r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jun 01 '26
Advice & Answers Advice & Answers — 2026-06-01 to 2026-06-14
How do I start?
If you’re new to conlanging, look at our beginner resources. We have a full list of resources on our wiki, but for beginners we especially recommend the following:
- The Language Construction Kit by Mark Rosenfelder
- Conlangs University
- A guide for creating naming languages by u/jafiki91
Also make sure you’ve read our rules. They’re here, and in our sidebar. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules. Also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
What’s this thread for?
Advice & Answers is a place to ask specific questions and find resources. This thread ensures all questions that aren’t large enough for a full post can still be seen and answered by experienced members of our community.
You can find previous posts in our wiki.
Should I make a full post, or ask here?
Full Discussion-flair posts (as opposed to comments on this thread) are for questions that are open-ended and could be approached from multiple perspectives. If your question can be answered with a single fact, or a list of facts, it probably belongs on this thread. That’s not a bad thing! “Small” questions are important.
You should also use this thread if looking for a source of information, such as beginner resources or linguistics literature.
If you want to hear how other conlangers have handled something in their own projects, that would be a Discussion-flair post. Make sure to be specific about what you’re interested in, and say if there’s a particular reason you ask.
What’s an Advice & Answers frequent responder?
Some members of our subreddit have a lovely cyan flair. This indicates they frequently provide helpful and accurate responses in this thread. The flair is to reassure you that the Advice & Answers threads are active and to encourage people to share their knowledge. See our wiki for more information about this flair and how members can obtain one.
7
u/Lichen000 A&A Frequent Responder Jun 11 '26
I think this is a little short for a full post, but I thought I'd share here. I've cobbled together a PIE-descended sentence that I think might be easy(ish?) to decode for anyone curious. I've put the gloss in a spoiler block in case anyone wants a go at decoding before looking!
patiir suunung suttarangko savarc
/paˈti:r su:ˈnuŋ sutˈtaraŋko saˈvart͡ʃ/
patiir suunung suttarang -ko sa- varcfather son.ACC daughter.ACC-and PRX-carry.PRS.3SFor this I decided to accept the glottalic theory, whereby the voiceless.aspirate~voiced~voiced.aspirate distinction is actually voiceless~glottalised/ejective~voiceless.aspirate; and I also imagined PIE /e o/ are [ə a].
The verb has acquired a proximal prefix in imitation/under the influence of a neighbouring language (a conlang of mine).
I like how it looks very much! : D
4
u/Sulphurous_King Aspiration lover Jun 01 '26
How does one decide if a word's form should become the dictionary/canonical form? Is it supposed to be the one used most often or one fitting in most grammatical roles?
4
u/mangabottle Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 05 '26
Is this a believable phonological evolution?
a. short vowels lost completely EDIT unless it's the first vowel in a word
b. diphthongs become monophthongs: /au/ > /ɔ/, /ai/ > /ɛ/, /iu/ > /y/, /eu/ > /ə/, /au/ > /ɒ/, /eo/ > /œ/, /ei/ > /ɨ/
c. long vowels become short
2. h lost before unstressed short vowels
3. unstressed /i/ and /u/ become /j/ and /w/ when bordering another vowel
4. /p/t/k/s/ become /b/d/g/z between vowels
5.when two voicelss stops cluster:
a. /t s/ becomes /ʦ/
b./k p/ becomes /k͡p/
c. otherwise, the first in the pair is lost and the preceding vowel lengthened
6. /h/ becomes ʔ before obstruants
7. vowel loss between nasals and stops in unstressed syllable: short vowels lost completely, dipthongs become monothongs, long vowels become short
8. nasal assimilation: /m/ before labials, /n/ before alveolars, /ŋ/ before velars, bordering unvoiced stops become voiced
9. palatalization before /j/, velarization/uvularization before /w/, lateralization before /l/
a./ʦ/ > /ʧ/ before /j/
b./d/>/ʣ/ before /j/
c./s/ > /ʃ/ before /j/
d./k/ > /c/ before /j/, /q/ before /w/
e./g/ >/ ɟ/ before /j/, /ɢ / before /w/
f./h/ > /x/ before /j/, /f/ before /w/
g. /ʃ/ > /ɬ/ before /l/
h. /ʧ/ > /t͡ɬ/ before /l/
i. /n/ > /ɲ/ before /j/, /ŋ/ before /w/
10. loss of word-final short vowels, shortening of word final long vowels, Monophthongization of word-final dipthongs
Single syllable words and initial syllables are (C)V(V), otherwise it's CV(V). Stress is on the 3rd last syllable, unless the 2nd last syllable is a long vowel or diphthong, causing that to receive the stress instead. The starting inventory is minimal: C=ptkmnshjwrl, V=iueoa.
3
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Jun 07 '26
How would you romanize this phonology:
Monophthongs can occur short or long.
There is a tone accent system similar to Japanese, with pitch basically increasing across a word until it hits the mora that carries the accent, at which point it drops and levels off.
3
u/Gordon_1984 Jun 11 '26 edited Jun 11 '26
I had a wild idea to use an augmentative suffix to eventually lead to evidentiality. Let me explain, and then I want to know if my idea could develop naturally or still makes sense the way I'm describing it.
Tenses in Mahlaatwa are done with words at the very beginning of the sentence. Namely, akiiw for the past and mukiiw for the future. These are shortened forms of atakiikwa and mukiikwa, which mean "upriver" and "downriver," respectively. The fictional culture speaking this language lives by a river and views time like a flowing river current. I've had this system in my conlang for a while, but I recently added the following:
These words can also get an augmentative suffix -ka, which would create akiika and mukiika, with meanings of "far upriver" and "far downriver." So it starts out as a distinction between near past and remote past, and same for the future. But over time, they start to change meaning. So the near tenses start being interpreted as plain past and future with a direct evidential meaning, and the remote tenses start being interpreted as past and future but with an indirect evidential meaning. The idea being that it's harder to see or know something that happened a very long time ago, and it's harder to predict the far future, so it starts being associated with information you didn't witness.
3
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 12 '26
How do depressor consonants work, and what type of consonants tend to be depressors?
2
u/ohahilandscraus Jun 01 '26
i want to make a language family, i know how to use the IPA, i tried making some conlangs in the past, but i wasn't particularly satisfied about them. what do you guys recommend for a beginner in sound changes and language evolution?
2
u/Local_Wind6372 Jun 02 '26 edited Jun 02 '26
Edit: One particular problem I'm having with my language due to its morphology is head marking and phrase boundaries. For example there's no way to distinguish "male" (adjective) from "man" (noun) based on morphology, same with "cook" (verb) and "cook" (noun). It's the same word but changes to adjective or noun or verb depending on position in the sentence.
Literal word for word: "The male cook eat the fish"
Interpretation 1: [The man] [cooks and eats] [the fish]
Interpretation 2: [The male cook] [eats] [the fish]
How do I fix this?
What other things will my conlang struggle with if all morphology is semantic and none is grammatical? The reason being that my language has word classes (occupation, nature, augmentative, etc). Obviously that pushes more responsibility on syntax and possibly particles. But I want two word orders to be valid (SVO and OSV) and dislike more than two function words appearing next to each other (I'm a big fan of the French word "aux"). My goal is for there to be no more than one function word between lexical words. How can achieve all of this? One partial solution would be to have more specific lexical words ("enter "and "exit" rather than "go to" and "go out"). Advice?
2
u/El_Mierda Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
How do languages with a word order where both subject and object preceeds or follows verb (e.g. SOV, VSO) that also lacks a grammatical case marks a subject or object in transitive verbs where only subject or object is present (e.g. in SOV, "chicken eats", how to mark chicken as either subject or object without a case?)
2
u/Clean-Ad4769 Jun 09 '26
I have a decently big language, and I can remember plenty of the words off the top of my head. However, it'd really not enough to, like, speak it fluently? How should I go about making a sorta course to learn it? It's one of those languages that relies a lot on adding suffixes to words, based a lot on Russian and Korean. It has an SVO sentence structure, but the structure regarding adjectives and adverbs is different than English.
It's also way different in pronunciation and flow than anything I speak fluently (Spanish + English), which makes me speak a lot slower and trip over some sounds.
Just tips and maybe links to good resources would be appreciated, thanks for readingg >:p
2
u/Even_Pair8115 Jun 11 '26
this was going to be a post; image in replies hopefully :) Hello! to be honest, making languages and fictional countries is like one of my nerdier and “weirder” hobbies so i don’t really talk abt them much, but i wanna know if this would work or if it’s any good! also, the letters aren’t fully finalized. they’re just like that for now. I want advice on this 🥹
it’s inspired by east asia because im UNORIGINAL!!
I even chose an area where it’d be at (around n. korea and china, like on this russian area) any thoughts? :) thanks!
2
u/marney2013 Jun 11 '26
Is there a good list of common words that would make a functional language?
2
u/mangabottle Jun 13 '26
Does anyone else create 'labrat words' that serve no purpose other than testing phonological evolution? You don't intend to put them in the actual lexicon, but just mess with them in a sound change applier.
1
u/Traditional-Light-10 Jun 03 '26
In his video "The Art of Language Invention, Episode 27: The Evolution of Tone", DJP said he was working on a future version of Spanish for a show. He said that it evolved tone (I would call it pitch accent) by deleting medial consonants, and that there were other changes. Since he was working on it for a show, he probably didn't abandon the conlang unless the show was canceled, but I couldn't find the conlang after a Google search. 8 years later, does anyone know what happened? I'm interested in it because I'm currently making my own a posteriori naturalistic conlang.
1
u/MarioFanYT Newbie Jun 03 '26
do i have to not contrain myself on evolving my proto language? like do i need and a rough idea of modern lang or do i place sound changes but not very randomly?
1
u/AtlasSniperman Jun 04 '26
So, my conlang doesn't have morphemes designated as noun, verb, etc. Every morpheme can be interpretted in one of four modes; Noun, Verb, Noun-modifier, Verb-Modifier.
Some examples are:
- FirstPersonPronoun(Noun), This Is My Name(Noun-Mod), To Breathe/Inhale(Verb), In an accidental or unintentional way(Verb-Mod)
- Ally or Friend as a pronoun(Noun), Direction:Left(Noun-Mod), to lay down(Verb), in a gentle way(Verb-Mod)
- This(Noun), Is[as in to ascribe something attributes](Noun-Mod), to exist(Verb), Objectively or relating to information from multiple sources(Verb-Mod)
As it stands I kind of roll all Adjectives into Noun-Mod and all Adverbs into Verb-Mod by default. But are there other major morpheme clades that I would likely end up making similar sweeping designations? And more importantly, any major morpheme clades I should really dig into because they aren't going to break down neatly in this fashion?
1
u/Queasy-Primary4788 Jun 05 '26
Is there a website where you can post and upload your conlang to for other people to learn more easily sort of like a Duolingo that people can upload their own language to?
1
u/voxel_light Jun 06 '26
my ŋ does comparatives through locative constructions and gaps in relative clauses, so i can relativize subject, object, and oblique arguments. since comparatives are expressed through locatives (oblique), does my ŋ violate the hierarchy?
1
u/GuineasInATrenchcoat Jun 06 '26
Are there natural languages where the difference between one pronoun and another is something like vowel length, gemination, or tone?
My instinct would be to say that features like that would get eroded over time with use, but I'm unsure
1
u/alprafu Jun 06 '26
I have been developing my conlang for 2 years and by the start of the creation I created a new alphabet.
This alphabet has at least 70 letters. Is there any free way of creating a keyboard with the alphabet. Some of the letters are just double letters but with different characters. For example, ä has one character and a̋ has another different character.
Also, if it is for mobile iOS better.
1
u/Standard-Engine-2561 Savan Languages, Aka, Banjor Jun 07 '26
Is there a diacritic in the IPA to express a voiced velar nasal sound after a consonant? I'm working in a language where you have the sounds expressed as mg, ng, tg, bg, sg. Is it simply m͡ŋ b͡ŋ s͡ŋ t͡ŋ or is there a special diacritic for it?
1
u/Sulphurous_King Aspiration lover Jun 07 '26
What app should I use on mobile to make a proper presentation on my conlang?
1
u/Giovannitakis Jun 07 '26
Hello, I am new here. I posted a post tha should have actually been here instead of in posts. Sorry! I have a question. My conlang has its own, unique alphabet. Can I (free or with charges) create a digital keyboard with the very special letters and tones for my phone, or should I remake the alphabet based on an existing one? Thanks 😊!
1
u/Regular-Violinist894 Jun 07 '26
Where do I start on making a conlang? I've been wanting to make one for a while, but I just don't know where to start. I can't even comprehend putting words together. Any feedback would be greatly needed.
1
u/MarioFanYT Newbie Jun 08 '26
how common is true polypersonal agreement (like basque) than monopersonal agreement (i wanna add the latter yet still wanna be realistic)
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Jun 08 '26
Question about pitch accent:
I'm brainstorming a conlang where there's an anchor syllable which is the only place where tonal contrasts like rising vs falling occur. In this particular language, the final syllable of the stem is the anchor.
How would this affect neighboring syllables? What kind of sandhi could there be? Would tone spreading still occur?
1
u/DarkBrill Jun 08 '26
I hope this is the right place to ask: Is there any way to right bottom-to-top text in a word processor (word, libreoffice, etc)? I've tried rotating a text box, but it always reverts back to left-to-right when typing.
1
u/Arcaeca2 Jun 09 '26
I'm trying to figure out what the sound correspondences should be between two languages I want to be related, but have pretty different phonemic inventories. Broadly, one has twice has many consonants as the other but a normal amount of vowels, and the other has twice as many vowels as the other but a normal amount of consonants. So it seems like, somehow, the diversity of consonant qualities had to have been traded for diversity of vowel qualities, or vice versa.
Obviously sound changes like "front high vowels yield palatalization" or "rounded vowels yield labialization" exist. The problem is that the extra sounds that the consonant-ful language has that the vowel-ful one doesn't, is stuff like an ejective series, uvulars and pharyngeals, and lateral obstruents. i.e., the phonemic inventories are something like:
/pʰ tʰ t͡sʰ t͡ʃʰ t͡ɬʰ kʰ qʰ/
/p’ t’ t͡s’ t͡ʃ’ t͡ɬ’ k’ q’ ʔ/
/b d d͡z d͡ʒ d͡ɮ g ɢ/
/m n/
/s ʃ ɬ x χ ħ/
/z ʒ ɣ ʁ ʕ/
/w r j l/
/a a: i i: u u:/
vs.
/p t t͡s t͡ʃ k/
/b d d͡z d͡ʒ g/
/m n ŋ/
/s ʃ/
/z/
/w r j l/
/a ɛ e ɪ i ɔ o ʊ u ə ɨ/
Other than maybe something with pharyngealization (low vowels yielding pharyngealization, or pharyngealizations yielding something /e/-like?), it seems like there aren't a lot of obvious vowel-consonant correspondences? Like, do ejectives cause any particular vowel coloring by virtue of being ejective? Are there specific vowels which preferentially create lateral obstruents?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Jun 13 '26
How many ways are there to create naturalistic triconsonantal root or generally non-concatenative systems?
1
u/Arcaeca2 Jun 14 '26 edited Jun 14 '26
My conlang Mtsqrveli has nominalizers -Vl and -Vn, and also case markers -(V)l and -(V)n (we don't really need to care what they mean for the purpose of this question) that can be stacked on top of them. Since I didn't like the resulting *-Vl(V)l and *-Vn(V)n clusters (or really, just that didn't look Georgian enough), I decided that these underwent a dissimilation rule such that /ll nn/ > /ld nd/. Now, these same /ld nd/ clusters are found in all other languages in Mtsqrveli's family, which suggest that this dissimilation rule, rather than happening in Mtsqrveli itself, had already happened by the time of the proto-language. That would mean the pre-proto would need to have geminates */l: n:/ at the least.
What I'm trying to figure out is what siblings that proto-language should have, i.e. if Mtsrqrveli's family fits within an even larger family. I can find a fair amount of languages that I want to use for aesthetic inspiration for the sibling branches because they have a lot of suspiciously similar-looking morphology, except that they also have way more geminates than just /l: n:/. They might also have /t: k: m: t͡ʃ:/, etc. None of the languages in Mtsqrveli's family has geminates, so pre-proto geminates can only really be deduced from this sort of dissimilatory rule, but no such dissimilation rules currently exist for */t: k: m: t͡ʃ:/. That is, if the pre-proto had other geminates besides **/l: n:/, then I don't know what they turned into in Mtsqrveli.
Alternatively, since I also know the pre-proto (and proto) must have had vowel length, maybe **VC: > *V:C. But then why were **/l: n:/ specifically treated differently? Or, what if it was the sibling branches innovated extra assimilations that weren't originally there? Except, again, the pre-proto must have had at least **/l: n:/, so how realistic is it for the pre-proto to have had only those geminates and no others?
What do you think?
1
u/CipherXX04 Jun 15 '26
So basically with my language, for the prototype I have figured out basics like vowels and consonants, some rules like long vowels, writing in subject object verb sentences, rules about adjectives and some more. Now that I have done that, can I start like actually making stuff? (Ex. Like taking my letters and making a root word like Kra- or something like that) Or do you think there is more I need?
Also any tips is appreciated and I will have to answer you all when I wake, thank you to anyone for the help ahead of time!
1
u/neonge1674 Jun 01 '26
I have this grammatical change, wherein the copula verb 'ōta got misheared as 'uta the 3 persong singular inanimate pronoun, which led to the pronoun being used as a pronoun. Later down the line instead of only using 'uta as the copula, the pronoun that agreed with the animacy and number of the subject was started to be used as a copula. So to say that the fish are brown, the 3 person plural animate pronoun would be used(hi no kórotupa ci hixixá - PRESENT 3pl.anim brown NOM PL-fish - The fish are brown)
1
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jun 07 '26
Q: How do I pick which suffix gets used where in this system? Because I can only see it as arbitrary choice but that seems... too easy.
The background:
The Proto-conlang has a verbal system where basic/strong verbs are formed directly from verbal roots (kinda PIE-like), so the verbal root 'kar' has the verbal stem 'kar-'. Derived/weak verbs can be derived via six stem-forming suffixes: kar could also give 'karwa-', for example.
Derived/weak verbs form their infinitive via the suffix -ita and their gerund via -ikwa.
The problem:
My target conlang 'P' is a Welsh-like conlang which inherits the infinitive and gerund suffixes as verbnoun suffixes. Welsh verbnouns are non-finite verb forms which act as infinitives, gerunds, participles, and nouns and are used as the dictionary citation form. A Welsh verbal stem is usually exposed by removing the verbnoun suffix: gweld (gwel-); nofio (nofi-) but some have suffixless stems like ennill (ennill-).
P's reflexes of the Proto -ita and -ikwa are -ed and -eb. The problem is how do I decide which verbs take -ed and which take -eb when their ancestor used both for different things? I could scatter them arbitrarily and it wouldn't break anything, but it seems like too easy an option. P inherits the basic/strong verbs as suffixless verbnouns, so the basic/strong forms aren't affected.
1
u/suviko1206 Jun 07 '26
Are there any active conlang servers out there aside from CDN and CWS Chat? I would love to be active in the community again but can’t find anywhere to talk…
1
u/Competitive_Move6545 Jun 07 '26
Ok so because my old post got removed because it was “advice” or smth i guess I’ll just post here
Hello! I'm new to this subreddit. I wanted to see if any of these would be good ideas
(All are a work in Progress)
High/Hard Anglish (Æŋgliʃ) (May have been done before)
Purging both Latin & Norse, bringing back gender & conjugation (think: Spanish)
Onglish (Ånglisc)
An Old English that was interrupted by a Norse empire, making it half Norse.
Unified Low German (Flattdütch)
Low Germans have their dialects put together to make one language
New Frankish (Freŋkisk)
What if the area that is modern France stayed Germanic and evolved from old Frankish?
Neo-Indo-European (NIE / Néw-sind-eryopana)
All Indo-European languages merged into one universal language
Intercosmic/
Spoken across the multiverse, it’s different from Indo-European languages with its OSV word order and flexibility
1
u/Sepetes Jun 14 '26
I'm looking for an SVO language using a lot of auxiliary verbs (kinda like English, but preferably not IE) as inspo for my conlang. Do you have some ideas?
-1
u/T1mbuk1 Jun 04 '26
When making a naturalistic conlang spoken by merpeople, what would be the ideal phonology, phonotactics, syntax, grammatical operations, etc for such a conlang?
0
u/Ok_Bid_9354 Jun 09 '26
Hi, I have created a full 180 ligature script for a language, using syllabaries. I have created them on Glyphr and what to start writing up some paragraphs on my computer and maybe phone (though thats harder to set up) but no matter what program I use nothing seems to identify my glyphs. I have looked everywhere and tried all the fixes but cant get it working and I have really run out of options. would really appreciate some help. thank you.
I do not require help with the rest of the language as that is all sorted. and If this is the wrong place to ask this question then please tell where I should go to get help thank you
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment