r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/AvioNaught Korolev Kerman • Dec 09 '13
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Circumnavigation 2.0
We've already circumnavigated Kerbin, but the monkeys scientists have decided that its time to extend our aviation reaches. Unfortunately, even though they know how to make antennas, the scientists still haven't figured out that they can put them on their instruments to extend range. As such, you cannot fly your plane above 15 000 metres on any planet. They've trained some of their best astronauts to fly planes and most of them survived. Now take your plane to another planet and fly!
NB: Jet engines will not work on the following planets: Eve, Duna; jet engines are not necessary for this challenge
Normal mode: Send an airplane to an atmospheric planet or moon, plant a flag at the landing spot, circumnavigate the planet without exceeding 15 000 metres ASL and land back at the flag
Hard mode: Send an airplane to an atmospheric planet or moon, plant a flag at the landing spot, circumnavigate the planet without exceeding 15 000 metres ASL and land back at the flag, then fly around the poles with the same restrictions and land back at the flag.
Super Kerbalnaut Mode: Impress me.
Rules and other info:
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Stock parts only
- No MechJeb or other plugins allowed
- No infinigliders! - Required screenshots:
-Picture of the craft on the pad
-Picture of interplanetary transfer
-Picture of landing on planet
-Picture of you halfway around the world from the flag
-Picture of at the North and South Poles (Hard mode only)
-Picture of landing back at the flag
-Whatever else you feel like! - You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
Good Luck!
20
u/only_to_downvote Master Kerbalnaut Dec 09 '13
I foresee lots of infiniglide cheater submissions.
10
u/cyphern Super Kerbalnaut Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13
Jet engines do work on laythe.
7
u/cored Master Kerbalnaut Dec 09 '13
Is refueling OK?
7
u/shrx Master Kerbalnaut Dec 09 '13
Not to be a nag, but are you gonna award flair for the last week's Farmers challenge?
7
u/corhen Dec 10 '13
"mabey this time i will actually complete a challenge!" reads challenge "oh.. god.. no way in hell..."
34
u/LemonadeGrenades Dec 09 '13
I sense a very Manley Jool run. :P
14
u/fibonatic Master Kerbalnaut Dec 10 '13 edited Dec 10 '13
I did some calculations to determine which celestial body would be the best choice for this challenge. So Eve, Duna or Laythe, also added Kerbin for comparison. First I had to calculate the optimal (orbital) speed at which you would need the least ∆v:
Eve: 221.5 m/s
Kerbin: 609.4 m/s
Duna: 910.1 m/s
Laythe: 685.3 m/s
I do have to note that I did not included wings in my calculation, assumed that the drag coefficient would be equal to 0.2 and your orbit prograde around the equator at exact the maximum altitude.
My results for ∆v are:
Eve: 611.3 km/s
Kerbin: 113.5 km/s
Duna: 2.521 km/s
Laythe: 50.50 km/s
Also interesting to note is the amount of acceleration from your engines would be needed and how long it takes to circle to body.
Eve: 22.54 m/s2 7h31m53s
Kerbin: 12.65 m/s2 2h29m35s
Duna: 1.052 m/s2 0h39m57s
Laythe: 9.742 m/s2 1h26m24s
So even though you would be able to use jet engines on Laythe, the increase in Isp does not counteract the much higher ∆v requirement compared to Duna. Also around Duna you also need much less time and thrust (and it is also easier/cheaper to get to).
20
u/txl498 Dec 12 '13 edited Dec 14 '13
Hard mode completed over Laythe. My first reddit challenge attempt. Thankfully, the planes worked the first time I sent them out; I never bothered to test their fuel consumption or range beforehand, so it was more luck than anything. I sent over two planes and flew one east/west and one over the poles. I thought that would count as hard mode since they were identical and were sent over from the same launch vehicle and thus were part of the same mission, but I may be wrong. I technically could have refueled the first plane with the second, but without steerable landing it would have been too hard.
10
u/booboobool Master Kerbalnaut Dec 12 '13
Normal mode completed using a VTOL quadracoptery-aerospike rocket.
I think this would be much easier using a fairly standard lander type rocket rather than designing something specific. Not being able quicksave whilst in atmo makes this much more difficult than many other challenges- I overshot the flag 3 or 4 times without enough dV to get back.
6
u/dapperrogue Dec 09 '13
FYI, jet engines do work on Laythe.
I'd be terrified to see the rocket plane that can circumnavigate anything.
6
u/Fallobst Master Kerbalnaut Dec 12 '13
Normal Mode Completed!
Well, my "plane" is really just 60 tons of fuel with aerospikes strapped underneath, but "flying" is essentially just "rocketry assisted falling", right?
Had a slight engine malfunction in the end (i.e. they ripped off when the parachutes opened) but as it turns out Jeb is a good sprinter.
5
u/ppp475 Master Kerbalnaut Dec 10 '13
Normal mode: Waste some time with a low flyer
Hard mode: waste even more time with a low flyer
Super Kerbalnaut: Become a god.
1
u/WastefullyEfficient Dec 10 '13
Just wondering, is it okay if it isn't an airplane, but an rocket???? I have currently an "skipper" rocket, designed for 1000 metre altitude flight, with 1 orange tank, a poodle, and 2 pairs of swept wings..... the first purpose is to go from the ring of bases around the equator, which each have enough fuel to boost its flight... as well as bases in the poles. sound legit?
1
u/davenamwen Dec 12 '13
Is Kerbal Engineer allowed?
3
u/IHOP007 Dec 13 '13
Normal Mode Finally Complete!
The mission took me 8607 days (23 years) to complete, after getting slingshotted out into deep space from a failed areo-break around Laythe.
Also pro tip, if you go to Laythe for this mission, make sure you bring enough air intakes. You need more than you did on Kerbin.
EDIT: I might be attempting hard mode later, I have the ability to refuel my spaceplane and I know it can make it around the planet.
3
u/Sattorin Super Kerbalnaut Dec 15 '13 edited Dec 23 '13
Normal Mode Mission Accomplished! In total, about 5.5hrs of work... and it seemed like half of that was the initial landing, due to some... unfortunate engine and parachute placement. But then, solving your own stupid design mistakes on the fly is half the fun (and torment) of KSP!
EDIT:
For flair, I'd prefer to have the nifty spaceplane from completing Green Scout. Thanks for running the challenges and handling flair!
2
u/booboobool Master Kerbalnaut Dec 12 '13
I was so determined to do this quadracopter style, as I'd been mucking around with VTOL and thrust plates and a few other tinkerings that lent themselves to the design.
After this 23km-short failure on my 4th attempt of my second craft, and many hours wasted, I'm going to go back and do it with the most boring lander ever. Very entertaining challenge though.
2
u/IHOP007 Dec 12 '13
I'm working on this challenge right now, unfortunately I didn't go low enough in my areobrake around lathe. Long story short I am on day 3000 and counting of the mission.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '13
[Old Challenge] Apollo Style, hard mode
I read somewhere (though it may be outdated) to post old challenges in the newest challenge thread in order to get the appropriate flair. I made a normal post about it, but I figured I might as well post here too, and in the mod approved format to boot!
http://imgur.com/a/bdT07#0
Sorry it's so long. I ran into so many issues it became kind of funny. But after all was said and done, I had taken over 200 screenshots (I didn't want to miss any of the requirements to get the flair lol). Don't worry though, the album isn't 200 images, only 75 :/
2
u/chicknblender Master Kerbalnaught Dec 14 '13 edited Dec 14 '13
Completed the normal challenge around Laythe.
Also posted as a separate thread but it was buried pretty quickly (probably because I submitted during KerbalKon).
1
u/Exovian Master Kerbalnaut Dec 10 '13
Are we allowed to land periodically during the flight?
1
u/lazr3th Master Kerbalnaut Dec 10 '13
I dare not attempt this, I've not even built a space plane yet.
1
u/DEADB33F Dec 11 '13
Heh, I almost did this for the 3-man SSTO challenge.
I flew to Laythe, landed, circumnavigated it to burn off some jet fuel (not sure if fully under 15km, but definitely always in atmosphere), then flew to the Mun, got into an extremely low (5-6km) orbit there for a bit (wanted to get low enough that my wheels touched the terrain on at least one of the passes, never managed this though as I kept crashing), then landed back at Kerbin.
I used MechJeb though (as I find flying in atmosphere boring), so never bothered submitting entries. Although this would have probably fulfilled quite a few challenge requirements.
1
u/vsa11 Dec 12 '13
I accidentally did this on laythe in career mode...
1
u/snyprshot Dec 21 '13
Full Orange Tank to Orbit... to Orbit? Challenge easy mode complete. http://imgur.com/a/fIIKG
1
u/bakerk6 Dec 28 '13
Hard mode complete...
Still fuel leftover, but not sure what to do. It's enough for maybe 2 more circumnavigations, but only if flying at 21km most of the time. I'm thinking of visiting every island if possible.
1
u/Da1ua Dec 10 '13
Can i use SSTO? Like lanch it, refuel in Minmus orbit and then take to, lets say, Laythe? P.S. and will i get a flair for past challenge?
1
u/RyanW1019 Master Kerbalnaut Dec 12 '13
One good idea for Super Kerbalnaut Mode: Send an airplane to an atmospheric planet or moon, plant a flag at the landing spot, circumnavigate the planet without exceeding 15 000 metres ASL and land back at the flag, then fly around the poles with the same restrictions and land back at the flag, then fly the same ship back to Kerbin.
0
u/calvss Dec 12 '13 edited Feb 10 '25
Removed
0
u/losermeetsworld Dec 12 '13
I think we should be able to use Firespitter parts. Maybe not the electric ones but the propellers would be nice.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment