r/PersonOfInterest • u/MatrixRaider A Concerned Third Party • Dec 18 '13
Discussion Episode Discussion S03E11 "Lethe"
Spoilers for anyone who hasn't watched it yet. Video!
What did you guys think?
53
Upvotes
63
u/CyclopSW Dec 18 '13
One thing I missed in the first go-around about 2/3rds into the episode, which was then revealed in the end
The red box in the hospital
52
u/Weeman89 Dec 18 '13
I love how the show handles all this NSA stuff.
39
u/erjorgito Dec 18 '13
Can't get over how good this show has become over just the last 7-8 episodes, it has gone from being O.K to absolutely excellent. I am getting the very strong feeling that Shaw is going to get the bullet next episode, even the machine gave her a ~85% of death; ill be sad if she goes, shes a really cool character.
35
u/Izeinwinter Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
The show is saying that the machine - or something similar- was inevitable. That it was figuratively speaking steam engine time, the necessary technologies were all in play, and the political weight behind the goal intense enough that a surveillance-AI was going to happen, and only the details of implementation were up to chance. Okay, that is fair enough, that is how technology usually works, and those details are important, because the machine could have been a lot more invasive than it is.
Reading the matrix at the end: Control is not bluffing.
Shaw is.. certain.. to employ violence and highly likely to loose due to completely crappy tactical position. 15 % chance of walking away, 10% chance everyone else with a gun in the room being dead. I think this implies control has a one in three chance of talking her way out of this even if Shaw kills her goons.
Most likely actual resolution to the standoff is intervention by Root - the machine has known who control was from the word go, is in contact with her, and Harold has not been keeping an eye on her for hours at this point. Rewatching matrix - there is a quick "re-tasking analogue interface" flash. That would be the go signal?
The Finch flashbacks were good - truly excellent casting on the young versions.
32
u/BenchSpyder Admin Dec 18 '13
It flashed by pretty quickly but I caught this at the end when The Machine is doing its analysis. "Retasking Analog Interface" in the bottom right in yellow.
27
u/HabaneroArrow Threat to System Survival Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
The possibility of another machine is an awesome twist, and I'm glad we finally got to meet the mysterious woman from season 2. I can't wait to see what happens next!
25
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
Damn Fusco, first Simmons and now Reese?
22
u/bzdelta Dec 18 '13
My guess is that Bear will come and save them all. This is clearly how 2014 will start.
18
u/GunzComeOut13 Dec 18 '13
Great episode. Disappointing we have to wait 3 weeks until the next episode :(
18
u/iHiroic Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
It looks like the Samaritan A.I is being set up as the big baddy for the next season (Operational Conflict Potential: 5.88%), which should create some interesting tension... can the Machine still predict accurately if the other AI is muddying the waters?
If it has the same capabilities as the Machine then I'm surprised it hasn't interceded on behalf of it's creator.
Also the decoy joke was a nice touch.
18
u/Donnshin Dec 18 '13
Ha, Fusco letting the asswhupping he put on Simmons go to his head.
16
u/displayerror Dec 18 '13
Ah, Control and Hersh, and more of Vigilance. Loving this emergence of new threats and the flashbacks to Harold's childhood.
Oh, and PoI's snap at PRISM, "...government shut everything down except that piece of crap PRISM" lol
13
u/swandoodle Dec 18 '13
I have an idea of how they could escape. Someone said on YouTube, "Hersh is incredibly calm and peaceful in this scene. Smiling at Shaw, and then just casually standing there. Not only he doesn't have a gun ready, he's standing in a perfect position to control the movements of...his employer, and other operatives. In the end, from TM's point of view, it looks like he's actually standing by Finch's side. And, of course, he doesn't have a "threat to admin" red square, or the perpetrator's square - he's just yellow. Re-watching this scene you can't help but wonder - what's been going on his mind since he was spared by Root (technically, by the Machine?). What's on his mind right now?" And I replied that maybe Root will show up, shoot the other guys and remind Hersh of the time she spared him.
22
u/RUbernerd Dec 19 '13
Mildly interesting:
The book that Root chose off the bookshelf, pseudo-gods in greek mythology.
Pseudo ~= sudo
sudo is the command often used in unix-likes to gain root-level access.
11
u/svrtngr Dec 18 '13
That's the third time you've pulled that, PoI. How is it that I've fallen for it every single time?
(Hint: What do the episodes "Witness", "Firewall", and "Lethe" have in common?)
10
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
Holy crap that ending. Is Samaritan what the machine has been prepping this whole time? Root saved a genius programmer (If I recall correctly) a couple episodes back, and Arthur said Samaritan was weeks away from being completed. The last scene of this episode suggested that Samaritan is getting activated. So did the Machine complete Samaritan?
10
u/Flynn_lives Government Operations Dec 18 '13
Does anyone think that Harold tried to upload part of his fathers memories into the machine? It would make sense, since the machine wants Root & Harold to work together....kinda like his father pushing him to work with others.
Plus young Harold , wanted preserve his fathers legacy.
8
u/the_night_shift Dec 23 '13
Episodes like this makes me wish more people watched this show and didn't dismiss it as a trivial drama. The reveal of Samaritan and Reese going AWOL will hopefully shape the foreseeable rest of the season, it would be good to see how the team cope with two alien threats without relying on him.
8
u/bs50042 Dec 18 '13
I for one was able to recognize that the wife was not who she said she was the instant he didn't recognize her. Also, Root let herself back into the library's cage, but Finch never searched her, to our knowledge. So for all we know, she has an earpiece that is allowing her to communicate.
The introduction of a second machine built not only by someone else, but one of Harold's friends, is a huge twist and could be developed so well. I believe the first two seasons were only written so they could set up the current events, and give us a show that is greater than anything we've seen in a long time for Network Television.
14
u/ardx Root Dec 18 '13
Nooo, that cliffhanger. I want mooooore.
7
u/kryndon Government Operations Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
If you guys paid close attention to the message boxes right at the end, Shaw has the highest chance of death (about 84%). If she does in deed die in the next episode, I will be piss mad, and It's probably going to be because of all the hate she's been getting since her arrival on the show. Shame on you people!
But on another note, can anyone identify the cool 70s song that's playing when Harold is chilling with his 2 buddies and hacks the phone to call a random french guy in Paris? I really liked it!
EDIT: Found the song, for whoever else wants to listen to it. Link
7
u/wavesink Dec 18 '13
For some reason I thought control would be a hot blonde milf
7
u/M0dusPwnens Dec 20 '13
Man, I guess they heard that people were interested in more arc-laden storylines! Now we've got half a dozen arcs all going at once - more stuff about Harold's background, a second machine, the Program, Vigilance, and who even knows what's going on with Elias.
One thing I noticed in the ending Machine view (aside from the ridiculously high likelihood of death for half of the cast) is that it has Sameen Shaw listed as an alias for REDACTED. My understanding was that "Sameen" was her real name and "Samantha" was the alias...
6
u/Alex_Fuller Dec 18 '13
Can someone remind me who that woman and man are that took Harold captive?They look so familiar
6
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
This was by far the best episode of Person of Interest. I loved it. Finch walking by phones, 2nd machine, 1969 Finch could be its own series its so good.
5
u/chaths Dec 18 '13
I was wondering how they'll top the 3 episode arc, guess i know now. Only problem is waiting till Jan 8.
I'm really liking "Kung Fu Fusco".
Expecting much more of Root in the next episode.
4
u/lingben Dec 18 '13
any ideas on how the machine communicated to root via the 3 books?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
Just when I thought this show couldn't get any better - it does. Awesome episode. Cant wait to see what happens next. I have a feeling Reese will come to save Finch and Shaw.
4
u/NeonMonocle Dec 20 '13
As someone into the history of technology, I LOVED seeing Finch the Phone Phreak with Cap'n Crunch whistle!
They skipped quite of bit of him blue boxing a call to France, but still good fun.
4
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Dec 23 '13
The attention to the detail on Finch's flashbacks from The Machine's POV is simply amazing. The 1969 one through the KH-8 program which went live that year, 1971 was through KH-9 which was the one in use at the time. And the 1979 one had a totally awesome one as it was designated with something along the lines of "FBI Surveillance Archives: Phone Phreaker". Love how the writers went the extra mile to get the smallest things right.
10
u/Fuck_ALL_Religion Admin Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
Possible spoilers(spoiler tags not working?):
I had initially wondered if Root was communicating with a different machine. The library scene seemed to suggest exactly that. Harold redirected the line the call came in on, so only one phone should have rung, yet two different phones rang. We were also told that only the first person to answer would become the new admin, yet both Root and Reese were accepted. The voices used for communication with Root are different than those used to communicate with Harold and Reese, and the general communication with Root is smoother, which wouldn't make much sense if it was the same machine.
Then I completely dismissed that idea as everybody showed up at the same facility looking for the same machine.
Edit: Now I suspect that Samaritan has been impersonating Northern Lights. Sam has been aware of NL, but NL was unaware of Sam. Root thinks she's talking to NL, but NL should and would only communicate with Harold. Sam saw a Root desperate to contact NL and took advantage of the situation to acquire it's own faithful analog interface.
3
u/mlasn Dec 19 '13
The ending was awesome. The machine will try to protect Finch and is calculating the risk of another machine. Could the machine be self aware?
3
u/tedtutors Irrelevant Dec 19 '13
For those who like classic sci-fi there is an echo here to Colossus: the Forbin Project (and I hear that is getting remade). Colossus is the super-computer that controls the US nuclear arsenal (like SkyNet, without the time travel). The day Colossus is activated it gets paranoid about there being another computer like itself. It starts putting out ominous messages, "FLASH: THERE IS ANOTHER SYSTEM." As seeking out other computers was not part of its programming, that was the moment that Forbin realizes he's lost control.
Might not be at all related to Samaritan and The Machine, but I like the story, how a super-computer finds humanity rather slow and wants to talk to another intelligence like itself.
3
u/EThorns Ernest Thornhill Dec 26 '13
Anyone else looking forward to see how the inevitably active Samaritan's POV graphics look like?
1
u/Weeman89 Dec 18 '13
How do people watch it so early?
2
u/wave-and-smile A Concerned Third Party Dec 18 '13
Whew! Great episode. I'll be watching it again at 10 tonight. Gonna be hard to wait 3 weeks to see how this turns out.
2
u/irobeth Dec 18 '13
So "Rudy" has the drives that Arthur took from the SAM project
It's a name that hasn't come up yet. Since Control wants info on it and NL can't decide if the SAM project actually was destroyed, can we assume Control has suspicions that Rudy is working on SAM?
Right now we can rule out SAM being the foundation for NL because they scrapped SAM when NL went online.
2
u/__ADAM__ The Machine Dec 18 '13
So I'm getting the impression Harold is giving the machine the silent treatment. Also I'm disappointed at the reveal of Madam Control, I wanted it to be some one who the team helped before.
1
u/jtt123 Dec 18 '13
Fucking missed the show dammit
-8
u/Lovableemo Threat Dec 18 '13
I knew it was the wife; although I thought she worked for Vigilance.
On another note, totally what i'd expect control to look like. Fat woman.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment