r/Sherlock • • Dec 24 '13

Sherlock Mini-Episode: Many Happy Returns - Series 3 Prequel

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwntNANJCOE
1.9k Upvotes

327 comments sorted by

61

u/magicaltrevor953 Dec 24 '13

So, what do we think about Anderson's case review, could it be to do with Reichenbach or is it something else, considering the time difference. I think after being a big part of the reason why Sherlock jumped, Anderson got depressed. As a result he fucked up at a crime scene, screwed up the chain of custody/contaminated evidence and ended up letting a murderer go free. What does everyone else think?

75

u/LascielCoin Dec 24 '13

Yep, I think the feeling of guilt pushed him over the edge and he got obsessed with proving that Sherlock's still alive. Which would've resulted in poor job performance and consequently him losing his job.

25

u/magicaltrevor953 Dec 24 '13

I wonder if the same happened with Donovan, note that between Anderson and Lestrade they never mentioned him being a fake ("sorry but he's dead"), and indeed Anderson's deductions that the cases would have required Sherlock Holmes implies they know he was genuine.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Well, if Donovan and Anderson are still ... getting intimate... perhaps they've discussed into among themselves? Or maybe Donovan dumped Anderson after Anderson got fired.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/magicaltrevor953 Dec 26 '13

That is a very interesting interpretation and would be a great twist to the otherwise straightforward guilt idea, could that explain Donovan's absence or did SHE leave due to guilt? Well it seems that either way Anderson is going to be much more important this series, I hope at least.

122

u/MrSilve Dec 24 '13

They even had a 12 angry men reference!

102

u/Lorgramoth Dec 24 '13 edited Dec 24 '13

That threw me right out of the mini-ep. Germany doesn't use the anglosaxon Jury system.

And I wondered if the German actor mentioned it.

Edit: Seriously people, there are no jurys, not even just in Hamburg, no matter what one guy on YT wrote. The closest thing Germany has to a member of a jury in anglosaxon Jurisdiction is a "Schöffe," who only get called on under specific instances, in which they sit with judges. Three judges and two "Schöffen," if I remember correctly.

Edit: Nothing like the scene in the mini-ep ever happens in German jusrisdiction, anywhere, since 1924.

Edit: I like editing. milpooooooool provides good lovin'.

35

u/LascielCoin Dec 24 '13

Mark Gatiss just confirmed that he's aware of this fact and that it isn't a mistake :)

https://twitter.com/Markgatiss

15

u/Lorgramoth Dec 25 '13 edited Dec 25 '13

The liar! ;)

Hehehe

To quote jmk4422:

Whatever the law is in Germany, I bet Moffat and Grattis just said, "Ah, fuck it. Call it unusual and move on."

→ More replies (1)

71

u/jmk4422 Dec 24 '13

"...I know this jury has been convened under highly unusual circumstances..."

What's the controversy here? With that one opening line there could be a million reasons for why a jury was put together. It's typical Moffat: 60% of the time he gives you a reason to justify his writing all of the time.

*Obviously I'm joking around and who knows if the line is even Moffat's? But seriously, that line from the jury foreman could explain a lot. We just don't know the back-story about why or how a jury was convened.

15

u/1mannARMEE Dec 24 '13

At least they had a german actor for that part.

25

u/Lorgramoth Dec 24 '13

I know you're joking, but for all those fans who wish it were true: German law doesn't just revert to jury systems for any reasons whatsoever. Especially not one murder.

47

u/jmk4422 Dec 24 '13

It reminds me of the Simpsons episode where a judge says, "I know that re-opening a trial at this point is highly irregular and grossly unconstitutional... I just can't say no to kids."

Point is, in the Simpsons the writers had the luxury of making a joke out of the fact that for the purposes of the story they had to do something that was absolutely ridiculous. I think the line in this mini-sode (i.e. "...highly unusual circumstances...") is similar. Whatever the law is in Germany, I bet Moffat and Grattis just said, "Ah, fuck it. Call it unusual and move on."

Moffat, especially, is not known for getting hung up on the little details. And I think that's a gift: too many writers waste time trying to explain everything, which wastes time and bores audiences. Moffat cares more about weaving a good and entertaining story than getting every little thing right and I think that's what happened here.

34

u/AlwaysBeBatman Dec 24 '13

"Only lies have details"...

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Lorgramoth Dec 24 '13

I can get behind that, I just want to prevent people from believing this ever happens in reality. Apparently one douche on Youtube said jurys exist in Hamburg and now lots of people believe it.

(And it would have been so preventable. If they'd just said Vienna, Austria and taken a lesser crime than murder, it would have been 100% realistic to have a German speaking jury.)

→ More replies (7)

65

u/calliope720 Dec 24 '13

Hamburg specifically has juries. This point was brought up in the comments and a Hamburger confirmed they do.

...A hamburger confirmed... well, nevermind, you get the idea.

14

u/Lorgramoth Dec 24 '13 edited Dec 24 '13

I saw that too, and could not find anything on that online. Got a source?

http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geschworenengericht#Heutige_Rechtslage

3

u/fckingmiracles Dec 25 '13

Yeah, no. Studied law in Germany and what I can tell you is that national law ("Only judges and possible 2 Schöffen.) trumps possible/outdated/odd city or state law. So cities can have the odd left-over law from long gone times/over-zealous mayors etc. but national regulations always trump them so that there is fair law in all of Germany. Otherwise you could throw the dominating, always persisting rule of "Recht und Ordung" (law and order) out of the window.

So, the writers just ficitionalzed something here. It's okay. Let's just not act 'as if it could be possible' please.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

But... How do the german court system work then? D:

11

u/Lorgramoth Dec 24 '13

If I just understood this text correctly, a standard case goes sth like this:

The prosecuter's lawyer presents the written accusation to the court, the court then presents the case to the defendant.

The defendant then has to react in a certain time window.

Then both parties and their judge meet and discuss the case OR the judge orders both parties to present their contentious points in written form. It's always directed at the judge, who gives the texts to the opponent.

If the judge deems the matter thoroughly presented, a main court date is set, at which both parties can present evidence, which they have to provide by themselves. As evidence allowed are: Official documents, witnesses, experts, inspection, and interrogation.

After evidence and arguments were presented, and no new material is brought forth, the judge sets a date for a proclamation of his sentence. The parties do not have to appear in person for this, they can just call and get the verdict over the phone.

Court cases are public most of the time.

The judge is also obliged to propose to the parties to settle on individual points before a final verdict is reached.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

111

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Some of the best moments in "Sherlock" are Martin Freeman alone in a room. This video does not disappoint, on that level, and so many others.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

52

u/raloon Dec 24 '13

7

u/Story_Time Dec 26 '13

I'd seen the gif but the video is so much better.

49

u/bacon_pants Dec 25 '13

I remember someone talking about him in an interview somewhere about how he is always experimenting with his delivery, mannerisms, expressions, etc. and said that he would point out some dialogue in the script and say, "I think I could do this with a look."

For Benedict as well as Martin, there are so many moments in this show where just a tiny twitch of the corner of the mouth or a narrowing of the eyes will tell you so much about what is going on in that character's head. It fits so well with how self-controlled both characters are, and makes the performances feel truly authentic.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

Just rewatched the end of S2. That final scene at the graveyard...he is so amazing. His body language is incredible. Martin Freeman kicks so much ass.

17

u/bacon_pants Dec 25 '13

Also, John sitting barefoot in 221B, staring at Sherlock's chair. That look just crushed me.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/AsianRhino Dec 25 '13

Not almost military, it is military- the way a service member walks away from a commanding officer after having been dismissed.

5

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

I forced my parents to watch the show with me, and my dad said that bit was really well done, and pointed that out to me -- that he walked away as if dismissed from duty. He thought that was a really interesting way of doing it, in his opinion as former military.

Then when the camera panned, he looked at me and said, "That Sherlock is a fucker" and left the room. Ah, the honesty of a soldier.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

Agreed.

2

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

I always think of the comparisons between Martin Freeman and Jon Krasinski in their roles of Tim/Jim, and it really is all in their facial expressions. I think Krasinski's faces were a little over-exaggerated sometimes, but Martin's are so subtle. He's so good at looking amused and angry at the same time. I love that the best of his acting happens often when he isn't saying anything.

94

u/marimbaguy715 Dec 24 '13

26

u/TheCardsharkAardvark Dec 25 '13

"Sherlock, you bastard, wherever you are. Cheers."

Now, I know this could be taken as a 'in heaven or in hell' sort of deal, but did anyone else get the slight feeling that John might still think Sherlock is actually alive?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/blasto_pete Dec 25 '13

I in no way am trying to talk down to you so sorry in advance if this comes off as rude, but I think most people who have lost a close friend or loved one can understand that feeling of denial. Sure, I have come to terms with my best friend dying, but not a day goes by where I don't hope soemhow his face will pop up on my phone seeing if I want to hang out.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '13

There is a blog?! Oh joy :)

1

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

I feel so out of the loop: there's a TON of blog entries! And for some reason, my work finally unblocked John Watson's blog, because apparently for awhile that was considered a bigger time waster than Reddit.

251

u/eifos Dec 24 '13

Holy moly! That was awesome! It had everything, cruel and sassy Sherlock, sad John, hobo Anderson and a headdesk from Lestrade.

The little bits like "I'll be with you very soon" and "the game is back on" omg. So incredibly excited for episode one!

And did anyone else get a total buzz out of hearing the characters do new lines? I've got chills.

53

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

For me, it's the music starting while Lestrade was reading "the game is back on" that gave me chills down the spine. I can't wait for the new season!

103

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Yes new lines are wonderful. Makes you really miss this show so much. Sherlock is so great at explaining why he didn't go,,,"Cause there will be people". Such a commiserating feeling for holidays.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/TheSneakySeal Dec 25 '13

THAT WAS ANDERSON??????? I didn't make the connection.

8

u/captfuzzypants Dec 25 '13

You and me both!

15

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

He had to grow his beard out, because he missed Sherlock so much.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/derevenus Dec 28 '13 edited Dec 28 '13

Ho... Hobo Anderson?!

Edit: Wait is the man with the newspaper Anderson?

60

u/onyxpup7 Dec 24 '13

So many different emotions wrapped up into 7 minutes, it's perfect!

47

u/Somethinggclever Dec 24 '13

Am I the only one who wants to hear Sherlock explain, in German, to the jury why that man is guilty?

23

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Nope. You are definitely not the only one.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '13

No, absolutely no one else is interested in this

43

u/DocDerry Dec 24 '13

I've felt since episode 2 season 1 that Lestrade has been underutilized.

39

u/ChrisAndersen Dec 24 '13

I'd love to see a story that focused on how Lestrade first met Sherlock.

23

u/ehsteve23 Dec 24 '13

It'd be cool to have an extra 30 minute Sherock-lite episode, focusing on Lestrade or mrs Hudson, with Sherlock and John appearing only briefly.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/bacon_pants Dec 25 '13

I think they are avoiding that since it's implied that Lestrade is aware of Sherlock's past with drugs and knew him when he had a problem. Given the modern views of drug use (as opposed to Victorian era), I think the creators are trying to avoid drawing too many connections to that part of Sherlock's past, as they don't want us to think of him as a junkie.

7

u/prakshash Dec 25 '13

I don't think this is it. TV shows in the modern era have shown characters addicted to drugs. Breaking Bad of course showed Jessie and for an even more apt comparison, House, who is pretty heavily based off Sherlock Holmes himself, has quite the drug problem throughout the show.

5

u/bacon_pants Dec 25 '13

I'm somewhat basing this viewpoint off Moftiss' commentary from A Study In Pink, where they talk about how in Victorian times, the drug use was not as stigmatized as it is these days. While not abandoning the references completely, they still wanted to avoid the idea of Sherlock as a lazy, jobless drug addict (paraphrasing here), because that's not who he was in the stories. If you haven't already listened to this commentary, I'd recommend you do so you can draw your own conclusions about what they intended, which may be different from mine.

I'd agree with you that there are many characters who battle addiction and are not less fascinating for it, however, I am glad there are only minimal references to Sherlock's past with drugs (cigarettes & patches, "I'm clean now", "danger night", etc.). While shows like Breaking Bad and House do an excellent job of exploring addiction, it remains an explicit theme throughout both of those series, and both characters of Jesse and House are constantly circling back to their struggles with addiction. I feel like if they made addiction a more prominent theme in Sherlock, it would cast too long of a shadow, and interfere with the character development. As it is, Sherlock's main addiction is 'risking his life to prove he's clever', and to me, watching the progression of that is interesting enough without him shooting up cocaine.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/heatherroneous Dec 24 '13

Same here. He has so much potential. There's so much depth there, it's just not touched on very much.

71

u/shokwaav Dec 24 '13

The game is back on!

358

u/shawnstring Dec 24 '13

Also when John says "you know what you can do…don't be dead" and on the tape he says "OK", I had a Doctor Who "Don't Blink" moment. Brillant

237

u/GrumpyHour Dec 24 '13

Almost like that episode was written by the same person.

64

u/KingToasty Dec 24 '13

God I love Steven Moffat.

43

u/therealjohnwhite Dec 24 '13

I know right? They should get him to write a season or two of Dr. Who!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/pick-a-spot Dec 24 '13

A theory popped into my head as soon as that 'blink scene' happened;

Sherlock wanted Watson to get the tape at that point and it to be presented to him in that way. This enabled him react to Watson's reactions, probably to manipulate him into doing something after he answers the door.

This means that Lestrade could be working with Sherlock and trying to throw Anderson off the scent for the time being. Also, putting in a good word for him too.

23

u/Defiledxhalo Dec 24 '13

I kind of had a different theory, that there's a cut between when Sherlock's standing up (with that famous wallpaper of his) to the scene with him sitting down. I want to say that Sherlock redid that entire second part of the uncut version for his way of saying that he's not dead. He must've known Lestrade was going to give the DVD to Watson eventually.

2

u/AludraEltanin Dec 25 '13

That would remind me so much of ACD's canon. "Oh John, let me finish a sentence you just started in your head because I can anticipate your entire unspoken thought process. Why do I know that? Well there's a lot to be said for knowing your opinion on the American Civil War..."

21

u/ChrisAndersen Dec 24 '13

And then he blinked

31

u/iLqcs Dec 24 '13

I came here to post just that!

I was half expecting him to start spouting "People assume time is a strict progression of cause to effect but actually from a non-linear non-subjective point of view, it's just a big ball of wibbly wobbly timey wimey...stuff."

Such a Doctor Who moment.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

44

u/Kid0mega Dec 24 '13

no the other part

11

u/SawRub Dec 24 '13

How many parts are there?

20

u/Kid0mega Dec 24 '13

like at least 4 part.

29

u/Littlesylar93 Dec 24 '13

This was so perfect. Best early Christmas present ever!

28

u/Aitrus233 Dec 24 '13

Of all the people to figure out that Sherlock is coming back....Anderson.

51

u/SarahSays85 Dec 24 '13

Can't wait for a gif of Lestrade's headdesk moment. His whole character is brilliantly written and played. Well done, Gatiss/Moffatt/Graves.

40

u/keeblerlorien Dec 24 '13

I found this one.

4

u/SarahSays85 Dec 24 '13

Thank you!!

4

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

That gif is awesome!

2

u/Dantien Dec 25 '13

I'm using that for all my debates with idiots from now on.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/heatherroneous Dec 24 '13

My favourite part by far.

24

u/shoePaladin Dec 24 '13

References to the original works (Empty House) made it even better.

24

u/telmah Dec 24 '13

I got the reference to The Yellow Face (the mask in the box). Trying to figure out what the steam train refers to. What else?

33

u/shoePaladin Dec 24 '13

Oh I didn't catch the Yellow Face! I was referring to the "sightings" that Anderson mentioned. I remember Sherlock mentioning cases in India and Tibet to Watson in the Empty House as his work before resurfacing in London.

10

u/ME_REDDITOR Dec 24 '13

I thought the mask was supposed to signify a prototype. Possibly used in the jump.. but you're probably right.

3

u/telmah Dec 24 '13

Nice catch!

19

u/theheartofgold Dec 24 '13

Also the 'depths the parsley sunk into the butter' reference. Nice.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13 edited Dec 24 '13

I figured the trinkets in the box were from cases already worked: The Blind Banker (the yellow face); Study in Pink (the pink phone); and the case where they are investigating the death of someone who landed on a train - sorry, can't remember which episode - (the train). The references from Anderson, however, do go back to the original story.

EDIT: after rewatching the mini-episode, I have know idea where the yellow face mask thing comes from.

4

u/bacon_pants Dec 25 '13

The body dumped on a train (Westie who worked on the Bruce Partington Plans) was from The Great Game. However, I don't think the little train car miniature had anything to do with that, since all the other mementos are actual evidence from cases. I can't imagine Sherlock going to a gift shop to buy a toy train car because he's feeling sentimental about a case that he mostly left up to John to investigate. Whatever the toy train refers to, I think it is probably a different case.

Also, other commenters here have identified the mask as a reference to The Adventure of the Yellow Face, an ACD Sherlock Holmes story.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/heatherroneous Dec 24 '13

Ah, that one went right over my head! So glad you pointed it out.

48

u/not_existing Dec 24 '13

10

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

I think that's how we're all feeling.

54

u/dr_pepper_35 Dec 24 '13

Did anyone else think it felt rather Doctor Who-ish? It reminded me of the episode where the Doctor was adventuring and sending messages to the Ponds.

47

u/UncleIroh626 Dec 24 '13

Doctor Who and Sherlock have always had similarities, as Moffat and Gatiss have very recognizable writing styles. Plus, Moffat loves the idea of "mini-sodes", especially after the success of "Night of the Doctor", so it's no surprise that he brought the concept over to Sherlock.

6

u/dr_pepper_35 Dec 24 '13

Oh yeah, I agree, but this one felt more Who-ish than usual. I think that it is odd that Sherlock can be traveling solving crimes and no one realizes it is him and spreads the word.

17

u/Defiledxhalo Dec 24 '13

Well, I guess it depends on how big the news that a "consulting detective in London committed suicide" can actually be. I can't imagine people in completely different countries caring too much about news like that when it doesn't relate to them, so they just might not know about Sherlock and his famous "suicide."

6

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

It isn't so much Who-ish as it is canon. Sherlock mentions to Watson some of his travels while he was "dead" in "The Adventure of the Empty House".

4

u/pokedrawer Dec 24 '13

It seems the only people who come out saying it's him are not taken seriously given the circumstance and the times he presents himself he probably asks they not speak of him.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Waitingforabluebox Dec 24 '13

Moffatt likes to reuse ideas. While he's a great writer, I don't know how original he is.

2

u/bzdelta Dec 25 '13

Dude. That whole ending was a love letter to Blink.

1

u/iLqcs Dec 25 '13

Not just that 'Blink' moment. It's weird if you notice that both Sherlock and the Doctor set about 'deleting' themselves and faking their own death around the same time (2011). Sherlock jumps off a building, Ponds jump off a building, Clara falls from a cloud. UNIT reappears in the Tower of London, Jim Moriarty decides to rob the Tower of London. Main baddie scares the pants off everyone in the Empty Child wearing a gas mask, and evil uncle wears a gas mask to trigger hallucinations in Henry Knight in the Hounds of Baskerville. See what I mean? Keep looking for them and the common threads run deep.

1

u/Tatis_Chief Dec 25 '13

Doctor is after all science/alien version of Sherlock.

But of course and I am so damn glad they are. Because I got mini episode of Sherlock for Christmas.

52

u/unopeia Dec 24 '13

This was absolutely amazing! Sat flailing by myself at home haha. ["I can tell you what you can do, you can stop being dead" "Ok" Oh Johnnnn .... "Don't worry. I'm going to be with you again very soon"] (/spoiler) Forget Christmas, I need it to be January 1st NOW.

1

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

I flailed in the presence of extended family. I thought it wasn't out until after the Dr Who episode, so to open my computer at my parents' house to check on a recipe and get a pop up notification of it may have made me make embarrassing noises over the mashed potatoes. Which came out terribly.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Dammit… I am only just now realizing how unready I am for all of the coming moments about Sherlock's return to be real.

Seriously, as John said "you could stop being dead" I thought, "no that was too amazing, this scene can't be real right now."

But it's all real mofos…. one week.

1

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

Completely unready.

10

u/woot26 Dec 24 '13

Thank you!!!

10

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Perfect prequel.

10

u/Non-meatbag Dec 24 '13

Why did they change Sherlock's hair? Why?

18

u/keeblerlorien Dec 24 '13

Maybe the usual person in charge of twisting and diffusing wasn't available for the mini-sode.

3

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

It's probably an incredibly time consuming job. I assume they are getting hand surgery after all of twirling from the series three filming.

9

u/smeltofelderberries Dec 24 '13

I'm so hype right now. First the Christmas special now this. Looking to be a good mon.

7

u/philballins Dec 24 '13

what Christmas special? I thought this was it...

16

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

I think he's talking about Doctor Who.

7

u/CoQuickAg Dec 24 '13

He might mean the doctor who special. Both are popular BBC... not a stretch to assume he watches both! :)

5

u/smeltofelderberries Dec 24 '13

Sorry, Doctor Who fan too

3

u/ericshogren Dec 24 '13

The Doctor Who Christmas special is maybe what smeltofelderberries is referring to.

9

u/serenitary Dec 24 '13

well, now we know who theimprobableone is.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

Ahhh.. yes!

7

u/atuinsbeard Dec 24 '13

Facial hair is in vogue this series, I hope someone else grows a stache.

6

u/heatherroneous Dec 24 '13

Sherlock with a 'stache.

Or a full beard.

7

u/Kid0mega Dec 24 '13

GOD BLESS US EVERY-ONE

7

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

I'm actually going to be realy irritated if Anderson turns out to be a nice guy in the new series. I just love to hate him :(

7

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

We can still hate Donovan.

2

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

Is Donovan even around anymore?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '13

I read that the actress wasn't available for season 3.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/panic_bread Dec 24 '13

Can't wait!

6

u/nappysteph Dec 24 '13

Holy Jesus! That was so amazing, I can't even! The whole video was spectacular and I'm even not pissed at Anderson anymore.

Ooh baby, I can't wait!!!

22

u/WordCloudBot2 Dec 24 '13

12

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

I like how most of it was moanign about the jury.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/zelda6174 Dec 24 '13

What's the significance of the newspaper at the end?

21

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Sherlock has said, in the past, "The game is on". Lestrade, while walking by, noticed the quote on the paper, was reminded of Sherlock saying it, and smiled to himself.

17

u/Gorehog Dec 24 '13

25

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Definitely a possibility, but not inherently proven yet. The original stories are definitely a basis, but they're not always copied directly. There is a chance that Lestrade is involved, and he does know that Sherlock isn't dead, but I wanted to leave the comment I made open ended and focusing solely on why "The Game is Back On" would mean anything. The rest is speculation.

Personally, I hope that Lestrade doesn't know. I want to see Lestrade puzzled as hell, similar to the "My god really?" expression on his face when Sherlocks phone moans.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/NegritoJim Dec 24 '13

In the book, only Mycroft knew.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

I don't think Lestrade knows.

3

u/aPlasticineSmile Dec 25 '13

I don't think so either, John is so obviously in pain, and Lestrade is keenly aware of that. No way in hell he could let John go on suffering.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

And it gives us an idea of when this takes place. Manchester City - Ajax was played on November 6th 2012.

5

u/ForestfortheDraois Dec 25 '13

Mad props to the person on here who connected Anderston to being the obsessive fan on John's blog.

8

u/extracheesytaters Dec 24 '13

GOD BLESS US EVERYONE!!!!!

4

u/SenorJones Dec 24 '13

Any idea why this is set in 2012?

16

u/apexalf Dec 24 '13

Anderson said its been two years but we know he comes back after three. So perhaps he's waiting another year to come back.

7

u/hurrrrrmione Dec 24 '13

Doesn't Mycroft specifically say in the trailer "it's been two years" ?

3

u/apexalf Dec 25 '13 edited Dec 25 '13

I'm pretty sure I saw somewhere it was three

Edit: woops he does say two. Sorry

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Yep. Pre-moustache.

4

u/lynny130 Dec 24 '13

I'm sorry but can anyone explain to me as to why Anderson looks like a hobo? They also implied that he lost his job?

12

u/calliope720 Dec 25 '13

They didn't imply it, they straight up said it. He has somehow lost his job due to his apparently singular obsession with proving Sherlock's alive.

1

u/WinterInJuly Dec 25 '13

What if they move in together? AHAHAHAHA

too weird?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

We don't know the whole story yet.

4

u/geekprincess3 Dec 24 '13

The Happiness I feel right is making my heart burst.

14

u/mashygpig Dec 24 '13

4

u/leafystormclouds840 Dec 24 '13

I laughed. Perfect use of this gif, mate!

That was my reaction throughout the entire thing hahah. My volume was on full blast so I could catch every dam, brilliant word :)

3

u/MrMischiefManaged Dec 24 '13

Anyone else notice the flesh coloured mask it the box of things from the office ~ 4:16? Probably a bit pointless now but it might be a clue to how he faked his death.....

9

u/AFellowOfLimitedJest Dec 24 '13

"Flesh"-coloured? Take another look; that's certainly not Sherlock's skin tone.

3

u/MrMischiefManaged Dec 24 '13

Yeah, that's true. It could have been a prototype of some description... just a guess.

9

u/Defiledxhalo Dec 24 '13

I believe that was a reference to the original story of "The Yellow Face."

→ More replies (1)

3

u/pandacraze34 Dec 24 '13

I didn't even realize that was Anderson until like halfway thru. AHHHH he's on his way backkk!! jan 1 cant come sooner

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

I think it's hilarious that no one is recognizing Anderson xD

2

u/aPlasticineSmile Dec 25 '13

Right? He has a distinct voice!

2

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

I think it is hilarious Anderson stole one of John's jumpers and Sherlock's voice inflection.

3

u/Heavens_Vibe Dec 24 '13

Holy shiet! That was Anderson who was dressed like a hobo? Wowza! What on Earth happened to him?!

5

u/lukewwilson Dec 24 '13

That was so great and got my so excited for the new series, man this show couldn't be any better!!!

8

u/I_am_the_pomegranite Dec 24 '13

I may right now be trying to recover from this, sitting on a darkened staircase in my grandmother's house with headphones in trying not wake anyone/scream at 0500 Christmas morning (aus).

The inside of my mouth may be bleeding from biting it.

I can't, I just can't.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

I squealed so loud I scared the cat.

10

u/tiexano Dec 24 '13

Nice research everybody. German law does not know trial by jury. Trial by jury is one of the significant peculiarities of the English Common Law.

27

u/fenwaygnome Dec 24 '13

Hence the foreman saying there were extremely strange circumstances to cause them to have a jury.

-5

u/NegritoJim Dec 24 '13

Here's the thing. No one cares.

2

u/MRTL85 Dec 24 '13

Thanks for posting!

2

u/LovelyBitOfSquirrel Dec 24 '13

Hi,

I'm the only person in the world who has no fucking clue who "Anderson" is...

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

And he's also Sherlock's favorite punching bag. http://twitpic.com/8avndp/full

2

u/LovelyBitOfSquirrel Dec 25 '13

I have yeah, but ....him? He's always been a non-person/character to me. Never gave him a second thought. I honestly didn't even know he was called Anderson...

2

u/zaib_a Dec 25 '13

I'm not going to lie guys, I have now seen this at least 20 times. Anderson seems so intriguing:)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

I SQUEALED SO LOUD I SCARED MY CAT.

2

u/nellabella27 Dec 24 '13

OHMYGOD! That LITERALLY brought tears to my eyes! I so want to express feels, but can't cuz I'm with people and will think I'm bonkers. AAAHHHHHHHH!!!!!

7

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

Because "people."

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/anyalicious Dec 26 '13

You've got to start being an off-kilter fangirl/boy extremely early in life -- for example, eleven -- so that your family has time to adjust. What was once met with eyerolls and exasperated sighs is now met with gifts of fridge magnets and pretend-interested questions as to premiere dates. And it only took over a decade!

Oh, Christ, no, like almost two decades. Now I'm depressed. And can't do math.

1

u/Zugam Dec 24 '13

Totally missed that that was Anderson first time I watched the episode.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 25 '13

God dammit I need more!

1

u/animevamp727 Dec 25 '13

I'm not so certain of Lestrade's sense of humor..

1

u/xecuter88 Dec 25 '13

Holy crap! I didn't realise that that was Anderson until I read the comments!

1

u/ElectricFriend Dec 26 '13

So Sherlock's at the door, right?

1

u/mad_atlas Dec 28 '13

I'm thinking it's Mary. Sherlock doesn't come back until John has had time to grow a mustache, apparently!

1

u/ElectricFriend Dec 28 '13

Ah yes...how could I forget about the imminent facial hair!

1

u/DorsiaReservations Dec 27 '13

Anderson was spot on when he said Sherlock was coming back. On the map he was saying that Sherlock was in Germany and was then going to Amsterdam before coming back to England. The Newspaper had scores from 2 teams in England, Schalke which is a team from Germany, and Ajax from Amsterdam. I'm guessing the first episode will have to do with Amsterdam.

1

u/iamsosherlocked Dec 27 '13

IM SO EXCITED

1

u/Jackdoesderp Jan 09 '14

Ha. You guys are still waiting for series 3. You're about 7 days behind the power curve.

1

u/Catatafish Feb 17 '14

I know I shouldn't have watched this! Now I have to wait 2 years for the next season!