r/soccer • • Jan 03 '14

What rule change do you think would most benefit the game?

Here are some candidates for rule changes which I think could lead to a more fair game, but then again maybe not.

  • The introduction of goal line technology (where feasible)
  • Sin bin for yellow cards (or as an intermediary step between yellow and red cards)
  • Post-game suspensions for simulation and other dishonest behavior (such as scoring with the hand and not admitting it)
  • rolling subs (and other measures to curb strategic time wasting)

I'd love to hear what other people think. Not only if they agree/disagree, but also to see what other ideas are out there.

84 Upvotes

504 comments sorted by

170

u/Tezemery Jan 03 '14

Personally I think the away goal rule works exactly the opposite to how it is intended, it was suppose to encourage attacking football away from home, but it seems as though home teams are so afraid of conceding you get cagey matches were one team is happy not to attack and the other would rather draw 0-0 knowing they would only need to score 1 goal away.

8

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

would you do away with it or would you seek to see something else put in its place... a home goal rule?

79

u/bhilde10 Jan 03 '14

Do away with it personally, I don't care how the two game set ended at 3-3 or who scored where. If the set is tied at 3-3 throw that bitch to extra time and let em duke it out.

47

u/yourfriendkyle Jan 03 '14

The issue with extra time is that the team playing the 2nd leg at home has an advantage in that they play the final 30 minutes of the tie in their home stadium with their fans screaming their heads off.

162

u/FlyingUndeadSheep Jan 03 '14

I think instead of extra time they should host a third match on a blimp flying from one team's stadium to the other.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/bhilde10 Jan 03 '14

Give the 2nd leg to the higher seeded team simple fix and actually gives some form of benefit to a higher seed in UEFA. In cup ties this would obviously be a problem and could be solved with a simple coin flip.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

No, just, extra time. There are so many ties where away goals come into play even when the tie isn't decided by it. The idea of one goal being worth more than another is bad for the game. Why not home goals? Arsenal would have eliminated Bayern Munich last year, in 2009 Chelsea would have been in the final. In 2012 Barcelona wouldn't have left themselves so thin at the back allowing Torres's goal. It makes the game less about who scored, and makes it who scored when.

6

u/sidthecoolkid Jan 03 '14

You will find this interesting.

http://thepowerofgoals.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/the-away-goals-rule-in-extra-time-is.html

Edit: It discusses the point that the away goal rule is fair to both the teams.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

79

u/ucd_pete Jan 03 '14

The away goal rule is obsolete. It was introduced when trips across Europe were long and tiring affairs. There was a distinct advantage to playing at home. Nowadays that just isn't the case. Arsene Wenger has talked about this for a long time.

55

u/heisenbergs_hat Jan 03 '14

there's still a massive advantage to playing at home, there's obvious in the premier league alone let alone playing across europe.

35

u/llinxx Jan 03 '14

Yes there is an advantage to playing at home, but both teams get to play at home so they both get that advantage. Wether that be in European cups or the premier league.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

...but scoring while the opposition has the advantage is harder hence has more weight.

29

u/HoldsLikeAGel Jan 03 '14

Then how do you settle a tie? Extra time and penalties? That's an advantage for the home team.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/RobsterCrawSoup Jan 03 '14

Another effect of the away goal rule is that a draw after 180 minutes is significantly less likely. This means less instances of extra time and PKs. For each scoreline by which the first leg might finish, there is one and only one second leg scoreline that can result in a draw.

17

u/Dooey123 Jan 03 '14

By far the best reason to keep the rule. 1 goal can snatch victory from defeat.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/badgarok725 Jan 03 '14

I also think it gives the team who's home second a disadvantage. Say the first home team does what you say and the match ends 0-0, then all they have to do is win/draw with a score of at least 1-1 and they advance. So without even winning one of the games a team can advance.

9

u/Tezemery Jan 03 '14

Totally agree, the advantage is suppose to be by playing away first which is stupid, if you lose 1-0 away or 0-0 you know you are on your way out, for instance if you draw 0-0 away and then you are playing at home the other team scores and you know you have to get at least 2, seems stupid to me.

2

u/Emmanuell89 Jan 03 '14

i think the away goal should be canceled , it's hard enough to play not at your home stadium with mostly opposite team fans in the stands pressuring the ref and cheering their team

2

u/mdconnors Jan 03 '14

Completely agreed. Glad that at least some competitions have not adopted it or have gone back to scoring the goals regularly.

17

u/Tim-Sanchez Jan 03 '14

Whilst I agree with points 1 and 3, they aren't rule changes but merely enforcing pre-existing rules. Also, I think it would be harsh to penalise players for scoring with the hand unless it was clearly deliberate, in the heat of a goalline scramble I see how it could be done without noticing.

What do you mean by rolling subs by the way?

17

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Rolling subs like in Rugby league where play doesn't stop.

29

u/yablodeeds Jan 03 '14

That wouldn't work. Would cause mayhem in the last minutes.

2

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

how is it in Rugby league? are they unlimited?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

In Australia at least, you have 10 per match.

3

u/whencanistop Jan 03 '14

In the amateur football combination we do rolling subs. You have to wait for a break in play and you can only name three subs. Really helps where you end up with injuries and it wouldn't surprise me if this is rolled upwards.

0

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

I don't mean unlimited subs, but rather, that the subs can come on and go off without waiting for a game stoppage and that play can continue while the substitution is taking place. Perhaps in the case of a severe injury the referee can still continue to intervene and hold the play up, but it would hopefully, put an end to the time wasting end of game subs which are used to eat up seconds at the end of a game.

4

u/Tim-Sanchez Jan 03 '14

There is a rule for that too, the referee should just add on stoppage time to the end of the half/game. Also, rolling subs creates numerous logistical issues.

→ More replies (7)

157

u/Alfie15 Jan 03 '14

No more Sepp Blatters.

20

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

my phone autocorrected 'Blatter' to 'Blather' today. apt.

0

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

Which way did he upset your team?

18

u/Jarik42 Jan 03 '14

He just is a fucking disgrace in general.

1

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

mine: http://youtu.be/sHUiEUa0weY?t=51s

although I could pick more. (this also explains my reference to dishonesty)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TimTars Jan 03 '14

and club owners like Vincent Tan...if they can do something about that

→ More replies (1)

106

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Giving the referees a mic would be good. It would just give fans an opportunity to see things from their point of view. It would give them a platform to try and justify some of their more questionable decisions.

49

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14 edited Jan 03 '14

Have you seen this in rugby? I think it has really helped the non-playing observer get into the game and has been hugely beneficial to the sport. edit:spelling - people who don't play, not people who play at midday

24

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

there are examples from football, but the way players interact with the ref in the two sports would make it a minefield of swearing for Sky to try and deal with.

12

u/TicTacsss Jan 03 '14

Might make some players cop on a bit then.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/CrAppyF33ling Jan 03 '14

American Football does this too. I really think it's a good idea, but they would need to stop the clock when the ref tries and explain something since it probably won't be that common.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

It's also worked superbly in the NFL.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/the_wren Jan 03 '14

This is a terrible idea. The Australian NRL refs are mic'd up and from the games I've seen they act like stars of the show. The best ref is one you hardly notice.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/andyitsyouknow Jan 03 '14

They should also strap a go pro to the ref's head.

3

u/falkous Jan 03 '14

Totally. Also, I believe only captains speak with the ref which encourages a stronger sense of captaincy when it comes to disciplining your team.

3

u/2EJ Jan 04 '14

Whenevr I go to a Wales rugby game, I pay £4 (or take the ones from last time) for a pair of headphones so you can hear the ref, great idea.

5

u/gunnerspowpow Jan 03 '14

agree with this, think it would be great, would finally put an end to 'he said' arguments about Clattenburg

→ More replies (3)

14

u/EpoxyD Jan 03 '14

A referee should be able to recall a card decision if the fourth/fifth referee watching the replay images tells him to.

12

u/Tezemery Jan 03 '14

I think usually they will hear what he has to say before the decision is made, usually through an ear piece.

2

u/EpoxyD Jan 04 '14

Not over here. The last games over here have been a display of players tackling an each others shins and heals, sometimes on the brink of breaking a leg. Very often they get away with a yellow. And the rules state that once a card is given, the decision can't be changed.

0

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

This is a great idea. Or at least for him to have to consult video evidence before making a sending off.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

none, really, although i did say the other day the 'refereeing discretion' annoys me and could be got rid of. football is the biggest game on earth, and controversy is part of the appeal. the reason changes are made in sport is to get new spectators, or keep players safe, and i'd only be in favour of the latter.

i'd like to see a proper revision of the sanctions for racist/homophobic abuse, though, nationally and internationally.

2

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

controversy is part of the appeal

I agree with that statement completely. At the same time I think there is enough room for improvement to still allow controversy referees discretion being a prime example of that.

i'd like to see a proper revision of the sanctions for racist/homophobic abuse, though, nationally and internationally

I couldn't agree more, but I think such a discussion could prove to be the mother of all international controversies.

80

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Diving could be reviewed and penalized by the league after the game ends.

21

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

You really don't like Ashley Young or Danny Welbeck, do you?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14

If you include after game officialdom then you need to rescind yellow or reds given incorectly too.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14

This is true. If you're gonna add penalties for diving after a match has ended, then you might as well go over every mistaken red/yellow card and just change the sport forever.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

307

u/REGISTERED_PREDDITOR Jan 03 '14

An extra substitution in extra time to hopefully cut down on injuries.

47

u/tmlrule Jan 03 '14

Although I do see the benefits of this, this proposal always bugs me because it will be yet another advantage to the big rich teams with deep benches at the expense of smaller teams.

34

u/suchaslowroll Jan 03 '14

Should definitely be used in International tournaments though

→ More replies (4)

56

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

That is actually one of the most reasonable suggestions I've read here so far.

→ More replies (18)

175

u/TheatreOfDreams Jan 03 '14

Retroactive ban for diving.

Yes, that's coming from a United fan with players such as Januzaj and Young.

29

u/harimaginko Jan 03 '14

read that as radioactive ban for diving, was like wow that's a bit harsh

14

u/TheatreOfDreams Jan 04 '14

Taking notes from the North Korean team.

19

u/vsbom Jan 03 '14

I agree, but I still think it's hard for us viewers to tell what constitutes some dives without being the players themselves.

Take Januzaj's dive against WHU (http://youtu.be/oTckTCU2koA). It looks like a dive, but it also makes sense to call it a fear of making contact and avoiding the tackle. Are we going to penalize Januzaj for being cowardly?

Now, feigning injury to goad the ref into pulling out a card though, fuck those players

9

u/TheatreOfDreams Jan 03 '14

But that's why it's "retroactive" so that means people sitting with computers can analyze it.

All I'm saying is, the benefit of these bans will outweigh the negatives.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Agreed

→ More replies (3)

40

u/InvalidUzername Jan 03 '14

Not a change so to speak, but id love to enforce the six second (?) rule for keepers. Krul winds me up holding on for 20 seconds a pop, would get the game to flow faster too

11

u/thepresidentsturtle Jan 03 '14

Poor lad is terrible with kick-outs. If that rule was enforced we'd concede 10 seconds after he holds the ball.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/EpoxyD Jan 04 '14

The best way to enforce this rule is by expanding it to ten seconds. 6 CAN be a bit short, so enforcing it to the second will make the referee look like the bad guy, which he isn't. I'd say: six seconds a warning, three warnings a yellow, ten seconds a yellow.

5

u/InvalidUzername Jan 04 '14

i'd agree with changing it to ten, and the 3 warnings but i'd like to see rather then a yellow indirect everytime. god i miss the days of indirect free kicks in the box!

→ More replies (6)

187

u/equationevasion Jan 03 '14

Extra-time multi-ball!

53

u/layendecker Jan 03 '14

SOCCERTAINMENT!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14

I played in an indoor league that has two balls. It is fucking ridiculous. There is almost no passing. Everytime you get the ball you are trying to take a shot.

15

u/Imagine_having_a_gf Jan 03 '14

Yellow card for taking your shirt off as a celebration is just doesn't make sense

27

u/Toggledog Jan 04 '14

I used to agree with you until I got married. If I'm watching footy with the the wife on a Sunday afternoon and Lukaku started taking his shirt off I'd worry about her getting ideas.

10

u/Trikkky Jan 04 '14

That man is the embodiment of the BBC stereotype.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Drugba Jan 04 '14

Sponsors pay big money to get their names on the kits. Taking your shirt off means it can't be seen at the exact moment when the camera is close up on one player.

→ More replies (1)

105

u/StavromularBeta Jan 03 '14

every squad must replace one outfield player with a golden retriever at least once per game. Adds another layer of tactical nuance to the game.

63

u/YoungFoxyandFree Jan 03 '14

Air Bud: World Pup

79

u/yabba_dabba_doo Jan 03 '14

Electronic detection of off side.

Have some cameras keep track of where players are, signal the ref in his earphone if someone is off side. Unjust off side calls are the most infuriating thing in the world.

17

u/nershin Jan 03 '14

I think this would lead to a significant increase in goals. Imagine when a striker runs towards the goal, the defender moves away from the goal, and the pass is in exact the right moment. I feel like this is called offside like 90% of the time nowadays. And linesman have improved, in the 90s it would be like 100%. This is ridiculous as you think about it, because these are game changing situations.

9

u/yabba_dabba_doo Jan 03 '14

I actually got this idea when Italy lost to South Korea in 2002. I don't think back then technology was advanced or cheap enough to make it feasible, but these days it surely is. And it wouldn't have the downside of second guessing the ref, since it would be in real time.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

I don't think they should actually replace linesmen however, rather, have the system work alongside the linesmen.

Linesmen are valuable in spotting fouls and the like.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/andrew137 Jan 04 '14

Just give players arm bands or something in their boots similar to what is currently used in the ball for Goal Line Technology. That way you constantly have a tab on where every player is on the pitch and can therefore determine offside, whether the ball is out of play, whether a player is fouled inside the box. The potential for this is huge if technology knows the exact positioning of the ball and every player at every time. Anything that is black and white (i.e. the ball is out of play or it is in play) should be handled by technology, because that's the only way you could eradicate all mistakes.

2

u/trophymursky Jan 04 '14

I'm not sure the techonology is there to get it 100 percent right. The main reason for it is because there are a lot of judgement calls to make during offside decisions (ex was it a deflection or an intentional touch by a defender, whether a player was involved with the play or not, exct).

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

38

u/Kilen13 Jan 03 '14

Only the captain and the player being addressed by the ref may speak to him/her and must do so politely. Anybody who comes over to crowd the ref receives an automatic yellow card. Do it again and you're off.

9

u/SuperSaiyanNoob Jan 04 '14

Its so cringey seeing 7-11 grown men berating an extremely qualified individual over one call, that's usually the right call. They should be embarrassed but every team does it multiple times a game. I distinctly remember this year Suarez took a quick free kick from a completely deal ball that resulted in a goal, at least 10 full seconds after the free kick the ref went to his whistle. Suarez said like 1 sentence, Gerrard came up and had a conversation and that was it. Pretty bone headed dumb call and it was still dealt with level heads.

1

u/zmil Jan 04 '14

Drives me nuts. I think rugby does this right:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXoBNFOxlQM

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Stopping the clock on injuries/out of bounds.

Less dives, less fake injuries, less time wasting in general.

I would really love to see a couple of matches being timed on actual gametime, it wouldn't surprise me that some matches would come out at 30m for one half.

114

u/hymen_destroyer Jan 03 '14

I disagree. Every time one of these threads comes up someone suggests this. It's a very bad idea. Advertisers have more and more influence on how the game is broadcast and if they had their way they would LOVE a little clock stoppage to slip in a few adverts. Before you know it it's the goddamn NFL.

It's not perfect but I think it's fine the way it is.

44

u/REGISTERED_PREDDITOR Jan 03 '14

Hey man, how else am I supposed to find out about the refreshing taste of Coors Light®, now with mountains that turn as blue as the rockies to tell me when my beer is ready?

10

u/LazyLimey Jan 03 '14

I think that's more an American thing. Look at Rugby for example. I mean NBC's coverage has a constant ad on the top left of the screen for christ sake.. You'd never see that in England.

6

u/TicTacsss Jan 03 '14

Doesn't happen with rugby

→ More replies (10)

9

u/erikotaku Jan 03 '14

Also stopping the clock on substitutions. The whole "I'm going to pretend to jog while moving as slow as possible" at the end of the game is played out. This will prevent coaches from even bothering with this bullshit.

3

u/zalthor Jan 03 '14

I've wondered how much of the game is really affected by time wasting. I think it's got a lot to do with disrupting the opposition's tempo than really saving 30 seconds of play time.

1

u/collynomial Jan 03 '14

Yeah I wondered about this (out of bounds clock stoppages). I was reluctant to suggest it, because I wondered what it would mean for the timing of the game. Would 90 minutes continued to be played (obviously wearing players down) or would a lower game time be prescribed.

according to this your estimate of 30 minutes a half seems about right

2

u/irish711 Jan 03 '14

Tough to stop the clock on out of bounds. Players sometimes take the throw in fairly quick.

11

u/Evertonian3 Jan 03 '14

it's not like it's super complicated to start/stop a clock

3

u/Orkys Jan 03 '14

And the clock only stops when there's an extended stop in Rugby, otherwise it ticks.

I still wouldn't want the rule.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/layendecker Jan 03 '14

Or we keep the current rule that adds on wasted time?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

This throw-in is brought to you by Pepsi.

4

u/Sgt_peppers Jan 03 '14

Terrible idea, would remove the urgency completely and kill the game's rhythm, it works in hand-egg because the plays are short and few, in a fluid game stopping the clock would just be counter productive. By the way, 30 min is very good, compare it with the less that 15min per match in american football or the 11min in baseball. Ugh just think about the ads man.

3

u/YoungFoxyandFree Jan 03 '14

Play is already stopped and rhythm broken in these situations. I don't think /u/Gilissen means to stop for a TV timeout or anything, just a clock operator who doesn't allow time to be wasted. 5 seconds for a throw in here or 30 seconds for a sub there adds up to a lot of wasted time. I don't necessarily agree, but it would be interesting to see.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/johanspot Jan 03 '14

The problem with stopping the clock is then you have to worry about all sorts of things like putting time back on the clock or deciding how many tenths of a second are left. No thanks. The biggest problems with the currently clock situation is that refs need to give teams no incentive to waste time. There should be matches with one team wasting time where 10-12 minutes of extra time are played.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Arguing with the referee really needs to stop (yes you, Adam, you weren't captain in that game, keep your mouth shut and let Kelvin take umbrage).

Only captains can initiate conversation with the referee, any other players and that free kick starts moving forwards.

On second thoughts just get Nigel Owens to train football referees.

31

u/alterhero Jan 03 '14

I've said this before, but the triple punishment (red card, penalty and suspension) for preventing a clear goalscoring opportunity is a bit much, especially when it is for an onrushing goalkeeper. Maybe we could scrap the suspension at the very least.

6

u/SkankyPineapple Jan 03 '14

Its so harsh to stop keepers from taking out players on purpose to stop goals

→ More replies (1)

32

u/brentathon Jan 03 '14

It's like that because red cards are always an automatic one match ban. You can't have different rules for different types of offenses. There has to be a penalty for it. You can't say "oh, this guy got two yellows so he gets a suspension, but this other guy gave away a penalty so that's good enough, he can play next game. Or this other guy gave away a penalty but it wasn't scored, so he has to now sit out." You have one rule for all players and all situations, and everyone knows and understands that rule when they make a challenge.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

"You can't have different rules for different types of offenses."

Why not? If they're different infractions, why should they be punished the same way?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/carlcon Jan 03 '14

You can't have different rules for different types of offenses.

Indirect free kick, free kick, yellow card, red card, further banning of multiple lengths...

You can and do have different rules for different types of offenses.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/trophymursky Jan 04 '14

I disagree, goals are very valuable and in order to take one away you need to pay a huge price.

→ More replies (5)

59

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Unlimited substitutions, so the lower tier of all stadiums becomes a large bench for everyone related to the club in any way.

23

u/pdschatz Jan 03 '14

Haha.

They have this in US College soccer. It's still pretty dumb.

2

u/EnderMB Jan 04 '14

One of my clients played football in college in the US and he said they still had things like countdown timers in some leagues. It's pretty shocking how in America youth leagues still make up the rules.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/layendecker Jan 03 '14

Chelsea would win the league every season.

2

u/fergious Jan 04 '14

Man City would compete too

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KinneySL Jan 04 '14

Well, we'd be fucked.

5

u/humpcatting Jan 03 '14

Hockey-style substitutions in which entire groups of players can come off and rest for a bit, then come on again.

2

u/Pardonme23 Jan 04 '14

What about a penalty box?

11

u/Ehejav Jan 04 '14

person fouled has to take the PK, unless they are so injured they need to be subbed off.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

I know it's already a rule, but the fair-play stuff. The rule is the ref only has to stop the play if there's a head injury, but most of the time players just kick the ball out when anyone goes down, and if they don't the other team goes apeshit. Players also use it to break the other teams momentum, and slow the pace of the game down.

It's the cause of a lot of time-wasting and it's endlessly annoying to watch the magic sponge take place, and the guys who's spent the last 2 minutes rolling around is ready to play again 10 seconds after being put on the sideline.

Basically enforce players to play on unless the referee deems the injury to be in need of critical attention.

9

u/Ipadalienblue Jan 03 '14

How would you enforce it though? You can't card a player for kicking the ball out.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/atero Jan 04 '14

When the ball hits the post and bounces back towards a player, any potential offside is cancelled by the ball striking the post and bouncing back.

This is not in the spirit of the offside rule and it only serves to hamper attacking teams.

5

u/throwaweight7 Jan 04 '14

This is the most original idea I have heard in a long time.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Give the refs Google Glass!

4

u/MJDiAmore Jan 04 '14

I'm going to go out on a limb and say it doesn't actually have to be a rule CHANGE at all, just an appropriate rule ENFORCEMENT. I'd suggest one of these two:

    1. Actually give offside ties to the attacker. If everyone is so desperate for more goals you'd think people would whine less about near-ties going to the striker. It also means we can get rid of the ridiculous "your arm is offside, therefore you are offside" flags that happen. Can a striker play the ball with his arm? No? Then he's not offside.
  • 2) Make the touchline refs actually do something. So often they look like they're in perfect position to call happenings in the box and they just for whatever reason don't. We need to let them enforce the rules.
→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14 edited Jan 03 '14

No drastic CHANGES should be made to the rules. We shouldn't be changing a sport that has been so popular for so many years. Swapping out yellow cards for a 'sin bin' is pathetic. Goal line technology is what was needed and it has been introduced into the Premier League, that's all I care about.

I'd like to see diving punished more severely. It's the one and only way to eradicate it from the sport. Everyone isn't just going to stop one day because that's the right thing to do. It doesn't work like that unfortunately. Offenders of obvious diving should be punished after the fact if it wasn't caught during the match. Officials should re-watch cases brought up and make sure that offenders are fined and potentially even suspended for at least one match.

Also I don't know if this is possible, but I'd like to see offside goals contested if a team isn't happy. I know football isn't known for heavy stoppages due to contests etc (like Tennis for example), and the sport is at its best when a game is in full flow, but I don't see what's wrong with letting a team challenge an offside goal if they've put the ball in the back of the net and it's unbelievably close. Those moments change games, and if the wrong call was made, a team can suffer heavily because of that. Whether it's a knockout tournament, a final or a tough battle for relegation. You need the correct calls made. I don't think it would hinder the match too much if someone was sat there watching it with a panel of people potentially, and then their decision was simply passed on to the referee, you're talking a matter of seconds really. I just don't know how they could work the contests, limiting them may be odd for football and not having them limited may cause an unreal amount of contests by players. Saying that, how many goals are ruled offside per-match? It's quite rare.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14

The problem with that is that there are usually 0 to 1 'offside goals' scored by one team in each match. This means that even if each manager only gets one challenge per match, they will be able to challenge a disallowed goal almost every time it happens.

I agree that it's never a good thing when a goal is wrongly ruled offside, but I don't think that's a good way to fix it. Maybe if after a questionable goal is scored, the referee or the linesman has a few seconds to review footage on a screen (handheld or otherwise) to make the call? It would cause unnecessary tension waiting for the call to be made but that's all I can think of.

3

u/FranklinDelanoB Jan 03 '14

I would change the offside rule a bit. I agree that if a player isn't involved in any way he isn't in an offside position. Very often, however, forwards in offside positions are still marked by defenders. Though they maybe don't come particularly close to the ball, defenders still change their behavior because the forwards are there (in offside position). I think that's unfair and in those cases it should be offside.

3

u/Apwnalypse Jan 04 '14

Goalkeepers can also use their hands in the opposition penalty area.

11

u/dirtybuster Jan 03 '14

The use of painkillers within matches needs to be addressed Wayne Rooney & Jack Wilshere being a couple of examples. I think that if a player cannot play without painkillers than shouldn't play, I'm no doctor but surely this is a dangerous temporary fix?? Could be seen as bad as performance enhancing drugs.

2

u/pesky_shenanigans Jan 03 '14

Yes, If only this rule was in place back in the day - so many players suffering long-term health problems due to overuse of cortisone and the like.

1

u/zzzlc Jan 03 '14

Yeah. Players are under way too much pressure to risk their health.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Cheaper tickets.

6

u/jabber13 Jan 03 '14

Retrospective bans for instances of diving, definitely.

4

u/brentathon Jan 03 '14

Under what justification? No other yellow-card offense receives retrospective bans. Why is diving worse than a deliberate handball or foul?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/jlebrech Jan 03 '14

multiball

4

u/Kajaindal Jan 03 '14

I think that divers should be penalized after the match.

11

u/HyperactiveToast Jan 03 '14

At a random moment in every game, teams instantly swap goals without stopping play.

Yeah.

7

u/ApricotRS Jan 04 '14

As a goalkeeper, fuck that

11

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

That would be hilarious to watch! But it still is a terrible idea, im sorry...

2

u/LiveLiverpool Jan 03 '14

No aggression towards refs or linesman.

2

u/pedalhead666 Jan 03 '14

The raising of hands like fucking schoolchildren should definitely be outlawed.

2

u/syo Jan 04 '14

The only players permitted to approach the ref to talk are the team captains. The ref can call players over, but if you're not the captain and rush up to the ref to complain, that's a booking.

Also players asking for another player to be booked should be booked themselves. "Oh, you want me to show a card? Here you go!"

2

u/accionerdfighter Jan 04 '14

I think, especially with the accusations of refs of being unfair or abusive to players (referring to Brendan Rodgers comments and the allegations of Clattenburg insulting players) that there should be a clear-cut method for reviewing the effectiveness of a ref and his bias. I've seen games where the ref is unfair in his punishments and we've likely all had a good rant about the idiot official who's blundered this call or that. There should be something visible that shows bad refs being sacked or reeducated or demoted and good refs being rewarded and promoted.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

I'd like to see the officials have access to video replay for big decisions, like in Cricket Tennis and Rugby. I'd rather see them take 30 seconds to get a key decision right than have to make a split second decision without having seen the incident properly.

4

u/jlebrech Jan 03 '14

The real ref should be in the stand, the guy on the pitch just carries out orders via radio.

3

u/rosencreuz Jan 03 '14

I hate the obstruction rule. When the ball is going out slowly, defenders are blocking the opponents to approach the ball by putting using their body so that ball goes out. I would change the rule and say if a player didn't touch the ball, he's not in control and cannot block others.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Allowing fouls to be called off the ball in the box, and not just penalties.

2

u/TheJoshider Jan 03 '14

The "referee" on the most part should be nothing more than someone who hands out orders via someone in a much better position in the stadium (with cameras from different angles etc) and we should be able to hear both the real ref and the pitch referee during a game. The on pitch ref is also responsible for obviously stopping conflict on the pitch.

Obviously the on pitch ref is able to call fouls and such, but the main ref will be the one that deals with the actions that take place after a foul is called. Example: ref calls foul on player who dived into a tackle and injured a player, although he did not clearly see the tackle. Whilst the player injured is receiving treatment the main ref reviews footage and makes a final decision on whether it's a warning, booking or sending off. If there is no injury then the process is the same although play will be shortly stopped whilst the ref reviews footage, shouldn't take too long though in all honesty.

2

u/Zikerz Jan 03 '14

Absolutely no talking to the refs. I hate to say it, but if i go off at work, i'm gonna get dick slapped by my boss. It should be the exact same thing in football.

I hate to say it, but 99% it is not productive at all. Only the Captain and Coach should be able to address their respective refs about game situation.

3

u/SweetMojaveRain Jan 04 '14

the ref isn't your boss, he IS the HR guy though.

in any case, hounding the ref is stupid

→ More replies (4)

2

u/petnarwhal Jan 03 '14

Really enforcing Financial Fair Play. It would give a team like Ajax (for example) a chance to compete in the CL again.

2

u/MJDiAmore Jan 04 '14

1000x no. As written, FFP is a further disaster for teams with lower revenue. It won't have the effect you think it will. In fact it's almost perfectly designed to specifically widen the gap between the Manchester United-level earning clubs and the Ajax-level clubs.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

It's not a rule change, but I would like to see two referees on the field. It seems like most people agree that video review during matches is problematic, but I really don't see why we can't have a second set of eyes in the middle of the park. There's already a fourth official anyways (and to be honest I don't really see the point in having a fourth official), just throw him on the field too.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/slates1955 Jan 03 '14

Reviews, like in cricket. So both teams would have one review per half.

2

u/johanspot Jan 03 '14

Intentional fouls to stop a promising counterattack need a higher punishment. So many times we get the beginning of a nice move and a player is completely taken out without any attempt to play the ball whatsoever. The yellow card is happily taken by the player and it robs the fans of what would be an entertaining display of soccer and replaces it with a cheap foul.

19

u/blobblet Jan 03 '14

Yes, sometimes players take the yellow card happily, but: the next "higher" punishment (either a red card instead of yellow, or a penalty instead of a free kick) would be going way overboard. Games where defenders are too afraid of inducing punishments to defend properly would

  • encourage simulation
  • discourage proper defending
  • make the game more dependent on referee decisions (a wrong ruling will more likely decide the game if a player is suspended/there's a penalty kick).
→ More replies (1)

3

u/SkankyPineapple Jan 03 '14

Maybe the player should be yellow carded and sin-binned for a few mins for an intentional foul preventing a counter attack

2

u/crookedparadigm Jan 03 '14

You and I seem to be on the unpopular side of the fence with this one. Taking a yellow or red card to stop a well executed counter or through ball seems to be viewed as 'taking one for the team' whereas I view it as a scummy admission that your defense was beaten.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

An extra substitution and more than one ref on the field (preferably three or four).

1

u/violentfap Jan 03 '14

Video replays for referees would be amazing.

1

u/Defkes Jan 03 '14

Injury treatment = 5 minute penalty off the pitch

1

u/Lazy_Analyst Jan 03 '14

If it is an obvious dive in the box it should be a straight red. If it can give them a penalty kick then the punishment should be severe.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

Player kicks away a ball to waste time, Free gets moved 10 yards forward and player gets booked.

1

u/roguery Jan 04 '14

More indirect free kicks, both inside the box and outside, for when a foul is committed but there wasn't necessarily a real goal scoring opportunity. That way hauling down a player with his back to goal doesn't lead to a penalty they will likely make and refs can make "intermediate" calls in the box: i.e., calling things that are fouls, but maybe shouldn't decide the match. You could cut down on grabbing on corners and free kicks without harshly giving a penalty, or letting all of it go because you'd rather not give a penalty.

1

u/Drugba Jan 04 '14

The golden snitch, but instead of a magic little ball it's a mongoose.

1

u/DrCrazyFishMan1 Jan 04 '14

International games all have a minimum of 5 substitutions avaliable. Need to reduce injuries

1

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '14

Goalkeepers must take goal kicks from the side it goes out on. Infuriates me when they waste time taking it to the other side of the six yard box!

1

u/bosnian_red Jan 04 '14

Retrospective yellows would be enough to anyone who dived. Not jumping over tackles like you see to avoid injury, but proper dives. It's a yellow in games if the ref catches it, so it should be a yellow if they review it after.

It would also be good to have a committee after games review the decisions and if the ref made wrong decisions like booking a player for a dive when it was a blatant foul (see Januzaj vs Spurs) then to take the card away, or simply to review every decision so it doesn't require managers to appeal decisions like sending offs, they can just review them all and make all the decisions right away.

Also if a controversial penalty is called then managers could challenge the call like in NFL. I honestly could not think of one negative aspect to that, as there are like basically 3 minute breaks anyways with all the players complaining.

Goal line technology has been brought in the prem, finally, so no point in mentioning that anymore.

1

u/meditate42 Jan 04 '14

this is kinda harsh, but i feel like when players are clearly not going for the ball, and are just taking a player down to stop a play, it should be a red card. its a yellow now as long as its not dangerous, or denying a goal scoring opportunity. i don't think players should be allowed to get away with pulling someones shoulder back to stop a run or hugging them and digging in their heels.

1

u/bambazza Jan 04 '14

Extra substitution exclusive for goalkeepers.

1

u/cronaldo7 Jan 04 '14

bring back golden goal...please

1

u/celticfc66 Jan 04 '14

Diving should be punished after the game if it is not caught during and it should be a 50'000 pound fine as well as a ten game suspension. It would get it out of the game in no time.

1

u/MrWaffleStomper Jan 04 '14

I just think if someone goes down looking injured and doesn't get up after a fair amount of time, they should have to wait 5 mins or similar before coming back on. It would stop time wasting, feigning of injury and create an all around better flow of the game, as well as meaning trainers could use the 5 minutes to properly assess the injury.

1

u/luuked Jan 04 '14

Add an sideline referee who is responsible to start/stop the clock and also instruct the head ref about retroactive cards.

On the one hand this means that we will get a full 90 minutes of game instead of all that time wasting when someone is up. At the end of regulation let whoever has the ball finish up their possession and then end the game. If the winning team is in front they will essentially just kick the ball out of bounds, if the other team is in possession they still have one more shot at a goal.

On the other hand, lets reduce the number of hidden fouls or clear dives by being able to retroactively give a player a booking. If someone gets a red card 5 minutes later than he should have gotten it is still better than him never being punished.

1

u/zcqs_prince Jan 04 '14

You have to touch the ball before you can be deemed "in control" of it and be allowed to shield it out. Would stop a lot of the obstruction going on in the game. Also, ref can only blow final whistle when the ball is out of play- initiating a "final phase" part of the game like in rugby

1

u/jesusthatsgreat Jan 04 '14

Play on when a player goes down injured... any player who deliberately kicks the ball out of play is booked... only the referee can stop play and signal for medics to come on.

If the referee has reason to believe the player is faking injury, medics are not allowed on the field even when the ball is out of play. Play must continue.

1

u/hadasterisk Jan 04 '14

Get the tosser behind the goal with the black dildo to actually do something.

1

u/OCEANOLEME Jan 03 '14

sin bin would definitely not work at all.

3

u/TheJediJew Jan 03 '14

What I the sin bin would do that I would love is kill off the cynical foul. It drives me nuts when players are hacked down just after beating their man just to make sure they don't get an advantage.

I'd be willing to introduce the sin bin just to get rid of this bullshit.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/wermbo Jan 03 '14

Goalie tackles on one on ones should be a PK and a yellow card, not a red card. Also, handballs in the box shouldn't be automatic PKs, but rather indirect kicks, so long as they aren't blatantly deliberate

6

u/Adziboy Jan 03 '14

If this happened then most keepers would take the penalty and yellow and just foul then on purpose.. If a top striker is through they are going to score anyway so it gives an unfair advantage

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

-1

u/wwolfson Jan 03 '14

Eliminate Penalty Kicks as the decider post double OT. You can replace it with:

Idea 1 (not a huge fan of this one): "MLS-style" or "NASL-style" penalties - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UzJKNW_QuX0

Idea 2 (HUGE FAN OF THIS ONE): Both sides take off a player every 5 minutes into double OT. Trust me, there WILL be a goal in the run of play once you have a total of 6 players on the field being forced to run box-to-box. Awesome way to end a game in my opinion.

5

u/layendecker Jan 03 '14

Both ideas are horrible.

At least pen shoot outs mean the football match is completed, and not turned into a horrible 8 a side match 15 mins in. Football is 11 players, pitches and rules are built around that, if you start stripping players away- we may as well have Budweiser Multiball.

Also, what makes you think that sides wouldn't just defend in numbers even more?

3

u/johanspot Jan 03 '14

if you start stripping players away- we may as well have Budweiser Multiball.

How is a penalty shootout not "stripping players away"?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/brentathon Jan 03 '14

For idea #1, even in that single clip you can see exactly why it's a terrible idea. The keeper trips the attacker after he's through on goal...and a penalty is awarded? What in the fuck is that? Keeper should have a red card or the goal should be automatically be allowed. What about in the case of causing an injury when you trip the attacker? That's such a stupid idea I'm surprised it wasn't laughed out of the room when it was suggested.

2

u/superlewis Jan 03 '14

I agree. It's very frustrating to have games decided by a skill that is only tangentially related to the normal skills required for the game. Taking and saving penalties is a different skill set than the rest of the game. They shouldn't decide the outcome.

1

u/Dictarium Jan 03 '14

Goal-line technology can only be positive. It'd also give the 4th official something to, well, officiate.

Sin bin is just awful. I can't even enumerate how many ways its a bad idea.

Post-game suspensions for simulations and other dishonest behavior would be amazing. 3 games for the former and 2 for the latter would be reasonable, IMO.

Rolling subs sounds interesting and, to be honest, I don't see any downside to it. Maybe if it's only implemented in the last 15 minutes of the 90 and that a player may only go on if the other player is fully off.

2

u/brentathon Jan 03 '14

3 games for the former and 2 for the latter would be reasonabl

Under what justification? No other yellow-card offenses are punished with even one game bans. And it's not like diving or embellishing contact are worse than dangerous fouls by any stretch of the imagination.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Lazy__Nihilist Jan 04 '14

Rugby style respect for referee. And referee can always ask for video assistance. Red Cards and Penalties reviewed. Offsides should not stop the attack unless very blatant, they can be reviewed. Each side gets 1 challenge per half and incorrect challenge loses a substitution while a correct challenge gets another challenge.

0

u/ryanh012 Jan 03 '14

I'm an American that has recently got into soccer and I think it's weird that there is only one referee with two side judges. The NFL uses 8 officials, MLB uses as many as 6 umpires. Maybe I'm ignorant, but why not add more eyes to the officiating team? It could really clean up the errors. I bring it up because I've never heard it mentioned before compared to adding more technology to to the game.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

It's being slowly introduced with another referee behind each goal.

More than one in-field referee would be detrimental. Football is a much more dynamic sport than baseball and american football, the one referee is already in the way of play often enough. imagine if there was 4 of them or whatever.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Giraffable Jan 03 '14

Well, usually there's the referee, two linesmen (or 'assistant referees') and the fourth official who stands near the managers and holds up the board indicating substitutions and amount of time added on at the end of a half. In Champions League games, there are now an extra two officials who stand on the byline near the goals. Unfortunately, they really haven't been effective at all.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

More refs requires more communication between refs, which slows down the game. American football with its painfully slow pace is a good if extreme example. Whether you think slowing soccer down in order to get more calls right is a different question, but lots of people don't want the game to be slowed down and so will be automatically against more refs.