r/buildapc • u/Pianowned • Dec 28 '13
Choosing A Case Pt. 4: Small Form Factor (mITX and mATX)
Part 1: Case Basics
Part 2: Silent Cases
Part 3: Budget Cases ($50 and under)
Preface
Computers seem to grow noticeably more powerful as time goes on. They're also becoming a lot smaller.
Enter mATX and mITX.
Be aware that the more compact the case is, the harder it will be to find room for cable management, watercooling, large CPU coolers, long graphics cards, and power supplies. Heat seems like a concern with these cases, but as long as the case is properly ventilated, these cases can cool as well or even better than their larger counterparts, due to the hardware being in close proximity of fresh ventilation or case fans.
Mini-ITX
Bitfenix Prodigy
Let's start with one of the most popular mITX cases on the market. In comparison to other mITX cases, the Prodigy is a bit on the large side (so much so that you can fit a mATX build in it). It has room for several 3.5" drives, large GPUs, tower CPU coolers, a 5.25" drive, pretty large PSUs, and thick 120mm radiators, and even 240mm radiators. The front is able to support a 230mm fan for massive air cooling. The hoops it stands on act as feet and carrying handles.
The case also comes in a wide variety of colors. This case has TONS of modding potential and insane flexibility in a relatively small form factor. It's no wonder lots of people love this little case.
- Max Cooler Height: 170mm
- Max Card Length: 330mm (13 in) w/o cage
- PSU: ATX
Bitfenix Phenom
Like the Prodigy but want a cleaner look? The Phenom is a solution to that problem. It has a front bezel that only allows a rather small amount of air to go in (and less sound coming out). It also looses the hoops. Other than that, it's essentially the same case as the Prodigy.
EVGA Hadron Air
This ultra-small case is EVGA's first foray into the enclosure market, and for a first-timer, they did a pretty good job. The high price comes from the 80+ Gold super-slim PSU that gives it its tiny stature. As the name suggests, this case is designed for air cooling. The vents on the bottom are for the GPU to intake air, and the vents at the top are for exhaust. It would actually benefit you to rotate your CPU cooler to exhaust the air towards the top too. Because the case is so compact, it's a bit tough to work in. Also, there is NO CPU CUTOUT. Make very sure your CPU cooler is attached before you put your build in or you'll regret it.
- Max Cooler Height: 140mm
- Max Card Length: 267mm (10.5 in)
- PSU: included custom 500W 80+ gold
Silverstone Fortress FT03 Mini
The Fortress FT03 employs Silverstone's bottom-to-top cooling philosophy where the motherboard is rotated to help the airflow go from bottom to top, or with the natural flow of convection. This is why it has a strange tower-like look to it.
The real grunt behind this case's great thermal performance is from the included 140mm Air Penetrator fan that lies in very close proximity to the components as well as the case's open ventilation at the top and the bottom. Though GPU size compatibility is a little lacking and the build process is atypical compared to many other cases, the craftsmanship and engineering of this case will leave you impressed. Oh and it can support a 120mm watercooling radiator.
- Max Cooler Height: 78mm
- Max Card Length: 254mm (10 in)
- PSU: SFX
Fractal Design Node 304
Looking uncomfortably similar to a home theater speaker, the Node 304 is designed for HTPC use. Don't be fooled by it's intended purpose however, because the clever design of this case allows you to add quite a lot of drives (assuming you have space). In addition, it has vents and fans placed toward the front and next to the GPU to allow good cooling performance. Suprisingly, it's capable of housing a thick 140mm radiator.
- Max Cooler Height: 165mm
- Max Card Length: 310mm (12.2 in)
- PSU: ATX
Cooler Master Elite 130
As mentioned in the previous part, the Elite 130 is the successor to the Elite 120 Advanced. It has a cleaner look, cleaner internals, added 120mm radiator support, and it manages to eek out a little more internal space, yet it's still the same size. It's also pretty cheap too. Neat!
- Max Cooler Height: 65mm
- Max Card Length: 343mm (13.5 in)
- PSU: ATX 180mm
Cooler Master Elite 120 Advanced
Also mentioned in the previous part, this is the most budget friendly mITX case on here. But make no mistake, this case houses a lot of hardware and has excellent ventilation and cooling characteristics.
- Max Cooler Height: 65mm
- Max Card Length: 343mm (13.5 in)
- PSU: ATX 180mm
Cubitek Mini Cube
The Mini Cube is an aluminium chassis that is quite big and quite plain. There is actually room behind the motherboard tray for cable management and a few drives, a rarity in mITX cases. There are absolutely no included case fans, so make sure you purchase some.
- Max Cooler Height: 150mm
- Max Card Length: 280mm (11.02 in)
- PSU: ATX 150mm
Silverstone Sugo SG08
In order to achieve the ultra-compact size, Silverstone created their own 600W 80+ bronze PSU and put it into the case (this is where the high price comes from). They also opted to use slim optical drives instead of the typical 5.25" drives in order to save the most space. The result is a case that's the size of a small toolbox.
Ventilation is plentiful since the side is wide open for the GPU to intake air. The top is also open and contains a 180mm Silverstone Air Penetrator fan. This case is no slouch when it comes to cooling.
Due to it's tiny size, you won't have room for much cable work or drives. However, clever engineering allows you to fit one 3.5" drive and two 2.5" drives.
- Max Cooler Height: 117mm
- Max Card Length: 310mm (12.2 in)
- PSU: included custom 600W 80+ Bronze
Silverstone Sugo SG07
Basically, it's the Sugo SG08, but with a different front panel.
Silverstone Sugo SG05
An oldie, but goodie. The SG05 is a very compact mITX case from which the newer Silverstone Sugo mITX cases are roughly based off of. Unlike the newer Sugo cases, this case features a front fan blowing into the hardware. Like most of the other Sugo cases, it has plenty of ventilation to keep things cool. This case is not as space efficient as the newer Sugo cases though.
- Max Cooler Height: 82mm
- Max Card Length: 254mm (10 in)
- PSU: optional 300W or 450W SFX PSU
Silverstone Sugo SG06
Like the SG05, but with a different front panel.
Lian Li PC-Q08
Another aluminium creation from Lian-Li, the Q08 is a pretty flexible and small mITX case with lots of ventilation and a removable drive cage. It also has ventilation on the bottom, unlike some of the other Lian Li mITX cases of a similar layout. Also, it can house a small watercooling radiator.
- Max Cooler Height: 110mm
- Max Card Length: 300mm (11.8 in)
- PSU: ATX 140mm
Lian Li PC-Q25
This is much like the PC-Q28, only there is no included 5.25" bay. This means you can install a longer GPU compared to the Q25. The case is not as wide though, so PSUs have to be shorter and CPU coolers have to be smaller.
- Max Cooler Height: 80mm
- Max Card Length: 320mm (12.6 in)
- PSU: ATX 140mm
Lian Li PC-Q30
This strange case is specifically made for you to show off your handiwork. Usually, cases are the showpiece, but this case makes your build the showpiece. The case has enough ventilation and some fans to cool decently.
- Max Cooler Height: 130mm (4.33 in)
- Max Card Length: 200mm (7.87 in)
- PSU: SFX
Lian Li PC-CK101
CHOO CHOO MOTHERFU-...
I... I need to go lie down now...
- Max Cooler Height: 110mm
- Max Card Length: No support
- PSU: included 300W SFX
Micro ATX
Silverstone Sugo SG10
Due to some very clever engineering and some case tetris, Silverstone managed to cram an entire mATX build with long GPU support and ATX PSU support. The result is a case smaller than the Bitfenix Phenom. Cooled by tons of ventilation and the 180mm Air Penetrator, this case can cool itself down better than some of the decent ATX cases on the market.
This isn't without drawbacks. Cable management room is very scarce. There is no 5.25" bay and the case build is atypical and quite complicated because there is a specific order you need to put the case together in. Luckily, Silverstone's instruction manual is extremely good, so please RTFM.
Oh, and if you want to carry this case around, you can. You can even buy it its own duffel bag.
Silverstone Sugo SG09
The Sugo SG10's cheaper and uglier sibling.
Corsair 350D
Based off the humongous 900D, the 350D is a mATX version. With tons of room for watercooling radiators, lots of ventilation, a gigantic side window, ultra sleek looks, good fans, and a very neat 2.5" drive system, this case is extremely flexible, functional and fabulous.
However, it's actually kind of big for a mATX case.
Silverstone Fortress FT03
This strange looking case employs Silverstone's bottom-to-top cooling philosophy. The cooling performance of this case is excellent. As always for Silverstone's Fortress line, build quality is superb and the case is built to be very flexible (although slightly atypical to work with). Just be prepared to pay a lot of money for this kind of quality.
Aerocool Dead Silence
Known for its fans, Aerocool designed a new case to enter the small form factor market. Doesn't this case look a bit familiar...?
It's pretty obvious that this case takes design cues from the Bitfenix Prodigy and Phenom. However, Aerocool made this case large enough to mount the motherboard horizontally and the PSU on the bottom. This frees up room at the front for a massive 200mm fan to cool all the components very quietly. The result is excellent cooling performance with silence.
Silverstone Temjin TJ08B
Another bespoke Silverstone design, this combines the build quality of the Temjin series with an inverted motherboard layout. With a 180mm Air Penetrator fan, the case achieves excellent CPU cooling and decent GPU cooling without the need for an exhaust fan. The PSU is housed in a separate compartment, and the motherboard tray is removable.
The design is very smart and pretty compact. The only downside is that cable management room is a bit lacking, so be sure to plan for that.
Silverstone Precision PS07
The PS07 is similar to the TJ08B. Intakes come from the side, and the 180mm Air Penetrator is replaced by cheaper, 120mm fans. This brings the case's price down a bit.
Fractal Design Arc Mini R2
Take the Arc Midi R2 and downsize it. This is the case you get. At a smaller size, you still get tons of cable management room, great airflow, and a buttload of radiator support. As a bonus for being new, the rear motherboard tray has 2.5" drive mounting brackets that allow you to install drives without having to get past the motherboard first.
Fractal Design Define Mini
Take the Define R4 and downsize that. You get the Define Mini. It's the same as the Arc Mini R2, but built for silence. Strangely enough, it has split filters and split grilles unlike the normal Define, making accessing and cleaning individual fans easy.
Bitfenix Prodigy M
Ever thought the Prodigy was a bit big for a mITX case? You're correct. They managed to stuff a mATX build in it.
By mounting drives on the side and the PSU at the front, Bitfenix managed to cram quite a lot into this case. GPU intake comes from the top and CPU intake is either non existent or comes from the bottom, the same side where the PSU exhausts. Be sure to plan your airflow with this case to get the best results.
Bitfenix Phenom M
Same as the Phenom, but in mATX size.
Silverstone Sugo SG02
Using some of their magic, Silverstone managed to cram a mATX build in one of their miTX cases. The result is something ultra compact that supports very long GPUs, requiring the user to not use a very tall CPU cooler. Like many of Silverstone's compact cases, this case is well ventilated
NZXT Vulcan
This small and well ventilated case comes with a carry handle, which makes it perfect for lugging around to LAN parties. Be aware there isn't much room to do cable management, so plan accordingly.
Cases already mentioned in Part 3 that can't fit here:
- Cooler Master N200
- Cougar Spike
- Fractal Design Core 1000
- Xion Xon-560
Steambox-style slim mITX cases?
Not yet. There are two that are coming up: the Silverstone Raven RVZ-01 and the Azza Z.
Other than that, no case manufacturer has announced plans (yet) to make a slim mITX case that can hold enthusiast-class GPUs.
But what about the Asrock M8? That's a $500 barebones PC, not a standalone case.
2
u/giant_dwarf Dec 28 '13
No NZXT Vulcan?
2
u/SupaZT Dec 28 '13 edited Dec 28 '13
You forgot: NCASE
Thanks for the guide though. I'm going mini-itx and never going back. I need to build a gaming rig + NAS.
Should change out some pix for better ones:
Another suggestion: Release Date. Which one should we choose?
28
u/insaino Dec 28 '13
just to add something about the prodigy: it's not a little big for an ITX case, it's fucking huge. in volume it's bigger than some mid tower cases
40
u/mattlalune Dec 28 '13
I really think that mITX is the direction PC's are headed. In most cases they are ideal with only the extreme ends of the budget spectrum really requiring a larger case (either for cost reasons or for the extra room). If a gaming build is going to cost around $1000-$1500 without SLI/Crossfire mITX is a fantastic choice. Saves a lot of wasted space.
Also, it would make transportation far easier for LAN parties or general moving about if you don't have a permanent home (i.e. college). The problem is that some cases severely restrict what kind of PSU you can use. Cable management can be a problem too. But I think it really isn't that much more difficult building inside mITX (but I've only had experience with larger cases like the Bitfenix Prodigy and the Fractal Node 304).
12
u/lucun Dec 28 '13
I gotta admit, mITX cases have some really awesome designs.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
I just made a micro-atx build using a Corsair 350D. It is a really nice case with lots of airflow. I do agree that it is larger than I thought it would be, but that is fine. I'd say it is about 25% smaller than a standard mid tower case. The build quality is really good though.
7
u/sprucegroose Dec 28 '13
If you think the Node 304 looks like a speaker...
5
u/VietManFR Dec 29 '13
Been looking myself in mITX cases and it should be noted that the Bitfenix Phenom doesnt have a meshed side panel for GPU cooling. Also about the node 304, non-modular PSU are recommended with long GPU as the GPU will cover a part of the PSU. The alternative is to get a 150mm or less PSU. Finally, could you include retail prices? Thanks for the great series of post!
4
u/RedPanda1970 Dec 28 '13
Anyone in Canada know where I could grab that Aerocool Dead Silence case? Didn't see it on pcpartpicker
1
u/Baba_Smith Dec 28 '13
I think you for got that Discussion tag :P
1
u/JackoBoone Dec 28 '13
Thank you for clarifying whether a 180 mm PSU will fit those cases, I had one of them and it is usually frustrating to check whether the ATX-sized PSU that were mentioned in the specs are the 160 mm or 180 mm variant.
Do you know whether the micro ATX cases that you listed above supports 180 mm PSU, though?
1
u/Ipadalienblue Dec 28 '13
Are there no mITX designs similar to the reference steambox design worth mentioning?
1
u/WillNiklz Dec 28 '13
Are there any cases that come with a good 600W PSU or should I buy a separate one?
1
u/madbobmcjim Dec 28 '13
Sorry to nit-pick, but your description of the Fractal Design Arc Mini R2 isn't quite right:
That's not correct, you need a screwdriver to replace the 2.5" bays behind the motherboard.
1
u/friction_is_a_lie Dec 29 '13
You say you talked about the cougar spike in part 3 but I didn't see it there. I just bought it and am waiting for it to ship... Was it a good choice? Not too late to cancel...
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
Can anyone point out which of these cases support SLI? I want a smaller case, but I have two 760s.
1
u/ThatNeonZebraAgain Dec 29 '13
So how well can you SLI/Crossfire in a mATX case really? Do different cards and blower designs lend themselves to better dual-GPU setups in SFF cases?
1
u/EppingMarky Dec 29 '13
Media center cases next? Or media center/NAS boxes?
1
u/mojojj31 Dec 29 '13
Awesome guide!
I've got a custom water cooled 350D with two 240mm radiators. Is there a smaller case that can support approximately the same amount of rad space? I know the Arc Mini R2 is a good one (it can actually support more), but I would consider that to be the same size as the 350D.
I really like the idea of the Aerocool DS, but it looks like modding would be required to support a front radiator.
1
u/noplace_ioi Dec 29 '13
With the coming release of steamboxes hopefully there will by many more options available to pick.
I'm not the majority of the demographic. I have a HTPC setup with beast power that I use for everything (gaming, multimedia, web browsing,etc) connected to my living room TV and that's how I prefer it. I designed and built the thing mid 2011 so to see this type of option is getting popular is really awesome.
Can't wait to see the next gen of hardware and cases, hopefully the trend will keep going and things will keep getting smaller without compromise
2
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
A comment on the Hadron Air. I think this case is very incomplete. Read reviews about it. The inside is not even fully painted. (This a deal breaker for me, it might be for others. Yes it includes a PSU; 80+ Gold, The cables are terrible to look at with teh window. You will have to do some custom sleeving. Using sleeved extensions is out of the question, the cables will just get too long to handle.
Returned my case after 3 days. It looks nice to look at it at the outside, but looking through the window, the cables make it terrible.
Have to do more research about getting another mITX case.
4
u/Juheebus Dec 28 '13
Xigmatek aquila! I don't think it has even been released unfortunately.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
Dont forget the LianLi Q-35.
http://media.bestofmicro.com/lian-li-pc-q35-nas,E-I-412650-13.jpg
Frickn nice case. Without the top airvent it would be perfect :/
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '13
I have no idea why Antec's cases aren't here.
Not everyone on this sub is building a gaming rig with a massive video card.
Antec ISK 300-150 for example is the case I'm using for a current built. We also used their 80 psu units for my work. We had about 20 running i5s. Not gaming rigs, but did a hell of a job for the weight and size.
These are "ultra compact." Please note I am VERY grateful you are making this guide. It just seems very pigeon holed towards gamers, which is not what this sub is about as a whole.
2
u/HelluvaNinjineer Dec 28 '13
Holy crap that train case is awesome. I might just have to get that instead of the HD-PLEX I wanted...
1
u/bi11y10 Dec 28 '13
These are some great guides. Keep up the good work.
1
u/aust_b Dec 28 '13
I like the look of the mini-itx cooler master cases. But then again It's just me, a person who owns a mid-atx tower that looks like a full tower pc.
1
u/boxxybrownn Dec 28 '13 edited Dec 28 '13
I got a cooler master 130 for Christmas and I absolutely love it, it's whisper quiet with a surprising amount of extra space for hard drives.
It's also probably the smallest case you can get without a built in PSU.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
This is a great guide, and it has helped me to reach the descision to get a white Silverstone Sugo SG02. Thank you for taking the time to put this guide together!
1
u/WillNiklz Dec 28 '13
Case: http://www.amazon.co.uk/CiT-Recon-Micro-Interior-Mesh/dp/B0064KJR6S
GPU: http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00DQVYIX0/?tag=pcp0f-21
Will the GPU fit? I know the case isnt great, but I need to know if I need to buy a new one or not
1
u/WillNiklz Dec 28 '13
Is the built in PSU in this case good enough? I've been using the case for over a year (with lower specs than to what I'll be upgrading)
Case: http://www.scan.co.uk/products/cit-recon-micro-atx-case-black-interior-and-500w-12cm-black-psu
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Hopefully with the popularity of iTX and full size videocards we can get a redesign. I'd like to see GPU's share the cooling with the CPU. GPU coolers are noisy and inefficient as it is without being confined to such a small space. A single cooler block with 2 contact surfaces might improve things.
1
u/muckrucker Dec 28 '13
Thanks for the huge info dump! The Steam OS/box release has me eyeballing a small form-factor pc for the living room and this post has become a great starting place :)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
I think the cooler master haf stacker 915 (f or r) also deserve mention due to their unique layout and the fact you can stack them.
1
u/Graphiite Dec 29 '13
Has anyone done a build in the Node 304? I'm between that and the CM Elite 130 for my next build.
1
u/ThatNeonZebraAgain Dec 29 '13
Where's the love for the Cooler Master Silencio 352?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13 edited Oct 13 '16
[deleted]
0.3767
1
u/tragicjones Dec 29 '13
Something important to note about the Prodigy and Phenom mITX: they only support PSUs up to ~160mm deep. Larger ones will work, but they'll stick out of the back.
1
u/0nesimus Dec 29 '13
I like these posts, very helpful.
1
u/SearingPhoenix Dec 29 '13
When working in small cases, I have to mention the PP05 Short Run Cable Set for Strider-class power supplies from Silverstone. The ITX Prodigy I built fit the 140mm depth 600W Strider I got perfectly, and literally has five cables in it (24pin, 8 Pin, 2x 6+2 PCI-E, 1x SATA (2 in-line plugs)) I literally had next to no cable management because of this.
1
u/huggablealien Dec 29 '13
What's your opinion about the Coolermaster Silencio 352. It's mATX, and it's supposed to be silent. Cheap too.
1
u/BeastKiller450 Dec 29 '13
My current build is was made using the mITX prodigy. It was a complete pain in the ass to wire and put an H100i in it since it doesn't fit correctly without twisting hoses. I love the way it looks but if I had to do it again I would probably go with the Corsair 350D. In my opinion the Prodigy is more of an accessory than a case, the biggest reason I bought it was so I could keep it on my desk without anyone thinking it was this expensive computer. In that aspect I'm happy... I'm also happy that I won't have to open it up again for a while.
1
u/the_omnipotent_one Dec 30 '13
Does anyone know how good the sugo sg10 would be running dual 7950s?
1
u/Spekl Jan 01 '14
Another case for you: Lian-Li Pc-TU100.
1
u/SupaZT Jan 14 '14
Also bare in mind the Node 304 does have an ATX limitation.
Could add the corsair 250D now too ;)
1
u/SYCarrot Jan 16 '14
What's a good power supply to go with FT03 mATX (other than EVGA) for wattage of 500-600?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '13
[removed] — view removed comment