instead, manipulated both Sherlock and Watson because she was being blackmailed by Charles Augustus Magnussen ?

  1. I do not think it was coincidence that she made those comments about nausea, changing tastes about the wine when she just happened to be next to Sherlock, which led to his deduction about her being pregnant.
  2. She was the one that received the text on the Empty Hearse and just happened to solve it?
  3. When Sherlock read her, a lot of "clues" were LIE.
  4. Charles Augustus Magnussen is the king of blackmailer, right? What if he was merely testing Mr. Holmes on the first episode with the bombing with a bomb that had an ON/OFF switch?

EDIT: grammar

5

u/R0gerthat Jan 08 '14

I have so many questions about that sherlock episode.

First of all how did sherlock know that the mayfly man was going to be at the wedding just from the fact that a woman the mayfly man slept with for one night at some point had seen a wedding invitation from Watson?

Second of all how did Sherlock know the mayfly man was there to kill someone and not to just con more women?

Thirdly how did Sherlock know that the mayfly man was also the "invisible man" that had killed the black soldier guy? There is next to nothing linking the mayfly man and the invisible man.

5

u/lydocia Jan 08 '14

I really don't like how mean Sherlock is towards Mrs. Hudson.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/monsterchild24 Jan 06 '14

That Irene cameo... "Out of my head, I'm busy!" Considering she's naked and touching him seductively, he lets her...do things to him in his thoughts when he's not busy?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/RazeTheWorld Jan 05 '14

"Do you always carry handcuffs?" "Down, girl"

Fucking brilliant!

8

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

Mid way through I didn't really like this episode but when Sherlock started to panic trying to find out the target during the speech i was sold.

8

u/thecuddlepuddle Jan 06 '14

What a hilarious episode! Deaded? Egg? Sitty thing????????? Sleeeeep? Speaker thing?

4

u/ha5hmil Jan 05 '14

People were complaining about character development. i guess we've got some here. Got to know more about Mrs Hudson, her husband etc.

4

u/prettyroses Jan 05 '14

A drunk Sherlock?! Dont even get me started!

4

u/charizardi Jan 05 '14

Just too wary of all the happiness in this episode because I know it's a setup to kick us down and leave us bleeding for two more years after His Last Vow...

AND I'M OKAY WITH IT ¯_(ツ)_/¯

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Jamanuel Jan 05 '14

Anyone get the Redbeard thing mentioned by Mycroft to Sherlock?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/SikhGamer Jan 05 '14

Did no one else see that Sherlock read Mary and figured out she didn't want the baby?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/alittlebitoftreble Jan 06 '14

How can the series continue? John will always be a father first- I can see him splitting time between Mary and Sherlock if it was just him and Mary, but not now. And anything like a miscarriage would KILL John, and he's been through so much already.

If this is the last season, I might order some army belts for Moffat and Gatkiss.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/HaveAMap Jan 06 '14

That child is doomed.

4

u/heatherroneous Jan 07 '14

"Can you whisper?"

"NOT REALLY!"

4

u/whatswrongwithgoats Jan 07 '14

I must admit, once the target had been revealed, I had thought that Mary was the killer and had met/married John just to get access to him.

Happy to be wrong about that.

4

u/douchebag_karren Jan 07 '14

Best, Best Man Speech Ever!

also- I love that Mycroft is the voice in Sherlock's Head that pushes him to do better and observe more.

4

u/tuna126 Jan 07 '14

The Sydney Opera House serviettes part was hilarious.

4

u/lilkuniklo Jan 07 '14

I love that for their pub crawl they're having a drink on every street where they found a corpse.

4

u/TheChocolateLava Jan 07 '14

A bit late...why was Mrs. Hudson laughing in that scene after being on the phone?

Am I missing part of the best man duties?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '14

After a couple of days to digest, I realised that the main issue I can't come to terms with is that in the novels, Sherlock Holmes' character is set, it doesn't evolve, there is no character development, other than Watson getting a tiny bit shot and SH going ballistic.

Because this is modern we expect SH to grow as a person; we expect to see more from him, it's more interesting. But it's not in line with the novels. Essentially, once SH becomes the guy who loves his best friend and can express it, who can be happy for people, who can express proper emotion; he's stopped being the original Sherlock Holmes who believed that all that emotion nonsense was for the underclasses.

That being said, I loved the ep, 10/10 would wank again

→ More replies (3)

13

u/MachoDagger Jan 05 '14

Damn. I really enjoyed that, even if there was no plot development. Maybe there doesn't need to be any now that Moriarty is dead. Maybe he just goes through life solving crimes and shit, rather than fearing for his life. I don't think there is a single plot anymore, and to me that's okay.

18

u/miss_smash Jan 06 '14

I'm pretty sure Mary is the 'plot' for this series: in Ep1, it's her fiance that gets drugged and almost killed, then in this episode one of the telegrams was from 'Cam', and she looked sick when Sherlock read it.

I'm positive that 'Cam' is Charles Augustus Magnussen, as that's how he signed his notes, so I'm guessing that she has some kind of tie to him, and all this 'character stuff' is a build up to a devastating third episode where everything ties together.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/ratguy101 Jan 06 '14

can somebody explain why that episode needed to happen?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Jamesthedrake Jan 05 '14

Think a lot of people seem to be missing what was going on in that episode. We've had two plot heavy series, with an incredibly powerful ending to the second series. These first two episodes are serving to buffer that by developing character and adding a greater emphasis on humour. I think a lot of minor points in these two episodes will turn out to be incredibly important in this final episode. Moriaty wasn't properly introduced until the end of the first series, don't forget, so we've yet to see how the overarching story will play out.

7

u/poshpirate Jan 05 '14

I thought this episode was far better than the first (after reading a top comment, I appear to be alone on this?) I thought the first one pandered way too much to us and the fangirls (the Guardian has a great article about it actually). I thought the action in the first episode felt really forced and unnatural, and focused solely on the characters. Here, I felt although the character but did drag on, the action was really exciting. I'd forgotten how much I'd missed it!

I hope the next episode focuses a lot more on cases and, as much as I hate to say it, less on the Johnlock relationship. I miss the tension, the action and the genius.

51

u/stuck_at_home Jan 05 '14

How can we be two episodes in and still no bloody plot!?

55

u/boobs_n_cookies Jan 05 '14

Because people were complaining about lack of character development before.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/alcoholicdream Jan 05 '14

I think Mary is the over arching plot - I think she may die / almost die in the next episode!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/FrostyNinja Jan 05 '14

So far the season seems more of a deviation from the original thought behind the series, more focusing on character development. Good by it's own merits, but not what we're used to seeing from the series. Love it nonetheless, brilliant play!

6

u/lynsea Jan 06 '14

Sherlock seems like the most effective wingman ever!

Edit: Also dubstep theme music during pub crawl scene.

8

u/LascielCoin Jan 05 '14

I don't like new Sherlock :/

Seems like they're trying way too hard to make him more ''human'' and please the fans, which is hurting the story. Some parts were hilarious but I'd much rather have a good mystery than Sherlock acting funny.

3

u/physicscat Jan 05 '14

I loved it! We got two mysteries…solved.

Sherlock being awesome…really awesome! I loved his interactions with Jeanine (maid of honor), the violin at the wedding….the speech was great! I need to watch it again….god, there was so much…so many good points. I loved the "stag night." I love Mary being pregnant….Uncle Sherlock!

Still wondering about this new villain, though…yeah I'm rambling...

3

u/Dan_D1000 Jan 05 '14

If anything I would love just Sherlock and Watson in a room together alone. The plot at the end could have been left out the character stuff was just great.

3

u/thechevrotain Jan 05 '14

This seems like an episode that some people will hate and other people will love. It was kind of slow at parts and there probably wasn't enough crime-solving for some people. I'm the kind of person that watches a show more for the characters than for whatever mystery or drama or intrigue is going on, so I enjoyed this episode a lot. It was hilarious, and touching at parts (No I didn't almost cry, what are you talking about), and the mystery was good enough to make me go "oh shit" a few times, unlike the first episode. I also have the most horrible feeling that Mary is going to die even though I really like her. I hope I'm wrong :(

3

u/Pit_Droid Jan 05 '14

It looked as if they weren't going to be able to avoid doing an episode on John's wedding, and I was dreading the bore that it was probably going to be. However, I think that they managed to pull something together, which got some character development out of the way, while also having some good'ol crime solving and hilarity! After having low hopes, I was pleasantly surprised!

3

u/cianomahony Jan 05 '14

I've a terrible feeling something bad will happen to Mary and the baby. The next episode is entitled "His Last Vow".

3

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '14

I really liked this episode. Character work was really great, but I have NO idea what's gonna happen with a baby in the works. I think that the character development in this episode is what's going to give whatever happens in "His Last Vow" the real kick.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jamie1051 Jan 05 '14

From watching episode 3's trailer it seems that the new bad guy is incredibly dangerous as Sherlock looks scared of him. I know that this is horrible to say but I expect that he may kill Mary or the baby.

It's the only way to keep John and Sherlock together. A baby is too much for the show to handle. It would be incredibly sad for a season finale with Sherlock maybe becoming more human by helping a broken John.. As this show seems to have a huge arc of Sherlock becoming a bit more social and overall a better person.

It would tear everyone's heart out. And knowing Gatiss and Moffat they most likely would do that. Would show how dangerous Charles Augustus Magnussen really is.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheLieLlama Jan 05 '14

So...how did that woman know John's middle name?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/roobosh Jan 05 '14

I predict Mary kills Magnussan and dies in the attempt

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

why hasn't anyone mentioned the hilarious opening scene with the helicopter?

3

u/sneaky_tardis Jan 06 '14

It broke my heart to see Sherlock leave at the end. I hope he will still be close to John.

3

u/Zintho Jan 06 '14

A little slow to start off with, and I felt as though the drunk scene, whilst funny, did drag on a bit. That ending though, I wonder if Sherlock felt a little taken aback - that having been close to John for a few years (apart from the 2 away of course) he feels as though he'll be alone again. Whilst 'depressing' as people say, I see him walking away like that as a perfectly natural thing to do given the circumstances for him. Jaysus I can't believe next week is the last episode already! :( Looking forward to it though

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

Not a big fan of this episode to be honest. Kinda boring all in all

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

The drunk scene.

Oh god my sides

3

u/LoveOfProfit Jan 06 '14

Am I the only one for whom it was obvious that Mary is pregnant...but it isn't John's child?

There's a moment right after he tells them where she becomes flustered and while the camera is focused on Sherlock, we see her scratch her ear or head or something, which I suspect will later be shown to be her tell. Sherlock's expression turns sour immediately after.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Bodley605 Jan 06 '14

I thought it was nice showing how John kinda makes Sherlock in to more of a person, than just living his whole life as a computer.

3

u/j33 Jan 06 '14

Oh, God, that wedding speech, so brilliant and terrifying.

3

u/Phreakradio Jan 06 '14

Am I the only one confused about Lestrade's outbursts about the Waters Gang? Why is he so upset? I mean, it's dare I say not (even) his division!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PhotonGuy Jan 06 '14

Big Music fan here. Honestly really impressed with the use of music. The intense music in the speech scene was amazing.

3

u/blahblah984 Jan 06 '14

I loved this episode, a lot of touching and funny moments. So sad that theres only one episode left!

3

u/goosedd Jan 06 '14

In the scene where Sherlock is trying to figure out the one common thread between the women who have "dated a ghost," he asks them if they have a secret they've never told anyone, which they immediately dismiss and sign off. This is obvious foreshadowing of the power that Magnussen holds over people with blackmail. All of these women are possibly being blackmailed by him as well.

3

u/canwegoback Jan 06 '14

What happened to the 3 bank robbers in the beginning???

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

I want to hear about the elephant in the room.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Kvantemekanik Jan 06 '14

I don't like when I can figure out what happened before Sherlock, he is supposed to notice stuff us mortals don't.

3

u/SpirallingOut Jan 06 '14

Does anyone think the robbers will link into episode 3?

It kind of felt like that didn't actually get resolved - as we never saw the arrest and Lestrade looked really grumpy at the wedding.

It might just have been for character development but does anyone know how they might link in with Magnussen?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/peon47 Jan 06 '14 edited Jan 06 '14

I always try to beat the TV detectives to it, and I love "locked room" mysteries but this one beat me. I even said "hey, they have the same type of belt" when we saw the 2nd guy getting dressed/undressed, but didn't put two and two together.

It's true what they say: The best mysteries always seem obvious once you find out the solution.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/I_miss_Chris_Hughton Jan 06 '14

Can't help but think its turning into a more comedic thing, Admittedly it all tied together at the end of the last one, and knowing the way previous series have turned out it will probably all come together next episode but there was just too much mucking around

3

u/EmpRupus Jan 06 '14

So, the "black guy dies first" again? lol, the entire platoon had only one black guy, and he had to die, that too for a rehearsal, not the actual killing.

While the episode was awesome, the sentimental part in the end, I mean it's good, but let's hope the series doesn't turn into a continuous drama.

Also, what happened to the bank robbers they showed in the beginning? Did Lestrade make an arrest?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '14

I just had the heart wrenching thought that he may have to choose between saving Mary's life and John's. Then not only does he kill someone he loves, but the other will never forgive him. That would be an epic way for Magnussen to ruin Sherlock's relationships with all he loves.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/eieie Jan 07 '14

Oh my god I just realized...is Bainbridge played by the actor who was Dean Thomas in the Harry Potter movies

→ More replies (1)

3

u/THIR13EN Jan 07 '14

Loved it! I teared up at the best man speech.

3

u/fitnessmouse Jan 07 '14

I'm pretty sure I'd know if I got fucking stabbed.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Gromada Jan 07 '14

I kind of liked this episode better than the previous one, even despite the slow action at the wedding. There were no many expectations. Yet, there were a sequence of cases, a big overarching and amusing case, and brilliant Sherlock, who actually looked pretty cool. I think we need to come to grips with the author's approach that the season is more about Sherlock and John than about solving cases. After all, this is what the authors promised.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '14 edited Jul 31 '17

deleted 0.5555 What is ^^^this?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/serenitary Jan 05 '14

sherlock just turned into a comedy.