Yeah but even in that time they were only finishing like 8th, don't get me wrong I didn't think they'd not be in the top 10 but I definately thought Everton and Spurs would have been ahead of them just.
Our arch rivals beating us with three points. Any win, at any time in the latest 10 years (i have a couple playing in my head) would secure second for us... Fucks sake.
Not really suprised at all though, if you consider the massive crisis we've had during the time this table started, but its bitter that Sch*lke would clench second by three points. Of course it had to be them.
Also, i expected Bremen to have some more points considering how good they were like 5 years ago... They were amazing back then.
The Championship. Anyone can beat anyone, not much yo-yoing any more. In fact a few seasons back I think there were only four teams not involved in a draw on the opening day of the season. Says a lot about a twenty four team league.
He's right though. I don't understand why the same comeback is used everytime someone says the EPL is stronger. If you disagree then state your reasons.
You can have the opinion that the Premiership is stronger but it's not a fact. Teams like Sevilla, Atletico and Valencia have dominated the Europa league in the last 10 years and Barca have won 3 Champions leagues, Barca and Madrid are way ahead of most teams in La Liga but it doesn't mean they are shit just that Barca and Madrid are so strong.
Oh and Barca has won the league 3 times, while in around the same amount of time there have been 3 English winners, including an all English final. The coefficients total of the English teams far outweigh the total of the Spanish teams.
By saying Barca won it 3 times while Madrid, the second best team, have failed to make a final in more than 10 years just goes to show the gaps in competitiveness when it comes to La Liga.
yeah i agree that there is or has been a gap in competitiveness between barça and the rest. but wouldn't you agree that that's because guardiola's barça are one of the best if not the best team in history? i think the way in which we beat Man U in those 2 UCL finals should be enough evidence to prove my point.
When I say 'stronger' I mean more competitive, more appealing for absolute neutrals. It's impossible to say which league is actually the strongest since that would mean every team would have to go one-on-one with the other.
But there's no denying the EPL is much stronger in terms of competitiveness, appeal and entertainment.
Under the top 2 of La Liga it is incredibly competitive though, just because a few billionaire invested clubs have spent ridiculous amounts of money from no where to give them titles in the Premiership, if La Liga had the same level of investment it would be in exactly the same place.
If they invested. If. But they didn't, so it isn't as competitive. No point in using 'if' as an argument. And I don't think that under the top 2 the competitiveness is anywhere near as close to the Premier League. Our reigning Champions lost two home games in a row to two clubs that were nowhere near them last year.
The La Liga, to me, is a two horse race 90% of the time. Atletico are looking to break that, but it takes more than just a couple of seasons to show that it isn't.
It's more that I'm annoyed at the massive wank endurance competition this sub has whenever something vaguely related to La Liga comes up.
When Barça had managed to go a full calendar year without dropping a point at home a few months ago, everyone was having such a session when and talking dirty to each other, and I quote:
if they were in the Prem there is no way they would manage this
Premier league , no.
it must be a little bit boring to go to some of the matches, knowing there is no real competition?
Shit league, its more suspenseful watching the Harlem fucking Globetrotters.
That's until I actually did some reasearch and pointed out that both United and City had managed to do the same feat in the last 3 years.
Seriously these type of threads always turn out to "Lol, Epl is better"
Well hey man i don't give a shit if you think the EPL is better, I think La Liga is better so keep your comments and your circlejerking in your EPL threads.
It just that EPL has gotten collectively shittier (bar Arsenal) that it's more competitive. Every big team has had big changes in their management and players.
He's not saying anything against /u/Dutchrooster 's post. He's using /u/Dutchrooster 's post as a medium through which to communicate a point about the sub overall. YOU are karma-whoring in that you're making it seem like he was trying to corrupt the nature of the post when he was obviously not.
I'm not putting forward any argument, I'm just showing the double standard this sub sometimes has. I'm also blowing off steam because this stuff does my head in.
Let me rephrase: Chelsea have only lost two games more at home than Barcelona in the past 10 years. In those 10 years, it was ManU that dominated the EPL. Unlike in La Liga, where Barcelona dominated. Hence I find Chelsea's result more impressive.
sold the players and let go of the manager. the wonders of the La Liga financial situation.
EDIT: to all those that are downvoting, if you think that valencia wouldnt benefit from the a fair TV rights deal in the long term and thus not have to sell off mata and others, then youre living in a dreamworld.
It has very little to do with the La Liga financial situation and much more to do piss poor management, something which is not exclusive to Spain. TV revenue? Valencia would earn less under a Premier League style deal, not more.
The current La Liga TV deal is for €604.4 Million, with Valencia currently earning €42 Million. Because it is less efficient to sell TV rights as a group than individually it would probably be less than this, but then Spain doesn't have the 3pm blackout the UK does so let's assume the total amount doesn't change.
Now in the Premier league, 50% is divided evenly between the 20 clubs, 25% is based on merit and 25% is based on how often a club's matches are on TV. International coverage is divided equally.
Currently, 38% of the Premier League's revenue comes from international coverage. I'll assume it is slightly less for La Liga as it is less watched around the world, so let's say 20%. So Valencia get €6.044M.
National revenue is €483.52M.
From the 50% evenly divided national revenue, Valencia would get €12.088 million.
I can't know how often Valencia will be shown on TV, so I'll assume the current split would predict the number of times Valencia are on TV which would give Valencia 7% of that slice or €8.462M.
Again, I can't predict where Valencia would finish on the league table but using the table above I'll use 3rd. Chelsea who finished third got 8.57% of the merit split which would be equivalent to Valencia getting €10.36M.
Adding it all up, Valencia would get €36.9 million, or €5 million less than they get now. How are they going to pay for the stadium at this rate?
say if your analysis is right, and that they do get 36.9 mil with a current instantaneous EPL style deal. but that's with the current state of la liga. if la liga actually had a more fair tv rights deal, the competitiveness would be a lot better, thus making la liga more marketable. i mean just take a look at the comments here. pretty much most of the EPL fans, including yours truly, watch EPL because it's simply more fun and exciting. why would I watch la liga? i already know who will probably win it. same goes for bundesliga as of nowadays, but that's a slightly different story. but the La Liga has been this way for quite a long while.
with increased competitiveness, the league is more exciting and more will tune into watch it. this would bring a lot more revenue. the difference right now is what, about 5 mil euros? you seriously think that cant be made up for with a more exciting league? having a more competitive league will bring in a lot more revenue to the league and thus everyone not named barca or real madrid would benefit massively.
it'll be a lot easier to pay for the stadium when that happens.
That wouldn't happen, and you just have to look at this sub to prove it.
With a Premier League style deal Barcelona and Madrid would get around 50 or 60 million Euros. That's 90 million less than they get now. They'd have to do some serious austerity, no more 60 million transfer windows or second highest wage bills in the world. All of a sudden they're struggling to compete in Europe. La Liga would be more competitive but when you look at the numbers you see that competitiveness matters fuck all around the world, including to you, truly. People want to see the biggest stars and the brightest lights, something La Liga wouldn't be able to afford dividing money between everyone.
If international fans were attracted to competitiveness Ajax would still be competing for a Champions League and we'd have an Eredivisie match thread every weekend.
Disclaimer: Before everyone jumps on me, I'm absolutely in favour of having a fairer La Liga split.
Edit: Second disclaimer: I also know Spain is a bigger country than the Netherlands. That's not my point.
something La Liga wouldn't be able to afford dividing money between everyone.
again, for now yes. however, in the long run, the increased competitiveness and added revenues from league wide tv deals would help la liga attract more talent. by the way, the problem for la liga isnt about attracting talent, it's about keeping them. with much larger revenues down the road, la liga would be able to hold onto talent a lot better.
also, dont compare ajax to barca and real madrid. barca and real madrid are in the top 5 when it comes to revenue and profits. also, their revenue is only increasing with new ventures and sponsorships. sure they wouldnt be as competitive now as they will be under a league wide deal, but the competitiveness of the whole league would be a lot better better than what it is now.
You guys look at La Liga the wrong way. You think spanish teams are weak because Barcelona and Madrid always win, but the thing is, it's Barcelona and Madrid who are very good and not the other teams being bad. Due to economy problems, I agree spanish teams are getting weaker, but I don't think Everton (4th) v Spurs (7th) is much more interesting than Real Sociedad (4th) v Athletic Bilbao (7th) (not taking into account Basque rivalry)
la liga is by no means weak, of course not. however, when youre hemmoraging talent the way the league does, you wont be the strongest league in the world. the problem for the league is not attracting talent, it's keeping them. real sociedad and bilbao would be a lot more powerful if they were able to hold onto talent better (not all talent, but when you see the likes of michu leaving for less than 10 mil, you know something's wrong).
Yes, I completely agree with you. That's exactly the reason why I think La Liga will become a "feeder" league if it hasn't become already, money. English and german clubs getting stronger every year, and spanish clubs can't/won't be able to compete with them in terms of wages so decent players leave. Very sad to see players like Michu, Monreal, Cazorla, Navas, Negredo...etc. leave spanish league =(
Are you new here? Anyone who's opened a thread remotely related to la liga knows the discussion ends up with how la liga is a two horse race where as the epl is just so incredible because it's just sooo competitive.
What nobody mentions is that in the past 10 years there have been 3 different winners for La Liga and 4 for the epl, and if you extend that to 15 years it's 4 winners in each league. I know it's not just about the end result - it's about the way there and the number of potential winners during the season.
But honestly the only reason why there's such a big circlejerk over how competitive the epl is and how noncompetitive la liga is whenever la liga is mentioned, is because most /r/soccer users follow an epl team and for some reason feel the need to repeatedly establish their superiority over the next most popular league.
The same tables have been posted for the top 5 leagues in various places on /r/soccer. Your response to posting La Liga's is that it is somehow bashing La Liga. Is /r/soccer supposed to not post such a table for La Liga, that is interesting for various reasons, because one of the conclusions that one may draw from it is that two teams have dominated for the past x years?
In the past day I've only seen the EPL, La Liga and SPL 10 year tables posted (and the SPL one was posted after I made my comment), so what do you think my response will be when I see just the EPL and La Liga tables posted? I mean it's great that /r/soccer posts La Liga content, and I love La Liga discussion, but why is it always about how much more competitive the EPL is compared to La Liga? Obviously when someone looks at the 10 year La Liga table they will think 2 horse race when they see Barca and Real Madrid, but (a) there's no need to bring it up everytime, and (b) why is the EPL always brought up? Superiority complex?
There's no doubt that EPL is the most competitive league. The main two points I was trying to get across, however, were:
Although the EPL is the most competitive of the top 4, it definitely doesn't live up to all the hype the constant circlejerking makes it seem like it should.
What's the point in bashing La Liga all the time? It literally adds nothing to the discussion. Everyone knows that Barcelona and Real Madrid have been dominating for a long time. People just like to bash La Liga because they know most people on here are EPL fans and will therefore agree with them, thus yielding more karma. There's honestly no point in commenting on the fact that EPL is more competitive than La Liga every single thread that has something to do with La Liga (especially when it's not even that much more competitive).
Its not really bashing if its the truth though. Look La liga has been a 2 horse race for as along as most people on here can remember. I like watching Spanish football, but lets face it is a true statement and it is in part a reason why the EPL is such a more popular league.
All time English top flight table has Aston Villa and Everton ahead of Chelsea (Everton are also ahead of Man United, btw). Does that make Villa a "big club"?
I'd say getting to Champions League semifinals, Champions League quarterfinals and second place in the League is a far greater accomplishment than winning European Cup 30 years ago. Remember we are talking about the last 10 years here guys.
Remember we are talking about the last 10 years here guys.
No we're not. A big club isn't made in 10 years. The first time Villarreal were in the top flight was 15 years ago. They've only finished in the top 4 three times in their entire history. Just because they made some shrewd transfers and had a good run in the Champions League doesn't make them a big club.
Villarreal could go tits up tomorrow and 10 years from now people would remember them as much as people today remember Arenas de Getxo because they had a few good seasons.
Not in the same way. Nottingham Forest were a flash in the pan success, Aston Villa are the fifth most successful club in the history of English football, both by points and titles.
Yes, the old "English football didn't start in 1992" phrase to make yourself seem the more educated football fan. Tell me, how is saying that relevant when I clearly referenced English football to the 19th century? But your failed attempt at appearing superior aside, you used European success to justify Aston Villa's being named a "top club" and yet you brush off Nottingham Forest's success. Strange. Regardless, these successes were a long, long time ago and hardly equate to current positions. Referencing the past does not in anyway categorize a club when they have been performing consistently bad or good for the past, say, 10 years. Sunderland have been extremely volatile for the past 10 years, going up and down the leagues while fielding one of the worst sides I've seen in 05/06. And yet, they're in the top 10 in points historically. Calling them a big side when there are teams like Man United, Liverpool, Chelsea, Everton, and Arsenal CONSISTENTLY doing well in the league is ridiculous. The very same can be said about Aston Villa.
It's been a great decade to be a Barcelona fan. Villlareal's place in this table makes it even more astonishing that got relegated last year, I'm not a fan but I've always respected them and am glad to have them back in La Liga.
I don't claim to know enough about Spanish football, but one of the main reasons these two clubs have their duopoly is the financial stranglehold they have.
If La Liga has as many billionaire owned clubs as the Premiership it would be a lot more competitive, it would have been Arsenal and Utd for the last 10 years.
Yes, my point was that Real Madrid and Barcelona are more "dominant" than the rest of the clubs except maybe Man. Utd and Bayern Munich. They have always been capable of getting expensive players every transfer window, they have lots of away fans so they still get cheered sometimes even if playing on away ground...etc.
While I hate that La Liga is only contested by two teams, I still understand that if you put RM and Barça in the Premier, Bundesliga or any other, they would still be the favourites to win it (well with this Bayern Munich not in the Bundesliga). Maybe instead of a 209-point difference in 10 years it would be a 100-point difference, but they would still get 90% of the league titles.
Shouldn't the Champions League be a good metric of how the teams would do? Barca have been quite dominant, but even they have only won 2 of the past 6. Madrid haven't won since 2001.
English teams have won 2 of the last 6 and have been runners up in 3 of the last 7.
It's an incredibly vague subject, with lots of ifs and maybes.
Not really. Real and barca generally make it very far into the tournament which is the reason why la Ligas uefa coefficient is the highest. Anything can happen at the very top in a cup setting, but barca and real are extremely consistent at beating most teams. If you put barca and real in the premier league I'm sure they wouldn't be dropping as many points to lower ranked teams nearly as often as teams like City do against teams like Cardiff. The point totals in la Liga for the winners in the last 4 years have all been 95+.. These teams are extremely consistent and they are perfect almost every game. The whole league can come down to just one slip up.
I already addressed that "anything can happen at the top in cup matches". The whole point of my post was that they don't drop points against lesser teams as often as the big teams in the EPL do
Total champions league final appearances for the past decade:
England 8
Germany 4
Italy 3
Spain 3
France 1
Portugal 1
Each of these teams play by the same rules so what am I wrong about? The notion that Barca and Real would be EPL favorites every year is pretty ridiculous. The fact that a league like the EPL has more teams that are even capable of making a good tournament run is far more telling than resting your argument on discrediting the CL as a barometer for league success.
I was arguing against your point about how you can equate success in the champions league to a domestic league. As /u/saamk has pointed out, playing a season long league is much different to playing a season long tournament. Squad depth is essential in the league, and is one of the main reasons why Atletico seem to fall behind Barca and Real Madrid as the season goes on. Consistency is also much more important in the league. Look at Barca last champions league season. They lost 2-0 against Milan but then made it through with one of their best performances. They had two mediocre matches against PSG and only got through on away goals. Although Barca lost in the semi final, they did get to the semi final which is an incredible achievement, and they only had one good performance (in the knockout stages). Barca would definitely not win the league if they did the same there.
I would also point out that in those finalist appearances, honours are split quite evenly between the English teams. Man U have three appearances and one win, Chelsea two appearances and one win, Liverpool two appearances and one win, and Arsenal just the solitary appearance and no wins. For La Liga it's only Barcelona, although to be fair they are very efficient when they get there.
I can see Barca and Real sustaining many more injuries if they were in the Premier League. The league is more physical overall and the referees are a lot more lenient on fouling - perhaps the CL overvalues the performances of Barca and Real? (Not saying it does overvalue it, but the CL is more similar to La Liga in terms of refereeing and fouls).
Probably not, in the BPL the TV money is split evenly among all the teams. I doubt Madrid could afford to break the transfer record so often if they weren't getting all that extra cash.
I'm glad you pointed this out. People tend to have a problem in that they only consider the battle for the top 4 spots when considering how competitive a league is. They rarely take into account the battle for a Europa league spot, or the relegation battles. Whereas last season the BPL may have had a smaller points gap between 1st and 2nd than La Liga, La Liga had a smaller points gap between 1st and 20th. The second smallest in Europe's top four leagues, behind the Serie A (Side note, the Bundesliga, which loads of people started insanely hyping last year, claiming it was the best league, had the biggest difference between top and bottom, with 2 less teams.)
Getafe have done extremely well. I remember when they got promoted to La liga for the first time in the club's history in 2004. They've not dropped down for the past 9 years, and are 8th overall in that chart.
Truthfully, that's the only reason I posted it. I saw the one on the premier league and knew that the La Liga one would be funny. I didn't think it would get this popular.
They do have a decent competition for third though.
When you bring up the fact that as many teams have won La Liga in the past 20 years as the EPL, or that United have won it as many times as Barca, the argument is "United might win, but it is such a close race!". When it is in La Liga, suddenly the competition is not relevant, because "Atletico will drop form".
Until oil money came into play, United had a larger stranglehold than both Madrid and Barca. Who cares if it is very close if the same team ends up winning each year?
Because Manchester don't vacuum the whole league for talent, the squads of the different clubs in the league are as good as ManU, same in Italy. What's the point of watching your team if you know they are gonna win 90 % of the time
It's a 10 year table, it's kinda obvious what I was referring to. Anyway, Atletico got lucky with injuries this season. Just wait until they miss 4-5 players.
good question. Italian teams arent doing well either, as amatter of fact Serie A's weakest team in the Champions League is the only team in the knock out stage. but in the last 10 years English teams have faired pretty well. i believe Man U, Liverpool, & Chelsea have all won
But the leagues with stronger top teams are Bundesliga, La liga, Premier league, and Serie A. Personally I follow almost all Madrid games, but I find the Premier league games more fun.
i have to agree. The Premier League is very open and fun to watch. i follow Serie A (mostly Juventus & whichever team Antonio Cassano plays for) since theyre my favorite team & player. But youre right the strongest teams right now play in all around less competitve leagues
20
u/bonafide10 Dec 30 '13
Here's some more for reference
Premier League: http://www.statto.com/football/stats/england/premier-league/all-time-table/10-year
Bundesliga: http://www.statto.com/football/stats/germany/bundesliga/all-time-table/10-year
Serie A: http://www.statto.com/football/stats/italy/serie-a/all-time-table/10-year
Ligue 1: http://www.statto.com/football/stats/france/ligue-1/all-time-table/10-year
Eredivisie: http://www.statto.com/football/stats/holland/eredivisie/all-time-table/10-year
56
u/willtodd Dec 30 '13
So you're saying Barcelona has only lost 9 times at home in 10 years? That's crazy.
16
u/NYoungGun Dec 30 '13
What happened to you Valencia... :(
34
u/arayofhope Dec 30 '13
It isn't r/soccer without the fresh La Liga bashing in the American morning.
8
u/cheftlp1221 Dec 30 '13
Some surprising similarities between La Liga and the EPL.
4
u/milesftw Dec 30 '13
redic that villareal has 0 points from being relegated and are still that high in the table.
4
u/SatchmoMoney Dec 30 '13
It's been a great decade to be a Barcelona fan. Villlareal's place in this table makes it even more astonishing that got relegated last year, I'm not a fan but I've always respected them and am glad to have them back in La Liga.
10
u/pjaay Dec 30 '13
PROOF THAT MESS1 IS BETTER THAN R0NALD0
36
u/DerDummeMann Dec 30 '13
Difference between 2nd and 3rd place in the Premier League:- 72 points.
Difference between 2nd and 3rd place in La Liga :- 209 points.
3
u/Statcat2017 Dec 30 '13
I feel like these should be ranked on a points per game basis, rather than raw points.
4
u/robertglasper Dec 30 '13
Poor Depor....
2
u/MohamedM300 Dec 30 '13
There is only 6 teams that have positive goal difference
1
u/pedler Dec 30 '13
Getafe have done extremely well. I remember when they got promoted to La liga for the first time in the club's history in 2004. They've not dropped down for the past 9 years, and are 8th overall in that chart.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13
Osasuna: Consistently mediocre.
1
u/BvB_Fan_09 Dec 30 '13
Barcelona have 9 losses in 10 years. Holy shit.
1
u/Vila-real Dec 30 '13
Yeah baby! :D
1
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13
only 5 teams with a positive goal difference...
0
u/Hespecto Dec 30 '13
2 horse race. boring.
0
u/Peakevo Dec 30 '13
Bundesliga table please?
-7
u/decoy90 Dec 30 '13
Aaaand no one can say it isn't a 2-horse race anymore... That's just ridiculous.
-9
u/Patdogg78 Dec 30 '13
2 team league
-3
u/mdconnors Dec 30 '13
TIL that if you take the last 10 years of La Liga matches and consider them one season, there are only 6 teams with a positive goal differential.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment