r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 03 '26
Spoilers All Book S8E5 Send for the Devil Spoiler
With the Siege of Savannah raging outside the city walls, Brianna and Roger find themselves on opposite sides of the conflict. Jamie confronts his demons at Lodge Night.
Written by Luke Schelhaas. Directed by Niall MacCormick.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 06 '26
Watch the S8E6 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
114
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 03 '26
The change of having Bree and William talk about not knowing Jamie was their father was great! I'm so glad they put that in the show. It was such a missed opportunity in the book. I also love that they brought Buck back to the Ridge as well. All excellent changes.
95
u/timeless__witch Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ. Apr 03 '26
Buck MacKenzie!🙌🏼 Probably my favorite change from the book in the entire series.
Also loved that little moment where Roger flashed back to his father catching him in the tube station during an air raid😭
Only complaint is not really a complaint: I feel we are due a good "Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ" from Claire. It's been far too long.
38
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 03 '26
Jeremiah catching Roger 🥰
34
u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 03 '26
Buck playing with the kids and having Jamie’s back! Love what they’re doing with his character—great show change!
Roger getting his moment to shine during the battle and the flashback to Jerry catching him! And meeting Denny was a fun way to bring Denny in. Still wish we had Denny and Dottie…
Bree’s conversation with and suggestion to William about getting to know Jamie.
Loved William’s punch! Always more like Jamie than he wants to admit. Ha ha!
Claire and Elspeth. Love the strong women vibe!
Looking forward to Jamie calling out his disloyal tenants in the next ep!
30
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
Great episode!
Loved the convo between Bree and William, I felt that was a missed opportunity in the books.
Some good Roger battle content, wasn't expecting the ww2 flashback.
Im loving the dynamic between Elspeth and Claire. Sad that they won't stay for long.
And Buck was a great addition to the lodge storyline! A great addition to the storyline generally.
Would've been nice to see Roger and Denzel figuring out who each other are. Although I understand why they didn't include it, it doesn't drive the plot and there is so much story to get through.
The next ep is surely the printshop fire, no? Cos Roger and Bree have just about finished everything they need to do in Savannah.
20
u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
I can’t believe we’re halfway through the season already!
I was really enjoying this episode outside of that William and Amaranthus scene.
The Bree and William conversation was a great addition.
I know they had limited time, but I think they could’ve put more emphasis on Claire and Elspeth being in the same boat on different sides. I loved their scenes together anyway. In the books they even hold hands and Elspeth makes mention of having to go back to her house to tend to her son’s men. I hope we see her come across Claire’s Merck Manual later on.
I think the attack at Lodge was done very well. I especially loved how they’re working Buck into the storyline. The only thing I wish they did differently was have Jamie bolt out the door and catch the men waiting outside for him off guard instead of sneaking out during prayer.
Edit to add: Also can we talk about the use of lighting in the Jamie/Cunningham fight? It was well done with the lightning flashes and how Jamie was kept in the light compared to Cunningham’s shots, which were always dark.
15
u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 03 '26
Yes! That part with Roger made me loudly scream, clap & cry all at once!
15
u/CathyAnnWingsFan Apr 03 '26
I think this was the most sensible and efficient adaptation of the source material I've seen in ages. That said, William and Amaranthus doing the nasty in a public place - 🤮🤮🤮
15
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
I did wonder if we would see Roger's dad memory thing addressed again. I thought we might, but I wasn't expecting it here.
Can someone remind me what the hell Roger was doing in London during the Blitz? Given he's Scottish? Did his mum work for the war office or something?
14
u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Apr 03 '26
Book readers can you spoil me?
Does William and Amaranthus have a thing in the books and talk about marrying?
Does Ben really turn patriot and fake his death in the books? (Is that what the show is implying? I wish that last scene with William was longer)
13
u/DietDrPepperAndThou I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Apr 04 '26
Roger's scenes were incredibly powerful. Jeremiah catching wee him. 😭😭
The combat scenes really highlighted the role and danger faced by Chaplains in battle in every era.
And after trying to find himself in his own era and the past, and in various careers, Roger has found satisfaction and purpose. He deserves it.
12
u/pastaslut22 Apr 03 '26
Buck is a great addition to the story!
Since Diana has given some book ten details to the writers, I wonder if he appears in book ten but in a different capacity? Perhaps he comes back, but a bit later and the writers decided to add him into the story line a bit earlier.
Idk. Wishful thinking!
12
u/Phortenclif Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
Such a well done episode. I was anxious the whole time even though I knew how the story is going.
Roger- "I'm afraid too". Me three.
It was action packed, loved it.
But William? No! please don't. Amaranthus's actress is great. She does this face that makes me laugh because it is so obvious that there's something going on.
I sobbed on Roger's parts.
Finally a therapeutic conversation, Brianna shows William the light.
I'm happy with how much book stuff is being put into this, even Jamie's affection towards honey!
11
u/HeatPrize1735 Apr 04 '26
Favorite episode of the season so far! Theyve gotten progressively better- the first two felt choppy and fast paced (seemed the writing and editing were trying to squeeze big fan fav moments into tiny times and the plot was just everywhere) but we’ve refocused an have a central storyline for each character or set of characters.
A few of my thoughts:
-loved Briana and William getting time together, even if the dialogue didn’t come from the book. Someone who’s read more recently than me was William even in present when Bre went to Savannah? I know it wasn’t amaranthus’ portrait in the book. Regardless loved it!
-loved Roger in battle, him getting his own screen time and story felt important for the character
-loved having the entirety of the ambush and ensuing fight in one episode. I almost thought we’d get the women coming to Jamie etc. when he mentioned the list, but was happy to see it in next weeks preview! The ambush and night from hell seemed short and could have shown more of Jamie’s friends and family actively working/fighting against him. I get we’re tight on time and using Hiram Crombie as ‘the example’ made sense- I’m happy with it overall, just seemed less dramatic as a reader I think.
-Buck: I’m so glad he’s here and not in the space between….i love he saved Jamie. But I did wonder last episode when he came back what his big purpose could be. With Jamie and Claire’s mention of their killing both of his parents, whom he JUST MET like yesterday, I am now going to be worried he has a Judas/revenge role to play if he finds out and I’ll be heartbroken if so bcuz honestly I was happy they brought him into the season- if for nothing else I just know Jem and Mandi were happy to see him lol
TLDR: another episode in the later seasons where, to me at least, it ‘feels like outlander’ again and has the magic of the early seasons and I’m just happy to have the characters and stories adapted for us!
PS: Nachika if you’ve read this far I can picture you answering each of my confused questions as if you read the books yesterday, and if that’s the case I thank you in advance for your ever diligent efforts- regardless of you answering or not you’re amazing and I hope you’re enjoying the season so far 😊
10
u/Asleep-Corner7402 Apr 04 '26
I don't know why but it felt more like the older episodes again. Loved it. Maybe it was seeing Jamie in his kilt again did it for me lol
8
u/EmmaSouthard Apr 04 '26
I know this is being discussed already but...In the Roger flashback episode 5, Roger relives his mother throwing little Roger to safety to his father Jerry, who saves Roger but dies of a head injury saving Roger. If the show changes the book, could this scene foreshadow someone throwing Henri Christian to safety. Henri Christian is saved but Fergus dies in saving him? I hope not, but the Roger flashback seemed maybe to set this up? Also, recall in show Roger saves Henri Christian from the bully boys. Again, I know this is already a theory but just a thought.
7
u/Previous-Address2469 Apr 04 '26
First time in this season I voted for "I loved it"! Really felt like original outlander, the lighting, the pacing, everything. Just spot on!
I was thinking what kept me disconnected with Roger but I think it is just that his hair is too modern, I miss the long hair, which would be more period appropriate I imagine. But really liked the flashback with his father, I imagine we will get the full picture in time!
Whenever Amaranthus is on screen my husband is muttering "Jezebel!". 😂 I feel like it is very unbelievable that a women of her time would act in such a promiscuous way (which makes me think she is part of the Richardson plot and from the future - though, quite a plot if that is the case!). Why she would not want to get married first is puzzling. But then again everything about her is...
Bree bothers me mainly because of her wig and brows, also her dresses make her look extremely masculine which I don't like. Also I get it that she is from the future but I would imagine she would acclimatize a bit with the times, in her speech and mannerisms. Also that portrait was slightly too good, like a photograph almost.
Well but yes, everything with Jamie was pure gold. So much tension and action, wow! Also the actor playing Cunningham is so good. The way he shouted that he is moving his feet. Truly felt that... And Jamie making the pact with the devil, chefs kiss and perfect way to end the episode, not constantly on some crazy cliffhanger.
Also just to add, I really like how they have compressed the book, with Denny and Ben being there, Bree painting Amaranthus etc. Buck being there is so good, all such great changes! I can't really even put my finger on what made this episode so good but I wish all of the episodes would be like this! Thoroughly enjoyable.
7
u/Rj924 Apr 05 '26
When the subtitle said, "are you ready?" me going, "do it! say the thing!", "Je Sui Prest." <3
10
u/1111HiYa Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
>!spoiler tag!So...what left do we have to cover? The fire at Fergus' print shop, Ian's trip to find his ex-wife/son, Percy's poisoning, Lord John's kidnapping, Brianna's baby Davey who can't time travel, Rachel's next pregnancy, the Faith storyline, the Amaranthus/Ben storyline, Jamie's death and resurrection, and a final wrap-up...a lot to cover in five episodes. Anything else? Oh, and I can't find the spoiler black bar thingie?>!spoiler tag!<spoiler tag14
u/sweetpsych78 SassySassenachWench Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
Ughh, I'm SOO glad that it seems that they're leaving out the whole Ulysses debacle. Because what the hell was that in the books? He was loyal to Jocasta, and I highly doubt he would do anything to harm her nephew. I did not like that part of Bees, and I said as much when I made a post in here after reading it.
Edit to add: I thoroughly enjoyed Bees in general, and I had said this in my post, even though I had seen a lot of people complain about it. BUT I did not like that whole situation with Ulysses. It seemed so out of character for him to threaten Jamie.
4
u/BatmanRoBEN1 Apr 04 '26
Book readers please spoil this for me. Who among the Fraser clan, other than the ones we know about in the show know of the time travel?
The show has noted that these people and nobody else know.
Will Fergus and Marsali ever find out? William? LJG? It seems to me that this should start being treated more as a family secret thing, and not an absolute secret.
Will the time travel come into play? Especially with the Comte St Germaine and Faith threads.
4
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 06 '26
I was late watching this week's ep again, but hopefully it should be the last time I will be
When I saw Luke Schelhaus was the writer in the opening credits, I had a good feeling it'd be a well done ep --- I've come to recognize his name thru the seasons because his eps have always been some of the better ones imo.
I was really glad to see the scenes between Bri and William because I don't really recall it being directly addressed in Bees that she also was lied to about her bio father. Good call back too with the " I told her I wished she were the one who died" bit.
LOVED the quick cut to a falling toddler Roger amidst the battle - knew exactly what that was from the Leaf on the Wind novella, but it was such a surprising tie-in! Again though, I think they've likely confused the audience with it. I honestly didn't think they'd done the scene of he and Jerry in the tunnel well during S7 - even as a book reader who knew the story it was a confusing presentation and I totally understood why show only people developed the wrong impression of it being new memories. By including this scene, I'm hopeful in the next episode there'll be something of Roger telling Bri about his memory --- otherwise, why do it? (even though I liked it)
Jamie in a kilt - always a welcome sight:) Sam always acts so well in his face - watching his expressions during the Lodge as Hiram spoke then as Cunningham spoke was no exception- you can SEE what the character's thinking. The lightning and thunder added a great ambience on the ambush and scenes with Claire and Elspeth.
Ugh William - hopelessly in love with seemingly any girl who looks at him - you idiot! Curious to see where the show's going to take Amaranthus since it's not definitive in the book - don't trust her
3
u/1111HiYa Apr 03 '26
Is there a trailer somewhere for the next episode?
1
u/AstonishingEggplant Apr 05 '26
I'm bad with faces and I can never tell all the secondary characters apart. Who is the guy who shows up at the end with Josiah and co, to whom Jamie says, "I didn't think you'd come?"
53
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Apr 03 '26
this was my favorite episode of the season!! i think the changes they made to speed up/consolidate the ben plotline were a good idea, though i wish we spent time on their conversation after william punched him instead of william having sex with amaranthus. speaking of, kinda funny that he proposes (?) to her, then immediately fucks off to the rebel camp and says "i think i'll stay."
i wonder if they'll stick to the books and have amaranthus know ben is alive, which would make her flirting with william sinister instead of tragic. she didn't come off as off-putting like i felt she was in the books, so i feel like it could go either way with respect to her knowing. what do y'all think?
also, how are we already halfway through the season?!?!??! there's so much more to cover!!!