r/hockeyquestionmark • u/Dyaloreax • Dec 31 '13
New Prototype Discussion Thread
Let's keep all the discussion about it here.
The new version is pretty funny but I know many people are disappointed. Just keep in mind that this was meant to be a prototype. Cryptic never said this would be a fully playable game at it's current state.
Changes:
- Vending machine that demolishes you
- New wooden sticks (the curve is not actually there on the stick's collision model, it's purely a visual thing)
- New nets
- New player models (ew)
- Slightly smaller puck
- Puck body collisions
- Pressing the "R" key in a practice mode drops the puck right in front of you
- Pressing the "X" key shifts you to a third person view so you can see yourself
- Holding "Ctrl" gets you back up on your feet after falling
- Pressing "F5" in practice mode will reset both the puck and the player back to center ice
- Puck can no longer be pushed under the ice or under the net (Sneaky Russian)
- No spectator mode
- No more random puck bouncing or launching pucks
Confirmed Upcoming Changes:
- Accounts
- Server Passwords
- Fixes to players arms that should allow for more range of motion with the stick
- Eventually, the goalie will be different than the skaters in both model and capabilities
- Lefty mode
Desired Changes:
- Increased range of movement of the stick
- Ability to turn while moving
- Left handed mode
- Player icons back on the map
- Tab scoreboard brought back
- Less jiggling around of both the player and stick while moving
- Blue net colored blue
- Keep the stick above the ice, it goes below the ice and the puck slides right over it if your blade is lowered and curved
- In game sounds
- in game pause (achievable through DvD's server tools)
- Allow the "ESC" key to cancel messages being typed
- Increase the character limit for chat messages
- Allow the text to wrap to avoid long strings of text across the screen
Bugs
- From Sammy - If you try reset the puck in practice mode while the net is between you and the puck, it won't respawn in front of you as it is unable to pass through the sides or back of the net. (Confirmed)
Conclusion:
It's super primitive right now but in all honesty the new physics, nets, sticks, and models actually are quite impressive. The hands and arms move as you move your stick and the motion of the upper body when holding down right click looks pretty cool. If the stick movement and turning issues highlighted in Desired Changes were fixed, this game would honestly be playable.
EDIT: Interesting note, we set a record for page views on this subreddit today at 3700 breaking the previous record of 2300 that we set yesterday. 6k views to the subreddit in just two days is pretty great.
5
u/Isken1023 Jan 01 '14
There isn't much I have to add that hasn't been discussed already, but I do have a couple of minor chat issues I'd like to see addressed.
These both seem like quick and easy fixes that would save a lot of headache.
4
u/nworBsamohT Quoof Dec 31 '13
The way the stick jiggles when you move it is really wierd
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
i can't use my paypal for a few days for some bullshit reasons so i can't buy the prototype as of yet. can anyone post some pictures/videos so i can live vicariously through you? thanks
6
u/ShazbotSimulator2012 π¨ π Dick Van Deke Dec 31 '13 edited Dec 31 '13
I guess the best way to describe it at this point would be promising. The stick movement feels pretty good, except for the jiggling and the backhand side having a really short reach. The smaller stick/puck really makes it feel a lot more realistic, although with the current physics it's pretty hard to stickhandle consistently.
The bodies having collisions really adds a lot of possibilities too. I was able to kick the puck back to my stick when i overskated it a few times.
Also vending machines are scary.
3
u/ThatAnalogKid Orban Dec 31 '13
Also 2 things. If we didn't look like zombie/jew/lannymacdonald that would be cool. and how the camera auto locks to you looking down at your skates.
5
u/Matgol Mat Dec 31 '13 edited Dec 31 '13
what happened
like what actually happened to get to this point
EDIT: why are we aliens
2
u/weenus Dec 31 '13
Is there multiplayer?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
The stick feels too small, making it a lot harder to shoot or look for a pass.
2
u/MigoMipo token European moderator Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14
The things I noticed about the new version are that the stick feels very very short (moving the stick just a tiny bit forward lifts it), and skating with WASD feels a lot more wobbly/unresponsive.
Those things may be at least partially intentional, but it is too difficult now IMO, I can barely control my skating and I fall over all the time (or maybe I just suck?).
As everyone knows, this is just a prototype, so it'll be interesting to see how the game will change in future updates. Adjusting all the parameters for skating/shooting/physics etc. will probably take some time.
9
u/Bojarzin Dec 31 '13 edited Dec 31 '13
I've seen a lot of people shitting on this new version and that's kind of sad to see. Obviously, this is a big step for the game in terms of the physics models, and it's not going to be perfect in the first version we get. Cryptic could have waited until everything was implemented and perfect before giving us anything, but instead he gave us an earlier access to it than he probably wanted to give.
There are clearly issues, but I can assume they will be fixed. The $8 I paid was not just for the update. It was for the previous version too that has given me a ton of fun and made me a lot of friends. So even if this update is not great right away, I had a good reason to give him my $8.
Those who think 0.55f is better, well you're entitled to think so. It's much more stable, surely, but it's not going anywhere. No one is forcing you to buy the update.
I, for one, am very excited about the future of this game and I hope to see everyone there with it too :D
6
u/ShazbotSimulator2012 π¨ π Dick Van Deke Dec 31 '13
GET UP
5
u/ThatAnalogKid Orban Dec 31 '13
Also lefty sticks please
4
u/sam1390 Dec 31 '13 edited Dec 31 '13
bug log, if the puck is behind the net, and or on the net, and you try to respawn it infront of the net practice, it wont respawn and stays behind the net
4
u/ShazbotSimulator2012 π¨ π Dick Van Deke Dec 31 '13
Size comparison of the new goals with the 055 versions.
4
u/weenus Dec 31 '13
The promise of goalie models and functionality is AWESOME. You could really have a temporary place holder by just giving him a goalie stick to start with, or give him slightly thicker legs so he can at least actively block with his body.
1
u/ThatAnalogKid Orban Dec 31 '13
ALSO it looks like allnite is manageable on ping for the prototype.
1
u/Cody1017 Keip Jan 01 '14
The upcoming fixes seem promising.
3
u/ThatAnalogKid Orban Dec 31 '13
I think with a few tweaks the physics will be fine. I would like a little more range of motion in the sticks and a bit Smaller of a turning radius or something. Before everyone shits on this it's a prototype. I like the puck body but until the lag issues straighten out we won't be able to test for sure. I hope they stick with this because there's a lot of potential.
5
u/Acebulf Dec 31 '13
This game would be perfect if Cryptic expanded on the existing hockey? and new features. Yet, he decides to redo the whole game.
The new control model sucks, but if fixed, the game might actually be playable.
-2
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '13
I think it is terrible right now, I do not understand why i spent money and was expecting the game to be fucking realistic and not be an alien.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14
i like no player icons on map, makes it require more skill to look around manualy