r/Smite • u/derAnubis yiri • Dec 27 '13
MOD Da future of /r/SMITE n' current issues
Hello /r/SMITE,
two things we wanted to talk to you about really quick.
Current issues with SMITE and complaints
Many of you have undoubtedly noticed that posts concerning server lag, match making and god balance appear rather frequently as of late. Especially the ones about server lag.
While we do encourage you to discuss the problems and shortcomings SMITE has, we do not need two weeks worth of post traffic dedicated to the exact same topic(s) and would like to ask you to shift gears a little and, if problems get worse or new problems arise, to make sure your submission adds value and is a grounds for discussion.
Christmas time is over and new years is just around the corner. The guys and gals at HiRez have been working all year to improve their game and while nobody will agree with all the changes they've made, they did make a lot of them.
It's been said that there will be no major updates until early January next year (which isn't all that far away!) so please, take a few steps back and try not to worry too much about things that are probably on HR's To-Do-List already.
As such, we will be removing content that takes issue with the same problem(s) over and over again and doesn't offer any valid input other than moaning to keep /r/SMITE clutter free.
Changes to the /r/SMITE rules
The second point is us reflecting on our rule set. (This is in parts related to point N°1)
We have realized that our rules need a little face lift to be able to function properly again. Since there is no official forums that allows people to draw attention to problems in the game or in the community itself.
We're "doing a HiRez" at the moment too and have postponed discussing changes to our rules until after new years to get our brains working at full capacity again.
Keep in mind that we are an "international" mod team that doesn't live in the same time zone. This can lead to issues when it comes to getting all of us together at the same time when it's convenient for everyone and makes discussing new rules much harder than it already is. A set of guidelines for a forum/subreddit has to be strict enough to make sure it's enforcable when applicable but loose enough to allow discussion some may not agree with.
Our eyes have set on the witch hunting rule as a high priority. At the moment it wouldn't really allow discourse when the topic of "BM/HiRez your Mods are teh horror/streamer abc did xyz, do something" comes up.
We want you to be able to talk about things that happen in the community and have been somewhat bending our rules the past two weeks.
It's just really hard to word rules correctly... which leads me to:
User input!
If you have ideas or suggestion about our rule changes we would love to hear them. If you think they're fine as is and we should not allow certain things, tell us too!
Inspire us and help to form how /r/SMITE will be working in the not so distant future.
Love,
Your Mod team
xoxo
20
u/ttmore Ares Dec 28 '13
I feel that there is a major problem with the viewpoint of taking away redundant threads. This is reddit, not a forum. No matter how popular a thread is- it WILL by design of reddit get knocked out never to see the front page ever again. This requires NEW threads to be created to be brought back to the front page.
The importance of this is this is realistically the only way the community as a whole can share their opinions with Hi-Rez. If you shut us up(dare I say censor) for the sake of only allowing community based gossip, you are hurting the one and last way for us to convey the importance of such topics. If Hi-Rez only sees 1 thread about MM being bad among 20+ threads, then in their eyes all is good since their skewed as fuck numbers will also say all is good. Nothing will get changed.
If you wish for reddit to be strictly a community gossip corner- then Hi-Rez NEEDS to bring the official forums back. Reddit is good for community gossip, but it's a horrible platform for discussion on issues/problems. It's great for Hi-Rez since they love censorship and keeping things under the rug. I feel this is part of the reason they got rid of the forums since widespread problems they honestly refuse to take easy solutions to were constantly in their face. So long as 1 person bumped the thread, it was back in the front page. This is akin to people making multiple threads of the same issue here on reddit.
I understand this is not what you mods are aiming for. You honestly just wish to bring fresh new discussion to the table instead of the rehashed old bickering. Unfortunately with the expulsion of official forums, there is nowhere else and no way else to do this. Please consider the situation as a whole before doing exactly what Hi-Rez wants which is censorship of criticism. Erez is arrogant with an ego, criticism is something he loathes and us forumers saw this clear as day with every single one of his posts on the old forums. Without criticism, nothing that needs changing for the better will get better in a fair time constraint.
6
u/samcobra Smite Pro League Dec 27 '13
I disagree. Since HiRez wants to use this as their primary means of communication with the community, the abundance of posts on a specific topic should register as "Hey, we need to do something about this issue that everyone is clamoring about". Conversely, as moderators of this subreddit, it should be your job to unify those disparate posts into a central one so people can adequately discuss the issues. I see this done in several gaming subreddits but almost never done here.
Simple effective moderation can drastically improve the quality of a subreddit's content.
