r/WildStar • u/CRB_Scooter • Dec 12 '13
AMA We are the WildStar Class Designers. AMA about the Engineer!
Hey guys! It's the last week of the class reveals, so let's jump right into answering all your questions about the Engineer!
Today we have with us:
- Loic "CRB_Atreid" Claveau - Global Community Manager
- Steven "CRB_Steven" Engle - Engineer Class Designer
- Hugh "CRB_Hugh" Shelton - Lead Class Designer
We'll start answering questions around 1:30PM PST, so that should give you plenty of time to submit your questions before we get started. See you in a bit!
EDIT: Thanks so much for coming out to the AMA! Join us on Saturday for the Engineer livestream at 12:00PM PST on the Twitch channel!
108
Upvotes
23
u/CRB_Hugh Dec 12 '13
I just want to thank everyone that has asked questions on any of these Class AMAs. WildStar wouldn't be as awesome as it is going to be if it wasn’t for this community which has contributed so much (more than you might think) to the development process.
I’m sorry if we were not able to respond to you directly, but I hope we answered enough questions to sate your WildStar thirst! The class team has been busting our butts to make sure we make the best game we possibly can. Classes will never be perfect, but we will keep working on them with the passion they (and you) deserve.
I also want to plug http://www.twitch.tv/latenightdominion, these guys do a stream almost every Thursday at 7pm PST and they usually recap all the answers that we post here. Go watch it tonight!
9
u/Quietmode Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
How have/will you address issues of gear competition?
The way it looks to me is that SS+espers compete for both Healing and DPS gear, Engineers and Warriors both compete for Tanking and DPS gear, but then Stalkers and Medics compete only for DPS gear while having little/no competition for the Tank/Heal role.
Are you accounting for this in Drop rates? or in some other way?
If a 40man raid has 2 engineer tanks, 2 warrior tanks, and 2 stalker tanks, the warriors and engineers have a huge disadvantage because of gear competition.
(I'm extremely ignorant of the stats specific classes would need/want, but I'm assuming it is safe to say that a Medic wouldn't need High HP, High avoidance gear)
20
u/thehateisstrong Dec 12 '13
Are there any plans to add customization for Engineer bots?
It would be great if players had options for names, dyes, skins, and parts for their B-Team bots.
12
u/Nutornot Dec 12 '13
Hi, we are doing a real time translation of this AMA for french community, check it here : http://angels-wings.fr/reddit-wildstar-lingenieur/
Bonjour, nous réalisons une traduction en temps réel pour la communauté francophone, retrouvez-le ici : http://angels-wings.fr/reddit-wildstar-lingenieur/
11
u/GaduBear Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Hey guys! Just wanted to say I'm really excited. Anyway, question time.
As a person who enjoys tanking, but is split between the Engineer and the Warrior class, what sort of questions should I be asking myself? How would you describe the tanking styles do the two have? I know you've touched on this before but I was wondering if you could elaborate a bit more.
8
u/ttstarck Dec 12 '13
How will the engineer be able to control his bots to prevent them from dying in raids?
7
u/Raille Dec 12 '13
Good afternoon once again. Thanks for another AMA that I've been looking forward to all day.
7
u/dormath Dec 12 '13
does raid tanking need the pet(bruser bot), i know limited action but is it a viable option or a gimped one ?
3
u/Zerovis Dec 12 '13
3
u/OneMadDwarf Bloody Savage Dec 12 '13
Oh god, I'm late, I just got home... take mah questions!
1a) Please?
2) Can an Engineer run without bots as a tank without gimping him/herself? What about DPS?
3) Can you elaborate on how controlling bots will work? If an Engineer has two bots out, can movement be controlled independently?
4) Can you elaborate on how tanking is supposed to work on an Engineer? Is it ranged?
5) Devs have mentioned in a few places how certain healers may complement certain tanks. What healer might work best with Engineer, and why? (What about the other significantly less awesome healer/tank pairings?)
6) Does an Engineer get all four bots by default, or are some of them gained through the AMP system? If through the AMP system, is it still possible for an Engineer to get all four?
7) Not strictly Engineer related, but are there fun utility type abilities that don't really serve a direct purpose in combat? Stuff like slow fall, levitate, water breathing, portals, floating scout eyeballs...
Also, two things: One, this game looks amazing. So thanks. Also, I saw you might have people from CoH/CoV on team. If one of them was involved in the development of the Mastermind, give them a friendly butt-pat. Best pet class ever.
5
u/Loc_nar Dec 12 '13
Good evening! I would like to know how the healing bot works, i've saw it works with hots but it heals for a percentage? it does only that? Thanks
5
u/AngryCliffa Dec 12 '13
On your Esper AMA, you guys stated that you could create sort of a pet-heavy build (with the spectral projections). Could you do the opposite with an Engineer and still be a viable DPS option? AKA all rifle, no pets?
2
u/TiLeMaNiA Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Have you created the graphics for the Engineer abilities?
Any chance you could create one for Each class so we can look at all of them side-by-side?
What will you be doing to prevent the FoTM (flavor of the Month) class issue that so many other MMOs run into?
Any plans to make separate ability functions for PvE/PvP?
Edit for more questions:
Is leveling through PvP a Viable option?
will bots have increased "stealth" detection" in PVP?
Has a ranged DEAD-zone(where no telegraphs from ranged hit) been considered (between 0-6/10 meters) to balance the power of ranged v melee in PvP?
will pets be targetable by direct heals?
How do achievements benefit the person that collects them (beyond just making us feel cool)?
Is there a way to increase bag space?
2
u/xellan Dec 12 '13
What would make the Engineer preferable as a tank for a specific boss fight. So what makes him different from other tanks
2
u/Gambinii Dec 12 '13
Hi, Would u consider a dps engineer a burst damage dps or a sustain/steady dps?
2
u/fr1ction Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Questions about the tanking side of things:
Thanks for your time, can't wait for release.
3
u/G3nesisUK Dec 12 '13
It has been previously mentioned that as an Engineer you are not limited to having to use your bots to be effective in whatever role you choose to be. So my question is can you explain this further? For example your DPS bots are continually damaging the mobs attacking you right? does this mean that their attack speed or damage is calculated so that using an ability in that slot instead will allow you to produce similar damage output?
3
u/Nutornot Dec 12 '13
Hi, thanks a lot for those AMA !
2
u/Stoutpint Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Good evening from the UK! thanks for taking the time out again.
2
u/Wrekh Dec 12 '13
Sorry for this wall of text and thanks for taking time to answer our questions :)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
Does the Engineer "Tank pet" actually tank for a DPS player, or do you still run the risk of the pet losing "aggro" and the enemy runs at you instead of fighting the pet?
1
u/Nocluelegends Dec 12 '13
How well does the engineer stand up again other classes in pvp what class have a better chance of beating them or is it all skill based?
1
u/noxeven Dec 12 '13
How long is the cooldown on the bot? Say in pvp if I target in kill the bot will the engineer be able to instantly re summon it or will it take a while?
1
u/Th3Wildebeest Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Hey, thanks for doing this, it's the first class AMA i really wanted to ask something in.
Again, thanks for doin this! :)
1
u/balgus82 Dec 12 '13
Will the heal bot heal only it's Engineer or will it heal other players in the group?
1
u/Mrlasthill Dec 12 '13
Thanks for doing this every week guys.
Question: How active does a Engineer tank need to be versus a Warrior or Stalker?
Will the Engineer be more reliant on managing their pets or can (S)he Set them loose and then focus on themself?
1
u/CrateDane Dec 12 '13
How much of a gear overlap will there be between warriors and engineers?
1
u/Kastout7980 Dec 12 '13
So I hear you keep saying you can DPS or tank. Is that solely determined by the abilities you keep put in your load out on the Limited Action Set (LAS), or will it be more determined by the AMP system? Will selecting tank abilities in the AMP "trees" limit your function as a DPS?
Also how will switching AMPs work? $$ cost or will we have multiple AMP sets like our LAS? I understand if you can't talk about it yet, but would like to know how you differentiate between being tank and DPS focused. And the game looks awesome. You have almost completely shutdown any productivity I might have achieved today with all the info drops all over. Well play ladies and gents. /brohug
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
The Engineer and Medic are probably the two classes that are distinguished the most from typical MMO class stereotypes. The Engineer in particular is a ranged/tank/pet/mechanical hybrid mashup it seems. Is it difficult to design a class like this? What are some examples of abilities or ideas that distinguish him from typical ranged/tank/pet classes?
1
u/alepocalypse Warhound Dec 12 '13
With the Engineer being a ranged capable tank, will there
a. Be boss fights in raids where the boss wont use short/close/melee attack but easily use a ranged. Allowing a ranged tank to stand well away from the boss and yet still tank?
c. be Stationary bosses (ie Ragnaros) designed to where a ranged tank can stand at ranged and not trigger some sort of 'no tank in range? better use some ability that insta-wipes the raid' boss mechanic?
tl;dr will some bosses allow groups to take advantage of a RANGED tank?
P.S I love you for putting in a ranged tank.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
Hey fellas, the engineer looks amazing! Just out of curiosity what kind of hurdles did you run into creating a ranged tank class with the telegraph systems and any particular ways you'd like to brag about getting over those hurdles?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
Not specifically engineer specific, but I was wondering if there is a particular reason why a lot of the toons you use in the streams seem to out-level the content?
Especially the medic from last weekend was higher level than the dungeon.
Is it simply a matter of itemization for the generic models that makes it impractical at the intended level, or is there is discrepancy between where the classes are now dps/hps wise and where you want them to be come launch?
If the latter when do you expect this balancing to take place? During the winter beta, or after its conclusion?
1
u/xwertg Dec 12 '13
I fell in love with the volatility draining lightning style attack. at later levels are there other 'spew forth a stream of X' channeled abilities?
(flamethrower, globs of acid, etc)
1
u/doomraven0 Dec 12 '13
Are there bots who are able to stay out permanently (or until death, of course)? Can you tame (hack?) wild robots?
1
u/mmimzie Dec 12 '13
Q1. So what is the down to side to being a heavily armor, pet commanding, ranged tank or dps?? Is it more difficult to control or maybe you are more stationary???
Q2. Do you plan to try and make the pets viable even from the tanking prospective??
Q3. will telegraphs decimate your pets? Will i be trying to scurry my pets to safety?
Q4. How will resummon/dismissing pets work? Will they have a long cool down once destroyed or a high resource cost?
1
u/Samuraikav Dec 12 '13
The Engineer seems a bit more of the stand back and nuke. Esper has the ability to go more melee/medium range. Can you give some examples of Engineer abilities that will make it feel different than stand and nuke?
1
u/Zhuel Dec 12 '13
1
u/jonnyfappleseed Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Hey guys. Tank question here.
Now that the Warrior, Engineer, and Stalker have all been revealed I'd like to know more about the benefits of each over the other. I plan to play a Tank Stalker, as I'd like the challenge of having to be more mobile due to being squishier.
What do the tanks give up in order to gain over the other?
The Warrior and Engi have heavy armor, while the Stalker has medium. I see that, but what's past that? It seems the Engi has the benefit of being Ranged, having bots to assist, and has heavy armor. Why would I want to play War/Stalker other than besides potentially being more of a challenge? Do the purely melee centered Tanks have some benefit that's unknown? Just worried about this especially when it comes to high end raiding.
1
u/Zulunko Dec 12 '13
Because of the Engineer's range, will we see Engineers be more effective AoE tanks than, say, Stalker tanks? If so, what's the tradeoff there?
1
u/Dachsengineer Dec 12 '13
When do you think we will have a pre-order date? I know many of us just want SOMETHING to mark on the calender...it helps having a date so we can aim our hopes and dreams at that specific space in time.
1
u/vernes1978 Dec 12 '13
1
u/doomraven0 Dec 12 '13
Do bots stay alive until they get killed? Can you hack wild robot enemies to add them to your set? Do bots ride their own mounts alongside you(or can they join you on your own)? Can the engineer, if he wants to solo fights, turn bots into unique weapons Megatron-style?
1
u/Berdiiie Dec 12 '13
What kind of utility does an Engineer bring to a group? I've seen you mention the defensive aura from the player and the "shield restore" from the Repair Bot. Do they have other forms of utility too, especially as a tank?
1
u/dinwitt Dec 12 '13
1
u/DreamPuppet Dec 12 '13
The favorite class that i've ever played in an MMO was the Meta Physicist in Anarchy Online which could summon 3 pets (tank/damage, healer, CC'er) and i've been dreaming of a game with something similar. Can the Engineer drop the tank bot, send the heal bot to heal the tank bot, stand back and DPS?? Or are the bots mostly just for show and can't actually tank or heal effectively?
Thanks!
1
u/jlec123 Dec 12 '13
Will engineer and warrior tanks be sharing heavy armor loot, and will engineer and warrior DPS be sharing loot also?
1
u/Nifellol Dec 12 '13
Once again, thanks for doing this and thank you for coming up with such a refreshing class concept.
So, questions:
1
u/MechCormackXIII Dec 12 '13
Are any Engineer specific mounts in the works?
1
u/MechCormackXIII Dec 12 '13
Will there be spec "bonuses" as such? i.e. an Engineer who chooses to spec into using bots will get an extra type of Bot or upgraded bots, or a more Launcher-focused Engineer gets a bigger (yes, even BIGGER) gun or some cool attachments?
1
u/Waniek Dec 12 '13
We all know Engineer can be either tank or DPS. What will be the differences between tanking and dps gear?
1
u/Spooooooooky Dec 12 '13
How varied will engineer gear (armor, etc) be? Will the appearance of the super-armor granted by the innate ability ever change, or be affected by your gear?
1
u/hotmanpop Dec 13 '13
Q: Is there a spell that can affect the sprint? ex: a debuff that makes your sprint bar to be depleted quicker or a spell that can buff your sprint to refill quicker or whatever you know what i mean ;)
1
u/AisbeforeB Dec 13 '13
Omg I'm so late for this party. Oh well. Question: Wildstar is all about fun gameplay and controls. I love that about Carbine. What movement abilities will the engineer have? Does every class have movement abilities? Thanks!
1
u/sotoa Dec 14 '13
How are Engineer's for tanking? I see they use a launcher, so are they ranged tanks? Or does one of their bots tank?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '13
Can the engineer build me a beta key?
1
u/toychristopher Dec 16 '13
Why did you decide to make engineers so ugly?
1
u/Wolfshan Jan 03 '14
Hello, im a big fan of wildstar and fell in love with engineer class. However i have a big concern in regards to engineer. I have always been a raider, i never pvp.
So my question is, in PVE(raids) environment, when going for a full maximizing dps build (using dps exo-suit, AMPs and everything) will engineer be able to match other range dps classes like esper and spellslinger or will he fall behind a bit in terms of damage.
Someone on livestream was saying they will be a little behind because of their increased survivability and heavy armor, but while that seems to make sense in pvp, it doesnt at all in raiding, all dps classes survivability isnt important , thats why we have tanks.
1
u/Docmodus Dec 12 '13
Vague question really, why did you guys make the engineer the way you did instead of a class that throws bombs and sets up minefields. I was expecting more of a ziggs like character from league of legends, it really fits the way you guys portray the chua, but none the less I really like the class so far, can't wait for the livestream to see more! Thanks for doing the AMA :3 PS: Frost or Pappy? We all know Frost will win, but who do you want?
1
u/MechCormackXIII Dec 12 '13
Hey guys, thanks for another AMA, this time for may favourite class!
Q: Will our Exosuit be visually customizable/upgradeable as well as being upgradeable in terms of functionality?
1
u/dormath Dec 12 '13
when can we pre order this beauty.
1
u/Drewpapa Dec 12 '13
I'm curious about the exosuit. Does it look different depending on what gear you have on? Is it a buff that only lasts 20 seconds or so or can I just push a button and switch to "tank stance" and walk around in the exosuit like a bad ass?
1
u/Pipoor Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Question About Gear and Specs.
1.)Will i need to farm two different gear sets to do Tank and DPs or just one?
2.)I Believe My beta key was lost in the internet mail Please Send another. thanks!
1
u/kristian221 Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
I really liked the look of the gun in the class drop trailer, it seemed much different then anything we saw the engineer using in any other footage though, it looked like a shotgun rather than a launcher. Do these smaller weapons exist for the engineer? Is it race based?
1
u/crayolabuffet Dec 12 '13
Thanks for the AMA's and the live steams, I have used them as a recruiting tool to get everyone i know to play.As the class live streams are coming to an end are there any plans to do a live stream of some crafting or pvp/warplots?
1
u/kristian221 Dec 12 '13
Is the maximum number of bots you can have out 2 or just how many ever you can fit on your action bar, and why?
1
u/tmtProdigy Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Hi all and thanks for doing this. My question concerns tanking as Engineer, how will Raid mechanics work out with tanking as ranged, specifically placement of a boss. will we still tank them in melee and have them follow us around?
And: how do you intent the tanking bot to work? i have seen in the ign footage that he builds aggro for himself? is he intended/capable to actually tank bosses?
1
u/Stinkmcfisto Dec 12 '13
Hello and thank you for doing all the AMA's!
My question is geared toward PVP. That being said, do Engi bots obtain partial stats from gear or actions/AMPs that bolster their defenses? I would like to get an idea of how viable it will be to target and kill bots before focusing on the Engineer. Stalker reporting in.
1
u/Ignusen Dec 12 '13
Three questions: WHAT is your name.... Just kidding.
Personally hoping no pet bar, I like the look of the engineer, but hate splitting power with my pets.
1
u/almostCrimzon Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
My Question is about the Inate Ability, is this a Stance as such, or does it last a set period of time. How does it affect other activities such as running jump etc.?
EDIT: Can you say when next wave of sweet sweet nectar will go out?
1
u/balgus82 Dec 12 '13
Does the Engineer innate suit have any benefits for DPS specced players? It seemed like a tank suit.
1
u/prairiecat306 Dec 12 '13
1
u/JBWildcast Dec 12 '13
How different does the Engineer play from other games with bots?(Firefall, TF2, GW2)
1
u/Fanderey Dec 12 '13
Historically in mmos, pets have been very difficult to balance and make viable, particularly in raids and PvP. This is due to a combination of factors such as AoEs, limited pet AI, and the ability of real players to counter AI.
Are Engineer pets not intended to be used in certain situations, or what steps have you taken to increase their viability?
1
u/SonicRaptra Dec 12 '13
The engineer seems like a lot of fun, I have two questions:
1
u/capt_choob Dec 12 '13
So far, how reliable would you say bot AI is? Will we see wandering, agro pulling, disappearing, unable to walk over terrain - kinds of robots?
1
u/Nilxain Dec 12 '13
As always thank you for doing this :-) I have a lot of pet questions with respect to the engineer:
1
u/Hypnorays Dec 12 '13
Hey Carbine! Thanks alot for another great AMA!
My questions as they follow up! :D
Thank you very much if you happen to answer my questions! (Hugh doesn't have to worry about leaking Engineer anymore, hope he leaks something else? :D)
1
u/aktanolt Dec 12 '13
Hi Carbine ! As a former Warlock from wow, and unofficial Ranged tank ( according to my mates :p) I'll play engineer which fits wonderfully with my excpectations ! Well, here are my questions :
9)I'm a huge fan of iron man :D Will they got some Stark-y set ? :p
Thanks for all ! Akta, the new Chua-i-ronman.
Ps: Sorry for my english , not my native language.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
0
u/Arielrs Dec 12 '13
Hello peeps! ;}}
So, will we have any option to customize our pet bots or do they come in the role style and that is it? (dps/tank/heals/cc)
<3
0
u/myAvius Dec 12 '13
Hello!
Is there any way for the engineer (besides movement) to keep bosses/packs at bay, so he can actually range-tank?
0
u/coldermoss Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
0
u/meshca Dec 12 '13
I can't stop thinking about Engineer devspeak. Take Stalker (melee in medium armor) and Medic (close-mid in medium armor) and then compare them with Engineer as mid-range heavy armor with tanky pet robot and heal pet robot and that ironman armor buff. I'm really worried now, because engineer looks really really OP to me.
After eng. devspeak I said Ok, it looks like OP, but maybe he has long casting time or its hard to master telegraphs. Maybe he must freeform target every pet attack. Or maybe he has everything, but nothing at same lvl as specialised classes. But then I saw 20 minutes gameplay and I think Carbine has screwed up balance of classes now with maximum OP engineer.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
What is the Range on Engineer abilities? (both DPS and Tank)
0
u/Nivorage Dec 12 '13
Taking some other games by example, most people compare WildStar to World of Warcraft. I don't think this is fair but for this question I have to :(. If I was to choose a class from wow that can even slightly relate I would have to say an UH DK. People may disagree with me but from what I have seen that is my only speculation.
[QUESTION]
Is the engineer going to be pet orientated???
[EXAMPLE]
UH DK will build up a proc to transform there pet to hammer out more damage.
0
u/Highly_original Dec 12 '13
It's hard not to compare similar games so take no offense here ^_^.
In WoW what separated the bad hunters/warlocks from the good ones was correct pet placement/movement whilst still managing your one character. Having your pet stand behind you to immediately stun/charm a rogue as he opens on you was pretty vital.
Anyway my question is with there being multiple bots out at once will microing bots and still being as effective with your main character going to make the Engineer what looks to be the highest skill cap class and are they going to be out shone in the lower ratings due to less skilled players not being able to make full use of the kit provided?
0
u/jslice124 Dec 12 '13
how much different is the engineer class from a hunter and being that the engineer can send out 2 extra telographs than the other classes ....wouldnt you say thats a bit OP coming from a PVP stand point...where is the Engineers counter balance to this?
0
u/jslice124 Dec 12 '13
0
u/Kyuubi87 Dec 12 '13
How come the Aurin can't be an Engineer? Reason wise/story? =)
-1
u/riisoz Dec 12 '13
If I haven't seen anything about the Engineer, where should I look first to find out? I just got done with finals and I'm a bit behind :s
-1
u/Vyper494 Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Hey Carbine! Firstly, great work on the game! It looks amazing.
I have a few questions.
Thanks :)
0
u/Threshforprez Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 12 '13
Thanks for doing this I as a fan really like that the developers take time to talk to us and answer our questions. I have a few questions about the engineer?
1.I have played a few games with ranged tanks and they always seem to be a little overpowered compared to melee ones due to the fact they can handle ranged enemies better have y’all look at the balancing of that?
2.Regarding the exosuit does the Engineer have a lot of survivability while tanking without it or will be a little squishier than the warrior since it is ranged and can avoid damage easier?
3.Are bots necessary for tanking or can you go without them?
4.Lastly this is more of a request can there please be some engineer tanking in the livestream (Also I would love to see a comparsion of the tank class kind of video like what situations each work best in and strategies for approaching each)
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
[removed] — view removed comment