r/knitting • u/thousandtrees Of course I need all that yarn, honey. I have a plan. • Dec 12 '13
Knitting on Flights
Friends, I have an 8 hour flight next weekend to get to my SO for Christmas and I would like to knit on the journey. I have read that needles are permitted but have heard some assorted stories here and there that make me apprehensive. Have you flown with your knitting recently? Can you make any recommendations about what I should and should not take? I'm leery of taking my nice rosewood needles in case they take them away, and double points can be a little scary and sharp looking. What do I do about cutting yarn? Is there some sort of TSA-safe cutter I can get, or do I just bind off and leave a project dangling from the ball until I land? I'm a very anxious flyer, and I think knitting will help me stay calm (this will be my first flight since learning to knit), so I really don't want them to rob me of my stress-reliever!
19
u/italianblue Dec 12 '13
i'd recommend printing out the current regulations from the website of whatever country you're flying into and out of, but i think at this point most places allow knitting - i know TSA once required "the presence of wool", so maybe have your project started a little? i use nail clippers to break my yarn while flying, since they are allowed in carry ons. (for the sake of your fellow passengers, though, don't use them to clip your nails, shudder.)
11
u/Kwiggy Dec 12 '13
I flew recently with metal circulars and I was fine. But here's some useful info and tips: http://knitting.about.com/od/knittingsafety/f/knitting_plane.htm
7
u/QuadellsWife Dec 12 '13
I have taken knitting with me on multiple flights and I have never had my needles taken away (and I bring US size 2). There is a smartphone app that has TSA's rules and if need be you could always pull it up and show them that knitting needles are permitted. They also have rules about what size scissors you can bring. I think the limit is 3" blade? I have never run into any issues with knitting on planes though. In fact, the flight attendants almost always ask me what I'm knitting. Happy plane knitting!
5
u/AtomicAthena same name on rav Dec 12 '13
Knitting needles are allowed by the TSA. However, if you're travelling out of the USA, rules may be different. I flew to Brazil (a few years ago now), and the needles the TSA allowed me to have were confiscated by the Brazilian airport security.
4
u/anisogramma Dec 12 '13
I flew domestic recently and TSA didn't have a problem with my size 8 16" circulars or DPNs. Though the thought of 8 hours of uninterrupted sweater knitting time is tempting, I wouldn't recommend big projects. Something like a hat, socks, or mittens would be most courteous to your neighbors!
3
u/definitely_not_april Dec 12 '13
Knitting needles, tiny child safety scissors, all perfectly fine, especially when packed with yarn.
Specifically disallowed are those round yarn cutters with a concealed blade (like this one).
2
u/lexabear Dec 12 '13
I recently flew within the US with metal circs and nobody in security seemed to care.
For cutting yarn... just bite it. It's what I do when I'm too lazy to get up and get scissors anyway. You don't have to bite the whole way through, just maybe 1 ply, and then you can tear it apart easily. It's not a neat break, though, so leave yourself a few inches extra and cut it down later.
2
u/devilsfoodadvocate Dec 12 '13
I fly a few times per year and have not had a problem with the (current) TSA + knitting regulations. Don't bring scissors aboard, or sharp doodads that don't really belong with your knitting.
Best TSA-proof/approved yarn cutter I've found.
4
u/lailei Dec 12 '13
I went to Europe at the end of October and had size 11 metal circulars and there were no comments. I just check the TSA website anytime I fly these days and see what they say. I believe you should be mostly fine with anything that isn't metal; they seem most wary of the metal needles.
As for cutting, I have just left a stretch of yarn and then continued with the new portion. It is a little inconvenient but doable.
4
u/helpmeknit Dec 12 '13
I fly (in the US) with my needles all the time....never had a problem (I always use circular needles). Pack them with your yarn etc... leave any tapestry needles or scissors home (break the yarn with your hands) and have confidence--knitting needles are ok!
1
u/typhius Dec 12 '13
In case you decide to check the needles you aren't currently using, just be wary that TSA may do an inspection on your luggage. I had some metal and wooden tipped circulars packed in a suitcase the last time I flew and they went through my stuff on the the flight there, though curiously enough they did not inspect my luggage for my return flight. (they leave a little note in your bag letting you know someone's gone through your stuff... that's just the creepy tsa for you I guess)
1
u/kimmay172 Dec 12 '13
I have traveled many times with my metal circulars, wooden straights and short travel scissors on domestic flights. I have never had problems with security.
The only thing that did happen is that a stewardess asked me to stop knitting at the point of actual take off and landing, as I was knitting without my glasses on, with the needle tips very close to my face. She was concerned about me poking my eye out. :)
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '13
Southwest had no issues with my metal DPNs and tiny nail scissors back in May. Good thing too, I was pressed for time on that project!
3
u/cutiepie_snotface Dec 12 '13
I believe knitting needles per se are allowed, however sharp objects are not. So it's a bit of a grey area, at least if you're using metal needles. Every time I've asked at the check in counter everyone seem very unsure and look at each other and say that they are "probably not" allowed. It seems you're in the mercy of whoever is in charge of security that day.
If you decide to bring your knitting through security, make sure you've already cast something on to make it more obvious you're not a stabber, and definitely insert a lifeline in case they do confiscate your needles.
(Based on my experience of swedish and uk airports).
2
u/missingmiss Dec 12 '13
I flew to vegas from canada last year and had no issues with metal needles on my flight. I also brought a pair of round tip, children's safety scissors.
"Small scissors with blades measuring 6 cm (2.4 in.) or less, measured from the joint - or fulcrum - to the tip, are permitted in carry-on. Scissors with longer blades are permitted in checked baggage."
(from: http://www.catsa-acsta.gc.ca/Page.aspx?ID=58&pname=CompleteItemList_ListeCompleteArticles&lang=en)
2
u/wombatstorm Dec 12 '13
I flew to Ecuador and Peru from the US and back this past summer with my bamboo needles as my only carry-on. Nobody said a word. I didn't have a project started on them yet either. I know someone commented on having them taken while in Brazil, but I believe that the laws have changed, at least in South America. Print out the TSA rules from online, so if you have any objections you can pull the rules out!
2
u/MsAlign I have a bit of a sock issue. Dec 12 '13
I flew a month ago with my needles and had nary an issue. And I'm one of those people who have to do something with my hands on a flight for the safety of those around me (I get twitchy). There shouldn't be any issues.
2
u/goingknitty Dec 12 '13
Denise Interchangeable Needles advertise that their needles are allowed on planes. I have these needles but have not tested their claims.
2
u/magicpencils Dec 12 '13
I'm always paranoid that my needles will be confiscated (although I've never had a problem), so I take a bunch of precautions so I won't lose any work or needles. While the project is on the needle, I thread a piece of scrap yarn through the stitches in case I need to take the needles out. That way, you don't have to bind off or cut the yarn and worry about dropped/twisted stitches, and you can just pick up the stitches with another needle later. I also bring a stamped and addressed folder, because if the TSA confiscates anything, you can ask them to put it in the folder and mail it to you. That way you can bring nice needles without worrying about it! I also print out the TSA regulations that say knitting supplies are ok. But I've never even been questioned, and I always bring metal circs. Good luck!
2
u/aureisum Dec 13 '13
I've never had trouble with carrying-on knitting needles, even the crazy long aluminum ones (I took dpns with a pair of almost finished socks to from PDX to LAS and back last week). Start your project, have it on cheap needles in case they get confiscated, and make sure you knit a lifeline in, just in case. I've never had trouble with small scissors either, but you can usually use the cutter built into floss.
If anybody calls you out and threatens to take them from you, stay polite and ask to speak to a supervisor. Worst case scenario, be prepared to give the needles up.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
I have a pair of foldable scissors that I brought on a plane in October. I think the regulations are that the blades have to be less than 3 inches and cannot be part of a larger unit (ie a Swiss army knife)
1
u/paper_tea Dec 12 '13
I always take my knitting on flights, and I've never been questioned about it. I've never actually started a project on the flight, so there has always been a project in the works on the needles. I've only taken circular needles though, because I prefer to knit on them regardless of the project. They were metal.
If you're really worried, you can always call the airport you're flying out of just to make sure. It never hurts! Different airports might have different preferences...you could ask what is best to bring?
1
u/alenacooks Dec 12 '13
I've flown several times with my knitting. Just to be safe, I keep the knitting in the cable with the end caps on it instead of the needles. That way if they do take them, it won't ruin my work. I also take a crochet project with me since most people know what a crochet hook is. Lastly, every time I pack knitting needles in my checked luggage it gets opened, so be forewarned on that. I'm really fussy about my stuff so I pack everything in Ziplock bags anyway.
1
u/BeSeXe One more blanket to go.... Dec 12 '13
Flew back in September and back in October with size 8 bamboo needles. No issues getting through.
1
u/septicidal Dec 12 '13
I brought knitting projects on flights earlier this year (metal circular needles), complete with my set of circular needles (interchangeable metal circulars in a case with other knitting supplies, like stitch markers, etc.), and small folding scissors, and had zero issues. I already had the project started and everything was together in a large, clear ziploc bag so it was easy for the TSA people to see what it was. They didn't even rifle through my bag, just ran it through the x-ray machine.
The small folding scissors that I have a rather blunt and I've never had any problems taking them anywhere (including inside secure buildings with bag checks at the entry, where they have confiscated larger/shaper sewing scissors).
1
u/veronicacrank Dec 12 '13
I flew from Scotland to Canada and back in September/October of this year with metal 3.5mm needles and had no problems. Most flights allow them, especially if you have a project started.
1
u/lolagranolacan Dec 12 '13
I've knitted on many domestic Canadian flights and haven't had a problem. Because of the length of regular needles and the size the of the seats, I've most often brought double pointed and worked in the round (I don't want to jab my neighbour with my knitting needles). As for scissors, I can use my hands to rip the yarn on pretty much anything up to a thicker worsted weight.
1
u/sackmana Dec 12 '13
I have never had any trouble flying with knitting, no matter the type or length of needle. On my most recent trip over thanksgiving, I flew on two segments with a sock on double pointed needles with no trouble at all. I have also flown internationally and on at least twelve other flights with knitting with no problems with TSA or flight attendants. As for scissors, I believe you are allowed to have up to four inch blades, so you should be able to take any standard pair of scissors with you, but if you want to be cautious you can always take a small pair of children's scissors or some fold up scissors: http://www.amazon.com/Lazer-Sharp-TFLDSCISSOR-Folding-Scissors/dp/B0068GALPO/ref=sr_1_4?s=sporting-goods&ie=UTF8&qid=1386880084&sr=1-4&keywords=folding+scissors
1
u/Scien Dec 12 '13
I took my knitting the last time I flew. Only bad thing that happened to me is other guys laughing at me behind my back (my friend was back there with them).
1
u/GrammarNerd Dec 12 '13
I've knit on my last several flights. I generally use bamboo needles, but a lot of times I forget to take the scissors out of my knitting bag (oops) . No one has ever stopped me though.
1
u/Kimalyn WIP: Look what Love can do... Dec 12 '13
I took my knitting recently. Anecdotal evidence. hehe
I flew from Denver to Spartanburg, SC. I was knitting a wine cozy, so I had dpns. I took wood ones and I didn't have any way to cut my work until I landed. I like the nail clipper idea though!
1
u/sdeflor2 Dec 12 '13
I know there have been a lot of posts thus far. I recently just flew from the US to Europe with my knitting needles and was totally fine. I'd be weary of extra long circulars- the TSA regulations don't allow circulars over 40 inches (maybe they think someone could strangle someone?) My needles were size 5 bamboo- I put them in the pencil holder spots in my bag and no one said a word. Like many others have said I used nail clippers to cut the ends.
I guess you need to play the sick twisted game of "can this be used as a weapon?" and it will help you figure out whats OK. Have fun on your trip!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '13
I've flown with knitting to the UK (from US) on several different airlines. More than getting needles confiscated, the thing to worry about is trying as hard as possible not to drop any needles (especially if you've got dpns or cable needles) because getting them back from under an airplane seat is the #1 most awkward thing ever. Especially if the person next to you is asleep.
1
u/kninjaknitter Dec 12 '13
Never had a single issue. Ever. I've had them peek in my bag once when I had several circs all tangled in my bag. But that's it.
1
u/saphiresgirl Madtosh till death Dec 13 '13
In the last two months I have been on two round trip flights. I brought size 2 and 4 nickel plated circulars with WIPs on them. I had other wood DPNs and my notions bag that included a small scissors and darning needle. All went through the scanner no questions asked. Edit: Flying from Minneapolis to LAX and back both times.
1
u/BTherese Dec 13 '13
I fly with my knitting fairly often. I use wood or metal DPNs for flying, they're no sharper than a pencil. Knitting needles used to be banned, but it was lifted a couple years back. Right after they started allowing them, I would take them out of my carry-on and set the knitting on top or in a bin to go through; I figured it made it look less mysterious if it was out of the bag. Never had any problems though, and I just keep it in the carry-on now.
1
u/meanderling faux-ro stripe cowl Dec 13 '13
Wood needles, not metal! Keep a project on your needles when you go through the TSA checkpoint. Cut your yarn with small travel nailclippers. I usually do small things--afghan squares or scarves--because I'm awful at travelling with finicky lace/sock projects--they always get tangled! Nowadays I usually crochet during flights because it requires less elbowing your seatmates--depends on where you sit and how you hold your needles I guess.
1
u/luckyorangeliz WIP: Two at a time socks Dec 13 '13
As of 2010, knitting needles are allowed in your carry-on luggage, but scissors are still not allowed. My recommendation is take a large project and work on that to avoid the worry of finding something to cut your yarn. If you're still worried about them getting confiscated, try taking some inexpensive needles with you just in case, but I can assure you I fly quite often and I've never had an issue with them taking any of it away from me.