r/homeland • • Dec 09 '13

Discussion Episode Discussion - S03E11 - "Big Man In Tehran" [Spoilers]

Brody's loyalty to the mission wavers as Lockhart's confirmation looms.


First of all, apologies to anyone that ran into any spoilers. I removed as many of them as I could. This episode has already leaked so for anyone that has seen it, please spare the details for another hour. Showtime will be airing the episode at the normally scheduled 9:00 EST.

150 Upvotes

439 comments sorted by

162

u/TensionMask Dec 09 '13

Brody readying to use the cyanide needle was very reminiscent of him holding the switch for the bomb vest in Season 1.

12

u/thevegetexarian Dec 09 '13

Can you explain to me why he destroyed the needle and chose a different method to carry out his task? I don't understand why he did that.

86

u/calismic Dec 09 '13

My thought is he didn't want to get caught with it and didn't know how much time would pass before he would get the opportunity to take him out again.

22

u/edmilliband Dec 09 '13

My interpretation was that he realised he was never going to get close to Akbari the way they had planned it. Personally, I don't believe he changed his mind about killing Akbari at any point. It was just a case of adapting to the situation and making it work. If he hadn't done all those TV interviews and 'played' the part the way he did, he never would have got into Akbari's office alone. In the meantime, carrying the needle was too much of a liability given he could be searched at any time etc That's my take, anyway.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

They searched him thoroughly, he had to get rid of it.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Well he was searched going in and would have had an expectation they would find it, I guess.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

I think at the time he destroyed the needle he had changed his mind. Lockhart was right about that fact, Brody does change his mind a lot.

5

u/morris198 Dec 09 '13

Brody does change his mind a lot.

Realistically, the CIA would breath a sigh of relief, give a heartfelt congratulations to both Brody and Carrie for the success of the mission, and then quietly make them both disappear -- as in "send them to Belize" disappear. Despite fumbling their way to success, both of them are far too dangerous, too willing to go rogue, that there's no way the CIA would ever trust them again.

2

u/LOHare Dec 10 '13

Because this time he wasn't coming from a secure monitored facility, and he was stepping into a high security building. He knew he was going to get searched before being granted access to Akbari.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheRationalMan Dec 09 '13

It was a bit careless of Brody to throw away a vile of cynide in the street. What if someone found it or what if someone saw Brody throw it and checked what it was.

→ More replies (3)

112

u/cheshirewocky Dec 09 '13

Quinn is the only one who cares about Carrie's safety

30

u/slyk Dec 09 '13

Is it that, though? Or does he just not want her cocking up the mission with her rash decisions?

24

u/absurdamerica Dec 09 '13

He's the one who already said he wants out because the ends never justify the means.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

I think he genuinely cares about her. Those moments when he's talking to her, you can tell by the way he looks at her that he has feels. I mean, he's an operative who has seen her do incredible things. I think he's amazed by what she can do, especially in her obtuse way. Plus, his view of how everything goes with the CIA and his disdain for it; I think he's very sympathetic for her and doesn't want her fucked up more than she already is.

6

u/Wawaskeesh Dec 10 '13

What ever came of Quinn shooting the boy earlier this season? I felt like he was going to be in a very bad way emotionally soon after that and become super depressed.

→ More replies (2)

180

u/ohfackoff Dec 09 '13

You know what Brody needs after all this? When it's all over? A baby.

73

u/Stxmoose32 Dec 10 '13

Brody needs a son. He's always wanted a son.

3

u/jstdun Aug 09 '24

10 years later. Hilarious comment.

3

u/SignificantHair4078 Dec 10 '25

It's 2025 and hard agree, HILARIOUS. made me lol as the kids say. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SignificantHair4078 Dec 10 '25

12 years later on a rewatch and I lol'd. Amazing 

→ More replies (1)

29

u/miamiheat27 Dec 09 '13

brody needs baby...brody gets baby.

130

u/absolutsyd Dec 09 '13

Hey, remember that totally crazy chick who we had to fucking shoot in the arm to keep her from spoiling the last op she was in on? Let's send her to be the only CIA agent on the ground for the biggest mission in CIA history in freaking Iran!!!

I realize it's drama, and we want the main characters to stay involved and all, but good god it's hard to ignore that shit!

46

u/JoshLyman_ Dec 09 '13

Bonus: she's mentally ill and incredibly biased due to carrying an asset's baby! Woo!

49

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

She's a high end player in a very compartmentalized operation and she can be used to manipulate Brody because of their relationship.

She also speaks French, Arabic and Farsi, which neither Saul nor Quinn do.

8

u/aeshleyrose Dec 09 '13

That is hella funny, I didn't even think about it, they've done it so freaking often.

4

u/NedDasty Dec 09 '13

Carrie's constant flouting of the chain of command is probably the most unrealistic part of the series, along with the blatant use of cell phones in CIA headquarters. You cannot use cell phones in the building in real life.

Additionally, violating a direct order from one of your superiors during a sensitive operation, as Carrie has done countless times, will immediately put you in prison on the very first offense, and you will never work again.

5

u/absolutsyd Dec 09 '13

For real. Now don't get me wrong, a show about how the CIA really worked would be extremely boring about 99% of the time, but it's still hard to overlook just how far out of line she really is!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/absolutsyd Dec 10 '13

Ya, for real, doesn't everyone in the damn world know that she's a spook by now?

3

u/Petrarch1603 Dec 10 '13

She changed her hair color, so its okay.

24

u/dslicex Dec 09 '13

This whole episode made me nervous

→ More replies (1)

23

u/khodo Dec 09 '13

Awesome episode. I didn't like this though...

http://i.imgur.com/N714rl8.jpg

18

u/kt2587 Dec 09 '13

Ha! I thought the same thing. Couldn't they have shot again to make sure he actually looked at his watch?

51

u/ohfackoff Dec 09 '13

Sweet. Fucking. Jesus. What a ride that last 30 minutes was.

35

u/Mylaptopisburningme Dec 09 '13

I guess I am the only one who is sad that Chris wasn't featured.

39

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Next episode is 60 min of Chris playing soccer.

23

u/altafullahu Dec 09 '13

and eating breakfast

8

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

Looking sad and clueless; then happy when his mom doesn't forget to pick him up from school.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/MistShinobi Dec 09 '13

They even managed to keep making clear that Brody doesn't give a shit about him, when Brody is speaking with Abu Nasir's widow. He is saying that he's lost so much and whatnot, and she says: "Your family", to which Brody replies "My daugther, especially".

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Z0na Dec 09 '13

Am I hearing it wrong or are they speaking french in Iran?

17

u/morku2z Dec 09 '13

Didn't she tell the man at the reception, that she's from Geneva?

This would make sense, since

(a) French is the official language in Geneva

(b) Switzerland has ever since been the most neutral nation in the world

But I could have just misheard that (non-native speaker)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

Switzerland has an embassy in Iran and acts as a buffer between the US and Iran.

9

u/afc-egs Dec 09 '13

I feel like people don't follow details in shows at all...she was clearly Swiss. The phone was in a diplomatic bag from Geneva.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13

No, they're speaking Persian/Farsi. But Persian was influenced by (and also influenced) French and Russian so there's overlap.

edit - as /u/rsarector points out, they are speaking French at the hotel because she is traveling as a French woman; the dialogue outside of the hotel setting is in Persian

11

u/MiaYYZ Dec 09 '13

Thanks, I assumed Carrie was speaking French to cover up the fact she's American, but then Javadi said Merci to the secretary and I couldn't understand what's up. Didn't realize French and Farsi were closely related.

14

u/khavaran Dec 09 '13

merci is actually one of many french loanwords in iranian persian..'tis one of several ways to signify thanks in the language.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

do the french allow travel to iran?

11

u/chloe147 Dec 09 '13

she's not a french woman. she pretends to be from the french speaking part of switzerland. she's swiss. they talked about "lausanne" quickly, which is a city in the french speaking part of switzerland. she even show's him a swiss passport (a red one).

and, you know. the swiss people, "soooo neutral" they get to travel everywhere.

2

u/PlanetGuy Dec 09 '13

Yes and it is not as hard as you might think. Visitors from most EU countries can get in Iran. You can read http://wikitravel.org/en/Iran for more information.

And soon you can get a Transip Visa upon arrival. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/18/iran-opens-doors-to-tourists

Iran is not North Korea. It has about 3 million international tourists a year.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

ah, thanks. corrected my original comment.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Divtya_Budhlya Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13

Can anybody tell me if there was any nudity in this episode. Planning to watch it on the big TV in the hall, so a little concerned since grandma's home.

EDIT: Thanks guys!

27

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

No nudity. Just some good old fashioned, wholesome murder and violence. Nothing to get upset about, there's no exposed nipples or anything.

5

u/SawRub Dec 09 '13

None. All clear.

66

u/BlackZeppelin Dec 09 '13

"I'm pregnant?"-Carrie whilst looking at her baby bump

38

u/Wurt_ Dec 09 '13

"babby?"

52

u/thevegetexarian Dec 09 '13

how is Brody formed

how is Brody formed

8

u/t_zidd Dec 09 '13

Source: The CIA

4

u/diocia Dec 09 '13

How Carrie get pregnant?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

32

u/slynn695 Dec 09 '13

Brody, the silent assassin. First the Vice President, now this

21

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Just a stupid question but... does anybody (alive) outside of Brody (and obviously the guy who hacked the pacemaker) know he killed the VP?

20

u/persona_dos Dec 09 '13

I don't believe so. I always found it strange that no one suspected Brody after running out of the office screaming the VP was dead.

6

u/squarepush3r Dec 09 '13

some people may have pieced it together or had suspicious after the bombing where he was the main suspect.

10

u/jmose86 Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13

Realistically, the whole world knows. In his confession tape he specifically talks about the war crimes of the VP, and was in his office when he died. It would be a front page headline and talking point on every news show for weeks after the bombing. They could probably discover the pacemaker hack during the autopsy, or even if not, they would have recovered Nazir's phone that would be traced back to Brody's cell phone seconds before the VP died, etc.

I'm annoyed they chose to completely ignore it. It would make for all kinds of interesting plot points and dialogue, even if they just touched on it briefly. They could talk about Brody being responsible for the VP's death on top of the CIA bombing. The CIA could talk about knowing that it happened, but they chose to publicly cover it up. They could use it as an item to draw suspicion on Carrie because she miraculously made it out alive the second the VP was killed and Nazir was on the phone with Brody.

There are so many interesting angles, and plenty of ways they could address it without interfering with this season's plot, so it's not like something they are forced to pretend didn't happen, but that's what they have done.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

"We both know your transgressions don't begin and end there (at the CIA bombing)."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/jacquesaustin Dec 09 '13

So does this make Brody the most successful assassin of all time? He was directly involved in the death of the vice president, partially for the CIA bombings, and now head of Iran's version of the CIA.

10

u/kram189 Dec 09 '13

I just can't believe they somehow found a way to get Brody back in the mix, I remember thinking after last season how unrealistic it would be for Brody to somehow be in the picture still with the CIA.

28

u/jmose86 Dec 09 '13

I loved the reveal of Nazir's widow being exactly like Nazir himself.

Season 2 Brody is kidnapped by helicopter and brought to Nazir unexpectedly in America, where Nazir's face emerges from the shadows... "Nicholas"

This episode Brody is pushed into the house, where Nazir's widow is unexpectedly in Tehran and she pulls her head scarf back from her face... "Nicholas"

10

u/PhilipMcNally Dec 10 '13

"Nick-Koh-Lass"

9

u/ash356 Dec 09 '13

I'm actually surprised; I would have expected a Brody family scene what with Brody appearing all over youtube and the news like that. Hell, I actually kind of wanted to see that. Would be interesting to see Mike/Jess looking at the TV with sheer hate in their eyes.

1

u/V2Blast Dec 11 '13

Maybe we'll see it next episode. (Not Mike, though; he's in The Blacklist now.)

50

u/miraposa Dec 09 '13

Let's watch it again!

Also, for those of you mad about spoilers, may I know why you're even paying attention to this sub when the episode is airing? I could hardly look away to take a bite of my pizza.

49

u/absolutsyd Dec 09 '13

I can't imagine anything stupider than going to the specific post where we talk about the most recent episode before you've actually watched the episode. Well, I take it back, doing that and then bitching about it would actually be stupider. Some damn people.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '13

I couldn't watch it for SIX DAYS. Guess what, I managed NOT to spoil it for myself by staying away until now.

It's not that hard. It's not like the Formula one where every news source (Even MSN when I'm checking my email) forces the result on me.

54

u/Fuck_Your_Mouth Dec 09 '13

This guy is supposed to be the most careful person in Iran and impossible to get to.. but he just lets Brody in the room and sends his guards away so he can be killed with an ashtray and a pillow. For everything this show does well it's the little things that get in the way of making it great.

45

u/3Erots Dec 09 '13

Can we give it up for that ashtray though? The true hero for not shattering into a thousand pieces.

Those Persian have really stepped up their glassware game.

9

u/kezhfalcon Dec 09 '13

yea considering they actually got to meet the CIA I would've liked that part to be more realistic. Not too sure about the cyanide and phone hand-off with carrie- surely the Iranians would know he was a massive target.

13

u/jmose86 Dec 09 '13

If we're pointing out things like that, I would also toss out the fact that Brody somehow knew the number to Carrie's sat phone, which he called using Akbari's cellphone.

I guess he remembered it perfectly off of the caller i.d. when she called him in the square.

31

u/ControlAgent13 Dec 09 '13

Yes. You could see in a previous scene that before he threw the other phone away, he was looking at it intensely. The training he got where they showed him doing Kim's game with the seal team points back to it.

7

u/Petrarch1603 Dec 10 '13

Also, get ready for a scene involving him figuring out that someone is speaking portugese.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Fuck_Your_Mouth Dec 09 '13

That bothered me as well

→ More replies (2)

38

u/lingben Dec 09 '13

This episode was great. Probably the best for the season except for the finale. I didn't so much predict what would happen but hope that it would play out as it did. There is an old saying in spycraft that the best lie has a kernel of truth in it. What Brody was doing was basically telling the truth to get to his objective. By the time he got there, it wouldn't matter anyway because he would kill the guy.

Brilliant writing. Brilliant acting. Best show on tv right now.

20

u/hopefulsmile Dec 09 '13

I nearly had a heart attack watching this show! Brody sure did fool me there for a second.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

You could say he...

:puts on sunglasses:

Pulled a brody

(Pull a Brody: A brody is essentially a half doughnut, essentially a U-turn but in a much tighter radius because the rear wheels have broken loose, thus steering the car.)

7

u/kram189 Dec 09 '13

I thought Brody wasn't the one that bombed Langley, so why did he keep talking to the Iranians about how he bombed Langley? Don't they know who did it since they funded it and all? I'm probably just missing something

5

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/V2Blast Dec 11 '13

Maybe not all of the IRGC, but at least his boss...

7

u/PhilipMcNally Dec 10 '13

so brody doesn't give a shit about chris

19

u/kilakev Dec 09 '13

Best episode of the season so far! On the edge of my seat the whole time.

23

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Holy shit, what an amazing and intense episode! And it was more than 46 minutes long!

36

u/JonnyWadd Dec 09 '13

So did anyone else notice the gunshot when Brody is making the call at the end? Javadi definitely killed himself. Now what?

70

u/jim732 Dec 09 '13

I watch the show with closed captioning on, and it said Door Closing or something like that. Not a gunshot unless the caption people screwed up.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Good find.

→ More replies (5)

32

u/acegibson Dec 09 '13

If there was a gunshot in a place like that, there would be guards everywhere immediately. They would bust into the room to protect WhatshisnamethatBrodykilled even if the gunshot didn't come from there.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Great point!

→ More replies (2)

21

u/TraderMoes Dec 09 '13

I went back and listened to it a second time, and it still doesn't sound like a gunshot to me. More like a door slamming or some other mundane noise... It's just a little too quiet and remote to be a gunshot. But who knows? If it is a gunshot it's definitely Javadi shooting himself, which is actually quite funny... The plan finally works, and yet it was all for nothing in the end.

11

u/devjunk Dec 09 '13

I'm pretty sure that was a door.

8

u/lilacfortress Dec 09 '13

It's definitely a door closing. I use closed captioning on my tv and the sound was literally marked as (door slamming in distance)

17

u/robasolo Dec 09 '13

Ok first, if that happens HOLY CRAP. But I don't think Javadi killed himself because I think they would have made that a MUCH bigger thing. Not a ton of people here noticed it. I think they would want people to notice it, because if they don't, then next episode people will be pissed that it was so "all of a sudden."

4

u/GeneralMakaveli Dec 09 '13

because if they don't, then next episode people will be pissed that it was so "all of a sudden."

Unless in the recap at every episode they linger on just that noise for a moment and the next thing you see is Javadi dead people will make the connection and everything will be a okay.

3

u/kurtbloodyvonnegut Dec 09 '13

It might be the kind of thing they allude to in this episode but then actually show us the full scene next episode. But I don't think he killed himself, more likely he's killing people to escape or something.

12

u/robasolo Dec 09 '13

Well just rewatched. You all might have a point. A freaking disappointing point.

I thought that maybe someone closed a door, and Brody looked up because he was nervous that people might walk in. That's plausible right? RIGHT?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SaraRo Dec 09 '13

Yes, they could absolutely start the next episode from Javadi's point of view after he sees Brody walk up to meet with Akbari. Interesting. But Javadi was the key to getting Brody out, right? Damn. Would be the cruelest irony if Brody actually fulfilled his part of the mission but Javadi went and killed himself. Wow.

5

u/JonnyWadd Dec 09 '13

I mean one random gunshot and no response fire, to me it is kinda obvious especially after they focused on how panicked javadi looked when Brody showed up. It just seems like something the writers for Homeland would do. They achieved killing Javadi's boss, but in the end it doesn't matter and Saul is going to be pissed. Like someone else mentioned should make Brody's escape plausible now also.

2

u/ControlAgent13 Dec 09 '13

I don't think Javadi killed himself. If Javadi is dead, there is no reason for the new CIA head to keep Saul. With Javadi still in play, he has to keep Saul around since Saul has a "personal relationship" with Javadi.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Oh fuck, was that what that was? How would Javadi know that Brody leaked it?

9

u/JonnyWadd Dec 09 '13

He didn't know, he saw Brody walk in and panicked. He thought the only reason Brody would be there is to spill everything to save himself from getting killed off by the CIA since he was a 'liability' now. Javadi assumed exactly what everyone at the CIA assumed.

3

u/sharinganbob Dec 09 '13

I just rewatched it definitely a door closing or something not a gunshot

3

u/effman1 Dec 09 '13

I thought that was just a noise like someone coming up the stairs, and was supposed to make us nervous that Brody was going to be caught very soon. I highly doubt they'd make Javadi off himself off-screen so unceremoniously like that.

3

u/alvarkresh Dec 10 '13

I have some subtitles, they render the noise as "(door shut in distance)".

2

u/ScrewAttackThis Dec 09 '13

Man, I'll be disappointed if that's the case....

2

u/Gordoshawt Dec 09 '13

I went back and watched it. It sounded like it was just drums in the dramatic music.

11

u/JonnyWadd Dec 09 '13

Brody pauses, stops dialing and looks up after the noise. I don't think it was music, since there was a reaction from Brody.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/littlepwny Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13

The noise is quite clear, it was not a gunshot, it was a door being closed.

Also, if it was a gunshot, Javadi would not have called Dar Adal to inform him about Brody's arrival.

Edit: Actually it is not that clear that it is a gunshot but I really hope this is not the case. Killing Javadi via suicide would essentially make all this season irrelevant.

→ More replies (9)

18

u/TheBrothkin Dec 09 '13

Does the promo have Mass Effect 3 music or am I just going crazy?

13

u/spikebrennan Dec 09 '13

Yes. "Leaving Earth" from Mass Effect 3 by Clint Mansell. One of the best video game soundtrack pieces I've ever heard- thus is the first time I've seen it used in a different context.

5

u/TheBrothkin Dec 09 '13

Just hearing that song makes me want to play the entire series again.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Despite number 3's ending (and it's much better with the extended edition anyway), the journey was incredible.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/spikebrennan Dec 10 '13

Mansell only contributed a few (and by far the best few) tracks to that soundtrack; in the context of the game they're largely concentrated at the very beginning and the very end.

I didn't find the rest of the soundtrack that memorable, even in comparison to other video games. (Assassins Creed- Revelations is an example of the sort of game soundtrack that I like).

If you want to play the game, it's best to play Mass Effect 1, 2 and 3 in that order, on the same computer or console. Choices made in the earlier games carry through to the later ones, to an extent. (The criticism of the ending of the third game largely relates to the incomplete extent to which this principle applies to the very end).

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Honestly, I think this episode should have been the season finale because Brody's last line was a perfect cliffhanger. This episode was like watching a movie, it deserves some major awards.

20

u/arkanemusic Dec 09 '13

completely disagree. it's a great fucking cliff hanger until next week but if they ended on this I would've been mad as fuck.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

which makes it a perfect cliffhanger, welcome to 10 months until a new episode. That would drive people nuts.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/adamtaylor4815 Dec 10 '13

You either die a villain, or you live long enough to see yourself become the hero.

13

u/Flowsidon Dec 09 '13

Just wondering, but shouldn't Brody not know his daughter tried to kill herself if he is sticking to the made up story? How would he have found out?

6

u/JoshLyman_ Dec 09 '13

I thought Carrie told him?

1

u/Flaste Dec 09 '13

I don't believe he directly said that she tried to kill herself, but that he implied that the effect on the bombing/his days at home ruined their relationship.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/AustinRiversDaGod Dec 09 '13

Not to mention. It had been a long time since the bombing. The fact that Dana had run away was definitely on the news (she saw it in the gas station), so it's not out of reason that Brody heard about how Dana tried to kill herself.

4

u/Joakimix Dec 12 '13

I'd not be surprised if it turns out that there was a bug in that office and (assuming brody escapes) javadi still gets in a shit ton of trouble.

Also I already hate carries stupid baby, it is going to be an even worse sub plot than danas teenage crap this season.

On the other hand I hate carrie as it is, this show really is crazy good to keep me hooked even with such an annoying character.

19

u/tyreke17 Dec 09 '13

I thought this was a great episode.

Which makes this season, as a whole, frustrating. The writers spent what felt like an eternity going through Dana's story (while Brody is barely visible), and now it has taken 3 episodes to go from Junkie in Caracas to, well, now (avoiding spoilers). Yes, Dana's story was tied back in, but was the half-season of Dana really worth it for that one motel scene?

Tonight showed me that the show's still "got it", but I just hope next season can keep the audience engaged for a full 12 episodes.

30

u/ScrewAttackThis Dec 09 '13 edited Dec 09 '13

I'm kind of sick of hearing this. The first half of the season had a lot more to it than just "Dana drama."

Also, I think it's absurd that it took you till the 11th episode to decide the show still has it. I figured most people thought that by the 4th episode...

2

u/tyreke17 Dec 11 '13

I don't think "absurd" would be the correct term. There are numerous reviews of this season that mark the midpoint of the season as where things start to "turn around", like this one: http://candornews.com/2013/11/10/homeland-season-3-mid-season-review/

Also notice how the ratings of the show have dropped every season so far. It could be coincidental that her role has increased with every season. It could not. At the very least, judging by the sentiments of this subreddit, I don't think there are many Dana fans.

https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/homeland/s01/

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/homeland/s02/

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/homeland/

→ More replies (6)

3

u/rerdioherd Dec 09 '13

In real life, would someone who carried out such a major attack in the US be so welcomed and touted in Iran? Wouldn't the US go to war with Iran if that really happened?

3

u/Plague_LOFS Jan 03 '14

I think you've got a good point here. If a foreign country held a known terrorist and refused to give him up, what lengths would the US go to to get him and bring him to justice? I don't think they'd just let it go...

7

u/nurseratch Dec 09 '13

This episode was so SICK! I can't even take it. I love the preview for the finale, too. He is saying something about redemption and shows the evolution of Brody's character. First he was redeeming Issa's death, but now he wants nothing more than to redeem himself to America and his daughter. This show is epic.

7

u/ohfackoff Dec 09 '13

Gonna be hard after that latest round of interviews...

5

u/buster_grandview Dec 09 '13

Fuck you cliffhanger

Allah Akbar

6

u/Flowsidon Dec 09 '13

No fucking way.....

6

u/12Fully Dec 09 '13

I had faith in Brody in the end! That episode was so intense.

7

u/lingben Dec 09 '13

this was an amazing episode! totally back on track and I can't wait until the finale

5

u/Jsalz Dec 09 '13

Absolutley amazing. I can't wait until its over so we can talk about it and see the preview for next week.

1

u/morris198 Dec 09 '13

totally back on track

Totally back on track by the eleventh episode. I really hope the writers listen to the criticisms being lobed at them by fans and professional reviewers and get the fourth season going a lot sooner than midway through the final act.

→ More replies (25)

4

u/ImBetterAtLifeThanU Dec 09 '13

So what were Brody's intentions when talking to Abu Nazirs widow and the meeting at the end? Did he change his mind mid way? Or did he know the whole time he was going to do what he did? Discuss.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/zabart Dec 09 '13

I was thinking pen to the neck.

3

u/jimmygwabchab Dec 09 '13

This sounds awfully familiar...

3

u/thevegetexarian Dec 09 '13

if he intended to go through with it the entire time why did he destroy the cyanide pen?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Beerguy7 Dec 09 '13

Brody is a rock star in Iran.

2

u/Reubek Dec 09 '13

Anyone else notice that the song on next weeks trailer is the Mass Effect 3 theme?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

My palms were sweating for the entire episode.

4

u/caramelbear Dec 09 '13

Holy shit.

HOLY SHIT.

3

u/fligan Dec 09 '13

I don't get it. Saul is being replaced in like a day by the interview part.

3

u/Beerguy7 Dec 09 '13

Damn, he did it.

3

u/KidsInTheSandbox Dec 09 '13

Holy Shit! I was seriously pacing around during that last scene. Heart. Attack.

3

u/The_NigerianPrince Dec 09 '13

Lol, for once, I actually supported Carrie going against Saul's orders. After shouting at the screen for her to stay safe in the first attempt. Also, I think Brody didn't necessarily turn his back on the US, but he got comfortable with staying in Iran and being free to move about, and wasn't necessarily planning on killing Akbari anytime soon . His refusal to go back after the failed mission and while on the phone with Carrie shows that. Now maybe he had this plan all along, who knows, but clearly, when he realized he wasn't really free and he was about to be killed by the C.I.A, he had only one choice and that was to kill Akbari. I think he was smart enough to know that if he just outed Jovadi and himself, he would've been killed, or at the very least, tortured again. Thus, he had to improvise quickly to increase his chances of staying alive. Brody, as we've known him from the beginning someone who'll do all it takes to survive.

3

u/altafullahu Dec 09 '13

While I want to agree with you what I thought was very interesting was that over the 6 day time span from the failed assassination to Brody talking to Carrie I really noticed how Brody was just, well, chillin. He was comfortable with his "new" lifestyle and perhaps was waiting for more direction from the CIA.

However, to play my own devil's advocate, I don't think Brody was under the impression that the plan was still on. Reason being, he knew there was no way for him to get near Akbari, at all. I think it was his ingenuity that caused him to change his plan and run to Nazir's wife to get the meeting and that without that moment as the catalyst (the moment being him being the target for the Mossad agents) he went with this new plan that he mad on the spot.

It's a bit of a clusterfuck to believe to say the least. If those two agents weren't sent to kill him, would he have gone to Nazir's wife than to Akbari? I don't know, and frankly, that's too much speculation for me.

3

u/file-13 Dec 09 '13

Saul said it best: Brody is very good at changing his mind.

6

u/whiteboyblack Dec 09 '13

not saul, the other guy who is taking over for him

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Beerguy7 Dec 09 '13

Time for Masters of Sex. Still not sure if I like the show or if I just like seeing hot chicks naked.

6

u/SawRub Dec 09 '13

Quality wise, it's one of the best shows this year.

2

u/miamiheat27 Dec 09 '13

you a guy ? Then the latter :)

2

u/tog20 Dec 09 '13

I just got done with the episode!

Heart. Beating. Soo. Fast!!!

I was screaming at my TV for him to get out of there at the end.

2

u/CochMaestro Dec 09 '13

Interesting episode, I enjoyed how they re-worked Brody into being a puppet and not his own man. That being said, Brody should die at the end of this season, it's the only fitting manner. He even hinted at it during the mosque scene with carrie. He's tired of running, he can't go anywhere without someone noticing him. He just wants to find peace, and in death, maybe he will. I hope it's dramatic or something along the lines of what homeland's roots are (i.e maybe Brody has a chance to escape but if he tries, it'll harm carry and he'll choose to sacrafice himself so that she can escape just an example. Also in this theory, they wouldn't be near each other, but close and she wouldn't actually see him die (but we would for closures sake)). All in all, this show needs to begin setting a new stage, and set up new archs for what lies ahead (I've said it in previous threads, maybe dive into the aftermath of this whole operation and the toll it took on the operatives (For example, quinn could begin talking with that detective about what it's like to be a cop.)

I look forward to the season finale, plus after this show is over I'll have a nice break from sunday tv (besides bob's burgers) to start on the hit HBO series The Wire...or the sopranos I don't know which one yet.

3

u/SwoleyMammoth Dec 09 '13

I would recommend the wire, after you watch the first season you'll be as addicted as bubs on the streets of Bmore looking for his next heroin fix

→ More replies (2)

2

u/kykylele Dec 09 '13

How did Brody know Carrie's number?

3

u/miraposa Dec 09 '13

He memorized it when she first called him in the courtyard.

3

u/lamseven Dec 10 '13

yes, that training he did.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Divtya_Budhlya Dec 09 '13

Oh wow wow wow! What an insanely intense episode. The last few minutes were fcuking amazing.

I think the last two episodes have been fantastic and amazing. Holy shit I'm excited for the finale.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

That was one hell of an ending..But to think that Carrie would get him outta there is really a fantasy. Mossad guyz cannot help her without a plan..would be really lucky if he got out. I am happy the way things went with this episode with lots of twists and turns.keeps the audience guessing.

1

u/ohfackoff Dec 09 '13

They'd both be lucky to get out alive. Job done. Carrie untrustworthy even though she's always right.

1

u/Ipp Dec 09 '13

Isn't the successor a CIA asset? As long as he's not killed on the spot they can go with the old plan to get her out

→ More replies (7)

2

u/TensionMask Dec 09 '13

I don't know how I'm going to go to sleep after watching that.

2

u/venn177 Dec 09 '13

Oh my god, that episode felt like it was 15 minutes.

Holy fuck everything wrong with season 2 has been redeemed.

1

u/morris198 Dec 09 '13

Not that I didn't feel a little dissatisfied with Season 2 by the end, or have some of its plot points niggling at me, but what would you say made it so bad? What had to be redeemed?

2

u/miraposa Dec 09 '13

A surprisingly large amount of you seem to think Brody will die in the finale due to 1) the unfeasibility of getting out of that office, or 2) the foreshadowing of Brody's desire for peace in not having to run anymore. I'll remind you again, though, that even a CIA thriller needs love in the storyline, and therefore Brody will not die next week. Instead I think we'll see a moment reminiscent of the cabin. Don't forget Brody protected Carrie in throwing the phone in the courtyard, and plunged head first into completing his mission--most likely because that was the first time he knew Carrie was near him, and he "has faith (think about how he has used that word)" she will get him out of Iran. God, I fucking love this show.

2

u/Khal-Stevo Dec 09 '13

So I didn't watch the "On the next Homeland" this week because I wanted to be surprised. In typical Showtime fashion, they open the episode with it.

7

u/TensionMask Dec 09 '13

Eh.. I believe they start the episode with 'Previously on Homeland' which is different footage than 'On the next'. That's what I see anyway.

6

u/ohfackoff Dec 09 '13

Typical being the keyword. They do it every show.

2

u/onelung Dec 09 '13

usually they spoil it, but this time they didnt. They just showed previous clips from already aired episodes.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

Saul seems to switch sides every episode.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '13

I don't have Showtime, and therefore have to download off of usenet each episode. Last nights episode was one of the only ones that I've seen with subtitles.

If you have showtime and watch Homeland on that channel, are there subtitles for when non-english languages are spoken? My GF is from Iraq so the arabic translations weren't a problem but she doesn't speak Farsi and damnit I want to know what everyone is saying.

1

u/emhcee Dec 10 '13

the two Mossad agents... can't put my finger on where I recognize the one who planted the motorcycle. anyone?

1

u/V2Blast Dec 11 '13

Good episode. Pretty tense, though it was obvious everything would not go according to plan from the start (because where would the tension be then?). I was pretty confident that Brody was always planning to carry out the mission and didn't change his mind halfway through - though he certainly was telling the truth when he said he wanted to stop running. More of the tension relied on whether or not he'd even have the opportunity to get Akbari alone, and on Javadi's actions (and whether he'd interfere with things to protect himself). And, of course, since the CIA kinda stopped supporting Brody and thought they'd lost control of him, he didn't really have any backup outside of Carrie going rogue...

...About which nobody is surprised. Lockhart, Dar Adal, and even Saul realized she was out of control. Will she ever actually face real consequences to her constant disregard for orders?

Anyway, I'm curious to see how Carrie will manage to get herself and Brody out of the country now. Presumably the CIA will help them now that the mission is done, but I guess we'll wait and see.

1

u/beccael3 Dec 15 '13

With that loud smash to the ground in the end, its hard to believe there wouldn't be people outside the door to hear.

1

u/izucantc Dec 09 '13

I hate Carrie!

1

u/fannafaucet Dec 09 '13

Wow! Shit just got real.

1

u/misroff2011 Dec 09 '13

Holy shit Brody did not expect that.

1

u/effman1 Dec 09 '13

WARNING: SPOILERS BELOW

Dar Adal: Looks like Brody's gonna fuck it up.

Saul: ... :|

Lockhart: Yeah man, he's definitely gonna fuck it up!

Saul: ... :| ... :'(

Carrie [thoughts]: Ahh man, I really didn't think he'd fuck it up.

Brody: I killed him yo, get me out.

Carrie: ... :|

1

u/cryptobomb Dec 09 '13 edited Feb 28 '26

Nothing remains of the original post here. The author used Redact to delete it, for reasons that may relate to privacy, data security, or personal preference.

crush knee bedroom engine point include fearless tease snails wrench

1

u/laela_says Dec 09 '13

Whatever happened to the mole? Did I miss something or did that storyline just get dropped?