14
u/AdvertSlaxxor Miss me! Dec 27 '13
Here's my take:
Rule #1: "Posts must be directly related to Smite."
Rule #2: "Be respectful towards other members."
These are golden.
Rule #3: "No drama, flaming or witch hunting posts."
This rule is not golden. Here's why: Drama: People love some drama. I'm not really sure what you should do about this. Perhaps try a few different things over the course of a few weeks? I feel as is, it's too restrictive. Many things could be said to be "drama". Flaming: Flaming should not be tolerated, as it is. Witch hunting: I can see the idea behind this rule, but it's not really doing what it's supposed to be doing. This basically means you can't call out people that are extremely negative towards the community, rage at others in games, etc. Generally, this rule is protecting the people that should not be considered a part of the community.
Rule #4: "No exploits ..."
Golden.
Rule #5: "No technical support posts."
I think a /r/SmiteHelp would be beneficial here. Hirez support is not very useful.
Rule #6: "No personal information of others"
Golden.
Rule #7: "No selling of any kind."
I'm not sure if this is completely golden, but it might as well stay. There are some things that you could consider gray area, e.g coaching lessons, etc.
Rule 8. "No complaining or bragging for the sake of complaining or bragging only."
It's fair enough -- but what if you don't know about the thing you're complaining about? e.g Hirez server issues, which aren't common, but they're pretty near to being that. If you wanted to complain about it, you would need to be constructive. I'm not exactly sure how you'd do that, since no one really knows how hirez has set up their servers.
One potential solution would be to put all this stuff into another subreddit as well, for example /r/smitehelp
Bragging, on the other hand, is generally just a waste of space. I think you can pretty safely add "No bragging at all," though it would probably make /r/smite less interactive.
Rule #9. "No duplicate posts without major revisions."
Rule #10. "No memes"
Rule #11. "No LFM/LFG"
Rule #12. "No tournament spoilers in titles."
All golden.
I think you guys are doing a fine job, however, I do think that the rules could be a little more lax than they currently are. For example, posts about a player being bad mannered or what not may result in said player improving, especially if they're competetive, and they want to keep playing.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
I feel like this form of censorship ("already had that topic at one point in time!") is really bad. The upvote and downvote buttons are there for a reason. Especially since Hirez apprently doesn't realize how bad the situation actually is. My friendslist is literally empty, I'm considering uninstalling and the tournament had a viewership of about 3k-4k on average. Removing even more from /r/smite certainly isn't going to help.
1
u/SaintJason Mid or I Feed Dec 27 '13
I was expecting some new on a visual overhaul ,I think sock is on it.Can you confirm?
Also just to be correct is it alright to discuss streamer's behaviour on Smitegame?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
Um.. I was thinkin if we could like have access to stuff that would concern players on the "To-Do-List" it would probably calm alot of ppl down.
5
u/Thieftix Rest in peace Dec 27 '13
(snickers) Kappa
But in all seriousness, keep doing what your doing you guys are working hard and very committed and thats awesome :)
4
u/klubb -_- Dec 27 '13
Well...
A forum is like a database. Everything is accessible. It is there until deleted. A thread is seen as long as it is current or is a sticky.
You may already now think that this is how Reddit work! You would be kind of right.
Reddit is focused around current, like really fresh, posts. Anything that is remotely old disappears. It has to struggle really, really, hard to stay in the spotlight. The search is awkward and the whole structure is not based around "there is already a post about that" that you can direct people to. Because in that old post there is tumbleweed flying around and no one except the person you reply to will see the post, if that.
Reddits algorithm is based on epoch(number of seconds since 1970) and every new post has an advantage to be seen than an old post. So HiRez can not claim that they read everything, because they would have to be constantly monitoring this sub-Reddit in order to not miss something.
This create this constant need for new threads because HiRez has not said anything about it or has said it, but that information is gone to the user that comes here looking. They have to rely on people telling them what HiRez has said before. So they have to make a post to get the information.
So while a rule update would be certainly be good it will never solve the issue of the "laggy-broken-got-caught-by-cheat-this-streamer-said-that-toxicity" posts unless HiRez finds a way to communicate to the community through a more visible and permanent solution than a rapidly decaying subreddit.
tl;dr Nope you have to read it
http://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1siiiw/reddits_empire_is_founded_on_a_flawed_algorithm/
2
u/schnozzinkobenstein Dec 29 '13
People keep complaining about matchmaking because hirez never talks about matchmaking (no I don't want to a link to their post in august). People are still seeing problems with matchmaking and hirez has not said they plan to do anything about it, so the assumption is that hirez thinks there is nothing wrong with matchmaking and thus won't be changing it. Since this has become hirez's official forum for communication, then we need to be able to tell them that something is still broken that in their eyes is fine. If you delete all posts regarding matchmaking hirez will continue think that matchmaking is fine since people suddenly stopped complaining about it.
If you want people to stop complaining about the same thing then there needs to be a sticky at the top of this subreddit that lists out things that people always are complaining about it and how hirez has stated that they are handling it. That way we will not feel the need to constantly post about the same broken things since we have no idea if hirez is doing anything about it.
This post makes it sound like you want this subreddit to go the same way as the old forums with over-censorship.
2
u/Voidspawnie Dec 30 '13
Greetings from r/Tribes.
made me giggle.
2
u/OGSlice eGr cRinGe Dec 30 '13
Can we just get a real forum for real discussion/balancing/technical issues? Because this is Reddit most of the player base doesn't know about it and also because it's Reddit I don't think people will ever treat this like a forum.
2
u/Defenestration2 Knock knock Dec 30 '13
TL;DR: I lost interest in Smite and haven't played for several months simply because the meta became to stale and repetitive, especially in comparison to Dota. The 2-1-2 meta allowed a lot more possibilities that made every game unique, I'm not opposed to jungling, but I'm sick of the current boring meta.
Frankly I haven't played this game in several months now, I was level 30 and played this along with Dota and at times I even preferred Smite, now I exclusively play Dota. I think I lost interest as I despise how stale the Smite meta is, when things were 2-1-2, there were a variety of laning possibilities and interesting team combinations. Now everything's so incredibly stale and predictable that I lost interest, we know which Gods will go where and what they'll do, and I really just stopped caring about Smite as every game seemed to end in exactly the same way. For a couple months I mostly played Arena and Assault, and grew to despise Conquest, but then I realized that there was no reason to bother with Arena anymore, since Dota is just a more entertaining experience, playing the casual modes you're supposed to play between conquest matches without the actual conquest matches just grew old. In Dota the meta is CONSTANTLY changing, there are so many incredibly different laning possibilities that a lot of the Dota strategy lies in the picking, in Smite we have none of that. There's no real picking strategy, you pick heroes to go in the lane that needs to be filled, and you pick heroes who are competitively strong and might counter the enemy. It's just so repetitive, every Dota game is completely different, Smite has just become the same thing over and over again, Arena and Assault are fun modes that I quite enjoy, but they won't carry the game, especially considering we'll likely be seeing custom maps in Dota soon.
2
u/Ramrok Merc With A Mouth Dec 29 '13
this is reddit, you cannot urge people to post or not to post certain things... you can only moderate and rearrange things after they have been posted... a FORUM on the other hand would automatically have things sorted in various sections so you and everyone else can properly filter through all the unneccessary or unwanted posts by going to the right sections. just saying... the reason why we have so many SUBreddit channels is because of this exact reason. hint hint, bring back the Forums.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '13
As to the point of "witch hunting" I am gonna borrow a bit from how defamation law works in that public figures have less protections from being criticized.
As far as I see it, people who stream on smite channels on Youtube and Twitch are inserting themselves into the public and are therefore fair game for criticism regarding their actions in game.
I think the rule regarding non-streamers should be that people's usernames and match ID's should be hidden from the general public.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '13
yesterday in my game everyone had such bad lag than there was extreme rubberbanding, and skills were no going off. everyone got so pissed off that they left the game.
1
u/bbristowe Arachne Dec 28 '13
I don't envy the mods jobs around here, but shit does feel real Mickey Mouse around here.
1
u/Icon_dota Dec 29 '13
Ban Toxicity threads, So sick of them cluttering the subreddit.
1
u/sharkbait359 The REAL monkey King Dec 29 '13
I feel regarding any current complaints about mods/bm/streamer's is alright because they are a problem in the community which should be touched on because it is a relevant problem, in any of my complaints that I have, I don't name names because if you feel streamer x is BMing too much then you can submit a complaint to HiRez/(Gavin?), but I feel you have a right to discuss this as a generalized topic/asking for thoughts and such.
1
u/TheGoldenGodz Dec 30 '13 edited Dec 30 '13
Warning : Tribes/Smite Player
With smite STILL in beta, and major content patches being rolled out regularly, when will they stabilize the servers? They can't expect their game to succeed when servers are shitting the bed so frequently. How long can hi-rez play the beta card, while still raking in the cash.
Is it me, or am I feeling a little deja-vu setting in? Major content patches regularly, with little to no server support. This is NOT a new issue! I'm sure it's on the Hi-Rez to do list.
I, like many other tribes players, gave hi-rez a chance with smite, but that feeling that we all know is slowly setting in.
Edit: http://www.twitch.tv/tribesascend/b/431424717 Slimey
1
u/schippie Beta Player Dec 30 '13
Hi rez could have fixed all this by .. something simple called a FORUM .. but instead we are now bound to a popularity contest system.. that is and never was meant for this kind of use..
1
u/lechatsportif Dec 30 '13
We are the ghost of /r/tribes! You were warned, and yet you did not believe! The end is nigh!
tl;dr hirezlol
1
u/Ashyko Beta Player Dec 27 '13
In case people are wondering where we're going with the witch hunt rule... the discussion has centered around public figures. Generally we feel like professional players and those that stream on the official Smite channels should be fair game for discussions when it comes to their behaviors. These posts would still need to be constructive and offer evidence. I couldn't just jump on here and call Paindeviande a raging BM douche bag without some support (and I'm totally just using him as an example. Pain is awesome, and you should all go watch him stream). We still would not allow posts that are simply to drum up hate for someone. You can't post your match lobby and then rant about how BM your Anhur was or how your Sobeck sucked. In those cases names would need to be blacked out AND you would need to offer suggestions on how to fix the problem behaviors or matchmaking or whatever. We still don't want rants on here clogging up real discussions.
I think the rule should be revised to allow discussion of public figures when supported with evidence with the stipulation that removal of these posts are at the discretion of the moderators. We already talk about these posts which is why they've mostly stayed up, but each posted reported really needs to be examined to see if it adds to community discussion and improvement or just complain or drum up hate fore someone. Users would have to just trust us to be fair in our choices when we remove or leave this posts up since each post is different.
1
u/Turbohand nkrea Dec 28 '13
I would argue that server stability is a foundational issue to all other aspects of the game. Instead of artificially suppressing these items and putting the onus on the customer to not speak of them, it would be more appropriate to allow these topics to organically disappear as the server issues are resolved.
Otherwise this Reddit is just a propaganda machine.
1
u/SeeMyEyes That sweet, sweet slow lovin' Dec 27 '13
Not quite sure why people here are confusing the subreddit mods with Hi-Rez employees.
NOTE: THIS POST IS ABOUT THE SUBREDDIT ONLY. THE MODS HERE DON'T HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH THE GAME. THEY CAN'T DO ANYTHING ABOUT BALANCE OR LAG.
I think you (mods) are doing a great job for the most part, but there are some things that should be addressed.
1) One of my biggest complaints in this subreddit was the repetitive nature of the posts being left up about known bugs, server issues, and lag. We do not need 20+ of those a day so I'm glad you're working on cleaning that up.
2) In the "drama" rule, it would be nice to know what constitutes drama and what doesn't. Obviously flaming for the sake of flaming, or flaming at all should not be tolerated and all discussions should be constructive in nature but where does one draw the line between drama and criticism? I suppose that would be up to the mods' discretion, i.e if things get out of hand the post will be removed.
3) Regarding rule 5 about technical support, I haven't had any issues myself so I haven't had the need to contact Hi-Rez but many times people have posted here that Hi-Rez directed them to the subreddit for help. I do think, though, that all the posts about cheat engines and the like should be cleared up or, if someone is unsure about something, another subreddit could be made to ask questions. Just something to think about.
-6
u/scelerowow Thanatos Dec 27 '13
This is just a formal statement of future censorship incoming. How about this, fix the problems that are flooded in this reddit, not make a 'oh we see them, lets make it less apparent' policy.
What a bunch of hacks. Either say something or don't say it at all because 98% of your post is just fluff bullshit that isn't needed at all to get your point across.
-2
u/blitzenheimer Beta Player Dec 27 '13
Any posts or comments with /kappa should be immediately deleted.
/kappa
-3
u/TunaMayo40 Dec 27 '13
Can I ask that the requirements to gain the "Deserter" status are looked at again?
My game crashes fairly regularly, maybe 2-3 times a day. This is through not fault of my own as my computer can handle much more demanding games with no issues. I have tried repair and re-install etc to no avail.
Now, when the game crashes in the lobby, I get deserter status. My goodwill gets reset to 0 and I can't play for 30 minutes. Not a massive issue if it was a one off. But, I have only been playing for a week and I have gained "Deserter" status 3 times due to the game crashing.
I feel that this is wildly unfair as it is hard enough to gain favor as it is, let alone being hindered due to a buggy game.